Discussion Locked

Exchange versus Groupwise

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
My company is thinking about migrating from Groupwise 6.0 to Exchange. I have to prior training in Exchange, so I am reluctant to suggest this as a viable alternative. We have recently been having problems with our GWIA which prompting the change, but also there are grumblings about getting a Blackberry server in as well. I know that in the past Exchange has been more susceptible to viruses and that it can become unstable and therefore need to rebooted alot. Has anyone made this migration lately or do you have an opinion on the matter.

7 replies

by oz_media

I have switched literaly a dozen shops FROM Exhange to GW and had nothing but praise for it.

Now you having experience with Exchange will know, GE is DAMN secure!

What version of GW are you using and what GWIa issues are you having?

If it is repeated logins, that can be normal due to network activity.

NOTE: With GW you can implement GWAVA Spam detection, by FAR the most robust, powerful and error fre spam tool.

I think maybe you should lok into buying some time before they make a mistake that can cost them big $$. Let's see if the issue with GWIA can be resolved, people get all antsy when there are little quirks, I have had one customer swear he would remove all email when the tiniest of issues arise.

It's easy to make the GW vs Exchange case, especially when it comes to ROI, downtime and security, Exchange....shudder. :(

by crazyal

We are running GW 6.0 and the GWIA seems to just stop distributing incoming messages. My boss and I still haven't figured out the cause of this issue. Any suggestions that you might have would be helpful.

Have you implemented a Blackberry server with GW? If you have what were the some issues that you had with it? Through all the reading I have done, I have seen Exchange is just easier to intergrate with almost all applications and other hardware. Is this just because everyone is used to the Microsoft world and therefore gears everything toward Exchange?

ROI?

Any help is apperciated.

by oz_media

much easier to implement, resourceful. It also like woreless, haven' played with blackberry server but hae done quite a few wireless clients (Palms, cells, etc.) Also integrated to NEc unified messaging platform which eases things.

For an issue with mail flow, this should be a Novell issue, hae you gone to thier Tech Suport? Checked the Novell Forums etc.?

ROI, sorry don't know if you needed the acronym or the outline.

ROI is Return On Investment: Which is FAR greater in a GW environment than Exchange.

GW=Less downtime, less maintenance hours, can be rebuilt and repared on the fly without any system outages, has the BEST SPAM protection available (after market).

Novell's site has some geat tools for ROI calculations and comparissons with Exchange. In fact they are just winding up the international Exhange VS GroupWise tour, where they have ben getting peope to switch from Exchange to GW all over tha world (Europe is HUGE on Novell with many cities and major banks implementing it).

Try starting here to make your case:

[b]Why are Exchange users switching to GroupWise? [/b]

http://www.novell.com/products/groupwise/exchange.html

by theheadmushroom

Hi Crazy Al!

We made the switch from GroupStupid (you couldn't really call it 'wise' in any sense of the word!) to Exchange 2000 about 18 months ago. We have not had any stability problems. The system was set up by external consultants, but apart from applying the odd Microsoft fix, we have hardly had to reboot the server at all. I think I can recall probably 2 occasions when an unscheduled (middle of the business day) reboot has been necessary.

No-one here was the least bit sad to see the back of GroupStupid.

by oz_media

Not taking sides here but can I ask why removing a more secure email messaging system for Exchange was a positive move?

and without implying anything at all, do you hold an MCSE, MCNE or both?

Just interested

by conjuror_bh

CrazyAl,
You need to know that no email system is trouble free. If you think that Exchange may solve your problems just search on google for exchange troubleshooting and you'll see what I'm talking about. Their problems seem to be much worse than ours (I'm running GW too). Wouldn't be better to upgrade your mail server to 6.5? The upgrade should fix GWIA problems you have. And just imagine what kind of problems you could have on Exchange with so many worms and viruses around. It is scary!

by ccardwel

I confess that (not by choice) I have been working in a Windows world (Exchange 2K and AD) for the last four years. Prior to that I had been in a Novell shop which I built from the ground up for about 7 years. I have had experience with both Groupwise and Exchange; though I confess it was an earlier version of Groupwise than you are currently using. I had a few headaches with Groupwise, but most of the headaches I had were the result of errors on my part. I found Groupwise to be very reliabel and very stable and we had no security problems with it at all.

Since I have been an Exchange Administrator in my current job for a while. I have to tell you that we just don't have many problems with Echange 2K either. It has performed quite well. I have had to perform very little maintenance on it aside from the usual Microsoft patching adventures. The only downtime I have experienced has been the result of hardware failures.
Here is the primary reason I would avoid Exchange if at all possible: IT'S A TARGET. Whether it's because it's a Microsoft program or just inherently nsecure doesn't really matter (personally I think it's a bit of both); the fact remains it is a huge risk because it is such a target. The second big reason to avoid Exchange in any of it's recent iterations is because it requires Active Directory. No matter what anyone tells you Active Directory is a joke, it doesn't provide anywhere near the functionality of NDS and it is based on a networking model that still has pieces in it from the early 80s. AD is the biggest hoax MS has perpetrated yet and you should avoid it all costs. If you are already running AD then maybe this isn't a big deal to you. If you are not running AD avoid it if at all possible. If you are used to working NDS then Microsofts' networking model will make you crazy...it's just not worth it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.