Food for thought: Trust ratings
As one of OZ's recent threads has pointed out, there is a need for some kind of rating method for users. We've been kicking around the idea of stealing Gamespot's Trust Ratings, and thought we'd run it by the TRIs.
The way Trust works is every user signature has a "Trust this user" button. If you click that button, the user would be added to your "Trust List." This would be different from your Contacts List, as your Trust List would be only for those users you consider technically competent and reliable.
Posts from Trusted users will stand out in some fashion, so you can intuitively add extra weight to them when you see them.
Moreover, every user will have a Trust Rating, which will be displayed on their signature. Something to the effect of "This person is trusted by X users." We'd also have a "Most Trusted Users" list, similar to the "Top 100" list.
The idea behind Trust is to highlight and reward those users who go out of their way to give good, solid technical advice. That, coupled with the "bad behavior" badges we hope to get going in Tech Q&A, should start creating a viable list of reliable contributors.
Also, the Trust system relies on a simple, one-click, binary action. Do you trust this user? Yes or no? It's clean and intuitive.
On a related note, as features like this start rolling out, we plan on revisiting the Site Activity meter. One of our current ideas is creating an aggregate "User Rating meter" which factors in trust along with various types of activity.
However, we'd also have a breakout page that showed various component meters, like raw activity, trust rating, Q&A answers accepted, Q&A closing rating/etiquette, profile completion, etc. That way, you could tell exactly how a user got the aggregate rating: was it just raw volume of posts, or a high trust rating, or what?
That's where we're at right now. What do you all think?