Discussion Locked

frame-ups go unpunished

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Thomas Goldstein spent 24 years in prison because a deputy DA in Los Angeles framed him. The US Supreme Court had already decided in Imbler vs Pachtman that the individual deputy DA could not be sued (Imbler had done 9 years and got out of prison by proving there had been a frame-up). So Goldstein tied to sue the DA himself for a policy of encouraging frame-ups. Yesterday the US Supreme Court decided to extend the immunity to administrators. The same rule is codified in California Government Code Section 821.6, so Goldstein cannot sue in California courts. There are similar rules in all the states of the Union.
In Canada the parallel rule is "No Servant of the Queen may allege the Queen ordered him to commit any tort.". Sec. 821.6 should be changed to "No Servant of the People of the State of California may allege that the People ordered him to commit any tort.".

4 replies

by john.a.wills

it is to give such power to prosecutors and administrators - and if Canada doesn't give such power neither need the U.S.

by tony hopkinson

Doesn't matter whether it's written down or not.

In the case of the Guildford Four in the UK, the judge ruled that policemen who framed them, could not be prosecuted because they would not receive a fair trial.

Everyone already knew they were guilty.......

The law is a bad joke, maintained by the legislature for their own benefit.

This discussion is closed to new replies.