From a Travesty of Justice to Poetic Justice
In my opinion, one of the biggest travesties of our judicial system, at least among the more recent travesties, is the court support of various jurisdictions concerning their implementation of the states' power of eminent domain. The power of eminent domain is the method by which the "state" can take (or buy for "fair market value") private land that could be put to better use for the "public good". This power was intended to be used primarily for the construction of public roads and such that might run through someone's front yard or back pasture. Many of the Interstate highways, for example, were constructed on land that was taken (bought) by the government through the power of eminent domain.
However, in recent years, many municipalities have been using their power of eminent domain to take private property (or buy for "fair market value") so they can turn around and sell that land to a private developer who has intentions of building commercial, industrial, or retail businesses. The increase in tax revenue derived from a commercial business versus the relatively insignificant property taxes collected on a private residence served "the public good", or so said the states' arguments.
There was a court case recently where a person challenged the government's power of eminent domain when his local municipality wanted to take his home so that a Wal-Mart could be built on that very spot. (Increased sales tax revenue versus residential property tax revenue, the argument went, equals "for the public good".) Balderdash, the home owner said. You can't take my home to make room for a Wal-Mart, and I'll take you to court to prevent it from happening. Well, not only did this particular case fail in court, but the practice caught on, and many different municipalities started doing the same thing.
One such case, Kelo versus the City of New London, went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. The question before the court was to consider if states and/or local municipalities really did have the power to take private land for the purpose of increasing tax revenues. (I'm paraphrasing the "question" put before the court.)
How did the Supreme Court rule?
They ruled, in a 5-4 decision, in favor of the municipalities rights to seize personal property for the "public good" even if that "public good" was described as being for tax revenue increases and/or for job creation, etc.
The supporting judges were:
Justice John Paul Stevens
Justice Anthony M. Kennedy
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Justice Stephen Breyer
Justice David Souter
The dissenting judges were:
Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist
Justice Antonin Scalia
Justice Clarence Thomas
Justice Sandra Day O'Connor
It this a travesty, or what? Am I alone in seeing the dangerous precedent being established here?
A developer in New Hampshire has recently filed the necessary papers, and it appears as though everything is in proper order, to have the state seize a private home that is situated in an area conducive to commercial development that meets the criteria established as legitimate reasons to exercise the power of eminent domain. This developer plans to build a hotel on the property, and the local municipality will reap financial gains as a result -- and financial gains equals "the public good". And after all, the Supreme Court ruled that such power is indeed in the hands of a municipality/developer partnership to do just that.
But here's the good part. The house in question is owned -- lock, stock, and barrel -- by Supreme Court Justice David Souter, who actually paved the legal way for a municipality/developer partnership to take it away. Let's see how he likes the government taking his house away to make room for a private hotel.
Relevant Links:
http://www.ij.org/pdf_folder/private_property/kelo/kelo-USSC-opinion-6-05.pdf
http://www.ij.org/private_property/connecticut/
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2004-09-28-justices-property_x.htm
And the good one: