Discussion Locked

George Bush rescues the people of Iraq from their tyrannical dictator

0 helpful
54 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

But apparently the rotten sods are not grateful.

The quality of miscellaneous discussions at TR has gone so far down the toilet, that I only pop in when I am bored sh|tless.

While so many w*nkers are wasting their time pandering to Maxwell Edison's absurd obsession with alleged human-caused global warming, life goes on in the real world.

It seems the continued presence of US and other foreign troops in Iraq is causing more harm than good.

[b]The Australian, June 21, 2006[/b]

THE level of violence in some areas of Iraq is worsening dramatically and US forces may soon be asked to leave by the Iraqi Government.

In an exclusive interview with The Australian, former US deputy secretary of state Richard Armitage has given a gloomy assessment of the situation.

"The British used to make a big deal of walking around in their berets in the south," he said. "Now they won't even go to the latrines without their helmets. The south has got much rougher, it's mainly Shia on Shia violence."

Mr Armitage said much of the violence came from differences over how the Islamic religion should be interpreted.

And he said he believed the Iraqis would soon ask the US to leave their country.

The most optimistic scenario following a US withdrawal would be that Iraq would become a loose federation -- although the term federation would not be used because it upsets neighbouring Turkey -- with a weak central government.

"The difficulty then will be to stop them (the Iraqis) causing violence for their neighbours," Mr Armitage said.

This was because almost all of Iraq's neighbours had restive Shia minorities and the governments of both Iraq and Iran would come under pressure to intervene on their behalf.

Mr Armitage believed the Shi'ites and Sunnis had not sated their appetite for violence against each other. But there were signs of the essential compromises necessary to make Iraq stable in the negotiations taking place inside the new Iraqi Government.

Mr Armitage said he hoped there could be a draw-down of US and other coalition troops in Iraq in the next 12 to 18 months.

Although George W. Bush had a good week, with the death of al-Qa'ida in Iraq leader Abu Musab al-Zarqawi and progress with the Iraqi Government , Mr Armitage believes Iraq is still a big drag on Republicans.

He said "many Republicans are running away from the President" as they prepared for the forthcoming mid-term congressional elections.

Mr Armitage was equally gloomy about Afghanistan, especially in the south, where violence was worsening and Australia was deploying a new provincial reconstruction team. "It'll be heavy lifting for them," he said. "Five years after the overthrow of the Taliban, the ordinary people don't see much change in their lives."

Several factors were driving the renewed violence in Afghanistan including drugs which provided money for numerous warlords.

"At the same time, some in Pakistan may believe that the Taliban may come back. The Talibs also see us handing over to NATO and they see some NATO countries as weaker than us."

But Mr Armitage identified the US-Australian alliance as one of the success stories in Bush foreign policy. He paid the ultimate compliment to the Australian Prime Minister: "Howard got everything he wanted."

[Edited to make heading fit]

54 replies

by gralfus

We civilized folk have a hard time understanding the extreme factions in these countries. We see them cheer when Saddam's statue is toppled. But then we see them cheer when a British helicopter is downed, and the chant that they are soldiers of Al-so-and-so, and that the evil Christian "crusaders" are worthy of death.

Then, in the name of God, they blow up a wedding party of Muslims. Then they blow up an old folks home full of Muslims. That didn't make sense to me until I heard they were the wrong *kind* of Muslims, and thus heretics worthy of death. And their God of course demands that they kill them since he seems impotent to do so on his own. This would be like the Baptists killing Episcopalians every day for heretical beliefs, and vice versa.

After this, they are outraged and weep into the camera that Americans are killing civilians, whether accidently or on purpose, makes no difference to them. We are obviously worthy of death.

Comedian Lewis Black is right: these people have no sense of humor. They riot and burn over a newspaper cartoon. I guess they didn't see South Park or they'd have already self-combusted. Remember kids, Islam is a religion of peace...Maybe they do have a twisted sense of humor after all.

by jamesrl

This is an oft repeated scenario where a minority manages to rule a country through divide and conquer, the Sunnis ruled a secular government (until Saddam thought he could stay a little longer and became "devout" for the cameras) trying to keep the lid on religious majority in the south, who had alot more in common with their populous neighbours to the east, the the "rebelious" kurds in the north who were very independence minded.

Even with the outside influences of the coalition and the Al Qaeda mischief makers, there still would have been a civil war/coup some day. That is how Saddam took power, thats how he would have left if the west had not invaded. And we would have had many thousands killed in any case.

The thing that unites many of them today in common cause is fighting the outsider. But make no mistake, if the outsider leaves they won't put down their guns. It could get much worse.

As far as Lewis Black is concerned, you could say the same thing about Christianity a few centuries back.

James

by oz_media

I think the whole reason th eWest is seen as the infidel is due to poor interpretation. It's no different than some of the Christian bible thumpers that go around preching the most absurd issues in teh bible. It is merely interpretation, as the original writer is not available of course.

the Muslim religion for example, which many now say is a religion that says to kill anyone who does not allow you to further your cause is a joke. I know many muslims, they see nothing but peaceful messages in thier religion. Some however see it as defining the West as 'the infidels' and the infidels must be stopped at all costs in order to preserve thier religion.

BUT...IS teh west really the infidel or is it merely some radicals completely f***ed up translation of the message? I woul dsay the latter is more true.

So once again, just as in most other religions, the translation is the cause of the problem.

by onbliss

Even, back in the 7th century when there was no US-Austrialian alliance, folks from that region impregnated with their way of life began forcefully spreading it across the globe.

Colonialism and Cold War added fodder and fuel to existing violence.

Yes, people seldom like outside interference. They are ready to be killed by one of their own, than by the outsiders. But they see Islam uniting them all.

by jdclyde

that when you have a brutial, savage population that is NOT a bunch of peaceful muslims just wanting to live in peace, the only way they can be governed is be force.

Let the US pull out and let them go back to killing each other like they have wanted to do all along. Then offer to help anyone that is left to form a peaceful civilization. From the way the peaceful muslims live, that shouldn't be too many left over.

by tonythetiger

That's the impatient answer, but in reality we just can't do it. We know that freedom of the human spirit is the right way and we should continue to strive toward that. Yes, even if most (or even ALL) of the rest of the world seems to be against us. The right thing does not become wrong simply because of a lack of popularity!

It's normal for there to be resistance, because there is much fear.

Fear from those who have never had freedom (and will be making choices for themselves for possibly the first time in their lives), fear from those who can't handle the responsibilities that goes along with freedom, and fear from those who have been unethically taking advantage of others' fears (you know who you are) that the jig is almost up!

We'll get there, but not without pain and more than a few setbacks along the way. That's what 'Stay the course' means :)

by jdclyde

But with the liberal weenies trying to set an artifical time table for retreat, someone has to say EXACTLY what will happen if we do.

How "caring" is it to allow the peaceful Iraqis get slaughterded? Just shows how either stupid, dishonest or both the left in America really is.

by tig2

Is that during Gulf One- a.k.a.. Desert Storm/Shield one of the points that you heard consistanly being made is that they don"t mind if they are fighting each other. After all, they are accustomed to it. It is only when an outsider steps in that the level of violence escalates. Or at least that was the theory.

Back then, it was also opined that Iraq NEEDED Saddam in order to keep the country from spinning out of control as a result of factional pull. Tht appears to have been a true statement- Saddam is gone and peace hasn't broken out.

I have felt for a long time now that we are perilously close to finding ourselves in another Vietnam- only reversed. But equally deadly. In Vietnam, we went in to advise- not fight. In H. Norman Schwartzkopf's "It Doesn't Take a Hero" he talks about his first tour working with the Vietnamese. And his frustration that he was limited to only providing strategic advice. In his second tour, he was introduced to the changes- not for the better. America had stopped advising and started fighting... based on direction Stateside that was often misguided. In Iraq, we started out as the fighters in the trenches. We are trying to move into an advisory role so that all h3ll doesn't break loose the minute we're gone.

And I am sure that given the "discussions" we've been having lately with Iran regarding nukes, it's nice to know that we have so much persuasive power so close at hand.

Iraq must know that they will have to find a way to a peaceful settlement- or even an uneasy one- while the US is still there. However, if the analysts predictions from Gulf One are correct, it may not be possible to find peace among the factions if the US is any part of the negotiations.

Above all, I would hate to see a war, already celebrating (?) it's third birthday, become the ageless thing that Vietnam was. I don't take issue with being there if we need to be there. I don't want to see it becoming a 10+ year debacle. And I DON"T want to see the troops that DO come home mistreated. Once was quite enough.

by oz_media

While we talk about Iraqi's finding peace, there is a third party that also must be appeased, which is why this whole war started. Bush wasn't happy with what he saw in Iraq, if it doesn't comply with American democracy, then it must be changed. So not only must we find peace between insurgents and Iraqi's seeking peace, that result ALSO has to appease the US administration, or else the entire effort will be fruitless.

I think appeasing the US may be the hardest part of all, because they will stay and fight relentlessly until thier own chosen outcome is seen.

by tig2

I used Vietnam as an example mostly because when I think of times that the US has treated the military badly, it comes screaming to mind.

Unfortunately, you're right. Haiti and Kosovo are still hotspots. You can include Korea and several others.

My point was that I don't want to see a return to a thinking that allows us to "hate the messenger". The military should not again be accused for the actions of government.

by jdclyde

and the most often used to control people. We see this with the Democratic party in the US, and most recently with that wingnut "church" that has been protesting at the funerals of soldiers, saying this is all punishment for accepting gays.

Even in the most EXTREME of modern day Christianity, while gays are not openly accepted, they are not hateful "things" that must be destroyed at all costs. At WORST, lost souls that need to be saved, not attacked.

How sad.

by oz_media

Whil ewe understand that being Gay is not the end of the world and violence will not remove these anti--christs from society. Radicals in Iraq have deemed the US (the entire West as such). Thier translation shows the US as an ememy to be fought until no man is left standing. This is not the interpretation or feelings that most read into the Q'oran though, just a mixed up and off base interpretation of some.

Mush as Christians are not bad people, but SOME Christians spend thier entire lives condemning anyoe who doesnt abide by THIER interpretation of what a good Christian should be.

by jdclyde

People stand up to the people that try to distort Christianity into a message of hate, and with the exception for Pat Robertson, most are held accountable by CHRISTIANS.

We do not see this inside influince standing up and being counted inside the Muslim world. It is easier and safer to allow the crazies to make them all look like savage dogs than to stand up to them and bring that same hate down on themselves. Better to be a live dog than a dead person standing up for what is right?

by onbliss

...not all muslims go about killing other non-muslims. And the bulk of them are just as immersed in everyday life as the rest of the world. I see bad and good people from them. Having lived with so many of them, I did not see anything inherently wrong in a Muslim.

But the moderate/good muslims keep quiet a lot. They do not raise voice against their radicals and take them to task.

Consider this: In a South Eastern Asian country (I forget the name), some of the Buddhists monks were allowed to watch the FIFA World Cup but not allowed to celebrate. And in Indian, tehre were a few Islamic Clergies that were contemplating on issuing a "fatwa" against watching the same on TV. They cited football related vandalism and lack of attendance in the Friday prayers.

Check http://www.faithfreedom.org, it gives good description of Mohammed's lifetime and Koran.

by oz_media

IN many countries they are not beheaded for not sharing teh same opinion or for speakign out.

Imagine living under a repressive dictatorship for your entirer life, having rebels, guerrillas, terrorists and other radicals constantly fighting and toppling th egovernment, killing people who stand in thier way.

People here woul dbe a hell of a lot less likely to speak out in the name of thier religion.

We live in a democratic society where it is okay, even encouraged to speak out. In Iraq it is encouraged to mind your own business and you just may get through life.

I can honestly say that any of us, who are always quick to offer our opinion, would be the same way having grown up in such a repressive society without even understanding what democracy is about.

by onbliss

So how many Islamic countries reel under dictatorship or autocratic rule? There are quite a few Isalmic democracies in the world. Also muslims are in good numbers in other democracies. 15% of Indians are muslims. That is almost 150million right there. You do not get to hear moderate voice as much as one would desire.
I am not saying there are no moderate voices, I am saying it is not enough. Though there are still feudal pockets in India, it is not as repressive as in other countries.

Also does'nt it make us wonder why the particular religion and dictatorship/autocracy/tyrannical rule are found together?

Edited: grammar

by onbliss

..that a fatwa is necessary to compel (word used in the article) to make Muslims obey the law of the land?

It is a different matter for any religious leader to urge the followers of that religion to practice peace, harmony and be law-abiding citizens; from a clergy issuing a fatwa.

Does that mean, a fatwa can compel them to not follow the law, in future?

by jdclyde

And that is EXACTLY the way I take this.

These muslims seem not to have anything in them like a moral guide that says to obey the laws, and that there is a reason they are there. There is nothing to tell them that breaking the laws is wrong.

Sounds like an easily controlled/manipulated religion to me. No wonder there are so many out there that do things that make us think all of Islam is evil.

Yes, evil. It is evil to behead someone just because they are not the correct flavor of your religion. Any and all religions that would condon that are evil and need to be recognised as such. Or at least the faction that has perverted the religion. When people go against these factions and defend them, then they are making their choice as well and will live or die by that choice.

I personally would rather see the muslim majority I have heard about in here stand up and set things right in their own house.

by x-marcap

There can be no compromise with the fanatics. The only way for the Iraqis or the US to be safe is to deal with the terrorists in their midst.

by jamesrl

I have heard and read many interviews since the arrest of the Canadian "home grown" terrorists, and many of those interviewed are high profile Muslims who are taking great pains to condemn the acts of these terrorists. That includes Muslim clerics, Muslim community leaders, Muslim rights groups etc. They are constanly making statements, talking to reporters, writing articles, preaching peace in the mosques etc.

The problem as described is that those who hate go underground. They don't preach it in the mosques here - they find young impressionable kids here attending mosques and they teach them privately and secretly the Wahhabi sect's faith.

It is a MUSLIM group in Canada which is trying to ban a radical imam from the UK from being able to travel to Canada and preach.

The problem is that unlike the Catholic Church, you don't have a hierarchy in the Muslim world. There are many imams in every sect and you can chose to follow which ever one you like. So you don't have the same kind of leaderhsip that exists in some of our Christian churches.

James

by jdclyde

do I not hear them?

Is there a reason this voice would not or should not get out to everyone?

I have actually read more quotes on what nice boys they were, and how the Candian Government is FRAMING them.

Speaking of which, what is happening with the claim that Canadians are torturing the "falsely accused young men"?

For the record, I do not believe this story about framing nor torture. I would like to know how it is being covered in Canada though.

by onbliss

You said:
[i]So you don't have the same kind of leaderhsip that exists in some of our Christian churches.[/i]

Sometimes a central leadership or authority can get tyrannical or oppressive or just plainly get in the way of progress. In a loosely set hierarchy, if the clergies still do not raise their sane voice and keep condoning the violence, then it only points to another central entity - THE KORAN (or its interpretations) - playing a more deviant role.

by jamesrl

But I have heard multiple interviews with Tarek Fatah, Mohamed Elmasry, and others on Canadian Radio, TV and newpapers all a) condemming their actions, b) urging their fellow Muslims to be vigilant in seeking out and denouncing this kind of behaviour.

http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=thestar/Layout/Article_Type1&c=Article&cid=1149889810923&call_pageid=1144159007037

http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=thestar/Layout/Article_Type1&call_pageid=971358637177&c=Article&cid=1149889810190

http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=thestar/Layout/Article_Type1&c=Article&cid=1149545412089&call_pageid=976163513378&col=969048863474

I don't know what media you get or don't get where you are. But I can't say I suprised you aren't getting it all there.

James

by oz_media

To stand up amongst peers in a democratic nation is generally not goin gto see much violence.

Standing up in a country such as Afghanistan or Iraq obviously had deadly conincidences. As we can tell by the current occupation, they are a force to be reconed with, not just a few guys who may come after you but a regime with no respect for life at all.

We can't suggest such things such as our own saying like "Better to be a live dog than a dead person standing up for what is right?"

Because we haven't grown up under repessive disctators and guerillas in the streets. I would suggest Christians (for example) would be far less happy to stand up if dradical Christians were alughtering people who spoke out, especially with little or no repercussions from teh government or police.

We have relative safety to speak our minds and not be killed, they don't. Now as far as fighting for your rights, I think they woul drather kill every peaceful Muslim seekgn a better resolve than to actually start hearing them out. In fact by doing so, they would reduce the resitance to thier cause.

Your comment may work in a world such as ours, but I dont dare say the same would be found if YOU lived there. You'd stand up and be shot, beheaded or whatever. So woul dthe next and the next and so on until they were all dead. Plus standing up and takign a combative stance is most likely not what Muslims believe in either, that's hardly peaceful acceptance of difference.

by oz_media

In Canada, many feel we have a big left wing. NDP, National Democratic Party is not the powerhouse it once was. Where most areas on Vancouver island were strong NDP supporters, that has since turned to a mroe liberal standing.

So in my eyes, the left wing tries to be heard still but has a very small and easily ignored voice.

One thing I must reiterate though is how are parties are very similar.
In the US, your parties are practically opposites. If Rpeublicans say one thing, the Democrats immediately denounce it sand say teh opposite, simply becaus ethey can't be seen as havign shared opinion. This results in the bizarre political difference in the USA.

In Canada, while the parties are quite different, they are much closer to actually having varied opinions on teh same end result. They seem to strive for similar issues, but with slight diferences in the way it is done.

So the left really isnt much different than th ecenter and the center is really not too far off of the right. Understanding of course that there must be some separation of objectives bu twe are far closer to being the same than the USA. I think this hekps a great deal when a two party system is in place. They can work together and spend less time combatting one another. No they aren't all on the same page, but not too far apart.

by maxwell edison

I'm amazed at how short-sighted some people are. I'm also amazed at how narrow-minded and selective they are as it pertains to how this war all started, and what it was intended to achieve.

If people were totally honest with themselves, they would have to admit two things. One: the war in Iraq IS a vital extension on the "war on terrorism" (or, as I call it, the war on Islamo-Fascism). And two: it was ALWAYS presented as such, and was ALWAYS MORE than just a search for those elusive WMDs. But people aren't honest with themselves. It's only been three years, and people are advocating a cut-and-run solution. Why can't people stay focused on the long-term goal? Perhaps it's because they don't know, or won't admit, what it really is. Or perhaps it's because they don't believe it's achievable? There is a long-term goal here, and it will be years in the making, maybe decades. And President Bush has maintained such a long-term perspective from the very beginning. Why don't people know that? Why don't people realize that? Why don't people remember that?

9-11 changed the world; and 9-11 changed the rules. But the instant gratification mentality so many people apparently have is getting in the way of achieving a long-term goal. I'm at a loss for words to describe how I really feel. I'm totally dumfounded at the narrow-mindedness and short-term mentality of so many. I'm actually shocked that so many put politics before principle. Criticize President Bush all you want, but he has stayed the course. He's stood firm in the face of adversity and extreme criticism. Quite frankly, I can't think of another politician who would have maintained the course so stead-fastly. Well, I can think of one who might have. Rudy Giuliani would have as well.

Leadership isn't appeasing detractors. Leadership isn't capitulating in the face of dwindling poll numbers. Leadership isn't changing course because of extreme criticism. Leadership isn't management by public opinion. Leadership is moving forward regardless of those things. Leadership is staying focused on the long-term goals. I think history will be very kind to President Bush if those long-term goals are realized. However, I fear for the world that will result if they're not. And I hope with all my being that those who wish to sabotage those goals fail. Unfortunately, in regards to this particular war, there are those both within and without who are working to sabotage those long-term goals. I used to pity those people. But my pity is quickly turning into despise.

by onbliss

... in my opinion (what ever it is worth), there were far more dangerous countries that could have been tackled. I list a few: Syria, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Iran. Indonesia would have been a good candidate too.

by maxwell edison

....they should have (or could have) been tackled.

Overall, this is an absolute GIANT of a problem. If ignoring the problem isn't an option, then it must be addressed. And one could certainly surmise that it won't be solved in one fell swoop. It won't be solved with one solution. Iraq was (and is) only one small piece of a big puzzle. Just because it, alone, won't solve the whole puzzle, and just because there are bigger pieces, it doesn't mean we shouldn't concentrate on this piece at this time. If we can solve this small piece of the puzzle, bigger pieces just might fall into place later on. Maybe that's the best way to address those bigger pieces.

by maxwell edison

...half the people in these discussions (including the guy who started this particular one), probably sympathize with the terrorists, and will justify their actions.

by ittp

If you "only pop in when [you are] bored sh|tless", then stay away. This is one of those "down the toilet" discussions you deride. Maybe you'd be happier if you were bored Shi'iteless. We've destroyed their country, for whatever supposed purpose, and they should be happy and thankful... They haven't got consistent utilities throughout the country, and they should be kissing Dubya butt. Homes destroyed, but "thanks!"?? Their doors get kicked in at any time of day, any day, but "you're welcome". It's easy, from here in the US, to think they're better off, but we have no clue until we speak to some residents or family members.

by jardinier

I am very pleased to see that it is one of the most balanced and fair discussions I have seen at TR about the Islam "problem."

by ittp

Have you actually read some of the posts, about leaving them alone to kill themselves off, as they would because they're Muslims? That's fair? Most of the posts make me think this is TechRepublican Right-Wing Forum. Balanced? Fair and balanced imply some opposing opinions. There might be 2. Most posts want them damn Muslims ta kill off each other. What a shame. But, that's exactly the mentality the PTB in D.C. want.

This thread is neither fair nor balanced. It IS a chest-thumping self-approval pro-killing thread. I pity the fool who kept saying that we all have short memories. Problem is that some of us have good long memories. Memories that include knowing this war-mongering dope couldn't wait to do more than his Daddy, another "War President". Both Bushes were/are "War Presidents" - one to help Kuwait, the other to help coffers - the coffers of fellow oil barons. Those with long memories would actually remember we who stated this dopey head-bobbin' fool would have us at war anywhere on the planet within 2 years of taking over. He was off-schedule, but understood why.

Hunt down and kill the slime that even thought of the 9-11 massacre, but don't invade a country under false pretenses, and then claim the right pretenses, when it's "discovered" after 3 years of occupation that they really did have WMDs... Forget WMDs, and supposed terrorists in Iraq. Hunt down Bin Ladin and pals where they actually were - Afghanistan. While there, it was just too close to pass up... all that good oil country to the West...

Zarqawi wan't "Al Qaeda" until after the US invaded Iraq. Then, forced into a partnership wherein your enemy is my enemy, they became partners in another conflict, against the invaders. Even during the Crusades various battling tribes banded together to repel the invaders.

Save your pity, and despise your own lack of understanding. Despise your own closed mind.

by onbliss

I ignored your following comments in the thread starter:
[i]
The quality of miscellaneous discussions at TR has gone so far down the toilet, that I only pop in when I am bored sh|tless.

While so many w*nkers are wasting their time pandering to Maxwell Edison's absurd obsession with alleged human-caused global warming, life goes on in the real world.
[/i]

You could have just started this thread without those unkind comments. Now it looks like the TR members are now "wasting our time pandering to your pet subjects and amusing you in your boredom". It does not make us look good, does it? Are we just pawns in the great fight between the Emperors Jardinier and Max?

We all come here to learn and spend some good time. Quality of discussions do go up and down, I guess it is part of the nature.

If you and Max do not get along so well, then it is best to ignore each other, right? Else it is just going to be like Israel and Palestine (tit for tat scenario) with no end in sight.

by jdclyde

Julian threw out a topic that is well known to get people stired up.

As for some of your comments ITip, some FACTS are that the infrastructure is better today than it was under Saddam. Half the city at a time not having electricity was a way of life, and they rotated who would have power, when.

We HAVE improved their quality of life in working on building the infrasturcture (that liberals complain about us doing.)

If you check some place besides moveon.org, you will find that there are a lot of Iraqies that are grateful for what has been done. Try talking in person to people that have been there. From those people, I hear more good than bad.

by j.lupo

It is amazing what people believe when they watch, read, absorb what the media allows the public to know. I rather talk to people and get first hand knowledge and then read around the world information to get a feel for what the "truth" might be.

I don't watch or read just one media channel especially not from just one country. It is important to understand all the views not just one part.

If you were running a business would only one voice matter? or do you listen to all sides on a business decision? I would prefer to hear all sides and then make a decision about my business, wouldn't you?

by ittp

Sure, the infrastructure is far better. That's why all towns are lit well at night. That's why businesses are thriving. I'd ask the 100,000+ dead civilians and their families how much better it is. Could you think that this many dead would foster ill will and bad feelings toward the US, and give too many misguided folks reasons to pack explosives somewhere, including their own bodies??

I don't visit or read moveon.org, but you're well versed in it. I listen to that drug addict Limbaugh, and self-righteous Hannity, and make my own conclusions about the mania that's sweeping America. It's cyclical, and Tail Gunner Joe is back. Now he's even a hero!! What a rotten twist of fate - the slime that put our country through neighbor-hating Dark Ages is once again a hero.

The FACT is that their infrastructure is NOT what it was pre-invasion. Yes, Saddam is gone. That was worth 2500+ dead soldiers and, what, 40,000 wounded, plus 100,000+ civilians?? I don't think so, and many independent thinkers agree. The mind-numb robots listening to the right-wing radio rats and thumping their war chests in complete lock-step (or is it goose-step) with those extremists need to find their own thoughts again... Rotating power... ya mean like California, under the reign of the greats in Sacramento and D.C.?? That's too funny... FACT beats any fiction mentioned in this thread.

Good luck.

by jamesrl

Having read that article, it would appear to me that it is as full of distortions and outright lies as it proports to have uncovered.

I had a chuckle about the "not illegal to buy fertilizer" line. I will say that in the past Canada has arrested some muslims on questionable evidence and had to let them go later. But if you build a bomb timer and buy 3 TONS of a very specific fertilser, and you don't own a farm, is that not somewhat suspicious? Add to that the fact that they have recorded internet conversations discussing blowing up places, and its pretty clear they waited until they had a solid case.

And in many interviews I've heard, far from dividing "normal" Muslims, its bringing them together to condemn this kind of thing, and perhaps pay closer attention to their kids.

James

by jardinier

[i]...half the people in these discussions (including the guy who started this particular one), probably sympathize with the terrorists, and will justify their actions.[/i]

This is total rubbish and you know it. I have NEVER sympathised with or condoned the action of any terrorists anywhere in the world.

As you WELL KNOW I have only ever spoken against evangelical/fundamentalist Christians who insist that the Muslim extremists represent the true teaching of Islam.

As I have repeatedly said, this attitude fans the fire of hatred towards ALL Muslim people in the world, and plays right into the hands of the terrorists.

by onbliss

You mention the following major points, the words in the round brackets are my interpretations:
1) Should have been tackled (Necessity)
2) Could have been tackled (Ability).
3) Giant of a problem. (Nature)

In answering the above points, without having any military, diplomatic or other expert knowledge, based on what seems to be happening around the world, I feel Iraq did not qualify to be at the Top in the list.

Why do you think it was not possible to do the same with say Saudi, Pakistan or Syria?

Edited: Typo

by x-marcap

1. Until recently, Saddam ran a brutal, but secular regime. Iran is theocratic with a nutcase on top of the heap. Iran was less dangerous until the current president was elected.

2. Iraq is going well despite mass media, and Democratic attempts to sabotage the situation via public opinion. It is a small step to a liberated Mid-East. Freedom and the Domino theory combine to give us hope that Iran may soon enjoy freedom...

Why would Iraq make the top of the list. Sadam and his cadre were evil and could be isolated and neutralized. In Iran there are too many Imams who whold life and death authority over too many people. In Iraq you have at least some people who are neutral.

3. You have to start somewhere. I would like to see Syria taste freedom soon. Then ...

by maxwell edison

Why not Saudi Arabia? What, and ruin the cozy relationship we have with the Saudi Royal family? We're better off with the current stability in Saudi Arabia, maintaining whatever friendly diplomatic ties we have. Besides, parking a couple of armored divisions on their northern border was all the encouragement they needed to change their Royal minds to help us cut off terrorist funding that was flowing through their country like oil. Moreover, disrupting the world supply (note WORLD supply, not just the US supply) of Saudi oil is a wee bit more significant than any disruption of Iraqi oil, which was pretty much insignificant anyway.

Why not Pakistan? What, and ignite a nuclear powder keg? No thanks. Besides, strategically and logistically, not to mention militarily, if Iraq was a 2 or a 3 in the degree of challenge, Pakistan would be a 10.

Why not Syria? Because Syria, like Iran, might be easier done if it could be one of those pieces that might fall into place if the mission in Iraq is successful. If not, it'll be easier launching from Iraq instead of from scratch.

Why Iraq? Because it's what's left after the aforementioned (plus Iran) are taken off the table; and because Iraq was indeed in violation of UN resolutions, which gave us (the U.S.) existing legal authority to proceed without any further UN approval; and because this was really just "calling off" the cease-fire of the first gulf war because of those UN resolution violations, not starting something new; and because Saddam was a murderous dictator who was directly funding and aiding terrorists; and because Iraq was indeed offering a safe-haven to terrorists who fled Afghanistan, running away from U.S., British, Australian, Canadian, etc. forces who were right on their heels in hot pursuit; and because Saddam was a miserable little piss-ant who deserved to be taken out. (Disclaimer: that last reason was my own.)

More reasons: Ask the people in power, the ones who know a hell of a lot more about it than you and I will ever know. I'm in full support, overall, of what they're doing. I say it's about time we say, "we're mad as hell, and we're not gonna' take it anymore". I say it's about time we do more than the nothing that's been tried for the past forty years. But, unlike a lot of folks around here, I don't presume to be a military or foreign policy expert. I'll leave the details up to those people I hired to do the job for me.

by tig2

I was a Navy wife through Gulf One. A couple of things from the "cease fire" that have been conveniently forgotten.

We didn't declare peace, we negotiated a settlement that we then tried very hard to enforce. Why was that a forgotten element? We had to repeatedly go back to the UN because Iraq entered into an agreement that they then cheerfully ignored. We DID go through all of the appropriate channels and use the appropriate sanctions. We couldn't get them to comply with an agreement that THEY entered into.

It was difficult to know that we would have to go back and do it all again. But my ex and I saw that coming.

by onbliss

There are 5-6 bad guys hanging out at the street corner. The good guy comes and beats up one of those guys, because the guy whom he just beat up had just recently engaged him in another fight. Also, he hopes the other bad guys see this and turn over a new leaf.

If the relations with SA was that cozy, would'nt it been easier to change that country in the first place. Both in the case of SA and Pakistan, arm-twisting them further could have saved (them from breaking their hands) and influenced many of the problems in that region.

by tonythetiger

that these people don't know how to make their own decisions, so they emulate the only thing they know.

by maxwell edison

You can keep asking more to try and reach whatever desired conclusion you want, but I'll rest on what I said. Take it however you'd like.

by jdclyde

First you start with [i]"but don't invade a country under false pretenses, and then claim the right pretenses,"[/i]

and when WMD are found showing it wasn't false pretenses after all, the tune changes [i]Forget WMDs, and supposed terrorists in Iraq.[/i]

If the WMD that you are saying to forget about do exist, then who is it that has been presenting false pretenses? You and yours.

No one is saying they HOPE the Muslims kill each other off, but it is a FACT that the only thing that stopped it from happening before was their dictator, and the only thing stopping it now is us. If you are the wrong flavor of Muslim, you are put in the same category as the rest of the infadels.

Talk in more circles fool.
Contradict yourself some more fool.

by jardinier

It is not about myself and Maxwell. The global warming thing is only one example of what I consider to be a fundamentally fruitless debate.

Primarily I am referring to discussions which start off with a serious topic, but quickly degenerate (yes, degenerate -- more criticism) into light-hearted repartee between peers which bears NO RELATIONSHIP WHATSOEVER to the discussion topic.

Of course I realise that many people participate in these discussions as a break from the pressure of work, but I have been a member of this website for more than 3 1/2 years and this particular phenomenon has arisen relatively recently and seems to be getting more and more prevalent.

I welcome a bit of humour, satire and repartee, but when it becomes the dominant nature of posts in what set out to be a serious debate, then people are wasting my time trying to bypass all this triviality in order to get back on track with the initial thread topic.

Nobody enjoys repartee more than myself, but I have plenty of opportunity during the normal course of my day, with shop assistants, check-out persons, or complete strangers who happen to be standing next to me in a queue. I HATE Sundays because my regular haunts are closed and I miss my interaction.

Call me a snob, condescending, patronising whatever -- but the general quality of miscellaneous discussions has deteriorated considerably -- especially I would say in the past six months or so.

onbliss, I respect your opinions because I have never known you to make a post that was not a constructive addition to the discussion, or a correction of wrong information.

I do not in any way apologise for or regret making my introductory comment to this discussion.

In a private email, a formerly very active member of TR expressed the same dismay as myself regarding the general quality of discussions.

This discussion is closed to new replies.