30 replies
by jamesrl
I didn't support Bush's rationale for starting the war. But now that the US is in Iraq, it should stay until Iraq is reasonably "stable".
This is a very delicate balancing act.
Iraq has three main groups and before it was created, it was three different provinces of the Ottoman Empire - one for the Kurds, one for the Shia and one for the Sunni. Right now many Shia and Sunni radicals have banded together along with foreign elements to fight the US. If the US leaves, they will fight each other for power. The Sunni used to control Iraq under Saddam, but the Shia are more numerous. The Kurds just want their own autonomy and not to be part of the larger Iraq. That makes Turkey with its own Kurdish rebel problems nervous.
Holding elections is not running a government - it may be a first step. But governments fall and have coups.
While its regrettable that civilians died during the war and during the insurgency, it would no doubt get worse under a civil war. And thats what would happen if the US pulls out too soon.
James
by jdmercha
I too did not agree with the decision to launch a preemptive strike against Iraq. But I assume that I don't have all the same information that the President had to come to that conclusion.
That is why we elect a leader in the first place. To act on our behalf so that we do not have to take the time to learn and evalutate every detail of an issue.
by inxale
Yes , you place trust in your leader , but even at the top I am sure that personal decisions are made rather than professional decisions just like in our work places. In my mind two facts though exist.
1.. Saddam Hussien was never a threat to US. Nor Israel. He is a Sunni , dislikes Shia. He was a threat to Iran , Saudi Arabia , Kuwait , UAE. He could have been managed. Now the future beckons to place a Shia in charge of Iraq. With Shia Iran we have a huge chance of a dual Muslim Fundametalist state in the future. Unless US soldiers stay forever. Or Bush attacks Iran ?
2.. Because the UK and US ignored the UN which was setup after WWII which happened because the ' League of Nations ' failed we have in theory made it impossible to be objectional to China to attack Taiwan in they so choose. They have no reason to listen to the UN. The US or UK didn't.
by av .
But we ripped their government out, and we have to stay until they are somewhat stable or they tell us to leave.
They can't defend themselves at this point and honestly, I wonder if they will ever be up to the task.
Its our fault for unilaterally going to war.
by aldanatech
We're even having trouble keeping the prospects for a fair and credible outcome on the upcomming January 30th election. As Dexter Filkins of the New York Times reported, rather than the normal democratic ritual of voters and candidates, what Iraqis know is "a campaign in the shadows, where candidates are often too terrified to say their names. Instead of holding rallies, they meet voters in secret, if they meet them at all. Instead of canvassing for votes, they fend off death threats." Filkins further reported: "Of the 7,471 people who have filed to run, only a handful outside the relatively safe Kurdish areas have publicly identified themselves. The locations for the 5,776 polling places have not been announced, lest they become targets for attacks."
Source:
by oz_media
Couldn't resist,
"where candidates are often too terrified to say their names. Instead of holding rallies, they meet voters in secret, if they meet them at all. Instead of canvassing for votes, they fend off death threats."
Much like if Bush was able to run a third time, if not rfom Americans you'd have an AWFUL lot of 'tourists' about that time I'm sure.
by protiusx
by oz_media
If you click to the time of a good sone, it almost sounds like you are playing it, the clicks actually do sound like different tones. Just don't play a slow song, the page will time out before you can post it.
This message is typed to the tune of "Hickory Dickory Dock."
I also saw the same report on Canadian TV recently, it's like the underground election. "Psssst, you wanna make a vote?"
"A VOTE???"
"SHHHHHH!!! , yeah a vote man,I got ballot, I got propaganda and I'll even tell you why you should vote for me!"
Reminds me of the bandit on Sesame Street trying to sell Cookie Monster a letter 'H'.
Yeah well, the reality is everything is prgoressing as expected...under gun fire and unrelenting violence.
But hey who knows, if the insurgents like one of the candidates enough, they might not shoot him before he can take office.
Like to see his inaugural parade, he'd be running faster then Bush's men were!
Election....whatever! These guys are getting killed by the shed load, no matter who you vote for you will need to do it twice weekly until the US leaves, at which time the new government will just be overrun anyway.
by thechas
Much as I still believe it was wrong to invade Iraq in the first place, leaving before the Iraqi government is ready to manage their own affairs will only make the situation much worse than it is.
First of all, should we leave Iraq now, the situation would quickly deteriorate into a civil war with regional implications.
Second, our leaving before the job is done will embolden the terrorists and increase global terror attacks significantly.
My third reason is a bit selfish. If we leave Iraq, and the situation destabilizes, we could easily see crude oil at over $100 per barrel.
The impact that such a high oil price would have on the US and global economy would be more devastating than the great depression.
Sorry, we MUST stay in Iraq until there is a new functioning government.
Barring a fundamentalist revolt, we should plan to have troops in Iraq for another 5 to 10 years.
Chas
by wordworker
by jdmercha
I don't think that there is a consnsus on what "finished" means. The Bush administration has commented many times that this will be very long war with terrorism. Afganistan and Iraq are only battles in this larger war.
I agree, America will not tolerate a prolonged presence in Iraq. But even if we pull out in 2-3 years we have to realize that that is still not the end of it.
by thechas
Sorry, while there are similarities, Iraq is not, and will not be another Vietnam.
The main issue with Vietnam is that we entered a civil war in opposition to the Communist countries providing support to North Vietnam.
In Iraq, we went in to free the Iraqi people from an oppressive ruler who had desires to become a major influence on the global stage.
In the process, we left Iraq without a government, army, or police force.
We must assist the fledgling Iraqi government in rebuilding its police and armed forces before we can begin to consider leaving.
It is my fervent hope that as we begin to place Iraq back under it's own auspices that the terrorist attacks will lessen.
In reality, we will have troops in Iraq until at least the fall of 2008 unless Iraq asks us to leave.
After that, it will be up to our next President to determine the course.
Chas
by oz_media
Then what? Send them all somewhere else to stir up the dust and leave?
When the world was against it, millions of Americans spit upon them for not backing such a righteous case. Others spoke of the long term committment and costs involved in what was not as seemingly straight forward as GWB had implied.
Americans then started calling people traitors and thankless for all the US has done fo rthe world. THey said how you give and give and never get ANYTHING in return. The world is just thankless for America makign the world a better place etc.
Several years later the truth surfaces. There is no realend in sight, a hopeful election but something tells me that much like Afghanistan, they will get half setup and the troops will be gone, within a few short months it will be back to square one, WAR. Your troops will not return, no more money will be spent, the country will remain at war.
So let your president leave your sons and daughters there, I know it's not their fault but maybe people will think twice next time they get scared into sending them in he first place.
Maybe the proud, "MY SON IS GOING TO IRAQ TO SAVE OUR LIVES YOU UNGRATEFIUL BUGGER!" won't be shouted from the treetops next time,MAYBE just MAYBE, America will actually think and plan before taking on an unknown enemy next time.
England, Germany, Russia, Japan etc. have all learned these lessons over their history. They are a little more reluctrant to support the country goig to war. In England reminders of WWII are EVERYWHERE, the loss of life an ddestriuction of war is never forgotten. Sure Blair jumped on board, but not with anywhere NEAR the support Bush got by his fear tactics and quotes of patriotism and saving The Homeland!
Unless the US and my own poor country can get the UN back on board in a police role we are there for the next 10 to 15 years, if not more.
We need an entire generation under a new regime and to educate them about the old one. Then Iraq's future can take hold of it's own destiny.
When you're hearing oh another year or so, remember the past and the progonoses of those in power, very few of them were right and most didn't even know they were wrong. Those who did, knew it wouldn't win them a vote to tell the truth.
WWI
WWII
Korea
Vietnam
Malaysia
Cyprus
Kosovo
Sudan
Nothern Ireland
and many more.
You name it every one understated out of ignorance or expediency
What price Iraq ?
by oz_media
The US is more likely to pull out 'support' early than it is to stay the test of time.
Afhganistan could have been SO much better off than it is now, it has pretty much reverted to what it was. Kandahar is still a breeding ground for Taliban, women are once again beaten for attending school or medical training.
A major water supply/well was destroyed just weeks after troops were pulled out of Afghanistan (and just months after they built it), women's support groups have been begging the various foreign embassies for funding and security support to no avail, women have to wear the bourqa in the streets or they are stoned and taunted for showing their faces etc. As one man said in an interview, "Well now that the infidels have gone back where they belong we can live like men again. They (the women) don't know who they are anymore, we must teach them again."
The freedoms they caught a glimpse of are mainly gone now, and once again, Afghanistan is riddled with radical extremists and women are repressed.
What happened? Where did all the flag waving and freedom go? Did they ship all the happy people, that they plastered on my TV nightly, back home?
Did they just moce to the next middle eastern nation who will once again pretend to be a changing society until troops leave?
Like you say, they need to stand the test of time now, unfortunately the record shows otherwise doesn't it?
'works' is if you are in it for the long haul. If the point was to make things 'better', then destroying what someone had and leaving nothing in it's place but some high sounding foreign ideals is a very bad plan.
Not rocket science is it ?
by jdmercha
I've always had a problem with this: Saddam Hussien was never a threat to US. Nor Israel"
1. I go outside to get my newspaper. I see my next door neighbor beating up his wife. He is no threat to me, why should I get involved?
2. I read in the paper that the inner city gangs are involved in selling drugs, drive-by shootings, and armed roberies. I never go into the inner city, why should I pay for the police to patrol those neighborhoods?
3. A terrorist blows up a building in Oklahoma city. I don't live in Oklahoma. I don't know anybody there. It was no threat to me. Why should I pay the cost of the FBI invesitgation and the ensuing federal trial?
4. Cuba decide to take over Grenada. I don't live there. I don'y know anyboby who lives there. Cuba is no threat to me. Why should my tax dollars go to fund a US rescue operation.
5. People in Ethiopia are starving. They have been terrorized for many years by varous warlords. I don't live there. The warlords are no threat to me. Why should the US go in there and try to help these people?
6. Saddam Hussien invaded Kuwait. I don't live there. Iraq is no threat to me. Why should the US get involved.
7. Saddam Hussien routinely tortures his own people. He drops chemical weapons on the Kurdish rebels. He refuses to comply with UN resolutions. He is still no threat to me. Why should the US go to war?
None of these senarios affect me in any way. Why should I care? Why should I do anything about them? How close to home does it have to be before I do care, or do anything about it?
Which is better: Women not being able to go to school at all, or women who get stoned for going to school, while they have the hope that they will be able to go to school?
And yes, the UN could not stop China from attacking Taiwan. Nor could they stop them from running over there own citizens with tanks. It is not the UN that has stopped China from attacking Taiwan it is NATO.
with both British and American involvement damaged NATO very badly as well. Mainland europe was talking about reforming without America. Not necessarily a bad thing for Europe, but they think differently to the UK and very differently to America, reaction to iraq proves that, so how were our countries interests served.
I don't have any problem with helping America out in her war, you did it for us on a couple of memorable occasions, however now the other boot is on the other foot and brits are left wondering how our friend got us into this fine mess. No one has come up with a satisfactory explanation as yet.
Given both NATO and the UN were created so we didn't have to owe you again what changed. Perhaps we are now consdiered socially evolved enough by our American cousins to no longer need a guiding hand.
by oz_media
It shouldn't Be rocket science should it?
Obviously this wasn't Bush's view though, in and out. We took them in 6 weeks last time, why not now?
A year or so toclean up and give the kids toys and we are done. PErhaps this is what other nations saw as futility and an impossible task when more daunting issues were in front of them, such as a larger and rising threat from al-Qaeda than was ever shown by 9/11.
by jdmercha
I don't think I ever heard Bush say that the Iraq war would be quick or easy. I don't recall that he ever gave a time table for when it would be over.
Yes, he did say that major hostilities in Iraq were over. But he also said that we are there to stay until a new government is in place and capable of defending its citizens.
However, I have heard some retired generals claiming the war would last anywhere from six weeks to 10 years.
so I felt duty bound to carry on. Put the question to GWB though, if you can get through Ari Fleischer and his brethren. I guarantee he won't say ten years, an ubderestimate I believe. In fact I bet neither side did during the election campaign.
Tell me why do people associate the neverendingly difficult war on terror with the invasion of Iraq.
Couldn't be two unconnected sentences uttered consecutively could it.
Can't see any other connection aside from a natural desire to make someone pay for 9/11.
by jdmercha
Afganistan was a direct response to 9/11
Iraq was a direct response to Sadaam Hussien's defiance of UN resolutions.
Both actions are part of the war on terrorism.
Th first link was them Taliban types sheltering Bin Laden. Giving them a bit of a telling off was definitely necessary.
Not sure that demolishing the entire country was the way to do it though.
But
America is at it's most successful militarily, when it goes in big and hard. 9/11 gave you the moral high ground, and a very international coallition the popularity to do it.
The alternative, would have been a surgical strike squad, killing team manouvre which I believe is seen as sort of un-american.
At least you didn't Vietnam it and send a lot of guys in piece-meal. Everyone at once is far more efficient.
9/11 to Iraq. I just don't see.
Hussein was and had been playing off his own inflated ego against a democracy's traditional lack of desire to go to war. Bit of sabre rattling and he would have shut up again. Last time you met, he didn't have an ass left to grab.
We were told WMDs, none found,
We were told Al Queda connection, circumstancial.
Support of international terrorism, perhaps, but not overtly.
There were alternatives.
Why was it done at the cost of the UN ?
Why was it done at the cost of alienating most of Nato ?
Why wasn't it seen that some of your enemies would benefit enormously from the act ?
And the best reason of all, if there should be another atrocity against american civilians, with Bin Laden or his buddies hanging out in another country. Will you have to go in again, with what and whom.
I sat with several americans watching the aftermath of 9/11 and I don't want to again but I believe Iraq has weakened your position in the war on terror not strengthened it.
Effectively you've been shown to cry wolf, mustering up enough shepherds if there is another time is going to very very difficult. I'm not even sure Britain would go with you again and we owe you and most brits do not resent you for it.
Neither my leader nor yours has given satisfactory answers to these questions. TB has had the grace to apologize, but I still don't see what the UK gained from involving themselves unless it was so we didn't leave a long time friend all by themself. I can live with that, if someone will respect me enough to tell the truth.
Still all that water is under the bridge, it's our actions now that we'll be judged by. If we leave Iraq before it can stand by itself, the world will rightly condemn us.
by oz_media
I also am mosty pissed at how even AFTER the fact, no apology, opps sorry, or anything was given for misleading people that way.
Even if the main goal was oil, which is doubtful but certainly it is ONE factor, if he had said, "Hey we are gonna invade Iraq because..." Fine and dandy, I might not stand behind the cause but I wsn't BS'd into support. I was given the facts and allowed to decide where I stood.
As for war on terrorism, it as been shown too many times that the US has MUCH larger adversaries than Saddam that DO actually pose an increasing threat to the US. Not to mention how it has allowed alQaeda to rebuild far bigger and stronger ever before, even right on American soil.
The same people that conducted 9/11 devastation are globally present, they are recruiting at alarming speeds, even PAYING people to join them now. There have been alQaeda rallies in England, Russia, Bosnia (where it is growing VERY fast since they did a LOT of rebuilding Mosques and gardens after the war) and the US, as shown on various news reports. A recent profile on alQaeda showed them IN America and demonstrating while burning the US flag. Meanwhile, Saddam is seen as a deadly threat to American security???
Whatever...nobody can possibly know anything that Americans don't already know though (if they do, it is deemed BS from a foreign country's slanted media, as thier own media outlets wouldn't mislead them of course) so it's pretty pointless really.
Sure Saddam had to go, to remove inspectors and go in alone, right now and against allied wishes, was just a BIG blunder by the Bush Administration.
One that the world will not forget for a LONG time to come. Well past MY lifetime, I am sure.
by protiusx
Syria, Jordan ?
Course you are wonderfully in place for Iran !
Back to Korea
Can't see the UN going back in while your troops are there, various nasties seem to have a bad enemy recognition program.
Ex-colleague working over there for a while, came back about two months ago and he said it was very nervous.
Best of luck.
by pbaryl
The elections have been held, and soon they will anounce the elected president. After the president is put into office how long do you think it will take US to pull the troops out of Iraq. I heard on the news that they want to lower the number of troops to 150,000 troops by June and 120,000 by next year.
On a side note. Don't you think that the terrorist will assasinate the elected president and this whole cycle of violence will continue?
by jdmercha
The US will leave when the government of Iraq asks us to. But you can probably expect that a pulllout will take at least 6 months. If I remember correctly, the new Iraqi government has a term of only one year. They are tasked with drawing up a new constitution for Iraq and establishing fair election process to elect a new government. I don't imagine that this temporary government will ask the US to leave.
I suspect that the US would put pressure on the Iraqi govenrment to allow us to establish a permanent military base somewhere on the Iraqi coast.
The cycle of violence will continue. But as long as the US is in Iraq, we will be the focus of that violence. If we pull out completely, the focus will then turn to the Iraqi government.
by protiusx
Did you know that Pres. De Gaull of France had 31 attempts on his life while he was the President of France in the early 60's? He had a good security apparatus and a whole lot of luck. The reason I bring this up is that terrorists have always attempted to use assassination as a means to get what they want.
I am sure that the new Iraqi government officials will have a lot of security surrounding them.
Most of the attackers had plans to live afterwards, these guys don't. It's one of the reasons why such extreme measures have been required, as a rule we want to mqke the world better for us in this life, these fellas can persuade people that it's a free pass into heaven.
They can't get close enough all they need is a bigger bomb.
That's why we've got to persuade the bomb fodder that the guys who organize the attacks are laughing their t*ts off every time one of them pulls the pin.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Community archive posts
Sort by Trending