Discussion Locked

God, I love you Brits

0 helpful
189 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

From the BBC News website -

[i]Last Updated: Thursday, 10 August 2006, 11:37 GMT 12:37 UK

'Airlines terror plot' disrupted

A plot to blow up planes in flight from the UK to the US and commit "mass murder on an unimaginable scale" has been disrupted, Scotland Yard has said.
It is thought the plan was to detonate explosive devices smuggled in hand luggage on to as many as 10 aircraft.

Police are searching premises after 21 people were arrested. Home Secretary John Reid said they believed the "main players" were accounted for.

High security is causing delays at all UK airports.

The threat level to the UK has been raised by MI5 to critical after the arrests in London, High Wycombe and Birmingham.

Critical threat level - the highest - means "an attack is expected imminently and indicates an extremely high level of threat to the UK".

Three US airlines are believed to have been targeted.

Mr Reid said had the attack gone ahead it would have caused a loss of life of "unprecedented scale".

He said they were "confident" the main players were in custody, but neither the police nor government are "in any way complacent".

BBC security correspondent Gordon Corera said the plot was thought to have involved a series of "waves" of simultaneous attacks, targeting three planes each time.

He also said the plan "revolved around liquids of some kind".

"Officials say the explosives would have been sophisticated and extremely effective," our correspondent said.

Meanwhile, Heathrow Airport has been closed to all incoming flights that are not already in the air, while several outbound services have been cancelled.

The airport is crammed with thousands of passengers, while at Stansted more than 2,000 people are queuing to pass through customs.

Metropolitan Police Deputy Commissioner Paul Stephenson said the alleged plotters had intended "mass murder on an unimaginable scale".

"We are confident that we have disrupted a plan by terrorists to cause untold death and destruction and to commit, quite frankly, mass murder," he said.

"We believe that the terrorists' aim was to smuggle explosives on to aeroplanes in hand luggage and to detonate these in flight. We also believe that the intended targets were flights from the United Kingdom to the United States of America."

Police had spoken to a "good number of community leaders to make them aware that a major operation was under way," he added.

Head of the Met's anti-terrorist branch Deputy Assistant Commissioner Peter Clarke said the investigation had had "global dimensions" and had seen an "unprecedented level" of surveillance.

The decision to take action had been taken on Wednesday night, he added.

According to BBC sources the "principal characters" suspected of being involved in the plot were British-born. There are also understood to be links to Pakistan.[/i]

A big thanks to you British for a fine job

189 replies

by gadgetgirl

1. There was no way I was going to put "You're Welcome", that's not for me to do, but you are, anyways.

2. Have you seen the list of "allowed" hand luggage?

In case you haven't... it's here...

http://tinyurl.com/jzvl4

Two points: Just tell me WHICH female is not going to be embarrassed all to hell walking around the departure side of an airport showing off her tampons in a clear sided carrier bag?? Ok, we know you know we use 'em, but do we HAVE to give you ABSOLUTE CONFIRMATION that we're needing them RIGHT NOW? Sheesh. Surely a sealed unit/pack, sealed by a member of security would be enough???

And: they're allowing prescription meds, yes, ok. What about over-the-counter meds? Personally, I take medication which can be either; I actually buy it over the counter in a large box, as the limitation on the number you can get on prescription isn't cost effective. There is no indication at all if they can be taken as hand luggage.

Don't get me wrong, here, I'm not knocking the Boys in Blue, they're doing a wonderful job, and I'm proud of them and that they stopped anything this horrendous coming to fruition. But considering MI5's "Critical Level" has always been in place, and the hand luggage option was always there, why hasn't a more practical or hands-on approach been taken?

oh, and it may amuse you to know that although everyone in the queues is miffed but calm, there are one or two who had a shouting session at airport staff this morning, sometime between 0200 and 0600 UK BST.....

some men from "over the pond" insisted on their right to take their laptops as hand luggage, as well as their mobile phones and briefcases...

they didn't succeed.....!!

London is still hardest hit, currently Heathrow closed to everything but planes in the air at the moment, Gatwick on restrictions, same as Stansted and Luton.

Being in the North has it's advantages..... delays only, even though flights to London are grounded (well, we have trains, anyway, terrorists won't stop us)

But, yes, the Boys in Blue did a fine job - and are still doing so.

GG

by jck

But, it's better than they have in Israel where all the airport police are armed with automatic weapons (because they're military) and are not afraid at any moment to stop you, and search everything you have.

As for the feminine product thing...better for them to show you have those...than...well...let's say battery powered devices :D

by mjwx

British Airport security carry Automatic's and so do the Australians. I was once in line at the metal detector not so long ago when the x-ray detected something (I dont know what it was) in an American man's bag (could tell by the accent), 4 AFP brandishing MP5's almost immediatly decendend apon the guy and said "you'll have to come with us sir".

Something tells me this guy was not a terrorist but probably had something in his bag that wasnt allowed on an Aussie flight. Like in the Airport episode, a texan was traveling to the UK with bullets in his bag (quiet accidentilly). There is a large list of thing you are not allowed to take on a plane, from lighters to Amunition. Lighters and aerosol cans get confiscated at the metal detector/x-ray station as do scisors, matches, nail-files and so on. Things like bottles of flamables may warent a visit from security, so I'm guessing this guy had a bullet or bottle of metholated spritis.

Airport security is nothing new here, they have had armories and police contigents for some time.

by jdclyde

I remember when I was about 10, my bud HAD to go to the store to get his mom some. :0

She gave us money for food if we did it. So the lowdown was I would take them to the counter and he would pay. I waited till the store was empty and no one was at the counter, grabbed them, set 'em on the counter and walked away. SAFE! :D My bud had to sit there and pay. Double bag that please.....

This was twice as hard on him as he was always the shy type!

by maevinn

I'm supposed to fly on Saturday, with a laptop, and can't find a durned thing to indicate if it needs to be checked. Water? Yes, can't have that...But the TSA site here doesn't meantion laptops or other electronics. I'll probably end up finding a larger duffel to stow it and my other stuff into, since I know I won't be working on the flight.

Edit to add: And I too am thankful that tragedy was averted!

by gadgetgirl

At the moment, this is predominantly UK to US flights. I would think something more forthcoming and concrete would show your side sometime tomorrow.

Keep checking the BBC news site, and if you go onto the link I put in my previous post, that actually takes you to the Department of Transport site, and the actual advisory.

Where are you flying to? You need to ensure if it's London, especially Heathrow, that things are back on track there.

Let me know if I can be of any help.

Safe home, anyway

GG

by gadgetgirl

GWB should be on your screens NOW with the latest..... should have started about 5 mins ago....

(around 1700 hrs UK BST)

GG

by mark miller

oh, and it may amuse you to know that although everyone in the queues is miffed but calm, there are one or two who had a shouting session at airport staff this morning, sometime between 0200 and 0600 UK BST.....

some men from "over the pond" insisted on their right to take their laptops as hand luggage, as well as their mobile phones and briefcases...

they didn't succeed.....!!

By "over the pond" I assume you mean Americans?

It's frustrating to me, as an American, that there are so many of my fellow countrymen/women who don't understand the terrorist threat. Not that they're a majority (I don't know). They hate having to take off their jackets, take off their shoes, sometimes submit to security personnel checking them over to make sure they don't have an explosive vest on, etc. Personally I'm thankful for the security measures. IMO they're doing what they think is necessary to keep passengers safe. What some object to is that security treats everyone equally. No racial/ethnic profiling is allowed. So they'll even do security checks on old White grandmas, who most people would think are the least likely terrorist threats. If people don't want to submit to that, think it's too humiliating, fine. Take an alternate mode of transportation that's not such a big target and take your chances that way.

by oz_media

It's like cameras in the workplace or public places, if you are not doing anything wrong, who cares? Take my picture, you can even take the vids home and get your jollies in the privacy of your mom's basement. I just don't care.

I hate people at parties with cameras, at gigs, backstage clickers etc. Those, more personal, times are when I am usually doing something I wouldn't want broadcast or recorded.

You can randomly snap my pic in a public place while I am being a saint, but please don't take my picture at a party where I am letting loose. I don't know how many pictures I've seen where I am either covering my face or offering a one finger wave (those don't get shown to most people and never get broadcast).

As for airports, whatever you have to do to increase my saftely and protect those around me is just fine by me, I can leave a bit early, take a deep breath and chill in a lineup, its not that bad. People expect security but don't want to suffer any inconveniences due to it, that's WHY people slip through in the first place, too many conveniences are provided.

by jellimonsta

I was on a Continental flight between Birmingham (UK) and Newark (US) 2 weeks ago... looks like I was pretty lucky! :0

by jdclyde

When I was 12, I was walking around at the mall. Hopped on the bus and went home. By the time I got home there had been a fatal shooting right were I had been hanging out 20 minutes earlier.

Guy came in and shot his wife 22 times, set the gun down and layed there until the cops came and took him away. The put him in the loonie bin, where he later tried to sue the state for loss of income because his wife was supporting him at the time.

by jellimonsta

I did not get a chill when I heard... my wife on the other hand (she's a bit of a sissy)!! :p
I have had a few occasions as a kid and young adult in the UK where I had to walk home because they shut down the city center and stopped all buses because of IRA threats. I am a little used to it I guess.
Your mall story reminded me of when I went to a local bar as a crazy 18 years old, looking for the guy who glassed my Dad in the face while he was having a drink with my Mom. After throwing about 10-15 people against the wall and interrogating them, my friends kicked me out of the bar and sent me home. Around 10 minutes after that the guy that did it was at the bar trying to find me and shooting holes in the ceiling with a hand gun. :0
Mind you, guns were not very prevalent in the UK 14 years ago, so that was supposedly a pretty big deal.
The guy is your mall definitely belongs in the loonie bin if he is trying to sue for loss of income after killing his wife. He's a winner that guy!! :p

by w2ktechman

I went to 7-11 with a friend some years back. This guy kept eying me and lightly pushing/glaring at me. No idea why, I usually would have said/done something but I was thirsty and knee deep in rebuilding my motorcycle.
My fiend had a police scanner with him as well. I lived 5 min. away from that store.
The gut was still trying to instigate something when my friends and I left. By the time we got back home, a guy fitting his description, open fired in the parking lot with a semi auto. 12 shots. This was broadcast over the scanner.
Although nobody was killed, 3 were wounded. I always thought that it was a good idea that I blew this one off rather than confronting him.

by maevinn

It's a domestic flight, so the Brit restrictions aren't valid. Hopefully they'll get everything updated before the COB Friday at the latest!

Thanks for the offer! :)

by tig2

Theoretically, the TSA will be updating their website periodically as things settle to keep passengers in the know. http://www.tsa.gov/

What I have been hearing today, no liquids or gels, no electronic devices. Your best bet is to check everything you can.

Do yourself a favour and pack toiletries in a ziploc and then into the case. The hold isn't pressurised so may have a negative effect on shampoos and such.

Interesting side note- barrel prices are falling. The impact of this may be a return to gasoline less than $3 a gallon.

by maevinn

And they're still just talking about liquids. Whatever--I'm checking everything but my purse.

Think they'll argue with me about Dramamine? Not prescription, but they'll regret parting me from it, I promise!

by m_a_r_k

The U.S. and its allies have several hundred warehouses stocked full of nuclear weapons. Why don't we use those weapons for something other than collecting dust and wasting taxpayers' money for their maintenance and security? I say we should start somewhere in the northwestern part of Africa and lay a blanket of mushroom clouds from there to the eastern edge of Pakistan, hop over India and Bangladesh and then unleash the mushroom farmers again and continue on until the eastern side of Indonesia. Problem solved.

by x-marcap

With an Axe. That is what you are suggesting. I suggest controlled violence that makes an opponent want to cooperate. Or Die. But it must be 100% certain. Make the Kim Jong Il types sleep very lightly.

Shoot his hat off 3 or 4 times. At different intervals, then let him no no more near misses if he ever bothers us or our allies... If he doesn't behave, then use whatever means necessary... When AD I liked knives

by w2ktechman

The reprocussions would be far more than just blowing up a few nukes. There will be global climate changes that will occur faster than life can adapt. Not to mention more radiation and more instability in the atmosphere itself. After a few hundred nukes go off, the world would be mostly inhospitable to life itself.

So before we consider this, we would need to build underground bunkers to live in for a few years at least.
But wait, the Mid-East already has many underground bunkers... So, we would effectively kill ourselves and allow the terrorists to rule the world.

by m_a_r_k

They want to wipe us out so we need to get to them before they get to us. They've stated this desire many times. It's a fundamental part of their existence. It's us or them. LOL And yeah, I know the environmental chaos that would be created from as little as a dozen nuclear weapons. I was being facetious in my post. I figured that was obvious. But hell, if we kill ourselves and let the terrorists rule what's left of the world after our nukes decimate it, that would be fine with me. I've said before and I'll say again that I'd rather be dead than live under fundamentalist Muslim oppression and their idiotic rules. Besides, I'm too damn handsome to have to hide my face beneath a stupid burqa. hah!

by mjwx

The radioactive fallout from just 10 Nukes would kill everyone east of Beijing and west of Paris via wind and water currents. 20 would turn the world into a radioactive ball which no-one but cockroaches and door-to-door salesmen would survive. Radiation from modern nukes cannot be contained and atmospheric conditions would spread radioactive particles everywhere.

The ones at the epicentres would be the lucky ones, they would die instantly as for the rest of us, well do you remember that episode of the Simpson?s when the nuclear (nukular) plant was about to blow up well we (US, UK, AU) would be in the yellow circle (slow and agonising death).

by m_a_r_k

I don't know about the accuracy of your statement on what 10 nukes or 20 nukes would do. In reality, it more than likely depends on the size of the bombs, where they are detonated, altitude of detonation, time span between detonations, etc. Not all nuclear weapons are designed to wipe out an entire city. There are some tactical nukes meant be used on the battlefied to kill an opposing force or to bury deep within the earth and destroy bunkers. Obviously, the fallout from these is meant to be naturally confined to a small area.

I do agree that I'd rather be sitting on top of the bomb when it detonated rather being 20 miles from it.

by geekchic

I thank everyone responsible for stopping this craziness and only hope that they did get everyone before they got away.

Thank you all so much for the fine job that you did!

by oz_media

While watching this morning's new. Bush was seemingly taking credit by stating how the US police force is the world's best (er, can you say Scotland Yard?). From three news reports I saw this morning, not a single one credited the British force with thwarting this issue, and each one implied it was due to Americas great security.

later in teh day, Bush did pass his kudos to Tony Blair but ther ewas no mention of Pakistan's astute work.

Pakistani authorities alerted teh British forces ahead of time, the onset of this whole thwarting is 100% due to Pakistani officeals heads up.

Pretty sad really.

by jck

I was just relaying what I saw on BBC early in the morning here when I couldn't sleep.

Yeah, the Pakistani government deserves credit too.

Bush tries to take credit for a lot of things to pump himself up, and tries to pass the buck where it's detrimental.

Gotta love politicians.

Oh well...no matter. Where's my Guinness!! :D

by tig2

And I would look again tomorrow as things may change from how they are handling it right now. They have already done that a couple of times today as the information gets out. Checking everything but your purse is your best plan. And let us know that you got home again safely too.

I am so glad that I no longer fly for a living. Don't think I could stand the daily changing rules and never knowing what to manage to.

by oz_media

"An American law enforcement official who was briefed on the investigation said it appeared the liquid to be used was a ?peroxide-based solution? to be detonated by an electronic device that was not specified, but could be anything from a disposable camera to a portable digital music player.

The official spoke on condition of anonymity because British authorities had asked that no information be released."

While thanking Britain for thwarting this horrendous crime upon humanity, some Americans deem it fit to ignore British Security requests. We all know what would happen if the tables were turned on that one. 330 million Americans would buy Fish and Chips or Toad in the Hole and throw it away.

An American law enforcement officer was breifed in secrecy. He was then told not to share the information with others. He then went to NBC news, blabbed about what he knew and requested his name was not posted because he was told not to say anything?

So what's worse here,

1) The guy that is a law enforcement officer that leaks information that jeopardizes the safety of the free world. Lynch him, deport him or kill the damn yankee.

2)The fact that NBC actually KEPT his comments anonymous. Is that not aiding and abetting a criminal?

3) The fact that NBC not only ignored the fact that he should have been reported to authorities but also decided to PRINT the story ?

Who are these morons and why do they breath air on our planet??

The more I read about the mindless idiots in America, the more I am completely dumfounded that they obtained 'super power' status. It seems most would have issues opening a bag of chips by themselves. I have yet to see a more clueless and purely ignorant nation.

I suppose I will now take a barrage of insults from Americans who feel the need to defend the idiot, just because he's American.

by tig2

You are absolutely right. The idiot should have kept his mouth shut and NBC should have considered that they shouldn't air the story.

I think sometimes that we should seriously re-think the whole "feedom of the press" thing as it pertains to National Security. Oh wait, we did that once. The press b!tched loudly and everyone talked about how horribly unconstitutional it was. That was during Gulf One when we at least had Schwartzkopf on the firing line... and he really didn't care that the press was unhappy.

"Loose lips sink ships". Of course, we have forgotten all that...

There's a name for what that "official" did. Treason.

by oz_media

I knew someone would see the error in his ways. History here has taught me that no matter what the issue, America is right, regardles sof how wrong it.or an individual may be.

I am elated to see I have been proven wrong and I accept your correction.

P.S. I am sorry for being so rude about Americans in this case. I read the comments about a half dozen times just to see that I wasn't misunderstanding it, I was horrified to see I wasn't wrong and posted quite a flame. I fully agree that one bad apple ruins the cider, and in this case I apologize if I did offend anyone.

by maxwell edison

First of all, Oz is a person who simply cannot be taken seriously. He's just throwing some flame bait out to see who nibbles.

Secondly, whenever a press report mentions an "unnamed source" or "anonymous source", it's a poor reflection on the press, not necessarily "the source", something I've been saying for years (regardless of the issue and/or story).

Do a Web search for "unnamed source" or "anonymous source", and you'll get millions of hits on stories written by any number of press nationalities using any number of "source" nationalities. (How many British "unnamed sources" have been used, for example, in the BBC to compromise British or American security? Remember the uranium stories? ) Moreover, one of Oz's "anonymous sources" would be a hero for divulging sensitive information if it advanced his own agenda, yet another is a goat if it advances the same agenda. And what's Oz's agenda, you ask? Well, if you don't know by now, you'll eventually figure it out.

All "unnamed sources" or "anonymous sources" should be treated equally. And like I said, it's yet another example of the dismal reporting we are seeing more and more of -- especially from the likes of the New York Times, the Washington Post, AP, or the BBC. Whenever you see an "unnamed source" or "anonymous source" used as the basis for a claim or a news story, the red flag of skepticism should pop up because there's a hidden agenda in there someplace, by someone.

From the same stories:

"American investigators praised Britain for preventing a catastrophe. 'If this plot had actually occurred, the world would have stood still,' Mark Mershon, assistant director of the FBI, told the AP in New York." (Gee, not an "unnamed source"!)

By the way, the "unnamed sources" used in the recent news stories originating in the New York Times, et al, about the wiretappings, call monitoring, phone number mining, bank record monitoring, etc., that was seen as compromising national security to me (and others) was seen as a revelation praised by others (like Oz) who used it to blast the American Administration. Why weren't those "sources" criticized? And consider this, it was actually those types of measures that helped the authorities (both British and American) hone-in on these potential threats.

Another hint: Never take what Oz says as gospel, especially when it relates to what he claims someone else said. Just read the news stories, in their entirety, for yourself; or better yet, read the actual words spoken by the person on whom the story was written. For example, instead of taking Oz at his word when he repeats what President Bush might have said, just read the president's comments for yourself. They're easy to find, and you'll be amazed that you're reading something entirely different.

All in all, it's best to just not take the bait -- especially, considering "the source".

by ontheropes

I think the Brit's did an excellent job.

Although I'm uncertain of the details, if it is as you say it is, then the law enforcement officer must be found and dealt with according to the [b]full[/b] extent of the law.

Our media? I'm not even going to get started on that one.

edit: That's almost a double-negative in the title but I'm just going to leave it. I'm sure you know what I meant.

?A senior U.S. congressional source said it is believed the plotters were to carry a "British version of Gatorade" onto the planes and then mix it with a gel-like substance.?

http://tinyurl.com/lx8as & http://tinyurl.com/hnokf & http://tinyurl.com/fd52x & http://tinyurl.com/ht759

by techexec2

"...An American law enforcement official who was briefed on the investigation said it appeared the liquid to be used was a ?peroxide-based solution? to be detonated by an electronic device that was not specified, but could be anything from a disposable camera to a portable digital music player.

The official spoke on condition of anonymity because British authorities had asked that no information be released..."

Not all Americans defend such stunning and embarassing stupidity, Oz. On behalf of all my fellow Americans, and on condition of anonymity, "I'm sorry". :-)

edited for clarity (smiley)

by ontheropes

I'm not going to do what I feel like doing. I won't say I haven't thought about it but I'm just not going to do it.

I'm going to do it... As a free American citizen I am no more responsible for what some idiot law enforcement official did than I am for what some idiots post at TR.

There. I did it.

by w2ktechman

ok, I agree that they should be destroyed. But, not all Muslim's are terrorists, and the Nuke'em approach is really ridiculous.
they need to be weeded out and excecuted. And if it gives more intel for weeding them out better, some forms of torture are appropriate.. Let me clear that up though, Some Forms. Like the ones that our US soldiers got busted for. I really dont think of that as torture, just teasing a bit.... but since it is classified as torture, then I say some forms are acceptable.

by mjwx

We shouldn?t send entire armies to kill the inept guards of the terrorist leaders whist the leaders escape and sleep comfortably. We should have sent infiltrators and assassins to take out the Al-queda leadership where they are most comfortable.

Make the terrorists afraid, that?s how you win against them. Killing one terrorist leader is worth 1 hundred thousand terrorist troops. When leaders aren?t safe they lose popular support (which is what we need).

by m_a_r_k

...we play by a humanitarian set of rules. The terrorists don't have a humanitarian bone in their disgusting inhuman bodies. I agree that the only way to fight them is play by their rules. Seems like there is more worldwide condemnation against the U.S. whenever we cross that humanitarian line than there is against a terrorist gang when they murder dozens of innocent people on their way to find out that the story of 70-something virgins is nothing but hogwash.

by m_a_r_k

That's the problem with trying to weed them out. They grow radicals like weeds over there. Have you ever tried ridding your yard of all the weeds. It's impossible. They'll keep on regenerating and if you don't keep them under control, you'll soon have a whole world full of terrorists...er, I mean a whole yard full of weeds.

by navy moose

I plan to hoist a pint of Bass Ale in honor of MI-5 and Scotland Yard for uncovering this and preventing it.

Bravo Zulu!

Navy Moose

by tphill

The US intelligence intercepted terrorist communications/chatter. US, British, and Pakistan(I'm sure begrudgingly), decoded and pursued the leads. Good job to all. But wait--the real issue of concern is how they gleamed this information and if the terrorists had their privacy violated.

by Member 25348569

I know that you're just trying to make some crassly obvious anti-liberal point here and also throwing in a bit of anti-Muslim crap at Pakistan but you're not really offering anything worth reading.

The plot was foiled when an undercover British agent infiltrated the UK-based group and passed information to the authorities. There was also a huge amount of information that played a very important role in the arrest of the 24 in London which was provided to Pakistani officials by British nationals arrested in Pakistan a week ago.

Potentially this plot could have killed thousands and changed the face of air travel forever as no-one would have known what had happened. I'm pretty grateful to Pakistan and I think that you are a complete pillock.

by old guy

assessment of that idiot. And, I appreciate your P.S in this post. However, to start popping off about "the mindless idiots in America" and that you "have yet to see a more clueless and purely ignorant nation" would be the same as me saying all Canadians are stupid. That is the furtherest from the truth and so is your observation and generalization of Americans. If it were possible to test this I would be sure that Canada, America, the UK, and Australia have the same number or morons in percentages. And, that percentage would be small compared to the average citizen of each country. Unfortunately, those are the ones the world hears about.

I think that most of us here in TR land probably feels very similar about idiots no matter whose they are. You come in with guns blazing attacking "the Americans" and, yes, it will piss us off. I would expect the same reaction from you and Jaqui if I came in spouting off that kind of stuff about "all Canadians". Most of us here agree with you on these kind of idiots but you don't need to try to put us all in the same breath. Try being a little more specific and a whole lot less generalizing--it goes much further.

Note: No, this is not to just get you riled up. I don't play that game. I just don't like for folks to come in here bad-mouthing everyone in any country. I don't play that game either.

by mjwx

AU UK CA and US have similar percentages of Idiots, It just sounds like the American Idiots are louder (but wait until an Aussie idiot gets a few beers into him).

by jck

the most ignorant country in the world:

Niger

(Based on a 4 year study determining the percentage of people who are literate.)

Am I pissed off about his comments? Nah...makes me laugh. With all the intelligent people Oz actually gets to communicate with here that are American, his push of a daft generalisation like that just means he's showing his arse for no good reason or that he is doing exactly what Max said...trying to ruffle feathers.

Besides, I'm not like a lot of Americans. I believe in the freedom of speech, so long as it does not infringe the rights of any other individual, break the law, or purposefully put into motion the afore-mentioned pair.

Remember...it's your right, as an American, to show your arse...why deny a British-ex-pat Canadian resident his right to do so too?

We want to spread democracy and freedom around the globe...just listen to Bush and he'll tell you all about it :D

(sarcastic post over...QED)

by mjwx

which was about methodology rather than motivation.

To use an analogy, sending an army to fight terrorism is a good as using a battle axe to perform brain surgery.

If you care to use the cancer analogy for the mid-east (I personally don?t but others do so I'll run with it) You cant remove cancer with a battle axe and sledge hammer and reading in to the cancer analogy you want the patient (the mid-east) to survive.

by Member 25348569

With full support from the US and the UK they are applying the "battleaxe" solution to Hezbollah. should we all act surprised when it doesn't work?

by techexec2

Lighten up, friend.

My post was only half serious. The other half was a joke. I've added a smiley for you and anyone else who might also miss it.

The AP report was exactly as quoted in my post (and Oz). Assuming its true, it's pretty stunningly stupid.

As for Oz, I did not blast him for blasting all Americans. He was begging for it and I chose not to comply.

It is more than obvious that his blasting all Americans is absurd and does more to discredit him than to make any point about Americans and America. People who want to be taken seriously don't make statements like he did.

My reply was part serious, part humorous, and part sarcastic. And, you apparently missed the point. Now who's the idiot? :-) <--HUMOR INDICATOR

Chill out. We're all proud to be American and salute the same flag. And, when there's a SNAFU, we don't hesitate to say so.

by ontheropes

call you an idiot? Are you calling me an idiot? Do I think Oz is an idiot?

Questions, questions, questions.

The below is for your further enlightenment as posted in my edited response to Oz.

?A senior U.S. congressional source said it is believed the plotters were to carry a "British version of Gatorade" onto the planes and then mix it with a gel-like substance.?

http://tinyurl.com/lx8as & http://tinyurl.com/hnokf & http://tinyurl.com/fd52x & http://tinyurl.com/ht759

Chill out. We're not all proud of all Americans or America and not every American thinks that continuous America bashing is a joke. If you choose to believe you're a funny man because you put a smile on your face now, go right ahead.

by techexec2

I tried to be friendly with you. But, you would much prefer to be antagonistic. I don't know why. I don't care why. You want to be Mr. Serious. Fine. Let's be serious.

Apparently, your point is that this is too serious for there to be any room for some light-hearted posting on this website. And, you think it is your job to set people straight. Fine. Point taken. This is damn serious. You're right about that much. I would have respected you if you just said that, two posts back. It's not your place to set people straight, pompous man.

If you choose to believe you are clever and accomplishing something by being sarcastic, insulting, condescending, disrespectful, and pompous, go right ahead.

Go take your silly word games somewhere else. The only joke here is you.

by oz_media

I actually renegged my shot at Americans and apologized if I had offended anyone. You just have to read on.

by techexec2

Obviously, I agree that we have an "American idiot of the day" (the anonymous leaker and the media) and I don't agree that all of us Americans are bad guys. It's good to hear you didn't really mean it. There are plenty of good smart people in America, and Canada too.

Looks like you and I are lumped together in the "dog house" by NeverBusted. What the h*ll is up with THAT guy? He was deliberately antagonistic and I haven't a clue what the h*ll set him off. Not getting my attempt at humor does not explain how he reacted.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=199288&messageID=2076789

Anyway, we've got a lot to be happy and thankful for with what the Brits did.

by tig2

It is never alright.

The fact that we have continually turned a blind eye to the press reporting sensitive/classified information doesn't make it acceptable. It simply means that the press has way too much power.

Should the press challenge closely held beliefs and present truth? In my opinion, they should... within some limits. The limits governing what the press may and may not report have been around for a long time. We don't bother to adhere to them. The net result is that if I want classified information I have to go no further than my local rag to get it. Or turn on CNN. I'm sorry- there are things that the public does NOT have a right to know.

The fact that the NY Times does it too doesn't make it less reprehensible. In some ways, it is MORE reprehensible- no one is willing to take a stand on the issue and the "public" insists that they have a right.

After 10 years closely associated with the Military, I got very aware of "loose" discussion. Does no one consider that the information that they can't wait to know could endanger American lives? While you're wrapping fish with yesterday's news, someone out there is using it to harm others. Or could be.

Oz is right on this one. I appreciated that he came back and toned back his initial post. I did, however, understand his sense of outrage.

by oz_media

All you do is post your clueless observations of others. How about some logic or comon sense for once? If your gonna post, at least post something, mindless flames are for 'flamers'.

If ou have something to say, then say it, if you don't then SFTU, it's pretty straight forward really.

by jck

Used to watch it a lot.

I love seeing the drunk idiots. I've always prayed I would get to come to the rescue of some cute gate attendant when one of those idiots goes off.

But yeah...security all over the world at airports is more military-ish than here...we have to worry about hurting peoples' feelings here in the USA, you know.

by x-marcap

of his anatomy (the one he thinks with) is totally inadequate for the job at hand. :0 (or maybe only for the job at hand ;-) !

by ontheropes

Oh...
I see.
You thought that I meant that Oz...

If great care isn't taken the entire portion of this discussion could just slip out of hand and go off in just a matter of a few seconds.

by tig2

I'm going back to the other thread to hide!

One week from today I should be in sight of the first cheering station...

by old guy

an Aussie working here and he has kind of told me the general feelings toward New Zealand. Do ya think we could export some of our idiots to them? :^0

by jck

I say we start in the north and move idiots into Canada since they are so clued and non-ignorant...

What you think, jd? :D

(P.S.- I'm already trying to get relocated out of country, so you don't have to worry about me ;) )

by tig2

I didn't catch your humour first time out either. You chose to escalate.

The antagonism can end now. There are really more important things you can do with your time.

by gadgetgirl

did you have to go and post that just as I was practicing on my banana..

erm...

I mean, eating my banana?

]:)

GG

by ontheropes

"It's not your place to set people straight, pompous man."

It must be yours then?

"The only joke here is you." I disagree.

How will I ever survive without having someone as sarcastic, insulting, condescending, disrespectful, and pompous as you for a "friend"?

We have so much in common.

by maevinn

I'll probably stop in in between as well.

My Mom used to fly out on Monday and back on Friday, about 3 weeks each month. I couldn't do that--I hate flying. I acknowledge that it is the quickest way to travel long distances, but I hate it. Hence the Dramamine. :D

by gadgetgirl

besides that, anything done to prevent terrorism has to be done - terrorists do not get, or deserve, privacy.

Besides that, in this country, the Defence of the Realm statutes still exist.

And for bloody good reason, too.

It also still outweighs any EU Human Rights Crap, legally speaking.

GG

Edit: "legally" has a total of 3 "l"'s, not two....

by m_a_r_k

It's also what the U.S. is half-heartedly doing in Iraq. Mighty armies have been stopped cold many times throughout history by small guerilla forces. So what is happening in Lebanon and Iraq should be no surprise. The only way to win a war like that is to apply a heavy hand, which implies that you can put yourself above public opinion. Recent examples include German oppression of Europe in WWII, the Soviet Union's rule over Eastern Europe, Serbian oppression of Kosovo, and Saddam Hussein in Iraq.

by techexec2

It's very nice of you to be a peacemaker. Really. But, it's not necessary. I've already said all I am going to say to this person. I've already made my point.

A "flame war" is stupid. For whatever reason, this person chose to start "something" with me. I don't know what or why and it certainly does not matter. This time, on this day, I chose to push back. It's not something I usually do. I know that responding to people who come at you like that is a waste of time.

Thanks...

by old guy

his last sentence, "But wait--the real issue of concern is how they gleamed this information and if the terrorists had their privacy violated" s/he was being sarcastic. Surely, it couldn't be anything else but...

by Member 25348569

but I didn't think it was particularly good and there's no law that say I can't call him a berk, ayway. He can make as many sarky pokes as he likes against US Liberals - I've seen so many on TR that they don't register any more.

The unnecessary ant-Islamic dig towards Pakistan, though, is the sort of crap that deserves a kicking given the real circumstances.

by old guy

one. I was just hoping he wouldn't be a total loss and would have enought neurons to realize it. I'm just glad they stopped it before anything happened.

There is a Pakistani that works for a company that we do business with that the two of us have had some great conversations. I have learned a lot from him on how things work in Pakistan and the Muslim ideals.

by gadgetgirl

I caught the DE -

and giggled -

ergo the "mess" with the half practiced on, erm, I mean half eaten banana!!!

]:)

GG

by Member 25348569

to model your actions on. Not.

Neil

Serious(ish) post so I put your underscores in but don't expect that every time! :p

by ontheropes

I'm sure I was the only one that didn't catch the humour in it. :0

You can see how badly I treated Oz originally.

I tried and failed to believe his carefully crafted "apology" that was posted after I'd posted.

I think that people who are truly sorry for doing something won't ever do it again without making qualifying statements such as, "in this case".

I should've just let Old Guy handle it. He did a fine job. I didn't.

As far as TechExec2 and Oz both are concerned...
I don't really give a rip what they think.

by tig2

You actually made me go back and re-read the original post. I am so used to Oz being over the top that I find I edit him as I read.

Finally the lightbulb of Great Understanding goes off over my head.

Sheesh. Talk about convenient "hearing".

I didn't catch the apology until after I had posted. And to be honest, didn't think much of it. When I read globalised statements, I disregard them. I just assume that I am not one of those being globalised. I'm special, dontchaknow? :)

I do get irritated with the failure to draw a line for the press between what we need to know and what they seem to need to print. That 10 years with the Military made that personal.

Oh well.

I'm getting worried about you, NeverBusted. I've read a couple of posts from you today that haven't been edited. What's wrong? You ALWAYS edit. Even if you don't have to.

Should I email you some coffee? (_)D :)

Edited because I felt like it...

by oz_media

You are so eloquent and educated, for a child. Now as far as bait, if you feel ou are being preyed upon, you can cower in your closet until tye meanies are all gone.

You dont have to insult other people's intelligence by explaining your most absurd deductions to them. Your tone is that people are too stupid to make up their own minds. People here are completely capable of conducting a reasonable discussion with me, even if you can't seem to achieve it yourself.

As for the source don't be so friggin dumb, even though most of us are used to it. This is nothign even remotely close to the example you cited and secondly whatever gave you the idea I would support someone offering intelligence he was told NOT to offer? The only times I have cited such soures are when people have LEFT theior positions and are excercising the right to free speech by showing their disdain or uncovering untruths about the US government. These people are not recently breifed with intelligence and are now breaching that trust. I have cited OLD issues, such as when Bush's speech writers are prompted to not mention some issues and only focus on others, or simply lie about what they know. Obviously coming ou twell after the fact. Next time try and think befroe you spew your constant lies, yes lies, no truth at all.

A hint for all those you are trying to lie to, Maxwell has an uncanny way of posting supportive links to hist posts that have no credibility at all. IF Max ever posts a link to support his comments, which are generally just simnple, single minded opinion, check the sources. Republican nutbags, left wing zealots, old stories since proven incorrect etc.

Fun yet Max?

the guy in question had recent VERY sensitive information, the suspects are not all captured and the investigations continue, for him to spew that infpormation to the press and then for the press to print it, fully understanding the seriousness of the information, is truly a breach of national and international security.

For others here, Max sees everything I say as bait. In this case, he wanted to be baited so bad he took it without it being there. Know I know I originally said how Americans would flock to support this idiot, [i]"I suppose I will now take a barrage of insults from Americans who feel the need to defend the idiot, just because he's American"[/i] Well I should have said Right Wing nutbags who feel America never has and never could be wrong, who support the US government and Bush blindly and without hesitation or question. Those people are conveniently represented here by our right wing nutbag zealot, Maxwell Edison.

Nice demonstration from you there Max, way to stand up and be counted. ONE!!!! hahahahahaha!!! ONE right wing American nutbag, ha ha ha!!!! ]:)

by oz_media

I fthis guy had simply posted his comments on TR it wouldn't be so bad. Instead he offered classified information to a national news source, yet you see some relationship between the two?

by m_a_r_k

Only truly bad people like the aforementioned Hitler, Soviet dictators, Milosevic and Hussein have the will and lack the moral character to be able to us the harsh means necessary to put down a popular insurgency.

by jdclyde

I think exporting to Canada is a wonderful idea! We can round up all of the democrats, as their politics are more in line with Candians than with Americans anyways! :p

Of course, because many are so vial and hateful, I don't see the canuks putting up with them for long. B-)

by jck

I'm gonna go pop some popcorn and get my robe and slippers on and kick back in the easy chair...

I wanna watch this... :D