Discussion Locked

Guantanamo Bay Closure - America listens to the world for once.

0 helpful
117 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Is this a turning of the tides? Has he US government decided to finally put the wishes of allies ahead of the wishes of their own people?

America's government has listened to the pleas of allies and decided that, against their own citizens wishes, they will close down GB to keep their allies happy.

They simply couldn't handle the pressure being placed upon them by allied nations and the media to close GB so they have decided to do so anyway.

Unfortunately when Obama went to ask for war funding he was denied 80 million needed to clear out GB until he had a firm plan on where to send them, so he was left seekign allies to take in these prisoners as Americans did not want an estimated 100 detainees released on US soil instead of Cuba.

Those for the action as President Obama, Hilary Clinton, John McCain, Kofi Anan, and Colin Powell among others.

Why do you think these politicians, who are leaders of the world's most powerful nation would buckle at the pressure by allies to close GB? Americans seem mainly against it so it suprises me that, despite what Americans want, that the politicians would ignore them just to keep allies happy.

117 replies

by jdclyde

Tell me, should either Canada or the UK take the wishes of other countries over those of the citizens? I would say not.

by oz_media

I just finished having a week long debate over this. Apparently,you are closing GB because of the pressure form allies. Because allies pressured you into releasing them, the allied nations should acccept them as refugees.

Hey. I didn't say it.

by puppybreath

I don't think that the decision has anything to do with the allies. I think it's being done to keep the people who voted for him happy and give the appearance that he's accomplishing something that was important to his core supporters.

As Tony stated, the detainees will end up in a different location with a different name but nothing else will change.

Just political maneuvering. Nothing more.

by jdclyde

and "bowing" to the will of the other nations in the world is exactly what makes his minions happy.

by jamesrl

Methinks this "bowing" thing is entirely too funny.

Yes, 200 years ago, bowing was meant as a sign of acknowledging roles, but mostly among nobility.

But today, bowing is a sign of respect and nothing more.

I've seen the Queen, up close and personal, and she doesn't care if you bow. She shakes hands even with commoners.

If I met a foreign monarch, I'd be happy to bow, but as a sign of respect, not to show any kind of obesience.

You gotta stop smokin the wacky tobaccy if you think that by bowing to Saudi royalty there was any hidden message. It may have been a protocol gaffe, but every president has those.

James

by oz_media

[i]"I don't think that the decision has anything to do with the allies."[/i]

case closed and exactly what I thought

by jamesrl

Many of the US' NATO allies had already lobbied the US and got their untried citizens freed.

Canada, because our sole citizen is the son of a notorious terrorist, has not done so, and frankly the shutting down of GB actually embarasses the Canadian government. They would prefer his trial complete in GB, and they would stand behind whatever the decision was.

So who exactly outside of the US lobbied for the closing of GB in the last year - a few lefty organizations for sure. But any allied governments?

Canada was asked BTW to take in some Uighars, muslims from the west part of China who are rebelling against China's central government. The Canadian government refused, most likely because its a no win scenario - if you let them go without trial, you are soft on terrorism, if you try them you will not convict them and your justice system looks bad.

James

by oz_media

Yuo see I have been debating another peer in another thread who was trying to assert that we should ccept refugees because we pressured the US and made them close GB.

I explained that I am confident that more Obama supporters in the USA wanted it closed than the entire population of Canada.

I mean with 3330 million people, and half of them supporting Oama, I am sure the US had more than 30 million people supporting the closure. It wasn't due to 'peer pressure'. The US has never acted against their own wishes just to appease allies, nor should they, really.

by charliespencer

"Has he US government decided to finally put the wishes of allies ahead of the wishes of their own people?"

Silly me. I thought the US government was elected to serve the interests of the US citizens. How could I have been so misguided?

Does this mean it's the responsibility of other governments to put US needs ahead of their own citizens'? I hope not. Citizens of the US are screwed enough with our own state and national governments looking out for us. The last thing we need are more governing bodies acting in our interests. Frankly, I think other national governments would be stupid to put US desires ahead of those of their own citizens, and I expect similar consideration from those outside the US looking in.

When our allies start paying US taxes, then I'll agree the US government has some obligation to put their needs on the same footing as (not ahead of) US citizens. Until then the needs, wants, and wishes of our citizens come first. If they happen to coincide with others, great.

None of this is to be interpreted as agreeing or disagreeing with the handling of Guantanamo detainees.

by jdclyde

and also symbolic to what the far left (Obama supporters) have been wanting America to do for a long time now.

Care to respond to the rest of the post?

by jamesrl

Um, that doesn't really give with my poli-sci 101 that says that the left generally is disdainful of monarchs. I know our Canadian left sure is.

I think I did respond to the other issues below, directly to Oz. I think that closing GB was an internal matter, wasn't influenced by foreign governments, for the reasons I mentioned.

James

by jdclyde

"They" hate religion (Christians and Jews), but bend over backwards to accommodate Muslims.

"They" hate the rich and greed, all the while flying around the country/world to attend global warming gatherings. (where do they get the money for the plane trips?)

"They" hate that the US has been the only "Super-power", and will do anything to lower our standing in the world.

"They" hate the military, and think if we were to disband our military the whole world would live in harmony.

"They" think the French are superior, even if they did turn out to be even more racist than people in the US.

Of course, there will be some that stand up and decry this, but these seem to be the mainstream positions of the far left.

by jamesrl

If it was truly in the best interests of the US to not give a rat's @ss about what the rest of the world thinks, then you'd already have a moat, a fence and no embassies in Washington.

But you've been a trading nation since your founding and even traded with Britain right after the revolution, and even during the war of 1812 (small towns in both Canada and US ignored the war and traded with each other).

So it makes sense to listen to what your allies think, and sometimes even try to compromise to accomodate them, because in the long term, allies are important, their trade (and yes its two way) helps keep jobs in the US.

But that doesn't mean anyone has a blank cheque.....

James

by charliespencer

I said it was our government's job to put our interests ahead of those of others. That doesn't always mean complying with the roar of our own masses.

Like a business that realizes it is in its interest to pay attention to customers, an administration has to be able to recognize when the requests of allies happen to also be in the best interests of the citizens. That doesn't mean the gov't is putting its allies requests ahead of its citizens' interests. Most citizens aren't privy to all the information that senior administration officials are brief on daily, especially the classified info. All we can do is trust those officials to act on that data in a fashion that benefits us. That's why it's important to elect someone you hope has a healthy serving of good judgment; someone capable of recognizing when it's in our national interest to comply with an ally's request, and when to tell them to stick it in their pointy ear. Complying only means that our interests agree on this issue, even if a disturbed citizenry doesn't have, may never have, all the details.

In this case, the administration thinks it is in our interest to close Gitmo. (Whether it is or not, or should have been done earlier, is beside my point.) If that happens to match what our allies think, great. If it doesn't sit well with voters, and the administration can't make the case that it's in our best interests, there's always November 2010 and 2012.

by jamesrl

agreed on the ever changing opinions of the "masses". I believe in representative democracy - the representative has the responibilty to get more detail than the citizen has before casting a vote or making a proposal. If the rep shows he/she fails to do that well, then turf them.

And often there are competing interests. Take softwood lumber trade for example. It was the US forest industry that pushed Congress to ignore the NAFTA rulings. But the home building industry supported Canada. Differnt industries and different regions, conflicting interests.

Same can be said for US protectionism. Its bound to make some items more expensive and hurt manufacturing, if for example the manufacturers can't import steel.

James

by tony hopkinson

Whatever intelligence value these people had, has surely gone, might as well get some points for letting them go....

by deadly ernest

1. Justify their vilification of Bush for having the prisoners at GB at all.

2. Make their senior monied lobby groups happy by doing what they asked for.

3. Get a few kudo points from the allies and others who lobbied for the release.

What they should do is hand them each a thousand dollars and let them go where they were captured. Then forget them.

by oz_media

and just got planted back on Earth, welcome!

Deadly Ernest - 06/05/09
[i]I wondered how long before the people who were pushing to close Guantanamo got asked to take the people they wanted released. If they weren't prepared to take them, they should never have spoken about closing the facility.[/i]

Deadly Ernest | 06/10/09
[i]"What they should do is hand them each a thousand dollars and let them go where they were captured. Then forget them[/i]

?? Which is it?

Deadly Ernest - 06/05/09
[i]"I just said those who complained and wanted it closed have to accept some of the responsibility for what happens to the people affected by the closure. "[/i]

Deadly Ernest - 06/06/09
[i]" the US was lying in their bed and a bunch of others came around and complained about what the bed's made of [b][u]and insists it's changed."[/b][/u][/i]

Deadly Ernest - 06/08/09
[i][b][u]The only reason[/u][/b] the US is taking action is because other governments kept putting the thing in the news and screaming about until the media attention created some responses within the US. [b]If the other governments had not kept raising the issue in the international forum, it's unlikely much would have been done.[/b][/i]

You clearly say that foreign government pressure was the reason for the closure.?

Again in case you missed typing ans reading it;
[b]If the other governments had not kept raising the issue in the international forum, it's unlikely much would have been done.[/b]

And yet here you offer three reasons, with nary a mention of what you feel is the ONLY REASON.

Deadly Ernest - 06/08/09
[i]Many countries agitate to have GB closed. [b][u]In response to the international media[/u] and the political pressure[/b] a political decision is made with a total disregard for the legal aspects occurring. Obama says close GB, he naturally turns to the countries that screamed for it's closure and asks if they want any of these people they want freed. A natural question, [b]as they wanted them freed.[/b][/i]

In the resons you cited in this thread, I am not sure which one reiterates your focus on the fact that the US was responding to foreign media pressure.

I wonder how you could be so adamant that the US was reacting to foreign pressure, against my argument that the US listens to nobody and Obama acted to favour Americans who support him.

I also wonder how you are so firm and adamant on their ONLY reason for closing GB, and yet that same day you have completely different reasons?

Oh well, I don't really wonder, nor care for that matter, I just wanted to be sure that some invisible media spin hadn't flown below my radar; I am short, my radar is low!

[b]credibility[/b]the objective and subjective components of the believability of a source or message. An evaluative criteria which involves questioning whether or not an author has the expertise to make the statement he/she is making

[b]Integrity [/b] consistency of actions, values, methods, measures and principles

by deadly ernest

better specimen as you were to messed up for them ot by them - they don't know.

The reason for the closure is a separate issue to the one of people calling for it's closure and then refusing to take any responsibility for the outcomes of the closure when it happens. but you demonstrated in the other thread you can not see that link, so I won't start the circle again here. but I do suggest you look up the meaning of the term 'Chinese Obligation.'

by maxwell edison

[i].....ahead of the wishes of their own people?[/i]

You've got to be kidding me?

Oz, you never have, nor will you ever understand Americans (real Americans, that is, not the namby-pamby ones). You can't because you see us through your own biased-colored glasses.

Our government better NEVER put the wishes of allies ahead of the wishes of their own people - nor has it in this case. It's a political shell-game - no more, no less.

A copy of a related post of mine:

My prediction holds

Guantanamo was no more than a symbolic and contrived issue to trash Bush. It had (and still has) a necessary and legitimate function.

When Obama campaigned to close Guantanamo, I predicted that he'd do no such thing. At best, it'll move to another piece of Real Estate and be called something else, but Guantanamo's mission will continue - and, of course, without the trashing in the press.

Same mission - different name and different real estate. Again, people have bought into an Obama lie.

by oz_media

Just something another foreigner told me.

I actually don't think they should close it either, unless the have somewhere eles to lock them up. I don't agree with all the captures, not that I know specifics of them all of course.

You know I oppose the war in Iraq and thus I am confident that there are innocents in there too who simply aren't being treated to what we would consider due process.

As it is a military charge and they are charged with terrorism, or ties to, they are rightfully not sujbect to the same speedy process our own criminals are.

My feeling is that there has been a lot of pi$$ing around and they need to work on processing these suspects to determine who should or should not be released. This 'limbo land', accused of using inhumane interrogation methods, needs to be resolved.

Lock up who you find are guilty and let the rest go.

by Member 25348569

How and why the US "owns" a small corner of a country with which - to use a little British Understatement - relations are a little strained.

Really rather convenient for something like a concentration camp cum torture centre that you wouldn't be brave enough to have on US soil.

:)

by Member 25348569

I have access to Google, too.

I was questioning the morality.

The PRC government and the UK signed a deal in 1984 that led to the handover of Hong Kong as agreed in 1997. I don't believe, anyway, that our holding on to Hong Kong before then was necessarily a particularly moral act but, given that the Chinese could have taken it back easily without any real consequences any time during the last fifty years, I guess that there was a deal of acquiescence on their part.

The Cuban government wanted the US out immediately following the coup in 1959 and still do and the fact that the US is still there is the thing that I wouldn't mind some justification for.

Just because you CAN doesn't mean you SHOULD.

:)

by deadly ernest

Withdraw all the US people and materiel from the base and hand it back to Cubs, complete with the prisoners, just let them out of their cells and give them the keys to the base. they can have it to stay in if Castro permits.

no worries about being killed if they go home, no worries about them being on US soil, no worries about getting others to take them. no worries at all.

now we can all have fun.

by deadly ernest

an early termination penalty added walking around on it.

Sorry, I ran out of coke and my evil genius part is taking over.

by the 'g-man.'

considering it was a World War?

Mind you, I think the UK is owed for it's backing & helping in recent times.

Care to call it quits then or shall we just back Europe instead and complete it's pending superpower status as the UCE.

by jdclyde

is it is long past keeping score.

Do you remind your friends that you did more favors for them than they did for you? How does that go over?

You help people because you can and it is in your nature. If the help is no longer wanted, you stop providing it.

There are certain places in the world we need to stop helping, in any why/shape/form.

The allies should be treated as such.

by deadly ernest

the Australian seals your seallers took from Australian waters and Islands in the 18th and 19th centuries, and the cost of helping you guys out in Vietnam, Korea, Afghanistan, and Iraq.

or we can call it all water under the bridge.

by jamesrl

For the loans it made with the US during WWII, and it did hurt the economy of Britain at the time. There were still shortages in Britain after the war, but the debt was paid in full.

I'm not sure what you think the US is owed from WWI? Of course there were many businesses in the US who took advantage of the war to rake in incredible profits.

And if you want to settle accounts for the wars, perhaps you'd like IBM, Ford and GM to pay back the survivors and their desecendents who worked in German subsidiaries of those companies in slave like conditions.

Or perhaps you'd like to pay reparations to the loyalists who legally owned land in the thirteen colonies and who were run out on a rail or tarred and feathered. They committed no crime, but in effect terrorists stole their land.

All I'm saying is that you can't open one can of worms without the possibility of someone else wanting to open another. And so on, and so on...

James

by tony hopkinson

shed load of money we didn't have, advance bases in europe, a load of intelligence, oh and effectively made you a world super power.

Let's see in return you helped the egyptians steal our canal, financed terrorists against our rule, and were willing to hand over our territory to the naked agression of your mates.

Pick a big bridge, you know, one your head will fit on.....

by oz_media

The billions you owe Canada in unpaid softwood lumber tarriffs that were set out by your own program. But hey, you made a reasonable offer instead, I suppose that is living up to your end of the bargain in your eyes too.

by deadly ernest

legal lease contracts between the existing governments of the day at time of writing signed contracts for both cases. The existence of the valid contract makes the continued presence legal. Like any contract it can be voided at any time by mutual agreement of both parties, but that hasn't happened.

The agreement between the Chinese and the UK in 1984 was not so much as handing Hong Kong back, but how they were going to do it and how the residents would be affected. The hand over was going to happen no matter what as the lease was going to expire. The 1984 agreement was done to settle fears of the residents and encourage most to stay on and keep it operating as a viable Internationally prominent city. Prior to the agreement most residents were talking about leaving HK and it would have ended up not being self sustaining without all the existing experts on hand to keep it going.

GB isn't quite the same as it's a military base as against a city.

by deadly ernest

truth and justice have absolutely nothing to do with any legal system - and morals have even less.

We can get into a debate about the morality of keeping the lease when the government changes, but that then brings into question the morality of the process of the government change. Also, the case re GB is different to HK. And you also need to bring into play questions about the reason for the lease in the first place.

by charliespencer

Maybe I can respond if you'll present what you find to be immoral about it. It's a legacy business deal, the same way the US once held a lease on the Panama Canal. It's a cheap way to keep Castro on his toes, a hedge against another missile crisis, and a port located a convenient distance from the mainland for training cruises.

by maxwell edison

..... for police officers in the United States to use tasers on old women because they refuse to sign speeding tickets, than for interrogation officers water boarding terrorists because they might have information on an attack that might kill 3,000 more people.

by oz_media

Morality, as with most decisions in the US is completely a situation of what suits them best at any given time. It seems to be self-interest confused as morality. No they are not the same thing, America, what feels good isn't always what is morally correct.

by deadly ernest

resolve a number of issues.

1. Obama and co want to close the GB prison.

2. They need to do something with the prisoners but do NOT want them on US soil and they have concerns about sending to their home countries or the places where they were captured, so they need a third party country.

3. Cuba wants GB back under their control.

So the US brokers a deal with Cuba, they can have the base back if they accept the people currently in prison there as migrants. All closed off neat and tidy. What's wrong with that. Three problems solved at once.

by maxwell edison

No country in the world wants these people because they're so bad, yet the USA was acting improperly by apprehending them. Ooookay.

They should be called POWs and held until the [i]war against terrorists[/i] is over.

by jdclyde

is that if people in the US will continue to work against the interests of the US as far as captured combatants, that they will just be killed in the battle field instead of captured.

by deadly ernest

heck, the only reason many of those from Afghanistan are alive is because they got handed to the US instead of just shot by the Afghanistanis.

by oz_media

We have humanitarian laws tha stop refugees from being extradited back home if they risk greater punishment there, in this case they will be killed.

That is the reason Obama is seeking places for them to claim refugee status. It's also not just Iraqi terrorists, Canada was asked, and turned down, taking in Chinese Muslim refugees from GB.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

'Damned if you do, damned if you don't.'
'Six of one, half a dozen of the other.'

No wonder these things are still around.

by Member 25348569

Oh, that's all right then. Innocent until proven guilty? Nah. Not for rag-heads.

Considering that the majority of inhabitants of GB were "captured" - some were sold to US soldiers by those nice Pakistani hillmen - several thousand miles away, I find the "information on an attack that might kill 3,000 more people" excuse just that - an excuse.

by charliespencer

Those in government are responsible for upholding the obligations their predecessors made. If the current Cuban administration doesn't like what it's predecessors signed up for, they're free to ask to renegotiate it.

Regardless of what they say, the Castros find it politically beneficial to tolerate the base's presence. It gives them an "example of US domination" to complain about in OAS meetings, while conveniently failing to acknowledge the badly need incoming US dollars paid to Cuban citizens employed by the base. Now we're in negotiations to remove the restrictions on the tourist trade between the two countries, and there's no better source of tourist dollars than visiting servicemen.

Of all the possible moral questions regarding the US government's actions at Gitmo, the terms of the property lease rank pretty damn low.

by deadly ernest

Some months back I remember reading a news article about a police officer being shot dead in a private residence. It didn't make clear how the warrant was issued, but in an older area with a few drug houses in it a 'No knock warrant' was issued for a residence. The police charge in, little old lady in bed pulls out her hand gun and shoots the first two home invaders screaming weird things (no point yelling police when her hearing aids are on the dresser). She sees two shapes behind a bright light and a gun pointed at her. She shoots both shapes. Both go down. One wounded, one dead. The following police open up and turn her into swiss cheese for protecting herself from a group of armed men invading her home at night. Last I saw of the case it still had to go to court as her family were suing the police department. As was the family of the dead officer.

by Member 25348569

It links in with why the US didn't see fit to site the Guantanamo Bay equivalent on US soil. The only reason that anyone can see for them doing that is for a little easement of the obvious level of hypocrisy that the prison inserts into the "Freedom" message that the US purports to stand for.

Of COURSE Cuba have used it as a propaganda tool. I'd be surprised that anyone would think otherwise. Most of the rest of the world, by the way, have looked on with some puzzlement at the US's attitude to Cuba. Had you had a more normal relationship with them, the Castro regime would have long been gone. It wasn't all their fault. Can we say "Bay of Pigs"?

by jdclyde

I can see unless it is someone HIGH up, they will no longer bother. Take no prisoners.

by puppybreath

Ever since Obama got in, the cost has more than tripled and just trying to find ammo can be extremely difficult.

:-)

by jdclyde

And I would bet part of the run is intentional. Supply/demand, make there seem like a shortage to increase the demand.

Still cheaper than what The Obama is wasting to move them from one prison to another. Idiot should have just changed the name and saved us all a lot of money. Talk about a total waste of money.

by oz_media

With these guys there is no point on holding them in prisons anyway. If they put them in prison, they sit in limbo at the taxpayers expense for indeterminate lengths of time, as they are not treated with due process the way a normal criminal in a free country would be. They just interrogate and try to wear them down. While there have been a few instances where information has been acquired, for teh most part they haven't really got anything that has helped end the conflict, as they may have hoped.

These terrorists are ready to die for Allah, for them to be killed/tortured for not sharing info is a righteous act to them, so what's the point?

Innocent peoeple get killed in wars, often by association or just being in the wrong place at the wrong time. I am confident that there are prisoners in GB that are guilty by association or for also being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

I am not sure of course but I feel they haven't gained enough 'secret' info to justify the number of people still detained and interrogated through deprivation.

Would it not have been better, in this case, to have not arrested them and to simply dispose of them? or at least detain those who are questionable, investigate them and either release or incarcerate them without the lengthy stay in GB that everyone is payng for but them.

Seriously living in a cave while waiting to go kill yourself for Allah, or three meals a day, medical and laundry facilities?

I think they are laughing at America some more at the whole concept of our humanity. Torture? Yeah some gung ho interrogation by sensory deprivation but still, do you think they are so fearful of that or strapping a bomb to themselves? It's nothing compared to what they were getting at home, and certainly a waste of your tax money for seemingly little in return.

by charliespencer

I interpreted your question being about the morality of the overall US presence at Guantanamo, not specifically the morality of using 'foreign' property as a concentration camp. Based on his answers, I think Ernest interpreted it the same way.

I won't comment on the morality of that specific question, since I haven't yet commented in this discussion about the morality of such a camp regardless of location.

I've long wondered why US administrations and candidates allow our policy toward Cuba to be dictated by the nearly unmeasurable portion of the electorate composed of Cuban expatriates.

by oz_media

Where do you get the left loving the French from? Perhaps that's an American thing but it certainly isn't so here, maybe because we have our own form of pseudo French folk here.

as for your comments on teh military and super power, again these are not comon issues up here, perhaps in the US but our left AND our right are extremeley different from yours.

by oz_media

I was proposing someone else's view, that I objected to, just to see if his view was shared by others or not, clearly it isn't.

by oz_media

Backpeddle, sidle, slip, dodge, duck, shimmy and you STILL land square ack in the same place of making assertions that don't even come close to being accurate.

So when you said "The only reason the US is taking action", you didn't mean that was the only reason they were taking action in closing GB, what you meant that's the reason they wanted to offload them on people who had joined the masses in wanting GB closed.

Why didn't you say that then? We were discussing specifically WHY they should be offloaded on others, your reply was it was only right becuase OTHERS had urged them to close GB and THAT was "THE ONLY REASON THEY WERE TAKING ACTION". But apparently your very clear assertion was not what you had meant?!

By "The only reason they are acting", you really meant that the reason OTHERS should accept them into their nations.

It's funny but no matter how I look at it, I don't see how you could say one thing, very clearly and yet mean something else completely different. no you are not going to bridge this and pretend you were misunderstood, too many posts support yoru previous position that America was closing GB due to peer pressure and THAT'S why those allies should be responsible for taking teh refugees. (NOTE: Even America refused to take them in from Cuba)

I suppose its an Aussie thing, say one thing, mean another. Is it because you are half a world away, we have to assume the opposite of everything you say then? Like our summer is your winter etc?

YOUR WORDS PROVE YOU ARE CHANGING YOUR STORY.

It's in black and white as typed by your very own fingers. sorry, you don't get to pretend that's not what you meant when you reiterated yourself very specifically several times.

But a nice try to work around what you had actually said though, except not very effective or convincing.

by deadly ernest

or some common words have a different meaning in your neck of the woods to those in the dictionaries I use.

All I've said, in both threads, is that the people who screamed for closure (especially those who are part of a government) now need to put their other resources where their mouths were and accept some of the prisoners out of GB as their jumping up and down about wanting it closed are a part of the reason it's being closed. Their agitation increased the pressure to the point it happened. They now have a moral obligation (not a legal one) to help provide for the care of those they pushed to have released. If they do not they are showing themselves to be lying hypocrites.

When you ask for something and you get, it's partly your responsibility, it's that simple. But that seems to be beyond your comprehension.

BTW: Have you looked up the meaning of Chinese Obligation yet? Once you understand that you can then move on to the above moral principle.

by oz_media

I couldn't give a toss what you have to say at this point, your credibility on the subject is nil.

Reading through the entire last thread again, it is so clear what your position was. When I replied in detail, confirming what you has said, you never corrected it or said otherwise. You just continued to repeat the same thing with more and more assertion each time. you don't have to try and explain it or pass it off any longer, it's very clear what your one reason was and you were clearly mistaken.

My mistake it was not, comprehension was not the issue, you painted yourself into a corner and jumped across the room.

Not interested from this point, it's in black and white.

by oz_media

uh, you mean you think the US should stop helping allies?

That'd be in your favour! LOL

by jdclyde

read it again.

I just said the pussyshit of the "you owe me for...." should stop.

by oz_media

At first I see your point and agree with it, but you wind up with [i]"There are certain places in the world we need to stop helping, in any why/shape/form.[/i] (I agree there too)
[i]The allies should be treated as such. "[/i]

That last sentence is what I don't get; [i]"the allies should be treated as such"[/i] meaning that you should [i]"stop helping in any way/shape or form?" [/i]

Or were you referring to your opening comments about friends and what goes around comes around?

by oz_media

Release then in Kentucky. They'll be wearin ball caps, driving pick-ups and and huntin with ther coon dawgs in the swamps in no time.

Either that or they will be found in the middle of a crowd of onlookers, just staring at them with puzzlement.

by jdclyde

In SanFran, they tried to get the military base out of the area.

It was a long known issue that the Clintons were anti-military (besides the draft-dodging issues).

to much on this to go into now, maybe later.

by oz_media

As you may remember we had a guy that was tazed in Vancouver International Airport by CMP that died of a heart attack. It has been the key case regarding tha validity of tasers.

A few days ago there was an investigative report done by a CBC based show that looked into the testing of tasers and they found that the specs the police were given were very inaccurate, much to the comissioners surprise. It showed that if not properly discharged BEFORE tests were done, the results woul dbe inaccurate, as explained in teh documentaion provided y teh manufacturer.

the third party that had tested and approved tasers for police use, had not done this test properly and thus the results were inaccurate.

They tested dozens of tasers from different departments in US and Canada(of the X25 I believe, which is in most common use)which is the first such test conducted ever.

4 out of 10 issued a LETHAl does of electricity that would instantly stop your heart.

Again, showing this info to police comisisoners in the US and RCMP in Canada left them very agitated and they have said they will be investigating the testing further to validate/invalidate the own, prior tests.

Just food for thought that came to mind when you brought up tasers, but some interesting news too, they may actually be a lot more lethal than we know.

by oz_media

Obama was denied teh 80 million he requested to close GB. They want him to find locations for the released first, which is why the quick plea to all allies to take on the burden of our arrests.

by deadly ernest

and GB gave them the best physical security. It's a lot harder for people to sneak up to GB and help people escape than any prison on mianland USA, mainly because GB has two sets of soldiers keeping and eye on the area. And if they get out they have a long swim ro end up in Cuba, and unable to cause trouble to the US citizens in general.

by deadly ernest

based on that of the congressmen and senators bought by the big corporations who had their property in Cuba taken off them when Castro came to power, they lost many millions and are still corporately pissed off. Also, that behaviour is now ingrained.

by jdclyde

One is the shitholes around the world that are NOT allies and hate Americans and Western ideals, let them rot on their own. It pisses me off that we continue to WASTE a single penny trying to buy acceptance around the world. Just because it works on Democrats here in the states doesn't mean it will anywhere else in the world.

Allies, should be treated as with respect. That doesn't mean we do what they say, when there is a disagreement you inform them you respectfully disagree.

by jdclyde

Congress rightly DEMANDED that The Obama have a plan on what he is going to do.

For the first time, they didn't just sign a check and "hope".

by oz_media

I can swallow that. However sometimes you can respectfully disagree but have to swallow the pill and do it anyway. While self preservation is imperative, there still needs ot be shared concession from both parties sometimes.

I could go on about a guy who had me leave work early to drive 60kms and explain to him that his head gasket was blown on the side of the freeway. I won't get into details but I certainly didn't gain in any way, and I don't think it would ever come back around but I accept that in the guys personality and take him as a friend because I understand his life issues right now.

by deadly ernest

very clear. When you misread it and then take selective quotes to support your misunderstanding, there is not point in trying to say anything as you are clearly a case of the old expression - "A man convinced against his mind is still of his opinion."

At no point in any of the threads did I say the only reason for the Obama position, ie the change in the US position, solely due to the pressure from other governments. All I've ever said is those governments MUST accept some responsibility for what happens to the GB prisoners now that they've got what they were agitating for.

I'll even add a little extra here. If those governments aren't prepared to take any responsibility for the prisoners being released, they simply show themselves to be hypocrites and of a lower moral level than GWB and his people because of their two faced attitude.