Discussion Locked

Guess I will have to stop being a member of TR.

0 helpful
94 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I clean my cookies, shut off acceptance of cookies, and go to see what is happening at TR. I immediately get bombarded with pop-ups to join TR. All because I am not logged in and there is no TR cookie on the machine.

With this kind of commercialization, migraine headaches feel good by comparison.

TR, get your shit together so that people can browse the forums and then maybe decide to be members! Don't annoy them every time they change forums!

94 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

There are still places in the US even with dialup so slow that the Internet, much less TR isn't worth the time and trouble.

by hal 9000

And they are in the Majority where the best Net Connection is Dial up. While some things like the Videos provided are defiantly not Dial up Friendly the site itself should be.

I've lost count of the number of Web Pages that I've had to advise on how to make better so that they do what they where bought by the concerned Business to do and that is sell the Company to the Masses.

On every occasion the biggest mistake made is to make the Site useless to Dial up by overloading it with too much unnecessary junk and Large Pictures or worse still use a very small picture format but instead of a couple of pictures the Web Developer goes nuts and inserts hundreds of Pictures so that the Page takes hours to load.

At this point potential customers turn to other sites that simply Load faster to do whatever it is that they want to do.

I have to agree with all the changes made TR is now defiantly only catering to the minority of World Citizens or the Minority of IT Pros around the world. God only knows what a First Time Visitor to the site things if they are on anything but one of the fastest Connections possible. Another case where supporting the Bleeding Expensive Edge isn't the best way to proceed.

Col

by boxfiddler Hot topic

in Hot Springs, where I come close to having a full 56k connection. My worst nightmare, however, is in FL, where at best the connection runs at 28k. 'Bout all I do from there is hit webmail to make sure I don't miss work related correspondence.

by dr dij

ittoolbox.com
has drop down boxes that block your view.
even if you ARE a member.

they try to get you to join any new groups you are browsing. Quite obnoxious.

My other problem is that if I get daily digests for a group for them (one email per group) some moderators take up to 2 weeks to approve them. So if I keep them then new ones coming in are pages down and hard to find. I've taken to deleting them regularly because of this.

The plus side is great content. interesting topic specific discussions filed under their own topics are, which TR kind of eliminated year ago, and good blogs, which TR still has.

Since it only happened to you once doesn't sound like is major prob and you can login to fix it. If you don't find anything of worth here then by all means leave, but I find the mix of IT, politics and other topics stimulating. Quite a few characters here.

Remember all sites need to have means to survive which include getting subscribers, even if free, and showing ads.

by Former member

The ads are worthless because I don't see them, and most likely do not want to.

by dr dij

I once got a virus warning from ad-rotator on major computer news site (not TR).

So they (mostly) go to 127.0.0.1 with the hosts org pre-loaded hosts file.

by gate keeper

with the pop-up problem. unlike you I have cookies enabled and it still logs me off when i close the tab ... and when I do come back I get the pop-up asking me to login again :(

by deepsand

Sounds like you may have your browser - FireFox? - set to automatically purge cookies on close. That will toss Permanent cookies, even if you've allowed them.

Or, you've not elected to stay logged in, in which case the cookies used are Session, i.e. temporary, ones, which automatically expire on close.

by Former member

You have deliberately purged your cookies and disallowed them while you work out a security issue.

Customer service is not a single thing; it is the only thing. Irritate your customers enough and they go elsewhere.

by tig2

I think I have been logged in constantly since 2005. You
might want to get in touch with Customer Service to see if
there is a recommendation on that.

by Former member

I am cleaning up some of the security attributes and need the "Allow Cookies" off while I finalize some issues.

Just maybe a person does not need cookies or to be logged in unless they are posting. Maybe a person want to be invisible while they browse and until or unless they wish to post.

This is a cheap and offensive method to increase membership!

by santeewelding

I would never be able to spell "reminisic..."

Oh, what the hell. I could use the high-end Scotch more than any memories.

by deepsand

Never could acquire a taste for bourbon; as I recall, found it too sweet. But, that may just be an alcohol induced fuzzy memory.

by santeewelding

When the defense attorney came to my door one evening, purveying fine Scotch. "Remember me and my client when you write tomorrow," he adjured, or seemed to. I couldn't remember by the next day.

by deepsand

That, and given the 25 mile, over the Delaware River drive between here & hearth, the Pinch is not immediately at hand.

by santeewelding

Couldna picked him out of a lineup. They all looked the same milling about the bar -- that kind, where you stand inside or outside.

by deepsand

The italicization was done with deliberate care.

To do harm, be it of any nature, should, in my opinion, not be taken lightly; but, neither should it be universally avoided simply as a matter of principle.

Doing harm is a means of communications. There are indeed times when harm is not only warranted, but demanded, as it remains the only means of effective & necessary communications.

A gentlemen will be cognizant of this fact, and make every effort to know the difference between necessity and simple desire, and act accordingly.

This concept hardly original. Perhaps the best known statement in this regard is attributed to Oscar Wilde, variously as "A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally," or "A gentleman never insults anyone unintentionally."

I hope that you are not offended, lest I have violated one of my own maxims.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

how deliberate your italics are, hence my noting interest. It is more than clear (to me - as well as I dare say others) that you are quite precise with your intent, whether or not I, or others, fully garner your meaning.

You've done me no harm. I meant only to let you know that I noticed your intent and found it remarkable.

by the scummy one

Always more changes, some are good, some are bad, some are good but implemented bad.
this happens everywhere!

Personally, between TR and another site I have had to allow javascript (I never used to), Flash -- recently, (I never liked it) and even to allow cookies.
Now I am just another Internet wh0re :0

by boxfiddler Hot topic

to the IW Club!
Benefits to membership are minimal, if at all existent. PITA while surfing, allowing vulnerabilities while same are among the more cherished bennies.

Opening your private computing experience to the wiles of a large variety of identity thieves is amongst the most prized of winnings.

Welcome to the Internet, the WWW, and have a nice day.

Sweepstakes winners are screwed for all they are worth, while the Sweepstakes game monger wins your @ss.

Resistance is futile.

Blame the freaking bourbon. :D

by tig2

Always room for a new member of the club! Drinking is not
a requirement but it DOES make us more fun!

by the scummy one

These cannot be forgotton

Install Flash -- keep it updated
Install Java -- keep it updated
enable Javascript -- just to make sure that the browser is more easily infectable.

then all you need to do is browse less safe -- oh yeah, turn off the popup blocker

by tig2

I'm not much for rules or organization either. We'll get along
well!

by tig2

I forgot the only important rule. Scum thinks he's in charge.
We humor him by ignoring anything he says. He has a
hidden agenda- he's trying to recruit for that church of his.

by the scummy one

of this club, since y'all are just ignoring me anyway :(

I guess I'll just have to find new recruits by using Spyware with subliminal messages...

Oh, at least turn off your popup blockers and install Flash
Muahahahahahahaha

by zlitocook

What O/S are you using? I use XP SP3 and have no problems with this site.
If you are using Vista you need to go into properties and and accept tr.

by Former member

First, unless you are using IE Explorer, browsers are pretty much OS agnostic.

Second, since I was working out a security issue, in short a hacking attempt on a multi-OS network, the OS is completely immaterial.

Third, IBM and most others needed to learn that if you dictate to the customer, the customer does not like it. IBM lost much of their fanbase over this, as also is Vista.

Fourth, cookies, or the misuse of cookies have been a known security threat for many year.

Fifth, javascript is a known security risk, and has been for many years.

Sixth, this is a tech site and should be aware of these issues.

Seventh, I have already submitted my request that my membership be revoked and given my reasons. As soon as that occurs, probably near Monday, I will no longer visit this site.

Since all of the above: cookies, javascript, nagging for membership are required for a modern website, please explain to me that while my business website does use cookies and javascript it does not compel the user to enable them. I use themes, the user can shut them off. Where javascript would enhance the users experience, I notify them that JS would enhance their experience without popups and let them proceed as they choose. If they choose not to use JS, they can still access everything on the site. If they choose not to allow cookies, that is their choice; I am not best qualified to determine why they have shut off JS, PHP, or cookies.

I use server side scripting to handle much of the processing that is normally off loaded to the customers computer. This is on the assumption that I most likely have more powerful computers than many of my visitors. I run an SQL server in the background as well. If I can not place a cookie on your computer, I simply log the IP address which is more accurate anyhow. For pictures I use gifs; nor do I waste my or my users time with flash.

That website has not been successfully hacked in the three years it has been up.

Now the machine in question: it is running a Linux 2.6.24.52 custom kernel and was hardwired to the network. It was being monitored by another amd based machine running an Apple OS X 10.4 (Tiger) guest running on a Win XP SP 3 host with WiFi. The DSL was being monitored by another computer running a Linux 2.6.24.52 kernel host by separate guests, one running XP SP 3 and the other a BSD VM for inbound and outbound traffic.

Just where does the OS matter in this?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

You are one I read with interest. I've learned a lot from you. Thank you for sharing.

by Former member

one click to cancel. I was doing more than browsing. The one click to cancel was distracting and disagreeably slowing a job I was doing.

by maxwell edison

Will close that prompt - period - and for good.

If that's too much of an inconvenience to gain access to a FREE SITE - you have a problem.

by Former member

You better check your facts. Disallow all cookies in FireFox, shut off JS, purge all cookies and temp pages, log off TR, shut the browser down, reboot the browser.

Now cruise TR while monitoring several different machines and VM's and try again to tell how it is only one click to permanently shut off the "Join TR or login nag screen.

Without cookies and JS you can not log in, nor do anything else but click the go away link on every page!

by maxwell edison

One Click and it's gone. If you experience something to the contrary, it's your issue.

Bottom line - IT'S A FREE SITE.

by Former member

I can duplicate what I described on any machine of your choosing by disallowing only cookies.

Free or not, we are not only the users (read customers), but the source of the expertize. If we go elsewhere, as I am, then TR looses what it has attempted to gain.

Irritate your customers enough and they go elsewhere. In sales, it is harder to gain a new customer than it is to keep an old one.

by Former member

just smarter than I. Since the objective was to keep cookies off while I tracked other issues, turning cookies back on does not count. That would be your four clicks. Otherwise every time you changed pages (posts) you would receive a nag screen right in the middle of the reading space or screen, depending, that would not allow you to continue until you dismissed it and could not be placed it in the background.

I am done with the issue.

by ontheropes

my site navigation is damn near flawless. Of course, I accept cookies, Javascript and what all. I haven't experienced any issues related to that in over a year so I don't know/can't say what the big deal is.

I HAVE cleared my cookies, removing TR's, and have had that pop-up float across my screen while browsing TR. One click shuts it off. If that's such a big problem for you I don't know what to tell you.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think that TR is perfect. I've whined about a few features several times and the Search function is pretty hammered too but I can't see canceling my membership over it. If TR is too annoying on any given day I have an easier solution, I don't come here. Simple.

I've threatened to quit before. Some of our members rants make me feel that I don't want to be a part of the same site that they are but that's just me. I've also seen where some, including myself, have announced that they're no longer going to visit and you know what? To me, today, that seems childish as if saying, "I'm going to take my ball and go home." Why not just give TR a break or is it that you're so addicted you can't do that?

You're pretty much a non-entity as far as I'm concerned. I've read many of your posts in the past but I can't recall any that seriously moved me. Sorry. You'll be remembered by me in a different light now. If you're going to go, just go. Why make an issue of it? As has been said, it's a free site. I've gotten my moneys worth out of it. So have you. You and I can't expect them to change based upon our whims. We're members not staff.

See you. Might've been nice to know you better but I'll never know. Happy trails to you.

by deepsand

These never really did go away for me.

They're still a PITA, but they are so normal that I've become essentially unconscious of their existence except then I'm in a hurry..

by ontheropes

For every page I tried to open here. I reset the satellite modem, no better. I reset the router and that seems to have made the difference.

It is odd that you get 404'd a lot on My Workspace and, if I remember correctly, you also have troubles with getting TR newsletters. I had newsletter issues in the past and sent an email to Beth about them. She said that I had what amounted to my own bug. They worked on it and fixed it.

Maybe if you sent an email to Sonja with the specifics she could pass it on to whoever fixes things over there. My experience has been that they do work on it. After all, they fixed my problems and I was the only one having my particular issues.

by michael jay

You don't want to be a member then don't, membership is free and the benefits are huge.

Just login and no problems, yes there are a few pop ups and such but it is what it is.

BTW your computer is still on fire, might want to check on that.

by Former member

My computer can't be on fire; I put it out just after the CPU melted. The hard drive is still smoking though.

The issue was that I was tracking a security problem and had a clearly defined reason for removing all cookies, disallowing them, and turning off javascript, and for wanting a website that would be easily monitored for incoming information. I was not interested in posting, or at the time even reading posts. I was just monitoring the information to and from my home network so that I could test to see if I had the problem cleared up. There was no reason to log on, and a definite need to have cookies, JS, etc. shut off, and a clear need to have information that I could trust coming to the network. On every post or forum change I was prompted to join TR or to log in. After 10 or so changes this gets old because of the amount of time spent clicking "No Thanks." I reached the point where clicking the "go away" button distracted from the work I was doing.

Down in the basement I have five servers running 24/7. On the main floor of my home I have seven computers hooked into this network and several others that I use as a sandbox. I had the servers off line and the cables rerouted to the machines I was using. The excess time and distraction to address the issue at TR was annoying to say the least and added considerable time to my task.

To browse a forum, there is no definable need, in my estimation, to deliver nag messages on every page. On my website I simply post a bright red message at the top of each page that you have JS or cookies disabled and that your experience would be improved by allowing them. No pop-up, pop-unders, etc.

The benefits of membership may be large, but at what point does the idle chit-chat detract from the benefits of membership or reduce those benefits to irrelevance? At what point do the often useless canned questions reach the point of irrelevance confuse the issue at hand. Yes, I understand that many who ask questions do not know much about computers and that we help these people as well as more serious issues and that sometimes many heads are better than one.

I really hold no issue against any here that I have not aired, but I do hold an issue with Ziff-Davis for the issue I am expressing displeasure with and withdrawing from.

by tig2

CBS Interactive. Ziff-Davis don't control the design of TR
since CNET. And now CNET is owned by CBS.

I hear you on the issue of the pop-ups and cookies. I
would recommend that you voice your concern via the
Customer Service link located at the bottom of the page. I
won't say that they will change it but I won't say that they
will ignore you. What WILL happen is that your points will
get better visibility through that method.

Another thing that you might consider is that the sale of
CNET (and thus TR) to CBS is still fairly recent. There is no
way of knowing if they plan to re-vamp the site.

by michael jay

Stay with us and keep the faith.

I think that I speak for all when I say that you are a resource we don't need to loose.

Still, your computer is on fire, that is cool.

by Former member

http://drupal.ro/node/2060
"Security: allow html posts creates security issue via stolen cookies, is that right?

* drupal 4.7
* How To Drupal
* post installation

I was planning to let users use html format.I'm reading wikipeda about security
According to this article
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_cookieit seems that lettings users post content in html format creates a problem: cookies can be stolen and used to log in. encryption does not help. the only way to address this is by disabling html format.Cross-site scripting allows the value of cookies to be sent to servers that are normally not sent these values. Modern browsers allow execution of pieces of code retrieved from the server. If cookies are accessible during execution, their value may be communicated in some form to servers that should not access them. The process allowing an unauthorised party to receive a cookie is called cookie theft, and encryption does not help against this attack.[10]
This possibility is typically exploited by attackers on sites that allow users to post HTML content. By embedding a suitable piece of code in an HTML post, an attacker may receive cookies of other users. Knowledge of these cookies can then be exploited by connecting to the same site using the stolen cookies, thus being recognised as the user whose cookies have been stolen.have I understood this correctly? I will disable html format if necessary.

* autentifică-te sau ?nregistrează-te pentru a adăuga comentarii"

http://www.derkeiler.com/Mailing-Lists/VulnWatch/2006-07/msg00019.html
"[VulnWatch] Corsaire Security Advisory - VMware ESX Server Password Disclosure in Cookie issue

* From: "advisories"
* Date: Mon, 31 Jul 2006 13:59:57 +0100

-- Corsaire Security Advisory --

Title: VMware ESX Server Password Disclosure in Cookie issue
Date: 12.05.06
Application: VMware ESX prior to 2.5.2 patch 4
VMware ESX prior to 2.0.2
Environment: VMware ESX
Author: Martin O'Neal [martin.oneal@xxxxxxxxxxxx]
Audience: General distribution
Reference: c060512-001

-- Scope --

The aim of this document is to clearly define an issue that exists with
the VMware ESX Server product [1] that will allow a local attacker to
gain access to users' (including root's) passwords under certain
conditions.

-- History --

Discovered: 12.05.06 (Martin O'Neal)
Vendor notified: 19.05.06
Document released: 31.07.06

-- Overview --

VMware ESX Server is described [1] as virtual infrastructure software
for partitioning, consolidating and managing servers in mission-critical
environments.

The software provides a virtualization layer that allows multiple x86
based operating systems to run on the same hardware concurrently. The
ESX Server product differs from other VMware products in that it does
not require a "host" operating system to be provided by the user.
Instead, it uses a custom x86 kernel as the host, along with a
customised Linux operating system as a "console O/S".

VMware ESX Server includes a number of network services and a web
application, called the "VMware Management Interface" that can be used
to perform remote administration of the system.

-- Analysis --

The Management Interface is a traditional web application, which
utilises a session ID contained within two cookies; vmware.mui.kid and
vmware.mui.sid. The Session ID format is proprietary and contains the
user account and password in a simple (recursively) base64 encoded
format.

If an attacker can gain access to the cookies by any mechanism, such as
through a simple cross site scripting attack, then they will acquire not
only the session ID, but the authentication credentials as well.

-- Recommendations --

Upgrade to a version of the VMware ESX product that does not exhibit
this issue.

-- CVE --

The Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) project has assigned the
name CVE-2006-2481 to this issue. This is a candidate for inclusion in
the CVE list (http://cve.mitre.org), which standardises names for
security problems.

-- References --

[1] http://www.vmware.com/products/esx/

-- Revision --

a. Initial release.
b. Minor edits.
c. Released.

-- Distribution --

The information contained within this advisory is supplied "as-is" with
no warranties or guarantees of fitness of use or otherwise. Corsaire
accepts no responsibility for any damage caused by the use or misuse of
this information."

Just two of many. Defcon routinely has presentations on cookie hijacking. The Use of cookie hijacking has most recently been used to access banking information; that is, if you follow MilWorm and a few other sites.

by deepsand

The vulnerability lies, not in the use of cookies themselves, but in the protocols employed.

And, cookies are not the only things vulnerable to such attackes.

Therefore, to single out cookies is to mislead.

by Former member

That I was tracking down an issue and seeing if I had resolved it.

If you read the response to "Micheal Jay's" you can gather a better idea of my network. I host my website with a firm but work out of my home. I use wired and wireless networking. I did not just single out cookies, but had previously determined that it was a contributing part of the problem.

I spend a lot of time at places that you are under attack from the moment you are on the website; I do research on these sites. I needed to make sure that no information was coming or going that I was unaware of, or would you rather that I unknowingly pass on some zero day exploit that I could have prevented (not that was the case here)?

by neon samurai

Heck, it's to the point now that I get excited; 404 means I probably have "My Workspace" updates though it's not uncommon for forums to show changes in the "hot topic" forum view but not show the same update in "My Workspace"

There is still the issue of a tech and exurity professional targeted site not using https for user login. Is it really that much effort to expense another SSL cert and offer an https layer over the entire site?

Cookies are low on my list personally. I have the browser blow them away after each session anyhow and there are larger issues that need to be addressed in TR's http cluster first.

by deepsand

I'd previousl addressed the issue re. Forums/Discussions showing new actvity while My Workspace/Updates did not.

The response From TR was that the latter is refreshed much less frequently than the former,

by neon samurai

Less to refresh in the active forum lists versus the number of members potentially attached at any given time. It's not a huge issue provided I remember to check the active forums list when my personal subscription list shows nothing.

so, now it's the login form missing SSL certs and the 404s.. but the content keeps bringing me back.

by deepsand

However, how does such mitigate the need for clarification of the earlier mention of cookies, so as to not perpetrate the myths about cookies being "bad?"

by mrkesik

You need cookies for about every site you login to. Cookies aren't dangerous either, you just have to clean them out every so often.

This discussion is closed to new replies.