Discussion Locked

GWB's first Presidential Veto

0 helpful
183 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

George W Bush has vetoed a bill which would have lifted a ban on federal funding for new embryonic stem cell research.

He is quoted as saying "It crosses a moral boundary that our decent society needs to respect, so I vetoed it,".

The setting in which he announced the veto, surrounded by "snowflake babies", was quite sickeningly contrived.

The veto comes despite polls suggest that most Americans back the research, which scientists hope will lead to cures for serious illnesses such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's.

What is much more interesting for me is his words, suggesting that there is a "moral boundary" that exists with him - and fellow Christian Fundamentalists - on the side of "good" and a majority of American citizens on the other.

From my perspective, I needed no proof that he is a dangerous religious nutter, but, regardless of whether you believe that stem cell research is moral or not, do you feel that it is appropriate for your President to so define morality - and immorality?

How do YOU feel?

183 replies

by maecuff

for the continuation of stem cell research. As for morality, my definition changes depending on what suits me at the time, so I'm pretty sure GWB isn't going to be able to handle that for me. :)

by dmambo

If you look at the states that put him over the top, they are bastions of religious conservatism in the uniquely American style. I think that the mobilized conservative Christians who helped put him in office would have have expected him to do just what he did.

In a way, the religious right has a lot in common with Islamic fundamentalist governments. Their belief system is expected to color their entire lives, including their politics. It's a contrast to some Western European governments in countries that are largely Catholic, but have many liberal views on social issues and where religion can be "compartmentalized" so as not to intrude.

BTW, what's a "snowflake baby"? Haven't heard that one before.

edit: I just noticed that EL has resurfaced AGAIN!

by Member 25348569

This is a child born to an infertile woman by implanting a donor embryo. The embryo has usually been frozen during in vitro fertilization procedures when, routinely, more embyos are created than are required. If the in vitro fertilization is successful or stopped for other reasons then these excess embryos are usually destroyed but can be used - "adopted" - if the donors are willing.

Does that make sense? Anyway, for GWB to surround himself with a roomful of these children when exercising his veto was completely barf-making!

Neil :D

As for EL. Some total loon has gone in and posted an answer to a year-old post. No accounting for stupidity. We just have to hope that EL is merely stirring in its sleep.

by j.lupo

was happening. I don't bother to try and find it now. So, I guess I am lucky on that one! ;)

by Member 25348569

What an awful thought that that could happen in your country or - less likely - mine. That's the way it is in Islamic Theocracies, you know. They just have a different "Book of Words" to you Christians, you know. Yours is no better than theirs and vice versa. They're just different. Interpretations are just different.

Most of the European countries managed to dump the Catholic Church's involvement in government and at that point were able to insist that the church burnt their own heretics and Jews.

"higher judgement". Well, you hope so else your whole belief system is based on very, very shaky premises. But you don't [b]know[/b] the truth of God yet you wish to impose it on everyone.

Hmmmm.

by onbliss

You said: "That means that right and wrong are immutable, and that if something is wrong yesterday it is wrong today."

Can you define the scope of your statement? Is it specific to certain facet of life like say - Killing, stealing - or do you think it can be generalized to all facets of life?

And would you agree that the corollary would be "that if something is [b]right[/b] yesterday it is [b]right[/b] today" ?

by wingedmonkey

I do not believe it is appropriate for the President of a country that claims to seperate Church and State to define morality-immortality. I can not imagine how many different belief systems there are that are contrary to GW's spiritual center. I would like to think they still had the ability to believe differently without the President now telling them that they are Immoral.
I appreciate Dmambo's post and the connection to a political agenda.

Edited after receiving some good feedback/insight from DMambo.

by dmambo

Winged, I believe a critical distinction is that the the "lives" (read "souls") saved by the stem cell veto are unable to provide any defense for themselves, whereas the American lives lost in Iraq and Afghanistan are men and women who have made a choice to fulfill their duty to country by putting themselves at risk, and are willing to risk the ultimate sacrifice. People fighting our troops are also making a choice, and would not be at risk if they would simply cease hostilities. It's basically the same arguement used to support capital punishment.

Of course this neglects those innocents lost through collateral damage, which fall into the "regrettable" category.

I think that some inconsistency shows when conservatives oppose doctor-assisted suicide bills. Those are people who have made a decision to end their own lives, presumably after accounting for their own religious convictions, and yet the state prevents them from carrying out their plans. At least from carrying out their plans in a controlled and humane way.

It all boils down to religion, and I don't believe that there's a religion practised on this planet that doesn't have some contradictions built into its tenets.

by jamesrl

I don't think the two are either mutually exclusive or inexoriably linked.

One can be "religious" and immoral by a common standard of morality. One can be highly moral and not follow any religion.

Therefore, I think given that the man was elected (twice), he has the right to vote his conscience. Thats the way the system works.

Personally I don't agree with his choice, but he has the right to make it, and we can't ignore the rules of the whole system of government just because we disagree with a decision.

James

by jdclyde

to do what they feel is the right thing to do, not what they feel is the popular thing to do.

It is funny listening to the people that throw out the anti-religious rants, kind of like they are attesting to religion being a bad thing.

Makes the title to Colters new book even more relevent, huh?

by Member 25348569

The bill was passed by a Congress majority but by less than the two thirds majority required to negate the Veto. He is imposing HIS morality, HIS conscience, HIS Biblical Viewpoint on the rest of American society. I suppose that the saving grace is that he's only done it this once.

I do feel that Religion and Morality ARE inexorably linked in the minds of such as GWB and, unfortunately, this leaves very little room for ethics.

by j.lupo

but we can make our voices heard. That is the way we have to do it. Also, that last election and even the first one had a lot of problems with the votes.

There were people waiting to vote at places (including several deciding states) that never got the chance cause the polls closed while they were waiting in 3 and 4 hour lines. In addition, absentee ballots were found later to have not been counted or used. They had been "misplaced". I don't remember where I read the articles about this, but I (my opinion) believe them to be true. The articles all came out about 3 months after the election. We still hear things once in a while about it.

The election process in the US has needed revision for some time. It no longer truly reflects the will of the American people. But that is my opinion.

by jdclyde

Bush is the first and only President of the Unitied States of America to ever provide funding for stem cell research, Clinton refused to.

Bush gave the funding to test on the EXISTING embryos, but is refusing to intentionally CREATE them just for the purpose of testing on them.

Of course the average person is [b]stupid[/b] enough to believe the media spin that[b] "Bush is banning stem cell research"![/b] Please feel free to show ANY organization or country that is CURRENTLY providing more funding.

To create for the purpose of experimentation, if you are in favor of this, you would just LOVE a man named Josef Mengele. Learned a lot, but at a high "MORAL" price. http://www.remember.org/educate/medexp.html

This is not about religion, and it is sad to see some here reduce moral/immoral to something only a religious person would have. I thought we had determined that non-religious people have morals too?

by dmambo

It about the politics of the religious people who elected Bush. I think he's essentially fulfilling an election promise that he made.

So for those people who expected him to veto the bill, it's is about religion. For Bush, it's about politics.

I guess you put your finger on the kernel of the issue. You are equating the embryos with fully-formed, breathing humans in your Mengele analogy. Many people do not put the two in the same category. Bush is implying that there's a slippery slope between embryonic research and people selling babies (to be hyperbolic). I don't see it. I'm sad to think that the research will be done elsewhere.

And I don't foresee the embryos being created specifically for the use in reasearch. There are many embryos, formed outside the woman's body, created to ensure that there will be enough for sucessful implantation, that are eventually destroyed because they are "leftovers". These are the candidates for the research.

We'll have move forward disagreeing about this one, bud.

by tonythetiger

"I don't see it."

and

"And I don't foresee"

That's exactly why he (Bush) is the President and you're not :)

by jdclyde

The embryos already made for other purposes ARE being used for testing using government money provided by Bush.

He is just saying that the government will not pay to create NEW embryos for the purpose of testing.

And Bush is not stopping anyone else from doing this, just saying the government will not pay for it. How do you get "the research will be done elsewhere"? Just means someone else will be paying for it, just like MOST medical research is.

There IS NO BAN on the research, although many dishonest political hacks would have you believe so. That is an intentional lie told to people to stupid or lazy to find out otherwise. They KNOW that a majority of the anti-bush crowd are too busy watching American Idol to watch the news or read a paper.

And yes, the demonCrats are already talking about his as an election issue. Just listen to they way it will be presented, and you will not be able to help but be offended at just how stupid they really think you are.

by tonythetiger

It's not far from inducing a pregnancy so that you can harvest the organs of the fetus. Not to mention the other potential cans of worms: are women to be forced to provide these embryos? Are we going to PAY them for the service? There are surely others.

by jamesrl

From reading a few source is that currently the rule is that research can only take place on specific embryos created prior to 2001 and that the bill would open that up to embryos created since then.

These are, from my reading, embryos created for in vitro fertilization. If they are are not used for IVF, they are stored and eventually destroyed. Thr research uses embryos that would be destroyed.

Who said anything about forcing women or paying them- thats a long stretch to a slippery slope.

If you think that destroying embryos is destroying life, then all of those children who sat with Bush, created from embryos, have parents who are murderers.

James

by tonythetiger

don't have the same reason. I don't have a problem with the research, but don't think the government should be funding it.

As far as morality/immorality goes, everybody defines it as they see fit. Being President doesn't extinguish his right of stating his definition.

"The veto comes despite polls suggest that most Americans back the research,"

One: But did the poll ask if they approved of the government [b]funding[/b] it?

Two: A leader who leads by poll is no leader. The majority is sometimes wrong! One who does not realize this is very simple-minded.

by Member 25348569

But, taken at face value, it's a pretty arrogant, uninformed statement and I would have expected better of you.

Excuse me if I'd rather have ethics than an imposed moral code with which I disagree. What you "moral" American people always forget is that Sharia Law is an equally valid moral code as that under which you live. That's what happens when your morality is defined by a God.

by tonythetiger

It's an ethics violation for me to accept a gift from a contractor valued at $25.00 or more, but if it's $24.99 it's ok.

It's a violation of my morals to accept either one.

by dmambo

I was trying to emphsize that these are my opinions and specifically trying not to be confrontational about it. I suppose I could had used "I don't think it'll happen" and "It's not my expectation that..." and had the same effect.

But call 'em like you see 'em. And thanks for the smiley.

by jdclyde

that IS voting his conscience.

Doing what HE feels is the right thing to do, even if others do not agree.

Ethical behavior is doing what you feel is the right thing to do, even when it isn't the easy thing to do.

by Member 25348569

It's not a simple matter of voting. He is negating the wishes of Congress (and the American people). I'm not really criticising as it is your political system and not mine - and I'm thankful for it in this case.

My key point, which no-one has yet answered, is whether he should be allowed to define the "moral boundaries" of a country with such a diverse set of moral codes.

Ethics is (or should be) a set of agreed codes of conduct for a group of people, be it a society or a more selected group. The difference between ethics and morality is whether the codes of conduct are formulated and agreed within that body (ethics) or imposed by an external agent (morality). That external agent is usually either the State or a Religion or one acting via the other.

You want GWB's rather ignorant Country Christian morals to form the basis of the way your country operates, be my guest.

by tonythetiger

that way for a reason... so that the majority could run roughshod over the minority... even when the majority is WRONG!

Without it, we'd essentially have mob rule.

"Ethics is (or should be) a set of agreed codes of conduct for a group of people, be it a society or a more selected group."

So if "the group" agrees that slavery is ethical, it's ethical? How convenient!

by jamesrl

The President has the right to veto any bill. The founding fathers set it up that way to balance the powers between Congress, The President and the courts.

I don't agree with Bush's decision, but he has the right to make it.

James

by Member 25348569

No one has in this thread. But hold on, one will come eventually...

My original question is not about religion per se but about the separation of religion from politics and morality from ethics.

The key point is that what is "right" for GWB is based on his Bible-inspired moral values and not necessarily based on an impartial judgement of what is right for the country. The latter is, of course, what he was elected to do and paid to do.

by j.lupo

That is the point that many people miss. I am certainly not anti-religion. I feel it is for each person to decide what they need and don't need. I don't know if you were involved with one of my conversations with onbliss about things being "shoved down my throat".

I believe my values and morals and religion are important to me. I don't like others trying to tell me what I should believe. It is fine to discuss the merits of something, but to enforce a belief then I have a problem with that.

I believe America was suppose to be a melting pot. A place where there was "No one true way" and now under GWB it seems like we are trying to take that away from the people. The Constitution - "We the People...", I think the signers must be turning in their graves.

by Member 25348569

Well, if that's what you reckon then that's what you reckon.

What I posted was my own opinion regardless of what your constitution does or does not say and how it is interpreted (it's much like the Bible in that respect - different things to different men).

My point is that the President may of course vote any which way he wants to according to his beliefs and conscience. When it comes to vetoing the decision of Congress, however, he has to be more, well, Presidential and judge fairly what he is doing rather than indulging his personal views as in this case. When it comes to defining the "moral boundaries" of your society, he should keep his patronising gob shut. When it comes to surrounding himself with all those little children (in the images that I can find, mostly or all white) whilst doing it, Gah! Sick-making! FOAD!

Just my thoughts. When all is said and done, he's yours and not mine.

Neil :)

by mickster269

I wasn't really going ballistic - I was trying to show how sometimes words can be taken out of context, and made into an issue that doesn't exist.

I really do respect everyone's right to thier own religious beliefs, even if that is NO religious beliefs. And I agree that the government shouldn't destroy anyone's beliefs...or promote anyone else's.

What I saw yesterday was the "Leader" of my country tell me that he doesn't care what the majority of our elected Congress wants, what the majority of US Citizens want. He has decided that HE will tell us what is morally right and wrong. He is deciding on HIS religous and moral beliefs what is right and wrong, the rest of the nation be damned.

I don't want any President defining MY morals. Not Bush, not Clinton - any of 'em. I don't want any religion to tell me who I can sleep with, who I can have a civil union with (not marriage, mind you, civil union), what day I can buy beer, etc.

I of course didn't really think you felt I shouldn't vote, because I wasn't of your faith. But I do get the *impression* that many deeply religious christians DO feel that way. So it wasn't aimed at you as a person.

See, even Buddhists can get cranky.

Editied because I can't complete a sentance to save my life somedays.

by jdclyde

There is no such statement in any of our legal documents, and was just taken OUT OF CONTEXT from a letter that Jefferson wrote.

Pathetically distorted, and poorly supported by the anti's, to be pushed on the masses that are too stupid to know better.

There are peopel STUPID enough in this country to think our Constitution actually says that. Sad. That must be where the "stupid American" image comes from that we hear tell of?

by j.lupo

quoted him as saying he wouldn't take a life to save another life. What then does he call war? You take lives in war to supposedly save other lives.

I have no love for GWB and I have always felt that he was as bad as Hussein, the Iran leaders, Hamas leaders, etc. He is just more subtle (for him anyway) then they are. He wants to make America the Empire of Bush. He even started setting the stage for his brother (the Gov of Florida) to run for President.

Bush (regardless of individual beliefs about such issues) wants to adapt our constitution to make marriage between a man and a woman the only legal marriage. He wants to prevent research that might help people with serious problems.

I am not saying whether I am for or against the various religous right issues, what I am saying is that these are personal values and morals and in a country that is SUPPOSE to be a melting pot of cultures, diversity of peoples, He is trying to make everyone the same with the same beliefs, etc.

I only hope we can get him and his cronies out of Washington before it is too late and those laws are changed too. Changed to allow them even more power.

by old guy

surprised by your post. I don't think Bush, nor any other American president has tortured and killed their fellow countrymen as Hussein and Iran and Hamas leaders have. Before you or anyone points out the torture at Guantanamo I stated their fellow countrymen. War is nasty and war is horrendous. Bad things happen in war--that's the reason it's war. And, like it or not no one can have an "empire" in government here. There are too many checks and balances and there is no way, unless all of us loses our minds at the same time, that any president could control all of the government.

As far as getting Bush and his cronies out of Washington that will happen soon. However, whoever is put in next time won't be much different. A lot of people won't like that either. The next "regime" will be held to the same checks and balances.

by j.lupo

of me. But I do see Bush in that light as Hussein and so on. I mean, I don't KNOW of any countrymen who have been tortured, but then there is a lot of secrets that still haven't gotten out. I could be completely wrong, and I admit that. That is why I say that it is only my opinion of him and not necessarily correct or right. Just my view.

War is horrible. I don't like it and I feel that the opposite isn't necessarily Peace either. I just wish it were possible for war to be a war of words without hostility and bloodshed and hate.

I don't pretend that a change in government here would make things better. All I can do is hope that enough people learned some lesson from what has happened and will get out and VOTE for the best of the worst that we have to choose from.

As to creating an "empire", well we have a majority in the Congress now that is from his party, he appoints the Judges that sit on the supreme court, slowly he gets control of government through appointements and supporters. Then next you know the laws are changing to give him even more power. The illegal (or questionably so) wiretapping is another example.

This is all just my opinion based on my reading, communicating and deving into understanding the current world in which we live. Could my perceptions of reality be wrong - absolutely. However, this is how I view reality right now and that doesn't make it wrong for me, just maybe not what will happen. I really hope that time proves my reality to be a myth and a new better reality takes its place.

Hope all that made sense.

by dmambo

See James' post below. The bill was about gov't funding of research, not creating embryos. The embyos that would be made available are going to be destroyed anyway. Many embryos are now sitting in the deep freeze right there next to Walt Disney and Ted Williams' head.

The Republicans will use this as a political wedge issue as well.

I DO NOT watch American Idol. But that Last Comic Standing show just kills me! :)

by maecuff

I watch Last Comic Standing also. It's the only 'reality' show that I've ever watched. I thought Gabriel Iglasias (sp?) had such a good shot at winning..then he went and got himself kicked off..

And as long as I am posting COMPLETELY off subject.. I had the worst, more horrible earwig ever. I was scanning through the music channels last night, and the 70's station played the song Rocky. From 1975. You remember that, right.. you know..Rocky I've never been in love before, don't know if I can do it..

I instantly remembered all of the words and last night I woke up a bazillion times with that stupid, smarmy, lame-a$$ song going through my head.

by Member 25348569

The purpose of professional ethics is to provide guidelines and codes of conduct for a professional body. I suggest that what you are describing are simply company rules. Either case, I fail to see your point unless you are holding yourself up as an example of a moral being whose God-given code is superior to that of the professional body.

Much like GWB in this case, I reckon.

Neil

(If your moral code that allows you to refuse all gifts [b]isn't[/b] God-given then it merely comes from your own ethics anyway).

by Member 25348569

DAD:
There are Jews in the world.
There are Buddhists.
There are Hindus and Mormons, and then
There are those that follow Mohammed, but
I've never been one of them.

I'm a Roman Catholic,
And have been since before I was born,
And the one thing they say about Catholics is:
They'll take you as soon as you're warm.

You don't have to be a six-footer.
You don't have to have a great brain.
You don't have to have any clothes on. You're
A Catholic the moment Dad came,

Because

Every sperm is sacred.
Every sperm is great.
If a sperm is wasted,
God gets quite irate.

CHILDREN:
Every sperm is sacred.
Every sperm is great.
If a sperm is wasted,
God gets quite irate.

GIRL:
Let the heathen spill theirs
On the dusty ground.
God shall make them pay for
Each sperm that can't be found.

CHILDREN:
Every sperm is wanted.
Every sperm is good.
Every sperm is needed
In your neighbourhood.

MUM:
Hindu, Taoist, Mormon,
Spill theirs just anywhere,
But God loves those who treat their
Semen with more care.

MEN:
Every sperm is sacred.
Every sperm is great.
WOMEN:
If a sperm is wasted,...
CHILDREN:
...God get quite irate.

PRIEST:
Every sperm is sacred.
BRIDE and GROOM:
Every sperm is good.
NANNIES:
Every sperm is needed...
CARDINALS:
...In your neighbourhood!

CHILDREN:
Every sperm is useful.
Every sperm is fine.
FUNERAL CORTEGE:
God needs everybody's.
MOURNER #1:
Mine!
MOURNER #2:
And mine!
CORPSE:
And mine!

NUN:
Let the Pagan spill theirs
O'er mountain, hill, and plain.
HOLY STATUES:
God shall strike them down for
Each sperm that's spilt in vain.

EVERYONE:
Every sperm is sacred.
Every sperm is good.
Every sperm is needed
In your neighbourhood.

Every sperm is sacred.
Every sperm is great.
If a sperm is wasted,
God gets quite iraaaaaate!

by dmambo

Neil, you're a regular pain in the a$$. You must have expected this topic to take off.

The fun's just starting!!

Well, I'll be on vacation next week, so I'll miss the bulk of it. (I hope). :D

by j.lupo

and don't give it another thought. The thread will still be here when you get back.

by Member 25348569

Religion and politics together!

Who could ask for a better topic? We haven't had a really vicious thread for a while. I thought we all needed shaking up!

]:)

by onbliss

...you are not going to vacation in Lebanon. On second thoughts, there might not be a country by that name, next week.

Have a nice time :-)

by dmambo

I'm going to CANADA!!!!

Driving tour through New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and if time permits, PEI.

Since we'll towing our pop-up camper behind the mini-van (how macho is THAT???) I'd appreciate it if someone could do something about gas prices and the exchange rate, pronto!

by tig2

We just couldn't take the Gaynor earwig anymore. Every time I opened the thread, that "witch" was back in my head!

AAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

:)

by j.lupo

with a 2/3 majority of course. So, there is still a chance, but I don't know how close the vote of Congress was to pass it in the first place. Also, not sure they will want to go that road with GWB.

by Member 25348569

Several months of heated - sometimes very heated - debate covering Astronomy to Zoology. There's a recipe for a modern love potion, an online romance and some really amazing posts from Australian Hebrew scholar and Astronomer, Gret, with original translations and explanations of the Bible.

It's worth a look but DON'T POST TO IT. Just open it up and hit the [print] icon to get the whole thing laid out. It's on page 1 at the moment because some dimwit answered a year-old post!

It spawned a couple of four-hundred post child threads along the way.

by faradhi

The President is not Defining Morality. He is acting on his beliefs. Just because he thinks it is a moral boundary does not make it so.

I do not think the Pres should have vetoed the bill. The reason is that this bill addresses very specific instances where it is acceptable to use stem cells from a fetus. In this case, when the fetus would be destroyed anyways.

The recurring argument is "if we allow it here, where does it stop." Which in my opinion is an unreasonable argument. The answer according to the legislation is right here. This legislation is not blurring a line. Rather, it is creating a bright line. Here and no further.

These fetus will be destroyed one way or another. So we are left with a choice, first let them die meaninglessly or let them live in the lives they may improve. The "Christian Right" apparently is willing to let the fetuses die a meaningless death.

Further, this is no more than organ donation. It is the family's decision. Don't forget, the fetus will be dying anyways. So if the family wants to have the fetuses used for research I do not see the issue.

Just my opinion.

by tonythetiger

I suppose it's only natural, given the past several decades of "saying", that someone who is more into "doing" would be met with a great deal of resistance. That's probably a good thing.

by mickster269

You are correct about the time line - but the termonology is a bit misleading.

There are 47 stem cell lines that were created and continued prior to 2001. Not embryos. Stem cells are harvested from embryos.

The restriction is that the Government will not fund the creation of any new stem cells, stem cell lines, or fund any research on any stem cell line outside of these 47.

I'm not trying to nit-pic. You've got the general idea correct.

But keeping 47 embryos alive... in an embryotic state... ::shudders::..That's a really creepy thought.

(Anyone, feel free to correct me- I did this post from current knowledge, not from recent research)

by Member 25348569

Not that they ever existed as anything other than a ball of cells. Stem cells are extracted from blastocysts, the embryo stage under ten cell divisions post fertilisation. Stem cells are cells with the ability - the requirement - to be able to turn into any other type of cell. The researches then keep the stem cells dividing without differentiating into any other type of cell.

Under these circumstances, the only belief that matters is whether you believe that human life begins at fusion of egg and sperm or you don't.

by x-marcap

I personally think embryonic research is ghoulish.

IMHO, Abortionists are 1st degree premeditated murderers. But if you state this opinion, and you become a pariah.

Why does abortion have to be such a sacrament to the feminists?

by mickster269

Because some people don't want the government to tell them what they can and cannot do with thier own bodies.

They want the Freedom of Choice about their own personal lives.

by tig2

As in, I should be able to choose to sleep around, not use/require appropriate protection, and dispose of unwanted pregnancy.

Speaking as a woman who CAN'T have children, I wonder where MY right to choose went.

by Member 25348569

Considering that, in your country, slavery was justified using the Bible as a source of the moral codes of the time, it's a very, very bad example to use.

"So if 'the group' agrees that slavery is ethical, it's ethical?" Yep. That's the way it works. Actually, slavery derived from ethics does tend to mean that the slaves are treated better (Romans, Greeks)than they were in a lot of cases in the US where Bible morality allowed blacks to be second class people.

So if a sixteen hundred year old book states that homosexuality is immoral, it's immoral. How convenient.

by onbliss

"The setting in which he announced the veto, surrounded by "snowflake babies", was quite sickeningly contrived."

Young Children in the background was the first thing I pointed out to my wife.

Somebody must have organized the entire thing, made research and the telephone calls (or emails), right? The right families would have to be contacted and brought in to attend the speech. The mobilization must have taken time and effort. I am amazed, Wow.

Its all about the art of swaying the public. No wonder Plato and Socrates did not think high of Democracy.

by Member 25348569

Sorry, Mambo, I need the Dollar at rock bottom until I've booked a few hotels and hired the car!

(Actually, it would be nice if it was way down until November)

:)

by dmambo

The current $857.891263954 to Pound rate (estimated) will break the bank for you!

I just want to go back to the 50% Cdn exchange rate we had a few years ago. It almost made up for the GST/PST that was imposed on everything except having a pee.

by onbliss

So you are not generalising, but if one were to generalize it means right and wrong are mutable?

by mickster269

"The founders believed and wrote that only a people of faith could be trusted to exercise the right to vote. They did stop short of requiring that step, but we may be the poorer for it."

I don't believe in your God. Does that mean I don't have the right to vote? If I don't get to vote, then I shouldn't be required to pay taxes. (One of the reasons the Colonies broke from England was that whole "taxation without representation"). I can't vote for someone to represent me in governement, so therefore I shouldn't abide by that non-representative governement's rules, right?

You are basically saying, that because I don't have faith in YOUR god, my opinion means nothing? I don't have the "faith' that founders of the USA had, so you don't trust me? Is this what you are implying?

Are you suggesting that the USA would be richer without my non-christian voice in it? I did serve in the US Army- maybe that was wrong too? Maybe we should keep heathens out of the military - you can't trust us to vote, how can you trust us to carry a gun?

==================================

Now, while this may NOT be what you were suggsting, this is how it sounded to me. And that is why us non-chritians get bent over Religion and Government.

I'm very glad you find your faith to be rewarding, and I truely do respect your beliefs. I wish you would respect mine, too.

by j.lupo

all the rest here at TR. Just for the record, I am very religous in my beliefs. I just don't believe in pushing that or anything else down someone's throat. I enjoy the discussions on religion, politics, and so on when they are debates of point.

Occasionally I let my emotions get the better of me and really do appreciate it when someone points it out so I can "self-correct" (??)

At any rate, I don't hold other people's beliefs against them. I just watch very carefully when they try to turn those beliefs into policies that affect my life and way of life. Then I try to stand up and take notice, try to understand. If possible, I try to take positive action to change the direction. I may or may not succeed, but I can sleep at night knowing I tried to make things just a little better.

Hope that made sense. Keep posting TJ and everyone.

by j.lupo

maybe because of some of our other conversations. I can see your point now that you said it too. I am very religous for my own beliefs. I don't think TJ said he was Catholic or Christian or whatever faith in his posting. So, I guess I just took it to mean ANY faith given I tend to write from a NON-Faith perspective, for my own reasons.

I like the way you ended your post because you did provide for the possibility that what TJ wrote came out differently than may have been intended. Thanks for another perspective.

As I think I may have mentioned, what everyone believes for themselves is fine. I have no problem with it. I just don't like it when they try to say or more percisely try to make it policy that it is the ONLY way to believe/act/be/etc.

by onbliss

Just to clarify, my focus is not on God, legal rights etc.. For the purpose of this discussion my scope is Past vs Present (or Future).

Are [b]ALL[/b] Rights/wrongs immutable across timespan? If I understand you correctly, you are saying they are immutable, but it is still not clear if you consider it for all aspects of life or just few of them.

For example, societies across the globe did not give the same rights to all people. It could have been because of so many reasons. But times are changing, can we say what was considered "right" earlier, now according to modern standards can be considered "wrong"?

edited: title

by jamesrl

Doesn't happen very often - it is very difficult to get 2/3, but not because they fear the president.

The nature of a veto is that you vote against something someone else proposed. What congresscritters fear is going against one of the President's pet projects.

It is in the best interests of the President not to use the veto too often, or he will find co-operation lacking. There is a two ways street involved in terms of ensuring support for each others' programs/agendas.

In that way there is more balance than in our Parliamentary system. In Canada, the leader of the governing party is the Prime Minister can discipline members who don't vote with the party (unless deemed a free vote). The Senate, an appointed not elected body, can block the bill, but the House of Commons can vote again to over turn. So we call the Senate the house of "sober second thought" but in the end they are a speed bump.

James

by Member 25348569

The [b]bill[/b] was nominally about funding but GWB's overly stage managed veto was [b]completely[/b] about his religion and the overtly public exercise of power based on his religious views.

Were a British politician to put on a display like that he would be rightly hounded by all shades of the media for patronising the electorate. Still, we are a different culture so maybe I'm just reading it wrong.

by tonythetiger

"Considering that, in your country, slavery was justified using the Bible as a source of the moral codes of the time, it's a very, very bad example to use."

No, it was because the [b]majority[/b] of the people were either actively participating in the practice, or were at least willing to accept it. It was wrong, and it took a minority of enlightened people to convince some to change, and to force the change on the ones convincing didn't work on.

Look for more of that in the future :)

by tonythetiger

A majority of five-year-olds would say it's perfectly acceptable to have icecream for lunch every day :)

by Member 25348569

The line lives on. The cells divide, live and die.

Do they have a soul? GWB's premise is, after all, that they are human life and therefore sacred.

by mickster269

"We don't care if you are pregnant because you were raped, your daddy slept with you, or your health is bad.

Tough luck, you gotta have that kid anyway."

by jdclyde

The president is well within his rights to veto any and every bill he does not agree with. He was put into office based on who he is and how he makes his decisions.

As for how the veto was handled, he publicly stated before the bill even came up for a vote that he would veto it. That the bill came up anyways while knowing they did not have the 2/3 vote to override the veto should have people questioning the house, not Bush.

And all politicians make up photo ops out of everything. Is it the fact that he didn't have a token representation from all races that bothers you?

And yes, this is entirely about the federal government not footing the bill for this. The politicians will pervert this to mean other things, but they suck.

by tonythetiger

it boils down to whose ox is being gored. Any decision is going to please some people and piss off others. It's the nature of the beast. Supreme Court decisions are the same way, every decision pisses off one side.

His job is not to simply be a "yes-man" to whatever congress decides. If it were, there would be little sense in the office even existing.....

Ewwwww, that would make us like most of Europe, wouldn't it.

by tig2

Unfortunately, as a woman, what I hear is about the level of disposability. I know and have known women that think that it is quite all right to use abortion as a form of birth control. I object to that. But it is not something that I ever had to deal with, either.

I don't object to saving the life of the mother, or the other examples that you make.

While I would like to see abstinence taught as wll as sex-ed, I know that my preferences won't get traction. I have counseled both young men and women from the standpoint that if the choice they are making is to be sexually active, they also need to choose a form of birth control.

The problem with knee-jerk laws and regulations is that they often backfire.

by Member 25348569

I'm not being at all judgemental, here, TT but having children is not a right. It maybe a deep felt need but it's definitely not a right for any man or woman.

Stem cell research is actually about researchers who either use "genetic material" from themselves or use the "extra" embryos created during the precursor stages of attempted in vitro fertilisation pregnancy. The additional embryos left over following the ending of treatment cannot be kept indefinitely and so are usually destroyed. Given suitable circumstances and permission, they can be "adopted" and implanted in a childless woman - snowflake babies - or, with permission, they can be used in research. The success rate is really rather low so it generally takes a number of such implanatation attempts.

It is [b]not[/b] anything to do with the abortion debate except in the tenuous link of being concerned with human reproduction. Stem cell research is about saving lives and improving the quality of poor sods like Michael J. Fox.

The morality of the whole range of human reproduction is generally pretty easy if you're deeply religious. It is much less so if one wishes to consider different aspects.

During ivf, it is standard practice to implant multiple embryos in order to anticipate the low implantation percentage. The "unsuccessful" embryos, of course, do not survive. Is this OK?

Sometimes the ivf is more successful than expected and a multiple birth is anticipated. It is sometimes necessary to deliberately kill one or more of the developing foetuses in order that one or two might survive to term. Is this OK?

My colleague's wife was expecting (normal) triplets. One of the babies died at about 18 weeks. The doctors were all pleased with this result and convinced mother and father that it was a good thing. I didn't know what to think. (She's due in 3 weeks and is the size of a small family car).

I could go on but I'll stop for now.

by mickster269

I personally wish there was never an abortion ever again.

But I can't make that call for another person- I don't feel I have that right.

by Member 25348569

Not sure what you mean. There are quite a few political systems, executive presidents, non-executive presidents, monarchies. Different flavours of left or right wing governments as well.

Seeing as GWB has used one - count it - one - I'll say it again - one veto in his two terms, I'd say he has pretty well followed the wishes of Congress. I guess that a friendly congress has helped.

My original post had a couple of issues: firstly "Why this one?" and secondly "why are you all not upset at being patronised by him?".

Nobody mentioned the French.

by Member 25348569

We haven't had a political/religious discussion for a while and this is both and I felt we were all in need or stir. I hoped to smoke Maxwell out.

I accept that GWB said he would veto it but I do believe that Congress should still have had a vote so that who voted for what should be there for the electorate to see if they choose to make this an issue.

I [b]am[/b] rather disgusted by the photo shoot as it was too tacky for words in the light of the fact that the veto was a done deal before the vote.

The race thing was just a big surprise and I've searched out a couple of different shots. Is ivf a white thing - cost, maybe? That's where the embryos come from.

Ah well. Nearly bedtime. It'll have to go on without me.