Discussion Locked

HATE the new download section at the bottom

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In the larger discussions, to have it end a page up from the bottom is rather annoying.

I HAVE clicked on downloads AND static ads, but I really really really don't like this new "feature".

Guess they can't all be gems.

Am I the only one who feels this way?

16 replies

by cactus pete

I'd rather get rid of the Barracuda ads that make my cursor go crazy.

Perhaps after they figure out the new format/layout/design, etc for discussions, it won't matter.

by jdclyde

it is a direct link to the downloads and webcasts.

I understand the ads are what keep me from having to pay for this site.

by smorty71

This is a short-term test to determine the best placement for these type of promotions. This element used to be in the right column of the page, so there was interest in testing placement in the left column.

Thanks for the feedback,
sm

by jdclyde

just with more and more posts going 100+ the first thing I do is hit the "end" key to get to where the new goodies are.

With this there, it gimps this out for me.

Question, with my screen resolution I get lots of grey along each side. If this was a relative page, then that extra space could be used to stretch the page some. Maybe even adding one more level in discussions? Another area along the side for STATIC ads?

by oz_media

While I don't agree with uprooting all the trees and paving over the lawn to build a bigger house, I do think there is a lot of wasted real estate on TR.

A hundred pixels or so on each side of the page is one hell of a lot of empty web space. 1024X768

by deepsand

Bear in mind that not all users have the resources required to handle large downloads. Many of them are accessing TR in their off hours, when they are away from the office & therefore not at a screamin' box.

This tiny thread weighs in at just under one-quarter Meg. For the really active ones, that size rapidly grows.

The really, really big ones, like EL, bring most boxes to their knees.

Discussion pages need to be kept as clean & small as possible if many are to not be discouraged from participating.

by oz_media

I hate it when someone posts to the EL thread. It shows up in My Discussions and I absently start drilling down th elist and before I know it, I've clicked the EL thread. It's not bad becasue my connection is a rocket but it's still a pain in teh ass.

We should be cancelling membershops for people who post to these threads, or else have them line up for a good stoning once a year from everyone who entered a couple of comments ong ao and get this thing turning up all the time. I'm NOT subscribed to it by the way, it's just that I posted a couple of comments over time.

Even if I DON't respond anymore, it still won't leave my damn My Discussions list.

We NEED a way to stop monitoring discussions like that, people find ANCIENT topics from search engine hits and post to them. 2 years after he issues was relevant, it turns up again in My Discussions.

okay, I'll be okay soon, just need a drink and some fresh air.

by anykey???

I only have dial-up at home, and jdclydes'thread about divorce is almost to much to handle,within a couple of weeks I won't be able to load it at all.

There has to be a better way to hadle the discussion pages that get pretty big.

by deepsand

You beat me to this one; I very nearly started a thread on this very subject, but caught sight of this one just in time.

The ad content has grown to the point that performance is taking a serious hit. Not everyone here has full-time access to a box with the resources needed to handle a googleplex sized download.

Give us a break & lighten the load.

by jdclyde

I don't mind ads. But I DO mind ads that triple the load time of a page.

With FF, how many times have you opened a discussion and the processing bar in the bottom right is still going two minutes later after the page is "done" loading?

The footprint of an ad on a page should NEVER hurt the page or that ad will end up costing more than it brings in with lost members.

by deepsand

I finally gave up trying to read it because it became too difficult to read.

The high density screens, the lack of contrast, the lack of stop white space & stop bars all failed to take into consideration the physiological factors involved in reading, leading to quick eye fatigue & loss of interest.

The key factor in [b]any[/b] publication is [i]readability[/i]. For web publications, one must add [i]useability & functionality[/i].

The latter two are here being increasingly diminished.

Lose the readers & lose the ad revenues.

by oz_media

I think it sucks Bobo too.

When I first saw that I figured TR was finally giving up and going the sponsorship before peers route. I figure it just a matter of time til I've seen enough of the downloads ads to give up. I have yet to see a SINGLE white paper or download in 5 years that I have been interested in. I've tried a few but they were so elementary it wasn't worth downloading. Not that I'm superior in IT or something, but the few that have interested me have been SO basic it's ridiculous. It's almost like ANYTHING that's somewhat relevant IT content is considered a handy download,

'Download these tips' when it's merely a few introductory pieces of information that most people would know already. Kinda like the tier one support guy.
1) Make sure it's plugged in
2) make sure the monitor is turned on
etc.

Other stuff seems to be proprietary advertising.

I know that's how tey make money, but there needs to be SOME balance before we end up reading a magazine full of subscription cards that need to be removed before you can turn pages.

I make money by working, but I don't work 24/7 so I can make even more money.

by jdclyde

from looking like a MSN splash page with so much crap everywhere that you don't even want to look for anything.

Got to be a better balance though.

Keep it simple, yet efficient.

AND get RID of the HIGE motion ads that move non-stop. I will NEVER click on one of those just out of principle.

And pop-ups are LOATHED, and rightly so.

by oz_media

Firefox. Pop-ups? Firefox.

I use FF and don't see ANY of that crap, but TR is still one big ad lately.

This discussion is closed to new replies.