Discussion Locked

Hear Ye, Hear Ye - NEIL WAS RIGHT. Maxwell was wrong

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=188273&messageID=1933292

I stand corrected. Neil was RIGHT, while I was WRONG.

It would take a minimum of TWO years to get to the moon, assuming ALL focus was dedicated in that one and only direction, and assuming absolutely everything went right, while absolutely nothing went wrong; and that is the best case possible, although still highly unlikely.

37 replies

by sleepin'dawg

linking from here is sometimes problematic.

A minimum of two years??? More likely in the time frame of five to eight years. A new lunar module would have to be designed, most likely in sections which would require assembly in space as well a new lunar rover much lighter than the previous ones would require design and manufacture. All this would require endless testing. Forget about the Mars rovers; they are much too small and slow to accomodate a human.

No problem is insoluble if there are sufficient funds to throw at it and there is a real desire to go but from my experience that is the way I see it and while not a propulsion specialist I do some of my work in the space program and know that is just the tip of the iceberg of the problems which would have to be overcome. Oh yes, one other matter, forget the current shuttles, they're too obslete now. Think more in terms of rockets which would have the necessary throw weight, like the ones used for the Appolo missions.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by gadgetgirl

I wonder how long it took for Neil to copy, print and frame the title of this discussion, before hanging it on his office wall!!!

Good on you Max.

You're a true gent.

GG

by Member 25348569

Space exploration is one of my interests and it would have been good to discover that the US had more to their space exploration plans than can be seen on the surface.

I think that we, for the benefit of the whole species, need to get into space. I don't, though, think we should go to the Moon or Mars - just get up there to stay. We can't really rely on Bruce Willis or Robert Duvall to save us in the event of a "dinosaur-killer" asteroid heading our way again. And one will.

Putting one over on Max by finding out I'm right about this is a bit of a hollow victory.

But very welcome!

Gloat!

Neil :^O :^O :^O

p.s. GG, I would have hounded him to the Ends of Miscellaneous for an answer but he was, as you say, a True Gent in posting it as a new thread without prompting.

by maxwell edison

.
TO THE MOON (In your dreams)

To Infinity and Beyond (but not to the moon)

When I'm wrong, I admit it (dag nab it!)

Well, at least I learned something today (like a little humility)

Would you like a little green cheese on that sandwich? Sorry, no can do

When dealt a lemon, make lemonade (but no Tang for me)

Crawling out of the crater I dug for myself

I'm only wrong, but Neil's a Lunartic

We may be swingin' on a star, but we ain't walkin' on the moon (Credit to the late great Bing Crosby)

I'm walkin', yes indeed .... but not on the moon (Credit to the late great Fats Domino)

I wasn't even crescent-right

Talk about shooting the moon!

I'm singin' my loony tune today

I guess I was just a little moonstruck

Sorry, Maxwell, the honeymoon's over

Maybe it's time for me to just shuttle outta' here, now.

The only rover in our immediate future barks and has four legs

The only moonraker around here is on a 007 video

Maybe I'll just become a Lunarian -- But there's no way home!

I see a bad moon rising ..... and rising ..... and rising ..... and out of reach (Credit to John Fogerty)

Neil to Maxwell: POW, To the Moon, Maxwell! (Credit to the late great Jackie Gleason)

Anyone care to join me for a little moon pie?

Okay, even I'm wrong -- once in a blue moon

I might be wrong, but I'm still always "right"

And Neil's favorite:

If we can send a man to the moon, why can't we send a friggin' man to the moon?

by rob mekel

should be.

taking a bow @ Max for his gentlehood. And no GG it is not that.

Rob

Life is to short to not enjoy it

by sleepin'dawg

I've got lots of respect for people who tell it like it is and are not afraid to admit when they've been in error. You showed a lot of class in the way you handled it.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by gadgetgirl

after all, he did stand me up in Brighton last year....

GG

(oh, I love it when I can haunt him with that one again!)

by jaqui

no, that would be unacceptable.

Maxwell was big enough to post it, We don't need to rub it in for days on end....

no matter that it would be so much fun to do so. ]:)

aww who am I fooling? go for it. ]:)

by rob mekel

If that is what makes you happy. :D

Personaly I would go for a new cow. :D

But then, won't be easy to get by. ]:)

And hats of to neilb. Good show it was :D

Rob

@life is too short to not enjoy it

by jdclyde

I repeatedly hear the "left" complain about how much is spent on the Space program AND the military, and both would be cut way back if someone like Sen. Kennedy had his way.

That has a lot to do with it being scaled back. Not seen as important to a lot of Americans anymore even though we would not be the same country we are now if wasn't for Velcro!

by Member 25348569

Squirm all you like but I have semantics on my side.

Can:

1. Used to indicate physical or mental ability
2. Used to indicate possession of a specified power, right, or privilege
3. Used to indicate possession of a specified capability or skill

[b]Present tense![/b]

You cannot send a man to the moon. No one person and no group can.

The fact that you might be able to in the future is not my problem. The fact that you could in the past is not my problem.

I gave Max more than a year of that future - generous chap that I am.

Gloat.

by maxwell edison

When I asked him the theoretical question, could we within a month, or could we within a year, his answer, without even batting an eye, was a definite NO. I then started to poke and prod, and I gave him all sorts of qualifiers, twisting his arm trying to get the right answer out of him.

What if money was no object, and all resources at the government's and private companies' disposal were made available? What if this was the ONLY national focus? Still a definite NO. But what if there was a 100 billion dollar bonus in it for you? NO. What if the mission failed, the Earth would be doomed? Well, he said, it's been nice knowing you.

Two years MINIMUM, and that's under the conditions described above.

Say it's only a paper moon sailing over a cardboard man,
And It'd only be make-believe if you believed we can.
Yes, it's only a canvas sky hanging over Tranquility Sea,
But we could not make it there, not you, not him, not me.
Without ten years, it's way beyond our reach.
Without more time, it's a memory played in our short history.
It's a Barnum & Bailey world, just as phony as email spam,
And It'd only be make-believe if you believed we can.

(Due credit given to Arlen, Harburg and Rose, and the late great Nat King Cole, of course, for his outstanding rendition.)

by jellimonsta

+++
++++
+++++
++++
+++
++
+++
++++
++++++
+++++++
++++++
++++
+++
+++
+++++
Sorry, couldn't resist! :p

by montgomery gator

Can you ask your rocket scientist friend:

How long would it take to build a Saturn 5 rocket, with command capsule and Lunar Module, like NASA used in the Apollo moon missions?

I would think that NASA still has the plans for a Saturn 5 rocket, command capsule, and lunar module. We could even save on payload, since computers of the power needed would be much lighter than the ones NASA used for the moon missions. We may even have some spare parts left over from the old missions that could be used, or even use museum pieces if the need was great enough. I would think that would be able to get us there in a 1 year period.

by bfilmfan

Part of the problem would be things, such as:

Most of the old road that linked the KSC Vehicle Assembly Building (VAB) to the launchpads doesn't even exist anymore:

http://www.space.com/news/spaceshuttles/shuttle_safehaven_000812.html

A Saturn 5 required 3 yeards of construction time:

http://www.spaceline.org/capehistory/3a.html

http://www.astronautix.com/lvs/saturnv.htm

Note that research on the 1 Million lbs of thrust engine started in 1953!

In December 1976, Two Saturn Vs, two Saturn IBs, three command and service modules, the backup Skylab cluster, and appropriate spares were handed over to museums.

We don't even have the manufacturing facilities for them anymore!

by maxwell edison

.....where I'm hanging myself out to dry, whipping myself with the wet noodles, taking my mea culpa's like a cyber-man, admitting a wrong, and so forth, it might be a good opportunity to apologize for those uncalled-for remarks I made to you in a previous discussion. (I think you know the one.) On second read, they certainly didn't come across very flattering. And since a good apology is always ruined by a bad excuse, I'll offer none of those.

by Member 25348569

Even given the political will to spend $50 billion on the project. The last Saturn V was used in 1973. It was built in a least two separate factories for the big bits and I doubt that the assembly facilities exist after thirty years!

You might have the plans but you'd need to completely retool and start the build from scratch, reinvent all of the transport procedures - barges if I remember correctly - and rebuild the huge crawler that's rusted up at Canaverel along with the rest of the Saturn infrastructure.

As you are building a 3,000 ton bomb you'd best get it right.

Computers was the least of it. They had enough computing power back then to do the job. Adding a 100 TFLOP supercomputer wouldn't get you there any faster.

Anyway. It's the last thing that I want anyone to do. The Moon is absolutely no use to us at all - never was. Let's get into space properly and mine Saturn's rings and the asteroids!

by maxwell edison

Replicating the Apollo moon missions. Let's throw the equivalent of a Volkswagen Beetle with a PC computer up there, and fling it at the moon. I'd bet Tom Hanks would command the silly thing; and let's give him a roll of duct tape in case anything goes wrong! (Disclaimer: last sentence = sarcasm. In fact, last paragraph = sarcasm.)

My guess is that even THAT equipment would take several years to repair, replace, replicate, etc. It did, after all, take 8 years (1961 to 1969) the first time around. Even if we could cut it by 75 percent, that's still two years. And it wouldn't serve any viable long-term purpose.

This discussion is closed to new replies.