Discussion Locked

Here's one for us Americans and loss of our freedom of choice

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Soon, the Washington, D.C., city council will likely tell business owners in Washington, D.C., that they can no longer allow their own customers to smoke. This is because the Washington, D.C., city council has determined that it, not business owners, knows best how to run a business in Washington, D.C.

The city council believes that forcing private businesses to go smoke-free will lure more families out to the city?s bars and restaurants. It also believes that a smoking ban protects the city?s bar and restaurant workers. By enacting a ?smoke-free workplaces? ordinance, the city council has determined that it, not individual employees, is better equipped to decide whether a given waiter or bartender would prefer to work in a restaurant that does or doesn?t allow smoking.

Similar policies have, of course, already been enacted in California and in New York City.

What is the rest of the world doing - or is the USA the only country doing this Wacko Stuff - to civil liberities... Do you you think this is a Good thing - bad thing - is it good for business - will it work - Hey Cal - NYC has it hurt your businesses?

13 replies

by oldefar

My dad used to say that his freedom to throw punches stopped at the end of the other person's nose.

Here in Texas, smoking has pretty much left the workplace as it has throughout much of the country. First tried was smoking provided a personal air filter was used, and then smoking in designated areas. Neither was effective in preventing non-smokers from having smoke thrust upon them. Finally, external areas were used, some covered, some not, and with a smoke free entrance area. This has allowed non-smokers an environment free from the smoke of others and has satisfied all but the vehement anti-smoking crusaders.

In Dallas, an ordinance was just passed that prohibits smoking anywhere in restraunts and bars. Some neighboring Chambers of Commerce welcome this as it will move some business to their communities.

The core issue is just how much control over an individual any government should have. The same mindset that attempts to make smoking illegal has attempted to make alcholol consumption, drug use, and a range of sexual activities illegal as well. I am opposed to such intrusion into private behavior, but I have no problem with an expectation to keep such behavior private.

"Clubs" that serve food and beverage to their smoking membership is one reasonable alternative. A workplace where all workers smoke or do not mind smoking and no external people need go seems to be reasonable situation. Requiring potential employees of such a club to first become club members, which includes acceptance of smoking, resolves the issue.

Now if there aren't sufficient smokers to justify a club, I have to say too bad. Have that smoke in the parking lot before entering, away from the door, and cut the non-smokers some slack.

by jimhm

I agree with your father - but where does the government stop - Smoking - next will be driving over the speed limit or SUV, because if you are driving a little car and get hit by an SUV you will die. Or Speed kills.

Where does it stop - Do they outlaw Fats in Foods - Salt intake - Caffine from Soda / Pop - Most city building ordances require low flow toilets (WC's to the Brits) to conserve water, the price of a used one now sells for more than a new one.

Are they going to require overweight people to go on a diet and walk 2 to 3 miles a day, have to eat selected foods only on the government diet?

So were do we stop our elected officals from thinking they know better than I do - on how I should live my life. And this Liberal BS - of they Know Best - even though they still drive the SUV's - eat fatting foods - drink to excess - cheat on their wifes and husbands - Smoke -

by hal 9000

Is the fact that the very same Governments who are desperately attempting to protect the inconent are only too willing to accept tax from the same tabaco products that they are complaining about now. Seems that they want as much money as possible in taxation but at the same time prevent anyperson from using these products.

Maybe it is just me but it all seems a bit self defeating to me as if they managed to prevent smoking they would have a massive hole in their budgets which they could not fill. But then again wasn't it the very same people who insisted that Lead be removed from automotive fuel? Well we might not have any lead exhausted into the athmosphere now but we do have H2SO2 which combines with 2 Oxygen atoms and comes back to earth as H2SO4 {Sulphuric Acid for those without the chemical knolledge} and the is something that Europe has been batteling for years now.

Maybe Soylent Green wasn't a fiction book/film but something that is going to come to pass with our governments being in the forefront of making the place safer for all and end up killing off everything.

by wordworker

Even in Kentucky where Tobacco is King, Lexington has passed such a law prohibiting smoking in public places. They're trying to pass a similar law in Louisville but it AIN'T HAPPENING! Business owners are beside themselves because they believe they ought to be able to allow smoking inside THEIR buildings if they want to.

The argument being raised? THEY WANT TO PROTECT THE EMPLOYEES OF THE BARS AND RESTAURANTS FROM PASSIVE SMOKE! I say, if you apply for a job in a bar or restaurant, you'd best be prepared to deal with smokers. If you can't handle the smoke, go get a freaking paper route.

I am a non-smoker and hate cigarette smoke, but as a part-time standup comic, guess what? I have to breathe in a lot of secondhand smoke when I perform. But I don't care, and if it bothered me enough, I'd stop doing that kind of work. To help placate nonsmokers, the local club offers two smoke-free shows, Thurs. night and first show on Saturday. http://www.comedycaravan.com

The fear, of course, is that they pass laws about smoking in restaurants and bars, what next? They'll want to regulate whether you can smoke in your own home? It's ridiculous.

by oz_media

You haven't been able to smoke in a BC based business for almost 15 years! I think it was the late 80's when that was banned and made a city bylaw.

Since then, they have banned smoking in Restaurants and get this YOU CAN'T SMOKE IN A BAR IN BC!!! Many people who don't smoke full time will only smoke when drinking, no more though.

I went to a local strip hoint a fre=iend was dancing in and they had a tiny little room with vaccuum like air conditioning and a few small windows so you can watch the dancers like a dirty old man at a peep show.

another has a smal glass room so you can see the dancers and other patrons easily but it is just a little glass cluod to sit in. People usually end up smoking outside instead.

this was all brought on by the city and a bunch of wankers who felt they wer jeopardizing thier health by working there, DON'T APPLY FOR THE JOB THEN YOU IDIOT!! It's a strip bar, what did you expect! But that would be unfair as it is not "an equal opportunity for employment." Of course it is, if I apply for a job as a policeman, can I then start complaining about arresting people becasue they may harm me and that they are an unequal oppotunity employer?? Of course not.

I just don't visit my firend while she's working anymore and we just meet up somewhere else instead.

But oh well, them's the rules, no one is getting hurt by them, just inconvenienced.

by djent

Smokers are the current target of the politicly correct nazis. How about our right to be free from MTB ground water pollution, mercury pollution from coal fired power plants, ad infinitum. Look at Bush's energy bill for protection from lawsuits of MTB MFG's. this bill is a turkey stuffed with pork. Energy is the favorite daughter and tobacco is the poor step child in current society. Our politicians are subserviant to the most monied lobbyists not the voters, one man one vote is a joke.

by jardinier

Only a complete fool would consider smoking (or chewing) tobacco non injurious to his health over a period of time. Continual heavy smoking over an extended period of time is no longer questioned as a major cause of heart disease and cancer.

So you should be free to kill yourself over a long period of time. [In Australia cigarettes have been described as "coffin nails" for as long as I can remember].

Incidentally the major portion of the price of a pack of cigarettes is tax, and of course tobacco companies represent a powerful lobby group as they sponsor sporting events. So that any government suffers a financial loss by banning smoking in any form.

The reason for Government interference is that it has been established that passive smoking is also injurious. Passive smokers (those obliged to share the same work or leisure area as actual smokers) have their rights too.

So no-one is telling you not to smoke, but to respect the rights of non smokers who may be adversely affected by your preference for smoking.

So the situation is that there are two groups of people whose civil liberties are involved. And why should the rights of one group be given preference over the rights of another?

by road-dog

When the government makes laws that restrict how one can best make use of private property, they are in effect taking away ownership of it.

Nobody disputes the adverse health effects of smoking, although second hand smoke studies have been found to be bogus and based on flawed scientific methods. I believe that the WHO's second hand smoke study was found to have had the conclusion drawn and then the facts beaten to fit them.

However, does one's "right" to a smoke free environment supercede the property rights of the restaurant owner? If so, then where does it end?

If the market demands smoke free environments, I'm sure that they will be popping up everywhere. If most of the market refuses to eat around smokers, then restaurants will be forced to change or die. Free enterprise is the purest form of democracy, because you vote with every cent of your income.

This erosion of property rights have even extended into the private residence, where homebuilders now have to make at least one bathroom in every home handicap accessible, to the tune of an additional thousand dollars per home in some states. This is certainly a boon to the small segment of the population that is wheelchair bound, but don't I have a right to choose a home without spending extra money to have a bug ugly aluminum bar down one wall of the bathroom?

Great intentions can be taken too far. If we err, better it be on the side of freedom. The greatest evils in mankind's history came cloaked in "the best interests of the many".

by john_wills

The problem is that if you allow smoking in some place some smokers will insist on overstepping the boundaries. The Berlin buses used to allow smoking upstairs, but you had to pass through the downstairs cab on the way between upstairs and the outside world, and people kept on smoking during that passage. So eventually the bus company forbade smoking in any part of the bus; for a while a few people continued to smoke upstairs, but pretty quickly even that stopped. My point here is that it was abuse of the privilege of smoking in part of the bus that led to the retraction of that privilege. If smokers had all thought twice - or even once - before lighting up there would not have been so much resentment against them.

by seabee69m

We have here in The commonwealth bodies known as
health dept. They have been given the right to enact
laws. I always thought we had elected politicians,to
enact legally binding laws. Well some time some place,we have twisted things around? The rights of the individual no longer matters. Special interests,
are now in control. And are political officials are
erecting another smoke screen to remove our rights.

by dc_guy

...I am gladdened by the nearly unanimous defense of individual liberty and disgust with Big Nanny. I grant that passive smoke is a health issue (although the state of science in the US does not make me entirely confident that we're being told the truth about this) but separate establishments for smokers should accommodate this issue. As for the boors on the buses, sometimes being tossed off the bus by an angry crowd is more effective than a regulation, and our snobbish disdain for even the mildest and most provoked vigilantism should be slightly relaxed. As for SUVs, it's a problem precisely because the huge, stupid, inefficient government has a near-monopoly on the transportation business. I wouldn't allow SUVs on my toll road because I wouldn't want them careening into and falling onto my brighter and less selfish customers. Or if there were enough demand perhaps I would limit them to a sedate speed and the one lane for all other vehicles designed for OFF-ROAD use! ^_^ You folks are all libertarians. I hope you will consider joining the movement.

This discussion is closed to new replies.