Discussion Locked

How do I turn a server and disks into a NAS capable of clustering?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have two Dell 2650s and a 220S storage array, that is clusterable. The write performance has been so poor that Dell says many have turned to taking a server and the 220s into a NAS and clustering that way. Can it be done and how do you do this? Can Linux or Windows do this? Any direction here greatly appreciated. Most of the NAS/SAN stuff I worked with has been appliance-based.

6 replies

by apotheon

Linux is absolutely capable of this, and probably quite easily. I'm afraid I haven't done any work with system clustering (yet: I have a clustering project looming ahead, I think, but haven't done any research into it yet). You'll have to find specifics yourself. Remember, LUGs (go to http://www.linux.org/groups for a listing of LUGs by region) and Google (including the Linux-specific http://www.google.com/linux search functionality) are your friends.

Windows is not yet capable of clustering (to my knowledge, and if it is I'd like to meet the genius that pulled it off), though Microsoft is supposedly going to offer a clustering-specialized version of its operating system late this year. I'm extremely wary of any Microsoft attempt to produce a clustering OS, however, to say nothing of the fact that the need to produce an entirely separate clustering version of the OS raises a whole new set of problems and issues in my mind.

by drummerb0y

Your quick blurb about write performance leads me to believe you want to improve access/write times to the SCSI array. I'm by no means a wizard here, but I do believe clustering only provides better availability and load balancing. If one server in the cluster breaks, the other server can still host the array. When both servers are clustering, they can balance the load of network requests for access to the array. But network load balancing two servers to one SCSI array will produce negligible read/write speed results at best, as opposed to using just one server to host the array.

Your bottleneck here is the SCSI (and subsequently PCI) interface, and whatever network cards you have. The 2650s come with dual GBICs, so you should be in decent shape there. But the 220S, if you have Ultra320, can only give "SCSI performance for up to 320 MB/s throughput" (Dell's page on the 220S). That's great in theory. But actual speeds are going to be slower, depending on other limiting factors such as the SCSI controller's PCI bus speed, the SCSI controller's ability to handle an array full of drives, etc. Check out this link for some good info on SCSI speeds: http://www.storagereview.com/guide2000/ref/hdd/if/scsi/protSpeed.html

As for clustering, Windows 2000 and Windows 2003 can do it. Win2k3 Enterprise and Datacenter Edition now support up to 8 nodes. I've never SEEN it done, like someone else here posted, but I think it can be done. *nix however has been clustering longer than Windows, so I'm sure you could find some good clustering documentation out there if you decide to go with a *nix flavor.

Cheers!

by jclutter

A true NAS can be any server that is connected to a Network. Network Attached Storage is just that, a bunch of drives connected to a network via a NIC. You can use Windows Server 2003 Enterprise Edition to setup the storage array write a batch file to make the Servers see the cluster as local disks and you are off and going.

by jtowner

So here's the basics, setup a server with the disk array, and install Windows + iSCSI target software (http://www.stringbeansoftware.com/products.asp). Next, take the two servers you want to cluster running Win2k3 Adv Server, install the iSCSI Initiator (microsoft.com search for "iSCSI Initiator") Ver 1.06 on both. Use the software to setup the shared disk.

Depending on perf, you may want to look into an AX100 from EMC for a low cost boxed solution.

This discussion is closed to new replies.