Discussion Locked

How do you rate the performance of Governor Schwarzenegger?

0 helpful
29 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I will not make any comments as I am not an American, let alone a Californian.

However I would be interested to hear the views of any Americans and especially Californians.

Additionally, does anyone know what progress the "Ammend the Constitution for Schwarzenegger" lobby is making, and is it attracting a strong following?

29 replies

by stress junkie

I don't live in California but I am troubled by a controversy that arose this year with the Schwarzenagger administration. A problem came to light where Gov. S. was being paid a lot of money to do ads in a muscle building magazine while he was in office. At the same time a bill came before him that directly affected the interests of the vendors serving the muscle building community. So it gives the appearance that his vote on this bill was paid for by the people that were affected by the bill.

As far as changing the Federal Constitution to allow foreign born citizens to become president I haven't heard anything in months. I take that to mean that if the movement has any momentum it is limited to California. I support keeping the restriction that the president must have been born in the US.

by jdclyde

fitness and muscle building, and is how he got his start in the first place.

He donated a lot of his time to promoting health and fitness among kids.

And now you are bothered because of the "appearacne that his vote on this bill was paid for"? Tell us if it was a bad bill, not that someone benifits from it if you want this to be a credible issue. Just because SOMEONE benifits, does NOT make it a bad bill, and this is not a new part of his life.

As for the amendment, I would NEVER support changing this, and we should NEVER have someone for president that was not born and raised here.

If the keeps Granhold (Dem from Michigan) shutdown, all the better. (was a cunnuck and is now just a nut)

by maxwell edison

.
I, too, would be vehemently opposed to changing the constitution to allow a foreign born citizen to become president. It's just fine the way it is.

And will you point me to a link (or links) to news stories that discuss that body building magazine flap you mentioned. I didn't hear about that, and would be interested in reading about it.

by charliespencer

I can't speak for the state of California, but in South Carolina no one gives a rat's fanny, including most rank-and-file Republicans. It is an attempt to skew the our governing document for one man's benefit. Henry Kissenger was a better politician with more influence in both the party and the federal government. If he couldn't pull it off, there's no way Arnold will.

The constitutional amendment process is a slow one. Assuming it cleared Congress, by the time it passed ratification by three-fourths of the states (38), Arnold would be eating the "early bird" special at Denny's before his bingo game at the senior center.

by montgomery gator

His performance in "Hercules in New York" was wooden, and his dialogue was so bad, it had to be dubbed.

He got a lot better as he went on, good performance in "Conan the Barbarian".

His performances in the "Terminator" movies were also good. Also enjoyed his performances in "The 6th Day" and "Predator" and "The Running Man".

Schwarzenneger showed he also could perform in comedies such as "Kindergarden Cop" and "Twins", although I think "Jingle All The Way" was a disappointment.

I have not seen him in the movies recently, although I heard he became the ruler of a state on the west coast of North America. Now that he has assumed the throne of that state, I assume he is trying to carry out his principle "To crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentation of the women!" that he advocated in "Conan the Barbarian" and making remarks about "girlie men".

by montgomery gator

The Governator is taking on a lot of the special interests, such as the teacher's unions and the state employee unions. He has suggested some reforms to streamline government. He has ruffled a lot of feathers of the "girly men", but from what I heard, he is doing a pretty good job.

However, I do not want to see the Constitution amended just so he could run for President (unless we could get Rupert Murdoch to run, that is. Now, he would make a good president.)

by jck

I think he had not the skill, communication or brains to be governor out there.

But hell, it seems the biggest con job with the most money wins nowadays.

oh well...

by jdclyde

Don't let bad dialog from past movies, or all the muscles fool you. If you followed his history at all, you would know that he got where he is now from hard work and brains.

Just because a man has an accent or doesn't pronounce everything perfectly, does not reflect anything on their intellegance.

If your going to make the slam from the other end of the country, at least back it up with ANY example of his lack of skill, his lack of communication (with who?) and his lack of brains.

Also, how about showing how he bought his way into the governers seat, as you are implying.

Without looking things up, I can't give specific examples of good or bad but I HAVE heard of things he was trying to do.

I think he is a damm good man who took a huge pay cut to do something he felt was important. After all, which position REALLY gives him more clout, the movie star or the governor? Which gives him more money? He didn't take that job for the money or the fame or the power, so what is left?

Note: I don't see that dimwit Barbra Streisand running for office, nor the very rich Soros who has done EVERYTHING he can to buy influince.

by maxwell edison

.
....when some blow-hard flunky calls someone dumb, or stupid, or whatever, after he reached such a high office. Agree with the politics or not, to be that successful takes some brains, not to mention perseverance and the ability to influence people. All preceded, of course, by the proverbial rags-to-riches story that epitomizes the American dream. Arnold "ain't no dummy".

by jck

I never mentioned his nationality or his accent or anything else about his ethnicity.

You're assuming...you have a negative pre-disposition of me and I don't appreciate it.

I was going on his past experience in politics, law, economics, and government, nor the capacity to deal with those critical issues in CA. Otherwise, he'd have been able to turn around California's economy. As it still is, the State of California can not even now afford to properly maintain all the highway infrastructure that it has built.

What I said was:
"I think he had not the skill, communication or brains to be governor out there."

And, I'm dead on.

He had no skills or experience to be governor other than being related to a Kennedy clan member. He stammers when talking about issues he knows little about (like someone else who's in the White House), and he hasn't had the brains to figure out how to handle critical economic and social issues in CA such as budgetary, illegal immigrant fraud on their social services, etc.

Programs Davis and Wilson let run rampant as well.

So, it wasn't implied or direct racism. Deal with it.

by charliespencer

We're not quoting Arnold. The lines are from a series of old Saturday Night Live skit. Hans and Frans (remind me, who were the cast members?) were indeed modeled on pre-acting Arnold, but we weren't quoting him.

by maxwell edison

.
From the CATO Institute (Fiscal Policy Report Card):

Arnold Schwarzenegger (R) California 84% - A (This is the top of the list for first-term governors.)

http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa537/governorsreportcardtable.html

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3691

From the Lambda Letters Project (To promote the social, economic, and human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex individuals, couples, and families; people affected by HIV/AIDS; people of color; and women. We do this by urging elected officials to enact and support legislation that accomplishes this goal.)

Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Intersex Issues: 83%

HIV/AIDS Score: 33%

"People of Color" Score: 17%

Women's Score: 70%

OVERALL SCORE: 51%

http://www.lambdaletters.org/gov_scorecard.html

One more:

http://www.hrc.org/Template.cfm?Section=Press_Room&CONTENTID=23005&TEMPLATE=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm

So I suppose to answer your question, you'd have to run the answer through the filter of the respondent's bias and/or agenda.

by montgomery gator

Rupert Murdoch has shown he is a successful businessman. He has built News Corp into a mult-billion dollar multinational media giant. I find that Fox News is one of the few news services that I can trust, "We report, you decide" is Murdoch's Fox News' motto.

Although he is from Australia, he is very pro-American, pro-business, pro-capitalism. He has also become an American citizen. Since Al Franken, George Soros, Moveon.org, and others of their ilk have taken a strong dislike (even radical paranoid hatred in some cases) to Rupert Murdoch, I figure he must be doing something right. One way to know someone is by those who oppose him.

(Also, admit it, Julian, you would like to see an Australian as the leader of one of the most powerful nations on Earth :-) )

by jardinier

He paid my wages for four years on a (now defunct) Sydney newspaper "The Daily Mirror."

I admire his entrepeneurial skills.

He created the first Australian national newspaper, "The Australian" and ran it at a loss for 10 years, subsiding it probably from the profits from The Daily Mirror and other Murdoch publications.

But he hung in there and the "Australian" has for many years had a reputation as a reliable and responsible news source.

While his methods were not popular (laying off staff and changing format and content) he saved certain British newspapers from going to the wall.

by montgomery gator

Just curious, from your days with "The Daily Mirror", did you ever meet Rupert Murdoch? If so, I was wondering what he was like in person. I do find it amazing how he built a media empire that spans the English-speaking world starting with newspapers in Australia. Your story about how he built up "The Australian" shows he has persistence and a long-term view to build up a business.

I also heard a story about an episode of "The Simpsons" (in which Rupert Murdoch contributed his voice as himself) that lampooned Fox News, and Fox News then sued the Fox Network. However, Fox News called off the suit when they realized that both organizations were owned by Rupert Murdoch. :-) I remember seeing the episode, and it was hilarious. I like Fox News, but I guess that was one time where the Fox News executives were not on the ball.

by jck

coming from a moneyhungry egotist.

He got famous because he did a lot of body building and had a talent management team working for him...and that takes a lot of physical effort...and not a whole lot of brains.

You go right ahead and praise him. You should praise him while you're at it for being a womanizer too. Rich and womanizing...takes a lot of brains to do all that.

My first assessment was dead on. He hasn't had the brains to lead California into prosperity, didn't not have the skills or experience of the usual governor, and was totally elected on "image".

At least I got the sensible, reasonable Bush kid running my state...

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "Otherwise, he'd have been able to turn around California's economy. As it still is, the State of California can not even now afford to properly maintain all the highway infrastructure that it has built."

Why is that, and where did you get your information? What are the biggest contributing factors? And what power does the governor have, regardless of who it is, to take whatever steps are necessary, and what power does he not have? And I'm speaking of California's governor, specifically, by the way. Why is California's economy in bad shape, what started it, how long has it been going on, and what would it take to turn it around? And be very specific, please. Don't litter your reply with the same tired old platitudes that are so often thrown around as facts.

Also, why does the CATO Institute give Governor Schwarzenegger high marks for his fiscal policies (an A), but you give him low marks. What makes the CATO Institute wrong, and you right? (And what letter grade would you give him, and why?)

And before you dismiss the CATO Institute as being biased, discuss the basis of the report, and perhaps even offer one of your own. Moreover, the CATO Institute also gave New Mexico's Democrat governor, Bill Richardson, fairly high marks as well, while they gave Bob Riley, the Republican governor from Alabama, a very low D rating; and they gave Ohio's Republican governor, Bob Taft, a dismal F, the lowest of all 50 governors. So no, CATO is not a partisan organization pandering to Republicans. As a disclaimer, however, I will point out that CATO was founded on libertarian principles, and builds its opinions on those principles.

http://www.cato.org/about/about.html

But my point being, don't play the "biased source" game. It gets really old, and people simply use it to dismiss a valid argument for which they may have no answer. So tell us, jck, and enlighten us with your economic prowess, what is your answer to these questions? And what should Governor Schwarzenegger have done that he has not done?

If I could ask everyone else to refrain from answering until jck has had a chance to reply, I would appreciate it. (But once he does -- IF he does -- it's open-season.)

by montgomery gator

Arnold Schwarzenegger has quoted Hans and Franz a few times himself, using the "girly men" and "pump you up" lines. Shows the man has a sense of humor.

The SNL cast members were Kevin Nealon and Dana Carvey, if I am not mistaken.

by jck

Q) Where'd I get my information about California being unable to pay to maintain their highways properly?

A) It's been in the news since Gray Davis was in office. He announced there would be no more new highway construction in California because the state could no longer afford to maintain what it already had, let alone new highways. Stories continue to be in the news concerning them.

Q) What are the details? Why did things happen? When did they happen?

A) I invite you to go to a library and read a book or a newspaper, or watch CNN or read their archives. I will not be your history, economics or social sciences teacher.

Have a nice weekend, bupo bupo.

by jdclyde

Do you think that a governor can do as they please?

It is just like the feds, where the president leads, but it is CONGRESS that is in control of the country. The most the pres can do is advise and veto.

In this heavily democratic state, do you really think he is getting co-operation to fix anything? It is in the best interests of the DEMS for things to STAY bad because if they get better than that would look good for the Republican "in charge".
[b]
I didn't say anything about race or ethinc background either, now did I? The ONLY thing I said was don't let the way someone talks be the standard you base their intellegence on. Looks like you just read way too much into that simple statement or feel guilty about something. Don't accuse me of accusing you of racism until I do.[/b]

You have done nothing to show his lack of "brains". If nothing else, he had the brains to hire good people to handle his career and isn't that what a good leader does? Surround themselves with good people?

Show ANYTHING that has indicated he is not intellegent.

As for womanizing in your post to MAX, I don't see him in jail for sexual assault, do you? Funny how it only "came out" as he was running for Gov of CA and then didn't go any further than that. But you see that someone accused him of this as guilty. Good thing we never had a predident accused of sexual harrassment.... (different story for a different day).

Did he act inaproapreately with some women? I don't know as I wasn't there. If he doesn't get charged AND convicted, it is impossible for me to put any weight on this.

What "beef" did you have with him before he was ACCUSED of this?

And you also know that problems as MAJOR as the wacko dems have CREATED in CA, are not going to just go away overnight. You create a welfare state with no regulation, and a state legislatior that will appose him at every turn and change will be slow and hard fought.

Your Dem in Rep clothing act is getting old. You are marching right along with every propaganda piece and supported every socialist idea that has come up on this board AND opposed any "Republican" people and ideas. If you want to believe all that crap, fine. It is your life. Just the dishonesty about admitting where you stand makes me wonder. I can understand you being too embarrassed to admit that you think that way, but if your embarrassed by that belief then that is something inside you that knows better.

Time to re-evaluate yourself. Look at what you have supported and what you have opposed. Look at the ideas you put forth and see which political party you are aligned with 90% of the time. Start by being honest with yourself.

by jck

It is an organization that calls itself "Libertarian" in ideals, but then backed Bush and his agenda to expand the rights of the FBI to infringe on civil liberties as a part of the war on terrorism.

"In 2002, a Cato news release endorsed new Justice Department guidelines giving greater latitude to FBI agents to monitor Internet sites, libraries and religious institutions. "As reported in the press, the new FBI surveillance guidelines present no serious problems," declared Cato legal affairs analyst Roger Pilon, a former Reagan administration official who writes frequent Cato commentaries defending property rights and opposing affirmative action that have appeared in publications such as the New York Times, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, and the Los Angeles Times. Pilon added that "law enforcement monitoring of public places is simply good, pro-active police work that violates the rights of no one."

http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Cato_Institute

so much for your non-partisan, non-conservative think tank.

by jck

or implied he bought his way in.

I implied he had the most money...i.e.-campaign funds.

As for the thing, you're right...I misread what you said...thought said "from the other country".

I misread. My mistake. I apologize...

(although you did stick accent in there...which, is implicative of being a foreigner.)

by jck

I'll reply to the rest of your thesis...

I'm...outta h'yah

"Screw you guys...I'm going home." - Cartman

by maxwell edison

.
.....I'll answer them for you, the way you would answer them if you were totally honest.

Maxwell: Why is that, and where did you get your information?

jck: I don't know why that is. And I got my information from the headlines in the Florida newspapers that I might glance at once in a while, and from the news stories I see on the Florida evening news, right before Jay Leno comes on TV. And speaking of Jay Leno, his jokes help me decide what's really going on in California. He does live there, you know.

Maxwell: What are the biggest contributing factors?

jck: How in the heck should I know? I live in Florida, not California.

Maxwell: And what power does the governor have, regardless of who it is, to take whatever steps are necessary, and what power does he not have?

jck: I don't know. I have a hard time understanding Florida government, much less California. But one thing I do know is this. I did hear some Republican make a stupid excuse about how all those California citizens have those initiatives and propositions out there in California, so the voters can literally tie the hands of the governor. By the way, what are initiatives and propositions?

Maxwell: Why is California's economy in bad shape, what started it, how long has it been going on, and what would it take to turn it around?

jck: They need to raise taxes. Raising taxes will solve everything. It will even solve global warming.

Maxwell: Why does the CATO Institute give Governor Schwarzenegger high marks for his fiscal policies (an A), but you give him low marks.

jck: Because CATO has a bunch of idiots over there. I'm smarter than them because ..... well, I just am.

----------

jck is a coward for failing to answer these simple questions, so I had to answer for him.

You're welcome, jck.

by jck

yes...tart...I know what I'm saying.

You can't even get my answers right, let alone your own.

Figures you'd talk to me even inside your head. Guess the conversations with yourself aren't that good.

BTW...I think Leno sucks...just so you can have a little more realistic theatre of the mind for yourself.

Enjoy Looloo land there, weh-ma

This discussion is closed to new replies.