Discussion Locked

I did not know this about out sourcing

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.infoworld.com/article/06/03/21/76507_13OPreality_1.html
http://www.infoworld.com/article/06/03/30/76980_HNh1blimitcall_1.html

There are a lot of things wrong with this. But what bugs me the most are the statements made by our leading high-tech CEOs about the poor quality of American education and the fact that there aren?t enough U.S. workers to fill the jobs. All the while, these same CEOs bring in outside workers -- not because the education is so much better abroad, but because doing so benefits their own bottom lines.

It is not because we do not educate and bring our young into the IT market. It is because the CIO, CEO etc can bring home a bigger paycheck!
The out sourced person gets about a 1/4 of what we do for pay and it sounds like what we do for the Mexicans that we use for illegal picking.
We use cheap labor and the only people who profit from this are the company CIO's.

We never hear about the data loss or the worker going home to use what they have learned here, even though they signed an agreement not to disclose.

Don?t get me wrong I have worked with several L-1 and H visa people and they were great people who loved to learn. But all of them did not want to leave and were trying to get extended visas.
Read these blogs to see what you think, I found things that I did not know and now question the reason why our government allows this.

Congress is looking into the visa program and will vote on it.
I am still wondering why we can not fill all of any IT jobs here in the US?
Because most post say that we need to out source to fill them, are our kids too dumb to learn what we know? I don?t think so; it is the fat guys in the driver?s seat.
We need to stop the take over and let the young of our county get into the driver?s seat. We can still train others in the field and help them to learn the way we do things.
But we started the IT, and we need to stay on top not let another country support us!
Here are a few lines from the article.
"First, some background on what the L-1 visa program is. The program allows a foreign worker employed by a company overseas for at least one year to enter the United States temporarily, ?in order to continue to render his services to the same employer or a subsidiary or affiliate ? in a capacity that is managerial, executive, or involves specialized knowledge.?
Here is what gets me mad.
"According to Frank Robinson, CFO at Darwin Partners, insurance companies are bringing in foreign workers under L-1, providing food and lodging, but are paying the guest workers at the salary they were getting back home. If a typical programmer in the United States makes $60,000 to $80,000 per year, these workers are being paid as little as one-quarter of that. And they can stay as long as five to seven years. "
And this is not right!
"These workers may be employees of the insurance company; or worse, they could be employees of IT services companies, known as ?body shops,? who hire them out for a fee.
Using foreign workers and paying them below American scale is only one abuse. A second is bringing in workers for training. In this case, there is no way to pretend that these workers have skills that the company needs. I am told that many high-tech companies do this and that I should ask Intel (Profile, Products, Articles) about it, especially at Intel?s Folsom, Calif., location. I called three or four Intel public relations people I know but got no response.

The irony here is that when workers are brought in like this for training, the American workers are in essence training their own replacements, according to Kim Berry, president of the Programmers Guild.

Finally, that DHS report I mentioned calls L-1 ?The Computer visa,? saying nine out of 10 companies that use the L-1 are ?computer- and IT-related.? The report says that it is ?difficult to be confident that a firm truly intends using an imported worker? as a manager or executive. It suggests that the term ?specialized knowledge? is so broad that ?adjudicators believe they have little choice but to approve almost all petitions.? And while L-1 workers must be employed by the importing company abroad for at least a year, the report finds that the United States has ?little ability to evaluate the substantiality of the foreign operation? and even allows ?petitioners to transfer themselves into the United States.?

I have been with a company that had hired three people this way and they were willing to learn but had no training in what they were hired for! But the contract was for one year so they had to give them jobs in house keeping for a year.

Is this why we need to have unemployment for IT workers and to import workers? How about the people we use to pick and pull from Mexico? We have technology that will let machines do all the picking and processing of products that a person can do.
Why do we still use a slave process like a low paid immigrant to do this?
Well this is going to be a rant! And I need to vent now; this is how business work or this is how to stay competitive? We need to bring in people from other countries because they have more know how then our young? We need to out source because it will make use more competitive? We need out sourching to let other countries use three workers here in the USA?
It is how business is done now? Say what?

We sell out our knowledge, our lively hood, our footholds in technology with other countries that put people in sweatshops, or you learn this or you go into the mines?
Or we import people to do the things that a machine can do faster, like with the Mexicans or the Canadians?

Sorry but we need to train and keep the IT stuff here. I bet there are a lot of republicans here!

53 replies

by maxwell edison

You and I have certainly had our share of, shall I say, heated disagreements. But this is, in no way, intended to ignite another one. It's simply sharing a simple lesson I've learned over the years.

Any employee-employer relationship MUST be a win-win relationship. All to many employees feel that they are entitled to a job, and nothing could be further from the truth. If an employee approached a job with the mindset of seeking ways for the company to profit (their reason for existence) and excel (necessary for growth), a job will ALWAYS be available. It's not enough anymore to just bide your time and do a good job.

If menial jobs or repetitious jobs are streamlined by whatever means, then the person who might be squeezed out of that position must find a way to do more. And there is absolutely no way a person who can be instrumental in helping a company improve its product, its process, and its profit, will be out of a job -- never.

It may not be the easiest thing to do in all circumstances, and a person might even have to change circumstances, but with that kind of mind-set, instead of a complaining and defeatist one, it will ALWAYS result in positive things happening, and that person will always be better off as a result.

by amcol

I'll go you one better. Every employee, from top to bottom, in any organization should be zealously working to find so many ways to streamline their own jobs that they end up putting themselves out of a job.

Fear of change, indeed fear of anything, should not be a reason to keep doing things the same old way. Those who are lucky enough to run their own businesses, in their own way, in industries which never change can do as they will. But the 99.9999% of the rest of us have no choice...improve, evolve, or die.

Corporate evolution is just as inexorable as biological (no debates about intelligent design, please). Things change, whether we like it or not. And whether we realize it or not, we all make the CONSCIOUS choice to participate...or not. Passively watching the train pass on by is, in fact, a conscious choice.

While I do buy the argument that there's more of an economic component to job outsourcing than the quoted CEO's would like to acknowledge, the notion that our colleges and universities are not turning out technical talent capable of becoming fully productive professionals is absolutely true as well.

by maxwell edison

You're right, I did omit that. And it's a great thing for you to point out.

If a person trains those under him to do his job, and/or streamlines himself out of a job, there's ONLY one way to go; and it's not out, it's up.

Even if it is out, can you imagine this on a resume: [i]I was directly responsible for streamlining the organization and implementing training methods that resulted in the consolidation of X positions, which saved the company $XXXXXX dollars annually.[/i]

Regardless, it would NEVER result in being out, unless it was a self-imposed exodus, of course, because that person wanted to test the waters with such an outstanding qualification.

Edited Addition Below:

What's a BETTER qualification for a resume?

1. [i]I was directly responsible for streamlining the organization and implementing training methods that resulted in the consolidation of X positions, which saved the company $XXXXXX dollars annually.[/i]

OR

2. [i]I studied very hard and earned my certifications for MCSE, MCP, MCSA, CCDP, CCNP, A+, A++, D-, ABC, ADD, and ADHD in only 5 years.[/i]

by jdmercha

I agree with most of this but...

Universities in the US are producing very capable technical talent. Again this is a failure of managers to understand what a fresh US college grad brings to the table. College degrees from major US universities are very braod in scope. They prepare their students to be able to handle many aspects of the job.

Companies today are reluctant to provide any training to new recruits. They wnat someone who has experience with a specific technology. So they look to tech school grads, certifications or outside the US. These students may have a better handle your specific technology but they do not come wiht the knowledge of how those technologies interact and benifit the company.

If you want an employee who will configure your Cisco switches for the rest of his life, then please hire someone with a Cisco cert. But if you want to hire someone who can learn to mange these switches and grow with the company to make greater contributions to the bottom line, then you need a college graduate.

by cloyd42

I am one of several who make hiring decisions for IT people at my company (we don't outsource by the way) and have seen this combination from US grads way too many times:

1) Requests for additional pay for core job skills (I'm glad you're certified but isn't that why I'm hiring you?)
2) Ridiculous pay requests (why is an IT degree worth more than a Master's in Engineering?)
3) Lack of math/reasoning skills
4) A long list of negative demands (all starting "I won't")
5) An inability to explain how they can help my company do better.

There are certainly smart talented IT grads from US universities but they're hard to find in an ocean of unrealistic expectations. They would help themselves tremendously by understanding what the market wants and needs.

by jdmercha

I swear I live in a differnt world than the rest of you.

"If an employee approached a job with the mindset of seeking ways for the company to profit (their reason for existence) and excel (necessary for growth), a job will ALWAYS be available."

I have never known this to be true. I've seen many productive workers loose their jobs, while less productive workers keep theirs because they live next door to the boss or go golfing with him.

"a person who can be instrumental in helping a company improve its product, its process, and its profit, will be out of a job -- never."

Again I've seen many mangagers fail to see how there subordinates contribute to the bottom line. Mostly because they do not understand what these people actually do. I've found this to be espeially true in the IT industry where many managers do not understand technology.

by maxwell edison

And that's my point.

I moved from your world about 25 years ago, and I don't ever care to go back. It's not even a nice place to visit. It's full of pessimism and gloomy outlooks. It has a negative poison that's rampant, and it spreads itself and infects all others who might be around. It has a negative pressure in the atmosphere that's always bursting people's bubbles. The skies are never sunny, but rather always cloudy; and that causes it to always rain on people's parades. And those clouds don't even have silver-linings. Can you imagine such a thing? And it's full of people who always see other people as bad people. Everybody's always to blame for everything, and there's always plenty of blame to go around. You just can't get rid of it regardless of how hard you try. And the longer people stay in your world, the harder and harder it is to move from it. People keep getting sucked into the black-hole of doom and gloom; that must be its energy source. No, I don't ever want to go back, but for some strange reason, not too many people want to leave.

Not to worry, however. You can move too! You really can. And it's never too late. No one has the power to stop you, although they will all try. Regardless, the choice is yours, and only yours. No one can decide for you. And there's plenty of room, too, here in my world. For some strange reason, not many people want to come here, only about 10 percent I might guess. I can't imagine why not, though. Opportunities of all colors are always sprouting up all over the place, and there are new buds of optimism that appear daily. Perhaps it's all the sunny days we have around here. Even when it is cloudy, those silver linings shine bright enough to keep everything in full bloom. It's truly a sight to behold.

I would love to help people find it, but not too many people believe me when I tell them about my world. They always tell me that they'll believe it when they see it. They think I'm crazy when I tell them that it's just the opposite, that they'll see it when they believe it. Oh well, at least I try.

by jkameleon

> But what bugs me the most are the statements made by our leading high-tech CEOs

Statements made by leading high-tech CEOs are like spam.

Spammer delivers his message to millions. Even if he cons only a couple of people into buying his pills, it's worth it. Sending spam is free.

High tech CEO bellyaches about critical skill gap, labour shortage, etc as soon as number of deperate losers per job opening falls below 250. Even if he cons only a couple people into IT field, decreasing his labour costs for 0.0000000020394%, it's still worth it. Drivelling is free.

> Because most post say that we need to out source to fill them, are our kids too dumb to learn what we know?

No. Because kids are too smart to participate in the world "who's gonna work cheaper" championship.

by ed woychowsky

Wouldn?t the bottom line be helped as much if in addition to the IT departments the accounting departments are also outsourced? In addition, to maximize shareholder value it would be more cost effective to outsource upper management. After all, why pay $100,000,000 when $100,000 will suffice? Let's put this concept to a shareholder vote!

by tonythetiger

"Wouldn?t the bottom line be helped as much if in addition to the IT departments the accounting departments are also outsourced?"

If examination proved that to be the case, then it should certainly be persued.

by jdmercha

Although I agree with your sentement - Have you ever heard of Arthur Andersen, Deloitte & Touche, Ernst $ Youg, KPMG or PW Coopers?

by amberhaze

A few years back, I worked for a government department which was forced to initiate some cut backs initiated by the political masters.

The Decisions about planning for cut backs were left to the financial administration department. Want to guess which department saw no staff cuts or pay cuts? The front line workers where the real need was, were cut beyond the point of crisis, while there were administrators litterally doing nothing sitting back and attending meaningless meetings about nothing.
Before you assume I was one of those front line workers, I was not... I was an expensive outsource consultant who was braught in to advise on the best way to achieve cuts and create efficiency... My contract was immediatly terminated when I came back with a plan that showed how they could make all thier savings required by streamlining administration while actually increasing the front line workers who were over stressed.
Yes this was my first experience in advising a Gvt department... never advise to cut off the hand that feeds you... hehehe

by johnnysacks

Maybe our kids will smarten up when it comes to either starving to death on the streets, picking scrap iron for 0.05 per pound, or swabbing toilets for $6.10 an hour minimum wage in 2020. As our jobs disappear, so do discretionary purchases. Housing, transportation, necessities, all bought on credit even as income sources dry up. Ever talk with someone who lived through the depression? Coming again someday and when it does, we'll see who works cheaper.

by tonythetiger

"... but because doing so benefits their own bottom lines. "

That's their job! If they can save the company money, they deserve a portion of what they saved.

Sad truth: "Those who can, do. Those who can't are jealous of those who did."

by amcol

This is exactly why I always chuckle at the plethora of questions that get posted herein about which cert should I get, is an A+ better than a MCSE, should I get a cert or a degree, ad infinitum and ad nauseum.

Whether you have 147 letters after your name or none at all, you're still only as good as the value you add to the organization. Too many folks never get out of the school mindset, in which rewards are the direct result of earning credentials. Welcome to the real world, where the only question that counts is "What have you done for me TODAY?".

by maxwell edison

I've discovered over the years (decades?) that people who get stuck in the limited mind-set mentality have extreme difficulty not only understanding how crippling it is, but actually breaking out of it. Once a person gets totally consumed by that "stinkin-thinkin" mind-set, how can he escape? And the sad thing is, it spills over into all aspects of one's life, it gets passed on to their kids, and so on. And when it comes to jobs and careers, and such, the fallacy on which all such thinking is based is, in part, that the preverbal pie is limited in size. But it's not limited. The pie is (or should be) ever growing and expanding.

The national pie, as measured by the national GDP, was about 6 trillion dollars in size in 1992. Today, it's pushing 12 trillion. The growing pie means more profits, more jobs, higher wages, more opportunities, and so on. In 10 years, what will the size of the pie be? And whether people realize it or not, all those new pieces of the growing pie are up for grabs (and even some of the old ones) -- unless, of course, a person thinks otherwise; in which case, for them, they will get no pie.

Blame is bad. Responsibility is good. Who's to [i]BLAME[/i], or what's to [i]BLAME[/i] for the loss of my job is the wrong thing to ask and the wrong thing to focus on. If a mind can only hold one thought at a time, which is true, how can even a one micro-second of thought spent dwelling on "who's to blame" possibly help that person's [i]response[/i] to help his [i]ability[/i] to move on? The answer is, it can't. The solution is, then don't do it.

I guess we've kinda' digressed a bit, haven't we?

by nighthawk808

if you can give me a lifetime supply of the happy-happy drugs you've been overdosing on. You make Polyanna look downright pessimistic.

It really must be a wonderful life walking around as blissfully clueless as you do. Usually your posts are so inane that I don't bother to read them anymore, but the title of this one intrigued me. That was a waste of a perfectly good click.

Edited to correct typo.

by amcol

I don't think this is a digression at all. The overall theme of personal responsibility is squarely on point as far as the original post goes and is a logical extension of this conversation. It's fascinating how many threads in TR, as a matter of fact, are germane to personal responsibility.

Or, more to the point and as you and I agree, the lack of personal responsibility on the part of far too many people. I hate to say it, but you and I are to blame...along with the rest of our generation for doing such an outstanding job of raising our children in so sheltered a fashion and with such a profound unwillingness to deny them anything that they all got the idea this is the way life was supposed to be. I am, therefore I deserve.

There's no such thing in real life as a black and white situation, one in which one party is all bad and the other all good. It's what makes life so interesting, that there are all these shades of grey. For myself, I'd rather concentrate on whatever learnings I can derive from whatever happens that allows me to improve as a human being. I can control only myself, and I see no value in wasting time assessing all the ways in which the other guy has done me wrong. At the end of the day that might make me feel a little better, but it's ephemeral. Where does it really get me? Not the most productive way to spend my time.

by sullyman69

Supply and demand!! The demand is exceeding the supply of skilled workers, in all areas. I don't see you posting about the migrant workers picking fruit in the fruit belts. Is that because people think they are above that? Or is it that you belive that "outside workers" should only have jobs that you feel are below you?

by jdmercha

Yes supply and demand, definitely. But "in all areas"? Certainly not around here. We have many highly skilled and highly educated people around here who can find nothing better that flipping burgers or running cash registers.

The thing is, until companies are willing to provide good pay and cover relocation expenses, these people are better off flipping burgers here.

Although I will agree that in some parts of this country high tech jobs are going unfilled. But it is not because of a lack of skilled workers. It is because companies are unwilling to pay what it costs to get the workers they need.

by sullyman69

If you can buy that same car at two different dealerships ( and all things being equal ), and the price is $5000 dollars less at dealership ?B? are you telling me that you would pay $5000 more from dealship ?A?? We spend our days searching for the best price on everything we do, where do you get your RAM from for your systems? Dollars to donuts it is made offshore!! Why should we feel that we are entitled to a job because of who we are? This is where the big debate comes in

If I own a company that employs 10,000 software programmers and we are loosing money due to fixed costs (salary etc?) should I continue to pay everyone and loose money? Or possibly find another more cost effective source of labor for some of my programmers?

Offshore outsourcing is directly caused by our thirst for the best deal for our money. Until cost does not matter, jobs will continue to be outsourced/in sourced using the most cost effective measures. I can?t speak for you but I do know that most of the time I can?t afford to pay 100% more for something just because it is made at home???.

by jdmercha

"I am still wondering why we can not fill all of any IT jobs here in the US?"

I just filled a job opening. I had 85 applicants for this one position. More than half of them were well qualified. Five of them would have been taking a step down from their current position. The job did not require a BS but I had 4 Phd's apply for the job, as well as at least 20 with masters degrees. I struggled to get the field down to six to call in for an interview. After the interviews I had to flip a coin to decide between three of them. I'd like to know where these unfilled jobs are. There are more than enough people around here to fill them.

by kiltie

I live in Scotland and the local newspapers regularly run articles about the shortage in tech fields, particularly in the computer field.

I am a PC consultant, lots of experience, specialising in Windows Systems, but I can't find a regular job, I provide free online help nowadays, just to keep my skills honed, maybe they are not being advertised?

Some discrete enquiries reveal 100 to 300 applicants per tech position, and I have been told that it is very difficult to narrow that field down to a short list for interview.

I have even been told that one of the rejection criteria being used is that many applicants are over qualified !!!!

So No Jobs about......

by zlitocook

In the states they want to double the amount of imported IT and pay them what our fast food companies pay. With my skill set I can always find a job. But most other IT folks here are hard put to find a living wage or at least a job that lasts long enough to let them learn more. Here in St Louis MO. there are lots of contract jobs that pays vary well but only last a best a year. But you never really know if you will be needed the next week.
The guy I replaced on the last contract was a sys admin and had been with the company eight years. But the company was consolidating and outsourcing much of its call center. The IT department was next, six people four hundred. He got a better paying job as a window blind salesman.

by sleepin'dawg

to recognize it is a jungle out there. Remember the [b][i]Law of the Jungle :[/i] eat or be eaten; kill or be killed.[/b] Jobs are not given out strictly on the basis of qualification but also on the basis of who proves themselves most worthy of being given the job, i.e. who wants it badly enough??? Don't beg for any job; make them beg you to take it. Settle monetary matters after they offer you the job; not before, otherwise you run the risk of pricing yourself out of the running. If you want the job badly enough, you will sell yourself to get it. I'll give work to someone who is hungry to do it, not someone who thinks he is entitled to it, because of his degrees and certs.

Import workers are invaribly, hungrier than the home grown variety, who think their papers entitle them to certain advantages in the work place.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdmercha

First off the "Same Car" really has to be the "Same Car". When you outsorce to save money you are most certainly not getting the "Same Car". You are hiring a company to do a job. You don't see who they hire. They are cheap, not because of low labor costs but because they hire inferior talent. They hire people you would not hire.

Secondly, you may only think you are offshoring the job. We have a company here in the US who subcontracts those "offshore" jobs right back here to the US. Why? Because where I live the cost of labor is cheaper than India and the talent pool is larger.

Thirdly, there is the philosophical difference. Keeping the job inhouse may cost you more, but it gives you more control over the product and can more easily be leveraged as a competative advantage. The 'cheapest' doesn't always when out when the quality just isn't there.

by sullyman69

The perfect example lies in the fact that for the majority of us in our roles price play an important daily role. If we have to roll out a piece of custom software to the floor and the quote is 2K per seat with company A in North America and 1K with a company that is outsourced offshore, most if not all of us would have a hard time justifying the 2k purchase price to the CTO or CEO. Now, that being said just because the product is cheaper and is being developed across time zones does not make it an inferior product. It can make it a cheaper product.

If we buy the 2k per seat software we have to pass those costs onto our customers, which in essence can force our customer to purchase our service (if applicable) from a more cost effective source. Now the ball is gathering moss?

We have it engrained into our minds to look for the best deal, find the best price, and the best value for our dollar. If the world wasn?t like this then we would all be shopping at boutiques and not at Wal-Mart.

But, the AVERAGE consumer does not care where something came from they just care about how it impacts their bottom line.

by tony hopkinson

who accepts the need for change, understands that they know 'nothing' and is constantly questioning their own performance and how to improve it. It's not so much the quality of education as the idea that graduation is ALL you have to achieve to make it, that's the problem.

You see them posting to this site regulary, I ve got my bit of paper why haven't I got a job? The answer is quite simple, you haven't done enough to convince someone to 'give' you one.

by tony hopkinson

Certainly in the economic short term hiring professionals from a country with much lower labour costs seems like a good idea.
However there are other things to take into account.

First the money is flowing out of your contry.

Second you increase unemployment in your own country and everybody remaining in employment gets to pay for that.

Thirdly and most importantly in my opinion, you suffer a massive brain drain, not only in the company itself, but eventually in the country.

Like most decisions made by bean counters and profiteers, it's a long term loss.

by absolutely

Tony Hopkinson: "Thirdly and most importantly in my opinion, you suffer a massive brain drain, not only in the company itself, but eventually in the country."

When jobs go overseas, they do so because the brains onshore have either already been drained, or were never filled. If the domestic labor decides to react to offshore outsourcing (or any other adversity!) by anything but improving themselves, each one of them has exactly one person to hold responsible for their lack of improvement: oneself!

by ebeck

You make a good point, that we are responsible for improvement, but Tony is dead-on in the point about brain-drain but with some mods. While we do have the people here with the knowledge, the work and experience is going outside.

Even if (or should I say when) it comes back in, the other parts of the business have processes aligned to surviving with offshore staff. The people here meanwhile have also adapted to other areas in technology or to self-employemend (there are many directions they go). When/if the jobs migrate back, the world will still be very different, and you can bet the salaries will never be the same. They will also be competing for these returned jobs with a newer generation of smarter young techs - grown and trained here in the USA.

by tony hopkinson

paper skills. I watched a very large firm outsource their entire IT effort to a third party to cut employment costs.

When the contract comes up for re-negotiation, what are the options ?. You can get IBM guys, you can get Linux one's you can get windows ones. But where is the competition going to get people who know the environment? What's the cost of them not having that knowledge?

You can manage a few (business) newbies at at time , 500 though, not a chance. Whether you outsource off or onshore your people are far more than the letters after their name.

The real brain drain, though is the one we are hitting, since IT is no longer the profession of choice in your country, no one is choosing it.

That was your's as in mine as well.

You wait, as costs of employing offshore workers beigin to increase the industry will start blaming the schools system for not turning out enough people with the requisite skills. At the moment it's just an excuse.

Nothing to do with the schools, it's the students being intelligent enough to know they can't compete cost wise with a chap from a country where 800 monopoly dollars a month is a top salary.

Thanks to ebeck for knowing what I meant even though I didn't put it very well.

by jdmercha

This has got to the best post I have ever seen on this forum. I could take this two ways. From one angle this describes my physical location quite acurately. From another view this describes my mental state. The only point I would disagree with is that "not too many peole want to leave". In the 18 years I've been here 10% of the people have left.

From the other side, I would leave in a minute if I could find some place to go. I've been trying for almost two years to get out. But I can't seem to find the world where these unfilled jobs exist. It's funny though how our fresh college grads here are able to find their way out. But then they don't have a choice, because there is nothing here for them.

by sleepin'dawg

where unfulfilled jobs exist but you "create" one, identify the jobs you are interested in and make that world yours. If you have a means of adding to the bottom line without any significant addition to overhead, people will "find" you. In your new world certs are meaningless; the question will be, "can you do it and how soon?" The other question of course, will be, "How much is this going to cost me???"

If you opt to explore this you need some rules for yourself.
Rule #1: You are available to everyone 24/7. This means your family as well as clients. You ignore the latter and you will lose a large part of the motivation necessary for you to proceed and keep growing in the former. As time goes on you will learn how to best allocate your time but at first you will feel somewhat stressed.

Rule #2: Under no cicumstances, ever refuse any job, regardless of your capability to do it. Never allow yourself to be in the business of refusing business. If you can't do a specific job yourself, find some one who can, hire him or her and then watch them so you can learn how the job is done and if necessary you will be able to do it yourself the next time. This is an excellent method of increasing your portfolio of capabilities that you can present to your clients. Always remember your client doesn't really care if you have a degree and certs; he is only interested in getting the job done for the least amount of money.

Rule #3: Never undersell your service by more than 10% below the going rate for the job and better yet try to keep that to less than 5%. Your clientele will value you by the value you place on yourself and your service. If you are too cheap you will not establish your credibility, never mind the world you are trying to create for yourself. Once your credibility has been established you can increase your pricing to be more in line with the market, perhaps trailing it by less than 0.5%. Never permit yourself to be bullied into low balling a price to get any job, your clientele will not respect you if you do.

Rule #4: Strive to learn something new every day; keeping your eyes open for anything that will add to your capabilities. Look for things that form a symbiosis to what you already have. That way you will be able to expand with a degree of logic to your expansion. Try to find things that minimizes labour and maximizes profit potential. If that means you take a road that requires outsourcing offshore, then that is the road you take. Remember you are under no compulsion to operate as a charitable, non-profit organization.

Rule #5: [b][u]Work smarter not harder.[/u][/b] Avoid labour intensive work for profit intensive jobs. I know this might make you sound a bit greedy but you will find labour intensive work the most boring, while most high profit work is interesting and will reap greater benefits. A little bit of greed is good motivation for success.

Rule #6: [b][u][i]If you keep doing what you've always done, you will keep getting what you've always got.[/i][/u][/b] This should require no explanation.

None of these rules will automatically make you rich but they should give you a lifestyle of comfort, interest, freedom and independance that will be the envy of your friends and associates. At first glance the outlook seems daunting but as someone once said, "The only thing to fear is fear itself." If you can get a handle on that, there will be no limit to your possibilities. Keep in mind you work at a company not for the company. Think of yourself as a supplier of necessary skills for the company you are working at. If you find yourself dissatisfied with your situation, then you need to look outside your current situation.

If you have more questions, pm me but I might be a tad slow in responding for a while, until I've topped off my current project. I will answer you but maybe not as quickly as you would wish. If you wonder why I am so free with advice, there is lots of opportunities for everyone and I was given lots of help and advice when I started out, so why shouldn't I pass it along. What goes around comes around. If you had told me 18 years ago that I would be in any position to be offering advice to anyone, I would have told you that you were crazy. Not all advice that I offer will necessarily be applicable directly to your situation, not all the advice I received was directly applicable to mine but you do learn to consider it and adapt it to your needs.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by absolutely

Words have exact meanings. Those exact meanings, however, are not always used precisely. The "loophole" in skilled worker immigration visas is the vague definition of "specialized knowledge". Excerpt:

[Finally, that DHS report I mentioned calls L-1 ?The Computer Visa,? saying nine out of 10 companies that use the L-1 are ?computer- and IT-related.? The report says that it is ?difficult to be confident that a firm truly intends using an imported worker? as a manager or executive. It suggests that the term ?specialized knowledge? is so broad that ?adjudicators believe they have little choice but to approve almost all petitions.? And while L-1 workers must be employed by the importing company abroad for at least a year, the report finds that the United States has ?little ability to evaluate the substantiality of the foreign operation? and even allows ?petitioners to transfer themselves into the United States.? ]

Before I vote for anything, I question whether the law is precise enough to punish only harmful actions, or whether it grants government(by which I mean the most malicious, incompetent bureaucrat you have ever met in any government office) the ability to harm people who have done nothing wrong. Generally, I'm for free markets in everything and consider competition more helpful than harmful, but this is a good opportunity to present an even more important and more fundamental principle: Govern others as you would like others to govern you.

by ebeck

I like the resume blurb (#1 of course) - haven't thought of wording things in that manner yet, even though that's how I've shot up the ladder.

You're correct - this is good even if it is out instead of up. It's much easier to explain why you left a company that way than if you are asked to leave beacuse someone else worked you out.

by gwcarter

As I see it, visa'd workers are not the problem. I have worked with several and they are all well-qualified and highly motivated. At my company, at least, they are paid commensurately with native Americans, and the do the same work. The problem is the shipping of entire projects to offshore sites in India, China, etc. They have no understanding or our culture, and so the delivered systems tend to jar the sensibilities of the users, who mostly refuse to even speak with them. Yes, they cost less up front, but the next quarter is all the guy in the driver's seat thinks about.

We are told that we are not competitive, and that we cost too much. Well, in a limited sense we are not in competition. Most IT departments are overhead expense (at least in executive management's view) and so we act to reduce net profit. The root of this problem is that CEOs pay more attention to the stock price and not to the operation of their businesses. Greedy investors want the maximum return on their money regardless of the long-term consequences. When our businesses are managed for the good of America and Americans rather than for maximum return to investors this situation may change.

Finally, the education argument is just trash. Although most of us may have college education, it is unarguable (I believe) that in IT we must be judged by the output of our functions, not on the input. Looking purely at output, American IT is second to none. The Peter Principle has something to say about this. Review that book and then ponder the real meaning of the Enron, Qwest, and other debacles in this light. If anyone should be better educated (not just trained) it should be those captains of industry that set the trends, not the techs who support them.

by btthomas51

Your comment about IT as a cost center versus a profit center is interesting. I have been an outside consultant for nearly10 years. When I am asked to work on an engagement, it is the IT department that can not step up to the plate to help the executives. This past year it has been system design, budgeting, and business process engineering. The year before this project the technology was content management and Documentum. The year before the technology was text mining and ontologies. I tend to adapt to a new technology every couple of years. My salary has risen each year.

My lessons learned in dealing with the C-level that brings my team into the company are:

1.) The leadership is being told that the current staff does not have the capacity to help the company implement a new strategic project.
2.) The technical staff does not have the skills to do the new projects.
3.) Foreign workers make the senior staff think that they are more adaptable.
4.) In some cases, the foreign worker's communication skills are superior to the American educated workers. The ability of the senior foreign worker to do work in the strategic environment helps them sell work that makes the connection between investment and results.
5.) Many of the technical workers that I have worked with can code, but they lack the engineering discipline, methodologies, and the formal deliverables.

The ability of the American worker to survive in this market may have more to do with interpersonal communications and the ability to adapt. Darwin's view of IT might tell us that those that wish to do the same job tasks over a long period will have a short trajectory. Companies need to adapt to their business environment, the workers that can help them adapt will be valued.

by tony hopkinson

with management. My expereience is the direct opposite the only thing the executive wants to do with IT is cut it because they do view it as an overhead.

There's a lot of guilt on both sides, you simply seem to be going down the usual consultant route of getting paid a lot by telling the executive what they want to hear.

I've seen IT waste money, I've seen them fail to the point where they were out of a job.

I've also seen the executive waste money until IT was out of a job.

A bit more balance might get you a better reception. After all if you can get buy in from IT and the executive, you've got an appealing business and technical solution.

I'm sure there are one or two time servers about, evereyone I've ever worked with in IT though has been a manager.

by maxwell edison

You said, "My experience is ..... the only thing the executive wants to do with IT is cut it because they do view it as an overhead."

But it IS an overhead. You don't disagree, do you?

An automobile dealership, for example, is in business to sell automobiles, not have a huge IT infrastructure. The IT infrastructure supports selling the automobiles, just like the building itself also supports that function. If they can get a bigger and nicer building, and one in a better location, and all at a lower price, they'd be fools not to do it. And sometimes that might mean they get the added benefit of not needing as big a maintenance staff to keep fixing all the things that were constantly needing repair in the old building. Likewise, if they can get a streamlined IT infrastructure at a lower cost, they'd be fools not to do that as well.

Even most "IT companies" are not really IT companies. Dell computer, for example, isn't really an IT company, but rather a computer dealership company. They're in the business to sell computers, no more, no less. They view a huge IT infrastructure as an overhead that may not necessarily help them sell more computers. (Note: I said "may not"; I didn't say does not. There is a distinction. Keep reading for the distinction.) The desired end result for any company is to sell more of their preverbal widgets, at a lower cost, ones with better quality, to a bigger market, and so on.

People have a choice. They can look at these things as the cruel and hard facts of life, and fall victim to _________ (whatever - fill in the blank), or they can see these things and realize that opportunity results just as well.

A person who's working at the automobile dealership, for example, might be content just biding his time, doing a good job, collecting his paycheck for his valiant efforts fixing computers, building computers, maintaining a network, retrieving people's lost files, and all that other "IT stuff", and that's a perfectly legitimate thing to want to do, and it can even be seen as a noble and helpful thing to do; but he won't go as far and/or be as secure in his position as the person who enthusiastically and proactively looks for ways to use that IT infrastructure to help the dealership sell more automobiles, and maybe even do so at a greater profit. The former is expendable. The latter is a rare godsend. The former might have a hard time finding and/or keeping a job. The latter will always have his choice of jobs.

And consider this. If a person's personal passion in life is his love for automobiles, and he happens to be such an IT support person, and he keeps looking for ways to help his dealership sell more automobiles and/or at a greater profit, then he's got the best of all worlds.

by tony hopkinson

IT is generally used to cut costs, of course you have to spend money on IT to enable it to do that.
When all the costs that IT can practically cut have been cut then IT is just an overhead. But only in the way that the number of employees/ amount of materials etc the IT function did away with was.

How you cut further after that, usually means you sacrifice something. The people who decide waht gets sacrificed are managers. Not many of them write their own name at the top of the list. Unless there's a lucrative early retirement or redundancy package on the table.

I'm with you on how to get ahead anyway, sitting on your ass and waiting for something good to happen is a recipe for disaster.

I've always been the guy who put his hand up and said I can do that, even when I wasn't exactly sure I could without a bit of research.

It's how I got my first job, seen no reason to change.

I'm not sure the guy was talking to right people in IT. It's the guys in charge with dated skills surviving on seniority who are most resistant to change.

by jdmercha

It is the approach to overhead that counts. IT should not be viewed as an expense to be cut, but rather a tool to be leveraged. Using your car dealership example:

A mechanics tools are overhead. The machanic is the knowledge worker that knows the job. They know what it takes to do the job. They pay for their own tools. They don't buy Stanley tools from Walmart.

If the dealership were paying for those tools they would would be buying one $5 screwdriver from Walmart, instead of six $25 screwdrivers from MAC.

by maxwell edison

(Read my previous message first)

The IT people who are just biding their time, as I described in my previous message, presuming to know how to run a better business, just because they know how to run an operating system, are fools. The CIO just want's a big fat bonus, they will say. Just wait until their whole network comes crashing down, they will say. Don't they know that Linux is better than Windows, they will say.

These people who presume to know how to run a better business ought to do just that -- try to run a better business. If Dell computer sucks so much because they "outsource" a support department, such as their helpdesk, then try to do it better. And don't say that you can't start a company out of your garage. Michael Dell, William Hewlett and Dave Packard might disagree.

And if these people who constantly complain and find fault can't build a better business themselves, the next best thing it to help an existing business be a better business. The last alternative is to be at everyone else's mercy -- and complain about it, of course.

Some people are so silly, and they don't have a grasp of reality when they complain about such things, or they advocate getting the government involved to exert more control over business (see France right now), or any and all of those tired old complaints and arguments.

Those people just don't get it.

by tony hopkinson

as well as a good business man. I'm an out and out tech. All I say is I can't help you run a better business if I aren't working for you.

If I've been outsourced, I'm helping another business run a better business. The business interests will differ. As long as they don't put their client out of business and they ensure you can't go to someone else except at a much greater cost, the firm I'm working for the outsourcee is quids in.

Don't have to be an MBA to figure that one out do you ?

So is it a sound business decision after all? That depends on the criticality of the function. IT tends to run towards critical nowadays.

In the UK they outsourced cleaners in hospitals. Sounds fairly innocuous, but now we have people dying in them because of lack of hygiene.

So how critical to the function were the cleaners ?

Certainly when the original decsision was made, no one thought how the cleaing company might maximise their profit to benefit their business.

by sleepin'dawg

In Canada where most hospitals have yet to out source cleaning, there has been a rash of
incidents involving the c-dificile virus and various types of moulds. It seems our hospitals have placed adequate supervision of the cleaning staff and proper practices on a list of low priorities. My old grandfather used to refuse hospialization unless he was extremely ill or had fractured something, on the grounds that hospitals were places you went to get sick and were to be avoided until all other options had been exhausted. I think he had a point but besides that, it is indicative that this isn't a new problem but one of long standing. My grandfather has been dead for over 35 years and when he died at age 96 he was refusing to be admitted to hospital because, "Hospitals are where you go to die." In his case, he was abolutely correct but he did have a sudden onset of pancreatic cancer. In those days, there was no hope of recovery from that. They did manage to keep him alive, lucid and comfortable for the remainder of his life, which was three months. Prior to that he had never had a sick day in his life and attributed that to his managing to avoid doctors and hospitals, whenever possible.

Most outsourcing contracts are written so that they can be terminated, in short order, if services performed do not meet a minimal level or standard of performance. Thats how it is done in private industry, whether it involves cleaning or IT. What happen in public service is anyone's guess but one thing I do know for certain; in the UK there has evolved some of the weirdest labour regulations on earth that might hinder the powers that be from taking any definitive action. I am not criticizing, I am just saying that's how it seems to be and sometimes some of the regulations for the public sector, spill over into the private sector. It is all quite confusing to an outsider and I think it must be confusing to you Brits as well. The labour regulations in the UK, does give an outside investor pause before he decides to sink money into any project in the UK, especially anything labour intensive. I don't know how you people got yourselves into the state you are in but you always seem to muddle through somehow but in the most convoluted of manners.

You might lay some of the blame on the doorsteps of your unions but they aren't solely to blame. The vast majority of blame can be applied to your political parties who will do anything to get themselves reelected and stay in power.

I remember history lessons which told of English unions striking in the middle of WW II, tying up the docks. England was barely surviving and needed every item being sent from Canada and the US but your unions were able to pull a stunt like that??? Over here they would have been imprisoned or shot for treason to the nation, under similar circumstances. A quick round of fatal heart attacks or strokes, amongst your political and labour leaders, might do wonders for your nation.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by oz_media

Which allows those such as you and I to progress and succeed in our goals. You don't always have to walk on people to get to the top, more often than not you simply have to step over them as they lay there dormant.

by sleepin'dawg

NOTE: Written in Autumn 2002

The Barbarians at the Gates of Paris

Theodore Dalrymple

Everyone knows la douce France: the France of wonderful food and
wine, beautiful landscapes, splendid ch?teaux and cathedrals. More
tourists (60 million a year) visit France than any country in the
world by far. Indeed, the Germans have a saying, not altogether
reassuring for the French: ?to live as God in France.? Half a
million Britons have bought second homes there; many of them bore
their friends back home with how they order these things better in
France.

But there is another growing, and much less reassuring, side to
France. I go to Paris about four times a year and thus have a sense
of the evolving preoccupations of the French middle classes. A few
years ago it was schools: the much vaunted French educational system
was falling apart; illiteracy was rising; children were leaving
school as ignorant as they entered, and much worse-behaved. For the
last couple of years, though, it has been crime: l?ins?curit?, les
violences urbaines, les incivilit?s. Everyone has a tale to tell,
and no dinner party is complete without a horrifying story. Every
crime, one senses, means a vote for Le Pen or whoever replaces him.

I first saw l?ins?curit? for myself about eight months ago. It was
just off the Boulevard Saint-Germain, in a neighborhood where a
tolerably spacious apartment would cost $1 million. Three
youths?Rumanians?were attempting quite openly to break into a
parking meter with large screwdrivers to steal the coins. It was
four o?clock in the afternoon; the sidewalks were crowded, and the
nearby caf?s were full. The youths behaved as if they were simply
pursuing a normal and legitimate activity, with nothing to fear.

Eventually, two women in their sixties told them to stop. The
youths, laughing until then, turned murderously angry, insulted the
women, and brandished their screwdrivers. The women retreated, and
the youths resumed their ?work.?

A man of about 70 then told them to stop. They berated him still
more threateningly, one of them holding a screwdriver as if to stab
him in the stomach. I moved forward to help the man, but the youths,
still shouting abuse and genuinely outraged at being interrupted in
the pursuit of their livelihood, decided to run off. But it all
could have ended very differently.

Several things struck me about the incident: the youths? sense of
invulnerability in broad daylight; the indifference to their
behavior of large numbers of people who would never dream of
behaving in the same way; that only the elderly tried to do anything
about the situation, though physically least suited to do so. Could
it be that only they had a view of right and wrong clear enough to
wish to intervene? That everyone younger than they thought something
like: ?Refugees . . . hard life . . . very poor . . . too young to
know right from wrong and anyway never taught . . . no choice for
them . . . punishment cruel and useless?? The real criminals,
indeed, were the drivers whose coins filled the parking meters: were
they not polluting the world with their cars?

Another motive for inaction was that, had the youths been arrested,
nothing would have happened to them. They would have been back on
the streets within the hour. Who would risk a screwdriver in the
liver to safeguard the parking meters of Paris for an hour?

The laxisme of the French criminal justice system is now notorious.
Judges often make remarks indicating their sympathy for the
criminals they are trying (based upon the usual generalizations
about how society, not the criminal, is to blame); and the day
before I witnessed the scene on the Boulevard Saint-Germain, 8,000
police had marched to protest the release from prison on bail of an
infamous career armed robber and suspected murderer before his trial
for yet another armed robbery, in the course of which he shot
someone in the head. Out on bail before this trial, he then burgled
a house. Surprised by the police, he and his accomplices shot two of
them dead and seriously wounded a third. He was also under strong
suspicion of having committed a quadruple murder a few days
previously, in which a couple who owned a restaurant, and two of
their employees, were shot dead in front of the owners?
nine-year-old daughter.

The left-leaning Lib?ration, one of the two daily newspapers the
French intelligentsia reads, dismissed the marchers, referring with
disdainful sarca?m to la fi?vre flicardiaire?cop fever. The paper
would no doubt have regarded the murder of a single journalist?that
is to say, of a full human being?differently, let alone the murder
of two journalists or six; and of course no one in the newspaper
acknowledged that an effective police force is as vital a guarantee
of personal freedom as a free press, and that the thin blue line
that separates man from brutality is exactly that: thin. This is not
a decent thing for an intellectual to say, however true it might be.

It is the private complaint of everyone, however, that the police
have become impotent to suppress and detect crime. Horror stories
abound. A Parisian acquaintance told me how one recent evening he
had seen two criminals attack a car in which a woman was waiting for
her husband. They smashed her side window and tried to grab her
purse, but she resisted. My acquaintance went to her aid and managed
to pin down one of the assailants, the other running off.
Fortunately, some police passed by, but to my acquaintance?s dismay
let the assailant go, giving him only a warning.

My acquaintance said to the police that he would make a complaint.
The senior among them advised him against wasting his time. At that
time of night, there would be no one to complain to in the local
commissariat. He would have to go the following day and would have
to wait on line for three hours. He would have to return several
times, with a long wait each time. And in the end, nothing would be
done.

As for the police, he added, they did not want to make an arrest in
a case like this. There would be too much paperwork. And even if the
case came to court, the judge would give no proper punishment.
Moreover, such an arrest would retard their careers. The local
police chiefs were paid by results?by the crime rates in their areas
of jurisdiction. The last thing they wanted was for policemen to go
around finding and recording crime.

Not long afterward, I heard of another case in which the police
simply refused to record the occurrence of a burglary, much less try
to catch the culprits.

Now crime and general disorder are making inroads into places where,
not long ago, they were unheard of. At a peaceful and prosperous
village near Fontainebleau that I visited?the home of retired high
officials and of a former cabinet minister?criminality had made its
first appearance only two weeks before. There had been a burglary
and a ?rodeo??an impromptu race of youths in stolen cars around the
village green, whose fence the car thieves had knocked over to gain
access.

A villager called the police, who said they could not come at the
moment, but who politely called back half an hour later to find out
how things were going. Two hours later still, they finally appeared,
but the rodeo had moved on, leaving behind only the remains of a
burned-out car. The blackened patch on the road was still visible
when I visited.

The official figures for this upsurge, doctored as they no doubt
are, are sufficiently alarming. Reported crime in France has risen
from 600,000 annually in 1959 to 4 million today, while the
population has grown by less than 20 percent (and many think today?s
crime number is an underestimate by at least a half). In 2000, one
crime was reported for every sixth inhabitant of Paris, and the rate
has increased by at least 10 percent a year for the last five years.
Reported cases of arson in France have increased 2,500 percent in
seven years, from 1,168 in 1993 to 29,192 in 2000; robbery with
violence rose by 15.8 percent between 1999 and 2000, and 44.5
percent since 1996 (itself no golden age).

Where does the increase in crime come from? The geographical answer:
from the public housing projects that encircle and increasingly
besiege every French city or town of any size, Paris especially. In
these housing projects lives an immigrant population numbering
several million, from North and West Africa mostly, along with their
French-born descendants and a smattering of the least successful
members of the French working class. From these projects, the
excellence of the French public transport system ensures that the
most fashionable arrondissements are within easy reach of the most
inveterate thief and vandal.

Architecturally, the housing projects sprang from the ideas of Le
Corbusier, the Swiss totalitarian architect?and still the
untouchable hero of architectural education in France?who believed
that a house was a machine for living in, that areas of cities
should be entirely separated from one another by their function, and
that the straight line and the right angle held the key to wisdom,
virtue, beauty, and efficiency. The mulish opposition that met his
scheme to pull down the whole of the center of Paris and rebuild it
according to his ?rational? and ?advanced? ideas baffled and
frustrated him.

The inhuman, unadorned, hard-edged geometry of these vast housing
projects in their unearthly plazas brings to mind Le Corbusier?s
chilling and tyrannical words: ?The despot is not a man. It is the .
. . correct, realistic, exact plan . . . that will provide your
solution once the problem has been posed clearly. . . . This plan
has been drawn up well away from . . . the cries of the electorate
or the laments of society?s victims. It has been drawn up by serene
and lucid minds.?

But what is the problem to which these housing projects, known as
cit?s, are the solution, conceived by serene and lucid minds like Le
Corbusier?s? It is the problem of providing an Habitation de Loyer
Mod?r??a House at Moderate Rent, shortened to HLM?for the workers,
largely immigrant, whom the factories needed during France?s great
industrial expansion from the 1950s to the 1970s, when the
unemployment rate was 2 percent and cheap labor was much in demand.
By the late eighties, however, the demand had evaporated, but the
people whose labor had satisfied it had not; and together with their
descendants and a constant influx of new hopefuls, they made the
provision of cheap housing more necessary than ever.

An apartment in this publicly owned housing is also known as a
logement, a lodging, which aptly conveys the social status and
degree of political influence of those expected to rent them. The
cit?s are thus social marginalization made concrete:
bureaucratically planned from their windows to their roofs, with no
history of their own or organic connection to anything that
previously existed on their sites, they convey the impression that,
in the event of serious trouble, they could be cut off from the rest
of the world by switching off the trains and by blockading with a
tank or two the highways that pass through them, (usually with a
concrete wall on either side), from the rest of France to the better
parts of Paris. I recalled the words of an Afrikaner in South
Africa, who explained to me the principle according to which only a
single road connected black townships to the white cities: once it
was sealed off by an armored car, ?the blacks can foul only their
own nest.?

The average visitor gives not a moment?s thought to these Cit?s of
Darkness as he speeds from the airport to the City of Light. But
they are huge and important?and what the visitor would find there,
if he bothered to go, would terrify him.

A kind of anti-society has grown up in them?a population that
derives the meaning of its life from the hatred it bears for the
other, ?official,? society in France. This alienation, this gulf of
mistrust?greater than any I have encountered anywhere else in the
world, including in the black townships of South Africa during the
apartheid years?is written on the faces of the young men, most of
them permanently unemployed, who hang out in the pocked and potholed
open spaces between their logements. When you approach to speak to
them, their immobile faces betray not a flicker of recognition of
your shared humanity; they make no gesture to smooth social
intercourse. If you are not one of them, you are against them.

Their hatred of official France manifests itself in many ways that
scar everything around them. Young men risk life and limb to adorn
the most inaccessible surfaces of concrete with graffiti?BAISE LA
POLICE, fuck the police, being the favorite theme. The iconography
of the cit?s is that of uncompromising hatred and aggression: a
burned-out and destroyed community-meeting place in the Les
Tarterets project, for example, has a picture of a science-fiction
humanoid, his fist clenched as if to spring at the person who looks
at him, while to his right is an admiring portrait of a huge
slavering pit bull, a dog by temperament and training capable of
tearing out a man?s throat?the only breed of dog I saw in the cit?s,
paraded with menacing swagger by their owners.

There are burned-out and eviscerated carcasses of cars everywhere.
Fire is now fashionable in the cit?s: in Les Tarterets, residents
had torched and looted every store?with the exceptions of one
government-subsidized supermarket and a pharmacy. The underground
parking lot, charred and blackened by smoke like a vault in an urban
hell, is permanently closed.

When agents of official France come to the cit?s, the residents
attack them. The police are hated: one young Malian, who
comfortingly believed that he was unemployable in France because of
the color of his skin, described how the police invariably arrived
like a raiding party, with batons swinging?ready to beat whoever
came within reach, irrespective of who he was or of his innocence of
any crime, before retreating to safety to their commissariat. The
conduct of the police, he said, explained why residents threw
Molotov cocktails at them from their windows. Who could tolerate
such treatment at the hands of une police fasciste?

Molotov cocktails also greeted the president of the republic,
Jacques Chirac, and his interior minister when they recently
campaigned at two cit?s, Les Tarterets and Les Musiciens. The two
dignitaries had to beat a swift and ignominious retreat, like
foreign overlords visiting a barely held and hostile suzerainty:
they came, they saw, they scuttled off.

Antagonism toward the police might appear understandable, but the
conduct of the young inhabitants of the cit?s toward the firemen who
come to rescue them from the fires that they have themselves started
gives a dismaying glimpse into the depth of their hatred for
mainstream society. They greet the admirable firemen (whose motto is
Sauver ou p?rir, save or perish) with Molotov cocktails and hails of
stones when they arrive on their mission of mercy, so that armored
vehicles frequently have to protect the fire engines.

Benevolence inflames the anger of the young men of the cit?s as much
as repression, because their rage is inseparable from their being.
Ambulance men who take away a young man injured in an incident
routinely find themselves surrounded by the man?s ?friends,? and
jostled, jeered at, and threatened: behavior that, according to one
doctor I met, continues right into the hospital, even as the friends
demand that their associate should be treated at once, before
others.

Of course, they also expect him to be treated as well as anyone
else, and in this expectation they reveal the bad faith, or at least
ambivalence, of their stance toward the society around them. They
are certainly not poor, at least by the standards of all previously
existing societies: they are not hungry; they have cell phones,
cars, and many other appurtenances of modernity; they are dressed
fashionably?according to their own fashion?with a uniform disdain of
bourgeois propriety and with gold chains round their necks. They
believe they have rights, and they know they will receive medical
treatment, however they behave. They enjoy a far higher standard of
living (or consumption) than they would in the countries of their
parents? or grandparents? origin, even if they labored there 14
hours a day to the maximum of their capacity.

But this is not a cause of gratitude?on the contrary: they feel it
as an insult or a wound, even as they take it for granted as their
due. But like all human beings, they want the respect and approval
of others, even?or rather especially?of the people who carelessly
toss them the crumbs of Western prosperity. Emasculating dependence
is never a happy state, and no dependence is more absolute, more
total, than that of most of the inhabitants of the cit?s. They
therefore come to believe in the malevolence of those who maintain
them in their limbo: and they want to keep alive the belief in this
perfect malevolence, for it gives meaning?the only possible
meaning?to their stunted lives. It is better to be opposed by an
enemy than to be adrift in meaninglessness, for the simulacrum of an
enemy lends purpose to actions whose nihilism would otherwise be
self-evident.

That is one of the reasons that, when I approached groups of young
men in Les Musiciens, many of them were not just suspicious (though
it was soon clear to them that I was no member of the enemy), but
hostile. When a young man of African origin agreed to speak to me,
his fellows kept interrupting menacingly. ?Don?t talk to him,? they
commanded, and they told me, with fear in their eyes, to go away.
The young man was nervous, too: he said he was afraid of being
punished as a traitor. His associates feared that ?normal? contact
with a person who was clearly not of the enemy, and yet not one of
them either, would contaminate their minds and eventually break down
the them-and-us worldview that stood between them and complete
mental chaos. They needed to see themselves as warriors in a civil
war, not mere ne?er-do-wells and criminals.

The ambivalence of the cit? dwellers matches ?official? France?s
attitude toward them: over-control and interference, alternating
with utter abandonment. Bureaucrats have planned every item in the
physical environment, for example, and no matter how many times the
inhabitants foul the nest (to use the Afrikaner?s expression), the
state pays for renovation, hoping thereby to demonstrate its
compassion and concern. To assure the immigrants that they and their
offspring are potentially or already truly French, the streets are
named for French cultural heroes: for painters in Les Tarterets (rue
Gustave Courbet, for example) and for composers in Les Musiciens
(rue Gabriel Faur?). Indeed, the only time I smiled in one of the
cit?s was when I walked past two concrete bunkers with metal
windows, the ?cole maternelle Charles Baudelaire and the ?cole
maternelle Arthur Rimbaud. Fine as these two poets are, theirs are
not names one would associate with kindergartens, let alone with
concrete bunkers.

But the heroic French names point to a deeper official ambivalence.
The French state is torn between two approaches: Courbet, Faur?, nos
anc?tres, les gaullois, on the one hand, and the shibboleths of
multiculturalism on the other. By compulsion of the ministry of
education, the historiography that the schools purvey is that of the
triumph of the unifying, rational, and benevolent French state
through the ages, from Colbert onward, and Muslim girls are not
allowed to wear headscarves in schools. After graduation, people who
dress in ?ethnic? fashion will not find jobs with major employers.
But at the same time, official France also pays a cowering lip
service to multiculturalism?for example, to the ?culture? of the
cit?s. Thus, French rap music is the subject of admiring articles in
Lib?ration and Le Monde, as well as of pusillanimous expressions of
approval from the last two ministers of culture.

One rap group, the Minist?re amer (Bitter Ministry), won special
official praise. Its best-known lyric: ?Another woman takes her
beating./ This time she?s called Brigitte./ She?s the wife of a
cop./ The novices of vice piss on the police./ It?s not just a
firework, scratch the clitoris./ Brigitte the cop?s wife likes
niggers./ She?s hot, hot in her pants.? This vile rubbish receives
accolades for its supposed authenticity: for in the
multiculturalist?s mental world, in which the savages are forever
noble, there is no criterion by which to distinguish high art from
low trash. And if intellectuals, highly trained in the Western
tradition, are prepared to praise such degraded and brutal
pornography, it is hardly surprising that those who are not so
trained come to the conclusion that there cannot be anything of
value in that tradition. Cowardly multiculturalism thus makes itself
the handmaiden of anti-Western extremism.

Whether or not rap lyrics are the authentic voice of the cit?s, they
are certainly its authentic ear: you can observe many young men in
the cit?s sitting around in their cars aimlessly, listening to it
for hours on end, so loud that the pavement vibrates to it 100 yards
away. The imprimatur of the intellectuals and of the French cultural
bureaucracy no doubt encourages them to believe that they are doing
something worthwhile. But when life begins to imitate art, and
terrible gang-rapes occur with increasing frequency, the same
official France becomes puzzled and alarmed. What should it make of
the 18 young men and two young women currently being tried in
Pontoise for allegedly abducting a girl of 15 and for four months
raping her repeatedly in basements, stairwells, and squats? Many of
the group seem not merely unrepentant or unashamed but proud.

Though most people in France have never visited a cit?, they dimly
know that long-term unemployment among the young is so rife there
that it is the normal state of being. Indeed, French youth
unemployment is among the highest in Europe?and higher the further
you descend the social scale, largely because high minimum wages,
payroll taxes, and labor protection laws make employers loath to
hire those whom they cannot easily fire, and whom they must pay
beyond what their skills are worth.

Everyone acknowledges that unemployment, particularly of the
permanent kind, is deeply destructive, and that the devil really
does find work for idle hands; but the higher up the social scale
you ascend, the more firmly fixed is the idea that the labor-market
rigidities that encourage unemployment are essential both to
distinguish France from the supposed savagery of the Anglo-Saxon
neo-liberal model (one soon learns from reading the French
newspapers what anglo-saxon connotes in this context), and to
protect the downtrodden from exploitation. But the labor-market
rigidities protect those who least need protection, while condemning
the most vulnerable to utter hopelessness: and if sexual hypocrisy
is the vice of the Anglo-Saxons, economic hypocrisy is the vice of
the French.

It requires little imagination to see how, in the circumstances, the
burden of unemployment should fall disproportionately on immigrants
and their children: and why, already culturally distinct from the
bulk of the population, they should feel themselves vilely
discriminated against. Having been enclosed in a physical ghetto,
they respond by building a cultural and psychological ghetto for
themselves. They are of France, but not French.

The state, while concerning itself with the details of their
housing, their education, their medical care, and the payment of
subsidies for them to do nothing, abrogates its responsibility
completely in the one area in which the state?s responsibility is
absolutely inalienable: law and order. In order to placate, or at
least not to inflame, disaffected youth, the ministry of the
interior has instructed the police to tread softly (that is to say,
virtually not at all, except by occasional raiding parties when
inaction is impossible) in the more than 800 zones
sensibles?sensitive areas?that surround French cities and that are
known collectively as la Zone.

But human society, like nature, abhors a vacuum, and so authority of
a kind, with its own set of values, occupies the space where law and
order should be?the authority and brutal values of psychopathic
criminals and drug dealers. The absence of a real economy and of law
means, in practice, an economy and an informal legal system based on
theft and drug-trafficking. In Les Tarterets, for example, I
observed two dealers openly distributing drugs and collecting money
while driving around in their highly conspicuous BMW convertible,
clearly the monarchs of all they surveyed. Both of northwest African
descent, one wore a scarlet baseball cap backward, while the other
had dyed blond hair, contrasting dramatically with his complexion.
Their faces were as immobile as those of potentates receiving
tribute from conquered tribes. They drove everywhere at maximum
speed in low gear and high noise: they could hardly have drawn more
attention to themselves if they tried. They didn?t fear the law:
rather, the law feared them.

I watched their proceedings in the company of old immigrants from
Algeria and Morocco, who had come to France in the early 1960s. They
too lived in Les Tarterets and had witnessed its descent into a
state of low-level insurgency. They were so horrified by daily life
that they were trying to leave, to escape their own children and
grandchildren: but once having fallen into the clutches of the
system of public housing, they were trapped. They wanted to transfer
to a cit?, if such existed, where the new generation did not rule:
but they were without leverage?or piston?in the giant system of
patronage that is the French state. And so they had to stay put,
puzzled, alarmed, incredulous, and bitter at what their own
offspring had become, so very different from what they had hoped and
expected. They were better Frenchmen than either their children or
grandchildren: they would never have whistled and booed at the
Marseillaise, as their descendants did before the soccer match
between France and Algeria in 2001, alerting the rest of France to
the terrible canker in its midst.

Whether France was wise to have permitted the mass immigration of
people culturally very different from its own population to solve a
temporary labor shortage and to assuage its own abstract liberal
conscience is disputable: there are now an estimated 8 or 9 million
people of North and West African origin in France, twice the number
in 1975?and at least 5 million of them are Muslims. Demographic
projections (though projections are not predictions) suggest that
their descendants will number 35 million before this century is out,
more than a third of the likely total population of France.

Indisputably, however, France has handled the resultant situation in
the worst possible way. Unless it assimilates these millions
successfully, its future will be grim. But it has separated and
isolated immigrants and their descendants geographically into
dehumanizing ghettos; it has pursued economic policies to promote
unemployment and create dependence among them, with all the
inevitable psychological consequences; it has flattered the
repellent and worthless culture that they have developed; and it has
withdrawn the protection of the law from them, allowing them to
create their own lawless order.

No one should underestimate the danger that this failure poses, not
only for France but also for the world. The inhabitants of the cit?s
are exceptionally well armed. When the professional robbers among
them raid a bank or an armored car delivering cash, they do so with
bazookas and rocket launchers, and dress in paramilitary uniforms.
From time to time, the police discover whole arsenals of
Kalashnikovs in the cit?s. There is a vigorous informal trade
between France and post-communist Eastern Europe: workshops in
underground garages in the cit?s change the serial numbers of stolen
luxury cars prior to export to the East, in exchange for
sophisticated weaponry.

A profoundly alienated population is thus armed with serious
firepower; and in conditions of violent social upheaval, such as
France is in the habit of experiencing every few decades, it could
prove difficult to control. The French state is caught in a dilemma
between honoring its commitments to the more privileged section of
the population, many of whom earn their livelihoods from
administering the dirigiste economy, and freeing the labor market
sufficiently to give the hope of a normal life to the inhabitants of
the cit?s. Most likely, the state will solve the dilemma by attempts
to buy off the disaffected with more benefits and rights, at the
cost of higher taxes that will further stifle the job creation that
would most help the cit? dwellers. If that fails, as in the long run
it will, harsh repression will follow.

But among the third of the population of the cit?s that is of North
African Muslim descent, there is an option that the French, and not
only the French, fear. For imagine yourself a youth in Les Tarterets
or Les Musiciens, intellectually alert but not well educated,
believing yourself to be despised because of your origins by the
larger society that you were born into, permanently condemned to
unemployment by the system that contemptuously feeds and clothes
you, and surrounded by a contemptible nihilistic culture of despair,
violence, and crime. Is it not possible that you would seek a
doctrine that would simultaneously explain your predicament, justify
your wrath, point the way toward your revenge, and guarantee your
salvation, especially if you were imprisoned? Would you not seek a
?worthwhile? direction for the energy, hatred, and violence seething
within you, a direction that would enable you to do evil in the name
of ultimate good? It would require only a relatively few of like
mind to cause havoc. Islamist proselytism flourishes in the prisons
of France (where 60 percent of the inmates are of immigrant origin),
as it does in British prisons; and it takes only a handful of
Zacharias Moussaouis to start a conflagration.

The French knew of this possibility well before September 11: in
1994, their special forces boarded a hijacked aircraft that landed
in Marseilles and killed the hijackers?an unusual step for the
French, who have traditionally preferred to negotiate with, or give
in to, terrorists. But they had intelligence suggesting that, after
refueling, the hijackers planned to fly the plane into the Eiffel
Tower. In this case, no negotiation was possible.

A terrible chasm has opened up in French society, dramatically
exemplified by a story that an acquaintance told me. He was driving
along a six-lane highway with housing projects on both sides, when a
man tried to dash across the road. My acquaintance hit him at high
speed and killed him instantly.

According to French law, the participants in a fatal accident must
stay as near as possible to the scene, until officials have
elucidated all the circumstances. The police therefore took my
informant to a kind of hotel nearby, where there was no staff, and
the door could be opened only by inserting a credit card into an
automatic billing terminal. Reaching his room, he discovered that
all the furniture was of concrete, including the bed and washbasin,
and attached either to the floor or walls.

The following morning, the police came to collect him, and he asked
them what kind of place this was. Why was everything made of
concrete?

?But don?t you know where you are, monsieur?? they asked. ?C?est la
Zone, c?est la Zone.?

La Zone is a foreign country: they do things differently there.

[b][i][u]La Zone is France and I am hard pressed to think of any other nation which more deserves its fate[/u][/i]

Dawg[/b] ]:)

by absolutely

to know that one subject of knowledge isn't good enough. I thought that was already obvious.

Tee Hee: "Nothing to do with the schools, it's the students being intelligent enough to know they can't compete cost wise with a chap from a country where 800 monopoly dollars a month is a top salary."

In terms of hourly wage, no, we don't want to compete. But in terms of ROI, we can still do very well, by being more versatile. Alternatively, we could unionize, or agitate like hippies for better work benefits, etc., and send all the jobs away real fast.

by tony hopkinson

I think the move to outsource / contract out is suicide for a business, economy and a country.

Not to mention it being highly offensive to my socialist principles.

All it's doing, is selling long term sustainability for a short term profit. That sort of thing is for dumbasses.

It's why you never put a bean counter in charge of anything, they can't see past period end and they judge success by only one number in the bottom right hand corner of the spreadsheet.

Not sure you should puts techs in charge of anything either. I'm thinking Nuns, they are long term people.

by amcol

So what's your suggestion? Should we all just blame everyone other than ourselves every time something happens, in a continuing desperate quest to avoid even the hint that we might personally have some responsibility for outcomes?

You think we're being optimistic, but we're actually being entirely realistic. I'm not happy because I hide my head in the sand and pretend everything's peachy keen. I'm happy because I have control over my life, because I know that what doesn't kill me makes me stronger.

Let me tell you something, sonny. Between me and Max we have well over 100 years of life, somewhere north of 70 years of combined professional experience. Before you refer to anyone as "blissfully clueless" be ready to demonstrate exactly how it is that you're able to walk on water without getting wet. Max knows exactly what he's talking about and he's making perfectly good sense, whether or not you agree with him. What have you offered to the discourse?

by tony hopkinson

The people managing public service are crap. They get paid about half the salary in an equivalent position in private industry.
They get killed on contract/project management on a regular basis.

One of my 'favourite' ones was a project to have all people on benefit use a smartcard to claim and get their benefits in order to reduce fraud. They set off on the usual study ...

Some years later project cancelled as unworkable after a spend of over ?800,000,000 of tax payers money.

What the hell did they spend that on ? I just can't get my head round it.

Others are are as bad

http://www.guardian.co.uk/welfare/article/0,,355748,00.html

Actually our labour laws are still 'weaker' than mainland europes (western), but our labour practices at top firms are much more beneficial than UK regulations mandate.

Course the sort of thing we find acceptable would drive a right thinking american into looking under his bed for people with fur hats on.

Equally us brits think you are stark raving mad to tolerate the conditions you work under. We'd be marching down from Jarrow and knocking policemans helmets off in short order.

As far as I'm aware cost of labour in the US is much lower than the EUs, but you seem to be getting hammered by outsourcing much more than we are.

Heretical thought, maybe those things go hand in hand.

Can you see a statutory minimum wage, 'free' health care, enforced employer pension contributions and twenty days plus bank holidays also statutory, solving the outsourcing 'problem'.
LOL

Our cost of living is of course also much higher than yours. Tanstaffl is a universal.

by ebeck

I thought this was an April fools post... I didn't really believe one would post such a pointless and clueless response.

This discussion is closed to new replies.