Discussion Locked

I don't like the new TechRepublic Look

0 helpful
51 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I hate this new TechRepublic look 'n feel... I'm gonna quit. NE1 want my 4500 points! I'm gonna give it away free to the first response and never sign on again.

51 replies

by khillabolt

You don't like the new look'n feel? I must disagree; I think the new site is sweet. Not only is there the wealth of info, but it looks visually appealing too...

Sorry to hear your dissatisfaction. Have you by chance seen Earthweb's new site (www.developer.com)? Now that's awful!

My 2cents.

by ebob

I suppose there are only so many ways to wedge some content into a site. The vertical ad banners on both sites' left and right margins are rather distracting. Thank goodness for "tunnel vision".

by syscokid

I don't mind the look and feel so much as the fact that Technical Q&A, where I spend most of my time, is worse than before, and when you ask Tech Support questions, all you get is an autoreply. I've ben waiting over a week for an answer to a question. But I'll take the points, if you want to post a question in the NT section.

by vanderlay

The Technical Q&A is a place where you pose questions to your peers and hope they answer the question. You are not guaranteed to get an answer. Hope that helps!

Please be more specfic when complaining about something. When you say it is worse than before, in what way?

by syscokid

Things I've mailed TR about:

In Q&A, there's a box to check to send email notification when your answer is rated. It's unchecked. It shoule be checked by default.

There's a choice to subscribe to thread. To see followups posted to a question, you have to click that. If you've answered the question and elected to be notified when your answer is rated, that should also subscribe you to the question. The choice to subscribe should be for when you don't post an answer but still want to follow the thread.

There's no selection for "View all open questions" like there used to be. Now I have to go from topic to topic again.

Things I haven't asked them yet:

The My Questions section shows questions I've answered, but only 20, notall, and in an apparently random order.

I don't always get notifications when my answer has been rated, despite checking that darn box.

There, I feel better now! :-)

by jmce

I never saw the previous version, but this site is seriously slow. I'm sure its all cross-browser friendly and it does have a lot of usful information, but speed is important. I feel grayer already.

by Member 21361443

I'm more than happy to tell you what's wrong with the technical Q&A - 2 major items, then maybe a few pet peeves. 1: No line breaks or carriage returns in the replies. No formatting options at all, but if I could have just carriage returns, I would be happy. 2: You can't open two questions at a time! If you try to open two questions, one after the other, then try to POST AN ANSWER to the first one, the post goes to the second question you opened! Yuck! If they would fix those two problems,I would be very happy. I don't like the new layout of the Technical Q&A entry screen, but I love that you can open just the questions waiting for answers. Anyone able to fix #1 and #2 of the problems?

Brian Lusk

by vanderlay

Why don't you offer some constructive criticism of the site. What do you dislike? What did you like about the old site? What features are missing? To often people complain about something but do nothing to fix it! It is a community-based web site. YOU CAN influence what goes on here! Hope you don't leave just because you don't like the color.

by Member 21361443

Vanderlay, I tried sending a comment to the editor about the problems in the Technical Q&A. All I got back was an automated response. But, it isn't the color, it's the function. If you go up and see my previous post, you will understand what I mean. I'm technical at heart, so I love designs that work. I don't love a design that doesn't work. Try leaving a space between paragraphs, so your post is more readable.

I've even tried
tags and

tags to see if I could use them! Don't get me wrong, I love techrepublic. It is the only site I log on to EVERY day. It has so much great material that I can glean information from. My gripe is not on the overall design, it is technical. (Again, see my previous post for details).

Brian Lusk

by Member 21361443

I stand corrected, BR and P tags (which explain the holes in the previous post) work in the discussion areas, but not in the Technical Q&A section. Why? I haven't figured that out.

Brian Lusk

by t. e. walker

In discussions, your "place" is kept - how the heck do you post at top level if you've read even one posting? Not covered in the FAQs.

by davidandgoliath

...clicking on the thread title in the tree at the bottom of the page to make it the active message, then click Post A Reply. So click on the top-level thread if that's what you want to reply to and it will be active. Then your reply will be attached to it.

by admin

It may be the location that is confusing you.... In the original article it's at the top right, near "printer friendly", I believe.

by Member 21361443

It appears that the TechRepublic people did indeed listen. Today is the first day I have been able to find properly formatted posts in both the Discussion Forums AND the Technical Q&A forums.

For those of you who desired it, here is the sound ofme eating my own complaints!

*Chomp chomp chomp chomp munch munch gag gag gag cough cough!*

TechRepublic, I thank you for eliminating a serious annoyance! My deepest apologies for doubting you were listening.

Brian Lusk

by white wolf

And that's a option in the Q&A sections like their article section - to be able to punch the printer friendly button and print the question and it's answers neatly. I don't know how many times some user asks me for details on something and I remember coming accross something in the Q&A the fits it perfectly and wishing I could print out a nicely formated copy of it to hand to these users. (rather than having to cut & paste it).

by mishratron

cut and paste and quit whinning
eat your beans and go to bed.

come on you are one of the elite and your crying about printer friendly ?
that sounds like a luser complaint.
cut and past and forget about it, heck in cut and past you can EMAIL them a copy
Chad

btw you can also alt+prtscr
ctrl+v

by boonchung

I do admit there's room for improvement. But techrepublic is unable to please all its members all the time. This is no logical. Why don't you get used to it? Be patient, good things comes to those who wait.

by krystian

Consider the purely visual changes of TechRepublic. Every time I visited the old site one thing stood out, and jumped to my eyes, the color red :) I'm glad the new site broke away from that comi look, now it looks less totalitarian and more pleasantto the eye. Now it is far easier to deal with all the technical incompetencies you might find when your eyes aren't bombarded with screaming colors :) The new look is cool and blue, now I can read without going blind.

by d'anno

Must admit it is still hard finding the discussion 'groups' I was used to posting in and replying too.

by greg.ahler

It used to take me a full 3 minutes to get the main page to open. I can now get my opening page in less than 10 seconds. THAT ALONE is worth the aggravation of the change in appearance. As far as that goes, I like the look, too!

by davidandgoliath

If you are talking about the partnership that TechRepublic has with FatBrain, you access it throught the 'Partners' link at the bottom of the page. I agree that it is not *nearly* as obvious as when it was in the left navigational area. It was probably moved to reduce clutter in the left nav.

by almo

I really like the new techrepublic design. It is brighter (black no longer dominates), the font size was reduced (but you stil can read it!). And the content: as good as before.
For the last reason I even considered joining TechProGuild. But here is my (small) complaint: I never could manage to change my temporary password through the new site so that it works from home and work.
I think TechRepublic is a great service. If you ever think about a new content section what about OO/Java or developers?
Kind regards to all of you!

by davidandgoliath

Make sure you are logging in using the same email address from both places. You should be able to click the 'Edit My Account' link from the home page, the 'Change Password'. The site has no way of knowing whether you are logging in from home or work so it should function the same from anywhere. Hope this helps.

by its a secret

The previous version, for some reason was very slow loading. This version seems much faster to me. I enjoy the new layout as well.

by admin

I don't seem to be having all these problems you guys are above. This is sure a hot article thread though! ;>

by generalist

Could there be a remote chance that things have changed in the last nine months or so? A lot of the postings have a 2000 date...

by swetbak

What the heck is up with the recent interest, at least for one person, in such an old thread?
By the way, I've forgotten what the old-look looked like, but I do remember an decrease in the page load time, which was nice.

by ebob

So he did not sign off and "never come back". Looks like he kept his 4500 points too.

Good for you Taupao!

by generalist

With a 5-15-01 entry on the question and answer side of things it does look like T Chieng is still around.

But is the person aware that a nine-month old discussion posting is now a 'hot topic'?

It just goes to show that an automated process can yield some interesting results. (At least I don't think that the TechRepublic changes qualify as a hot topic today, at least from a topical point of view. Now from a 'number of response' viewpoint...

by epepke

he's making fun of the fact that this is presented by the software as a Hot Article and possibly also the tendency toward amnesia expressed in other threads recently.

by generalist

A good point about the amnesia...

The multiple postings also demonstrate how you can 'goose' a thread to move it up in the rankings. I believe that a person mentioned this ability in a different discussion and demonstrated it by posting six or more entries designed to start people talking.

Of course, we are contributing to the problem. Just think of the number of people that may think TechRepublic is going through another design change. (The sky is falling. The sky is falling.)

by ebob

... of the house. And then "admin@l33tcentral.com" opens up this old-ish (8/22/00 or 2000/08/22 for the 'real' geeks) thread.

I wonder if Taupoa knows this open? I wonder if I care? Not likely. Hmmm.

by admin

It wouldn't remain a "Hot Topic"

I was actually surprised it worked at all just by my own numerous postings. I never expected others to pick this topic up.

I had seen a trend here of reviving old postings into the hot topic area, so to experiment, I picked a really obscure one that I thought would be safe from annoying people with , since I figured no one would actually reply to this one, and at most it would last 2-3 hours.

I'm actually interested in how this social phenomena called TR discussion works. Points, Blue Squares etc.

But thanks a lot for thinking for me, I guess I'll be picked last in the TR softball tourney now, eh? :)

by generalist

I'd say that your actions, combined with the rest of us, works quite well as an experiment testing social phenomena and software code.

By making numerous posts, you convinced the software that it was indeed a hot topic. By making it a hot topic,you got the attention of several people.

Some of those people noticed that the 'hot topic' wasn't exactly hot. Others might have missed the point.

From what I've observed, a 'hot topic' remains on the list for a couple of days if there are a lot of posts in a short time. And if free-style thinkers like us see such things, we'll reply just to stir things up and get people to use the stuff they have between the ears.

Now, is there anybody out there wanting to do a sociological study ondiscussion boards?

This discussion is closed to new replies.