I Just Want to Program! Don't Make Me Learn Math!
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by rmcnaught
If the average person is pretty stupid, then (nearly) half the population are even worse!
MathMan
by iteration84
That's pretty disheartening... I'm sure its true. All we need for proof really is simply this: watch an hour or two or TV a day :)
Edit: Man... I just thought about what you said a little bit more. Where will that put the world in another century? What type of state will it be in? I mean, if its this bad now, and our future is truly in the hands of our children (who are being widely under -educated), I'd say we're easily on the fast- track to a dystopian future. Maybe not in some of our lifetimes, but it is certainly possible within the next couple centuries I believe. Look at the shape the world is in now. I believe we can save it, but one of the answers is most certainly bringing our educational standards up and actually teaching at that level, then work on other things. Sad though.. I don't see it happening any time soon.
by daveo2000
I had my kids were in a "Charter" school out here for a while thinking that they would get a progressive education. Big mistake. My older kid was in 4th and younger in 2nd. Both were complaining about being bored. The 2nd grader brought home a "math" problem page for homework that was all single digit addition of "x + 4" type. No, they weren't using variables, they had 100 problems on the page and all were any of 0 through 9 added to 4. The 4th grade teacher one day told me that they had finally found he spelling book so he had 3 weeks of assignments to catch up on. They had never bothered to tell me that he was missing anything!
They are both now in a private school even though we have to cut expenses to afford it.
I realize that not all public schools suck but, good grief, I never realized how much some of them can!
by absolutely
[i]All we need for proof really is simply this: watch an hour or two or TV a day[/i]
There is cause for hope: At the rate that the quality of programming is deteriorating, soon even the most lethargic people will be too disgusted by what they see to continue wasting time on television.
by absolutely
by daveo2000
Throughout this thread I have been trying to think of when I have ever needed calculus in a programming task. I can't explicitly think of one.
Oddly, it wasn't until deepsand mentioned sliderules that I remembered how sine waves had been useful (ok, the connection is tenuous, but the thought train got me there).
I can see how my [b]basic[/b] understanding of calculus may have formed my thinking and caused it to flow differently over the surface of a problem to lead me to alternative solutions. That doesn't mean that I [i]needed[/i] calculus to get where I am, just that it has most likely helped me.
That said, those concepts go a long way in helping turn physical models into coded models since most physical models do require abstract mathematical descriptions to work their way into a computer.
I still disagree with Benito's apparent assertion that coders are never programmers and you can't be a programmer unless you know higher math. I apologize for the arrogance of this next statement; but, we will always need the lower paid programmers to build the GUIs and connective glue-code for the more interesting stuff that [i]does[/i] require the higher math background.
by daveo2000
Reminds me of the geek joke:
There are 10 types of people in the world. Those that understand binary and those that don't.
by daveo2000
I took typing in high school because a beautiful brunette was in the same class. I didn't get very far with her but the typing skills have been incredibly useful. :)
I have also found the understanding of language grammar and syntax to be very useful in working with parsers and developing languages, even simple ones.
If you ever want to really stretch your brain, try writing the input to yacc to parse common English (current British or American. Both are screwed up!).
That is just for the programming side. Now try communicating your ideas to either a client (who will use Business idiom) or another programmer (who may be in a different country and learned a different dialect of English)!
Walter Cronkite English rules! Learn it and learn it well!
(Edited because I am not perfect.)
by hmmmmm!
My "code" days go back to something called a IBM 2500, patch boards, 16 "drives", slave printers and such.. early 1970's. I since then have kept current but do not cut code of program, etc..Let others do that in various programs I ran.. NOTE "Programs" as in HW and such as I had the budgets and schedules.
I am still mildly amused at when the SW folks come in and brag.. "We got it to run"... before during or after crashes, start up, etc as that is what they were paid to do,.. as they are not on a journey of discovery.. which they sometimes forgot.'
But way back dealt with data that had actual VALUES of ZERO.. and the more math we had, them less things crashed when "ZERO plus say plus five added and result was 2.5 not zero plus any nr is zero.. and such things.
Same today.. the better program types have a good math understanding..and background. I have seen time after time.. "well we just imported that routine and we finally found the issue was a fault in sub-routines, etc. I have a friend in IT in money area and he shudders at what he hears from non-math types as they can only speak IT, not math or stat or such. Given druthers I will take the well "mathed" type every time, as I feel the others simply dodged the hard stuff.. there are code cutters and there are programmers...and there are very good IT types...I simply worry when I find no strong math....and I do not mean to insult..but no math and do not want any is kind of doing but not really knowing.. an assembly of routines..not a knowledge of functions..
by iteration84
by dbenito
I was talking about this with a physicist friend, and we both reached the same conclusion: even though you are not exactly likely to need calculus when reasoning about programming (in the same way you're not likely to need trigonometry or geometry), there are a number of concepts you normally study as part of calculus that do have a lot more to do with programming. As part of any basic analysis course, one studies concepts like functions, series, convergence and limits, all of which can come in handy when understanding or writing new algorithms.
(I wouldn't particularly call that higher mathematics, though, since in many places it is something that is taught in high school.)
I still stand by my previous assertion: programming is not the same as simply writing code, and a good programmer needs a number of mathematical tools (though, again, not calculus) to program efficiently. I also think the programming world would benefit enormously if the people who you think can get along being mere coders were actually skilled programmers - I believe software in general would be of a consistently higher quality.
by deepsand
of the problem. What if in reality a line is not infinitely divisible.
ie space is discrete, the granularity being so fine that treating it as infinite in a mathematical model results in an effective approximation.
One of the biggest problems in physics is relating the discrete and therefore finite quantities in Quantum Mechanics to the Rieman based geometries of relativity.
At the moments it's done with a set of mathematical transformations that can only be justified by their result. It's right because it works, (incredibly well I might add), but we have no mathematically rigourously provable theory as to why.
There's a strong feeling amongst physicists that it's applying the math based on continuity that's causing the problem.
If a line is not infinitely divisible then calculus is an abtruse piece of mathematics with no foundation in the real world.
Public schools in the UK are judged in league tables.
Number of passes has become more important than what the pass means.
I mean why would you pay taxes or private tuition for a school where the pupils consistently failed.
Option 1 Choose students that will pass
Option 2 Teach students so they can pass
Option 3 Make course easier so students will pass.
Option 3 is the most popular option, not just in Maths either.
by dbenito
(Actually, non-Euclidian geometry is not a problem at all! Neither is the continuity or discreteness of spacetime.)
The point is that, by definition, a line is infinitely divisible. What you call a line in "reality" is an approximation to the Platonic ideal which mathematics deals with. Whether the physical line is infinitely divisible or not does not make calculus wrong.
Let me put it another way: mathematics is NOT an empirical science, where we need to conduct experiments to check whether our theories correspond to reality. On the other hand, physics is not and can never be mathematically rigorous; the theories we construct are only models that can be disproved by experiment.
I showed your post to a physicist friend of mine, and he couldn't quite understand exactly what you were referring to. At large scales, discrete systems exhibit continuum-like behavior (which is why calculus can be applied to physics, economics, etc.).
Obviously, if you go down to scales where the discreteness of spacetime becomes apparent, techniques meant for continuous pseudo-Riemannian manifolds are going to give weird results. Then again, M-theorists have bigger problems, such as background dependece, or the fact that they cannot even come up with a testable or falsifiable theory. But don't blame the maths, blame Edward Witten ;-)
I really begin to wonder why you are going to such lengths to discredit calculus...
by mikeholli
by iteration84
My daughters GCSE math paper, I could have passed at age 11, and maxed it 13.
She would have had to take an A level to get passed the one I had at her age.
That would have been without a calculator too.
Pen and my trusty book of log tables.
by absolutely
I meant 'the limit of [b]f(x)[/b] as x approaches zero. Please, Leibniz forgive me!
:p
by daveo2000
The term "programmer" applies to more fields than just computers. A programmer is simply somebody that programs things. I think you might want to add an adjective to the word for your chosen limits.
We apparently agree that one should have a more advanced knowledge of mathematics to have interesting prospects in "programming" and I think that this is the real crux of the thread. The degree of that advanced knowledge is subject to debate.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by absolutely
Would you [b]object[/b] to the existence of classes, for aspiring programmers whose interests do not call for it, which allow varying mathematics requirements to match their career intentions? For example, apotheon notes that for his degree, calculus was formally required, but not pragmatically necessary. I have no such objections to any of the major requirements of my education, but I have similar feelings about general education requirements, so I can relate to the sentiment. And, I have no interest in [u]forcing[/u] people to learn subjects that don't interest them.
Thanks for your opinions,
by iteration84
by absolutely
by deepsand
However, students, by virtue of having neither a sufficiently broad base of experiences nor a prescience sufficent for determining their future needs, are not sufficiently qualified for determining what knowledge is requisite and what is not.
Even if one is certain that he will employed as a programmer, he cannot know what type of applications he will be called upon to develop, and cannot therefore know which particular mathematical skills will be needed.
where I need eugenvalues, lebesque integrals, and calculus.
Now there's something to look forward to. :D
by daveo2000
It is so rare that one ends up performing the jobs that one is specifically trained for.
I hear so often about how somebody has ended up in one field when they studied something completely different in university. Getting a broader background whilst in the innocent days of high school (or equivalent) doesn't strike me as such a loss.
Not only that, but how many people do you know that were studying a particular career track because their parents thought it was what they [i]should[/i] be studying? Maybe the people that chose the requirements realized that parents would influence their kids to take specific electives and steer them away from others "in their own interest".
It is a hard call in such a mass-production oriented education system.
by apotheon
by wayne m.
There are multiple paths towards developing analysis skills and I am not convinced that mathematics provides the best alternative.
Requirements analysis lives in the world of human ambiguities, contradictions, rules and exceptions. These things are not handled well in mathematics, outside of specialized areas such as probability and fuzzy logic. These analysis skills are better honed through language such as doing analysis in a good literature course.
Set theory is an interesting proposal, because the set-like objects in programming do not map particularly well in mathematical sets. An inner join is a straight-forward concept easily understood by developers working with databases. It is quite complex to represent this based upon sets. The inner join provides an intersection based upon keys, a union based upon columns, and a relationship (1 to 1, 1 to N, M to N) among elements. I can't see how understanding sets provides enlightenment concerning database operations.
Concerning algorithm development, software is the act of automating manual activities. Software developers implement algorithms; this allows the implementation to be validated. Are there algorithms created by programmers? An algorithm to generate user recommended pages might be an example. Is the result of the algorithm valid? That is simply unknowable.
I am assuming that the reference to "RAD" actually is in regard to the practice of iterative development. Iterative development is actually based upon the engineering concept of feedback and successive approximation. Feedback loops are difficult to handle mathematics and usually avoided. The ability to track and reproduce a highly unpredictable input stream is a wonderful model for software development, but one that is not going to come out of the study of mathematics.
Is the study of mathematics a good thing in general? Yes, though I would put statistics at the top of the list. Mathematics, however, is not fundamental to software development, nor does it provide any unique insights.
by absolutely
by wayne m.
There are 10 kinds of people in the world, those who understand binary and those who don't.
[I just saw this in a letter to the editor of the May 7, 2007 Computer World by Mark Everhart].
Calculus was a stroke of genius. I merely wished to back up what Apotheon said in that it is guestimation, when applied to real world problems.
All engineering is a guess, good engineering a good guess.
Also it would seem we are all agreed that the actual process on integration or differentiation is of limited value to developers, we are more likely to use the results of it. Yet maths courses to back up computer science, spend a lot of time in it and correspondingly less of math we are much much more likely to apply.
Compared to set theory, groups, boolean algebra, iteration....
by iteration84
by absolutely
by apotheon
I think part of the reason so many people find education distasteful is that they're being "forced" to learn what someone else wants them to learn rather than what interests them. I know that I'd probably have taken a hell of a lot more math in college if I hadn't been "forced" to learn Calculus as the One True Math. Similarly, the ludicrous general ed requirements are absurdly restrictive -- like that asinine "interpersonal communication" class I ended up taking as the alternative to a speech class. I thought speech would be a stupid class. Silly me: "interpersonal communication" wasn't what its dry, formal-sounding name implied. It was all about how being touchy-feely and having exactly the same opinions about how people should interact as the teacher would bring about world peace.
Holy mudder o' gob, that was a complete waste of my time.
by warrenpeas
I guess the rest of this sub-thread shows the futility of using shop math to supplant things like vector analysis.
Perhaps that should be the lesson an aspiring CompSci should take away from this discussion.
by deepsand
I've a friend who is a teacher in a rural area that has long been economically depressed. Most of the families in the school district are poorly educated, unemployed or underemployed, with a sufficant portion being on the dole.
Parents here are so unable to grasp the value of education, and therefore see it to be of little to no value to their children. They are so convinced that it is inevitable that their children will fare no better than they, that they [u]actively[/u] resist they efforts of teachers there to do anything that they the parents perceive as threatening the ability of their children to continue to be eligible for public welfare.
by hmmmmm!
You hit it dead center.. WE are the customers and we (the public-parents) establish the product. Most no longer really care, perhaps 25% on a good day. others, well try and gut a sports program verse a science lab and see what really incurs the wrath of the "parents".
NONE seem to upset that fully 1/3 no drop out of HS. and most college grads are very poorly educated.. in general areas, some even wonder about how well the major is done. I think I read where somewhere around 60% of college grads cannot do basic percentages, much less understand loan and credit card interest, and even less can compute APR's.. NONE wish to discuss what happens and whom pays for the 1 MILLION/YEAR HS dropouts.. as they are now a burden on society as pretty much must compete at the very lowest end jobs..
I am sorry to see it and say it.. but the education system is not failing.. as you said it seems it's customers are not very demanding... they set on butts and blame the system... and when I read of those that feel math is not needed for their "major".. any MAJOR.. it is no longer surprising that min payment on maxed out credit card is the standard... not the exception'
USA is dumbing down fast... as it seems all feel they will be the next "Idol" or NBA, AFL or AM league star.. etc. To out it in terms they can understand "NOT". Yes, we do not need math, or history or economics or other such "stuff", even at into or basic levels.. we will just make the min payments.
by absolutely
May be I'll get a job one day where I [b]get to apply what I intentionally learned[/b] about eigenvalues, lebesque integrals, and calculus.
Now there's something to look forward to. Enjoy your self-imposed ignorance.
by deepsand
by apotheon
Of course, the reason that a good craftsman fits that description is simple:
A good craftsman is someone who chose a craft he enjoys. A bad craftsman is often the result of being railroaded into a related, but far less enjoyable (to him), craft because it's as close as he could get to what he actually wanted to do.
Not sure where that came from, or why.
Self imposed ignorance, that's well funny, considering the only reason I know anything about them was completely voluntary on my part.
by wayne m.
If you want to join the ranks of the true programmer, you will need to study high level mathematics and every other bit of arcane knowledge available on the off chance you might need it somewhere at sometime to do something.
As it is, I am afraid you will have to join me and the other gibbering masses as we sit drooling at our keyboards yet somehow create programs that actually work without integrating or taking a derivative.
by absolutely
So, what do you [b]do[/b] about it?
"I [b]wish[/b] people would bring the real world back into education and tell a student in no uncertain terms when they stuff up."
I wish I had Microsoft's cash flow. What of it? You [b]people[/b] who have the right to vote, yet blame the government you elect, disgust me.
by deepsand
be they those of a calculator, a spreadsheet, or any computer printed output. For them, the mere presence of more numbers following a decimal point connotes great accuracy.
And then, when they see a column of numbers whose values should, for example, total 100%, they're baffled to see the total showing as 99.99%.
by deepsand
by absolutely
I learned long ago not to expose either to the sun for long, thus they are not at all tan!
:^0
by deepsand
by deepsand
by deepsand
is an opportunity, to expand them.
One I've always looked forward to.
by deepsand
by wayne m.
by absolutely
by deepsand
by daveo2000
I had a friend in high school who was a stoner. He was because he couldn't take the boredom. He was incredibly intelligent and would have probably committed suicide if he didn't get high. Instead, he devoted his time to creative ways to avoid boredom.
We had an electronics teacher that taught as if everyone of his students wanted to be either an antenna installation specialist or a TV repairman. I had thought of going into electrical engineering until that class.
My friend was equally bored in that class and found a way to entertain himself. When the teacher got especially boring, this guy would ask him a "genuine" question on the religious implications of something. The teacher would then step up onto his metaphorical pulpit and spend the rest of the period on the question.
Sad...
by apotheon
It's always nice when someone saves me the trouble of having to take the moral high ground by yielding it without so much as a declaration that I want it.
"[i]I was peeved by the logic: I hate calculus, they taught calculus in CompSci, studying calculus made me change majors, therefore calculus must be removed from the CompSci syllabus unless we want all the students to drop out.[/i]"
If that's what you though the "logic" was, I think you either failed some logic courses or failed some reading comprehension somewhere along the way. That was about the most superficial analysis I've ever seen of anything I've said. It's a bit like scraping some makeup off a woman's face and, after analyzing it in a lab, declaring her inhuman because you found no human genetic material in the makeup.
"[i]Mentioning 'algebraic thinking' (which the poster still hasn't been able to explain)[/i]"
It's blindingly obvious. Consider the word "algebraic" -- referring to that which bears characteristics of algebra as contrasted with something non-algebra (pretend that's a word for a moment). Now, imagine you know what the word "thinking" means. Ta-da! Comprehension. Your "playing dumb" routine doesn't hold up any more than it would if I said "linear thinking" and you started yammering on about how a line is defined by two points so obviously what I said means nonthing since a brain has trillions of synapses.
"[i]'orthogonality' (when the poster actually meant 'tangentiality', in the sense of barely touching)[/i]"
This certainly makes it seem likely that your problem with following my logic (as I noted above) is a failure of reading comprehension rather than a failure of logic on your part. Go back and read again what I said about my use of the term "orthogonality". It's the term I meant to use. It's the appropriate term for what I was saying. Stop disagreeing with me when I tell you what I meant to say -- you do not know my meaning better than I do. Trust me on this.
"[i]the last straw was probably the whole Myers-Briggs psychobabble[/i]"
So . . . now you're putting down psychology, too. Are you capable of going three sentences without insulting someone?
"[i]A solid knowledge of logic, set theory, graph theory, algorithmics, etc. are essential prerequisites for proper reasoning about programming.[/i]"
. . . which, while clearly related to mathematics in general, has very little to do with calculus in particular (note that I speak of "calculus" in the commonly understood mathematical context of the term, not in a manner that should in any way be confused with formal logic terms like predicate calculus).
"[i]Throwing in elementary algebra (and by this I mean the rules to manipulate mathematical symbols) simply shows a lack of insight. The concept of a variable in an equation bears only a superficial resemblance to that of a variable in a programming language; a much better parallel might be drawn between the concept of functions in both areas (which is why I brought up mathematical analysis).[/i]"
Algebraic mathematics fields are not just about variables. Holy crap. I suddenly doubt your claims of mathematics-fu.
[b]as for daveo2000:[/b]
"[i]Chad is a person who regularly contributes here at TR and in a great many other places. He offers some unique insights into issues that get discussed here and does so in a helpful manner, at least in the first post. If somebody attacks him he will come back, often with witty and/or scathing remarks.
His posts are usually informative and occasionally opinionated. I don't always agree with them but he presents them intelligently.[/i]"
Thanks. That's pretty much exactly where I'm aiming when I comment here at TR, generally -- it's nice to know someone thinks I'm hitting the mark.
(edit: I've been out of town for three days or so. Pardon the tardiness of my response.)
by deepsand
a liberal arts education. This, so as to prepare one with both a broad overview of the breadth and scope of knowledge, and the ability to then continue learning such as one's avocations and vocations required.
The present situation of universities acting as [i]de facto[/i] trade schools, oriented toward teaching those specific skills needed for a particular career, is a relatively recent phenomenon, driven, in general, by the technological exposion spurred by WWII, and, in the U.S., by the GI Bill's education benefits & the large number of GI who availed themselves of such.
by apotheon
I don't think the way to solve the problem of unfortunately narrow education is to say "You have to take a speech class to graduate!" It is, instead, to say "You should have a liberal arts basis for your education. With that in mind, pick something from this bucket of thirty classes (including speech) to satisfy this one requirement, or make a good case to the dean for why a class not in this bucket is a good alternative."
As things currently stand, you have to have a [b]documented learning disability[/b] to get out of a speech class and replace it with something credible but of more interest to you as an individual. Meanwhile, there is [b]no way[/b] to avoid calculus in favor of more of a focus on algebraic mathematics in a CompSci course of study -- which is just mind-boggling.
by deepsand
by apotheon
"[i]Well, well, well, this has to be the first time I've seen anyone mention MBTI in a computing forum.[/i]"
You don't get around much. Some computer geeks have interests -- and knowledge -- outside the limits of mathematics.
"[i]the kind of algebraic manipulation they teach you in high school[/i]"
Considering you're the one who brought up high school, I cry foul on your straw man. Feel free to keep rambling about it, though.
"[i]How you manage to conclude that I also meant that symbolic logic was not related to programming is beyond me (and probably beyond you too, since you made it up).[/i]"
Where you got the idea that I claimed you meant that symbolic logic is not related to programming is beyond me. Where do you get these ideas? I never said, nor even implied, any such thing. Is it because I mentioned it in a sentence that also mentioned your difficulty recognizing the strong relevance of algebraic mathematics? It seems to me that what you're having difficulty figuring out is that [b]all three[/b] are related to one another. I mentioned symbolic logic in the hopes that seeing it mentioned in the same sentence might actually spark a thought in your head -- "Oh, yeah, logic and algebra are closely related. Why didn't I think of that?" I guess my error was in expecting that you might have failed to make a connection, rather than that you simply like disagreeing with people and will (apparently) manufacture any flimsy excuse necessary to do so in pursuit of making yourself sound smart.
"[i]Once more, in case I didn't make it clear: just because certain functional languages use brackets and function names does not mean the functional programming paradigm is modelled after algebra.[/i]"
1. You didn't say it before, so you're not saying it again.
2. I didn't say the functional programming paradigm was modeled after algebra, so I don't know why the hell you implied that I did.
"[i]Do you even know what abstract algebraic logic is?[/i]"
Yes, I do. That's why I talked about it. Do you?
"[i]You clearly don't know what orthogonal means, if you confuse it with tangential.[/i]"
I'm sorry. The moral high ground is about to slip away from me. I offer this disclaimer to everyone used to seeing me keep my cool before I blow the hell up:
[b]What kind of idiot are you that you think I confused "orthogonal" with "tangential"?[/b] I [b]very clearly[/b] differentiated between the two, [b]you f*cking dumbass[/b].
Maybe that woke you up enough to [b]read[/b] something and [b]try to comprehend[/b] it.
"[i]If you think calculus is 'mathematical guesstimation', you obviously weren't taught calculus all that well.[/i]"
Don't take it personally when I describe calculus in terms that don't make it sound like the fruit of the tree of knowledge. You may, if you like, take it personally when I point out that your inability to think outside the box is simply appalling, though.
"[i]Ever since Newton first used it, calculus has come along way - analysis is a very rigorous branch of mathematics.[/i]"
I know it is. Get over yourself for knowing how to do calculus. Stop looking for excuses to be insulted just because I express an opinion that calculus is itself pretty much unrelated to programming, and stop looking for excuses to put people down for acting unlike calculus groupies.
"[i]Truth be told, I haven't studied analysis/calculus since my first year as an undergraduate, so I'm not particularly interested in defending its use.[/i]"
Why make fatuous, facile arguments about how my statement that it's not the center of the universe proves I'm a moron, then?
"[i]All I was saying was that your argument seemed to be based on your distaste for calculus[/i]"
The fact that I mentioned a distaste for calculus in the same post that I mentioned calculus isn't much relevant to programming doesn't link them as a statement of causation. Learn some reading comprehension. Attack the argument, not the person. Get a clue.
"[i]Not only that, but half of your comments (again, the whole 'algebraic' thinking) made no sense.[/i]"
You're like the idiot who said "Superannuated? What's that mean? Man, I don't understand what you're saying. You must be stupid!" Maybe you're a little like another idiot, too -- the one who said "You're not reading that book for class? Why are you reading it, then?" as if reading for my own pleasure made [b]me[/b] the stupid one.
It's not my fault that your thinking is so limited in scope that you can't clue in on the concept of a descriptive phrase like "algebraic thinking". I suppose you would have the same problem with the phrase "circular reasoning", since examples of reasoning don't have radii.
"[i]It looks like psychobabble has a new sibling. Shall we call it algebabble?[/i]"
See the title for my answer to that nonsense.
by apotheon
"[i]I'm rather sensitive to the type of unfounded criticism of calculus to which I originally responded.[/i]"
I think the term you want is "hypersensitive" there. I didn't criticize calculus. Thinking I criticized calculus by pointing out its (almost complete) irrelevancy, as contrasted with other mathematical fields, to programming (which I actually do on an almost daily basis -- so no, I'm not clueless about programming) is about as much a reasonable reaction as thinking I'm criticizing calculus when I say that study of calculus is irrelevant to the field of English lit. Criticism? Hell no. It's a simple statement of fact. Calculus is not the only important field. Get over it.
by apotheon
"[i]I received a long reply that addressed things I didn't say in the first place. Hmmm.[/i]"
It looks like dbenito is pretty committed to constructing that army of straw men.
by absolutely
to be a contradiction to the fictional character's favorite fictional attribute of itself?
"The most wonderful thing about Tiggers, is I'm the only one!"
:^0
by apotheon
Actually, I find the tendency to subsume pervasive concepts in mathematics within calculus classes as odious as the requirement for studying a bunch of largely irrelevant calculus as a prerequisite for linear algebra. These concepts -- the concepts that are actually useful for programming -- have nothing more to do with calculus than linear algebra itself. In other words, these concepts are not specific to calculus, and the fact that these concepts are subsumed within the calculus courses of study in most universities is the only "logical" reason for calculus as a prerequisite for linear algebra courses.
I guess I see calculus as, in some ways, the Java of mathematics. These days, when you go to school to learn programming, many schools only provide basic programming concepts within the context of Java classes -- classes that are prerequisites for classes related to AI development that has nothing to do with Java programming at all. Similarly, many universities treat calculus as the universal field of mathematics just as they treat Java as the universal language of programming -- not universal in the sense of being the only one, but in the sense of being the one that everybody wants to know if they're going to be studying [programming|mathematics] at all.
The failure in reasoning that occurs in that approach to designing a curriculum should be unavoidably obvious.
by absolutely
No reply to the content of your post, for now. I just thought your title was ironic, and wondered if it was intentional.
Later.
by daveo2000
Sandy was speaking of someone being certain that they would be a programmer and so are educating themselves for that certainty.
Having met so many people that graduated with a degree in one field and ended up providing for the family in a different field, I am somewhat convinced of the uncertainty of such a decision.
Yes, the person making the decision is certain that they want (or think they want) to be a programmer but stepping back from them the reality that they will end up living is nowhere near as certain.
by absolutely
by deepsand
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=221757&messageID=2233217 .
The study of Comp. Sci and learning to program are quite different things.
by apotheon
by deepsand
by wayne m.
by deepsand
Or, is this a trick question?
"[b]Computer science[/b], or computing science, is the study of the theoretical foundations of information and computation and their implementation and application in computer systems."
"[b]Computer programming[/b] applies specific programming languages to solve specific computational problems with solutions."
by deepsand
by absolutely
by deepsand
by apotheon
Man, you seem to want to turn everything into "I want a broad education, and thus everyone that doesn't want to mandate calculus must be in favor of making degree programs into daycoder factories where people don't learn anything they can't get in a trade school." The truth, however, is that neither Absolutely nor I am saying anything of the kind.
He suggested that a more flexible degree program (not a more narrow program -- a more [b]flexible[/b] program!) might make traditional universities more competitive with trade schools. The underlying (and logical) assumption is that it would do so without sacrificing quality -- and may, in fact, improve in quality.
by absolutely
by apotheon
by apotheon
Computing often started in the Maths faculty.
To be considered to be 'qualified' at math at degree level, you must know calculus....
by absolutely
by daveo2000
It is now 2007. I found a copy of a New York magazine from May 1997 once when cleaning up some stuff. The most amazing thing I found was that it didn't have [b]any[/b] e-mail or web URLs in it!
When I graduated from University (around 1985) the computer facility was in the "Math/Sciences" building and the two were very linked. The big deal was the vector based supercomputer that they had installed which could crunch numbers at an amazing rate.
Now, 20+ years after graduation and 10 years after that magazine was printed, the world is a very different place.
There are a lot of folks out there who just don't need very advanced math and simply will never become analysts. The definition of "computer programmer" is getting more diluted every day. (Far more than little Ben would care to admit!) I have heard of the job descriptions "Excel Programmer" and "VBA Programmer".
Yeah, it is probably time for a change in requirements but that doesn't require that I not be sad to see the deeper understanding of these concepts being left behind.
(edited because my keyboard made a mistake)
cud not agree moor.
The is boogers who car not spell, eh?
Bet they car not add up either.
by danlm
by deepsand
This is a forum where one is both allowed and expected to [b]not[/b] have the luxury of time for a complete and thorough review of one's keystokes prior to their being committed to public view.
Here, as long as the intent is unambiguous, close enough is good enough.
by absolutely
by wayne m.
I believe, especially if one reads much of the previous discussion, people are overestimating how much of what they do is related to higher mathematics.
Where equations do come into play, we evaluate the result of the equation, we do not manipulate the equation into different forms.
Where we do implement equations, for the vast majority of times, we implement the equations created by others. There is no shame in this, we are eliminating the tedious work of repeatedly entering values and recording results.
Where computers are really advantageous are in handling discontinuities and problems with high numbers of variables. These are the situations that are avoided or simplified in mathematics because the resulting equations are far too complex to be humanly understandable. Computers are great way to apply numerous conflicting rules and getting a result. We avoid the difficulty of trying to merge those rules into a single equation to be able to work with them.
There is a great deal of knwoledge concerning computer programming. There is no need to try and portray computer programming as higher mathematics.
by deepsand
You've missed my point, which is that, by and large, [u]universities [b]have become[/b] trade schools[/u].
And, in keeping with that, they [b]do[/b] offer study paths that are less broad than that of a Bachelors degree.
To maintain that one is "forced" to study that which you find extraneous in order to learn to be a "programmer" is specious indeed.
by daveo2000
by deepsand
This sub-thread is re. the distinction between Comp. Sci. and computer programming, and the fact that the latter is but one particular subset of the former.
Please refrain from claiming that it is others who fail to pay attention when interjecting yourself in their conversations.
by deepsand
by deepsand

by absolutely
by absolutely
as wall!
:^0
Sort by Trending