Actually I do have a legal background of sorts. Over the last 18 years I have attended more courtroom proceedings than many lawyers, this is exactly the type of issues that were addressed. My brother operates a corporate law firm, for the longest time it was my focus. As for defamation and libel, that is something I have been in court defending MANY times as an artist manager, that industry is full of such issues on a daily basis.
So no I am not a lawyer, but yes i do understand the reality of law. He would be DAMN hard pressed to find any attorney dumb enough to even attempt taking on such a ridiculous case.
Your points were:
Pre-meditated malicious action, an outcome resulting in the loss of money, injury or reputation resulted.
Obviously you have failed to accept the fact that he's a salesman. There IS no income loss as he is not guranteed an income nor has lost a confirmed income by a prospect wasting his time, sorry but it happens to ALL sales reps DAILY.
INJURY?, er yeah. What is he gonna complain that his brain hurts?
Reputation, he is a SALES REPRESENTATIVE. Losing a sale is something that ALL sales reps face, no matter WHAT the reason for losing the sale is. You could easily and lawfuly tell a sales rep, we have decided not to deal with you because I don't like short men.
In essence, the laws concerning HIS position lay completely in the FCC's (or up here the CRTC's hands), he is protected by laws surrounding telemarketing and that's all, none of them allow for any compensation based on what you have presented.
Think about it a bit, I could sit here and flame Sprint Canada representatives and with a group effort devise a way to waste time and string along all Sprint representatives that call me.
This is completely within the law, they do not have a guarantee of income nor a mentally stable client when they call you.
You are not allowed to tell a telemareter to FO or make any slams regarding race or religion(even then it's a HARD case), but to string them along and be a nutcase entirely is in no way illegal.
Now the matter of Evidence.
The only way evidence shown here can be incriminating is if TR can provide PROOF that it was a certain person who made a posting, trace the IP to the ISP and then have a court order request the ISP delivers the confirmation of the source of the IP (which most states will disallow anyway, this the RIAA's problem), EVEN then there is the issue of WHO had access to that computer. Certainly it may be used as inconclusive evidence if compounded with other solid evidence, but will most likely be strcken even in that case.
Or else, maecuff's husband could create an alias with her name and her company info and use it to incriminate her. Fotunately, the law isn't as dumb and a screen shot is NOT evidence unless it is either compounded or proven as belonging to the accused by evidence proven beyond a reasonable doubt. The fact that ANYONE can create ANY profile, use ANY name and ANY company here creates reasonable doubt and the evidence is not even worth the printer paper.
No company names, personal names or livelihoods are being defamed in this case.
There is no case, period.