Discussion Locked

[i]Congress shall enact no law . . . . .

0 helpful
89 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[i][b].....that does not apply equally to all Americans. [/i][/b]

- Nobel Laureate economist/philosopher Friedrich A. Hayek when asked if he could propose one law that would restore, promote and preserve liberty in our country (the USA), what would that law be?

If this "law" were to become the 28th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, what would be the repercussions; which previous amendments would be in conflict and/or would have to be reviewed and/or repealed; and which government programs and/or laws would become unconstitutional? Would you support such an amendment to the U.S. Constitution? Why or why not?

89 replies

by charliespencer

It doesn't apply equally to any two people.

"Airlines shall enact no fare that does not apply equally to all passengers." :-)

by maxwell edison

You're right. But do you agree or disagree -- and why?

P.S. Airlines are private companies. Are you suggesting some government "big brother" overseeing their practices?

by Member 25348569

Are you suggesting that the government spending is divided by the number of US citizens (regardless of age?) and each one is presented with a bill for their "share" - presumable with a pro-rata reduction if you are born or die within the year? All regardless of ability to pay.

It would have the advantage of being simple but be pretty unworkable.

Or is it acceptable - as currently with tax - to set up a comprehensive set of rules and then apply those rules to everyone. You could make the whole thing simpler by burning all tax lawyers and bent accountants.

I guess that you - and Hayek - are saying 'No'...

by deepsand

Hell, I don't even trust them to provide the service offered [i]with[/i] regulation.

by charliespencer

I disagree. I think it's rarely a good idea to use absolutes. Perhaps an amendment requiring a two-thirds or even three-quarters majority before passing a law that exempts or gives special treatment.

I apologize for the unintended distraction of the airline remark.

by absolutely

Airlines charge different fares [b]for different seats[/b]. The subject is equal protection [b]of law[/b], which, unlike a particular seat on a particular flight, [b]can[/b] be extended equally to all.

Go fly a kite.

by pser

No politician may except any compensation from any source other than their approved government paycheck. Including but not limited to monetary gifts in any shape or form, special treatment from any and or all sources NOT government related in any shape or form, token jobs or titles that would entail financial or social gains in any shape or form ... etc.

Word it so it "bottom lines" the fact that the only thing you will earn, being a 'Politician", is an honest paycheck for an honest job. Basically, No special interest groups, no lobbyist, no corporations, no organized religion or any other entity would be able to "buy" anything "political".

Start with honesty, take away temptation, and we just might find a few honest people who can run the Government of this great country the way it should!

Oh, and you could throw in something about the punishment of violating this "law" ... like deportation, loss of citizenship, a public ROSHAMBOING!

Okay, Go ahead and tare me a new one Max.

BTW: Ron Paul ... WOW! Now there is a Republican (actually Libertarian) I would vote for. Okay, now shred me ...

by absolutely

Can politicians manage an investment portfolio while in office, in your proposal? Can they hire an investment manager to do so? Don't all exemptions & exceptions just institute an "accomplice" requirement without doing squat to address the essential corruption that political power, unchecked, tends to attract?

by pser

Yes, they would have the same rights as any other citizen to manage an investment portfolio. As well, they can hire an IM to do so. Otherwise this would be violating their "rights".

You are Absolutely correct that exemptions & exceptions just institute an "accomplice" requirement without doing squat to address the essential corruption that political power, unchecked, tends to attract?

This is the "meat and potatoes" at the heart of my feeble minded attempt to address the same question asked of "Nobel Laureate economist/philosopher Friedrich A. Hayek", "when asked if he could propose one law that would restore, promote and preserve liberty in our country (the USA), what would that law be?"

I am by no means a "Nobel Laureate economist/philosopher" as is Mr. Hayek. Nor am I as well versed as Max, yourself, and many others here in such matters. (it was this kind of "Discussions" between the likes of yourselves that attracted me to this "Discussion Board")

Anyway ... while I may not be the sharpest tack on this board, I do have eyes and ears and I am as much a patriot as the next American (should be). I want what is best for this country and it's people and with my eyes I only "see" corruption in politics. With my ears I only hear BS from Politicians. It sickens me to see the caliber of "our representatives". They are nothing more than a bunch of Lawyers "playing the game" and playing it for THEIR benefit NOT that of Americans.

Do I have all of the answers? Hell no! A plethora of questions I do have though. First and foremost, "How in the Hell have "we the people" let them get away with this sh!t for so long?!?!? Second, how do we stop it? Granted my "input" was simple and idealistic but like I said, I see these things as being at the root of all of Americas problems. And I just want it fixed!

I will follow this thread with much hope of learning. Learning from yourself, your supporters, and your opponents. You gotta give it to Max, whether you love 'em or hate 'em ... he'll make us ALL think. Like I told him long ago, it was him and his discussions that "hooked me". Good or bad, right or wrong, agree or dis-agree, Max has definitely got a head on his shoulders and I have learned much from his contributions to TR's "Water cooler Discussions". Although he mostly infuriates me personally, I still have nothing but respect for his passionate sense of instigating dialogue directly related to the issues of our tumultuous time of existence.

Take care!

by pser

I thought I ... somewhat answered your question(s). Looking back I see there are several questions you posed.

At this particular moment, I suppose I am out of my league when it comes to answering your questions in the manner they were asked. (not that there is anything wrong in the way you asked them) I am just a mere mortal and will take a back seat for now in hopes of acquiring more knowledge than spewing out my own simplistic rhetoric.

I am looking forward to reading your own responses to the questions you posed to us all. I hope you give them as though you were responding to the questions at hand and not waiting for other replies to feed off of. You're much more eloquent when your on your "soapbox" rather than when you are in "defense" (or "offense" for that matter) mode.

Take care.

by tonythetiger

Ban politics. All positions usually filled by election should be filled by drawing names from a pool (like jury duty). Convicted felons are forever barred from holding office; otherwise, service will be mandatory, and compensation will be equal to the median income of the jurisdiction you will be representing. You must have lived in the jurisdiction for at least half the number of years in one term of the office.

There, That ought to fix them :)

by absolutely

That would make a great local referendum. I think I'll start with the most minor local dignitary jobs and work my way up. Any takers on how far up the pecking order I might get in a lifetime? Well, something to do, anyway ...

PS I think I'll make service optional, because compensation equal to the median income would be equivalent, for some, to punishment, and thus objectionable to me. The payment algorithm you suggest is right, I believe, but since some people have earned higher pay than that, they should be allowed to decline the honor if they so choose.

"There, That ought to fix them. :)"

by jdclyde

So much for people in the never ending search of artificial diversity.

So much for tax breaks for people who qualify.

So much for the whole syndrome of victimization.

We would hear from the left leaning people on how unfair this would be, as somehow reverse discrimination and preferential treatment of some people is a good thing.

I would support this rule. Instead of dividing people into groups and special interests, start working for the common good of the country.

Oh, and remind the law makers at the Federal level that they are not the care takers of the world, and to stop trying to solve every conceived problem by throwing my money at it.

by deepsand

That unless & until one commits a crime one is immune from the Criminal Statutes?

Ergo, does that not mean that one's [b]first[/b] criminal offense is a "freebie," as the law didn't [u]yet[/u] apply?

by maxwell edison

Answer: No

Follow up question: Are you suggesting it's the roll of government to make them equal in all things and in all ways? If yes, what's your basis? If no, what's your point?

P.S. Based on my reply, it's not necessary for me to define "equally"; but perhaps you should.

by deepsand

to being an issue which is repeatedly left to the Courts to decide.

Ditto for the absence of a definition of "American."

by absolutely

No implication nor assertion is made [b]nor required[/b] that all citizens are "equal in all things & in all ways". Agreed?

by maxwell edison

The person to whom I replied segued to some airline issue, and I'll choose not to engage in such discussions. Discuss my intent or be ignored.

by absolutely

What is [b]your[/b] answer to that question?

I apologize if I seem to be asking you to fix an opponent's thesis. My answer is "Americans" are individual citizens only. There should be no special privileges for citizens based on membership in any collective. What does maxwell edison say to that?

by maxwell edison

.....to discuss "issues" unless it's first discussed (and agreed upon) the role of government. Before discussing ANY issue, check your premise. It might eliminate a lot of disagreements and make any "solutions" much more obvious.

What's YOUR premise? Should government favor one citizen over another?

by tig2

Because I simply HAVE to answer the question you have presented.

In my opinion, government should NOT favor one person over another. But they do it every day.

While I can see government valuing an individual with great talent and ability in a specific desired skill or knowledge set, I have some issue with the idea that the favored individual is somehow more valuable than the School Teacher who cares deeply about educating children.

Those US citizens of us are taught that we are equal before the law. Unfortunately, there have been too many cases in which certain individuals were treated in a manner more consonant with them being perceived as above the law.

And PSer, it changes when we the people realise WHO we are and WHAT we want. Sadly, there are too many who prefer to let someone else make the hard calls and want the option of blaming the gov when everything goes pear-shaped.

I personally sick and tired of being told that I have to do (fill in the blank) because it is for the "greater good". Really? Even when time and time again it ends up costing me for something I receive no benefit from?

My father used to say that any man desirous of attaining political office probably has no business being there. In my opinion, my father has a point.

Responsibility and accountability are concepts that I find more and more to be completely misunderstood. I don't get it. I lead teams of people every day with the expectation that they will be responsible and accountable for their project activities. Why do we not have the same expectations of elected officials? Why can't we hold them to those expectations?

by absolutely

The first step toward a solution is knowing that there is a problem. The next step is identifying the problem. Eternal vigilance means addressing whatever it is that you believe to be the problem(s).

by absolutely

observation by implication, that classes of Americans have been singled out for deprivation of the rights granted by law to all, to such a great extent that specific [b]protections[/b] of their rights have been necessitated. I agree with women's suffrage, and do not object to an Amendment specifically guaranteeing women a vote of their own. Marriage is not a requirement.

[i]Congress shall enact no law that provides for [b]punitive measures[/b] that do not apply equally to all Americans.[/i]

Agreed, Max?

by deepsand

Hell, as worded, the proposed Amendment doen't even define "American."

Owing to the simplistic wording of such, this is a lawyer's dream come true - guaranteed lifetime employment.

by absolutely

Because Hayek's idea looked like an exception to the Mencken-ism about neat, obvious ideas being always wrong, and you peed on the parade. You're right. You're also a killjoy. Annoying job, I know, but somebody ought to do it.

To the general issue of simplistic wording, guarantees of rights ought, in general, to be sweeping generalizations, assuming their intent is to be universally applicable, ie, consistent with the premise of universal human equality (before the law!), ie, consistent with the classic liberal ideal of human rights.

by tonythetiger

Also I wasn't clear enough on a point. The median income is only for the period of time you are actually performing your government duties. Naturally on those days when congress is not in session, you can be working at your regular job.

by tonythetiger

that's supposed to be "speedy", or the process leading up to it?

We should up the pay for jurors too.

by absolutely

Accepting, hypothetically & for sake of discussion ONLY, jury duty would definitely be a punishment, not a just requirement of citizenship in a *free* country.

by absolutely

Accepting, hypothetically & for sake of discussion ONLY, jury duty would definitely be a punishment, not a just requirement of citizenship in a *free* country.

by tig2

For the sake of argument, Max, I make the following assumptions. Tell me if I am wrong.

Congress is taken to mean the current body of duly elected congressional representatives from each state.

American is taken to mean any individual (a) living within the borders of the United States of America who is (i) provably born here, (ii) has successfully petitioned the government for Citizenship, whether singly or dually held, (iii) is currently in the process of attaining citizenship. The term does not apply to (a) H1B Visa holders, (b) temporary Visa holders or student Visa holders, (c) those living or working in the country illegally.

With those assumptions, I would say that there is no new law that could be enacted, in my opinion, that would satisfy the litmus test of equal application.

Unfortunately, this does not mean that bad laws will be passed. They are every day.

I liked Tony's suggestion that we start by de-throning politicians. I fear that will not happen in my lifetime. But the benefit to all Americans (see assumption above) would be immediate.

Without knowledge of a specific law that would amend the Constitution, I cannot say that I would favour or disfavour. Nor can I speak to your other questions.

As I have said before, there are many things that do not take notice of the equal impact rule. I do not agree with those things.

by deepsand

"bad" Federal laws.

If the present Constitutional "guarantee" of "due process" proves insufficient, it is foolish to believe that another choice of words will suffice.

The battle between the explicit & the implicit will continue to rage so long a men disagree.

by w2ktechman

While the lottery could work, there should be more restrictions. I would not expect that a crack head could get into office just because he/she never went to prison...

I think that for a position like this, someone would need to be educated, versed in the law, understands the constitution, bill of rights, etc..

Also, instead of declining the role, maybe people should be voted in by their community. Each district could vote for their favorite, and out of those, the 'lottery' could be drawn. Although it seems like it would be more or less what we have, my 'vision' of it would be quite different. I should probably expand a bit.
Each small community should have a selection in mind. In a small community people know others well (or pretty well at least). Out of those that the communities vote for, it would go to a county wide vote (or drawing). From there it could be all drawings(lottery) until the end.

by w2ktechman

I do not always get my points across well, so bear with me a bit. This is why I only lightly post in most threads that I look at (if at all). I leave the majoriy to people like you, apotheon, jmgarvin, deepsand, etc., etc., etc..

What I meant was not that they be a lawyer or judge or he like. That would F*** up things worse. But, what I meant is that they must have taken a course in law as well. This by no means meant to imply that they received a degree in law, just that they understand law from a legal point. That way they can read and understand legal documents that pass their way. And to be able to find things that can be mis-interpreted and or find loopholes, etc.).
And finally, that they know and understand the constitution and bill of rights.

And I had another thought, to help make people do the right thing, make them be accountable for their actions....

by tonythetiger

[i]I would not expect that a crack head could get into office just because he/she never went to prison...[/i]

... it hasn't already happened?

by absolutely

"In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed..."

I see a guarantee to a speedy trial, and no mention whatsoever of "the process leading up to it".

by absolutely

I've said "equally, with respect to the law only." With that addendum, are you now on board?

by deepsand

As I've elsewhere noted, it is not our burden to supply the definitions intended the one who submitted the proposition.

As stated, said proposition is sufficiently vague so as to literally invite Court intervention.

by absolutely

I think in this case a [u]good[/u] idea is implied in the (vague) hypothesis, and I intend to support its development.

by absolutely

would suffice for Hayek's phrase to be useful & viable? Or, do you think such impossible? Why?

by deepsand

I cannot speak for either Mr. Hayek or maxwell; therefore, the question, as posed by max, is vague to the point of be unanswerable.

It is not for me to define max's question, any more than it is ours to define Zealot's hypothesis.

In both matters, I will not presume to take up their burdens. Rather, I shall ask those questions which may serve to elicit the required definitions.

by absolutely

We should not be exporting our wealth to dictatorships. We should not be competing in terms of wages for labor against [i]de facto[/i] slaves, in countries which don't respect their citizens' rights as human beings. We should not do business with countries that won't do business on our terms. The less we cater to foreign dictators, the more pressure their citizens will put on them for their human rights. On the other hand, when we export our jobs, our diminished wealth is their improved standard of living, which pacifies their would-be dissidents. The entire world becomes less free because they make economic gains without political ones, and our pursuits of happiness become ever more difficult, which in turn encourages more people to part more easily with rights they aren't *enjoying* anyway.

by absolutely

I post here to refine some very specific ideas I have about (ouch) "the way things ought to be" (irony noted but not deliberate, not a Limbaugh fan). I've gotten great assistance in that from the precise use of language and adherence to principle of deepsand, apotheon & maxwell edison. I haven't noticed jmgarvin much, except that he shows more knowledge of Linux than I have.

I also think I have a general bias toward approaching everything with a scientist's perspective, which means that if I nitpick, it's likely because I find something in your statement interesting. That was certainly the case in my post to you about lawyers & judges. I'm sorry that was unclear.

Now that that's out of the way, I think what you propose is brilliant. I'm actually ready to put together a referendum for the local voters. I'll just need to decide on which office to begin with for this experiment. It should be comparatively minor, elected, and one vacated by resignation in the next election cycle. I don't want to make this any harder for myself than necessary! The other detail to resolve will be exactly what "course in law" to require. I'm leaning more toward a study of the US Constitution and local laws than theory of law or the like. People will already have their particular theories of law & government, and part of life in a republic is getting along with those with whom we disagree.

by deepsand

And, it served it's intended purpose, in that it did get at least one person, yourself, to actually [u]think[/u] beyond the rosy intent, and consider the real life consequences of the actual words.

Yes, it is an unrewarding task, one that is necessary.

To those who do not like having attention called to the warts, "not my problem."

by deepsand

Un-defined terms:

1) "apply"

2) "equally"

3) "Americans"

It is the burden of Mr. Hayek to provide such definitions; your's as well, if you desire meaningful & thoughtful response.

by maxwell edison

.....for yourself, if you desire to engage in genuine discussion (versus your usual disingenuous ones). Anything short would suggest that absolutely every word in the constitution be discussed, at length -- "equal" being one of them (many times over) -- until all hairs are split accordingly.

You're an absolute idiot if you really want to "debate" over the meaning of "equal".

You're a bore and an imbecile who needs to get a life.

Definition of "equal: Deepsand EQUALS an idiot.

by w2ktechman

just more needed to flesh out the idea. I think Tony's idea was the most brilliant so far anyway.

Anyway, I would lean towards theory of law and constitution law.

by deepsand

After all, he has [u]the[/u] answer to every question.

:^0

And, not unlike his behavior at "The Last Word ...," there's no reason to expect that maxwell's going to step up to the plate & define his terms.

by absolutely

...and be free to decide that for themselves, just as you are free to choose the airline that provides you the best -- according to your standards -- service/price ratio.

by absolutely

He does indeed have [u]the[/u] answer to everything: it's really the same answer to even very different questions, if you waste enough time trying to "understand" the little twerp, and it's BS every time.

by absolutely

]:) ?

Whatever. He's just a lost cause as far as I'm concerned. "Zarathustrian" may or may not mean "lost cause" to some other dead culture, which might be slightly less disagreeable than Z. It's all anti-intellect to me, and despicable.

by thechas

While having laws apply equally to all is an interesting concept, the constitutional impact would be far less than many would think.

The only law that comes to mind that this would impact is affirmative action.

The biggest overall impact today, would be the nullification of most of the Bush "signing statements".

The second impact would be that Congress would not be able to exempt themselves from the laws they pass.

Congress also might not be able to exempt small businesses from some of the rules and regulations that they presently don't have to follow. Individuals might now have to follow the same environmental laws that businesses have to.

The key here is the word "apply" almost every law in the US "applies" equally to all. Very few laws "impact", "effect", or "benefit" equally.

Even the much maligned tax code "applies" equally to all. Even though "effect" and "impact" vary widely.

In our day to day lives, the only impact we would see is the clogging of the appellate and Supreme Court dockets with cases challenging assorted laws. That, and a new reason for people to become lawyers.

Chas

Added 7/5

Max, I forgot to answer your specific question.

No, I would not support such an amendment. For a variety of reasons.

First, the best way we have to hold Congress responsible is to vote the bums out at the next election cycle.

Second, the amendment would impair the ability of Congress to aid any specific business facing unfair competition.

Third, it would strip provisions of existing laws that exempt small businesses from rules and regulations that they may not be able to afford to comply with.

It would tie up the Judicial branch for years if not decades as interest groups push for their interpretation of how existing law is impacted.

Some gifted lawyer might be able to present a compelling argument that Veterans benefits are now illegal, as all Americans are not eligible to join the armed forces.

Finally, the actual impact and the desired impact will be far different. I don't think it will make near the change in US law that some expect it would.

Chas

by deepsand

It is disturbing that so very few here have recognized both the vagueness inherent in the wording of the proposal, and the reasonably expected results of its enactment.

Whether or not maxwell knowingly & with intent did deliberately set forth such a vague proposal, and, if so, for what purpose, remains known only to him. However, given that he has resisted any & all efforts to induce him to address such does suggest that he sees all the words presented as being, both separately & collectively, [i]implicitly[/i] self-defining.

by absolutely

"Whether or not maxwell knowingly & with intent did deliberately set forth such a vague proposal, and, if so, for what purpose, remains known only to him. However, that he has resisted any & all efforts to induce him to address such does suggest that he sees all the words presented as being, both separately & collectively, [i]implicitly[/i] self-defining."

TheChas didn't ask what those terms were intended to mean, he just replied, as if the terms were "both separately & collectively, [i]implicitly[/i] self-defining." So are they, or aren't they, "self-defining"?

by deepsand

Zoroaster/Zarathustra/Zartosht was, by the time of his becoming known to Western culture, a name associated with lost ancient wisdom.

Voltaire "promoted research into Zoroastrianism in the belief that it was a form of [u]rational Deism[/u], preferable to Christianity."

by deepsand

From the original post:

"[i]The key here is the word "apply" almost every law in the US "applies" equally to all. Very few laws "impact", "effect", or "benefit" equally.

Even the much maligned tax code "applies" equally to all. Even though "effect" and "impact" vary widely.

In our day to day lives, the only impact we would see is the clogging of the appellate and Supreme Court dockets with cases challenging assorted laws. That, and a new reason for people to become lawyers.[/i]"

From the addition to the original:

"[i]It would tie up the Judicial branch for years if not decades as interest groups push for their interpretation of how existing law is impacted.

Some gifted lawyer might be able to present a compelling argument that Veterans benefits are now illegal, as all Americans are not eligible to join the armed forces.[/i]"

by absolutely

of maxwell's/Hayek's quote assumed to have precise, well-understood definitions, but also "impact", "effect" and "benefit", all of which are not specifically defined, either. For example, the following sentence requires the assumption that "effect" ("affect", maybe?) and "impact" have contrary rather than complimentary definitions.

[i]Even the much maligned tax code "applies" equally to all. Even though "effect" and "impact" vary widely.[/i]

When, and on which subjects, you choose to critique ambiguity versus proceed according to the assumption you deem most likely is interesting to observe.

by deepsand

"[i]In our day to day lives, the only impact we would see is the clogging of the appellate and Supreme Court dockets with cases challenging assorted laws. That, and a new reason for people to become lawyers.[/i]".

by absolutely

"I think it's rarely a good idea to use absolutes."

I prefer minimal governance, with rules clearly & precisely stated. Exceptions should be rare.

by charliespencer

you're asking why I think absolutes should be avoided.

You'll look like an idiot at best or a hypocrite or liar at worst when you have to go against them. "Read my lips, 'No new taxes!'" leaps to mind. I'm not discussing the value of the statement or policy, or passing judgment on Bush I. My point is that the statement came back to bite him quite badly. Mandatory sentencing often results in "tough on crime" officials looking foolish when jail overcrowding forces them to release non-violent offenders before their sentences are up. School rules require suspending students for Mommy's mistake of packing a plastic knife in Susie's lunch.

I agree that exceptions to "one law fits all" should be rare. That's why I think a super-majority should be required to pass such laws. Robert A. Heinlein had an interesting proposal in "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress". One legislative body passes laws by a two-thirds majority. If you can't convince two-thirds, it's probably not a good law. The other body repeals by a one-third or great minority. If more than one-third feel it's a bad law, it probably is. (Why Hollywood shouldn't adapt RAH: this is another of his ideas that wouldn't survive the transition to the action-oriented format Hollywood forces on sci-fi. End of way off-topic microrant.)

by absolutely

[i]You'll look like an idiot at best or a hypocrite or liar at worst when you have to go against them. "Read my lips, 'No new taxes!'" leaps to mind. I'm not discussing the value of the statement or policy, or passing judgment on Bush I. My point is that the statement came back to bite him quite badly.[/i]

Just as it should! Politics, law & government will always exist because (some) people are vicious animals. We should make the task of liars who wish to fleece us as difficult as possible. One method is to encourage specific & absolute commitments beginning with election campaigns.

by charliespencer

"We should make the task of liars who wish to fleece us as difficult as possible. "

Agreed; apparently we differ only on the degree of difficulty. I feel a super-majority requirement is a sufficiently difficult obstacle to put in front of laws that would not apply equally to all citizens.

Sticking to a campaign promise after the circumstances have changed demonstrates an inability to adapt policy to fit the country's changing needs. "Stay the course!" isn't always the best approach. Sticking to a campaign promise is different from trying to force a law to apply in inappropriate situations. Also, campaign promises are often made while ignoring the necessity to work with other legislators or government branches before they can be fulfilled. Campaign promises are made by the deceitful for consumption by the gullible.

This discussion is closed to new replies.