Discussion Locked

Identity of Science Fiction

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
In over a hundred years of existence, science fiction has lacked a true definition- one that the majority of the sci-fi community can agree on. My question is this: Does science fiction have a clear definition? Why or why not?

19 replies

by charliespencer

"I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, ..."

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart

by dr_zinj

Actually, the original definition of pornography was "writing about prostitutes".
Prostitution is defined aby Ask.com as, "The act or practice of engaging in sex acts for hire." Notice is says "writing" and not "pictorial depictions".

Also, technically, there is almost no such thing as child pornography as very few child engage in sex acts for hire. Child Sex Slaves, and child sexual abuse are a whole other matter.

by tony hopkinson

Remember a pigeon hole is small box you can't much in to.
And a favourite resting place for those with a brain the size of a pea.

What is sci-fi, it's a made up story that revolves around a potential scientific advance.

Course then you have to define scientific....
Science fantasy is a made up story in world where some scientific advances would have to have been made in order for it to occur.

Anne Mcaffery's Dragon universe is Sci-fantasy
Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars is science fiction.

by mjd420nova

SCIence FIction has many smaller catagories that range from the FANTASY to Techno-thriller. Some are pretty plausible to extremely unlikely. If it has to do with science, we don't know what the future holds and Fantasy is more of a comic book future.

by snak

The basic identification of 'Sci-Fi' is where a scientific law is bent, broken, hypothesised or otherwise manipulated in order to create a scenario for adventure.

In Romance novels, someone somewhere falls in love and things move on from there. In Crime novels a crime is commited and 300 pages later, someone solves it. In a Horror novel, some silly monster terrorises the daft blond before the hero pops up and stakes it through the heart.

All of these are simple fomulae with predictable beginnings, middles and ends. Sci-Fi on the other hand can encompass any or all of these genres (which makes it by far the best kind of fiction IMO).

It is possible to have a heart-wrenching love scene, or a dribbling monster scene, a murder or even gun-toting cowboys in a Sci-Fi story. The addition of a Flying Saucer to a Romance makes it Sci-Fi (or just silly).

Fantasy on the other hand is much like Sci-Fi but includes magic, mythical creatures or both. The existence of magic is analogous to the bent scientific rule and the dragon or unicorn is analogous to natural creatures found on other planets.

I think that Sci-Fi and Fantasy are probably the only two genres where romance, crime, horror, cowboys, war and all other 'types' of stories can live together, happily ever after.

Which of course gives them far more scope than any other type of fiction.

by don't read this

are the works of Arthur C Clarke. I compare all other Sci Fi to his books. Stories that use science, engineering and technology in futuristic but plausible ways. The best part is that I now live in the world he created in my imagination as a kid.

by jaqui

If we can accept the term speculative fiction as a core part of what became science fiction, it goes back to the first verbal stories about what the moon is made of. :p

what lighting is.

what thunder is.

yup, speculative fiction has been around since before writing was ever a glimmer of an idea. It was used to explore reality and what may be true. as science became more of a "science" the terminology changed to suit the times.

though, this makes Mary Shelley's Frankenstein a candidate for Science Fiction. ;) after all, she explored what would happen if someone did manage to make the dead live again.

by forum surfer

So is it safe to say it would be called "science fiction" if you take "speculative fiction" and add some form of transistors, electron flow and/or rocket propulsion?

by bblackmoor

Science Fiction is a subset of Fantasy that appeals to the language of science and the trappings of technology for its verisimilitude.

by pjamese3

Science fiction and fantasy are two entirely different genres of fiction. Science fiction utilizes current or imagined future science and rational science-related thought for its basis. Fantasy is magic and magical creatures.

by trilkin

SF has always attracted interesting writers with stories that do not fall into traditional categories. One could argue that SF has the most varied catalog of any other, more strictly defined fiction categories. Indeed, I think variety is the genre's defining, and best characteristic.

by jkelleghan

Years ago I read a Cliffs Note about Dune that defined Sci Fi soemwhere along the following:

Science Fiction is a literary form in which science happens to be an important element of the plot. But the science used in the plot does not have to be correct if science correctness hinders the development of the plot.

It is similar to fantasy where magic, instead of science, is used as an important element of the plot.

by seanferd

After reading the thread, I am not going to offer a definition of science fiction. I will only suggest that perhaps the works of literary scholars be consulted.

In the posts, I have seen the following terms used as if they were interchangeable: Science Fiction, SF, Sci-Fi, perhaps there were others. While used in this manner colloquially, they are technically not the same things. I do agree that not every work can be neatly pigeonholed to fit a certain definition, but that is just how all of reality works.

Anyway, there are plenty of definitions provided by scholars, writers, and critically thinking readers. See what your favorite author has to say, especially if that person has also been an editor or critic. A lot of anthologies (especially awards anthologies) contain essays on the very subject.

Happy holidays :)

by quintastiberius

There have been several good definitions given for Sci-Fi above, so I won't muddy the waters by giving my interpretation, other than to say the word SCIENCE is the all-important component.

But I do know what is not Sci-Fi . . . and a perfect example is ECW.

For those of you who are not familiar with the acronym, try tuning in to Sci-Fi(?) channel Tuesday nights at 10:00 PM. If this is acceptable fare on a channel supposedly dedicated to Sci-Fi, then perhaps we should look forward to Britney Spears on the Discovery Channel.

However, I would agree that ECW is total fantasy.

Sorry for the rant, but I had to get it off my chest.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I understood Science Fiction to be fiction based in Science with futuristic imaginings of scientific application that could conceivably, one day, come true.

I still tend to define it that way, but a whole lot of stuff that doesn't fit that definition is sold in the Sci-Fi section of the bookstores and is very, very good reading.

by snak

Q: .. fiction based in Science with futuristic imaginings of scientific application .. :Q

A story set in Dark Ages England could perhaps be called 'histrical fiction', but the same story set on an imaginary world would be 'fantasy', with or without 'magic' as such. Enter Time Traveller from the future (2008?) and it becomes Science Fiction. Providing the TT arrives in a silver machine of some sort, or is projected back by some form of scientific process. Of course, if said TT arrives after being sent back by a future Wizard, using incantations and weird serendipity, we're back to Fantasy. Then, if the TT machine is called the Window In Zeit (ger: time) And Relative Dimensions (WIZARD), we're back to Sci Fi.

Let's face it, genres are only for the convenience of the average book shop worker.

This discussion is closed to new replies.