Discussion Locked

If Kerry Wins the Popular Vote and Bush Wins the Election

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What do you think will happen if Kerry wins the popular vote and Bush wins the Presidency?

Max's electoral vote prediction got me thinking a bit about this. I,like Max, think its a shoe in for Bush on the electoral vote, but what if there really is an unprecidented voter turnout instead of the apathetic near 50% and Kerry actually wins the popular vote.

How will the US citizens react?

41 replies

by tomsal

If I'm not mistaken I believe Gore scored a bit higher on the popular vote and Bush got the electoral vote.

Remember all the nasty talk you heard for weeks after the election because of this? The Gore voters slandered the Bush voters screaming they cheated, they stole the election...Gore should of won ..blah blah blah.

It'll be the same deal this time except it will most likely be a lot worse -- this election is more emotional in the minds of most voters than the 2000 election was...by far.

Sometimes I wonder why this country just doesn't kill the electoral college system all the way and just go with a straight popular vote.

by maxwell edison

.
If half of the voting population could be targeted in just a handful of states, then the rest of the states could be considered insignificant. If the USA decided the presidency based on a popular vote total nationally, then the presidency could, in theory, be decided by the residents of California, New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, Florida, Michigan, New Jersey and Texas. The heck with the other forty-one states. They could focus their efforts - and favors - on just a select few, and the others would be insignificant.

Besides, we're a republic of equal but united individual states. The USA was never intended to be just one big happy (family) country.

The people in California, New York, and Pennsylvania would love to be in the driver's seat whent it cones to electing our president. But the people in Vermont, Wyoming and Alaska might not be too thrilled about it.

by cactus pete

Add to your list of states Georgia and North Carolina, and you have enough electoral college votes to win the election anyway!

I'm really starting to like Australia's voting system these days...

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, there's no popular vote contest to "win" (or lose). Words have specific meanings, and "win" is the wrong word. How can a person win or lose anything that's not defined as being the desired outcome of the contest being waged? That's like saying I "won" the Chess game, for example, because I ended up with more pieces than my opponent, even though I found myself in checkmate. So if the presidency was decided on "popular vote", the contest would be waged differently - much differently (and a lot of states' citizens wouldn't be happy about it).

Second of all, the only way a person can receive more national popular votes than the winner of the electoral contest is if the electoral contest is decided buy just one state - any state - and even then it would be a fluke. In 2000, Bush won Florida by only 537 (I think) votes, while Gore won New Mexico by less than 300. (It's interesting, as a side-note, that a Gore/Democrat tactic was to challenge the results of a close state election, while Bush/Republicans did not.)

Pick a state, any state, and consider that if that state went to the other guy, and that flip would change the electoral outcome, then it's possible, depending on the population of the state in question. But if changing that one state wouldn't change the outcome, then it's not possible. If President Bush, for example wins enough states to put his electoral number above the 275-280 range, it would probably be a mathematical impossibility for the loser of the electoral contest to have received more "popular votes".

This is ensured by the occasional redistricting of state's congressional districts, which is based on the population alignments as determined by the national census taken once every decade. And the assignment of states' electoral votes is determined by the number of total congressional seats. California, for example, lost a congressional seat - and an electoral vote - in 2002 because of a big loss in state population. While Colorado picked up a congressional seat - and an electoral vote - because of a big gain in state population. (A couple of other states traded one as well, I believe, but I forgot which ones.)

Besides, it won't happen, so it's a moot point.

Bush - 338
Kerry- 200

by dc_guy

If a larger proportion of the eligibile voters voted in a couple of large states than in the rest of the country, and the majority in both of those states voted for the losing candidate, that would increase the total number of popular votes for the losing candidate, perhaps to the point that they exceed the total number of popular votes for the winning candidate.

In my opinion, this is one of the few rationalizations for the electoral college system. It's possible that a candidate could whip up a frenzy in a couple of states where he's popular, and bring in a larger percentage of the voters in those states. Not likely, but possible.

by garion11

To prevent these candidates from just campaigning in the populous regions, NYC/LA/Chicago etc.

by cactus pete

Do the candidates campaign anywhere based on population? Would they, really?

California is getting no attention, but would either candidate really spend a lot of time there if this were only a popular vote [in this particular election]? I don't think so - same for NY and Chicago.

by maxwell edison

.
Adding Georgia and North Carolina would bring that list up to 11 states.

Contrast that with 2000 when GWB had to win 30 states to get the required 270. And if Florida had gone to Gore, his state total (including D.C.) would have been 22. Either way, significantly more states are "in play" with the electoral system.

We could go back and forth all day (time permitting, of course), but I'm not convinced that the electoral system doesn't distribute the voter power much better. And after all, those states have their issues and we have ours, and all of us cowboys out west don't want those eastern high-brow elitists to have too much power over us.

by cactus pete

The electoral college system is based largely on population, anyway. It only gives a marginal increase in the effect of the smaller states.

One candidate can theorhetically win every last one of the electoral college votes and have a 1% margin in the popular vote.

If we didn't have a "two party system", much of this wouldn't matter. Happen to know when the last time a third party candidate got an electoral college vote?

by maxwell edison

.
The last third party candidate to win any electoral vote(s) was............wait a minute, let me think........no, I'm not going to "cheat"..........I won't look it up...........how about John Anderson.

I understood your point. I just don't think the system is "broke", so there's nothing to fix. And that "marginal increase" might make a difference.

Besides, I stand-fast on my notion of a republic of individual states. We don't have a national election for anything, and I want to hold on to what might be the last semblance of the states' rights to tell the federal government what to do, not the other way around. (It also irritates me when the feds take money from the states, at least the states' citizens, and then demand that they do certain things if they want a small percentage of it back.)

Is my John Anderson guess correct? If not, who was it?

by cactus pete

"Broke" Well, I don't know if that's quite the applicable word for what I think of it. But I think it can't be the best plan... I'd love a national debate on the whole idea.

States rights... Well, this is a federal post we're talking about. A federal document determines how the election runs, ultimately. But it does rather give the states about all the say-so there can be.

Anderson wasn't correct - a god stab at it, though. Wallace, in '68. Before him, Strom Thurmond in 1948!!

I'll look up the rest:
LaFollette in '24
Taft in 1912 [this one's a bit screwy, as the third party came in second.]

Earlier than that, I think the rules were very different, so I won't bother...

by garion11

I do not DO NOT want another Florida like repeat. If a candidate wins (Bush or Kerry) I am praying to God that he wins both the electoral college and the popular vote and even wins the electoral college in a decisive manner in every state (no close votes).

by cactus pete

Both sides are already preparing for the possibility of a close loss. Republicans in WI, Dems in FL, for example.

by admin

But I personally hope it is both decisive and that the winner is supported by both sides whoever wins.

by aldanatech

Two popular wins and electorals looses in a row? I hope that doesn't happen again because people might really start to think that our democracy is a fraud. This was one of the major reasons why our country suddently got so polorized after the election in the first place. At the very least, I can picture protests and strikes all over the country, particularly in Washington.

by maxwell edison

.
The Democrat party started the polarization with their nonsensical and frivolous charges, their mean-spirited attacks on the president-elect, and their incessant court challenges that they kept losing and losing, but kept appealing. (They actually lost EVERY court decision except the Florida Supreme Court decision, and the U.S. Supreme court voted 7-2 that the Florida Supremes overstepped their authority.)

If the Democrats would have instead just accepted the loss with grace and dignity, like Nixon did in 1960 (and Nixon actually had more reasons to make a challenge), and if they hadn't carried it on throughout the Bush presidency, perhaps we wouldn't be so "polarized". But "grace and dignity" is something all to foreign to many Democrats.

The Democrats have shown their true colors over the past four years, and they ain't pretty. And, in my personnel opinion, they ain't red, white and blue either. In their unrelenting quest for power, they've done a lot of harm to the faith people might have in our system, both at home and abroad.

So look at your own party - the party of polarization.

by delbertpgh

I recall on election night 2000, Gore made a phone call to GWB congratulating him on his win, but then as the vote narrowed in the next hour to a couple of hundred, Gore's people called back, retracting the concession. Karen Hughes (GWB's highly trusted press secretary and advisor) went on TV saying she had never heard of such a thing, and that Gore was doing an injustice to the electoral process and going back on his word.

I thought this was a pretty over the top reaction. Waiting for the vote to complete is cheating? I was stunned at how silly it sounded.

Later, when GWB's majority stood in the hundreds, the Gore team asked for a recount in selected districts. Mark Racicot, governor of Montana and head of GWB's post-election Florida task force, accused the Democrats of underhanded tactics, and trying to steal a fairly won election by tricks and strategems. He blew up like Zell Miller... rage and indignation.

I was stunned at the anger. The idea of getting a recount seemed only sensible to me, when the vote was so close. An accurate count is a fair count, right? Not to the GWB team. The fair count was the one they already had.

So, I pretty clearly came away with a different take on the 2000 election than you did. It looked to me like there was no principle the Republicans would not betray in favor of winning. One thing is different this time: both sides are meaner and readier for a fight than anybody was in 2000. It will be a miracle if this election is not a history-making disgrace.

by aldanatech

No. It wasn't because of either party themselves. It was basically two reasons:

1. In 2000, Gore won the popular vote but lost the electoral vote. This gave the people a sense that they didn't get the president they actually voted for.

2. There were some irregularities in the election, particularly with the new touch-screen voting machines. Also, there was sense that Florida's governor had to something with Bush's victory. Even though this was not clearly confirmed, it was still left out as a suspicion.

And by the way. I already said it before but here it goes again: The Democratic party is not my party at all. Neither is the Republican party. I only vote for the best candidate regardless of the party.

by admin

The first major party that steps forward and refuses to deliver low blows and cheap shots even if they are being threatened by them will gain my respect.

This is everything that has divided our country and made a mess of things:

We forgot what we were all supposed to have learned on the playground.

Two wrongs still don't make a right.

by maxwell edison

.
Name one main-stream Democrat Party issue in which they don't polarize, in which they don't demonize, in which they don't attack someone.

Standard Democrat "charges" as follows:

Corrupt big business.

Corporate welfare.

The greedy rich taking from the poor.

The fanatical religious-right trying to force their values.

They're polluting our water.

They're killing our children.

They're disenfranchising the voters.

The Democrats ALWAYS levy these stupid and POLARIZING charges.

There are two different Americas in our country today, the Democrats claim.

They always pit the rich (whoever they are) against the poor (whoever they are).

They always pit one race against another.

They always pit one group against the other.

They always pit one class against another.

Just listen to John Kerry or John Edwards for 10 minutes and all this becomes crystal clear.

And you're right, we're all sick of it. So why don't you guys STOP DOING IT?

by aldanatech

Many of those "charges" actually apply to the Bush administration, not the Democratic or even the Republican party. The kind of polarized country the this president created is one that has one side that supports him mostly because he is simply the president, and the other side that knows he messed up big time and that the country is ready for a fresh new start. Among his wrongdoings include:

1. Misleading the Nation Into War and Failing To Plan For Post-War Iraq

2. Lying to the Nation During the State of the Union

3. Exposing a Covert CIA Agent for Revenge

4. Halliburton and Dick Cheney

5. Lying About Medicare Costs and Threatening Whistleblowers

The list can go on and on for quite a while. Maybe more on that later.

by chameleon186

The fact is don't have nothing bad on one candidate well because has never been in office. I can assure all will have little dirt after running a term don't give a crap what party he/she belongs to.

I don't support the B&C because of the over whelming things that don't add up and can not come to a clear decision about character and judgement.

among what others mentioned I would like to point out the following

besides 9/11 reports saying something different. Than what was addressed to the nation.

Also questionable act during 9/11 investigation why was G&C interview done behind closed doors no recordings no video and why was there over dozens pages removed from the report, I question who is being protected and why.

"Rice" was also a board member for a major energy company. You can research this on your own....clue=che

why after reffering to attacks by alquaeda was connected to 9/11 said doesn't care to persue laden which as for everyone knows is the leading figure. Was it a mock up from the beginging. This is what I gather from this..

When it comes to iraq and saddam being this extrememly evil dictator why was rumsfeld shaking hands with this man after the chemical attacks on his so called country men and women. I certaintly wouldn't be shaking this mans hands, might spit in his face...

besdies chenney being president for a large corporation as this. Surely there are still some friendly ties still rub shoulders with...

The draft is more likely with B&C because simply have nothing to loose on popularity can only run 2 terms and chenney well don't see him running for president at his age and health conditions.

There jsut seems to be to much mystery behind it all, all seems to be way to dark shade of gray for me to have any kind of liking towards....

However saying all this I'm not so sure the other will be any better. I guess in short the problem is US is a product of a bi-party government. and in History at least within recent enough time frame for most to relate to that are still alive or recently past. All presidents have come from some what wealthy lives with powerful people around them. The day I see a common well educated man or woman become president maybe then I'll see more eye to eye with the political system in the US.

Just some thoughts P.S. I belong to no party because I don't believe in that system. My theory is more parties better checks and balance......

by delbertpgh

One neat thing the electoral college does is provide a decisive majority even when the vote seems to lack decision. However, in 2000, this did not come to pass, because GWB (with Florida under his belt) won by only a single elector.

One risk of a popular vote tally is that in a very close election, every vote in every district would make an equal difference, so lawyers would pop up to make a post-election fight absolutely anywhere they could find one. In 2004, nobody in Brooklyn will care if there is fraud in Possumtown Mississippi, because Miss. is so overwhelmingly Republican that a few votes would make no difference. However, if one vote in Mississippi could cancel one vote in New York, then there'd be plenty to fight about.

The big trouble this year is, we could have majorities of only a few thousand in up to 11 states, and we could have the biggest voter turnout in quite a while, including record numbers of new voters, and record numbers of absentee ballots. We'll be lucky if we don't have a half dozen Floridas this year, delaying a decision through Christmas.

by av .

This race is very much like the race in 2000 in alot of ways so one outcome could be the one that you are talking about. I hope not. If that happens again I think our voting system is very, very broken.

Something thats unique to this race is that there are thousands of newly registered voters that I believe will vote. We don't know how they will vote. I would say they are not coming out to vote to keep the status quo.

Also, many Americans overseas have been compelled to vote in our election driven by the resentment towards Bush in other countries. I don't think that has ever happened to the extent it is in this election. I'm not sure how their vote counts unless they are considered part of the state of their last residence in the US?

The 2nd outcome of the election could be that a large enough turnout in one candidate's favor could happen so there is no contest and the majority of people will have decided. I hope it happens more like this.

We, as a country, have become too divided over this race. Throw in another Osama Bin Ladin tape and there you have it.

by delbertpgh

If there are margins of only a couple thousand votes in enough states to swing the result, there will be a fight.

Expatriate voters usually are required to make their last domestic U.S. residence the place where they vote. Except people in the military. They get shipped around so much, they are allowed to declare any state they want to be their legal residence. When I was in the Air Force in the 70s, a lot of the career men picked Texas, largely because there was no income tax there. I don't know if things are the same today.

by maxwell edison

.
...how we both see the same event but in a different light.

Who was it that said, we all see the world through the prism of our own biases?

Perhaps that's more true than we realize.

I won't get into a rehash of the 2000 Florida election, but I will say this. I don't think the courts have any business getting involved in an election process - not ever. (And the Democrats started the court challenges in 2000.)

The individual states' constitutions and the U.S. constitution have provisions for just about anything that might happen, and those provisions should be followed to the letter. If they're flawed, they should be changed and corrected, but they should be followed and we should just accept the chips as they fall.

And in Florida in 2000, 537 more chips fell into the Bush camp, as every recount - as required by the Florida constitution - made very clear.

Richard Nixon accepted the outcome in 1960, and Al Gore should have accepted it in 2000.

by maxwell edison

.
There is no win or lose the "popular vote". Because there is no contest waged to win or lose the "popular vote".

As far as your other comments, see the message I posted above to DelbertPGH.

And you are a Democrat, in principle, based on your constant repetition of the Democrat Party "plans" that you've continually cut and pasted from John Kerry's (and others) Web site. If you vote for a Democrat, whether you realize it or not, you vote for the Democrat Party platform. So you are either a Democrat or a very naive' voter.

by aldanatech

Even if there is no contest waged, the candidate with the most popular votes is simply the one that wins the popular vote. That result is recorded in the hearts and minds of the American people.

On the other hand, I insist that I don't vote for John Kerry because of the Democratic Party platform. I do it because he is the best candidate. It wouldn't make a difference if Bush was a Democrat and Kerry a Republican, I would still vote for Kerry.

Now, if I ever do any cut and paste is because is because I am way to busy here at work and I don't have that much time to do a lot typing, and only when John Kerry's opinion and view is similar to mine.

by maxwell edison

.
If John Kerry's opinions and views are similar to yours, then you are cut from the same philosophical mold that he is. Okay, I'll remove the Democrat label if you abhor it so much. And I suppose, in all accuracy, one is not a Democrat (large D) unless that person is registered as a Democrat. Okay, I'll concede that you may not be a registered Democrat. But you are, by your own admission, a liberal thinking person since John Kerry is a liberal thinking person (since John Kerry's opinions and views are similar to yours). In fact, John Kerry has repeatedly been named as the most liberal member of the Senate.

Whether or not you vote for John Kerry because of the Democrat Party agenda is immaterial. The point being is that you will get the Democrat Party agenda by voting for John Kerry. You can't get one without the other. Their identical records go hand-in-hand. They are joined at the ideological hip.

Hey, I'm a conservative-libertarian and proud of it. I wonder why people aren't proud of their liberal mind-set as well.

Perhaps it's because liberals believe.....

That it's alright to tax productivity and subsidize non-productivity.

That it's alright to pay children to have children.

That the United States national security needs should be determined or approved, either all or in part, by foreign leaders and the United Nations.

That a person's medical care should be paid for by someone other than the person receiving the care.

That abortion on demand should be the law.

That we should save the whales, but not the unborn.

That women should serve in combat roles.

That government should dictate to private business how they run their private business.

That a person can't save for his own retirement without government approval.

That a person's retirement savings can't be passed on to his/her children after that person's death.

That there really is a Social Security Trust fund.

That global warming is more of a threat than nuclear proliferation.

That it's alright to take a dollar from the person who earned it and give it to a person who didn't earn it.

That taxpayers should pay for the medical care and education of people who've entered the country illegally.

That doctors should be targets of multi-million dollar "punitive damage" lawsuits - the real costs of which are passed onto the medical consumers.

That pharmaceutical companies should be targets of multi-million dollar "punitive damage" lawsuits. (Why do you think they didn't manufacture any flu vaccine this year?)

That cigarette smokers should be taxed, but heroin users should be given free needles.

That other people should pay for smokers' health care after they become victims of their own self-destructive behavior.

That equality of opportunity really means equality of outcome.

That people should be categorized by the color of their skin.

That the parents a child (the ones they choose not to abort) do not have a right to choose which school that child attends.

That people shouldn't be given the opportunity to take self-responsibility.

.....and they just don't want to admit it.

Hey, vote for John Kerry and get the most liberal agenda in the Senate. You can't get one without the other.

by protiusx

Here we go again?
The President responded to the intelligence he was given at the time and made the right choice. He is and always has been concerned with the wellbeing of this country. Should that not be his first priority given that he is the commander in chief?
You are running your points together so number two follows along with number one. How can one lie when what one says one believes to be the truth? A lie is when one deliberately says something that one knows not to be true. Just ask William Jefferson Clinton about that. He was tried and convicted of it.
Halliburton was awarded the no-bid contract because they were the only company that was able to fulfill the needs at the time. You know that but like the other liberals out there you hate that which opposes you so you will reach for anything to chant as you burn your flags in effigy.
When did he lie about the cost of medical expenses? He has consistently stated that the cost of medical care in this country is sky rocketing and it is that way because of the growing cost of medical malpractice insurance.

by aldanatech

I guess I didn't make my point clear enough, or as usual you misunderstood me. I'll try it once again and let?s see if you get it this time: Democrat, conservative, Republican, liberal, Libertarian, whatever, all of that is irrelevant in my voting decisions. The kind of leaders that I vote for are the ones that have a clear understanding of what is going one, what the issues are, and have a solid set of proposals to address them. Bush doesn't reach those qualities to the point that actual president should have. John Kerry however, does. That is why I'm voting for him. Not only that, Bush turned out to show a great deal of incompetence throughout his entire administration. The country deserves a President that can put us back in the fast lane, and that of course is John Kerry.

by admin

Yep, the thread is to long so I'm replying to the reply of your thread Max, but I believe 4 states were won by the American Party with Wallace.

Since 1988 the Libertarians have recieved enough votes to maintain political-body status, but of course they are not poised to win more than 3% of the vote- which even figured in to your election day Presidential estimates -taking every Libertarian vote and giving it en masse either to Bush or Kerry would not change the election one iota. It could theoretically possibly change the popular vote slightly enough to make Americans more aware of the Electoral College process- but it will not change the election at all, because, as you have elequontly established, the electorate is really all that matters and for good reasons.

I do think I have found the real reason Bush will win though, and intend to post the link right after I reply to this :)

by maxwell edison

.
I realize that you are a "vote for the person" guy, and not a "vote for the party" guy.

And I also realize, in my humble opinion, that you, as a result, are a very naive' voter. You don't truly understand how our system works.

You may think that you are voting for "the best person" for the job, but the results of voting for that person have much wider consequences and repercussions than just winning a popularity contest.

So I understand all too well. I just happened to disagree with it.

So I would say to you. You just don't get it.

by maxwell edison

.
I'm not suggesting that Republicans are carrying on the polarization that the Democrats started. To the contrary, all they are doing is fending-off the incessant attacks. You don't see from the Republicans, as a rule, the mean-spirited demonization of people like the Democrats carry out - in concert. First they demonize Ronald Reagan, then Clearance Thomas, then Newt Gingrich, now it's George Bush. You just don't see that, as a rule, from the Republicans. They then carry it further and launch the mean-spirited attacks on different classes of people. You always hear the Democrats demonize evil big-business, or the greedy rich class, or the intolerant white people, or this class or that class. It's the Democrats who polarize, then they turn it around and blame others for the very thing that they, alone, are doing. They - the Democrats - are the epitome of mean-spiritedness and hypocrisy.

All you have to do is look at these threads. You see such a deep-seated hatred of an individual, namely George W. Bush, along with all the vile and contempt that comes with it. It's absolutely disgusting, and I'm not a party to it. In fact, I've even tried to help them see the self-destructive nature of their ill-feelings. You just haven't seen such attacks on John Kerry or any other Democrat on these threads or in the general population. Sure, you might see an isolated case of similar attacks from the right, but it's the exception, not the rule. Today, with the Democrats and Democrat Party, it's the rule, not the exception.

Moreover, it's for that very reason - the Michael Moores of the world - that a big turnout will result in a big win for GWB. I'm not the only one disgusted by it, and others will let their disgust be heard by their vote. And the Democrats just don't get it - they're absolutely blinded by their self-destructive hate. And it's that very hate that started - and that sustains - the polarization.

Republicans would welcome a real dialogue and debate on the issues - the REAL issues, not the contrived issues, those contrived issues born of hate and contempt. Just look at how aladentech evaded my messages that related to the real issues. But they can't argue those issues on their own merit, so they have to resort to their attack tactics. And after all these years, that's simply become the trademark of the Democrats. And that is sad.

by delbertpgh

Yow, Max, you've really turned me around with that one. You're right... there's just no end to Democratic mean-spiritedness... how can you compare the demonization of Ronald Reagan or Newt with... oh gosh, the Clintons? Why, compared with the heartless abuse we heaped on poor Ronnie, the impeachment and the Vince Foster conspiracy stories just look like love pats... yeah, like therapy, really. For their own good. And the Swift Boat crew... another well-meaning attempt to set politics up on a more high-minded plane. Yup, no comparison at all. Don't know how my fellow Democrats ever got the idea there was any partisan hate originating out of the right wing. What illusions.

by jamesrl

I can't pinpoint the moment that this kind of thing started. No doubt it precedes my birth.

But an outsider like myself can clearly see that for every Michael Moore there is an Ann Coulter.

I would argue that the attacks on John Kerry regarding his military service, some of which were funded by leading republicans(not necessarily members of the Bush campaign, but close friends of the campaign), are just as bad or worse than Michael Moore's rants. And I can go on -Bill O'Reilly's verbal abuse of the son of the victim of 9/11, Rush Limbaugh etc.

Its self feeding - your two parties feed each others hate.

If we take a look at Canadian politics - its much more civil. We had a long time politician, committ the theft of a diamond ring, during a time of personal crisis. Though no one sought to excuse this act, people from all parties sought to recognize that in balance, given all the good work the guy had done over the years, we should put it in perspective, and not seek jail time.

Max, you have attempted to stay away from personal attacks, though you will have to admit you haven't always been successful. But the Republican party has not got such a clean record, for decades at least. The Democrats are no better.

James

by maxwell edison

.
I'm not suggesting that Republicans are carrying on the polarization that the Democrats started. To the contrary, all they are doing is fending-off the incessant attacks. You don't see from the Republicans, as a rule, the mean-spirited demonization of people like the Democrats carry out - in concert. First they demonize Ronald Reagan, then Clearance Thomas, then Newt Gingrich, now it's George Bush. You just don't see that, as a rule, from the Republicans. They then carry it further and launch the mean-spirited attacks on different classes of people. You always hear the Democrats demonize evil big-business, or the greedy rich class, or the intolerant white people, or this class or that class. It's the Democrats who polarize, then they turn it around and blame others for the very thing that they, alone, are doing. They - the Democrats - are the epitome of mean-spiritedness and hypocrisy.

All you have to do is look at these threads. You see such a deep-seated hatred of an individual, namely George W. Bush, along with all the vile and contempt that comes with it. It's absolutely disgusting, and I'm not a party to it. In fact, I've even tried to help them see the self-destructive nature of their ill-feelings. You just haven't seen such attacks on John Kerry or any other Democrat on these threads or in the general population. Sure, you might see an isolated case of similar attacks from the right, but it's the exception, not the rule. Today, with the Democrats and Democrat Party, it's the rule, not the exception.

Moreover, it's for that very reason - the Michael Moores of the world - that a big turnout will result in a big win for GWB. I'm not the only one disgusted by it, and others will let their disgust be heard by their vote. And the Democrats just don't get it - they're absolutely blinded by their self-destructive hate. And it's that very hate that started - and that sustains - the polarization.

Republicans would welcome a real dialogue and debate on the issues - the REAL issues, not the contrived issues, those contrived issues born of hate and contempt. Just look at how aladentech evaded my messages that related to the real issues. But they can't argue those issues on their own merit, so they have to resort to their attack tactics. And after all these years, that's simply become the trademark of the Democrats. And that is sad.

by cactus pete

I respectfully disagree. I wouldn't blame either side for starting it, but I'm pretty sure both sides have deep emotional outbursts regarding members of the other party going back a long way...

I think you've missed the Rushes of the world, the Carter bashers, the JFK bashers... I'm sure it goes on and on.

[Note: I'm not pointing out the other side, as you already have.]

But why stop there, really? There are more facets: The Greenie Terrorists, the PETA extremists, the abortion clinic bombers, religious zealots of all stripes, McCartyists, etc and etc...

The two main parties are simply "keeping up with the Joneses" - and this is what disgusts me. This is why I cannot commit my life to civic service as a politician. A pity, really.

by rob.mangus

If the election was determined by popular vote then candidates would campaign in the areas believed to deliver the greatest number of votes per dollar spent campaigning. Because we have an electoral college candidates do the same kind of thing and campaign where they believe they will get the greatest number of votes per dollar spent only now they have to cover more than just the large cities.

by cactus pete

Maybe I just need to see the numbers in everyone's example.. But I don't see how the electoral college makes a candidate expend more effort than they would have otherwise.

States with large cities have large electoral college numbers as well. Most campaign speaches are in the larger cities of whatever state the candidate is targeting. Certainly, the TV ads are broadcast from a center of population...

What do we have today? 10 states where the campaigning happens? And they happen to be the mid-level electoral college counts...

When people use the argument that candidates will only campaign in large cities, they ignore the fact that the majority of Americans don't live in large cities, which is all I'm trying to point out, I suppose. So I see little difference...

This discussion is closed to new replies.