Discussion Locked

If you can read this, you're a TR Insider!

0 helpful
60 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Greetings, and welcome to the TR Insider's private forum. If you have found your way here, that means you are one of the 15 hand-picked TechRepublic members who have been invited to help redesign and redefine the TR community.

Out of more than 300,000 members, you 15 were selected on the basis of your extraordinary level of involvement in the TR Discussion Center and Tech Q&A. You and your 14 fellow Insiders are the only TR members who can access, post to, search against, or even see this discussion forum. It's your own private universe, where the 15 of you will be able to speak directly with the TechRepublic staffers charged with rebuilding our entire community system.

Our goal is nothing less than making TechRepublic the best and most indispensable forum for technology professionals in the world. We're starting with our best members, and asking you to help us make that dream a reality.

Look for an e-mail in the next few days, formally welcoming you into this group and asking that you tell us more about yourselves (so that we can brag about you to the other technology Web sites). Until then, feel free to start posting your thoughts and ideas for improving TechRepublic, and mingling with your fellow TRIs. After all, you've earned it.

We look forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely,

The Community Redevelopment Team

Rex Baldazo (RexWorld)
Beth Blakely (beth.blakely)
Paul Cook (pcook)
Jay Garmon (The Trivia Geek)
Mark Kaelin (MKaelin)
Shawn Morton (sMoRTy71)
Ted Smith (tsmith)

60 replies

by maxwell edison

.
I've been hanging around this site for a long time, been involved in more discussions that I probably should have, answered more questions that I can possibly remember, and have seen a lot of improvements over the years. I'm glad to see that you keep looking for whatever will make it even better.

by maxwell edison

.
If you're going to only converse with 15 members, my vote would go to include the following:

TheChas
Joseph Moore
dklippert

Joseph Moore and dklippert don't seem to hang around the discussion forum too often, so if they don't post a reply, I'd hope that you'd send them an email anyway. Especially dklippert. It's been a while since I've visited it, but he put together a Web site that's organized all of his MS Office (and other) issues, and it's quite impressive - at least it was the last time I saw it. (Isn't he also an instructor and tech. writer?)

by oz_media

Whn I first came here, content was very limited, participation was down and it was just another tech site (as you all know tere are many).

Since the last revamp, some great changes have occurred yet there is still room for little bugs and tweaks here and there, I look forward to seeing where this all goes.

Does this mean we will actually get the TR coffee mugs that were supposed to be sent out.....I don't remember it was too long ago now.
(Why not take this chance to get a little shot in ?!) :)

Look forward to hearing from you and working to build the site up.

OM

by zlitocook

Well I have been using the internet for a long time! And I have great ideas, for your site. I still like the idea of a new user area, so the people who are just starting out with computers can get help with out negative comments. I have given away alot of points to new users so they stay around and keep posting. Can you make a new user area for a faq and a link to help for new useers?

by Jay Garmon

Part of our thinking right now is an escalating scale of site privileges, based on demonstrated skill and interaction. In other words, the more expertise you have, the "deeper" into the site you can progress, and the more toys you'll have to play with. The idea is that this would let newbies operate in peace in the general access areas while offering experts some designated areas where they can commune with their peers.

Good idea, or are we way off track here?

by oz_media

but it would have to be far more detailed to pass judgement on it though.

What benefits would there be other than talking to more experienced peers?
Better content, free whitepapers and downloads, maybe free TPGuild or some other form of pay content that would actually motivate people to achieve more, work to increase points etc. other than merely being able to talk to others with more points, thus creating an elitists section of TR.

by Jay Garmon

The big picture idea is just making Tech Q&A (or whatever that evolves into) more useful because you'll have a very clear picture of the qualifications of the guy answering your queries. As for what features would be used to entice that achievement, you've provided a pretty interesting list, but we were thinking about offering stuff that isn't available on the site right now.

It's VERY early in the discussion process (that's why you guys are here, to help vet ideas), but we've talked about enhanced private messaging features, gated groups, privileged blogging systems with RSS syndication and promotion, privileged Web-based email accounts, and, on the whole, a hyperextended recognition system that would make rock stars out of our top performers.

Oh, and I forgot to mention a whole suite of social networking features geared at developing online/offline groups that could collaborate for common purposes, meet socially, and compete in TR sanctioned contests for fortune and glory (not just for TechPoints, but actual tangible prizes of financially significant nature).

But that's just the first draft.

What do you think, and what would you like?

by oz_media

great list of ideas, needs some thought. in this case (and only this once!) I will actually put some thought into it and see if I can offer any tangible ideas.

I just didn't like the sound of creating an UPPER level, it removes the term 'peer' from the whole site.

Believe me, IT staff turned ROCK STAR's is not what you want. I have enough trouble with professionals becoming Prima Donna's, I cringe at the idea of inflating an IT ego.

I do like the idea of a TECH SUPPORT FOR DUMMIES section. Kinda like the many well written books for Dummies. New users, seasoned IT pros with daunting issues to resolve etc. But to create an UPPER level of peers wil just get nasty.

Increasing member benefits for active participants is nice, opening up new content areas and such, but to consider some people ABOVE others due to spcialization, I just can't see being welcomed.

Perhaps specialty groups, such as security pros, Windows 2K Pros etc. would work.

I think the discussion forums are filled with may people with Prima Donna attitudes and they just feel so clever because well versed in one area. IMHO, the tech sector is the wrong place for an ego boost.

by Jay Garmon

...and we certainly don't want to create an intimidating atmosphere. We're actually looking to--if you'll excuse the term--"expose" people who have only one area of expertise and are a bit nasty about it.

We want to create a recognition system that identifies both the type and level of your expertise. If you're a Win2K genius and a Linux newbie, we want to recognize both those strengths and weaknesses so that your Win2K opinions are respected, and your Linux pronouncements are, shall we say, taken with a grain of salt.

Under this system, almost everyone would be newbie-level at something, so both the establishment and our members would have to be a little humble and newbie friendly, to a certain extent.

by hal 9000

In the Q & A section would be to have the questions asked have some closure to. As if the recommended fixes actually work.

It is part of the reason why I stopped answering questions as while I might know a little bit there is always room to learn a lot more and that was just something that I was not getting by answering questions. They just seemed to peter out without resolve.

Col

by hal 9000

I visited the Q & A section after listing the above and I placed some answers to 6 questions.

I've just had a look and every one is now closed with every answer either rejected or not rated. Also no solution was reached or listed.

I even had one of the people actually e-mail me for more information on how to do something.

Now I really do not mind helping in the slightest but the current situation just seems to be wasting our time and effort. I'm in no way insinuating that I provided the total correct answers or for that matter even a part way correct answer but on every question they have all been closed with out a result being listed either way. We can hardly learn from this can we?

Col

by oz_media

Like some kind of video game ranking system for fighters or something.

Er......like in Ghost recon, a specialist can have excellent leadership skills, great accuracy but poor energy.

So you could have a bar chart system, ie: Level 7 windows, Level 9 security, level 1 Linux etc.

When they reach a level 10 in on category, it gives then a new star or states they are LEVEL 2 but then the bars ae at zero until they eventually reach level 3 etc.

When a Linux or Windows answer is rejected, the level drops for that topic and so forth.

have I spent too much time gaming this week? :p

just a thought.

by maxwell edison

Jay,

On the All Questions page (from the View All Open Questions Link), I'd like to see the category in which the question was posted. Your five columns currently are the question number, the question title, the date, the status, and the points. How about adding a Question Category column as well (such as PC Troubleshooting, Windows, NetWare, Careers, etc.)?

I realize that the purpose of the "Open" column is connected to your filter options, but the default is to show only the open questions. And since we get there from following the View All OPEN Questions link......

Perhaps you can replace the Status column with a Category column, or just add a sixth column.

Thanks,

Maxwell

by Jay Garmon

We've talked about doing away with the division of Discussions and Tech Q&A, especially since so many users don't relize there is a difference. Instead, we've discussed folding the two back together, with the option of flagging a thread as a question (and later as a solved question).

As part of this, we'd give the users a whole range of sorting options, so you could search/sort against the category, the poster, whether it was a question, and whether those questions are open or closed.

Would this be useful, or are we going too far?

by oz_media

nothing is more of a pain in the ass than opening up some thread you THINK is a discussion on IT, only to find someone doesn't know what AdAware is or doesn't know how to enter a descriptive title.

I think a GET SOME HELp section would be great, nobody understand what Tech Q%A is and how it differs from Discussions, I think that is the main reason the two get lumped together so often.

IMHO, Discussions are somewhere I go when I feel like chatting with peers, if I want to help users with questions or ask one myself I go there instead. It's nice to have them separated.

I think it just needs to be CLEARLY defined in more than an unformatted text paragraph on the entry pages.

GET HELP WITH YOUR TECHINCAL QUESTIONS, or something similar is much more explanatory, and all along (hate to be a broken recod) the DISCUSSIONS link is STILL before the Tech Q&A link, when people are frantically trying to get answers they may post to four or five similar sites (all in the general discussions forums) they come to TR and lo and behold DISCUSSIONS!

The navigation here has always needed some tweaking in that respect I think.

OOOh and one more thing, sorry, how about a nice dark colored background similar to the one you use on the Builder.com site? The extra contrast really helps simlify the look and feel of the pages!

by hal 9000

They are and maybe make it easier for the newbies to see the Q &A section as there is nothing worse than on a long thread just how things get sidetracked onto different tangents. While great for discussion forums it would be very counterproductive to the person asking the "Question!"

I think it would put off a lot of new members and the current system of auto generated responses to asked questions is great if you have a particularly nasty one where you need help ASAP. Honestly I have always got far better responses to any question about MS products I've asked here on TR than from MS itself. Even if I do not get the correct answer it at the very least starts you thinking in different directions which always lead to a solution and I quite happily post the fix before I close the question. Which a lot of others do not do which is very off putting to me as when you take the time to attempt to answer the questions and they get closed without a result you do not learn anything new and there is no need to reinvent the wheel every time that a problem arises If we have seen a solution posted previously it just makes things so much easier than fixing the problem from scratch when others have already done the same thing.

Col

by thechas

I think part of the problem that newbies have with the T Q&A section is the title and the description of what the section is for.

I suggest that the T Q&A section be renamed something along the lines of Computer help, Help I have A computer problem, or something similar.

Then, change the opening page description from:

" Join our community of IT pros in a free marketplace of questions and answers about technical, strategic, and career development issues."

Ask our community your questions about problems with your hardware, software and systems.

I think it is the "IT pros" in the current statement that causes some new users to post questions in the discussion section.

The title Technical Questions and Answers is too close to what many web sites use for FAQ's and user support.

Perhaps we even need 4 forums.
General computer help.

Help specifically for system administrators and related IT professionals.

IT related Technical Discussions.

The "Water Cooler" for the "off-topic" discussions.

Access to the IT pro questions section could use the proposed privilege system.
People posting questions would need to have full profiles that confirm that they work in the IT field.

Those posting answers would need to be either in the field, or to have shown proven expertise.

Then, email notifications to users with open questions need to be beefed up.

After 1 month, rather than the old auto-close, perhaps in the case of either no answers posted, or no answers rated, the question should be auto-withdrawn.
Charge the peer who posted the question the number of points specified, and place the points in a pool for a weekly or monthly points promotion.

I'll try to add more later. My brain is going numb. Blame it on all the time I spend here after working 60 hour weeks for the past 6 months.

Chas

by Jay Garmon

I had no idea people were so fond of the current Tech Q&A setup. Good to know. As to the issue of people never closing questions, how about enforcing a "one open question" rule, where you can't ask a second question without closing your first. That probably won't solve the issue of people wandering in, asking one "homework" question and never returning, but it will help for regular members. That, perhaps tied to the required profile system some of you have suggested, could do a lot to curb this behavior.

Or am I being blindly optimistic here?

Jay

by hal 9000

Even a psychotic loony like me was asked to join in so your not in such good company.

After all who in all honestly would take an Aliases of an AI who went mad and killed the entire crew of a space ship?

Col

by willcomp

I feel honored and humbled to have been placed in such illustrious company. Not yet sure why, other than I griped about number of answers with no ratings.

TR is best site I have been a member of. Especially impressed with depth of content, general accuracy of answers, and cost (nada).

Dalton

by apotheon

This was a nice present to find in my inbox today. I seem to make an impression everywhere I go (not all good impressions, but that's okay too).

I'm glad to be given an opportunity to "give back", as it were.

by Jay Garmon

Last week, all fifteen of you should have received an e-mail message welcoming you to the TR Insiders, and asking you to tell us about yourselves.

We haven't received responses (even opt-outs) from several of you. Did anyone fail to receive the message (maybe because a spam filter or Outlook rule caught it)?

In simplest terms, we want fifteen active and involved members to help us start testing features and developing online relationships. If that doesn't interest you, no harm, no foul, no hrad feelings. But we do need to clear the spot for other nominees.

Please respond to the e-mail invitation (which will be resent today) by noon, EST, Thursday, Nov. 4. If we have not received a response by then, we'll have to clear your spot for another member.

Thanks,

Jay

by oz_media

I am assuming you are referring to the info we discussd previously and that you have me up to date okay? Or did I miss something else?

by Jay Garmon

...and greatly appreciated. As were e-mails from e.lockett, ozi_eagle, and tksolway, We're still waiting on everyone else, but all your nominations have been taken to heart, and we'll start inviting a second wave to fill our slots at the end of the week.

by hal 9000

I did get the invitation but when I first attempted to log on I got the Page not Available Screen for about 2 days.

I could get into other areas of TR without a problem well hardly a problem as on some threads I would get random page unavailable listings but I could go back a page and sometimes just trying refreshing the page would bring it up.

Col

by Jay Garmon

Our tentative plan is to reveal some feature, mockup, or beta test every Thursday, so that the TRI group can critique/test it and give us feedback, which will directly affect the next iteration of the feature. It's sort of our version of Must See TV.

In any case, those of you who have attained TR Insider status should make it a point to check this forum area every Thursday for a new thread, which will include links to our latest reveal.

Feel free to discuss these items with non-TRI members, but we'd ask that you don't repost any of the links outside the private TR Insiders forum area. This is equal parts for security reasons and because we don't want to overwhelm any of the test environments these features might reside on, since they aren't designed for high-level traffic.

See you on Thursday

Jay

by oz_media

Just like a help desk. YOu can get basic PC help from all users, if it goes unresolved you can escalate it to the next tier of IT support based on thier merits and nobody else can respond.

Tier two members could always help in tier one support but if they didn't want to be bothered with the simple tasks, they could just focus on the tier two issues etc.

by Jay Garmon

Using member levels to control who is allowed to answer a certain question...very intriguing idea. However, my only fear is that everyone would escalate their answer to the highest level immediately, and our All-Stars would get slammed with tedious newbie questions that lower tiers could answer. But the concept is certainly worth examining.

by oz_media

Rejectable, is that a word?)

Perhaps you could make it so that 'tier 2' support could actually reject it or send it back to the 'tier 1' level.

OR

Perhaps make it mandatory that it have been at least responded to once by tier one help, nah....I dunno.

by hal 9000

Myself as a "Newbie" to almost every level as hardly a day goes by without me learning something new.

I firmly believe that the day I stop learning new things is the day I give it all away as by that time I would have become far too smug for my own good.

Col

by willcomp

Tech Republic makes it too easy for new users to sign up. That may explain the number of facetious questions seen lately and poor answer rating results.

Recommend requiring essentially same information as for peer listings. Don't recall if TR verifies eMail addresses, but, if not, need to do so.

I don't believe registration should be onerous, but weeding out pranksters and site shoppers would help those of us who answer questions.

Some of you older TR members (who are probably much younger than I) weigh in on this.

Dalton

Answered this somewhat by checking out Peer Directory discussion.

by hal 9000

Water Cooler side of things for a short time may do some good. I can remember the very first time I posted something there.

It was something about "Rouge States" and I honestly asked who was to decide who a Rouge State actually was.

Needless to say with the responses that I got and all the personal attacks leveled at me my first thoughts where I don't need this rubbish. If it had not been for one particular TR Member who e-mailed me personally and encouraged me to continue posting I would never have returned.

So maybe it might be a good idea to keep this side of TR closed to all new members until they get a feel for TR and what it is actually about.

Col

by oz_media

Perhaps read only rights untilhitting a certain level of points or merit.

Then people would read our rants and be itching to get two cents in, perhaps encouraging them to hit Q&A and earn some merits.

Then I suggest water tortrue followed by bamboo under the fingernails, and then stringing....well you get the picture, make it a member privalege to participate off topic.

by oz_media

I an not sure about the one question issue, perhaps if done along along with a timed closure if the question is not updated, or closed after 30 days, then the points are automatically divided up between any and all respondents?

Have you thought about changing the name of the links though? IMHO, it is so simple and yet imperative in order to differentiate between them, and moving the links apart would help too I think. Content is is said to be useless if navigation isn't laid out properly.

by hal 9000

Limit those of us who run into some serious problems and instead of posting several different questions they would all get grouped into the one.

While I'm the first to admit it has so far {touch wood} never happened to me I can see the possibility of needing to post a couple of different questions on different subjects at the same time.

Those who are only after a fast fix for assignments tend to place these in the Discussion area anyway so it just might be more of a hindrance than a help.

Only my thoughts and I'd welcome comments about these.

Col

by oz_media

If a peer could flag a discussion as not belonging to discussions and an editor or whoever verifies it, it would help get rid of senselessly dropped discussions as well as Q&A's.

Sort of like a part time moderator, who just gets notified of flags and verifies them, once a week even.

by hal 9000

I don't know what this person is doing as he obviously knows very little doesn't he?

I liked the way you forgot to mention the fact that with XP it can only recognize 10 workstations on a peer to per network and that XP home can not be used on a domain.

Max beside the obvious I'd give you a 100% for that answer as within the confines of the original question your "Unrated Answer" is correct. But I think this is a case of someone wanting a quick answer without needing to apply them self at all. If it was me I'd call it cheating.

Col

by willcomp

Judging from previous questions by the same individual, I rather doubt it was a classroom exercise.

From this one and prior questions, I suspect he is an independent "expert" in over his head. He needs to do more research and become more competent. Here are 2 of his previous questions.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6251-0.html?forumID=55&threadID=161744&start=0&tag=search

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6251-0.html?forumID=48&threadID=162972&start=0&tag=search

Here's another one ya'll might enjoy. Guess I don't know much.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6239-0.html?forumID=47&threadID=163286&start0

Dalton

by thechas

I like the basic idea of limiting the number of open questions from a single user. However, I think 1 open question is too restrictive.

Perhaps a tiered system starting with a 3 question limit. Expanding to 5 or 10 based on the users question closing history.

Or, if a question is left open for more than 30 days, restrict them from asking more questions until they close the old ones.

Chas

by willcomp

Prohibiting new questions with open question >30 days old is a good suggestion.

However, I think TheChas is too lenient on number of open questions. Initial limit of 2 and max of 5 would seem about right to me.

Dalton

by hal 9000

Isn't that torture enough?

We both know exactly what it's like to walk in after someone has totally messed things up and have some jerk {most likely the person who did the damage in the first place} pushing us for the quick fix.

However restricting the area where we just blow off a bit of steam is a good idea.

How is this one at 11.00 PM Saturday night I got a call from a Surgeon who I built a LT for about 4 months ago and he is leaving AU for a medical conference Thursday and wants a replacement LT for the one he had stolen Saturday by the 11-11-04 and these are a "Special Order" with at least a 2 day wait in Sydney and then T'Port up here. I'll get it sometime Wednesday and most likely be dropping it off at the Airport as he leaves. Thank GOG I have a backup of his HDD.

Col

by willcomp

I'm afraid what you experienced has become the exception rather than the rule. Answers rejected with no explanation (even though they fit problem description), questions not closed, and sometimes snotty remarks.

I sometimes wonder if they even understand the answer or have enough expertise to try suggestions. Feedback would be helpful rather than Rejected for no good reason.

But then there is the rare occasion when someone expresses gratitude for helping them out of a sticky situation. These almost make up for the nitwits.

Dalton

Got first sentence bassackwards. Has become rule rather than exception.

by hal 9000

I started answering questions was not only to help others but to learn more as I'm certainly no "Expert" and I think that most of us here would say the same thing.

What I find really concerning is the way that society in general is going they expect answers quickly for their problems and never consider thanking the person who provided the answer or like in the case of TR T Q & A section leaving final results. On a lot of the Q & A that I've participated in I have always seemed to get the impression that there are those who are willing to ask a question and then when answered close it down without awarding points, which in its self isn't much of a worry to me but some form of finalizing the question would be appreciated.

After all most of us are IT professionals and we do not need to reinvent the wheel every time we run into a problem that most likely someone else has run across previously.

Col

by oz_media

Yeah right, Phhhhhhhhhhhhhhtt :p

Funny though I was talkng to a guy this afternon about a 'primad donna' in his office. I guessed that probably 75% of IT staff, especially new, have Prima Donna syndrome and it is to be expected but it will die over time, as it has over the last few years, because IT is becoming a mainstream skill and not such an elite occupation now.

I do get sick of the "I know everything about computers, but your case is odd" crowd though. :D
OR
Every other computer does this just fine. I don't know what's up with YOURS though."

It seems that these guys/gals always seem to know everything BUT the problem they are working on.

by hal 9000

X being the unknown quantie &

a Spurt is nothing but a drip under pressure!

I've currently got one of these and for the third time in 2 weeks he is in the process of reloading a computer that I built for him 3 months ago. Funny thing is it worked perfectly until he got it out of the office and into his home which was about 2 weeks ago.

1.5 Hours on the phone talking him through formatting the HDD but the best thing was last time I was down there I caught him trying to Flash the BIOS from the command line in XP Pro.

Well it certainly isn't boring and as it's 120 K round trip I much prefer to talk on the phone and get other work done rather than spend far more time driving down there for 5 minutes work.

He does scare me though because he is considered as an expert by his mother who runs the company and he told her that SP2 would work perfectly with her computer again one that I built and supplied 3 months ago. Funny thing was that after he installed SP2 I was called in to get it to run something about the BIOS and not addressing the P4 CPU properly. And even though I had already turned off Auto Update and instructed that company by e-mail and letter not to consider installing SP2 until I had more time to test it against what they are using guess who's fault it was that the computer didn't work and this was done at the end of the month when all the financial stuff has to be done. Funnily enough I didn't get paid from them that month. But I did get a phone call complaining about the nonworking computer at 3.30 pm and after I went down there they just had to complain that they wanted to leave at 5.00 pm at the end of the day. Well I did have 25 minutes to fix the thing up and test all the critical software.

Now I'll get back to my Intel on line training building "cyborg" computers with poor descriptions on what is required.

Col

by maxwell edison

.
Yea, right - I "forgot" to mention those things. Yea, "forgot", that's the ticket.

But he could have done wonders with a simple and inexpensive 12 port switch and a single router.

by hal 9000

That was outside the terms of the assignment.

And as you quite rightly said you didn't need to do all his home work for him did you?

Col

by maxwell edison

.
Using three routers in such a case is just silly, unless I'm missing something.

Use one router, one switch, end of story.

Unless you can tell me why he'd want 3 routers? Heck, routers can be a real PITA (My own acronym). Why triple the PITA factor if you don't have to? And cost isn't an issue, as one switch could be just as inexpensive, or more so, than two routers. And the way it was asked just made it seem like a test question designed to get a student to think a little.

Am I missing something?

(Actually I like the challenge of trying to figure it out - both the "assignment" and the guy's motives.)

by thechas

I have had a few email correspondences with cyberghost. As Dalton suggests, he is in way over his head with any thing beyond a very simple network.

I'm not positive, but I believe he is outside of the US. And thus may be the best tech in his area.

Chas

by hal 9000

Sorry but I'm still laughing from the last question as if the person actually took the time to read the shutdown screen they would know exactly what was happening.

But about the other two and the one that Max posted they are all about Internet caf?s and all with limited time constraints so I'm guessing that they are assignment questions that have not been looked at until near closing time for the assignment and the person is panicking and looking for the easy out by not actually learning what he/she is suspose to already know.

Col

by apotheon

While I don't think Oz_Media's "bar charts" idea is perfect as presented, it does raise (implicitly) a very good point: What I think would likely be most useful here is some kind of quantitative measure of skill and helpfulness in various categories of IT knowledge.

I'm not sure that extra benefits should be granted based on such "advancement", though. Perhaps, instead, additional features and resource acesses could instead be granted by spending points gained as those ratings increase. For instance, perhaps someone gets a central pool of points that receives another point every time a rating goes up by one. Those points could be used to "purchase" a web email account at TR, and more might be spent to grant the ability to make it a forwarding or POP3 account. "Spending" the points, of course, wouldn't affect the rating: these values would have to be tracked separately.

As another option, perhaps instead of a point-expenditure system there could simply be a set of activities on the site where there are varying levels of affect an individual can have. For instance, features that involve allowing TR members to "vote" on things relating to the site: if that issue happens to fall within an area wherein a member has a very high rating, that rating might modify the amount of clout he or she has when voting. Votes from someone with a rating in Mac hardware that is twice as high as my own (not a difficult thing to achieve, I'm afraid) might have votes that are worth twice as much as mine in that area.

These rating statistics could also be displayed on user profiles, so that people that view the profiles can get an idea of what a given person has contributed to the community in that area and how useful his or her comments are likely to be on various subjects (as has already been suggested).

. . . my two pence.

by apotheon

It seems to me that there needs to be a couple of requirements for Q&A entries:

1. One shouldn't be able to reject an answer without either posting or sending a comment about why.

2. One shouldn't be able to close out a question without posting a resolution status.

I'm not sure about the back end to the Q&A section, but it seems to me that this set of changes should be a doable addition to site functionality.

by apotheon

The tiered system seems like a great idea to me.

I like the rejection idea. Perhaps, for rejection, it would require three members of the higher tier to reject an item or, alternatively, one rejection and a certain amount of time to pass with no other responses (other than rejections).

It seems to me that rejections (or at least the first rejection "vote") should require a statement of the reason that the rejection was issued.

Escalating support requests, by the way, should probably only be possible after a question has sat unresolved for a minimum period of time. This would help to cut down on the number of auto-escalations that occur just because people think their own questions are That Important.

I'd also think that it would be a good idea to allow the question submitter to de-escalate his or her own requests for support.

by apotheon

There's a possible problem there, in that raising the bar to entry for participation runs the risk of just alienating everyone. It certainly reduces the "community" feel, if done incautiously.

I think that I'd probably be inclined, at most, to just make people sign up in the peer listing to post, grating read-only rights to anyone that happens by. Anything more demanding than that is likely to cause problems.

by oz_media

First of all, welcome to our special little corner of TR, I've seen some great input here so far, I think it will prove very constructive for TR and ourselves.

To make sure I am clear, my last suggestion is just referring to the Miscellaneous or 'BS' forum, where we bicker and argue about who killed who, even when it's supposed to be a happy occasion. :)

The reason is because there have been a lot of VERY heated and often ballistic sessions in the Misc forums. People have a tendency of hitting a TR discussion from a web search, then they just come by to start flaming and jumping in with the most absurd crap that has already been churned over and over again. After that they are gone.

Generally these people will just stir it up, they have no care about an IT community etc. Just to scream a bit and be heard.

I can accept this and dish it out just fine between the peers here, but when others just jump in with a ridicuous alias and no other information just for the sake of bitching, I am not interested.

If you needed some points or credit in order to join such discussions, the 'drop-ins' would end. Also, there has been a regular issue with people creating multiple aliases, just to gang up on people or reinforce their own point, this would also end immediately if a rating system was used. It would solve a LOT of common issues here, but again JUST for that ONE forum.

We have earned the right to argue between ourselves and call each other nasty names, then we all help each other out in Q&A.

by apotheon

Thanks for the welcome. I'm pleased as punch to be here.

I didn't realize you were speaking of one, limited section. I'd have to reevaluate what I said based on that. You may have a point there.

I'll defer to more informed minds. Heh. I'll pry my foot out of my mouth, too.

by hal 9000

It's hard to get a handle on what been going on durring a discussion when you come in late for whatever reason.

Welcome to this little corner of TR I hope you enjoy and have a lot of constructive suggestions.

Cheers Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.