Discussion Locked

I'll start the ball rolling on Arnie!

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Arnie gets elected Governor of California!

Seeing as we like things 'political' on here, what do we all think about this? Speaking as a Brit, I say why not?!! After all there is precedent for this in the USA. Didn't another two-bit actor make it big in politics? Oh yes, Ronnie Regan, bless his socks! And it's not only in the USA. Here in Britain we have several celebrities who have turned to politics and done rather well. Glenda Jackson, an accomplished actress (if you don't believe me, look her up on www.imdb.com) is a Member of Parliament. Sean Connery is very active in Scottish politics, and that's just two for starters.

Perhaps when we are so sick of promises by mainstream politicians we are happy to let someone else have a go? After all, they couldn't be any worse, can they? Maybe we SHOULD all be voting for the personaliy rather than 'the party line'? Arnie has made a comfortable living up to now making people happy. Now he is in charge of the world's 7th largest economy (not best....largest - California is virtually broke!) is he in the same line of work - making the people happy.

Governor is about as good as it can get for Arnie. No matter how good a job he may do, running for president is not an option as he is Austrian by birth and is therefore ineligible. Should this make a difference or not?

Any Californians in the house? How did YOU vote? And why?

27 replies

by road-dog

I suspect that the big guy was elected mostly out of dissatisfaction with Gray Davis. California is also an entertainment state. Arnold was a natural for the situation. He's not really a conservative, nor a fire breathing liberal. He appeals to the middle, cutting a wide portion of both sides of the political spectrum.

My only worry about the results of the election, is he has taken the helm of a sorrily damaged ship. The ship has many crewmen who are not interested in his getting credit for fixing it.

Personally, I believe even the "Governator" cannot salvage this state in the time allotted. The collapse of California's economy will be blamed on a Republican then. If I were Arnold, I'd demand a recount.....

I see California as a test bed showcasing the results of liberal ideology. My apologies to Californians, but the state should have been left to run to it's conclusion, if or nothing else but a lesson to the rest of the country.

My home town of Titusville, Florida would be a great place for Cisco Systems to relocate, great beaches, space shuttle launches, limited taxation.

by thechas

Not to take away from Arnie, but he won by telling the people what they wanted to hear.

I don't see how he can balance the California budget without a new source of revenue. (TAXES)

The last I heard, around 80 percent of California's state spending is mandated and constrained by initiatives from the people.
Couple that with the 2/3rds vote required to pass a budget, and I think ANY Governor in California is in a very tight corner with no place to go.

Several groups are already putting together campaigns to recall Arnie!

The interesting item related to this is that another elected official is working on a bill to remove the restriction that prevents non US born citizens from running for President.

Chas

by road-dog

Unless All spending in California's budget is scrutinized for cuts, Arnold is doomed to failure. Unless he were to zero the 20% discretionary spending, (ain't gonna happen) the budget will still fall short on current income projections. That leaves tax increases, which will chase away more businesses.

As for the bill to allow Arnie to run for President, ain't gonna happen. The "foreigners need not apply" clause is Constitutional, requiring state ratification and supermajority for amendment. 3/4 I believe.

I find that funny because such an amendment was mentioned in Stallone's flick "the Demolition Man". Supposedly the Constitution was amended to allow Schwarzenegger to be President. (Part of a running joke between the two)

by maxwell edison

I'm not involved in the issues relevant to California, but I do have some observations on what you said.

Considering the huge amount of both media spin and political mud-slinging, it's not possible to know for sure the sincerity or true intent behind the things Arnold, or any one else, for that matter, has been saying. And I suppose there's certainly justification for skepticism. However, almost 70% of California's voters cast their vote in the matter, 55% chose to to recall Gray Davis, and Arnold received more votes than his three nearest competitors combined. Some people may think that Arnold spoke from the heart, and the least he deserves is the benefit of the doubt until he proves otherwise.

As far as the budget problems that plague California, from your bleak description, you must think that no one can solve the problem. If that's the case, perhaps someone with the optimism of Arnold Schwarzenegger is just what the doctor ordered. Moreover, perhaps he really does have a sense of committment to the people of the state who, as he said, gave him everything he has. And after all, if failure is not an option, and it doesn't sound as though it is, then someone must find a way out of that mess and facilitate its implementation. If not him, then who?

If "several groups are already putting together campaigns to recall Arnie", and I haven't heard about any specific (or genuine) movements to do so, one must realize that, at this early point, it's all political.

A "bill to remove the restriction that prevents non US born citizens from running for President" would not be enough. To allow such a thing would require a new constitutional amendment. That's much too difficult and way too time consuming to make it even a factor for him. Such a measure would have to pass the U.S. House of Representatives by two-thirds majority vote, pass the U.S. Senate by two-thirds majority vote, survive a possible presidential veto, and then pass the House an Senates of ALL 50 states' legislators, again by two-thirds majority vote. I would bet my house that it would never happen. By the way, who is that "elected official" that you alluded to who suggested such a thing?

by maxwell edison

Three-quarters of the States' legislators would have to pass it, not all of them. (38 states) Also, I don't think that the President would have veto power over a proposed constitutional amendment.

Another way to amend the constitution would be a constitutional convention called by two-thirds of the states. Has there ever been one other than the first in 1787?

In the last 216 years, thousands of proposed amendments have been advanced, but only 27 have passed.

I'd still bet my house that it would never happen. In fact, I'd bet my house, all my cars, my record album collection, my life savings........

by thechas

Hi Max,

The person was a Senator or Congressman. I didn't commit the name to memory. (must be getting old) It was mentioned as a side comment on one of the NPR talk shows Wednesday.

The concept appalled me on several levels. Then, the commentator or guest mentioned other potential candidates including Michigan's Governor Granholm.
I trust her even less than I trust President Bush.

I did in the back of my mind think that any change to the requirements to be President of the US would require a constitutional amendment.

I agree with you, that it is not a likely scenario. I included it in my post more to point out the audacity of this whole situation rather than to scare or incite people.

As far as Arnie's chances for success, we have a toma'to tomato' view here. I see realism, you see pessimism.

The problem with the California budget is that far too much spending is 'locked' in place by ballot initiatives passed over the past 10 years.
If I understand the process correctly, there would need to be voter approval to make ANY changes to the spending that is presently locked in place.

Therefore, if you can't change enough of the spending, the only other way to balance the budget is through increased revenue.

Arnold has mentioned bring back jobs to California.
This is well and good. And, the best way to increase state tax revenue.
However, this won't happen overnight. Certainly not in time for the 2004 budget.

So, what's left?
A federal bailout?
A private bailout?
Perhaps the book and movie rights to Arnold's life story?

My point was that Arnold told the voters what they wanted to hear.

I do hope Arnold is able to deliver. If he is successful, perhaps both parties will see the wisdom in promoting their moderates over the extremists on both the Right and Left.

Chas

by jimhm

All Politicans do the same thing - From a canidate - Group A hears, more services for the elderly - Group B hears lower taxes - Group C hears - more spending on education.. Well they are all hearing what they want to hear.

So he was only doing what all of them do - "Blow smoke up the peoples butts." ..

But CA should of been left to crash and burn .. then they could get ride of all those spending mandates... and start a new...

Hey Intell - Pa is a nice place to move - low housing prices - land is cheap -

by oldefar

This will be fun for the late night hosts for at least another year.

On a serious note, most support is given to the "personality" rather than the party line and probably always has been. Think of the top 10 people you admire for their intellect, any time in history. Now think of your top 10 admired leaders. Same list?

Arnold has a better chance a doing well than most others. He is perceived as a tough guy on the side of good, who will stay true to ideals regardless of personal impact. Californians may respond to him laying out the cold facts and picking unpopular solutions. The difficulty will be having a support team that can find those paths for Arnold to "lead" California through.

As for precedent, this is very much what Ronald Reagan did. Having fully expected to see a US-Soviet confrontation and all the horrors that would have entailed, I am thankful that we had Reagan for President. However, he isn't even considered for my admired intellect list.

by zulj

I think they should try get the entire cast of Predator as Governors. Jessie Ventura (Blaine from Predator) I believe is also Governor of some state.

by maxwell edison

Jessie Ventura was governor of Minnesota. He ran as an independent, and won in 1996. He did not run for re-election in 2000, and if he did, would have easily been defeated. (At least that was the speculation at the time, although it's not possible to know for sure.)

by jkaras

Dont forget that also the actor who played Billy the indian guide who cuts his chest on the tree bridge waiting for the predator was also a governor according to geek trivia a few weeks ago. I'm not sure which state it was but that makes 3 from an elite group in a movie all holding the same political position in other states.
I knew he would win, why?, cause they have nothing to lose. I used to live in California and loved it but since I left my friends that still live there inform me of how bad its gotten over the years. Hopefully this election will stimulate the rest of the country to revolt against the do nothing leaders that we are stuck with. After the David Duke election where everyone voted to keep him out I hoped that people would feel the empowerment to force our politians that the easy ride is over. They need to clock in the hours like the rest of us and perform making changes to benefit the people and not their pockets. The only problem is that there is no money in it for them and if everything is fixed would we still need them?

by onbliss

..you are right! I have heard one conservative radio talk-show host talking about how nice it was having Ventura for Governor. Though the talk-show host did not agree with Ventura most of the time, he said at least the people knew what they were getting from Ventura.

by cactus pete

Well, if you'd bet all that against my new play-money 20, you're on.

Though I'd still hope I'd lose.

by maxwell edison

....my house has a 125% mortgage attached to it, all of my rusted out cars are sitting on cinder blocks in the front yard with engine parts strewn all over the place, my record album collection really consists of water-damaged, scratched and warped worthless piles of vinyl and cardboard, and I'm always "borrowing" from my life-savings coffee cup that sits on my desk (desk = more cinder blocks and an old sheet of plywood) so I can buy a soda once in a while.

All for a nice new crisp $20 bill?

???????????????????????????????????

Why would you want to give me 20-1 odds?

(just kidding......or am I?)

by cactus pete

I thought you live in the mountains of the West, not those of the East...

;)

[Disclaimer, I used to live in the Blue Ridge area, so I can poke fun.]

by john_wills

Bishop von Preysing of Eichstatt, later of Berlin, wrote when Hitler got elected "We are fallen into the hands of fools and criminals". At the same time a priest named Alfred Coppenrath, later to be exiled from Berlin for anti-government sermons, wrote to a friend abroad how wonderful it was to get away from the hypocrisy and procrastination and in-fighting of parliamentary government. I think that Schwarzenegger is just a fool, not a criminal, but I also think we have here a kind of repeat of the causes of Hitler's election. Hitler had a genius of an economics minister, who really did get unemployment down, something a pastor like Coppenrath really appreciated, but I do not think Schwarzenegger will find an equally good cabinet member, and if he does he will have fewer instruments (California can't run a deficit or print money) and no legislative majority to make his ideas law anyway (Hitler won power precisely by getting a majority in parliament, but California has separation of powers).

by jimhm

Look at it this way - the people have spoken load and clear to the democratic party over in CA. (56% voted for a republican candidate). The people are tired of the Democratic system of government over there - High Taxes - green laws - reglatory laws..

Now the "Terminator" has a mission - Before CA goes bankrupt - fix it. Of course he has to get things through the Senate and House - which I think is controled by the Democrat's - so they will be blocking all his good ideas...

What the heck - In the Movie "Demoliation Man" - wasn't there an Arnie Memory Library - for when he was president .. Does life Follow the Movies or do the Movies imitate life???

"Turn them Cal Girly Boys into Men - Arnie" ...

by onbliss

I got into a discussion where the other guy did not want the Republicans to win. One of his points was that Arnie did not have any experience to run the Government.
I said, he does not have to....becos the Gov. is usually surrounded by several advisors who literally run the show from the behind. The Gov. needs to have a strong personality apart from other things like honesty, integrity...yada-yada yada-yada.
To this the guy comes up with this...."The energy crisis was created by the energy mongers in Texas". That did not surprise me...

So what da you folks say....Does he need the experience or will his buddies look out for him?

In IT they don't hire people with experience. Why should somebody be elected to Gov. with out any expereince in Politics/Government?

by maxwell edison

Arnold Schwarzenegger has experience taking nothing and turning it into something great.

Arnold Schwarzenegger has experience focusing on what's possible, regardless of the seemingly insurmountable obstacles, and not being distracted by the nay sayers.

Arnold Schwarzenegger has experience being truthful, even if it may provide ammunition to his political opponents, as he did when he entered the race.

Arnold Schwarzenegger has experience debating issues and advancing his point of view with the political opposition, as he has been doing that very thing for over twenty years with his outlaw in-laws, the Kennedy family.

Arnold Schwarzenegger has experience running business endeavors, as he is one of the most successful business leaders in California.

Arnold Schwarzenegger has experience building a resume that was preferred by the founders, being a regular but involved citizen rather than a career politician.

Arnold Schwarzenegger has experience, as this campaign proved, of connecting with the people of California, which will undoubtedly be the most important area of expertise since it's the people of California who must make the decisions, make the sacrifices, and approve a change the policies that will again put their state in the right direction.

It sound to me that Arnold Schwarzenegger all the right kind of experience.

by jardinier

of making a posting. I agree with everything you say, and was considering making a posting along the same lines. Arnie has well and truly proved that he can succeed in any field of endeavour which he chooses. I wish him well.

by oz_media

Hey an actor for President!! Sounds like a flashback from Back to the Future.

I think if you don't elect a typical politician, you probably won't get the results of a typical politician. seeing as Arnie has only been involed in any form of politics for about four months, give him a shot. Not too many people wii argue with the Terminator!

Just think, if he goes another term he could be Governor Part 2 or even California Governor 3D. It could be really "entertaining".

He seems to have a sincere outlook on his objectives, doesn't sidestep the issues when confronted, "Yes, I've been a bad boy and grabbed some titty" . All the power to him, just to bad he wasn't president. Maybe you will all rewrite the political guidlines restrcting him from becoming President, who cares if he's Austrian, Austria's a phenomenal place with the most wonderful people. I think some of my best memories come from Austria.

I just can't wait to see the Red and White flag waiving across America. You'll have to rename Patriotic songs, I can just see the Vienna Boys Choir singing "Oh hooray for the red, white and...?" or Talk of the good ole Red White and?
"The stripes and stripe."

Yodel-ay-e-hoo!! Better than the famous pig calling competition.

by bmckee

He does not have to raise taxes on the people of California; all he has to do is get Indian Gaming to pay its fair share of taxes. Right now they only have to pay voluntary taxes with little or no oversight. Arnold can get this through because he didn't take money from them and he has no debt to the politicians in office. He can take names (of people that oppose his ideas) and kick some butt.

by maxwell edison

It was Senator Orrin Hatch, a Republican from Utah who is proposing a constitutional amendment to allow foreign born citizens to hold the higest office.

I never did care for Orrin Hatch, and now he's given me even more reason to dislike him. I think that would be a terrible thing - no, it would be worse than terrible. I would consider it to be a threat to our republic. And if it ever got some real momentum behind it, I believe I would get heavily involved in an attempt to kill it - donate time and money to defeat such a measure. In fact, I'm gonna' sit right down and write that ass a letter. (Including one to each of my own state's senators.)

I have to disagree with your suspicion that Arnold Schwarzenegger just "told the voters what they wanted to hear". Personally, I think he was the most sincere of the whole bunch.

You also said that you saw realism, and I see pessimism. Did you mean optimism? I am certainly no pessimist, just the opposite. In the case of Arnold, I think he's going to get something done. He and I are both optimists - always looking at what's possible to achieve, not reasons why it can't.

by maxwell edison

Under the Hatch Amendment, foreign-born people who have been naturalized U.S. citizens for at least 20 years would be eligible to run for president. Currently, the president must be native-born.

Let's see, a terrorist organization from Syria plants a 20 year old "brain-washed" terrorist in the U.S. and works to become a citizen by the time he's 25. As Representative Maxine Waters has shown, just about any blabbering idiot could get elected to a national office, and with the right kind of connections, the right kind of hand-outs to the hands-out, a blackmail here or there, and after a dozen or so two-year terms, that blabbering idiot suddenly becomes Speaker of the House - just a pop-pop away from the oval office.

Or worse yet, maybe it would be a Frenchman!

What a scary thought.

by thechas

As you may recall, Senator Hatch wanted computers to be set to self destruct if the user downloaded copyrighted material illegally.

On my comment about pessimism, I see myself as a realist. I think that you see me as a pessimist.
Yes Max, I agree that you are an optimist.

Chas

by maxwell edison

Thanks for clearing that up, Chas. I went back and read the passage again, and see that I misread it. (But you're right, accurate or not, I do see a bit of "pessimism" in what you say from time to time.)

Orrin Hatch, there's not much I like about him.
Hey, something on which we agree - and he's a Republican, no less!

As far as being a realist, I believe that a person's "reality", or how one sees reality, is a direct result of his thought process - with obvious exceptions, of course. A person can't change the reality of a rainy day, for example, but could certainly have the reality of enjoying it or despising it. One person's "reality", therefore, could be the exact opposite of another's.

Let's see, using the usual pessimist/optimist example of whether the glass is half full or half empty, how would a "realist" see it?

Maybe:

"Well, it could go either way."

or....

"The bottom half of the glass is full."

or....

"The top half of the glass is empty."

or....

This discussion is closed to new replies.