Discussion Locked

Impeach The President, Vice-President and all members of Congress

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The President, Vice-President and all members of the United States House of Representative and Senate should be impeached for violations of the United States Constitution.

And exactly which section have they violated?

Article IV, Section 4 which states:

"The United States shall guarantee to every state in this union a republican form of government, and shall protect each of them against invasion; and on application of the legislature, or of the executive (when the legislature cannot be convened) against domestic violence."

Researchers estimate there are between 11 million and 12 million illegal immigrants in the United States. Illegal immigration is an invasion and failure to protect the border of the United States is an offense which all the politicians should be impeached.

History has taught us that no nation has survived uncontrolled immigration, with the Roman empire being a highly illustrative case (some have said America is in fact the New Roman Empire).

13 replies

by jamesrl

This is not an overnight problem. You can't blame the sitting president for starting the problem, you can only blame him for not doing enough, and by that measure, you would have to blame every president for how many hundreds of years.

Uncontrolled immigration seemed ok a century ago when the country needed resources to labor in the industries and in resource extraction. Things are different now, and immigration must be controlled.

Canada has a problem, but on a much smaller scale. We are currently sending back illegal immigrants from Portugal and other countries who do have a life here (own car house, etc, work here for 7 years). I symathise, especially for those who have kids born and raised here, but at the end of the day I look at fairness. Many qualified immigrants do all the right things, fill in all the paperwork, pay all the fees and wait years to legally immigrate. Why then should we reward the people that jump the queue.

James

by bfilmfan

I was quite prepared to enjoy both Carter and Reagan's impeachment trials on the same issues.

The US had a much tougher immigration policy a century ago. While I don't support a no-gain immigration policy, I do support a get tough with the illegal immigrants. I live in an area of the US (southern Arizona) which is simply over run with illegal immigrants. If we cannot protect our national borders, how can we protect against all the terrorists, which are said to be all over the world plotting acts of evil against the citizens?

With the current proposed Senate bills rewarding illegal behavior, you are guaranteed to get more of it.

by jellimonsta

Being a 'legal' immigrant, I fully agree that things really need to be buckled up. However, I do not think this is worthy of impeachment of any members of congress.
Do I think there is enough being done? No!.... however, I feel the 'protection from invasion' should refer to 'hostile' invasion, and not merely occupation. Just my 2cents.

by absolutely

Close.

Since they do not protect our national borders, why should we assume they are trying to achieve their stated goals, on immigration, terrorism, free lunches for all snot-noses or universal health care and non-English education for all illegal aliens?

by bfilmfan

"Mara Salvatrucha" AKA MS-13 and "Salvadorians with Pride" aka SWP would qualify as terrorists and enemy combatants, based on the current White House policies. Considering that there are an estimated 10,000 MS-13 gang members in 33 states, I don't know what to call this other than a hostile invasion.

Considering that Ebner Anibal Rivera Paz, the reputed leader of MS-13?s Honduran branch was arrested in Texas in February of 2005, I'd say the problem is a low worse than most citizens have been made aware.

And since most of the illegal immigrants are from Central and Southern America, this problem is only going to get worse.

by jellimonsta

Something should definitely be done about gangs, but how many of the gang members are actually 'legal' residents/ citizens, versus 'illegal'?

We do have some small pockets of gang activity in Madison, WI. It seems however that a large number of them are 'culturally mixed' so to speak (Caucasian, Afro-American, Asian, Hispanic (mixed up is what I would say)).

I am sorry I cannot fully appreciate your situation. I agree something needs to be done about gang warfare (shouldn't this be considered a war on terror)?

by oneamazingwriter

in a New Jersey city that is presently under siege. For the last few days helicoptors fly overhead because the gangs have been staging a street shoot out withone another.

While I do not place the blame for gangs on illegal immigrants, the gangs would be smaller if there were fewer illegal immigratns to join them. Cutting things down to size would help, and certainly wouldn't hinder.

by maxwell edison

Other than Colorado Congressman, Tom Tancredo, I've not heard of a single member of Congress or the Executive Branch to not only cite this provision of the constitution, but sound the alarm from high atop a soapbox. This has been Congressman Tancredo's battle cry from his first day in Congress, and he has yet to capitulate, regardless of the mud that's been slung at him as a result.

If you make him the lone exception to impeachment, how far down the line of succession would we have to go before he would be in-line to assume the presidency? I'd have to look it up, but I don't think the line of succession extends down into the ranks of mere Congressmen, but I could be mistaken.

There could indeed be others like Congressman Tancredo, perhaps ones from Arizona, New Mexico, or Texas, but there sure aren't many.

Great message, BFilmFan. I concur with the spirit of your message 100 percent.

By the way, wasn't there a sheriff in Arizona who was using this provision to arrest many of them? It's been a while, and I don't remember the exact details, but I seem to remember some "creativity" in that regard.

Edited Addition:

P.S. Go to his Web site or do some Internet searches for his position. Perhaps you will agree to make him an exception from your call for impeachment. And he might run for the U.S. Senate next election, depending on what the current incumbent decides to do. I hope he does run for the Senate. If he wins, he could make much more of an impact with this issue in that chamber than he could in the House.

by bfilmfan

I wasn't aware of this member of Congress. There was actually a new story on him today over at http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12017855/site/newsweek/. Thus, I stand corrected that one of the mombers of Congress is awake and is trying to deal with the issue!

I hope he doesn't run for Senate, but for the Presidency! I nominate Ron Paul to be his running mate. Maybe we will finally have some kind of common sense politicians again.

I am sure there are a few other congressman and senators that are white-hot on the immigration issue and it does need to be addressed.

I did some research and House Resolution 2319 attempts to address the scenario if the entire US government is wiped out, except for some Congressional representatives. http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c108:H.R.2319:

I also found this interesting site which covers the succession to the Presidency:

http://www.doctorzebra.com/prez/a_succession.htm

by maxwell edison

He actually HAS indicated that he'd be interested in running for president. However, the odds of him winning would be extremely high. The odds of Colorado Congressman Tancredo winning the White House are probably as high as the Colorado Rockies winning the World Series. (They're 300 to 1, by the way.)

Bet there were, after all, those 1969 Miracle Mets.

http://tancredo4prez.blogspot.com/

http://tancredo.blogspot.com/

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=43531

P.S. And as a disclaimer. I've known Tom Tancredo before he even ran for congress. And he just might be setting the stage for a serious run at it.

"If no one is willing to pick up the banner... yeah, I'll run," the Colorado Republican said Saturday during a visit to the state with the earliest presidential primary.

http://www.boston.com/news/local/new_hampshire/articles/2005/06/12/tancredo_immigration_reform_may_push_him_into_presidential_race/

by av .

BFF, I can't even imagine what AZ must be like because of its border issues. It truly is an invasion of our country. Illegals have spread out all over our country, living off of the legal taxpayer services.

To be fair, the Bush Administration didn't cause the immigration problem, but collectively, most seem to be in favor of some type of amnesty-like program. If they ever pass an amnesty-like bill, I think we should then impeach all that voted for it.

I can't believe I'm seeing illegal aliens protesting in the streets of America holding the Mexican flag demanding their rights. And look at how many of them! Our lawmakers have been sleeping on the job on our dime.

Even worse is our government's acceptance of them. Okay 11 or 12 million people is alot, but I don't care. Every one of them and their kids should be deported from this country one by one. They broke our laws and now they are arrogantly parading down the streets demanding their rights because they're here.

Just because they work here doesn't give them any rights at all. I don't care if they did it for 10 years. They're here illegally and for too long. Good bye, hasta la vista, babe. Next . . .

I am tired of hearing Americans won't take certain jobs. What jobs are they talking about? Agriculture, construction, landscaping, dishwashing, busboy, waitress, etc. There are plenty of people here that will do those jobs. Employers just can't pay them "under the table".

I think legal Americans should have first dibs on the jobs. Maybe our lawmakers need to do a roadtrip through America and look at the poverty in many areas. Those people might like one of the jobs the illegals are currently filling.

We need border security NOW. Not amnesty. One day, in NJ, I'd like to drive down the street in one of our fine cities and not see 20 day laborers that are obviously illegal aliens, standing on the corner waiting to be picked up by construction companies and landscapers.

I don't know if you saw any of Lou Dobbs broadcasts from Cancun, or his debates on CNN's Situation Room, but they were very good.

by andrew e

The Matthew Shepard Act has been stalled in Congress. The Matthew Shepard Act, or the Local Law Enforcement Hate Crimes Prevention Act (or the LLEHCPA - that's a mouthful) is intended to include homosexual persons covered under hate crimes legislation, as they are a minority. Senator Jeff Sessions, R- Alabama, is trying to get the bill killed by putting on a "poison pill amendment" to extend more unsecured loans for the F22 Raptor program, an unnecessary cost according to the Pentagon. (They know better than he does in this case.) Homophobia is running rampant, but it seems civil rights aren't a priority to Sen. Sessions. It's worth more than pay day loans to pass the Matthew Shepard Act.

by floridaguy

The sitting President has taken actions against the citizens of Arizona and failed while in office to assist in closing this nation's borders. Additionally, all those who stood and applauded the Mexican President should be impeached because that was an act that is in violation of their oath of office.

To the poster who said it was unfair to call the sitting president into question because the problem began prior to his taking office, the sitting president has made jokes and other sly remarks against citizens living in Arizona and therefore, he deserves to be impeached because he has failed to uphold his oath of office.

It is high time that those elected to represent their constituents chose to support those living in the United States legally over those who have entered the US illegally and those from other countries. The actions of many Congressional members was unthinkable and I too call for their immediate removal from office.

This discussion is closed to new replies.