On the "next you'll say ..." part, nope. The OS needs to be secure while retaining both functionality and ergonomics (user-friendliness, etc.).
My point was not that Windows doesn't have to be perfect. My point is that I think MS gets some unfair bashing.
I don't have a problem with someone pointing out a security flaw in a program with the intention of getting that flaw fixed. (There are caveats on that - publishing a flaw openly before the developers have had a reasonable chance to fix it is unethical.)
I don't have a problem with someone pointing out a security flaw in a program with the intention of helping someone avoid that security problem, even if the problem isn't being fixed. (Actually, especially if the problem isn't being fixed.) That's helpful. It's just like I'll tell people I refuse to do business with Fry's Electronics, because of all the flawed hardware they've dumped on the market and some bad experiences I've had with them. Same deal.
What I do have a problem with is general ranting and raving about how horrible MS is, while setting an unattainable standard for them (or anyone else). I'd have the same problem if it were directed at anyone else, not just MS.
As far as MS not caring about product quality, I don't see that. In my opinion, Windows XP is at least moderately better than DOS 3.0, and I've used both extensively. (To be fully accurate, I think Windows XP was a significant improvement over everything they released prior to it.) A company that doesn't care about quality at all wouldn't continually try to improve their product.
Of course, their emphasis is on user-features and ergonomics. That's because that's what actually sells software (or anything else for that matter).
Which do you think would sell better to the general public:
A cruise aboard a nearly unsinkable battleship with military MREs (prepackaged "Meals, Ready-to-Eat"), no deck chairs, no swimming pool, but you are as safe as you can possibly be aboard a boat at sea.
A cruise aboard a modern luxury liner with 5-star meals, 5-star accomodations and stops in so many tropical islands that you can't keep track of them all. You're only as safe as the captain and pilot haven't had too much champaign at the deck parties, and you don't drink any of the local water, and the other passengers don't make off with your cell phone and laptop, etc.
Which do you really think will sell more cruises?
On that analogy, Windows needs to be safe enough to pass government safety standards (enough lifeboats, shipboard doctors with penicillin on hand, etc.), but needs to have as many features, including pointless flash, as possible.
Even the "pointless flash" fits the analogy. Transparent windows are necessary? Hardly. But then, fireworks displays aren't "necessary" either, but they do draw more of a crowd now don't they?
So, I think MS is trying to be the luxury liner, not the nearly unsinkable battleship.
On the other hand, maybe in the business world the battleship is more appropriate, and the liner should stick with personal/entertainment venues (home computing).