Discussion Locked

Iran and Nukes ? Who woulda thunk it

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Here are some links that show that Iran is attempting to develop Nuclear Weapons.

World Net Daily
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=41549

Colin Powell offers evidence of Iran?s attempt to acquire missile technology
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6516658/

Iran refuses to stop Enrichment
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3670018.stm

Now I wonder what they?re going to do with Nuclear Weapons once they acquire them?

27 replies

by delbertpgh

After losing 600,000 men fighting Saddam, they probably figured they needed an edge. But once Saddam looked like he was done for, GWB proclaims them the axis of evil, and I suppose they now want something that guarantees we won't attack. A couple of atomic bombs would make a mess out of our ground and sea movements in the gulf.

However, the guys who run Iran are a genuinely scary bunch. They are religious hard cases. God leaves them messages under their pillows at night, telling them what crazy things they should do the next day. They might decide they should attack Israel, or protect their Shiite brethern in southern Iraq (and all that oil, too). Or they might just decide that holding the bomb is proof against retaliation, and would be free to support freelance jihadi murderers around the world.

I doubt that they would give an a-bomb to terrorists. The things are just too precious and hard to get, and the consequences of them being used by some irresponsible Al Qaida type are just too grave. If Teheran supplied somebody the bomb to blow up Baltimore, we'd blow Teheran.

But all the other stuff they could do is bad enough. It makes for great instability in the most strategic region in the world, and once they have a nuke, it reduces our freedom to act against them.

Am I missing something, or has GWB really screwed this up?

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
I doubt that they would give an a-bomb to terrorists.
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

I so disagree. bin Laden got permission from the elders to use a nuclear weapon against the US. He got that permission because he was able to make the case that America is not just waging a war against terrorism - but against Islam.

While our elected leaders say that's not true - he was able to point out a zillion instances where our theological leaders have said it is true - that the war against terrorism IS a war against Islam.

So, if Iran develops a bomb, and they think bin Laden can deliver it to its intended target, they will most certainly hand it over to him.

Bush knows this, and I think he's okay with it. He's made NO effort to strike against Iran's weapons facilities, even though we know where they are.

I think the reason he's okay with it has to do with his belief that he somehow enjoys a special relationship with his gods. His faith teaches that Muslims and Christians *should* be at war with each other and that his problem with not having enough troops will be solved when God reanimates all the dead christians and conscripts them into this holy war.

by packet spoofer

Bush knows this, and I think he's okay with it. He's made NO effort to strike against Iran's weapons facilities, even though we know where they are.
You sound exactly like John kerry and bill clinton and ted kennedy about iraqi wmd......your confidence is astounding on this.....You actually believe our government has valid intelligence!? wow....you need one of those head arse dislodging devices.....I will chip in a few bucks.....

by protiusx

I wasn?t aware that you were so versed in President Bush?s religion and so closely connected with the man that you know exactly what his agenda is. You are amazing. You have an answer for everything.

Not only that but you also have close relations with Osama Bin Laden and the hierarchy of the Islamic faith. Wow you really are an important person!
I for one can?t wait until your next post. You should create a website where admirers such as myself could go and read your nuggets of insight.

by delbertpgh

I don't see signs that Iran's leaders want to carry war against the U.S. and the West outside of the Middle East. If they work hard over years to build a nuclear weapon, spend billions and endure expensive diplomatic and economic retaliation, why would they give it to some over-the-edge crackpot like Bin Laden? Osama has his own agenda, different from Iran's. Osama is a Sunni, and deep down, he thinks Shias are dogs. Iran is a Shia theocratic state. If Iran wanted for some crazy reason to deliver a nuclear weapon across the ocean, why would they put their fate in Al Qaida's hands? It makes no sense.

I think that Iran would like to exert influence over Iraq and Kuwait, because they have Shia majority populations and lots of oil, and over Afghanistan, because it is swarming with criminal and security problems, not to mention the CIA. Probably their biggest reason for wanting a bomb is having American troops on two of its borders, while George Bush calls them the axis of evil. They probably think that GWB would not send his army out to eliminate another government if that army faced nukes. They're probably right.

It looks to me like Iran is looking for security guarantees. Seems like we ought to do everything we can to reassure them that we'll be sweet if they don't build nukes. Our other options don't favor us.

by house

I don't know if Iran should be considered a valid threat. Perhaps they just want to make sure that they have a bargaining tool when Bush admin, Saudi's, Asians, and whoever else starts drooling over their assets. Religion aside, every man has his influences...the current state of the world is our own.

Keep in mind that Iran is surrounded by threats to their own country. Look where they are on the map and look at all of their neighbors N, S, E, and W. I'd arm myself to the teeth too especially now with western influence scratching their butts next door.

I'm not trying to downplay the recent efforts in the Middle East. I'd just like to be able to visit without fearing their hate for the modern man. I think that this has only been amplified and not suppressed within the past couple of years.

by fluxit

Modern warfighting does not always require the commitment of ground forces and conventional methods. A greater part of warfighting today involves leveraging information differentials and wars are winnable on information alone.

While we committed ground forces in Iraq and Afghanistan to combat a greater part was an information war. Even Sadam himself and terrorist tried thier skill at this. Other wars were fought and won on pure information. For example, Libya gave up its WMD without any ground forces. The old Soviet Union caved in principally because they thought the US was so technologically advanced that they could not win a war.

If you will recall our infamous President Clinton, his administration namely Madam Albright and O'Leary held a belief that if there was no information differential to exploit then there would be no war. So during those 8 yrs his administration they were busy leveling the playing field using various tactics. For example, in the DOE O'Leary had a belief that security clearances were racist and changed the system. This resulted in summary release of information such as how to build Bio and Chemical weapons from your local Eckards. They also released how to build a Nuclear Bomb. Clinton tried to pin it on Wen Ho Lee when congress came after him. The result was Pakistan and Iran obtained the technology. Coincidentally, the DOE information was found in the world's most advance bio chem lab north of Tora Bora and in the Terrorists notes.

In another instance, Clinton gave ballistic missile technology to the Chinese for peaceful space exploration. One man went to space and some 400 missiles are now aimed at Tiawan.

In another instance, the failed networking company Global Crossings ended up in Iraq networking air defense stations.

The world is a much scarier place today for certain. The best thing we can do is elect principled leaders and live our lives as righteous as we can.

by hal 9000

The average High School Physics Student should be able to tell you how to build a simple A Bomb.

It is basic physics now days the main problem is obtaining the fissionable materials which where very hard to come by but with the collapse of the USSR that has all changed. Now days there is a lot of weapons grade material around that can not be accounted for but there are two main problems even after you have constructed one of these things the first is a long range delivery system as you do not want it going off on your back door step and the second and biggest is the chance of a misfire where you get a fission reaction while the device is sitting on its delivery platform. The very crude fission bombs that both India and Pakistan have are perfect examples of this and are considered as so dangerous that they are stored dismantled to prevent any chance of a misfire occurring which could lead to a full scale war before the fault was found if ever.

But as far as enriched Uranium goes by itself it is fairly harmless unless it falls into the hands of some radical people who use conventional explosives to disperse it around that is something to worry about.

But it is also required for a basic nuclear power generation station as not all Nuclear power stations are of the fast breeder type.

Personally I would be a lot more concerned if Iran was attempting to obtain Plutonium for power station as that is a far more dangerous substance in every respect.

Col

by fluxit

Having cursory knowledge, technical skill, and the intent to leverage technology are very different.

Nearly everyone has cursory knowledge of many things but that does not make them a Tiger Woods, DaVinci, or a Alexander Bell.

Fewer people have developed a technical proficiency than those with cursory knowledge. I watched sand castle building competition once. A team of Under 10 year olds built a basic castle using thier buckets and plastic shovels. Another team of Teens used wheelbarrows and metal shovels to pile sand high then they carved the castle using thier hands. But a third team and the winners they too piled the sand high, dug a trough from the ocean leading water in, then they carved the castle using spoons, brushes, combs, and water spray bottles. maturity plays a major role in applying technical skills.

However, if one has the WILL to conduct mal-intent then only marginal knowledge and skill are needed. The plane jackers on 911 did not know how to land.

I don't think obtaining the material is that difficult. The skill necessary is marginal and delivery can be effected many ways. The creative minds of someone hell bent will find a way.

It is the intent that is worst than the weapon. Guns don't kill people do.

by protiusx

I will probably shock you all with my opinion. At one time I believed that Iran was much like the Talaban where they persecuted their own people and were more interested in furthering their own despotic goals. Then about a year ago I was getting my haircut by a woman who was Armenian and had immigrated to the US from Iran. She told me about her experiences about growing up in Iran as a Christian and it wasn?t what I thought. She said that when she was a little girl and the Ayatollah was still alive the government tried to force the teaching of the Koran in the public schools. Other than that she said that her family wasn?t persecuted or discriminated against at all. She enjoyed the Iranian people and said they were a very warm and loving people. There are Christian (Orthodox) Churches in Tehran across the street from Mosques. She said that she was not forced to wear a burkha and not only were women encouraged to go to school but the school was free. She graduated from college in Tehran and migrated to the US to be with other members of her family.
After talking with her and doing some research on the Internet I feel that Iran is trying to a lot of different things by developing nuclear technology (including weapons) but I don?t think this is to the detriment of the United States. With advanced nuclear technology Iran could become an international exporter of radioactive isotopes used in the treatment of cancer, or to be used in an industrial fashion. Iran would gain nothing but ostracization from the world community by developing nuclear weapons in a threatening manor. India and Pakistan have Nuclear weapons and they are blatant antagonists with one another. The only one of Iran?s neighbors that threatened her was Iraq and that is no longer the case.
It could be said that they might launch a preemptive strike against Israel but I don?t think they?ll do that as they would be a little outgunned. Israel (although they nether confirm or deny the fact that they have nuclear weapons) would, if attacked by Iran, turn Iran into a sea of glass.

by fluxit

Turkey is a Democracy and Islamic. Iran was a Democracy but now is a puppet to the Religious rule. The country is not as desert and tribal as some may think.

However, the advancement/proliferation of nuclear technology should be highly monitored for peaceful purposes. However, once in use peacefully the potential is ominous that some future leader or government could misuse it.

In Iraq there are cities that the US soldiers cannot even go into because of the 'use' of WMD by Sadam. This is not a good use of those technologies.

by olprof67

One wing of my extended family is Iranian, so I have firsthand knowledge that the people themselves are as decent and adaptable as any of us; the problem is a religion that still clings to the 6th century.

Unfortunately, the social structure of Islamic societies, coupled with access to petrodollars, provides an opportunity for some individuals to designate themseslves as lone avengers.

Our leadership has responded to this by attempting to challenge the most brazen of the would-be avengers and draw them out in the open. If martyrdom is their goal, that can be obliged.

Unfortunately, no one can guess what the ultimate response will be from the masses caught in the middle and held down by their own leaders.

Like the native peoples of the New World of 500 years ago, the Islamists are trying to cling to a value system which can't cope with the course of societal evolution. Unlike thier counterparts, they have some concept of the workings of property rights, and can use their resources for a transition to a post-petroleum ecomomy.

The world today is more forgiving than that of the Sixteenth Century. But if the radicals among Islam continue to wage a war of terror on non-combatants, they may provoke a terrible retribution from their victims.

by olprof67

Not what they're gonna do when they aquire them, but, what WE'RE gonna do before they acquire them!

by hal 9000

The Prototype Jindeele Over the Horizon installation it read "Caution RF Radiation" which was taken by everyone in town to mean that there where radio active isotopes being used there and they where likely to develop cancer have children born with two heads and the like. They get fixated on one single word and simply do not understand the real message.

When I pointed out to one of the main protesters that in their home they had sources of EM Radiation they where adamant that they had no radio active materials at all anywhere near them except for the installation which was going to kill them all.

It just seems to me that the very work Radiation scares most people and they loose all prospective. It is well known that Iran has Nuclear Power Generation facilities and how do you run these things unless you have enriched Uranium? Just because a country wants to produce its own value added products in no way means that they are attempting to build a fission weapon but not pay the exurbanite price for this material from other countries who sell it at inflated prices for their own benefit.

With any U235 reactor you need to be in a position to create fuel rods and reprocess the spent ones this should be only common sense to most people but again mention the word RADIATION and people loose all prospective.

Col

by protiusx

I can?t believe we actually agree on something but I must say that here we do. My wife works in nuclear physics. She?s bloody brilliant while I, on the other hand, am not. So what I write about nuclear material I have learned from her. She is amazed at the lack of understanding that people have about the nuclear industry or anything nuclear for that matter. It?s like you say; if you make a statement and use the word nuclear the focus will be on the word and it is one that the general public associate with fear.
I don?t think I need to go on record as being a proponent of nuclear energy. It is sad to think that the United States has been forced by public fear and misunderstanding to veer away from improving and increasing our nuclear power plants.
I like you feel that Iran is working scientifically to establish itself as a source of these materials to proliferate this clean power source throughout the Arab world. If Iran could build a breeder reactor not only could they supply themselves with nuclear fuel rods but they could contract out to other countries to build nuclear reactors and fuel them with their fuel rods. This sounds like good business to me not terror.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
You should create a website where admirers such as myself could go and read your nuggets of insight.
---- ---- ---- ----
Didn't you say you did this? I'd be interested to read it.

Personally, I don't build web sites for myself. That's a gamble I'm only willing to take with OPM funding.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
It is sad to think that the United States has been forced by public fear and misunderstanding to veer away from improving and increasing our nuclear power plants.
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

I agree, but unfortunately, you elected a president who has no sincere desire to shake the oil addiction.

by hal 9000

It now appears that the HALF WAY POINT will very soon be reached in the use of all of the available fossil fuel oil.

So from about this point on we are begining to loose the very substance that we require above all else. With a bit of luck those involved will realize the potential problem and stare developing alternative fuels but like most business they will most likely attempt to get as much as possible for the dwindling reserves that remain.

Col

by protiusx

Have you heard of converting diesel engines to run on vegetable oil? I saw a program on the discovery channel about this. A man in California invented a cheap way of converting a standard Mercedes to run on vegetable oil. I think this is brilliant.

by hal 9000

Fuel not contaminated with a foreign substance like Ethanol is a good idea as the Ethanol adversely affects many things.

The least of which is the damage to paint work if it is split on it and the worst is damage to any alloy parts as Ethanol increases the rate of Electrolytic Decay in all alloy parts. Also you just might need to have a look see at the makers guidelines as well here as a high ethanol content fuel does void car makers warranties.

Col

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
Unfortunately, no one can guess what the ultimate response will be from the masses caught in the middle and held down by their own leaders.
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

This sounds like when Bush said "noone could have expected them to fly planes into buildings" after he got the memo warning that al Quaeda was going to fly planes into buildings.

Since the Islamsists were caught in between in the cold war, and we know how they turned out - it's easy to see what the people who are caught in between in the war on terror will do. The survivors will strike back at Americans.

You probably meant to say no *neocon* can guess what will happen.

by delbertpgh

You can combust just about any kind of oil in a diesel engine, so long as it's not too thick. I read about ecology-minded people picking up used fryer oil from fast food joints, adding a little lye to it, and then pouring it straight into a conventional diesel. Of course, you have to not mind driving around to 20 restaurants every week and begging their junk oil. But it shows that if you don't mind putting a lot of energy into recycling, you can do something.

The big limit is cost. When I buy a 44-ounce bottle of Wesson oil in the grocery, it costs around 4 bucks, but when I buy a 128-ounce gallon of fuel, it costs less than 2. (In Pittsburgh.) I'm sure that if they had a whole agricultural industry dedicated to producing bio-diesel fuels, they could lower the price a lot, but it would still need subsidies (or $5 gas) to be competitive.

We may get to that point soon, anyway. China is industrializing fast. They are talking about China increasing its daily consumption of oil by 5 million barrels per day in the next decade. That is as much production as three Kuwaits.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
why would they give it to some over-the-edge crackpot like Bin Laden? Osama has his own agenda, different from Iran's.
---- ---- ---- ----

The answer is simple - to strike at America. The President has been leading a faith-based war movement against them - so it's only logical that they would want to be able to decide when and where that war would be fought.

It's not like there's anything they can do to avoid war. *Nothing* they do could possibly deter Bush's Republican Guard.

The only thing that will stop the Bush Oil Crusades, overextended as it is, is to eliminate his war-making resources. Nuking Langley would go a long way toward that goal.

by delbertpgh

Re:
The answer is simple - to strike at America. The President has been leading a faith-based war movement against them - so it's only logical that they would want to be able to decide when and where that war would be fought.
-----------------------------------
Why would they want to strike at America? For the sake of global religious supremacy? My impression is they are primarily concerned about religion and life in Iran, not cleansing Bethesda of infidels. Besides, if they blow one bomb on our land, or supply Osama with the means to do the same, they know we will respond with a devasting attack, and it won't matter if they have extra bombs.

Figuring that the most important thing on your enemy's mind is you is just natural human egotism. Like anybody, your enemy thinks mostly of himself. Tip O'Neill said "all politics is local," and the U.S.A. is not in their neighborhood at all.

This is not to say that some pumped up Iranian crackpot wouldn't bomb Israel. But since Israel has 200 bombs and better delivery systems, probably they would hold back on that, too.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
Why would they want to strike at America? For the sake of global religious supremacy?
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

No. For survivial. Americans call it "Pre-emptive defense". They *know* Bush will attack Iran if he gets the chance - just like he did in Iraq.

It doesn't matter if they do or do not have nukes - he's going to attack if he gets the chance.

Bush has made it clear that he wants to use Iraq as a jumping off point to wage war on more Islamic nations. It would be outrageously foolish for Iran to NOT take action to prevent it.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

Corn Oil fuel technology is very old. One reason why it's not viable is because it takes a LOT of corn to produce. It's more profitable to sell the food as food.

Here, in Dallas, you used to could buy gas that was watered down with this stuff - but not anymore. After Bush leased the governor's mansion, it went away.

by delbertpgh

Ethanol is used as an oxygen-improving additive, besides replacing some of the gasoline. It does not have as much energy ounce-for-ounce as petroleum fuel, but it was useful as a pollution reducer in some climates.

It also is a mainstay of the grain-producing states. Tom Daschle lobbied for ethanol subsidies all the time. Probably John Thune will do the same, now that Daschle is deposed. Ethanol from corn always needed a subsidy, because it was too expensive to replace gasoline.

Shell is partnering with a Canadian company that has developed a yeast that supposedly produces alchohol out of weeds and field waste. It has the potential to be cheaper.

This discussion is closed to new replies.