40 replies
by maecuff
by jkaras
Yes I agree that these are two different things. The only reason that I added this to the post was to point out that we as a society blame an "ism" on any failure we experience to absolve the person from responsibility when not performing as expected. Everyone finger points blame away from themselves claiming it's beyond their ability. This issue could be a boring subject, poor teacher, a genious bored not challenged, or poor teaching habits that dont get the attention of the person having the problem. These people after being labled at a young age begin to accept their short cummings accepting defeat that they cannot do because they suffer from this aielment. It's not in all cases mind you but happens alot. Thx for the input for me to ponder.
P.S. What do you mean labor pains dont hurt that much?
by maecuff
by generalist
The problem with some reporters and politicians is that they want to simplify things so they can get their little minds around it.
The statement that addiction is all in the mind probably applies to part of the total population of addicts. But it doesn't apply to everybody.
Some addictions are biochemical. You get pleasure from the chemicals you use and pain when you don't use them. While you did make the initial choice, the biochemistry makes a nice, tight feedback loop that keeps youaddicted unless someone or something intervenes.
Then you have addictions that are involve the physiology of the brain. While it is all in your mind, you didn't choose the addiction because you were prewired for the addiction. If you are in an environment where the addiction manifests itself, stopping said addiction can be hard.
Sometimes I wonder if some reporters and politicians are addicted to the attention they get when they come up with comprehensive solutions that are simple, obvious and wrong.
by jkaras
by mallardtooxx
If you were to smoke 6 Cigarettes a day for a week and then stop you would feel the tug of nicotene but easily deny that tug. If you smoked 6 a day for two weeks you would begin to think about them and wonder if you wanted one or if it was in your head. If you smoked 6 a day for 3 weeks you would buy a carton and have a hell of a time quitting.
Most all of the addiction arguement can be summed up by exposure.
The mind, well it is a puddle of Bio-chemicals and they are affected by different substances in differnt ways. That is why I have trouble buying the it is all in your mind argument, of course it is your mind is swimming in the stuff. Nicotene attracts dopamine which is your little "mind Drug" so does THC and LSD, as well asPCP and Opium and cocaine. All of these are different chemicals that are put into the blood stream and wreck havoc on your brain chemistry. The cry of an addict is not because he made a real choice to become addicted (no one ever thinks they will)the cry of the addict is because they have altered their brian chemisrty to the point that they need to have the substance to maintain "normal" function. That is why the mind and body become so violently ill when you go through DT's and sometimes the person never really recovers, they have changed their "mind" forever and to try to alter it back to original state is painful and next to impossible.
-duck
by cactus pete
Maybe it's just that this forum doesn't permit you to write the whole study, or perhaps you weren't exposed to it all, and they really were thorough, but you mentioned one tet were one rat was not affected. He happened to be the alpha. This doesn't prove anything other than you need more tests.
And a placebo works very often because your mind thinks it is getting what it needs, so it produces the desired benefit. Not all addictions work this way. [An example of this sort, though, would be to always have A ring a bell, which then leads to B turning on the light, which always lead to C opening the door to let D the dog eat. Soon, upon the sound of the bell, the dog salivates even when the door isn't open.]
As for your smoking, Ducky has summed that up pretty well.
And Max is very right - it's a combination of both, which makes every individual reaction very hard to predict.
Addiction is both "in the mind" AND real. Chemical addictions, to be sure, do indeed take over one's body, and the body (and mind) can certainly crave a certain substance. However, the ability to overcome that addiction (to whatever) is dependent onhow one thinks about it.
I think we've all hear the saying, whether you think you can or you can't, you're probably right. So if a person truly believes he can quit something, he will. If he thinks he can't, well, he's falling short of applying the true power of the mind.
By the way, that was a special by John Stossel of ABC news. You could probably find an outline of the story (perhaps the whole story) at ABC's Web site.
by arial27usa
Just because something is in your mind doesn't mean it is not real. I have had a host of medical proplems for about 15 years. I was told by doctor that they could find nothing wrong with me. I finally came up with symtoms that could be DXed. Foryears I smoked pot to help with my physical symtoms and depression. Then I had an MRI and I have MS. So now I am on some very expensive drugs that I don't like taking but I have to stay on them to get my SSI-disablity. If I had just stayed smoking pot is that any worse than taking betaseron and prozac. The pot was cheaper in the long run. I also felt better. This was something that was just in my brain, is that not the same as in my mind. Things in your mind are real and me tell you very real.
Arial
by jardinier
The nature of "mind" actually belongs in the realm of metaphysics. Unless you can define what you mean by "mind," then you can't say whether or not it is independent of the body.
Until someone can prove otherwise -- and I doubt if this can be done -- for all practical purposes the "mind" is the brain, which is a physical organ, and subject to physiological reactions just as any other organ or part of the body.
While you are defining "mind," you might also have a go at defining "Spirit" and Soul."
And while your'e at it, you may also care to define "reality," "consciousness," and "sentience."
Good luck.
by madroxxx
by hal 9000
You are right any change must first be brought about by a desire to change and it is the desire that causes the change rather than the actual change itself. I am a smoker and while I smoke upwards of 40 fags a day I can also go without when requiredLike when I'm in a clean room it isn't practial to go outside just for a fag and then spend hours getting back in again.
Also a few years ago I was in a hospital for a couple of weeks and I went without a cigerate all that time because I couldn't get up and walk around at first and even when I could walk I was not allowed out of sight of the nurses station si I went without and had no illefects nore desires for a fag.
But at the same time I was hooked up to a LT and a cell phone that wasconnected to the LT in this way I could continue to work so I guess that my addiction to computers is greater than my addiction to fags.
The question here is should I want to be curred of my addiction to computers or should I just continue to earn a living by building/repairing these things?
by travldoc
First a definition of Addiction so we can be on same page (sic): Current medical definition of addiction: 1. Introduce a substance into system, swallow, inhale, absorb, insert (generic we) use any orifice; ... which produces a pleasurable affect leading to; 2. Desire to repeat exposure. 3. Requires increasing dosage to reproduce initial effect tho rarely does. 4. After repeated (varies with substance) doses, person stops. However then experiences a adverse affect which is uncomfortable (again variable degrees of discomfort), but can be relieved by readmitted of substance of that type of substance, i.e. Nicotine, alcohol, opiates, cocaine, et.al. Again depending on substance the discomfort can be minimal, to deadly. (Addiction to opiates, withdrawal is unpleasant...Alcohol and 'minor tranquilizer [Valium] has up to 50 % death rate if not treated!
Back to opiate addiction, the unpleasant side affects can be largely blocked by giving alpha adranergic blockers until body able to resynthesizes body's endogenous production. [The runner's 'high'; and yes, distance runners that can't run {break a leg} go through same symptomatology]!
Interesting that recently there have been found opiate receptors in the gut, totally separatefrom CNS, stimulated by spicy foods. (Watch out for Cajun and spicy Mexican foods, just 2 of many 'food styles; and not mentioned to bring aspersions to Cajuns nor Mexicans nor anyone!!!
Thus the body.
Back to brain if still functioning after this drivel (though true). Again research has found the endogenous opiate receptors and our ability to make our own fix helps us to survive. Also found however, are benzodiazapine receptors (Valium, Xenix, et.al. [my apologies for using brand names.]
by jardinier
From reading the postings to date, I wonder how many of you have had close personal contact with a heroin addict.
I understand that if you use heroin at intervals of two weeks, you may avoid addiction. But once addicted, it is definitely a physiological craving. The alternatives are "cold turkey" -- a genuinely terrifying experience that the addict has to endure for about 10 days; or methadone, which is even harder to withdraw from than heroin.
A close friend of mine, after being on the methadone program for a number of years, tried to quit. She literally almost died.
Some people of course are addicted to the sound of their own words. It is by no means journalists alone who are subject to this form of addiction.
by mallardtooxx
This is a discussion about abject conjecture, Come now julian are you casting stones? I do not think it is a matter of whether or not these people know an addict personally or not. It is a matter of whether addiction is a mental or physical state.
I will not go into my knowledge here but suffice it to say I understand the mindset. Just remember you don't necessarily have to know from expirenece to be conversant on a topic.
-duck
I think Julian is addicted to casting stones. He just can’t help himself. Whether or not we know an addict or have ever been addicted (to whatever) is not really the point of the discussion. The original post was summarized by asking the following:
“The more we blame outside sources for our failures etc., the easier it is to fall back on excuses. What is everyone's opinion on this?”
Moreover, the premise of the discussion was John Stossel’s recent television program. Personally, I did indeed see the program, and I generally like the way Stossel points out the lunacy in many things. The program did talk about those addicted to the really nasty drugs – like heroin – and how difficult it can be to overcome. But the majority of the program focused on all those other addictions - people who claimed they can’t quit smoking arguing with ex-smokers who claimed that you could if you really wanted to (even if it was difficult); people who blamed their promiscuous behavior on sex addiction; and fat people blaming McDonalds for making them crave fatty foods. It went on to claim that many of the treatment centers were more focused on making money – thus making up all the “isms”– and often times were no more than overpriced vacation stops.
One guy on the program who was addicted to alcohol and smoking pot became fed up with the leaches at these treatment centers spouting their nonsense. He said he came up with hisown 12-step program. He said screw the first 11 steps, and the 12th step was to just stop, which is what he did.
And I agree with that earlier statement – too many people blame their problems on outside sources. If a person blames someone/something else for all his problems, then the only solutions are from the outside sources. If a person blames himself for the problem – WHATEVER THAT PROBLEM MAY BE – the
by jardinier
I guess you have all heard of the Life Education Centres which were founded by the Rev Ted Noffs, of the Wayside Chapel, King's Cross.
I believe the first centre set up in America was in Chicago, but this has now become virtually a world-wide program.
Ted was motivated to devise this prophylactic approach to drug dependency after burying some 150 young people who had died from mostly heroin overdoses.
I guess I feel very strongly about this particular addiction because I have had close contact with so many people who were effected.
One friend, who was a prostitute and a junkie, used to sometimes visit me in the evenings, and then lie down for a nap, asking me to awaken her at 10 pm so that she could go to "work."
However on occasions she would decide not to go to work, but continue sleeping. By the early hours of the morning she would be thrashing around in the bed beside me as the first physical symtoms of withdrawal started to occur.
I am fullly aware that this discussion was only ever intended to be on an intellectual basis, and
I regret that some persons interpreted my earlier posting as judgmental, as this was not my intention.
by hal 9000
More weight if we didn't live in a society where blame is apportioned to everyone but ourselves. This society requires blame to be apportioned and came about from the beloved Legal Profession who make their living from Blaming Others for someone's problems no matter what they may be. We constantly live in a society where it is acceptable and even encouraged to place the blame for our actions onto others as an example just how many people involved in something as simple as a trafic collision {mistakenly called accidents} will accecpt that they are responsible for the collision?
Me I'm personally addicted to Chocolate of the Swiss variety I love it and can't ever get enough but that doesn't mean that I should start legal action against the makers of this product does it? Personaly I prefer to sit back and enjoy some more and not worry about any potential risks as I believe there are far more dangerious risks that we have no controll over and are propageted by Governments in an effortto make a quick buck at the least expence possible as example the low intenisty Electro Magantic Fields that are found around overland electricity transmission cables {sure there is so far no sicentific proof that they are at present dangerious} butby the same defination there was no proof that mercury was dangerious when used to make hats hence the term {Mad as a Hatter} there are numerious other cases where something thought to be safe is latter found to be potentially dangerious but once itis found to be a danger if it is controlled by the Governments the pass legislation to prevent people from instigating legal action to sue them for their lack of insight in properly reserching the thing in the first place.
What would happen if RF transmissions where sometime in the future found to be hazadours to Human Health?
Colinluck and I agree on something! Perhaps there's hope for the world, yet!
Yes, this "blame anyone and everyone else" syndrome has indeed been perpetuated by the shameful legal profession. I couldn't agree more. But just because it's so, doesn't make it right.
If you were to ask this American to list what's wrong with America, the abysmal legal system (as well as the disgraceful tax system) would be at the top of my list.
Pass the chocolate, please....
by cactus pete
It's all relative. If you truly want that badly to stop, you will. If you don't care, you won't. This is true.
So the degree you're willing to put up with the hell from whatever addiction, either way, determines - to a large extent - the outcome.
I've been addicted to caffeine [am again], and that was a bad two days of withdrawal. But it was fairly easy.
What's harder for me at the moment, is my addiction to the leisure life. I've got to get off of my fat duff and slim down. So far, I've only made initial stabbings in that direction. I know I need to do more - but the sofa is quite comfy.
But I haven't personally been addicted to much that was stronger - like heroin. I've heard stories, though, that people sometimes want to stop - so bad - that they kill themselves to be rid of the addiction.
Now, I'm no expert, certainly. But I believe that's a pretty strong will.
by jardinier
for any of the many habits/dependencies/obsessions/addictions that I have experienced throughout my life.
My current "addiction" is collecting software of all and any kind at bargain prices from garage sales and Op Shops. I am "addicted" to watching about two hours of TV drama each evening. I am addicted to stimulating conversation. I could not live without regular and diverse mental interraction with other people. I COULD live without TV drama, and I COULD live without collecting software.
So some of these addictions are of choice, and could be ended by choice. As for the exchange of ideas and experiences, well I think that's almost as fundamentally essential to human existence as food and shelter.
However from both personal experienceand observation, I am also convinced that many people have genetic predispositions to all manner of physical and mental disorders. If drugs or other forms of therapy are required in order to give these people an acceptable quality of life, then I would regard these compensatory measures as dependencies, and definitely not addictions.
As for the use of "leisure drugs," well this can start with peer pressure, or personal choice. And as mentioned in various other postings, the longer one accepts the addiction, the harder it is to break.
by jardinier
Maxwell, I don't stoop to making personal remarks about you in TR discussions, whatever my feelings or opinions about you might be.
Perhaps you could show the same respect to another TR member ... one who, by the way, is always ready to admit when he has made a mistake.
Well let's see. Let me go back and read again what I said. (Pause......Pause......Please wait while I go back and read that comment......Please continue to wait, I'm re-reading the comment......Discuss amongst yourself while waiting - I'm re-readingyet again and again......The topic of discussion while you're waiting is how wrong all the doom and gloom anti-war folks have been......Still re-reading......)
Okay, I'm back. I read my comments again. That seems harmless enough - or so it seemsto me. A little attempt on my part to be humorous - using a comment another person made (casting stones) kind of mixed in with the subject of this discussion (silly addictions). Okay, I'll admit, I tried to be cute, but perhaps I missed the mark, albeit only slightly. Julian, with all due respect, you are either being overly sensitive or, perhaps, you're just playing a sort of devil's advocate role. I must admit, I can't discern which it is. I suspect the latter for the most part, but with the former having a strong influence.
But wait a minute. I remember another John Stossel program about how often so many people "choose" to be offended. It was about how people seemingly have to walk on egg shells wondering about the things they mightsay and do, and how others seem to be offended at anything and everything. I have to wonder, Julian, why you chose to be offended instead of choosing to be amused - or at least choosing to give the benefit of the doubt?
As a point of reference, see the following link:
https://www.techrepublic.com/forumdiscuss/thread_detail.jhtml?thread_id=124049&message_id=748398
or
Now Julian, what was that you were saying about how you never, as you put it, "stoop to making personal remarks about (me) in TR discussions"?
by jardinier
Well you really have caught me out, haven't you.
And I think that I detect that you are still being nice to me despite my fairly frequent emotive outbursts.
So I guess we are still friends, and we agree to disagree on various issues.
by hal 9000
Since I last looked in on this posting and acording to the books addiction is when the body develops a chemical need for a susbance of any kind. This could be Herion or some other illegial drug or it can also be Insulin which is used by type 1 Diabetics under a madical defination a type 1 Diabetic is addicted to insulin and it is not possible to stop this addiction and allow the person to live as they have a chemical need for this substance.
I think the whole defination described in the posting that started this off is too vauge and lacks knowledge about what constitutes addiction from a medical stand point.
by jardinier
I often wonder how the word "empathy" ever found its way into the English language. I have NEVER met anyone who could really understand how another person feels inside themselves unless the "empathysing" person has had some personal experience that is at least remotely related to what the other person (in this case the addict) is undergoing.
I have no idea what it feels like to be an alcoholic, because I have never been in that situation. I know very well what it feels like to be addicted to nicotine, because I have been in that situation.
And I could not count the number of times that I have been assured by no doubt well-intentioned people that "it is all in the mind" and you can "do or be anything you want."
The reality is that I amwho I am: I have definite limitations, and I must learn to make the most of both my weaknesses and strengths.
My dentist is a classic example of someone completely incapable of empathising with the agony which accompanies toothache for most people.He has never experienced toothache, so he just says "take a couple of paracetamol and I'll be able to fit you in next week."
John and George, a couple of old hippies, are both addicted to smoking the wacky weed they grow in the backyard by the fence. (They’re consuming what they’re growing now-a-days for self-defense). Both John and George have a genetic predisposition to such dependencies, as both their parents and grandparents were alcoholics. At least that’s what the experts have told them. Neither John nor George is really hurting anyone by their life style (whether it be by choice or fate), as they do manage to do odd jobs here and there and make enough money to get by. But all-in-all they are just wasting their life away, living in the fog created by that wild weed flower. However, they both have dreams and aspirations of owing their own construction company, and they constantly talk about those dreams and what's stopping them from realizing those dreams.
John has a good friend who’s convinced him that, because of his genetic predisposition, his future is pretty much outsidethe realm of his own control, and he’s destined to remain stuck in the quagmire of the lower class – just getting by, but not really achieving much of anything.
George, on the other hand, has a different friend who’s convinced him that the mind is indeed a powerful thing, that people only use about 10% of the mind’s power, and that these limitations he faces are all self-imposed. George struggles to overcome these old habits and thought patterns, to be sure, but he has at least come to the point where he believes that his limitations are indeed self-imposed, and that he can overcome any obstacles and dependencies to ultimately make his dreams become a reality.
Who has a better chance of shedding his dependencyon the wacky tabaccy, and moving on to be successful in achieving his hopes and dreams?
Whatever your mind can conceive and believe, it can achieve.
- Napoleon Hill
by hal 9000
The above posting only points out the fact that any person who has a chemical need for a substance is clasified as addicted by the medical organisations.
Thus we are all aditics of one sought or another as we all have a chemical need for food water and various other things to stay alive.
The term addict is very lose and covers many things so what are you lot trying to get across?
As the original posting said something to the effect that any person could overcome whatever addiction that they had I was simply trying to point out this was sometimes impossible as no one seriously would recomend a type 1 diabetic to stop injecting Insulin. Similarly no one would even try to suggest that humanity could live and prosper without food or water. Saying addiction is all in the mind is just stupid as anyone addicted to something requires it to continue to fuction at whatever level they chose.
I agree that illegial drugs are only a means of excape from the real world but there are many legal drigs that perform the same fuction and there are far more people hooked on prescription drugs than those who use illegial drugs. BUT there are some addicitions that are necessary or we would just die in a very short period of time on adverage about 4 days without water.
Now who wants to give up their addiction to water or liquards of any kind?
by mallardtooxx
I have risen to meet your challenge Colin! I have not had any liquids for 3 days and am only eating rocks to sustain my self.
As soon as I get fitted with some dentures and they let me out of intensive care I will let you know how it is going ;)
-duck out of water
by jardinier
Actually I much prefer cold fizzy drinks to water.
However I think the whole topic of "Addiction" can be broken down to four separate categories:
1. SURVIVAL: Food, fluid, oxygen, rest.
2. HABIT: Activities or substances that may be be quite harmless, but save us making unnecessary multiple decisions each day.
3. DEPENDENCY: An activity or substance which makes us feel good, but does not require an ever-increasing amount to achieve the desired result.
4. ADDICTION: An activity or substance which makes us feel good, but DOES require an ever increasing amount to achieve the desired effect.
Luke, you're going to find that of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view.
- Obi Wan Kenobi, Return of the Jedi
by hal 9000
by admin
everything :)
We humans seem to cling to those truths most tightly that are the most affected by point of view as well. No one argues a lot that water has hydrogen in it. (although I am sure someone could prove this wrong!) :)
by hal 9000
As an example of how people are told what they can and can't do. The person advising John? what he is susposed to be capable of doing.
I can remember a student undergoing the latest sifentic tests and his parents were told to buy him a shovel so he could shovel up the hores droopings from the streets {Ok it was a long time ago but the points still the same} as he would never amount to anythinghe simply lacked the mental ability to master anything that would better his life.
This person went to work in a patent office and taught himself mathmatics at night and became the Greatest Matamation this world has ever seen he is the Father of all Modern Mathematics and Phyiscs. Anybody want to take a guess who he was?
by jardinier
Of course it goes without saying that if you believe in the quotation to which you have referred, have have achieved every goal you have ever set for yourself and that you are, according to whatever image of the ideal human that you hold, that idealperson.
However I am utterly astounded to learn that you are apparently unaware of the many persons who are born with physical or mental deficiences which prevent them from functioning as normal, healthy individuals.
The most obvious example, which Colin has referred to, is the diabetic (a condition suffered by many high achievers) who will literally die in a very short time if deprived of insulin.
I presume that you also believe that schizophrenics, epileptics, manic depresssives, thalidomide babies, haemophiliacs ... and the list goes on indefinitely ... could by a simple act of will become fully functional, normal human beings.
I must therefore presume you have never encountered the medical term "endogenous." Well then you are indeed fortunate to be free of deficiencies of any kind, and blissfully unaware that many people are not so fortunate.
by hal 9000
But surerly while you're in intensive care they have an IV in you injecting Saline just so you stay hydrated don"t they?
Thankfully someones actually seen the funny side of this.
by hal 9000
I thought that I was only addidictaded to cholacate,and fags now I find out I'm also addidicted to work as well. What a frighting thought that all of us are dependant upon someone elses decissions for our continued survival. Work being the most insidious form of addidicition as almost every ones affected in this way and there is never any thing done to cure us poor devils from this most incidious form of social control.
Perhaps the Dole Bludgers {for those in the US the unemployed who don't want to work} are to only free ones amoungst us as all their interested in doing is having a good time but then again I suspose that thats another form of addiction.
by admin
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Community archive posts
Sort by Trending