Discussion Locked

Is George W. Bush a murderer?

0 helpful
147 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

147 replies

by jardinier

No it is not to increase my knowledge. However I am learning some amazing notions. Some people are 100 per cent convicted that people who observe the Sabbath on Sunday rather than Saturday, will go to hell.

Some people are 100 per cent convicted that people who have the wrong understanding of the nature of the godhead, will go to hell.

These people are fundamentalists. Extremists also, but definitely fundamentalists in that they believe the Bible -- preferably King James version -- is literally true in every word.

Actually I post out of loneliness and boredom. However I do think I shed an occasional glimmer of light into the darkness of rabid fundamentalism.

The challenge of posting at TR is that one is dealing with (mostly) highly intelligent people who have a wide general knowledge.

The challenge of posting at meetchristians.com is trying to chip away at a shield of rigid, inflexible thinking. [Yes that is tautology but I wanted to stress the point.]

Well, must rush back to the Christians and see what nonsense has been posted while I have been writing this. ]:)

by jdclyde

is the boys in grade school teasing the boy that has a girlfriend.

"oh, you have a giiirrrlllfffrrriiieeenndddd".

All the while, jealous of the boy you are teasing, wishing you had what he does.

Pretty sad, actually.

How is your own "enlightenment" search going? How does trying to shatter someone else's fit in that?

by santeewelding

You have a line on his thinking.

I've come back to your post, now, maybe for the third time. Each time has been salutary. But each time, not quite entirely.

This time I notice.

You switch from boys plural to Julian singular.

What of them?

Who are they?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"The challenge of posting at meetchristians.com is trying to chip away at a shield of rigid, inflexible thinking. [Yes that is tautology but I wanted to stress the point.]

Well, must rush back to the Christians and see what nonsense has been posted while I have been writing this."

When/if Christians try to shed some light into your dark and sinful thinking, how do you like it?

by jdclyde

he is to quick to go on the offensive to give someone a chance to actually discuss ideas with him.

What a sad way for a life to turn out. :(

by jardinier

Have you found a new wife yet? If so, my congratulations. If not:

What a sad life you lead. I cannot imagine that you would spend so much time here if you did in fact have a partner.

What a sad life you lead.

One of the primary reasons that I prefer posting to meetchristians.com is that they do not clutter up the threads with a lot of childish repartee as is the case here.

Nor are they cynical as so many are here.

And I do not post to knock down their beliefs. I post to encourage them to EXAMINE their beliefs. I also ask a lot of questions which people like to answer. My input is quite constructive.

Oh what the heck. Get a wife or get a life. My life is especially fulfilling at present.

As for my degree of enlightenment, you wouldn't understand if I set it out in one syllable words.

I have found "The Truth." I no longer have nagging questions about the deep issues of life. I am a very happy cheerful soul.

I think you are just a case of sour grapes.

by jdclyde

No, I have not found a wife.

No, I have not been looking for a wife.

I have my twin boys full time now, and only have a few years left with them before they grow up and leave the nest. That is time you never get back and is more important than any woman ever will be (to me).

When they are gone, I will have time to look in that direction.

As for your post, if you go back and look at your last few posts, it is clear that you were going their to harass, not to discuss. Is it possible you just misspoke earlier and didn't intend to sound so negative? If it would have just been me seeing it, I would reread your posts to see if I just misunderstood. For Boxie to see the same, it is clear that it was NOT just a misunderstanding on my part.

Would you care to re-phrase why you go to Christian sites, when you are not gaining any enlightenment for yourself, and are only their to criticise?

There was nothing in your posts about religion that reflect that you are either happy or content with your life. You are coming across as a very dark individual.

How is that sour grapes on my part?

We both know "finding a wife" is not the end all to fulfillment, right? Or is there something you haven't told us?

by $$$$$$$$$$

... and the act of asserting it?

Reply in the negative if you need it explained to you in
one-syllable words.

by jardinier

having a meaningful discussion with Christians. There are always many threads running at the same time, but someone has asked people to describe their experiences with the "indwelling of the Holy Spirit" and answer various questions regarding the veracity of their experiences.

This is a very interesting discussion because just about everyone at the website claims to have the Holy Spirit but apparently He reveals different things to different people, because they argue endlessly.

Hello jdclyde. I am already happy. A loving female companion would merely raise my emotional status to blissfulness.

by forum surfer

You quoted that saying incorrectly. It is southern in origin and very fitting since religion seems to be the hot topic. It actually goes like this:

"Don't let the door hit you where the good Lord split you."

Had to throw that in...

by puppybreath

Do you remember another person using Jardinier's cop-out reply about "just asking questions"?

The last time I heard that excuse was when Rosie was spouting off with all of her conspiracy theories.

Birds of a feather.........

by jardinier

all the little schoolboys playing their silly little games, but this thread is about [b]George W. Bush.[/b]

It is NOT about Julian Hancock who will now return to the Christian website where people actually stick to the topic and DO NOT play silly little games.

And you actually wonder why I prefer to have discussions with Christians rather than listen to the childish, egotistic waffle which clutters up so many TR threads?

Well if certain people wish to believe they are more clued up than myself, that is their privilege.

by jdclyde

[i]The challenge of posting at TR is that one is dealing with (mostly) highly intelligent people who have a wide general knowledge.[/i] - jardinier

[i]And you actually wonder why I prefer to have discussions with Christians rather than listen to the childish, egotistic waffle which clutters up so many TR threads?[/i] - other side of the mouth of jardinier

===========================

[i]Hello jdclyde. I am already happy. A loving female companion would merely raise my emotional status to blissfulness.[/i] - jardinier

[i]Actually I post out of loneliness and boredom.[/i] - other side of the mouth of jardinier

=========================
[b]
Sounds like you have a real Jekyll/Hyde syndrom going there?

by jck

your 2nd example. he says he's happy...a woman would make him happier...and he posts out of loneliness and boredom.

i'm lonely and happy. i don't get that one.

but the first one is a RIOT!!!! :D lol

by forum surfer

Perhaps a little thing called humility will rub off.

This is an off-topic thread to start with, so it is no big surprise the thread strays off of it's own topic. Would you like some cheese with your whine? If you don't like posting here why are you doing it? Just a thought...if I see a thread with 60+ comments I'll check it out. If it doesn't interest me or I don't want to jump in on the flame war...I don't post. Maybe you should do the same if it doesn't interest you or you don't like the direction of the thread?

by $$$$$$$$$$

I'll have to read the bloody report in full now, but I'm suspicious that the repeated excerpts of the phrase "were substantiated by intelligence information" were provided without context, because each originally was prefaced by "none of which was" or words to that effect.

[i]Seems to me there's still two sides to this story.[/i]

I agree. I want to hear both, fully.

[i]Especially when the Dems admit the statements were substantiated.[/i]

Careful, there. Not all the Dems, and not even all Republicans voted to authorize the invasion of the sovereign nation of Iraq, despite the wish of the GOP party elite to marginalize the most authentic member of that party in a national office, Ron Paul.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]You [b]quoted[/b] that saying incorrectly.[/i]

Note the absence of "quote marks" from that post, dumb@ss.

by forum surfer

dumb@ss? Ok my "quote" was all in good fun and I thought I stressed that pretty well, given the fact I was in agreement with you at the time. It suddenly makes me unintelligent to quote you using quotation marks as opposed to italic or bold tags? It's a few extra keystrokes and this ia freaking forum, not a professional web page. Who gives a flying f#$%? Seems to me resulting to name calling when no one is picking on you isn't exactly a sign of intelligence, either.

by jdclyde

[b]blissfulness[/b]

:^0

I will admit, while I have a damn good life with my boys, I am far from "blissful"... ;\

by jck

if i could get a good woman in my life full time, i'd be more than blissful...i'd be KING OF THE WORLD!!!! WOOHOO!!! lol :D

by kattoon

That's why we are a government of checks and balances. It was not just Bush who made the decision to go to war...congress had to vote on it, and they voted yes...

I get so tired of people crediting the presidential office with all the problems or successes in this country. We are not a dictatorship or monarchy...the president cannot make all the decisions without approval from congress.

that's my 2cents...

by $$$$$$$$$$

Check the votes of the few [seven?] Senators who did get to look at the real intel, not just the poppycock "NIE".

"2 cents" is an overestimate of opinions based in ignorance.

[i]That's why we are employ a government of checks and balances.[/i]

And in the same breath that you parrot the Bush administration's lie that "Congress had all the same information," you presume to lecture adults on political theory!? Typical.

by kattoon

...and making sure they have the answers is part of their job. Have you ever heard of intellegence, staff, etc...

Be honest, do you really think that in this day and age, anyone can keep anything secret?

It's congress's job to make sure they have the info. They have the ability and the resources to get the correct info.

If Bush had been keeping documents about his involvement in a prostitution ring or drugs or something like that (hypothetical), you can bet your bottom dollar that congress would find out about it. So don't give me that line of Bullsh** that congress didn't know any better...

I don't parrot Bush's admnistration, I don't agree with the war and I think our troops should come home, but I'm not so naieve to believe that the president has all the power.

I don't appreciate being called ignorant just because I disagree with you and wanted to comment on YOUR article that you put out there for people to comment on.

I'm not lecturing adults on political theory, i'm just stating the obvious that so many people who are "Bush Bashers" and "Republican Bashers" tend to forget.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Poor word choice, given our earlier disagreement about whether you were "corrected" by another member. You were corrected, dumb@ss. I was not.

by forum surfer

Like I said before, I was not corrected. My opinion is different from yours. You are not the be all and end all of information and correct opinions. Resorting to name calling is pretty lame. Although our opinions differ I at least assumed you contributed an intelligent point of view. You are obviously intolerent of any point of view other than what's in your own little world. Attempting any further dialect with you would be pointless, as you obviously are not as open minded as you preach. Not that I really care...just my 2 cents.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]But the questions about al-Libi may be the most significant--and embarrassing--new disclosure in the Senate panel's report, both for the White House and the CIA. The Senate report found that al-Libi was "the [b]principal[/b] intelligence source" for assertions by Bush, CIA director George Tenet, national-security adviser Condoleezza Rice and Powell that Iraq had provided chemical and biological weapons training to Al Qaeda operatives.[/i]
http://www.newsweek.com/id/141009/page/2

This [i]News Week[/i] story mentions that "most of the Bush administration's claims were 'substantiated' by some internal intelligence-community reports," but unlike the piece you posted, it doesn't stop with the part of the story that implies that the President was not negligent nor dishonest. The full story indicates the opposite.

[i]The CIA's al-Libi report is one of several new--but so far largely overlooked--disclosures to be found deep in the fine print of the Senate's long-awaited "Phase 2" report on pre-war intelligence. The Senate investigation sought to compare the public statements of top administration officials during the run-up to the Iraq War with the underlying intelligence-community reporting within the government that provided the basis for them. After much partisan squabbling within the panel over the issue, the final report (approved by all seven of the panel's seven Democrats and two of its Republicans) reached a largely unremarkable conclusion: that while most of the Bush administration's claims were "substantiated" by some internal intelligence-community reports, the public statements of President Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney and others were selective and failed to convey the considerable doubts, dissents and uncertainties within the community about much of the public case for war. (The panel's GOP vice chairman, Sen. Chris (Kit) Bond, and several other Republican members strenously dissented from the report on the grounds that it did not examine the pro-war statements of leading Democrats such as Sen. Hillary Clinton and Sen. John Rockefeller, who now chairs the intelligence panel.)

Among the new nuggets in the report: the Defense Intelligence Agency was concerned that a key corroborating source for the claim that Iraq had developed mobile biological weapons labs "was being coached" by Ahmad Chalabi's controversial Iraqi exile group, the Iraqi National Congress, "to further its political agenda." In May 2002, the DIA cut off contact with the source, an Iraqi officer identified only as "Major General al-Assaf," and issued a warning notice about him after determining his information was "assessed as unreliable and, in some instances, [is] pure fabrication." [/i]

At the time, they had less reason to believe al-Libi than to disbelieve him, yet he was chosen as the "'[b]principal[/b] intelligence source' for assertions by Bush, CIA director George Tenet, national-security adviser Condoleezza Rice and Powell that Iraq had provided chemical and biological weapons training to Al Qaeda operatives." The only question left is: because they're all fscking morons, or because he told them what they wanted to hear?

by puppybreath

"The only question left is: because they're all fscking morons, or because he told them what they wanted to hear? "

You forgot the most important option: "All of the above".

by $$$$$$$$$$

A very strong possibility.

Aside from those resulting from introducing a new logic gate, do any other major questions remain?

Also, I infer from your reply that you agree with my main assertion, that al-Libi was known to be not a credible source, and that using him as [b]primary[/b] source is, on its own, grounds for impeachment. True?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Alt + [NumPad] 139

You need to educate yourself about the access to secret documents that the President has that most members of Congress do not. Most of them are not able to gain access to documents on espionage and secret military documents that the President does not want them to have. Exceptions are for the [b]chairs[/b] of a few committees.

It's congress's job to make sure they have the info.

You didn't read that in the US Constitution, you made it up.

They have the ability and the resources to get the correct info.

And if the President tells them something, outside of a Press Club comedy event, they should be able to trust what he says. If they have to assume he's a liar, and independently verify everything he says, why employ him at all?

by jdclyde

never even read the reports provided them, as many are hundreds of pages long. Very common.

by puppybreath

I agree that al-Libi was not a credible source (disclaimer: based on what I currently know of the facts which are limited at best).

However, I'm not ready to admit that it's grounds for impeachment. But that's because of my lack of knowledge and understanding concerning what the valid grounds for impeachment are.

That being said, if the courts decided that there were valid grounds for impeachment based on this information, I would not object to their decision.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I liked your previous answer, by the way; it shows willingness to accept facts, even if you find them unpleasant, as I surmise that you do.

[i]But that's because of my lack of knowledge and understanding concerning what the valid grounds for impeachment are.[/i]

Are you willing to opine on how this compares to the grounds of the most recent impeachment?

by puppybreath

that there's a big difference between the two. Clinton lied under oath and Bush didn't.

However, I don't believe the Clinton investigation should have been started in the first place just like I don't believe they should have continued to investigate Libby after it was proven that he was not responsible for the leak.

Once he was trapped, Clinton would have been much better off with a "Jimmy Swaggart" moment rather than opening the door for the perjury charge. He would have been forgiven by most and the scandal would have blown over.

But the Republicans should have realized what would happen if they proceded. Ever since Clinton was convicted we've been spending countless hours and millions of taxpayer dollars while the liberals try to get even. What a waste.

In the long run I'd say they're both idiots for thinking they could get away with it. They've both damaged the country with their arrogance.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Like OJ Simpson's guilt, I overlook references to Bill Clinton's guilt that are consistent with my belief, rather than with the legal determination of the courts.

If there is a "vast right-wing conspiracy" it would have motive to instill a general distaste for the thought of impeachment, shortly before committing premeditated impeachable crimes.

by puppybreath

I was under the impression that he had been convicted of perjury which lead to his impeachment. This was obviously not the case. I stand corrected.

by nicknielsen

[i]Clinton lied under oath and Bush didn't.[/i]

That is a true statement. However, I think Clinton's lie was more a "misdemeanor" than a "high crime." Bush's lying to take us to war and ignoring current law are much worse and, to my mind, constitute "high crimes" worthy of impeachment.

by jdclyde

the last effort is out to try this.

I doubt it will go anywhere just like the last few times, no matter how much encouragement these efforts bring insurgents and terrorist alike.

http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/A3FE0336-5662-46EB-9B83-10F8D6DB0803.htm

If there is anything more than "opinion" that what Bush did was illegal, we will see.

Believe it or not, while socially in the Democratic party lying is perfectly acceptable, ANY time someone commits perjury it is seen as a greater crime than the crime they are trying to cover in most cases, in the eyes of the courts and the law.

And as we saw with Clinton, impeachment does not equal removal from office, and is going to be entirely symbolic. If it did, a President Cheney would be interesting, huh?

Even with Kucinich getting full support from aliens (the green kind), he will get no further than he did the last times he tried this.

This discussion is closed to new replies.