Discussion Locked

Is it just me... or have you noticed, too?

0 helpful
157 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For many years, I have looked to TechRepublic for help and answers. Whenever I had a difficult situation, I could come here, do a search in the forums, and usually find someone else that had had a similar problem. I could then read the resolution and learn from the steps it took to get there.

Things seem to have changed over the past several months.

There seems to be an incredibly high number of issues that are never resolved. Not because a tech here doesn't respond. But because the person asking the question either never returns after the initial post, never answers the questions asked by the responder or because they disappear after suggestions are made - never stating whether the issue was resolved or not.

I started noticing this about three months ago and now it seems to be common place.

So, I started a little investigation on my own and here is what I found:

In the cases where questions are not closed...
Over 86% of them are questions posted by someone from India, Pakistan, or Bangladesh. In some of the other cases, the language used by the questioner leads me to believe that their Location listed as somewhere in the US is questionable.
I also noticed that almost all posters (92%) that left unfinished questions do not have user names. They just use their email address (ex. shawavata@..., vashawna@..., etc.)
In addition, I did not find one situation where a question was unfinished and the questioner was from a mid-eastern country where they allowed email to be sent to them.

I like to think of myself as one of the thousands of regular visitors that greatly appreciate what all the techs here at TecRepublic do to help. I always tag my question as complete, give credit to the tech's post that ultimately helped or at least close the thread with final comments.

Is it that most Middle Easterners (or least those from IN, BD, and PK) do not understand the difference between a 'Discussion' and a 'Question' or is just that they are comprised primarily of INGRATES?

157 replies

by tig2

And tough to answer.

There will always be challenges in an international forum. We have had off and on challenges with hacker wanna-bes, script-kiddies, and the generally obtuse. We get trolls and flamers every day.

To me, the trick is knowing who I can depend on for good answers and recognising their expertise. But I think that you are valuing your peers in the same ways.

All I can say is keep coming back. If you see a "seagull" question and would like to see an answer yourself, re-ask the question with your particular situation. Most of us really do want to help in any way we can.

Hang in there. I think that the phenomenon that you describe is self correcting and will subside.

by tig2

They fly in from out of nowhere, drop a partial question bomb, and disappear. What is sad is that people are responding to the question asking for additional information and the querent never returns.

The other type of seagull shows up, posts a question with a title of "database" and a single word- in this case, "database".

And finally we get questions titled "want hack xp password". Those can actually be fun sometimes.

I think that the original poster is just tired of the juvenile behaviour.

Edit- too many sssss

by mjd420nova

There is so much more on any post that isn't said, but implied, or revealed in the user name and date joined. We all like to get some acknowledgement that our ideas or experiences were able to help others but never get any feedback from posters. I could care less about the points or rankings as any set of numbers used to evaluate performance parameters can be manipulated and influences external and unrelated can slant and imbalance any meaningful figures. I see this exagerarated on other sites and forums but most haven't been around as long as TR. I see the international aspect of the site to be more revealing than most assume and is quite enlightening. We cannot all be well versed in the ways of others sites unless we observe and try to follow by example. Some mistakes will happen and some over look other areas and jump right in.

by winnie the pooh

My disappointment is not that the questioners don't seem to care for the tech so much as it is that they don't seem to want to add to the value of the forum.
That is, they do not contribute to the forum being a source of quick ideas or fixes. I think of TechRepublic as being, in one sense, a troubleshooting database.
Make sense?

by w2ktechman

this has been happening for years already. What I have not seen happening as much is when an answer is posted, and someone else posts a duplicate answer, that the 2nd poster gets the credit while the first does not.
This happened more often a few years ago though. Now, you are right, there seems to be less people responding with the resolution and/or marking as helpful.
Even when people do get back and say what the fix is, most do not mark as helpful as well.

I do not foresee any big change in this area. But for the 2 questions that I have posted, I have not only kept up with them, but marked several as helpful.

by tig2

You are an active participant to the forum.

I think that what is being decried here is the large number of seagulls lately. You remember the issues with the children in Ireland? Lately it has been children in India. Bottom line is that there are idiots everywhere and TR isn't immune.

You remember to post your Questions in the Questions forums and mark people helpful because you are a contributing member of the family and you know about Mae and her shovel. Others may fail to follow through because they don't perceive the interactive nature of the place and they are blissfully ignorant of Mae's shovel.

You're right- it isn't likely to change soon. We need more people like you and fewer seagulls.

by mr.wiz

are downright demanding and rude as well. Many of them ask questions (appear to be students) and either want us to do their homework for them or are asking about schools/courses in their location that could be more easily answered there.

by captbilly1eye

The ones that annoy me are those that perform a disappearing act after posting a question.
I like puzzles but
I was never good at mysteries. :-)

But, I guess, if we focused on the 'little disappointments in life'... and believe me they ARE 'little' ;-)... we'd just sit in a rockin' chair and watch the oranges grow until it was time for the great dirt nap.

Personally, I just ignore most of 'em from IN, PK, HK and BD altogether. Which is a sad thing for those from Indiana. :D

by neon samurai

I suspect I've left a few questions hanging just because I didn't know until this point that there was a "resulved" status indicator.

I don't know why more unresolved questions are coming from over seas specifically but I'd suspect that a number in general are due to not fully knowing how to interact with all the websites functions.

by deepsand

Neither does replying to respondents who have indicated that more information is required.

The problem's not with the site, but with some of the "members".

by neon samurai

Responding to a comment is fully in the lap of the site member. I was meaning only in terms of site functions such as a "question cleared" kind of indicator alluded to.

Your right though, website functions don't account for good old fashion poor manners.

by charliespencer

Most of these posters have membership dates that match the date of the post. They join, immediately ask a question, and are never heard from again. I have a policy to avoid responding to a new member's first question, especially if the member claims the subcontinent as his location. My apologies to those sincere new members from these regions, but some of your neighbors are making all of you look bad.

by deepsand

no matter how long they've been a member. Surprisingly, of those few who reply, it is the newbies who are the more likely to be both co-operative and thankful for the heads-up, with the older members taking umbrage.

by charliespencer

I've done that a time or two. I think if the question has a objective answer or is strictly on a technology, it belongs in Questions. If it subjective or non-tech, it's a Discussion.

by charliespencer

I love the second type, the ones who post a single-word topic and a one- or two-word message body. I enter the words into Google to see what results I get. Ah, to be so easily amused.

by gsg

I posted a couple of questions and gave up after some idiot posted a response flaming me for even asking. I never went back to the questions, because I figured that after that, I don't want to go back. That doesn't seem to be the case that you looked at, but I'd be interested to know how many questions were "answered" this way, and which people are doing it. I don't post questions to TR any longer just because of this.

edited to correct the mistake that the typo demon forced me to make

by mr.wiz

That were posting flames to legit questions. They eventually gave up and went away.

by tig2

Is to flame back. Or grab another peer so that we can all get in on the fun.

We've had some pretty vicious trolls. It's sad to me that you encountered one and won't ask questions as a result. That is NOT the desired effect.

Give us another chance. And keep in mind that you aren't alone out here. To the best of our collective ability we try to keep a lid on that kind of stuff.

by jdclyde

I looked at your profile to follow back the questions you started, but nothing shows up. Would have been interesting to see what the question was, and who/how it was replied to.

There will be times that people ask for information that should be flamed, such as hacking into a system. This is/should be met with ridicule everytime because there is no place for that on a site for working tech professionals.

There are also times that people don't even TRY to get a solution before posting, or expect to be spoon-fed a step-by-step solution. If a simple google search has the solution, you might get a RTFB reply. People have worked hard to get where they are now, and lazy people are especially annoying.

I am not saying ANY of these were the case, as I didn't see your question, nor the responses. Just trying to point out some of the reasons why people get flamed around here.

Then again, sometimes you just come across a real jerk. Again, I can't say.

Give it a shot and see what you get.

by tig2

I think I recall this situation. I am fairly certain that the thread was pulled. It was during our little "Irish" problem.

If I'm correct, he did get his hat handed to him for a reasonable question.

I hate trolls. Now I'm going to have to find Palmetto and give him a slap.

by gsg

I last asked a couple of years ago. The questions were specific to Healthcare IT, so I didn't expect a big response. One was asking if anyone had experience with CPOE (Computerized Physician Order Entry) and how it was received by their medical staff. The answer I got was one telling me we were stupid for trying to implement the system, etc... Another was in regards to one of the multitudes of federal mandates that we have to comply with, and the troll that answered that one showed his lack of Health IT knowledge.

by w2ktechman

Myself and others have been flamed for responding to questions...

Doesn't that beat all...

Anyway, if you have problems that cannot be resolved in the questions area, just send a peer mail to a few of us with a link to the question. f you are flamed for no reason, we can get involved (and maybe answer your question too!)

I am infrequent to the questions these days. Sometimes I visit a lot, and sometimes I will not. But there are others here that do not (or rarely) visit the forums as well.

by charliespencer

We seem to have the idiots under control at the moment. (I think the recent aerial spraying program is putting a dent in the breeding population.) Even if an idiot posts a flaming response to your question, remember that he is not the only one on this (or any other) forum. Check again later and you'll probably find a reasonable answer.

by absolutely

Don't allow members who don't accept peer mail to [u]start[/u] threads, or some similar sort of requirement.

If enough of you reply that like this idea, I'll start another thread with tag "feedback" or "site feedback" or whatever it is, with exactly the requirement we decide we want.

by w2ktechman

I am sure that many of the email accounts used are new and setup just to create an account at sites like this. They probably never even check them and/or close them out for another in a few weeks or less.

But, I could be wrong as well.

Also, putting more restrictions up may cause less people to decide to post here. And that would be a shame for TR and everyone else here.

So basically, the best that we could do is monitor better on our own. If we see flamers replying, we should get involved. If we see that the questions area are being abused, we should inform TR. If we see that people are not responding back to questions, ignore it, no reason to get upset. If we see that people are not marking as helpful, but have participated with responses, we should ask them to.

Tis a community effort (at least those are my thoughts).

by charliespencer

I know at least one of them peer mailed me a few times, always from a different account. These wannabees are hit-and-run, and don't care what shows up in an Inbox they never check. Besides, would you want to peer mail them and let them get your address?

by deepsand

that might cause them to lose eyeballs.

The idea of having requirements in order to be able to exercise and/or continue to use certain functions has been debated & requested on more than one occasion; in all instances, including those where TR actually [u]asked[/u] for such suggestions, [u]no action was taken[/u].

I see little reason to believe that TR's reluctance to lose views is any less now than before.

by jdclyde

I am lucky if I can remember how to spell my name without looking it up, let alone who our irish punk was giving crap.

So I was just giving him a full pass on it, and wanted to point out what I feel are valid reasons for chastising people when they ask questions. (just in case)

if nothing else, that gave Beth something to occupy her time! :D

by deepsand

The only difference is that now it's harder to find those Questions which are properly in the Question forum.

And, no, it's not just "them foreigners;" the U.S. has a more than ample share of the offenders.

by steffi28

He must be feeling left out after the recent lack of trolls he hasnt had too many slaps, we'll have to slap him every now and again just so he doesnt feel left out or lonely

by charliespencer

I've already been b!tch slapped for the "Irish" problem. You can't smack me around for something that happened six months ago! The ringing in my ears was just starting to quiet down, and I'm down to only 14 aspirin a day.

by steffi28

You see our hands have stopped hurting from all the slapping and just as we were getting used to the tingly feeling too.

We just missed beating you up! Sorry

by ghostbrowser

Just for you all

Try not to be or act like a troll
Yes I may be guilty of it

But if you must troll at least make it funny
People at least will get a laugh out of it
Laughter is the best medicine

Some people have no sense of homer

by shellbot

there's really no trolls in this thread..so your advice is not hitting the target audience :)

I'm sure we could find some though..I believe w2k has some sort of bridge that there may be some living under..i'll go check..

*runs off excitedly like the girl i am*

by deepsand

Even under the previous version of the site, with the "Technical Question & Answer" forum, supplicants routinely ignored peer-to-peer messages asking them for additional info., for their rating of answers or the closing of resolved questions.

The problems of questions being posted in the Discussions forum, rather than in the Questions one, not responding to requests for additional information, and providing no feedback are [u]all[/u] owing to exceedingly poor manners.

by neon samurai

At least most of them can find the Caps Lock key and turn it off. ;)

Point taken though. I've had my hands inside machines for nearly 30 years now and even I'm still learning this online forum stuff (beyond ye age-old IRC etiquette that is).

by deepsand

I'll not mention their names here, for fear of attracting their attention; best leave sleeping {fill in the blank} lie.

by deepsand

A fair number of newbies are using the People section to find regular participants who accept peer-to-peer messages, bypassing the Question forum & directing their questions to selected individual members. In general, these missives are no more well written, or containing of sufficient detail to even try to resolve the problem, than are those posted here.

I've had to adopt a policy of replying with a boilerplate missive that instructs them to first search TR for similar questions, try the suggestions given their, and then, if need be, post their questions to the Question forum, beign sure to include all necessary details; I also invite them to send me a link to their Question is & when such is posted.

To date, [u]only one[/u] has ever responded; in that instance she thanked me for my pointing the way, gave me a link to her question, and rated my responses there.

by w2ktechman

I either know the person, or they leave a link to a post. If not, I may look up their username and look for something that they have posted to.

by deepsand

and that they feel more comfortable making a private plea for help. To what extent that accounts for the e-mails I get I cannot say.

By giving each the benefit of the doubt, I've no reason for later questioning my personal behavior towards others.

by charliespencer

I just toss the messages in the ol' bit bucket. However, if you wouldn't mind posting the boilerplate, I could probably use it. Also, does anyone have a good template for posting, "Hey, put this in Questions, newbie!"?

by w2ktechman

Hey Dumba$$, get a clue
or
Is this supposed to be coherent?
LOL
Ok, enough for now.
Sorry Palmetto, I dont use templates often (which is funny cause my Outlook email is full of them that I have created).

by deepsand

Try the "Questions" forum; the "Discussion" forum is for matters of general discussion, not specific problems in search of a solution.

There are those who specifically seek out problems in need of a solution, and that's where they go to look for such.

Additionally there are the benefits that:

1) The "Questions" forum provides for your feedback, by way of your being able to mark "helpful" responses as such. This does not necessarily mean that a given response contained the complete solution to your problem, but only that it served to guide you toward it. This is intended to serve as an aid to those who may in the future have a problem similar to yours, so that they might have a ready source of reference available, thereby perhaps obviating the need for them to repeat questions previously asked and answered.

2) The revised TR makes it quite difficult to find both "Discussions" and "Questions" that have not had a fairly recent post, owing to some functions comingling them in the listings. By keeping each type in their respective forums, it is easier for all to find what they are looking for.

by captbilly1eye

... ready-made response... I like it. As it is (chalk it up to my laziness) I just drag the email into BounceBully so they get a "Unable to Deliver..." message.
My bad.
Maybe that's one reason I only have a 1.
:-(

by w2ktechman

you knew to stay as #1 for a lot longer than I did. I am at the lowly #179......
Oh, what it was to be #1!

lol
keep working on it, your number will change soon enough.

by tig2

For those as wants it...

Thank you for your post. Unfortunately, it is not likely to get the attention it deserves in the Discussion forum. Please re-post to the Questions forum by selecting the "Ask a Question" button. You may copy and paste your content to there.

Many do not read the Discussions forum and taking this step helps to insure that your Question gets the attention it deserves.

Please do not forget to rate answers that you find helpful as being so.

Good Luck!

You may all copy and paste as you wish. May a thousand Tiggers come and pounce you. Oh wait. I'm the only one. I'm hiding from a tornado just now or you would be in all kinds of... oh wait... tornado over. YIPPEE!

by captbilly1eye

yea... looking at it that way, I guess having a lower number is like bein' in stealth mode.
Less pestering, less expectations. ;-)

[Nilsson - "one is the loneliest number..."]

by deepsand

If it's a "how do I use" a named technology, it's a Question; those soliciting opinions about a technology and/or comparisons among several, would be Discussions.

Basically, Questions are those which seek a specific objective response regarding a technical issue.

by w2ktechman

but my solution works for me anyway.
And if it is for problem resolution, it will not help the 'next' person with that problem if it is not posted.

by deepsand

it's quite likely that they will [u]not[/u] post their question there, which still leaves that "next" person without benefit!

by ghostbrowser

They?re just birdbrains
And giving them the whole bird may crediting them with to much

But I have seen what is being talked about

I was part of a discussion
The person I was trying to help had used the OEM recovery disk from another OEM
Why?
They could not find the XP disk and were unable to buy one
They had a HP computer so told them that HP would sell them a disk
Some ever so helpful person had chimed in and told the person that what they were doing was illegal

So stupid and of no help to the person with the problem
Shows how MS also very clever people lost a sale
HP made one
The person may now be happier with HP
They also maybe less than happy with MS
Not to mention the birdbrain who chimed in

by ghostbrowser

The person already has a problem
Which means they are already unhappy

Some of them are happy when it is fixed and tell you

Some think that it shouldn?t have happened in the first place
And don?t see why they should be happy now just because it?s fixed

Others are only interested in what they can get from someone else
When they have what they want they?re gone

One in ten people may thank you
One in fifty may praise you
The rest are unhappy for many reasons
Don?t let it get you down

Cheers Steve

by ghostbrowser

"peer mail them and let them get your address?"

One of the resons I don't use peer mail
It's not the only reson

by w2ktechman

but often do not respond with it. It depends on a few things, like do I know the person, and/or do I want to trust them enough.

I can always get a new mail account and use it here, so I am really not too worried about that, but I do hate SPAM.
Usually I respond to peer mails through a post. If it is something that I do not think needs to be posted, and I am comfortable enough with the peer, I will respond via mail.

by gadgetgirl

I think you're correct - another initiate to the Impure Brigade....

oh, I does like the ways this guys minds woiks!

Now, Ghostie, how about some squirty cream or body choc with that 69?! ;\

GG
]:)

by daveo2000

You should feel the shame that is due you!

Go now, to the alter of the Goddess of Purity! Look up into her eyes and let her clense your vile thoughts.

Make full use of the tools of the Goddess to bring you to the brink of rapture! Feel the waves of warmth enrich your tortured soul! Know her ways! Drink of her Purity! Feel her followers around you! The laying on of hands will help you come to the Pure side. Ask not for these devices that you seek. That which you truly need will fill your desires and you will overflow as you bring the weigh to your bosom!

Now, go 4th and feel the Purity!

(I think Steffi, Mae and Shell are in line before you.) ]:)

by shellbot

I think you've just volunteered to take Ghost under your wing for a day or two..You know..show him the things he needs to know..

thing is: is he all show (just leaves a tantalising title..or is he willing to go all the way and actually post!!??

squirty cream..ughhh..nasty stuff..choclate fudge sauce...nice and sticky takes ages to get off..er get it off i mean.. ]:)

by ghostbrowser

Guess only the not so clean and impure misunderstood 69 my reference

Which may be that the person occupying the 69 position on the list may be having a lot of fun

Again
No I don?t want to hear about your kinky sex acts

Had to add this

Or your dry or non dry-cleaning methods

Yes things appear better when drunk
But the results maybe

1. Having to extract yourself from a difficult position
2. Not being able to extract yourself or find the exit (let alone the entry)
3. Controlling yourself enough to do this or anything at all
4. Weird delusions which you may be unsure of as to the truth
5. Choice of undesirable locations, partner (or not) and or accessory?s

Just some
So beware evildoers the law has arrived
The keystone cops and all

by absolutely

Just search for strings 'gadgetgirl', 'steffi28', a couple others, including now 'Ghost Browser'.

]:)

by daveo2000

Oh, youthful innocence! Venture not in the ways of the Impure! Whilst danger begs the question of excitement, not all excitement is good for the sole!

Be ye, at all, of the Pure of heart, go knot this weigh! The live vile veil of evil will masque the knarly teeth which lie beyond!

Stay amongst the Pure amongst us and ward off the nasties that line the road of the Impure and Impure thoughts! Keep your eyes on the goddess of Pureness, the ever pristine image of the Ivory Snow Girl. She will lead you beyond the green door of Pureness, not the red door of the Impure!

Don't bow yourself in shame, keep yourself erect, your head high, your thoughts Pure!

Only then can you be brought to the bosom of the Goddess of Purity and live your life in the rapture that awaits you there!

[i][/i]

by daveo2000

How can you suggest such a thing? To bring such shame to the Goddess of Purity? You must be a base and callow fellow to have such vile, evil, veiled thoughts!

You bring discredit to your name and shame to those that would walk with you into the valley of dolls. You must REPENT and DISAVOW your ways of villany and impure thought!

I can't believe you could say such a thing about this poor innocent young waif who brings smiles and thoughts of warmth to so many. If only you could feel the caress of her soft hands upon your brow. You would melt as she strokes your head and shows you what a good time should be! How could you be so cruel as to make such allegations?

Are you so IMPURE?!?!?!?

It was the early 70's.

by deepsand

What righting skills I may have owe to Mrs. Breon, a high school English teacher, and a love of reading.

by daveo2000

My Dad, who came out of Annapolis in the 50's was well versed in the use of the language as well. He had inflicted me with the same verbal virus. ;)

It is quite distressing when somebody asks me what a word means and I find that it is a word that I thought was a basic one. :(

by daveo2000

Would you think that I would stoop so low? Would I have to stoop so low? ]:)

I thought I only had to mention it, no trick intended :p

by gadgetgirl

Muller Fruit Corner....

guess what the fruit in the corner is for?? ;\ ]:)

Squirty cream - favourite: Tia Maria, 2nd - Lambs Naval.....

]:)

GG

by gadgetgirl

1. I never feel shame.
2. The Goddess of Purity? Nah - killed her off years ago..... far to sickly pure...yeucch...
3. Look, just cos I'm not that tall doesn't mean I look into the level of other womens' boobies. Not that way hinclined at all. Totally carnivorous. Never been into vegetarianism.
4. The only rapture I've even know has been something to do with impurity.... ]:)
5. My soul is only tortured for one reason, and he knows who he is.....
6. Laying on of pure hands? On ME? If they're male, well, [B] BRING IT ON! [/B]
7. What devices I seek? I've already got my own...thanks anyhow
8. Fill my.......desires? Oh. Ok.
9. overflow as you bring the weigh (sic) to my bosom? oh, so YOU'RE the one who managed to shrink all my bra's last week! Just wait, I'll get my revenge for that! As for weight - who's been talking about my melons?

10. Go 4th and feel the purity? Nah.

I'd rather go second, and come first.... ;) ;\ ]:)

GG

(D-02K - thanx for pm! )

by daveo2000

it takes ages to get chocolate fudge sauce off. It doesn't have any nerve endings. Happy endings, maybe. :)

Maybe GG was talking about putting the Choco fudge on top of the eyes cream?

by daveo2000

than thinking of a healthy young lass running around excitedly. ]:)

Unless, of course, it would be Steffi after the operation. She might knock herself out or suffocate! Couldn't have that!

by absolutely

among TR regulars, these, & jdclyde & HAL9000 & a couple others, but I won't name names that I can't remember, pretty well [b]epitomize[/b] vulgarity. Just an observation...

by deepsand

A Willie Dixon blues song from 1961, this has been covered by John Hammond Jr. and Howlin' Wolf, among others. The Doors decided to cover this after their guitarist Robbie Krieger heard John Hammond Jr.'s version.

A "Back Door Man" is a guy who has relations with a woman while her husband has been out slaving away to provide for her. The usual guilty perpetrator if a wife was caught cheating was a regular tradesman caller (Ice Man, Insurance Salesman etc.). He would then run out the back door as the husband entered the front door.

The "Back Door Man" theme has been taken up in several Soul and Blues songs, including "Back Door Santa" by Clarence Carter.

See songfacts.com for more.

by ghostbrowser

Cut the new, young and innocent stuff
You have no idea of the depravity

What you want more
That?s it

No I don?t to hear about your kinky sex acts