Discussion Locked

Is it now the time to switch to renewable energy?

0 helpful
143 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
We've all seen it on TV and felt it at the pumps. BP?s shutdown of half of the nation?s largest oil field in Alaska is just the latest blow in a series of hurricanes, war, pipeline leaks, and just plain greed that have all contributed to rising oil prices and exposed our dependence on fossil fuels. Should now be the time to switch to renewable energy? Why or why not? If you think it is, what should be the best approach? Should Congress provide better support to renewable energy?

143 replies

by onbliss

...late than never!

I would recommend a steady phased approach for the transformation of using more renewable sources of energy in our life. Sudden changes - changes in a short amount of time - could make it little tough to handle the resulting global impact - political and economical.

by aldanatech

I agree onbliss. Now, would you consider start giving some energy sources a higher priority over others?

by onbliss

Yes they should get higher priorities, at least in thoughts. But, how much of that translates to effectively in the every-day life remains an important question.

by w2ktechman

The switch should have been done many years ago. It seems a bit retarded on mankind to keep burning fossil fuels for power that can be obtained much more cleanly. This is not any 1 persons fault, but is the fault of the masses, and greed. Many times we have looked towards cleaner energy, but cost and profit were not in line.

by jaqui

bio-diesel.

the grease tossed out by the local choke and puke
[ mc donalds ] just needs to b run once through a paper filter and it can go directly into a stock diesel engine.

since the origin of the grease is vegetable oil completely renewable

editing to add:

only a 10% reduction in fuel efficiency with bio diesel

by jamesrl

And I've read many artciles, technical and non-technical, about biodiesel. I saw my first biodiesel in the early 80s.

If everyone, or even a significant number of people start asking for the leftover grease, the McDonalds of the world will start charging for it. And even at a wholesale level, "new" vegetable oil costs more than diesel fuel.

I did see an article for a still to create ethanol from waste wood products (sawdust, wood chips etc). Some manufacturers, GM included, are making flexi fuel vehicles which can run E85 (85% ethanol, 15% gasoline) or gas. If you have a farm or a woodlot, this might help.

James

by tonythetiger

There's coal gasification. Not renewable, but at least we wouldn't be at the mercy of the Saudi's et al, while looking for better.

by nicknielsen

It takes water to grow the biomass used to produce the ethanol. It then takes more water to reduce the biomass to ethanol than was required to produce the biomass. In fact, it takes more than a gallon of water to produce a gallon of ethanol.

I believe the problem is that the initial burst of funding for alternative fuels research resulting from the 1970s fuel shortages was essentially shut down by the Reagan administration back when oil was "plentiful." Had research funding continued at the levels of the 70s, I don't doubt we would be well on our way to telling the Middle East "We don't need you any more."

My personal preference is for fuel cells, but this is something we need to let the market decide.

Edit: type, post, proofread

by jck

http://www.theaircar.com

This car is going to be featured on The Science Channel on Wednesday at (I believe) 8pm US ET.

125-185 miles on compressed air alone with in-city driving under 45 mph.

And, the car can go (reported) up to 1243 miles (2000 km) on the dual mode engine with mixed speed driving. the dual mode engine runs both on fossil fuel and compressed air. And while the fossil fuel mode is running, it recharges the compressed air tank.

be nice to get about 80-100 mpg, eh?

cheers

by aldanatech

Well done jck. This is one alternative that can at least give us a starting point. Let's just see if the big oil companies don't oppose -- again.

by maxwell edison

How are they blocking the creation of an industry that has no ties to them? If you want to blame any particular industry, it would be the automobile industry. Unless, of course, you are suggesting that "big-oil" is holding a gun to everybody's head forcing them to behave in a certain way. And if you make that claim, please prove it with solid support, and not the usual rhetoric.

(By the way, I'm with you on this issue. I just don't believe in those silly conspiracy theories.)

by tonythetiger

Is America's middle aged population ready to take over support of their parents when their pensions, which are largely invested in oil company stock, collapse?

by Member 25348569

that very few to none of these will be sold in the USA without some sort of major shift in either public attitudes or the price of gas. What idiot is going to drive that tiny shoebox on roads where SUVs and trucks are the majority.

The car is, in a way, a bit of a sham. It's only the size that gives it the fuel consumption figures as compressed air has to be compressed by something and that uses fuel. The compressed air is only an energy store and is probably less efficient than a really good lean-burn petrol engine.

Sorry to rain on your parade, son. :)

by maxwell edison

Nobody in the USA wants to drive one of those little tinker-toys you guys call automobiles. Heck, even the most extreme environmental whackos don't drive them! However, in their (our) defense, your country is a heck of a lot smaller than ours, and those little tinker-toys aren't very practical for traveling distances that cover hundreds or thousands of miles.

I also don't believe that a sentiment such as suggesting a life-style change is very realistic either. Our nation was built "spread-out", our cities and suburbs were built with a dependency on automobile travel, and we can't really unbuild any of it. The best we can do is integrate something new into it.

And we also don't have a government that "forces" people to behave in such a way. (Although there are a lot of people trying to make it that way!) I mean, really; we don't have an Adolph Hitler telling everyone they must drive a "people's car", nor do we want one.

All of which brings us to the perfect solution. Build a vehicle that can compete in size, comfort, reliability, and practicality, but one that runs on alternative fuel that can be purchased at comparable prices. Now I'm not smart enough to do it myself, but there's bound to somebody (or somebodys) who is.

Why it hasn't been done up to now is very telling. It must not be as easy and clear-cut as that. However, when it becomes crucial, It'll happen. Necessity is, after all, the mother of invention. It must not be to the point of being necessary enough.

by mjwx

Sales of SUV's in the US are down 45% in the past financial year. A shift that dramatic shows that attitudes are changing or fuel has just become too expensive.

In the case of high fuel prices, I welcome our US brothers back to the rest of the world. :)

by jck

There is actually more than one model of those cars. I guess I should have pointed you to the models page:

http://www.theaircar.com/models.html

I agree that American attitudes will have to change. The majority of people here think if they have the buck to buy it (or can get the credit card limit to buy it), that it's okay. They often don't think beyond their own personal greed and desires at all.

As for the mileage being a sham, I have to point this out:

Rather than pay for electricity to run a gas pump to pump more gas to burn in the car (burning oil and coal to power a pump to give you more gas to burn), you can use that electricity to run a compressor in your own garage to recharge it at your house (notice, it says recharge time 4 hours on the models page). You won't necessarily have to go to a "station" to get refilled unless you're doing long distances.

And then if you buy the car with the dual-mode engine...highway driving while consuming petrol will recharge the compressed air tank. That would significantly reduce the amount of petro used.

Therefore, it will reduce in every case the amount of fossil fuels necessary to operate the vehicle.

As for less efficient...how efficient does an engine have to be to move 2-5 people around? Do you need 0-60 in 4.3 seconds?

And if you meant efficient as in fuel consumption...isn't using compressed air 100 percent efficient at reducing both the pollution caused by and consumption of petrol?

Sorry, Dad. Your analysis just seems short-sighted. The car and its design makes sense. Whether it will be popular is another thing. Here in the USA, it will become popular...if gas ever reaches $9 per gallon. People will be screaming bloody murder...and...probably some corp will invest heavily in that car or one like it to make a huge profit.

BTW...if I get to move to Ireland or the UK, I will be buying the van model once I purchase a car there. Guess I'll be an idiot? :D

Curry and pints on the way! :D (hope the ear is getting better)

by maxwell edison

And the best way is to get Congress OUT of it, not to provide better support, as you suggest.

I believe that all the money and effort that has been spent trying to get other people to do it, should ALL be diverted into just doing it. Build it and they will come.

Congress won't "build it", nor should they. Private Enterprise should, and the people harping the loudest should put their money where their mouth is. And personally speaking, I'd jump on board, because when it happens it'll be a boom industry. If Detroit won't do it, start a new industry in ___________ (fill in the blank), and make it the alternative fuel vehicle capital of the world. An entirely new industry sprung-up in Silicon Valley, and this would be (could be) no different.

By the way, why hasn't all that money and power behind the Democrat Party already done it? Don't they really believe in it? Are they simply paying it lip-service? Or is there another reason?

by onbliss

How much of an issue is nuclear waste? Sometime back, I heard on radio that some states in USA were having some problems in disposing the nuclear waste.

by Member 25348569

We need a reliable way to dispose of it. the only way that seems to be feasible is to get it off the Earth. Current space technology isn't good enough and what we need is some form of SSTO spaceplane with considerably less explosive strapped underneath it than the Shuttle. It needs to be scramjet powered or some newer technology that can get to space in a failsafe fashion at which point we can strap the waste to some booster rockets and drop it into the Sun. The spaceplane should be re-usable but if it blows up on the way down that's not so bad (we make it pilotless!) as we just have to not have it blow up on the way [b]up[/b]. The amount of money available to pay for such a service would be astronomical! (PI)

by tony hopkinson

is called vitrification. Course it's expensive so it's only suitable for really radioactive waste. The slightly radio active they are going to bury in your backyard.

Vitrification is turning the stuff into glass. You get to hear how it will last 200,000 years and pose no danger to the public.

Three bits they tend to gloss over are. When dumped on the sea bed (perfectly safe place to put the perfectly safe toxic crap), it will not mutate any marine life, it kills it instead. This is a beneficial side effect !

The next is, the first step in the process is keep the stuff in a big tin for forty years so the gamma radiation and the odd invetible leak of alpha and beta bleeds off in to our environment.

The third and absolute killer, is that decommisioning costs including disposing of the reactor, cooling system, sheilding et al run into billions. If the energy industry had to foot the bill there would be no nuclear power at the moment, fortunately they get to foist this wee overhead on the taxpayer, so the share holders can make a quid.

Still lets forge on, I'm sure our great grand-children are going to call us c***s anyway, so what's one more disaster to bequeath them.

by jamesrl

I worked for a company that designed and built nuclear reactors.

My former employer's reactors did not sue highly enriched uranium and the waste created did is not as bad as those that do(which is everyone else's). But on the scale of things, the area with the most problems with nuclear waste storage is from weapons making, not reactors. We've learned much about storage since the 50s when the bomb making binge started. There are many weapons making sites with serious problems. And often its the toxic and radioactive byproducts that are the problem as opposed to the bombs themselves.

Most of the reactor waste in the US is safely stored, but if the number of plants is increased, new plans will have to be made. But if we can handle deadly chemicals, we should beable to handle nuclear waste, if we committ to the long haul monitoring of it.

James

by Member 25348569

Interestingly, there was a "natural nuclear reactor" in Gabon, Africa, which was active around 1,700 million years ago when the ratio of fissionable Uranium to non-fissionable was higher than it is now.

The fission products to do appear to have moved or been leached out by groundwater in that length of time! AND it wasn't vitrified.

Seems like burying it is OK if the rock strata are stable.

by too old for it

You load the nuclear waste in a Saturn V booster. You mount a rudementary guidance system on top (find the sun, head toward same). Install big enough engines to get it up, up and away, and eventually the gravity of the sun wil take hold.

by aldanatech

... but I do have the strong suspicion that they might attempt to do something about it, since it is an industry that depends largely on combustion engine vehicles. And you know, I do strongly blame the automotive industry as well. I'm pretty sure you could of come up with a fuel economy vehicle decades ago, so what's the hold up?

by maxwell edison

...."so what's the hold up?"

Even if there is a concerted effort between "big oil" and "big auto" to maintain the status quo, and I'm not suggesting that there is, they can't possibly be preventing two completely different and competing industries from being created. If that were the case, you could surely show me just one case in which a person or a fledgling company was destroyed by the "big conspiracy". Show me just one instance that supports such a theory. You can't, because that's not the case. Show me just one modern-day Preston Tucker.

Which brings me the comments and questions I asked in a different message. I believe that all the money and effort that has been spent trying to get other people to do it, should ALL be diverted into just doing it. Build it and they will come. Why hasn't all that money and power behind the Democrat Party (or that particular movement, such as the "global warming" movement) already done it? Don't they really believe in it? Are they simply paying it lip-service? Or is there another reason?

by aldanatech

You're right Max. We can't really rely on the government (any government) to work on something like this. As for the Democratic Party, well, I don't know. High oil prices were not an issue back in the 90's, so perhaps they didn't consider it a big issue. Now it really doesn't matter since they hardly have any of the power they had back then. So the question is, will the current government consider to at least discuss it?

by Member 25348569

I don't see anyone in the UK buying one either as I can't see garages adding compressed air to their long list of gas, diesel, lpg, hydrogen, bio-diesel, U235 and whatever they'll need in the future. The car is a sham as there is no such thing as a free lunch with the compressed air needing energy to compress it.

BUT - and you knew that there was one coming - we both need to go away and check some figures.

Factopinguesstimates (tm)

How [b]does[/b] the average miles per person per year stack up for our two countries? I don't know and I can't seem to find the figures (yet) but I'll bet you a steak supper that they're closer than you think! What differs more is the size of the engine.

The average mileage of the standard automobile in your country has stayed the same or gone down when compared to automobiles before the first oil crisis of the 1970s. This means that every advance in engine efficiency and decreased emissions has been swallowed up by a commensurate increase in the power of the average engine.

Ok, so I don't want you to buy a Smart or jck's little air car but...

To be honest, I think we both know that commercial interests drive (PI) the whole sorry mess. with gas at ?1/litre we have people who exercise their creator-given right to drive their penis-extension SUVs in this country with its narrow roads and little country lanes so the wide-open spaces and cheap gas of the US aren't going to force change.

What will? I don't know but it can't go on for ever.

by mjwx

Given that our two countries are of similar geographical size and our cities are more spread out than yours in terms of population density, we have fewer people per 100 square metres (Ha suffer the metric system).

What would drive up the mileage in the UK is high population density (70 million people on that tiny island) and climate (US and AU climates are fairly temperate, or at least calm which is better for driving in).

I will probably invest in your bog standard regular automobile (sedan or small car) with a LPG conversion (LPG is only 60c per litre and is produced locally) until we can decide on a new fuel standard.

by Member 25348569

Several insurance websites have much the same data and that is that, on average, UK motorists travel 9,700 miles a year. One government statistics site suggested an average of 6,800 miles per person per year so I'd guess that that would be inclusive of non-drivers. it varies from 5,500 in London up to 8,200 in the more isolated areas. The figures are for 2001. Nearly 30% of UK households don't use a car for whatever reason.

The US figures for 1994 that I have found are per car and per household so the correlation with the per head of population per year isn't applicable. Per car, the average was 11,400 pa. Per household, 21,100 miles pa.

Not so far away. I scent blood. ]:)

Whose, I'm not sure, so I'm off to search for some better statistics.

by maxwell edison

...IS discussing it, at least the president is. Whether or not one believes it's genuine depends on one's opinion of the president, I suppose. But he's discussing it more than his predecessor ever did -- and approving more funding.

And while high oil prices may not have been an issue in the 90s, "global warming" certainly was (if you believe in it, I suppose, as the Dems certainly did). Why didn't they start something back then? And "Mr. Global Warming", himself, Al Gore, was in the U.S. Senate and the White House throughout the entire 80s and 90s, half of which both houses of congress and the white house was controlled by his own party. He did nothing except yap.

It goes to the old saying, look at what they do (or don't do), not at what they say. And it speaks volumes.

by mjwx

I find them insanely hilarious.

However back to the matter at hand, it seems strange to me that oil companies claim they cannot lower the price of fuel at the pump whist making record profits. No conspiracy here, just plain old fashioned greed.

by mjwx

A space elevator would be incredibly cheap, all we need is a few thousand KM's of super high tensile cabling. After that its a simple method of using a mass driver type of cannon to launch the barrels into deep space (current mass driver technology is sufficient for this use as the waste only needs enough speed to break geosynchronous orbit).

Currently the best way of disposing of Nuclear (Nukular for any Texans playing along at home) waste is to bury it deep underground. We (Australia) have made a trade out of burying other countries waste. We're kind of double dipping here, exporting uranium and importing waste.

by danlm

Part of the problem is building a car that use's alternate fuel which can be competitive with the current comfort, size, and power of our current vehicles as previously stated in post's here. But another part of that problem is the distribution of that fuel.
Electrical Cars - I don't think so, and here are my reasons why.
1). United States distribution system of electricity sucks. Look at all the blackouts. Get 2 million cars plugging in, and watch the lights go out all over.
2). I live in an apartment on the third floor, where are people like me(apartment dwellers) spouse to power our vehicle.
E85 (85% ethanol, 15% gasoline) - I think this is a better solution. And for several reasons actually.
1). We have the farmland to produce it.
2). There already is a small distribution system in place. I seen this listed in the article I am talking about in 3). Not sure if it was msnbc or some link off there.
3). Walmart just did a news release that they are going to look into putting in tanks for distributing this at their walmart super stores and Sam's.
If they do this, that is a huge help in the distribution system. Thus, people would be more likely to buy these types of cars cause they could get filled up at any Walmart.

Now, before you all jump all over me. I don't know if this will happen. But what ever occurs with alternate sources is going to require a distribution system, which would be as big of an investment as the development of the technology.
And the distribution system is where the oil company's have us, and is also probably a consideration of the automotive companies in their decision in developing another type of car.

Dan

by maxwell edison

...and whether yours have merit or not, there's always a way around them or through them -- always.

And I wouldn't see any "distribution system" as a problem to run from, but an opportunity to embrace.

Why is it that people see a problem and use it as an excuse to do nothing? Whenever a problem exists, there's always an opportunity to either solve it or render it moot. The key is to focus on the opportunity, not the problem. This is true in absolutely every facet of life.

by x-marcap

The government regulates how much can be spent on the Power Grid that can be passed along to consumers.

Get the Government out of our businesses and we'll get it done sooner...

by nicknielsen

It's probably going to take a hybrid to significantly reduce oil consumption. But until then, there's the VW TDI. 247lb-ft torque @ 1900 rpm from a 2L engine (http://tinyurl.com/o7vg5). You need a Hemi, a big V-8, or a blower to get better torque, and none of them will give you over 40 MPG highway (http://tinyurl.com/ovlrc).

Edit: the links are for wagons, since that's what I plan on buying next

by danlm

I guess, I worded that incorrectly. What I meant was, its part of the over all solution. I really had not seen any discussion on that part of the solution.
And your right Max, its an opportunity. From my view point. It's an opportunity for someone to make big money. Who ever gets in first, has the most to gain.
Truthfully, I'm surprised the oil company's ain't trying to be first. They could win both ways if they modified their own distribution systems to allow for alternate fuels.
1). High price of gas still being bought.
2). They would be set for when oil/gas is phased out to still acquire profits.
3). Public opinion, we are trying to do the right thing.
Eh, what do I know. I know my car gets 28 miles to the gallon back and forth to work. And I'm looking at a few inexpensive ways to improve that mileage. Already change the oil and filter regularly. Fuel injection cleaners, better tires, balancing, quit gunning it when pulling out from red lights. I'm locked into this car for a few more years, but when the lease is up. I will be looking to move to a smaller car again. Miss my Geo metro right now. Shoot, it was even more fun to drive then this car is. All though, I'm not sure I want to deal with a standard again in the trafic I drive now.

Dan

by nicknielsen

I'm actively looking for a new car right now (my poor Escort will hit 250k in the next few weeks), and I'm having trouble finding one because I want a 5-speed. I like the stick for several reasons:
1. It's what I learned to drive on (my Grandpa's '53 Chevy, three on the tree, uphill both ways out of his driveway!)
2. The majority of my 600-1000 miles/week are highway miles, so there's not a lot of shifting.
3. Even in traffic, I find I pay better attention when I have something to "play" with, like the gearbox.

I've looked on all the Big 3 lots in my area and found one (1) new vehicle equipped with a standard - a bare-bones no options PT Cruiser (only $13,499 after discounts!). We're talking about 7-8 dealers and me looking at sedans, station wagons and the small crossover sux-up vehicles like the PT and the HHR. Of the foreign car dealerships, most are the same. Only the VW dealer has more than one stick-equipped vehicle on the lot.

Edit: late!

by maxwell edison

I'm actually on the same side as you guys, in that I want to become as energy independent as possible, and not be reliant on foreign oil from the middle east at all (see note); I abhor air pollution (but I believe MAN-CAUSED global warming, or climate change, or whatever it's called now-a-days is a crock); and I believe the time is ripe for the development of a new source of energy to run our automobiles.

However, the difference between you an me is the road we take to get there. I believe market forces should drive (no pun intended) the effort, while many believe it should be forced by government mandate. And what really gets my goat are the tactics used by those who try to force the issue; they're downright deceptive and manipulative, and they would take us further down the road to socialism (of some sort and to some degree). And something else that irks me about them is the obvious hypocrisy in that they don't do what they preach and/or try to force others to do. Moreover, none of them have actually started a movement to create the industry to make it happen. Shut the f*** up and just do it, is what I say. But they don't. Why is that?

Get about a 10 billion dollar investment (or 20, or 30, or whatever it takes) from various sources, focus on R&D for several years, mass-production for a few more, and inside of ten years some innovative group could give Detroit a run for their money. But those screaming the loudest aren't even coming close to anything like that. This only shows that their motives are not what they want us to believe.

Note: Yes, I know that all middle-east oil is simply sold into the world-wide market, which includes nations that are not in the middle east. However, different trade agreements could certainly be worked out with Mexico and Canada, especially if we cut our use by a significant amount. I believe that only around 20 percent of our oil comes from the middle-east, per se, and that's a manageable number by which to reduce our use. Moreover, without that commodity in the equation, the war against Islamo-Fascism could be waged quite differently.

by mjwx

It also used for most lubricants, synthetic materials (plastics) and literally hundreds of other applications.

Now on global warming, you seem more interested in ensuring the blame is [b]not[/b] placed on your shoulders than doing anything about it, seems like your priorities are a bit out of order, fix first blame later unless of course you are denying that there is a problem. But there is no point in arguing about this with you so all I have to say on the issue is Time will tell Max, sooner or later Time will tell.

As for industry, industry hates anything that changes the status quo, not that I am implying a conspiracy max. I am just saying that industries are comfortable with little change from the norm, in the case of IT rapid change is norm but in the case of the auto industry no change is norm. My point is that sometimes those people need a swift kick up the arse to change, and by the sounds of it you don?t want to deliver that kick swift or otherwise.

by tonythetiger

I wonder how long it will be before you hear "Gee, how many poor people starved to death because of all the money you wasted on that 'global warming hoax'?

by maxwell edison

....and that's why I mentioned in another message that the oil industry will not dry-up and go away.

On global warming, the LAST thing I'm concerned about is either avoiding or assigning "blame" of any sort. As far as doing anything about it, we may as well try to "do something" about the sun rising in the morning. In a nutshell, my position on "global warming" is this (sorry, Neil, but he made me do it.): No, I do not believe that human activity is causing any such thing. That's the most ludicrous notion I've ever heard. And if the global temperature IS rising as part of a natural cycle, there's nothing we can do about it anyway. Yes, I suppose I'm in the minority of people who have not yet been duped into believing that we are causing the sky to fall ..... or in this case, to warm.

As for industry, I disagree with your presumptions. First of all, creating a different kind of automobile wouldn't necessarily take a change in a current industry, as it could be advanced by the creation of a new one. And even if it would take a change in the current industry, to one degree or another, I wouldn't be so quick to paint all industry with your wide brush of skepticism.

Successful industry leaders, regardless of the particular industry, don't resist change at all, as you suggested. To the contrary, they embrace change. Moreover, they teach it and preach it. It's the very thing that keeps the wheels of industry turning. Any industry leader worth anything knows that change is inevitable, and it's not something to be resisted, but rather to be embraced.

And while you espouse giving them a swift kick to get them going (in your direction), I espouse giving them a swift run for their money.

Go ahead, Australia (or any interest in the U.S.), give the U.S. auto industry a swift run for their money. Create an automobile that runs on anything BUT oil, make it attractive enough and affordable enough to compete with the likes of Ford and GM, and you'll have tens of millions of Americans beating a path to your door to buy it. Go ahead. What's stopping you?

by maxwell edison

Money leaving one investment source is usually invested into another. When a downside exists on one hand, there's always an opportunity on the other.

Moreover, the oil industry would not dry up and go away if an alternative to fuel consumption automobiles were to become main-stream. The airline industry, the trucking industry, railroads and shipping, etc., would, most likely, continue to use oil, not to mention many homes, especially in the east, are still heated with the stuff.

by nicknielsen

All them Texans in the White House, and you know how Texans are about oil. Everybody's seen Dallas. ;\

by jck

Bush's administration has spoke of cutting our dependence on [b]foreign[/b] oil, not all oil. They have backed the exploration of American land for more oil(such as off the gulf coast of Florida and the Alaskan National Wildlife Refuge). And they are raising the average fuel economy of certain cars, rather than taking steps to require the fuel efficiency of all cars be increased across the board. Burning oil, whether Saudi, Venezuelan or American, still produces pollutants.

Bush's backing of CAFE requirements increases in fuel mileage would require about 2-3 years to have any affect, since auto manufacturers would have to re-design cars and put them into production somewhere around the 2010 model year.

If Bush really wanted to do something in the short-term, he'd team with the Republican-controlled Congress and make a tax break for people who ride public transit which would make a far greater impact on near-term oil consumption in this country.

Promoting activities that save fuel, produce less pollutants, and makes less wear-and-tear on the roads (and thereby cutting use of federal tax dollars used on funding road construction) through a tax break for buying rail or bus passes would make a major, near-term impact than raising the required average mileage of automobiles.

If you need an example of a car that was made in the USA, the King Midget was a car made in the 1940s-1970s that got (reported) between 50 and 75 mpg. Sure it wasn't a Yukon or Humvee, but not everyone needs a 7 passenger vehicle either.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Midget

The technology exists to get better mileage in automobiles. But, who in the auto industry wants to spend the money on redesigning their automobiles to get far better gas mileage when they can be pocketing that money?

The answer: No one.

As for Al Gore...he was too busy in the 1980s kissing his wife's behind and pestering the record industry to worry about the environment. He only took up the cause when it became popular. He's no real friend of the environment.

John Denver was more of an environmentalist than anyone on Capital Hill will ever be.

Plant a tree...for your tomorrow... :D

by maxwell edison

Neil: [i]"How does the average miles per person per year stack up for our two countries? I don't know and I can't seem to find the figures (yet) but I'll bet you a steak supper that they're closer than you think!"[/i]

Max: [i]"I'll make that wager"[/i]

Neil: [i]"....Several insurance web sites (suggested) ..... on average, UK motorists travel 9,700 miles a year..... One government statistics site suggested an average of 6,800 miles per person per year ....."[/i]

Max: Sounds like 8250 for the UK per person might be a good number to work with.

Neil: [i]"The US figures for 1994 that I have found are per car and per household so the correlation with the per head of population per year isn't applicable. Per car, the average was 11,400 pa. Per household, 21,100 miles pa."[/i]

Max: In the U.S., on average, 67 percent of vehicle travel is done in an SOV (not to be confused with an SUV), [i]single occupancy vehicle[/i]. Great, we have a bunch of SOB SOV SUV drivers around here!

Source:

http://www.metrocouncil.org/planning/transportation/TBI_2000/PassengerVehicleOccupancy_13County.pdf#search='single%20occupant%20vehicles%20average'

(Note: I did not read that whole document, nor did I even browse through it. The ONLY statistic I look at was the one I posted. Perhaps you'll want to browse through more of the document.)

Therefore, if we take the "per car" average and combine it with the "per household" average, we might come close to an overall average of 16,250. If 67 percent of those are SOVs, that would be a per person average of 10,887 miles.

Let's review up to this point: 10,887 for the US and 8250 for the UK, for a difference of 2637 miles, which is about a 24 percent difference. Therefore, US drivers, on average, drive 24 percent more miles than UK drivers.

However, if we throw in another statistic, and consider that there are more cars in the United States than drivers, and assuming, of course, that we concede that one person cannot drive more than one car at a time, the aforementioned "per household" number would be closer to accurate. And since there are 1.9 cars per household (let's just round up to 2, since neither of us would want to drive .9 of a car.), the "per car" average is pretty irrelevant.

Source:

http://usgovinfo.about.com/cs/censusstatistic/a/carsperhouse.htm?...+survey

Therefore (again), if we take the "per household" average of 21,100, multiply it by the 67 percent SOV factor, we have an average miles per person of 14,137 in the US, which is 5887 more miles than the average UK driver, or about 42 percent more.

Another source that might even suggest MORE miles traveled (and I believe this might be the same one Neil saw, but didn't read it through.)

http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/rtecs/chapter3.html

A final review: Drivers in the United States drive, on average, 42 percent more miles than drivers in the UK. And since I thought it would have actually been closer than that, by definition, it is not closer than what I would have thought, which is what the wager was. (If I didn't say what I thought I wanted to say about what I thought, I'll give it some thought and restate my thoughts.)

Conclusion: Neil owes Max a steak dinner.

Bottom line conclusion: Both Neil and Max have WAY TOO MUCH time on their hands.

by Member 25348569

My problem with hybrid petrol/electric cars or this hybrid compressed air/petrol car is that it seems to be "lost" as to where the energy comes from to charge the batteries or the compressed air tank. Electricity generally comes from fossil fuel. Admittedly, for American markets, it is "rag-head" free. I also have problems in that the efficiency of the whole engine must be compromised by not doing just one thing - burn petrol [b] or[/b] run on compressed air - as well as it could in order to support both modes of propulsion. Carrying the compressed air tank, high pressure tubing, compressor and whatever else is needed to give the dual propulsion adds weight.

That hybrid car is just [b]too[/b] small. Bigger versions would probably sell but I suppose that it does defeat the purpose.

Anyway, given that the simple social change in the US to reduce the percentage of personal automobiles that are trucks and SUVs to the level that it was twenty years ago would probably free the US from the neeed to import Middle East oil at all, an entire country [b]that[/b] blind isn't EVER going to buy that little car.

Neil :D

Had the bandages off and all is going OK.

by jck

Glad to hear about your ear :)

I agree about the USA mentality...totally. People here usually won't make a fairly simple social change until something radical happens.

As for why the car makes sense...OK...I'll simplify:

The difference is that once the oil is refined at the refinery, the petrol has to be trucked to a station and off-loaded. That requires a truck which itself burns petrol.

Then you run your car only on petrol, there is no reduction in petrol use there.

The compressed air car reduces number of truck deliveries needed to stations as well as the amount of fuel the car itself uses to go it's 2000km max dual-mode range vs what a petrol-only car uses.

Hence, it cuts in fuel usage and pollution both at the end-user and the supply chain.

And...if you were a city only driver...you would use the electricity to power the compressors rather than run the gas pumps. 3 mins = air refill time at an air station. I think it takes more than 3 mins to fill up my Kia with petrol.

As for your question:

[b][i]"My problem with hybrid petrol/electric cars or this hybrid compressed air/petrol car is that it seems to be "lost" as to where the energy comes from to charge the batteries or the compressed air tank. "[/b][/i]

Most hybrid cars, as they run on petrol, will recharge their alternative source.

Therefore:

What does burning petrol in a mixed-mode/hybrid car get you? Answer: The ability to operate the vehicle longer on a single tank of petrol.

What does burning petrol in your gasoline-only car get you now? Answer: Nothing, other than the need to stop more frequently to get more petrol.

Anyways...the specs and complete technical info are on that site. I don't think their van version is too small. And, I'm a big man. I definitely couldn't use that "Mini-CAT".

Well, anyways...enough preaching about that...I don't need a huge car...it's why I drive a Kia now. Will look at getting the van model and a home compression unit if I move over and decide I want a car.

by jck

http://www.zevcat.com/index.html

A corp established in 2003 in California is trying to become the first in that state to market and sell the cars for MDI.

That makes me smile :) I am gonna email them and inquire about getting one of the vans here...

by nicknielsen

is the old-time carriage-makers who converted to automobile design in the early 1900s. I believe Ghia and Pinifarina are included in this group.

by aldanatech

The fact that our government is at least discussing it does bring us to a good start. However, I do agree that answer will ultimately come from the private sector.

by jeffykins

Excuse me, but WHY do you think government getting involved is a GOOD thing? Just look at all the things the government has made a complete mess out of.

"Airbags are a good thing; we should require them. Oh, we can't let private sector engineers do their own specifications; we'll have to specify they have to be powerful enough to stop a 190 lb man, not belted in. HOW many kids got killed by the super-powerful airbags? Oops."

I don't want to see a replay of the government control idiocy with fuels. Even though it will take a bit longer, in the end we'll have a solution that works. If we let the government make decisions, we'll just end up with whatever the people with the most expensive lobbyists are selling.

I'm a former public school Physics and Chemistry teacher, and I'm telling you that most of the schemes being pushed right now will make someone a LOT of money, but bring little if ANY other benefit to the country.

Believe me, I'm as eager as anyone to get to the point that we can tell the Arabs (and Chavez) to get lost, but I can't make myself believe that the government taking control will really get us there.

If the government wants to give money for research, that's probably harmless (though extremely unlikely to be directed in the most useful direction). Just look at the COMPLETE LACK of progress we've had in Cancer research in the decade the government's been directing the lion's share of the BILLIONS of $$ spent. 99% of the progress in Cancer treatment has been done by people NOT doing "pure research"; is it any coincidence these are the ones who are NOT government funded?

The only difference between Republicans and Democrats on this issue is that... Come to think of it, there's really no difference; not on this issue.

See if you can email me back ONE thing that the government actually does well. The only example I can find think of is fire departments.

Be well.

by Member 25348569

by which North Americans will switch to alternative fueled or hybrid vehicles, will reduce the miles driven, will switch to smaller engines, will switch to more aerodynamic personal automobiles, keep to the speed limits, anything, WITHOUT government influencing in some way.

Will you all do it on your own? Well, I don't think so.

So, if your not prepared to do anything about it, STOP BITCHING ABOUT THE ARABS. STOP BITCHING ABOUT CHAVEZ.

Have a nice day. :D

by jmgarvin

See, Americans could spread out...ALOT. We have HUGE cities (look at Houston) and highly spread out cities (look at Albuquerque). It is IMPOSSIBLE to live close to work for both you and your spouse. It is very hard to use public transportation (for a large number of reasons, but they can summed up in US public transporation sucks). It is very hard to walk/bike without proper trails and difficult crossing areas.

What REALLY gets me steamed is the total lack of change in the US, even at $3/gallon.

by jck

I'm sending 20 percocet 2nd day to catch up with the beer and curry.

You sound like you need them :D

Sonny Boy

P.S.- Can you call any of your Irish connections and help me get a feckin job over there? :D

by Member 25348569

London is BIG but relatively few drive and not least because it costs 15USD per day to get into the centre and, when you've got there, will cost you anything up to USD30 for a day's parking. That's a combination of money-grabbing capitalism (parking) and money-grabbing socialism (congestion charge). It does have transport which, although grossly overcrowded and antiquated (Mind the GAP), costs a lot less than driving.

However, the size of Houston or LA and the lack of alternatives isn't the reason for the growth in ownership of SUVs and pickups and the reluctance to adopt smaller cars. Wait until it's $6 and people STILL won't change. If here is anything to go by, they'll cut back on something else to pay for an inefficient, un-aerodynamic waste of space.

by Member 25348569

Got loads of paracetamol free from the doc who sewed up my ear. Took some the first night but I only have a little soreness. Can't get oxycodone without a prescription so posting them will probably be illegal. Don't screw up your welcome to the UK on my account - I'll survive.

I'm fine anyway - just having a little fun. We've had this discussion many times before and no-one has yet come up with HOW you're going to change US public opinion without any government input. Just wanted to see if jleven was up for a "robust" discussion. :)

Dad :D

by maxwell edison

Have a noble vision and the ability to clearly and accurately articulate that vision. Don't blame anyone for past mistakes (or perceived mistakes), but rather remain focused on the possibility of future solutions. Stoke the embers of human possibilities, and rally the people to rise up and meet the challenge by performing at their best; and never assume they're incapable of being the best. Don't lie or mislead, or otherwise spew rhetoric. Be real and genuine, and truly believe in what you say. Inspire people to be better than they ever thought possible, and to achieve goals they previously thought unachievable. Sow the thought of lofty possibilities, and reap the benefit of putting that thought into action; sow the seeds of character in action, and reap a future that is to be our destiny. Make our destiny clear and noble, and an entire nation will not only follow, but make it a reality.

by Member 25348569

In a previous like discussion you raised the idea that this crusade should be the equivalent to the placing of a man on the Moon and I do think that something like that is needed.

We have been driven by taxes to smaller cars and lower consumption and you obviously believe that the US can be led to weaning yourself from ME oil. I wish you luck.

by dmambo

We in the US have chosen to trap ourselves in the lifestyle where 2 and 3 car families are a necessity. Thanks to the Interstate Highway System, a HUGE proportion of our economic development is tied to the automobile. Factories are built in exurbs where some workers drive 100 miles per day to work there, shopping malls draw folks from miles away, and housing is built 30 or 40 miles from city centers. Even "local" activities like going to a park or kids getting to school are now driving activities for most people, so a small personal or commuter vehicle is impractical for many families.

In a way, the federal gov't building highways has underwritten the corporations who benefit from our auto jones. It makes sense to me to have the government help us ease out of it by sponsoring the some of the R&D that's needed to move beyond oil. There are lots of universities out there that can do the research and take most of the political BS out of the process.

by dmambo

I was thinking of a small 3-wheeled jobber that a friend photographed while he was in Italy. I'm too lazy to google it or to remember the name.

But for most folks on this side, a Honda Civic or Ford Escort is an example of one of those crazy, impractical, weirdo cars that only dreamers drive. A Ford Explorer is considered a "small" SUV by some.

Hell, it's the exertion of climbing in that puts the "Sport" in Sport Utility Vehicle!

by tonythetiger

It's that public transportation doesn't conform to your [b]chosen[/b] lifestyle. Like everything else the government does, it's impossible for them to do it to everyone's satisfaction.

by danlm

I guese thats true, I never thought of it that way.

I know with my current job, that public transpertation would probably take me twice as long to get back and forth to work. But, if I worked in the main metrapolitin area. That it would be perfect.

Another problem I use to have with public transpertation. Working IT, needing to work overtime. The public transpertation would stop running at a certain time. I would have been stuck.

Part of the public transpertation problem is though. People won't use it. Why should the goverments expand it.

Dan

by x-marcap

It is reasonable. For Farmers like I am forget the city. I pass it on my way to my day job...

by jdclyde

Many of the smaller ones are neither sporty nor utility. they are the station wagon of the new era is all. A fancy smancy grocery getter.

by maxwell edison

.....in October. Driving across the Rocky Mountains at that time of year might result in some unexpected -- and very lengthy -- delays. That could be great, or it could be not so great.

So I suppose I can plan on that dinner, huh? I choose Binion's Ranch Steakhouse. (Look it up)

Scampi a la Maison for the appetizer

Lobster Bisque soup

Binion's Cut Prime Rib

Steamed Asparagus

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Wine - I don't care. Anything is fine.

by x-marcap

It is time to uncap wells in PA,TX,and one in my back yard... Yea! I'll get more than 47.00 / year again. Yea!!!

by x-marcap

I have experience at breeders and at regular reactors. It is more feasible to use breeders and deep well burial...

by mjwx

but an observations, Industries like people prefer to exist in their "comfort zone". There is nothing wrong with wishing to exist in your comfort zone. What I was trying to say is that stagnation in the industry is doing no good for average people as technology progresses and industries don?t. The industry leaders need to me motivated to try new things. Some are trying (like the tesla roadster) and I applaud them for doing so. I am going to assume that you are not an inventor amateur or otherwise so I will inform you that it takes dozens of failures (thinking tesla roadster) to produce one good success and for the most part that success will pay for each failure a dozen times.

Also Nick pointed out a good example, did you know max that the US government in the 1900's limited the speed of automobiles to under 10 MPH as to support the horse and cart industries. How times change.

Max, I don?t expect you to understand my motivations for this (which are to ensure a sustainable future) as the old saying goes, you can?t teach an old dog new tricks. If you are afraid to innovate then don?t be upset when you fail. Its a catch 22, wont innovate because youre afraid to fail, fail because you were afraid to innovate.

Now Japan has already given the US auto industry a run for their money. JD being a michiganer could explain the kind of damage the Japanese did to the US auto industry and how the government had to bail them out. Australia on the other hand does not have the population or infrastructure to support a large auto industry so our strengths lie in other areas (see below). In Australia as I suspect in Western Europe there are more Mitsubishi?s than fords.

Australia has three key industries, Primary producers (food, we produce tonnes and tonnes of food), mineral (no other nation in the world can match out iron ore output) and high tech. We are becoming a world leader in bioengineering and several engineering disciplines thanks no less to our excellent education systems which (for the most part) support people entering into high level scientific and engineering disciplines. Try getting the US to compete with our resource sector.

Point in short, no point in comparing our strengths with your weaknesses, it isn?t an accurate test.

Now on global warming again, I am making the assumption that you believe that the earth is warming (its cause being irrelevant for the purpose of this exercise), as we have seen from palaeontologic dig sites in places like the Mohave Desert that marine life once existed there. So there is proof that sea levels will rise (unless you believe in creationism but lets ignore this as we already have politics and global warming in this discussion and I don?t feel like going for the trifecta today).

Sea levels rising just a metre will make life in costal cities very difficult but we can take actions against it to safeguard costal cites like Brighton, New York and Sydney. Sea walls and dykes as well as taking measures that water levels in sewers don?t rise are good measures to take. Talk to the Dutch, they have hundreds of years of experience in holding the sea back. Protective measures wont be taken until naysayers stop trying to absolve themselves of blame and start acting.

by dmambo

Around these parts, people justify driving SUV's for the 4-wheel drive or all-wheel drive. Snowy roads 4 months of the year and hilly terrain can make it tough to get to the ski areas on the days the conditions are best!

I do have a hard time understanding why anyone feels they need a Hummer, though. I suppose it's a matter of status in many cases.

by jdclyde

Here I thought we were talking cars, and then the conversation goes right back into the gutter! :0

To address your question, [i]"I do have a hard time understanding why anyone feels they need a Hummer, though. I suppose it's a matter of status in many cases."[/i] [b]if you have to ask the question, you will never understand the answer! :D

by jck

An event for which they can not compensate adequately in their finances that will necessitate them to make that change.

For example: Crude oil going to $200 per barrel and petrol selling for $9 per gallon.

The average price in 2 years has already doubled in some places in the United States. I was paying $1.68 per gallon in fall of 2004. I last paid $2.85 per gallon last week. That's almost a 70 percent increase. And, it was worse after Katrina when gas some places here was $3.33 per gallon.

Most Americans will have to be coerced into it. Changing a lot of the time here is seen as bad, even if it's for the best.

If petrol was $9, you'd see things like Humvees all but disappear and Americans demand better mileage cars.

That's what it would take.

by maxwell edison

There are only two ways for gasoline to reach that price:

1. Market forces.

2. A forced market.

Are you suggesting that one or the other will and/or should happen? If so, which one and why?

by Member 25348569

but if it happens in too precipitous a manner, say with an Islamic revolution in Saudi Arabia, economic meltdown is quite likely with all the problems that that will bring.

If it's done gently then we may all cope and you may get the result that you wish.

by x-marcap

I keep it tuned up, and I get over 25 miles a gallon back and forth from work. I may get 12 city, but the 24-28 highway is always better than my buddy's micro-car that uses fuel at 15MPG at 70mph.

The point is driving rationally, accellerating slowly, etc. helps more than does the type of car, or size. Some people are just idiots. If I drove a Prius I'd get 34 MPG, but spend weeks in the hospital in traction or need a back operation.

by tonythetiger

that if you had to take 6 people somewhere, you'd have to take two of those sardine cans :)

The whole thing is about some people wanting power over other people anyway. If Al Gore was so concerned about our environment, he would give up his own SUVs before asking others to give up theirs.

Maybe these people would be listened to (slightly) more if they weren't so hypocritical. There are at least twice as many liberals as conservatives in the Forbes list.

by nicknielsen

But it's not stock. I'm 6'5" tall. There's actually plenty of leg room, but I had to sit hunched until a buddy of mine with a cutter and a torch knocked an inch out of the rear supports of the driver's seat. Fits great now.

Believe it or don't, there's not enough headroom in a Roadmaster for me. I fit better in Volkswagens or Mercedes. Those Germans understand that people come in different sizes much better than American engineers.

by jdclyde

Chrysler Concorde. Big full size car, shocks the heck out of me that it can pull in the mileage that it does.

I have no idea how it would fit you, being ONLY 5'11", but it does me and my boys nicely.

Why are you not driving a voldswagon if you would fit in it better without having to mod it out? Comfort while driving is a plus to helping you concentrate on the road, ya know?

by x-marcap

Is the only civilian vehicle that you can mount a Browning .50 caliber (Ma Duece or M3 .30) on without it ripping out. It still has the Military hardpoint...

I have guns, can barely afford to shoot them once a month, but can't afford the Hummer...

Too Bad...

by Member 25348569

on launch from Canaveral (that sort of thing [b]does[/b] happen) and jck has to find somewhere else to live for a couple of thousand years.

Any space disposal has to be guarenteed on hundred percent failsafe when getting rid of high-level waste. Once we've got it safely up there we can use a mass driver/rail gun to zip it towards the Sun.

by jck

I live far enough away I would not be in the effective radiated area and I get water from a totally seperate aquifer...I'm over 140 miles from Canaveral and the launch complex.

Plus, the winds usually blow west-to-east here with the gulf circulation...so...the Bahamas would get a lot of crap.

Don't worry, Dad. If that happens, I'll get on a plane to Ireland right away and risk arrest for illegal immigration. :D

by jck

Right now with the instability in the middle east...the basic answer is: Islamic fundamentalist mentality.

With the emergence of ruling Islamic fundamentalists such as Hamas and the leadership in Iran, I see a trend toward propagating an anti-western mentality.

And with this rising Islamic fundamentalism and anti-western sentiment growing in most Islamic countries...what makes you think it's not eventual that it will grow in the middle east, and that it's influence will persuade oil controllers to restrict out supply and cause our prices will not go to $9 per gallon?

What makes you think it's implausible that this growth of Islamic fundamentalism could cause middle eastern nations to restrict oil to the point that $200 per barrel is out of the question?

Who do you think can ride the "white horse" into the middle east and keep something like this from happening?

Two years ago, I thought I'd never see $3 per gallon until later in my life when I was paying $1.60-ish prices.

Surprise...surprise...surprise...

As for market force or forced market...one is cause...the latter is effect.

Everything can be classified as a market force.

So, I'd have to say...Market Force...

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"What makes you (me) think it's implausible that this growth of Islamic fundamentalism could cause middle eastern nations to restrict oil to the point that $200 per barrel is out of the question?"[/i]

First of all, I didn't say that I thought it was implausible. All I did was point out the two ways it could happen, and I asked you which one you thought more likely and why. Based on your answer, should we assume that you believe Islamic fundamentalists will be taking over the entire middle-east in the near future? If so, why do you think that? If not, what's your point?

However, since you asked, I'll answer.

Yes, I do think it's implausible, at least in the short term. A $200 per barrel price would be a three times increase over current prices, and it just won't happen overnight. Any number of the following observations would prevent that scenario:

1. It would hurt other nations more than it would hurt the United States. Japan actually took-on the United States in 1941, in large part, because of oil. Nations wage major war over resources, and if the middle-east nations cut-off what they supply to the world, the United States would not be first in line to wage such a "resource war".

2. The oil goes into a world-wide market, and cutting off supplies to only the United States would involve more than just a few despot middle-east leaders. Even if that were the case, under the worst case scenario, we already could (and/or do) control all the oil in Iraq, and it wouldn't take too much more to control the supply in Saudi Arabia as well. Not that I would believe or hope that would happen, but such a move on the part of any middle-east despots would indeed be tantamount to a declaration of war against the United States, in which case, all bets are off, and any and all options would be on the table.

3. Only about 20 percent of the United States oil comes from the middle-east. Between the reserves in our own country, in Mexico, and in Canada, especially since harvesting the oil in the northern Alberta has been put on a faster track, it wouldn't really take that much to replace that 20 percent between increased production in North America coupled with some reduction in demand due to modest price increases and some realistic conservation efforts.

4. The oil from the middle-east is a two-way street of benefit. They want to sell it as much as others want to buy it. By cutting off the supply, they'd be cutting off their major (or only?) source of revenue.

by maxwell edison

...market forces will dictate change. And guess what? We will adapt just fine. I simply don't fall into the "doom and gloom" trap, regardless of the source of such doom.

Name all of the "doom and gloom" predictions and/or scares perpetrated over the decades and centuries. Then name even one that actually came to be. So far the score is a whole bunch to nil.