Discussion Locked

Is It OUTRAGEOUS or is it just ME?

0 helpful
330 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

330 replies

by eddie n

...and I'm sure if I look hard enough I can find my old Windows for Workgroups 3.11 3.5" floppies. :)

Heck, if I REALLY dig around my attic, I'm sure I can still find and dust off my TRS-80 DOS disks! I rarely throw anything away, because, hey, you never know! :)

by eddie n

Check this out:

"Microsoft will force PC makers to stop selling machines running XP by the end of this year, despite ongoing compatibility problems and demand for XP from users.

Demand for XP is particularly strong among small and medium-sized businesses, according to Dell, which announced it will continue offering some machines with XP pre-installed.

However, the clock is ticking, and Dell and other PC makers will be obliged to stop selling machines running XP by the end of the year, despite ongoing compatibility and performance issues with Windows Vista...."

Read the whole article here:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/pcworld/20070412/tc_pcworld/130657;_ylt=AvlFANdOIXm4q9HcLroSQfdk24cA

by stanj.miranda9

They are forcing them to stop installing XP,because of the very slow sales of Vista.Microsoft has gotten to the point that they want to control eveyone,and thats just not right.I bought a brand newcopy of XP Pro the other day,and installed and activated it,only for it to tell me it found new hardware[keyboard] and had to be reactivated.When i tried to reactivate it.It said i none left.This was a builders CD,and had only been used once,so how is it possible to have no activations left? When i called,they suggested I buy Vista.lol When i told them i already had enough of problems,i was cut off.Thats no way to treat a customer.

by rkuhn040172

Now that this thread is a whole one month old, you've all been proven wrong.

Most retailers and some OEM's have, are, and will be bringing XP back.

So, any apologizes? Apparently, all along you could buy XP and not Vista and apparently those companies (including MS) are being customer friendly.

End of story...ya'll are WRONG!

by pringles86

Well... Maybe they shouldn't have done it in the first place.

They are just now coming to their senses about it.

by breathoffrost002

I got some free versions of linspire, its a nice looking OS with some decent features, and i was able to get it loaded into my system with all the stability you could want

but

none of my games worked, it was pretty much net only, and there are plug ins that you can buy to make it work with most windows compatable objects, but then your shelling out like $150 in cnr

so far vista has been alright, i got it free, its very nice looking, although i did spent a good 12 hours worth of time downloading and installing/reinstalling/reinstalling all the drivers for my MoBo and GFX card, and things still have some issues

i would say to anyone considering vista, if youve got XP, hold off untill SP1 comes out for vista, unless you have a moderate to high technical knowledge and a good ability to scour the net for working drivers

by apotheon

I'm not sure how you could consider the fact that a Linux distribution isn't a Microsoft Windows release cause for a "but". If your only purpose is to run software designed for MS Windows, you should stick with MS Windows. If you want a stable, secure platform that has software of its own, however, you might want to look elsewhere.

Your problem wasn't software support on Linspire. Your problem was looking for MS Windows software support somewhere other than MS Windows.

by rkuhn040172

Throw away all your MS software and MS supported software and go 100% open source.

Oh boy, that'll speed up the masses converting to open source not to mention virtually eliminate the odds of any business doing so.

You live in a dream world...

by deadly ernest

it's available from www.winehq.com this works like a Windows emulator.

Scouring the net for drivers would assume that people are writing drivers for Vista, I'm not sure many are doing that yet.

by so.cal guy

there are plenty of driver for vista

i tried wine and i don't care what any one says you get a perfomace hot explsley with games and wine is an emulator not works like

and emulators suck

by rkuhn040172

If you have XP but are replacing your PC, go the Vista route.

The OEM will be installing hardware/software that has been tested and will work with Vista. So there shouldn't be any problems there unless you are installing older hardware/software on the new PC.

by neon samurai

"
i got it free
"

Free as in paid with it in the cost of a new machine, free as in given too you form work to learn or free as in "uh.. it turned up ;)" purely curiousity though so don't fee like your in a fight.

I'm with you on the last bit definately; Vista will be better after SP1 when full driver and third party software support mature.

by apotheon

I pointed out that if Microsoft refused to sell XP to OEM vendors, the vendors wouldn't be able to resell them. That has nothing to do with whether or not Microsoft decided to sell them copies of XP after all.

by deadly ernest

and agitated for them to put XP back on the shelf, the choice wouldn't be there. DELL and co only make XP available now because they were losing too many sales through people wanting XP not Vista. It's called a consumer strike back. Or buying power.

by w2ktechman

Dell is offering XP because of demand for it. Their website for customer feedback was flooded with alternate OS's besides Vista. Mainly XP and Linux. This is why Dell is now offering both.

If everyone was just happy and bought up machines with Vista, do you honestly believe that XP would suddenly start flowing again?

by vegas21

I thought only manure was a viable commodity when selling S.... to the public. Even then the "Market" usually approaches the seller. Gate's need for money is only surpassed by Bush's NEED for oil. When is enough , enough?? I am speechless

by rkuhn040172

Enough is only enough when the person making it thinks so.

I know that is a difficult concept for some to grasp, but we (here) live in a free, open society with free, open markets where capitalism rules the day.

If Bill Gates decided tomorrow that he's made enough and decided to give Windows away for free, that's his right.

If he decides to milk the public for everything the market will bear for the rest of his life, that's his right too.

You, on the other hand, have the right to not buy his products. So, stop complaining, if you don't like it, vote with your wallet and feet.

by apotheon

"[i]we (here) live in a free, open society with free, open markets where capitalism rules the day.[/i]"

You're drinking the poisoned Kool-Aid again.

by rkuhn040172

Here's your quote:

"Imagine for a moment that Microsoft wants to sell Vista, instead of XP."

From that, you are correct, but then you went on to say:

"this is obviously the case."

And then to top it off, you said:

"Are you entirely unaware of how the software industry actually works"

OK, so you never did actually say MS stopped but like always, you heavily insinuate and suggest which I believe serves only to mislead the reader and you do it on purpose.

Once again, you are wrong and have a hard time admitting it.

MS may have started down the wrong road as far as making XP hard to get a hold of. But a few things.

1) It was always available
2) They corrected their actions based on feedback from customers

That kind of behavior isn't of a mean spirited, greedy corporation. That kind of behavior to me looks like they responded to customer feedback and responded in a pro-customer service kind of way.

by rkuhn040172

Isn't true?

You look around and see barriers to your success.

I look around and see opportunities waiting for me to grap and be more successful.

To you, the cup is always half empty. To me, the cup is always half full.

by deadly ernest

Because MS change their instructional code set with each Windows version most third party software, and some MS software, isn't compatible between versions. So you need to get new copies and shell out more bucks.

In XP most of my older Windows software and games won't run, yet they work perfectly in Linux in either WINE or Cedega.

I have friends at Uni who play NWN and a few other on-line games, the games are written for Windows based systems; yet they all say they see a better game performance on Linux using Cedega than on XP.

I know many small businesses that are converting to Linux as it's cheaper for them to buy Crossover to run their few critical Windows applications in than buying the latest versions because their existing versions aren't compatible with Vista.

So it all comes down to how much you want to pay and how much trouble you want to go through is 5 or 6 years when the next Windows version comes out.

by deadly ernest

I checked the manufacturer's websites, they don't have Vista drivers for my gear, to go to Vista means a new printer, and new scanner, new accounting software, new version of MS Office, and then I also lose a lot of my old files as Office 2007 doesn't open all the older MS Doc formats.

Why should I have to replace perfectly good hardware and software just to use Vista. no thanks, it's too costly.

by hal 9000

But with all M$ products you can continue to drink from the Poisoned Challis at every opportunity that you feel like it. :p

Even if they fix one problem of Contamination that doesn't mean that it can not crop up again or mutate slightly and cause another major pandemic. :0

[i][u]OH DAM IT I forgot to add the sarcasm alert again.Now Rickk is going to have to cry it off all over again.[/i][/u] ;\

Col

by rkuhn040172

You would like most people to believe you don't you?

Yes, some programs were "broken" when XP came about, mostly for security reasons. Just like some programs are "broken" when Vista came out.

The numbers are much smaller than you imply. I can only think of one (1) program I have that I never got to work in XP when it did work in Win 98 and that is a game called "Shadow President".

Needless to say, patches come out to correct issues and yes, occasionally people have to update. Take the whole Quicken issue at hand with Vista (Intuit's fault not MS...btw).

But 9 times out of 10 the software that gets "broken" probably is so old it should be replaced anyways.

by rkuhn040172

1) Please list and be specific your periphals. I'm interested in why NONE of them have Vista drivers.

2) Office 2007 most certainly can open old file formats. There are already converters out for that.

3) Why does upgrading to Vista force you to upgrade to Office 2007?

FUD, more FUD, and damn lies.

by w2ktechman

Hey, have you tried Off03 on Vista???
Then shut the F up!
I have and it errored often, on not 1 but 3 systems. It was not until upgrading to Off07 when they would actually work as supposed to.
So, maybe you should try it before saying anything. Just because MS says it works does not actually mean it does, or havent you learned that yet? If not, Why not???

by apotheon

Your stunning argument is that Office 2007 is compatible with older file formats because of "converters" . . . ?

You've got to be joking. Really. That's just . . .

Man. I don't even know what that is. Pathetic, I guess.

by rkuhn040172

Yes, actually I have.

I got Office 2003 up and running on Vista beta without any problems.

Yes, you're right, I don't use Vista just yet. One, I'm happy with XP at home and two, we haven't tested Vista at work with our ERP software just yet.

by rkuhn040172

Ok, so you're a huge anti-bloat fanboy.

Tell me this. How exactly is any office suite ever going to support previous file formats dating back years and years without adding bloat to the suite?

Periodically, file format changes become a necessity whether you agree with that or not.

With Office 2007, yes there are converters in order to work through a transition period where older versions of Office will coexist.

There are reasons why the world isn't using the same file formats that we used 10 years ago. And there are reasons we won't be using the same file formats 10 years from now.

But, along your line of thinking, all software should either A) never change file formats or B) be bloated to hell and back so that they can support all formats dating back to the beginning of time.

by nicknielsen

[i]Office 2007 most certainly can open old file formats. There are already converters out for that.[/i]

Why would I want my office suite to open old file formats using internal bloat [bcksp][bcksp][bcksp][bcksp][bcksp][bcksp]converters instead of external converters? Gee, I don't know...

[i]How exactly is any office suite ever going to support previous file formats dating back years and years without adding bloat to the suite?[/i]

Don't change the file format between versions. WordPerfect has managed to do that for two decades and is a better, far more flexible app than M$ w0rd will ever be. IMO, and yes, I already know yours is different.

by w2ktechman

Office 03 installs fine, if you open Word and type a few characters, it appears to work fine.
Outlook sets up fine.
USING either program for a little while will crash it or hang it.
all problems solved when migrated to 07.

by apotheon

1. NickNielsen already covered the question of how to avoid bloat for supporting older documents -- don't change the file format every two or three years just to force upgrades. File formats do need to change now and then, but not the way Microsoft changes its formats. Besides that, something as critical as document backward compatibility isn't exactly "bloat".

2. You say "[i]But, along your line of thinking, all software should either A) never change file formats or B) be bloated to hell and back so that they can support all formats dating back to the beginning of time.[/i]" You seem to have missed the fact that there are a number of office suites out there with a tiny fraction the installed size of MS Office that not only support fifteen years or so of legacy file formats, but actually support fifteen years or so of Microsoft Office file formats -- well beyond what MS Office itself supports.

edit: In any case, I just find it astounding that you try to say that MS Office supports older file formats by pointing out the existence of external converters. Como se huh? That's like saying you have a .22 LR rifle that'll take .308 Winchester rounds, as long as you use a separate rifle, or (for a more accurate analogy) mill the bullets down to about a .22 inch diameter and seat them in a .22 LR shell casing yourself.

by deadly ernest

I don't have Vista at home, not prepared to waste the money, but helping someone else try to get their software working on Vista on two machines, upgrading from Windows 2000 and Win 98:

MS Office 2000 - would not install

MYOB - would not run properly, kept locking up.

4 year old colour laser printer no drivers in Vista or from the manufacturer (QMS brand I think from memory).

4 year old HP scanner no Vista drivers and no default drivers that allowed it to work properly.

Special Dvorak keyboard drivers wouldn't install, and the default MS Dvorak conversion software didn't set it up as a Dvorak keyboard either. Need to map each key to get it right.

Games that wouldn't install or run - Ceasar 3, Doom 95, Diablo, Diablo 2, Rise of the Triad, and several other games I can't remember the name of. I know I couldn't get some of these games to run properly in XP on my system either. Load an emulator and they would work, but that shouldn't be needed.

Businesses need to be able to readily access documents from ten to fifteen years ago as that's how long some are required to be available for legal reasons, the majority have a minimum life span of 8 years - current tax year plus 7 years for tax laws.

Office 2003 and 2007 do NOT readily open Word 6 or Word 2a or Excel 4 documents by just clicking on them. Yet Open Office does - seems they're better programmers than the MS ones.

Yes, sometimes you do need to update the format of files, in most cases you just add extra capability and that's stored as extra code at the start or end of the file. But when you have to make a significant change, it's industry standard practice to give the file a different extension thus the changes to .jpg became .jpeg - this is to allow the system to know which is the which format. MS don't believe in doing this and just keep .doc and then arbitrarily stop supporting the older versions without making a public announcement. The companies that have older Word and Excel documents are just 'expected' to know they need to convert them to be able to use the latest versions of Office to read them.

The problem with Quicken is MS's fault as MS has changed the instructional code set required to access key aspects of the OS and transfer commands to the peripherals and internal components.

A well written OS means people can write software that's compatible with the OS and those same commands will work with the next version of the OS - a printer command should always be the same in every version of the OS, but not in Windows or other MS applications.

by w2ktechman

that the very next OS upgrade should not run large amounts of programs from the previous version?
If it is built around the previous version, it should be able to run all of the programs properly.
The difference would mostly be when a new OS is re-written completely, like win9x platform to WinNT platform. Or from 32-bit to 64 bit OS. If the security model changes, they should offer help to SW manufacturers who already pay them to be certified, to make the changes needed before the OS is released.

As for this comment
"Throw away all your MS software and MS supported software and go 100% open source."

Why not? It can be done! It will not be an overnight thing, because most people are not interested in change. But, even if I can help people realize there is an alternative by using Linux instead, others that respect me will listen.
In the last 2 weeks, I have given out 2 Linux cd's to normal Win users (live cd's). 1 person has not tried it yet, the other said they were going to install it and use it on a machine that they were going to scrap. That person tried the live cd and decided it was worth looking into moving to (PCLinuxOS '07 beta).

But then again, people seek me for advice because they know and respect my opinion, something that you obviously know nothing about. Almost all of your posts are crap, and your attitude is shameful for an IT pro (if you actually are).

Just because you are a MS fanboy, probably because you have 2 or 3 stocks in MS, is no reason to mislead people into being fools with bad advice.

by tig2

And recall that not all of us are in the US. As such, hardware may be dramatically different but still need to work, regardless.

While I understand that we are more and more a global society, it is critical to recall that we are different people.

When we signed up to this board, it was with the knowledge that we would be exposed to people of different culture and language. To expect everyone here to be US born and bred is fallacy in the extreme.

I just begin by assuming that everyone who chimes in on a discussion has a truth to tell. For those who have only flames, I am saddened and disappointed. I thought better of you only to have you prove to me that valuing your opinion is a waste of my time.

Not everyone you disagree with is an idiot, Rickk. If you would just can the rhetoric, I believe you would discover as much.

I took the time to try to understand where you were coming from. Perhaps you could learn to extend that courtesy to others.

by neon samurai

Apath dared to mention FOSS so we'd best take that single point to an extreme.

In the case of this comment; your a troll

by tig2

I have had the best luck with Kubuntu but am thinking that PCLinuxOS will be better.

My end user is a 76 year old who is very bright but a total novice. She was "raised" on Windows.

Linux may not be altogether ready for the corporation- although there are those that argue compellingly that RHEL is ready- it is a possible alternative for those home users whose functionality requirements are different.

by neon samurai

But it's a thin layer emulating the hardware only. WINE can be a little laggy though and there are other emulators that really take a performance hit. My WINE based Google Earth runs fine.

Now, I may have recommended Cedega for gaming but WINE should do well also depending on the resource demand of the game.

And just to keep the Windows fanatics ryled up; Longbow2 written for win95 runs flakey on winXP even with 95 or 98 "compatability". I've also got a friend asking me to see if I can get his own win95 game running under XP though I think they will be putting a win98 box together for it.

by tig2

I can purchase brand new parts for a 20+ year old vehicle. But then, so can you.

And I just bought a "Titled as New" 2002 Saturn with warranty. Beautiful car. Has a little pink ribbon on her nose.

by rkuhn040172

But not new.

You can't call Saturn and tell them you want a brand new, factory built 2002 Saturn. Not going to happen.

His point is still valid.

by tig2

However I can buy new 20 year old car parts. I dare say that I may be able to purchase new 10 year old computer parts.

New meaning "never before purchased or used."

I think that the key point is that not every end user wants the newest, biggest, baddest, whatever. They want reliability and they want familiar. They want dependability. And they want to know that they can find support when they need it.

I also think that we techie types think on a different plane than the average end user. We see technology in a different light because we will use it in different ways. We tend to want to explore the length and breadth of new technology to see and understand what we can use it for.

The beauty of a world that includes a variety of different technologies is that we can custom fit solutions that are truly based on customer need.

by tig2

Is DOSBox an option? I have used it successfully to work with older software.

by neon samurai

Janes Longbow 1 was a dos flight sim (technical chopper to be specific) and would probably have a chance with DOS compatability or the option to boot to a dos environment (Is that still there, I used it last with winNT).

Janes Longbow 2 (still not replacable by any other chopper flight sim option that I've found) is pure GUI so I think a Dos box would be of little help since it's looking for the win95 graphic environment.

The othe game I'm going to have a go at getting to run is an old win95 Animaniacs game which is also a graphic environment.

Incase I'm mistaken though, is the DosBox option just a windows dos environment or is this something different that I may not have yet stumbled across?

Your comment to Rikk was well spoken. I suspect he started with the good intentions of pointing out true FUD against Windows when posted but if that was the starting point, he's digressed into the very troll he claims to have been responding too. I thought I simply taking things too personally when he lost credability in my view; I'm glad to know I'm not just being overly sensative.

And now for something completely different... (a man with three buttocks)

Rikk; don't get me wrong, I keep saying you post some great comments and that includes the "what's your network" discussion you started. As you say though "I call it like I see it" to which I still prepose that how "I see it" (er.. you see it) has been skewed by your own bigotry and personal mission to make life misserable for anyone who mentions anything FOSS without end notes, explicit references points and detailed statistical analysis including all calculating formula.

Now I'm still going to take each of your comments indavidually in an effort to not let my opinion of a seporate comment currupt the potential value of a current comment. Hostile comments, however, will be treated with the respect they show and are due as a result. You get what you give and I hope it's a load of great information where you give and verbal "curby" where you detract.

I hope Ubuntu continues to treat you well and I hope one day you get off your high horse and pull the MS pole of rage out of your @ss. You'll find that some of us heretics are actually very intelligent people with much information to offer and a much more open view of software than you give credit for.

by neon samurai

I've heard it's still alive and well in the embedded world also. Embedded Linux, embedded Dos or something developed in house seem to be the norms these days.

As for my own license; Dos boots in under a second on an AMD 1.9 ghz. Now if only I could think of something remotely useful to do with that perfectly tuned command.com since I've yet to rebuild any software on it and can't route the VMware Server com port to a telnet deamon.

by rkuhn040172

Thanks for the politically correct BS speech.

Who expects us all to be from the US? Not me.

And who said I believe anyone that disagrees with me is an idiot? Thanks for speaking for me and putting words in my mouth.

It's not just me spreading rhetoric. I will never extend courtesy to anyone who relentlessly attacks MS for no purpose other than for sport.

Lastly, the amount of mindless lemming like behavior on TR is mind numbing. Open source has become (for some) a cause and NOT a technical debate.

It's to those that I primarily target my comments to.

by rkuhn040172

Other than to be misleading then, why did you say ""Titled as New" 2002 Saturn"?

You were either intentionally misleading or your analogy is false.

BTW, there are still plenty of "brand new parts" out there for free for older versions of Windows. So, once again your analogy is false.

by tig2

Brian said that you couldn't buy new old parts. I say that you can. Either way, flawed analogy or not, the fact is that you CAN indeed purchase new parts that are old.

Your point to software is equally valid. There is a lot of older technology available, much of it free, for those who would prefer it. As I said above, the beauty of a world that includes a variety of technologies is that we can custom fit solutions that are truly based on customer need.

by apotheon

It's obvious rickk is just "playing stupid" because he wants anyone that disagrees with his opinions to be Wrong -- thus, he refuses to get your point.

by nicknielsen

[i]It's not just me spreading rhetoric. I will never extend courtesy to anyone who relentlessly attacks MS for no purpose other than for sport.[/i]

The problem (and apparently you don't see it) is that you attack the poster of [i]any[/i] negative comments about Microsoft products, accusing them of being FOSS propagandists and open source stooges, regardless of the veracity of their comments.

It's almost as if you believe opinions different from yours affect your manhood. It ain't personal, dude, but you sure seem to be making it that way.

by w2ktechman

was never registered to anyone except the dealer, and it was in all purposes in the new condition. whether or not it was the newest model created is beside the point.

by deadly ernest

In Windows XP I can't use the driver that comes with my modem as it isn't digitally signed by MS. I loaded it and it worked, but the next time I rebooted the system Windows declared the driver to be faulty and replaced it with a generic one from their library that didn't work. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the driver I installed except it wasn't approved by MS and didn't have their digital signature, it was different as it was for the Australian phone network not the USA one.

To get over this problem I had to get a new driver from Hayes and turn off some settings to get it to work with the Australian network.

When WGA kept crashing my machine because I didn't have ALL the updates and was over 4 weeks since I last did an update (did it on four different systems four times) I switched three systems to Linux (selling the legal copies of XP Pro I'd bought from MS Australia) and kept one machine with XP without SP2, so no WGA.

Edited to add: I have a slow rural dial up service and auto updates chews up the whole bandwidth so I only selected updates that I felt I had to have.

I buy software and it works I don't expect the supplier to give me an update that crashes the system - when they gloat about it, then they can expect to lose a customer and that's what MS did.

At that point I'd already sold on my copy of Office 2003 as it wouldn't open my old Word 6 and Word 2a files or my Excel 4 files - all retained for legal reasons.

Despite what MS say, it is legal here to sell software on as long as you delete it from your system before doing so and hand over the licence number with the discs.

Another good thing about Linux over MS, I can install a new program or driver WITHOUT having to reboot the whole system.

by maxwell edison

(Note: This is a reply not only to the original message, but to many of the replies that have been posted.)

I just don't get it. For the past twenty years (longer, actually), hardware and software manufacturers have been leap-frogging each other in a dual effort keep up with the others' new and improved capabilities and to make their own product better. Anyone who doesn't understand this is naive'. If many people had their way, or so it seems, we'd still be computing with an 8086 processor with 64 KB of RAM running DOS version 4.0. Moreover, look at the all the industries and companies (including CNet and TechRepublic) that have thrived as a result, offering support, information, training, and such. How many millions of people earn their livelihoods on, what many of you call, "milking" the market? How many peoples' 401(k) plans have grown because they, themselves, invest in the industry?

I heard the same things twenty years ago that I hear now. When is Bill Gates gonna' be rich enough and when will hardware and software manufacturers stop milking the market? (Get off the Bill Gates demonization, will you?) Well I have a news alert for you, folks. They have not been "milking" the market, but extending it and expanding it to create the greatest era of economic growth and technological advances in the history of the world. Such things have given all you people jobs and security, but you gripe about it. Such things have changed the way we live, but you complain. The opportunities created as a result of them "milking" the market are unlimited. But you want it to stop.

I wonder what some of you people think with. Some of you people wouldn't recognize a great thing if it jumped up and bit you in the ........ nose.

by deadly ernest

ignored the customer needs and gone their own way, like Ford did with the Edsel (I think that's the model I wish to refer to) It was basically a reasonable car but not what the clients were looking for. Well Vista is the Windows version of the Edsel, it's basically OK except its still has the faults of the earlier models uncorrected and is NOT what people are looking for, they've gone off in the wrong direction. However, unlike Ford, MS intend to push us all in that direction too.

by rkuhn040172

Give me one version of MS's OS's that people didn't say the same damn thing each and every time?

This gets old!

Every time is the same old, worn out arguments.

It requires too much hardware
There aren't any drivers available
It's too bloated
It's full of fluff
There's another form of anti-piracy
It makes absolute older file formats
blah, blah, blah

It's a broken record!

Here's a better analogy for you Deadly Ernest:

All companies make mistakes. All companies have some good products and some bad products. Things are very cyclical. But, just like Ford has been around for over 100 years, so will Microsoft so don't hold your breath for their eventual demise.

Whether or not the new Vista will become the next Edsel or the next Model T, only history can tell...see you then.

by maxwell edison

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11179-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=89748&messageID=542987

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6247-0.html?forumID=12&threadID=54086&messageID=328325

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6286-0.html?forumID=11&threadID=40706&messageID=250068

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html?forumID=3&threadID=65514&messageID=401843

Want more? I could post hundreds of complaints about XP when it was first released. Substitute Vista for XP, and there ya' go. Search the old messages for yourself. Same song, different verse. (But this time is different, right? Yea, just like then was different.)

by rkuhn040172

The negativity and complaining on here is ridiculous.

It is absolutely astonishing how many people harbor ill will towards certain things.

The mantra seems to sound something like this:

"bluesuits (unless you wear one) suck, accountants (unless you are one) suck, bosses (unless you are one) suck, success (unless it's you) sucks, making money (unless it's you) sucks, expensive products (unless you made it) suck, big companies (unless it's yours) suck, America (unless you're an immigrant dying to get here) sucks, George Bush (no wait, that was Monica and Bill, never mind) sucks...

Get over it people.

Is the IT industry really that distraught? Is there still a lingering IT hangover from the late 90's?

I, for one, love my career, enjoy working for my company and co-workers, and look forward to the exciting changes that the future of IT holds.

I'm glad I don't have a x186 anymore even if my OS is "bloated", I'm really stoked about being able to own multiple PC's at home instead of having to sell my car to afford one, it's pretty damn cool that I have a 3 PC's, 3 servers, a Palm, a Playstation, and a PVR all networked together at home.

I actually, in a strange way, look forward to the next round of security issues as it pushes me to learn more and dive deeper into the inner workings of my PC's and network.

I'm glad to see newer programming languages and IDE's so that less technically savvy folks can be a part of the action.

Contrary to popular belief, I'm glad to see Linux pushing MS and others harder so that we all get the best products available that more competition creates.

I fully understand the diverse nature of people's backgrounds on TR. However, I will never understand the incessant complaining almost to the extent that you wonder if some people actually enjoy doing what they are doing or are just doing it out of fear of leaving the industry.

by hal 9000

Today when you go to work for your house building company walk up to your Boss and Demand that he immediately drop all existing M$ product and switch to Vista.

You openly admit that while you use it at home you don't as yet use it at work so now the perfect time for you to [b]Bite That Silver Bullet[/b] and migrate everything to Vista now before any full in depth testing has been done. If you're such a great believer in this product insist that you switch everything at your work to Vista now immediately and dump all existing M$ product as the Obsolete Rubbish that it is in your opinion. I'll be interested to see just how long that building company remains afloat if they where to move immediately.

You've been so forthright in your demands that everyone follow you so start to lead by Example :D

Col

by apotheon

Some of us prefer to build things, rather than just continuously fixing things that shouldn't have broken in the first place. I, for one, am more interested in producing than holding up a house of cards.

That's why I actually don't make any money these days supporting broken MS software. Oh, sure, I'll take money fixing it if someone really really wants to pay me enough to offset the annoyance factor, but I haven't had to do that for quite a while because there's plenty of work to be had doing something in the IT industry a bit less soul-sucking.

by maxwell edison

.....that I've never found myself [i]"holding up a house of cards?"[/i]

I've never had any of the ongoing problems that so many people seem to gripe about. Sure, it's presented a challenge getting new and improved products into our technology infrastructure, but once I get things working in concert (and it's never been an effort in futility or frustration), things have hummed along just fine. And I've been doing it for twenty years.

The way I see it, if people find themselves [i]"holding up a house of cards"[/i], perhaps they have a faulty foundation to begin with. Perhaps they need to design their systems a little better. Perhaps they're overlooking some structural or mechanical consideration. I design my technology infrastructure like an architect or engineer will design a building -- everything ties into everything else. Perhaps people who don't will be fighting that falling house of cards. You might think that I should be [i]"smarter than that"[/i] (whatever that means), but I assure you, I'm smart enough to keep my own house standing strong, thank you very much.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=213341&messageID=2229637

by tig2

And the ability to do so is not unusual.

I just happened to luck into a very sweet deal on my new Saturn. She is a beautiful little car that is no longer produced- 2002 was the last model year for my Saturn.

I think that I am going to have to send Palmetto a new hard hat. It seems that any response to Rickk is the equivalent of feeding a troll.

Can we take away his birthday or something?

by rkuhn040172

Apparently, you have a reading comprehension problem or you interpret only what you want to hear.

He said, "when was the last time you could order/buy a new year 2000 vehicle or a 5year old TV".

No where in that did he mention anything about parts. He said a vehicle or a TV. Nothing about parts.

Yet, you continue to pound away just to prove a point that doesn't exist.

Once again, as the crowd roars in hating me, I'm only pointing out the obvious and the truth.

Go ahead, spin this anyway you want, but you're still wrong. I imagine you'll go back to calling me names or accusing me or this, that or the other, but again, he didn't mention anything about parts.

by rkuhn040172

No, the analogy is wrong because it is based on a false premise.

No where were "parts" mentioned.

Re-read the post.

But once again, you and your "friends" are taking the journalistic liberty to spin something to suit your needs instead of working with the facts.

by rkuhn040172

Oh Dear Lord!

We're sinking to all new levels.

Never registered, blah blah blah.

You sound like Bill Clinton and "it depends what is is".

Ok, so imagine this. HP overstocks a product with Windows 98 on it. They find it in a warehouse 10 years later and you can still buy it.

Yeah! Just about as ridiculous as your interpretation of her statement in an apparent attempt to bail your friend even when she's wrong.

by tig2

Was a commodity.

Please stop this. You have good points but the ranting does you no credit nor does it allow anyone to see your side.

by tig2

You can beat me up all you wish to. There aren't many people here who fail to recognise you as the troll you are.

You are attacking people for no purpose and bringing nothing to the table. You attack anyone and everyone who tries to bring a level of reason to any technology discussion.

Listen up, sonny. You are in no way, shape, or form a "technology professional". You are an ass and you obviously wish to continue to be one.

You go on poking people. I hope you do the same sh*t in real life as it would give me the comfort of knowing that someone will eventually clean your clock.

You are an embarrassment to the profession.

by w2ktechman

you are either really stupid, or just like to hear your keyboard clicking. You seem to think that you are convincing people of something, but instead you are looking more the a$$ than anything else. You have deluded your brain into thinking that you are important or something. That crack pipe has really tweaked you boy!
Ok, lets look at what I wrote, c'mon scroll up a bit. Ok, I commented merely on how I interpreted Tiggers comment. I did not include anything else. So I sunk to low levels, how exactly? Only in your warped mind young'un.

I will say however that the HP and 98 thing is in the same arena, although SW changes faster than autos.

by w2ktechman

And I would doubt that anyone gives him credibility at all. So for being beaten up, I think not. See it takes reason to win, and, well, Rickk has none. I think that he just likes to instigate crap honestly, thats why I do not usually reply to his posts, nor read them. But even I get bored sometimes and want to see what humorous items that Rickk posts. After all, circus clowns need attention too! Besides, it gives me a good chuckle to know that Palmetto, well, nuff said.

by rkuhn040172

But you know what, we're preaching to the choir.

These people don't want to change, they don't want to admit they're wrong, and they don't want to let go of the past.

by maxwell edison

Outside of Bill Gates and Paul Allen, how much wealth has Microsoft created for Microsoft employees? How much wealth has Microsoft created for investors? How many independent companies have been created because of Microsoft? How many people outside of Microsoft are (have been) employed as a result of that company's success? How influential has Microsoft been to the United States' economy over the past twenty years? How much has Microsoft directly contributed to the economy of the United States? How much has Microsoft indirectly contributed to the economy of the United States? How much tax revenue has been generated by all the aforementioned sources?

The wealth of Bill Gates is minuscule compared to the impact Microsoft has had on the American economy -- indeed, the world economy. And people demonize the guy who's systematically giving all his wealth away. I just don't get it. Anyone who suggests that Bill Gates "does it for the money" intimately knows the inside of his own anatomy.

by deadly ernest

Check ALL the past posts by those you're bagging. Many of us have supported MS for years but finally got fed up when they went too far. After 20 years of being a MS user I tossed them because I was fed up with WGA crashing my system and all the old Word and Excel files I needed for legal reasons wouldn't open in Office 2003. So I switch to software that functioned PROPERLY, as well as looked pretty.

by rkuhn040172

Sorry your experience has been so bad.

But others of us have had quite the opposite experience.

I support over 14 servers and 100+ PC's. I have had one WGA issue in the last 2+ years.

Hardly anything worth dumping MS over.

BTW, I called MS on the phone to resolve my WGA issue. The rep was very nice and the issue got resolved in less than 5 minutes.

by deadly ernest

Rickk,

The difference with Ford and MS is that Ford didn't try to push the consumers into the Edsel by withdrawing all other models; MS did; and continue to do so in less obvious manners. Ford accepted they did a lemon and fixed it with a new model that WAS better. MS try to hide the lemon under a new paint job and a few extra bells and whistles - the engine still sucks.

Windows 3.11 got rave reviews by everyone who saw it, so did NT at first.

TT,

Trolls don't have birthdays, they're created by super compressing garbage until it's super dense. You're at a serious disadvantage in this argument, he's dragging you down to his level of idocy so he can beat you due to his higher experience.

BTW In the mid 1970s I worked for a company that finally got around to clearing out its old warehouse. In the back of the building we found over 3,000 spares parts that were brand new, still in their original wrappings for cars from 1925 through to 1936 - brand new parts for old cars. Must have been some sort of record at the time. Most of the cars they fitted were no longer on the road anywhere. Near as we can figure they must locked the back rooms up prior to WW2 and later forgot about them when other things were stacked in front of the doors.

General
My biggest concern with Windows for years has been their refusal to clean up the kernel and close the back doors that are utilised by the trojan and virus programs. despite that, I still supported them until about a year ago when they forced WGA down our throats and started screwing over machines on a regular basis because it's faulty and they won't fix it properly.

About seven years ago they put forward a concept for their future of computing which got heavily bagged as being to draconian, now they're introducing it bit by bit. They want to set up the Internet so every message you send is checked through their clearing house to ensure all your software is registered and they get a slice from everyone's pie. Look up the past discussions on Secure Computing and Palladium.

by hal 9000

About 25 years ago now one army base was closed down and as they where clearing it out they found 300 Pre WW11 BSA M20 Motorcycles still in their original packing crates unassembled and still wrapped in Grease Proof paper.

These Pre WW11 Motor Cycles when registered had to be registered as New as they had never previously been registered and to make matters worse because of the age of them they where considered as Classic Motor Cycles and attracted a greater Tax component than what a new off the floor modern Motor Cycle would ever attract. I bought 5 of these when they came up for auction and when I moved north I had to sell them off 2 where out of their crates assembled and running as show Bikes while the other 3 where still unpacked and remained unassembled.

From a Legal Prospective these 1930 something Motor Cycles when first registered where considered as [b]NEW[/b] and there is no other way to consider them. Of the 3 that I sold unassembled and still in their original crates they where sold as [b]New[/b] and no one would accept that they where anything but that New Old Stock that had never been pulled out of their packing crates.

The ex army M20's looked great beside my much older restored M21 and sidecar. Now I stick to fast fun to ride Motor Cycles and while I would willing buy a 1950 something Vincent HRD Black Shadow if I could ever find one it's the only current Pre Classic that I would now be interested in looking at.

Col

by hal 9000

Are right for now. Initially when XP was released we had an option of weather or not we used it and for 18 months or so M$ continued to sell Windows 98 SE and 2000 beside XP and for those 18 months Windows 98 SE always outsold XP at the very least as stated here by M$ at a Partners Roadshow which the data covering the entire world.

The problem with Vista is that people are being forced to use it weather or not they want to as M$ was claiming way back in 2003 that they had learnt their lesson and would never again offer 2 distinct OS for sale beside each other again. It didn't matter that it cost more for 98 SE than XP Pro cost as OEM product the customers where wanting 98SE and able to buy it.

A few took up XP from the very start and they lived on the bleeding edge and covered the problems that where found with the system as originally XP Pro was sold claiming that you didn't need Servers with it you should remember that claim by M$ Marketing.

The majority of Business customers didn't move to XP till SP1 had been released and most of the bugs ironed out and then it was usable in a business environment but prior to that it was far to costly to attempt to place into that type of environment and have the business remain solvent.

Personally I don't give a Rats one way or the other but as I'm not planning on supporting Vista for a very long time and I'll be buying XP for all the time till people decide if Vista is worth the effort to move to or if they are unhappy with M$ offering I'll be looking for something different to suit their needs. It all depends on what Vista actually does and how it performs. I don't give a rats about extra hardware as it's already here and is really basic stuff compared to what you can place into one new computer so that Isn't an issue to me and nor is the fact that it is much bigger after all there is no problem with limited storage these days and really a few TB's are no problem to get now as well as RAM measured in the several GIG catagory the stuff is just easy to get and cheap compared to the hardware that we where buying even 5 years ago. So I don't care one way or the other only if it actually works or not and that is the current problem and because Vista as yet hasn't been out long enough it's a question that none of us can answer with any certainty.

When there are the available Hardware Drivers and software available I will start to load up a couple of new computers with the Volume License Copy that I bought in November 06 but till them I'm sitting back waiting to see what if anything happens. Earlier this month when I last looked some Hardware Makers where still offering Beta Drivers for their M'Boards so really we are not quite yet ready for a mass deployment of Vista which seems to have been rushed to market and the problems will be fixed while in the field. This is OK for gaming systems but in business this just isn't acceptable and even M$ accept this as they have not even tried to remove XP from the Volume License Range of available product.

Col

by rkuhn040172

Stop the story about XP Pro and not needing any servers.

A) That has never been an official MS position, maybe just a stupid rep.

B) We are tired of hearing it. You repeat the same old tired stories, over and over as if the more you tell them the more likely people will accept it as a fact.

Other than that, your assessment was fair. No one is encouraging anyone to live on the bleeding edge.

Upgrading to a new OS is a risk/reward decision that everyone has a different tolerance for.

After any new OS comes out, including new Linux distros, few big companies take the plunge immediately. It's common sense not too. There is planning, testing, budgets, manpower, etc to consider.

So, given the number of factors involved for a business to make the switch, quit acting surprised that people aren't tripping over one another to make the switch.

This is quite normal and not an aberration. We need a little spin control here.

by hal 9000

I'm off to the hospital for immediate Heart Surgery as I don't think that I can stand the stress of someone finally seeing the light of reality.

If you where not supporting XP from the very beginning like I was you can not be sure of what the Marketing M$ People where incorrectly telling the customers in an attempt to move product. The No Server thing is not an isolated item but a common occurrence Luckily for me or unluckily for me I did support XP from Day 1 and I did get a phone call from M$ Technical Support asking me to look at a new setup and that caused me nothing but pain and suffering so is there any wonder that I'm unwilling to jump on the band waggon again and push something that I don't know just how big the holes in it actually are?

Or worse still if it's actually going to work as M$ say it will and not be full of [b]Undocumented Features[/b] like so many of the previous versions of Windows are?

But on a more realistic note when it comes to M$ Licensing why is it more expensive for 2 X 5 pack CAL'S than it is for 1 OEM Copy of 2003 SBS? After all the 9 CD in SBS allow 5 CAL by default so why are 10 extra more than the cost of the entire OS which is a lot more than a few CAL'S/Terminal Services.

Col

by maxwell edison

Just to be clear, I NEVER upgrade simply for the sake of upgrading. This is especially true with operating systems. For example, I never even upgraded to XP, not at work and not at home. W2K was just fine, it ran all our applications quite well, and there was no compelling reason to upgrade. And it's usually the applications (as opposed to the OS) that's the driving force behind our upgrades, whether that be software, or hardware, or both. Our upgrade to Windows Vista is no exception.

The reality of our industry is that we, as users of technology, (and this applies to ANY industry) continually place more and more demands on our applications. In my case, we're relying more and more on specific engineering applications, graphics applications, and we're on the threshold of implementing some building information modeling applications that integrate both graphics and engineering data. We're demanding more and more functionality from our applications, and more and more computing power from our hardware. It's unrealistic to believe that any operating system or hardware designed during one generation of applications will be sufficient to drive the hardware and application demands of all future generations.

These things (hardware, applications, and operating systems) are continually growing side-by-side, they're being influenced by each other, and they're being driven by each other; and as a result, they are constantly leap-frogging over each other to keep the momentum going forward towards faster and more demanding computing power. Our applications of today will simply not function with the limited computing power of yesterday's hardware and operating systems. And the hardware and operating systems of today (including XP), will not provide a sufficient and powerful enough base on which to run our application demands of tomorrow. And for us, to remain competitive in our industry, we better be implementing tomorrow's applications today.

Windows Vista will allow us to do that. A new generation of processors will allow us to do that. Moving forward, remaining on the leading edge (but not the bleeding edge) will allow us to do that. Just as companies turn-over their fleet of leased cars on a regular basis, they also do with their hardware and software demands. And anyone worth his salt in what he's being paid will not continually cry and gripe about "yet another operating system", but use it -- and embrace it -- as the basis for how we will use our computing power to produce the goods and services that keep our economies growing and moving forward.

But you go right ahead, Colin, and tell me all you want about how I don't know what I'm talking about; tell me that I'm not looking at one thing or the other; tell me whatever you want. I don't care. But my company, in my industry, producing our product, can do anything that any of our competitors can do, and we can do more than many of them are able to do. Why? Because we embrace tomorrow's applications today, and we try to stay a step ahead of our competitors. And our growing client base recognizes that. We can give them what they ask for, not because we gripe and complain about advances in technology, but rather because we embrace it.

And that's the way it is.

by hal 9000

But not a blind rush to deploy something because it's new as the only reason to deploy something now.

Software may very well make it necessary to change an existing OS and much more likely it will be a lack of processing power on the older hardware that fails to meet the new demands for customers needs. But other than Intuits updated Software to work with Vista I've not personally seen any new software that requires Vista to work properly and powerfully enough when there is existing hardware available to drive this software.

But much more importantly why is all the CAM stuff that I'm currently working with relying on DOS to drive the machines that make the items? Granted these are only medium sized things like Lathes around the 20 foot bed length and 3 foot swing depth. But all the newly fitted CAM machinery fitted to that plant about 5 years ago is still working on DOS and will be there for a very long time to come yet as it takes them about a year to replace equipment on the production floor and be up and running again.

Even a small Stone Bench top maker that I'm supporting CAM Machines only run on 98 at a pinch but DOS quite easily and currently the machines have as yet to be delivered as I'm still working with the Architects to get the floor plans right so that the equipment can be rolled in and set where it's needed then forgotten about once in place and the fitters can just connect things up after these big heavy machines have been dropped in place. The Computer Connections are the easy part but getting all the dust excluder's to work without leaks isn't quite so easy.

So there are 2 CAM plants one making Electricity Generating Equipment and one Custom Bench Tops for Kitchens and both are still using what is effectively DOS to make the product and will be for many years to come and both with relatively new equipment on the production floor.

But Maxwell if you are moving to Vista soon lets know how you get on plugging the holes and what problems that you encounter.

Col

by deadly ernest

aim high or low when the greenies race out to recover YOUR ducks?

I'd bet you're one to cover all bases and fire one barrel high and the other low.

Or do you put out decoy ducks that explode on being picked up?

by rkuhn040172

Pretty funny how everyone has to come up with the most extreme examples to support TT's point of view but no one can come up with a normal, everyday example.

by deadly ernest

every time I rang up. In the end I went through the Australian sales people to talk to a tech here in Australia. After getting some actual service from a tech who understood the porblem and not some semi-trained person following a screen prompt, I got the full story.

Seems there is a fault in the WGA code - it automatically assumes your copy is a pirate if you get too far out of date as they assume everyone with a valid copy will keep all updates up to date. If, like me, you're on a slow rural dial up service and don't want to spend all the time running updates, you turn auto updates off (seems MS see this as a standard practice of pirates, so you're immediately suspect), you pick and choose which updates you want (another assumed pirate practice), and not having all the previous updates (another assumed pirate practice), that's three negative points. Let the time between update go more than a month, and that's the critical four negative points - bingo you MUST be a pirate and close down your system.

Most annoying and they refused to do anything about fixing the problem apart from making me call and ask for a new registration number. Another hour or so wasted in convincing them it's a valid copy (I bought it from MS Australia direct). the fourth time this caused me to lose work because I couldn't do what i wanted due to WGA closing my system down at a critical time, and it was "I'm out of here, I can't afford the losses."

by rkuhn040172

Never have I proposed anyone dropping XP immediately and taking on Vista.

As a matter of fact, I just finished writing another post explaining (the obvious) about considerations to make before rolling out Vista, ie budgets, manpower, testing, hardware, drivers, etc.

Bottom line is that's our job. I approach it with enthusiasm and you dread it.

And, once again, you use an extreme example and unrealistic conditions to prove your point when in reality you are just trying to stroke yourself at my expense.

by hal 9000

Never put off till tomorrow what you can do today so since you are so looking forward why wait?

[i]Bottom line is that's our job. I approach it with enthusiasm and you dread it.[/i]

Not quite right as you are making assumptions again that are unfounded if you actually could read you would have seen above that I mentioned that I had the RTM Product since November 06 that means that I went out and with my money brought a Volume License. Which is a hell of a lot more than you have ever attempted to say isn't it?

And I am dreading it if it was fostered on me right now but if Vista works in another 12 to 18 months I will be willing to roll it out company wide but first I want to know what holes there are in it and that is part of the reason why I'm not rushing out to deploy ASAP.

But as you continue to sing the praises of Vista I can not see why you would want to wait for one second longer than you absolutely need to.

Col

by hal 9000

Things like that are what dreams are made of and they still do exist in some small numbers in very limited numbers today finding them is the hard part and as I don't owe anyone anything I have money to spend on what I want to instead of living from day to day worrying if I'll have enough food to feed the children this week or if the bank will walk in and repossess the house. This is what I see all the time with friends and members of my family and today that is something to worry about.

On the other hand I'm willing to go out and blow a cool .5 Million on a wreck of a car if it's something that I want and then a few million more to restore. But Honestly I draw the line at buying a new Cylinder Head and start to build a classic Mercedes from that. But for only 6K for a 1950 Gull Wing Mercedes it was tempting at the time but not even I could justify starting a new build with just a cylinder head even if it was new.

Col

by rkuhn040172

Sorry for your bad luck although I question it's accuracy.

I have deliberately setup a PC with XP Pro, no service packs and no updates (testing machine). Been running it for quite a while now.

No problems with WGA here.

by rkuhn040172

1) I can agree with you more if what you say is more reasonable

2) I did support XP from the get go

3) Licensing - easy question. The value of that product lie not in the server itself as much as the number of people that can use its functionality.

A standalone server, not connected to anything is worthless. However, allowing people to connect to it to get files, receive email, DHCP, DNS, RDC, Terminal Services, etc is the valuable part.

I'm surprised that MS hasn't lowered the OS licensing and raised the CAL's to be honest.

by deadly ernest

load without installing WGA. You can sit there working the machine OK with just SP1 and any updates PRIOR to SP2, but once you try for SP2 or any update after that, or any update after that date for any other MS applications, it won't give it to you without you first get WGA. And you can't turn it off and still get updates.

So the choices are either use Windows with lots of 'essential and critical' updates not loaded (placing the system at risk) or going with WGA and spend all my Internet time watching it talk to MS about updates or drop Windows.

I dropped Windows as it was the most effective option of the three.

As I said - the problem isn't XP per se, but WGA. And the WGA in Vista is worse.

by apotheon

What -- that thing about the parts in their original packaging found in some storerooms? I took that as an amusing anecdote related by someone who has other things to do than spend all his time refuting your absurdities. I certainly didn't imagine it was part of this Vast Linux-Wing Conspiracy To Disagree With The All-Powerful Rickk you keep talking about.

(edit: This is in response to rickk, by the way.)

by apotheon

It's interesting how first you're talking about how Microsoft provides "us" with a lucrative livelihood maintaining it, and later you're talking about how stable everything is.

"[i]The way I see it, if people find themselves "holding up a house of cards", perhaps they have a faulty foundation to begin with.[/i]"
Yeah -- poor software choices.

by maxwell edison

Where exactly did I say (or imply) that the growth in the industry was a result of simply "maintaining" Microsoft products?

Are you a Democrat? Taking what I say and stretching it to the absurd so you can simply support your point (whatever it is)?

Providing "maintence" for a product and growing with it are as different as night and day. (I would say as different as a Democrat and Republican, but it's getting harder to see the real distinction between many of them.)

By the way, I'm writing this message from my Vista computer - networked, configured, and everything working just fine.

by apotheon

"[i]Where exactly did I say (or imply) that the growth in the industry was a result of simply "maintaining" Microsoft products?[/i]"

It's ironic you should talk call this kettle black, maxwell, considering that's not what I said or even implied. You're the one that specified that it must be [i]only[/i] about maintaining it by introducing the word "simply", not me. All I said is that you talked about Microsoft providing us with a lucrative livelihood maintaining the operating environment provided by the Microsoft platform.

Consider this statement of yours:

"[i]Moreover, look at the all the industries and companies (including CNet and TechRepublic) that have thrived as a result, offering support, information, training, and such. How many millions of people earn their livelihoods on, what many of you call, "milking" the market?[/i]"

Your implication there -- or, at the minimum, the logical inference -- is that maintenance is a (or perhaps [i]the[/i]) significant livelihood. What many of us call "milking" the market, what involves providing third-party support and information, and what consists in part of training as a way of making money is maintenance. Regardless of your intended implication anyway, maintenance is really all there is to provide for software from Microsoft, unless you work for Microsoft itself, because of its closed nature. It's damned near impossible to build a livelihood off nothing but piecing together "solutions" out of MS "products" like building spaceships out of Lego blocks -- most, if not all, lucrative businesses that provide that service make the majority of their money off maintenance (and I know, having been in that business myself for several years).

So . . . perhaps you didn't mean to say that Microsoft provides us with a lucrative livelihood in maintenance, but that's what your statements in context imply, and if you failed to mean that you simply failed to recognize the implications of your own words as applied to the real world. If you have some kind of common counterexample in mind, please illuminate me.

Hell, even the vast majority of MS Windows system security is nothing but maintenance.

"[i]Are you a Democrat?[/i]"

Nope. In fact, I'm thinking about registering Republican and voting for Ron Paul in the state primary.

"[i]I would say as different as a Democrat and Republican, but it's getting harder to see the real distinction between many of them.[/i]"

It's always nice to find common ground. I certainly don't disagree with that.

"[i]By the way, I'm writing this message from my Vista computer - networked, configured, and everything working just fine.[/i]"

I'm sure there are thousands of people who haven't had any problems at all with Vista yet -- or, at minimum, haven't had any problems they didn't expect simply as a part of doing business with computers (whether that's a valid excuse for a particularl problem or not in any given instance). I, at least, have never meant to imply that Vista never works right.

(edit: italics typo)

by maxwell edison

.....my "application" driven perspective.

Quite frankly, I was content with DOS 6.0, at least as it relates to an operating system. But my APPLICATIONS became more demanding. My APPLICATIONS became more complex. As such, both hardware and operating systems had to evolve to keep up with the demands the users (my users) were placing on the APPLICATIONS. And then it happened again ..... and again ..... and again .....

Why don't you tap into your vast Anti-Microsoft knowledge base and enlighten me as to which operating system will better support MY application (any Autodesk product) than Microsoft.

A big difference between other "IT Professionals" and me is that I don't consider technology (or an operating system) the ends in itself, but rather the means to an end. I need to maintain an environment that can best support the design of smart buildings -- Building Information Modeling. You tell me, what operating system can best support MY applications?

And quite frankly, I've come to see the "Linux-Type Gurus" (the ONLY Microsoft alternative) in a similar light as I see the liberal elitist snobs who think they're more "enlightened" than the rest of the population. Well, you can take your elitist attitude and shove it!

(And if you thought I was [i]"smarter than that"[/i], well, too friggin' bad -- up yours, you snob.)

by w2ktechman

Although I dont agree with you too often, you seem knowledgeable. But this last post was a cry of desparation, something I would have more expected from, say, Rickk!
c;mon, if you are choosing your OS around 1 app, or 1 company's apps, then there may be other problems! I often have to compare and re-compare apps as time goes on to determine which to buy. I am currently looking at document comparison SW. over the last 5 years we went from Delta View, to Diff-Doc, and now I was asked to look into alternatives because Diff-Doc got too expensive.
If you are only looking at "Autodesk" products, and they only write for MS, then you are stuck. But with a little research, you may find an alternative package that is just as good but made by someone else, that can allow more flexibility.
And I do not believe that technology has an end at all. It is like the energizer bunny, it just keeps going, and going, and going....

Yes, I can agree that some Linux guru's have that attitude, but the majority that I have met do not. They have many different reasons for moving to Linux, from desire to learn to just having free SW. Listening to just a few does not make the whole.
If everyone judged Vista from Rickk, MS would have had no sales by now... But I judge Vista for what it is and what it lacks.

P.S. This was posted from SUSE 10.2 Big friggin deal...

by deadly ernest

the fact you can still get things that are still 'brand new' despite having left the factory many years ago. Until they're sold retail or used they're 'brand new' and will continue to stay that way.

It's part of a sub-thread discussion that's well off the track by now.

by hal 9000

You need SP 2 installed as unless you have that installed you don't have WGA and will have absolutely no problems with WGA related issues.

Col