Discussion Locked

Is playing in the registry bad?

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A lot of people have a thing against messing around in the registry. Now granted, if it's your company's main file and print server, or proxy, or web server, you should be a little hesitant. But I happen to enjoy messing around in the registry, changing stuff on the desktop, then changing it back. that's the only way a win 98 machine can be truly secure, is with a lot of thought, and plenty of registry tweeks.
There's only one true way to know and love the registry, and that's to go play with it. So why does everyone seem so scared of it? I know the majority of us have more than one computer if we screw one up anyways?
What's the big deal?

8 replies

by admin

Sometimes it is the quickest, or just plain only, way to do something :)

by klingon

Heck! That's the most fun of all...especially when you completely screw a machine up! then you'll know not to mess with that key again!!

by generalist

If you have a test machine that isn't needed for something essential and you don't mind the risk of having to reinstall everything, playing with the registry can be very informative.

But warn people not to play with the registry on their computers. There are too many people out there who may listen to your tales about playing with the registry and try doing the same thing with essential systems.

by mckaytech

I think it is useful to separate "playing" in the registry from the somewhat different idea of making useful changes to operating parameters on mission-critical devices.

The registry is just an editable file where the stakes are a little higher than with other editable files. I'm not at all bashful about making registry changes on a production server but only if I know exactly what I'm doing. If I don't have that confidence, I work out the details on a test machine first.

Within the environment in which I work, registry hacks are time-honored ways of getting things done. In particular, you can often save a re-install of the OS if you know how to clean out orphaned keys after a failed software install or upgrade.

paul

by admin

I hadn't thought about people just playing around with no clue as to what they were doing. Registry hacking is playful, it's just fun to make a machine work better. If someone wants to learn this, they should get some info and definately work on a machine that is not mission critical.

by michael roark - ccna/da mcp 3csa

Yes I agree, you can't mess around unknowingly on a mission critical machine. But in order to get to that point, the difference between messing around and knowing exactly what you're doing, takes time, experience, and many times of screwing up machines.
I own all of the little black books that are supposed to show you stuff, (most of the things included are in poledit anyways) but, in order to learn the OS, I feel it's a necessary evil to destroy and reload a couple of machines.
That's what it took me, and now I have not the slightest problem with editing most stuff, and have to, for validating logons, and for making sure a default user doesn't have anything.
How many of your 9x machines could someone logon to, without knowing anythingabout your company, or any accounts/passwords, but would then have access to any/everything.
A couple additional keys can hide all of that for Default user, and you won't have to worry so much, granted, yes, they could still turn on the computer. but without anything on the desktop and nothing in the start menu, or the taskbar, they'll probably give up quick.
Not to mention the wonderful key of MustBeValidated, that will stop unauthorized logins, (except for safe mode, when the default user kicks in)
there are so many possibilities, and so little time, I don't think you can afford NOT to screw up a couple (hundred) times in the registry. It's taught me well.

by generalist

When you think about it, the only way you can truly learn is by making mistakes.

Doing everything absolutely perfectly based on notes from a book just teaches you how to respond to the known and things that resemble the known. If everything neatly would neatly fall into these categories, life would be wonderful.

Unfortunately there are more ways to foul things up then there are pages on how to fix them. Learning by making misteaks, and then figuring out how to fix those mistakes is anexcellent way to both prevent messtakes and to learn how to troubleshoot misstakes.

by ebob

...sometimes it is the only way to do certain things.

And yes, it can be fun.

But saying that the only way to "know and love the registry" is "to go play with it" seems a bit like saying that the only way to really appreciate your gun is to shoot yourself in the head (or at least the foot).

Most of us who advise against registry tweaking ARE NOT AFRAID of this activity. We have simply learned just how bad it can be. (Learned by many of us from working on real computers rather than PCS, and many more of us from royally srewing up a Windoze box!)

For those who don't undertsand this, you should know that very often, registry items are tied togegther. So to effectively change something in your computer you really need to make relevant changes to several related keys. Do you really know which keys are related, and how they are related?

Here are my "rules of thumb":
1 - On business systems, NEVER registry tweak unless there is no other way around this. (And since I only run NT and W2K on business PCs requiring Windoze, there are almost always other (read: better) ways to accomplish the goal.
2 - Always have a good backup.
3 - Only make one change, then try it out with everything on your box, before moving on.

And keep your OS and Apps CDs handy and ready for the inevitable reload.

Have fun.

This discussion is closed to new replies.