Is Rumsfeld the right leader for the Department of Defense?
Do you consider that Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, is doing a good job for the Department of Defense? Some people, even longtime supporters, have begun to recognize that he is not. According to Mississippi's Republican Sen. Trent Lott, Rumsfeld doesn't listen enough to his uniformed officers. Lott says that the United States needs more troops to help with the war and a plan to leave Iraq once elections take place in late January, but he doesn't think Rumsfeld is the person to carry out that plan. "I would like to see a change in that slot in the next year or so," Lott said. "I'm not calling for his resignation, but I think we do need a change at some point." Rumsfeld has also been under heavy criticism since a soldier asked him last week why the combat vehicles used in the war in Iraq don't have the proper armor.
On Monday, Republican Sen. of Arizona John McCain said he has "no confidence" in Rumsfeld, citing Rumsfeld's handling of the war in Iraq and the failure to send more troops. McCain also said that his comments were not a call for Rumsfeld's resignation, explaining that Bush "can have the team that he wants around him." He said he had also expressed lack of confidence in Rumsfeld when fielding a similar question a couple of weeks ago. Loren Thompson, head of the Lexington Institute, a defense think-tank long supportive of the secretary, said on Monday that Rumsfeld won't face reality: "He knows what the situation is, but he has been unready to change his plans."
Rumsfeld has been most reluctant to change his plans about the size of U.S. land forces, and the Army in particular. It was, perhaps, a good idea to "go early and go ugly," as senior generals put it, to war in Iraq; waiting longer to build up forces in the spring of 2003 was not a risk-free proposition, and most of those now bemoaning the size of the invasion force are at heart still bemoaning the invasion itself. But the experience of the past 18 months must count for something in reconsidering the overall size of the Army.
In agreeing to stay on as Defense secretary in the second Bush term, Rumsfeld has made it known that he wants to "complete the job of transformation" he has started. Do think he's on the right track, or would it be better if he dedicates himself on winning the war he helped begin?
Source:
http://www.cnn.com/2004/ALLPOLITICS/12/16/rumsfeld.senators/index.html