Discussion Locked

Islam, enemy of all non-muslims?

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory?id=1744148&CMP=OTC-RSSFeeds0312

Abdul Rahman is facing a death penalty for the high crime of converting from Islam to Christianity. In the Islamic faith, this is a crime punishable with death.

[i]
"We are not against any particular religion in the world. But in Afghanistan, this sort of thing is against the law," the judge said. "It is an attack on Islam." - Judge Ansarullah Mawlavezada

"He would have been forgiven if he changed back. But he said he was a Christian and would always remain one," prosecutor, Abdul Wasi told AP. "We are Muslims and becoming a Christian is against our laws. He must get the death penalty."
[/i]

these are the people we are told we should be trying to reason with? I am very afraid the Muslims of the world are going to make this world war III, Muslim vs non-muslim, kill or be killed.

This of course is after the different flavors of savage muslims kill each other off. In the mean time, the civilized nations of the world will be standing around trying to reason with crazy people.

30 replies

by bfilmfan

I would point out that a number of societies in history have used the "convert at sword point or die" principle of dealing with others. Due to those experiences, civilized people, no matter their belief or lack thereof, recognize that it is a basic human right to believe as you wish, as long as your belief doesn't harm another.

What chaps my behind is that we (the US taxpayers and others) spent billions of dollars to free these people to only watch them create another autocratic government. The allies certainly didn't give Germany, Japan and Italy back to the people that started WWII.

by jdclyde

stop giving ANY financial aid to any and every nation that follows this type of barbaric law.

Yes, it is a shame that an entire race seems to be completely insane. If this is still seen as a just part of muslim life, people will start to see that maybe muslim DOES equal terrorist? What a shame.

So where are all the human rights groups now? Quick to cry for people in a US prison that is being treated better than he deserves, but where are they during modern day religious persicution?

[i]

(kind of funny that this has already been banned from the "NEW" discussion list)

by dr dij

Well yeah,

TR people aren't dummies.
They don't want their servers blown up for talking bad about radical muslims.

Islam is facing a serious crisis in that the moderates need to reign the extremists and agree to rule of law rather than rule of religion, if they want to co-exist in a civilize world.

Sadly, the radicals think that the way to get what they want is always by force. In Thailand, radical muslims in remote village were cutoff from govt funds. They actually said that they thought they should get more money 'to keep them quiet'. Brilliant, lets reward terrorism!

If they don't, they will be ignored, spat on by rest of world, the very things they claim they do not want. (as long as the rest of the world looks away while they kill people for helping women, for free speech in indonesia ( a moderate newspaper and Islam self help groups were targeted with killings and death threats, censorship by death threats there))

by mjwx

You seem to forget that the US is heavily Christian. If not for wealth I suspect the US would be acting in much the same manner as the Middle East with the exception of the fact you would kill for Jesus instead of Allah.

Perhaps the Islamic fundamentalists want WWIII but they will not ignite it (the will only provide an abundance of fuel) it is there way to avoid blame. With a belligerent Texan in the white house this job is made easier for them. Individual responsibility seems to be foreign concept to all religious fundamentalists regardless of their beliefs. The kind of economic strain and social discord another major conflict will cause will be detrimental to the US who's economy is already under strain from its current wars (note the plural you?re still fighting in two foreign nations) and increased global competition.

The US compared to other western nations is not a beacon of civilization. I can?t seem to find this quote on Google so I can?t tell you who said it but here goes "the mark of a civilized man is to discard less desirable traits in favour of better ones". To quiet a few Americans greed is a desired trait. Perhaps you should correct your own society?s shortcoming first and provide an example to these ?barbarians?.

Secondly the US is the biggest reason that we can?t stop giving the Middle East money. You need their oil. There is not enough oil outside the Mid East to maintain global economies. Just to screw with your heads a bit Google LATOC (Life After The Oil Crash).

I have resigned myself to believing that I can?t change the world yet. But I can try to change the society I live in.

Mike

P.S. this post is decidedly anti-American I?ll be the first to admit that, but is it undeserving.

by m_a_r_k

...the more they stay the same. The Romans, for example, killed anyone who believed in any god(s) other than their own. If you put any god before the emperor, it was a crime punishable by death.

by sleepin'dawg

The pantheon of gods, both Greek and Roman, never fell under that classification. Zeus(Gr) and Jupiter(R) stayed supreme but the emperors rated equal status with the others such as Ares(Gr)and Mars(R) or Athena(Gr) and Minerva(R). It was applied to gods of other races such as the Christian God and Hebrew Jehova but there was some latitude given to Egyptian gods that had Roman or Greek equivalents often recognized as the Roman or Greek gods equivalents by another name. Believers in the Carthaginian gods, Babylonian gods and others were treated in the manner you describe.In the end what difference did it make. Today they no longer exist but you might be interested in hunting down a book by Thorton Wilder called "The Twilight of the Gods" It's entertaining and quite humerous but it's been out of print for years now, as far as I know. You might find it in a second hand book store or at Amazon. It shouldn't be very expensive; maybe a couple of bucks.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by m_a_r_k

Thanks for the info. I read a couple of novels recently about the very early Christians and Romans (right after the destruction of Jerusalem circa 70 AD) and it got me interested in some of this stuff. [i]Twilight of the Gods[/i] might be an interesting book. I searched for it at Amazon. No luck. It'll probably turn up somewhere.

by dr dij

The majority of Muslims are interested in peace. They are more interested in their personal lives and when their trash will be picked up.

Islam DOES however produce more radical, ticked off people than other religions by quite a bit.

I'd hazard a guess that this is due to 1) the particular religious tenets they expouse, 2) and fact that the Koran is re-interpreted in radically different ways. combine this with 3) lack of central figure in islam to give them an official agenda

this combines to produce a 'psycho-agressive' or 'bully' mentality that is widespread among many. In their own societies, this balances out and hatred / agression is directed outward, at non-muslims. even so, lifetime vendettas are not uncommon in the tribal areas of Pakistan, among themselves.

Many of their neighbors are very peaceful so are overwhelmed and swept away by the agression, such as the fights with Hindus or other sects in India, or the killing of Christian settlers on the Indonesian islands in remote areas by the Laskar militias.

Sadly, this combining into 'gangs' and aggression is acting as a valuable (to them) survival and expansion instinct.

In the cities of more developed areas, their societies are more peaceful.

by absolutely

A "core value" is by definition singular. "Core values" is a non sequitur, and an attempt to pass off a patchwork of postulates as personal integrity. Your lack of a single core value is our point of disagreement "Maxwell Edison".

by absolutely

I don't believe that post is too extreme. I do think I can elaborate a bit. If Islamic terrorists do not respect the West, or the United States, or Americans, is it because we aren't kind enough, or because we are too unlike the brutal theocratic dictatorships under which they live?

by sleepin'dawg

President Bush being deeply troubled impresses the hell out of those authorities but it's not going to the guy much good if they decide he is mentally fit and they stretch his neck. The bit about mental fitness is to leave them a way out in case the US decides to flex a bit of muscle and they can save face by declaring him mentally deranged. Otherwise you can stick a fork in the poor guy; he's done.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by tig2

Although short, it brought out a couple of really good speaking points.

First- I appreciate that the president finds the situation troubling. Unfortunately, he was elevated to President of the United States and not President of the World. Unfortunately, you gotta play by the rules of where you are. Had I been this individual, I would have left town before converting.

The second point was more interesting. The article mentions that his mental capacity is in question and must be evaluated in order to proceed. Help me out here- is he being considered of dimminished capacity because he has chosen Christianity and therefore MUST, by definition, be insane? The article suggests that the charges will be dropped if it is determined that he is insane. Okay. Then what? So is this just a way out?

So I am a Christian- I must now be put to death OR deemed insane. No sane person would convert. Therefore I MUST be insane- thus ducking the bullet.

That's some catch, that Catch 22.
-Joseph Heller

by sleepin'dawg

those under thirty years of age??? Thought not.

It is disenfranchised youth that is driving the fanticism and I've noticed you don't see many of their youth condemning the terrorists, if anything they support it. They need to be taught a lesson and so far diplomatic efforts have failed and are continuing to fail. So tell me this; what's your alternative and what's it going to be when they pull off another attack and it turns out to be worse than 911. If I could think of an alternative, I would suggest it but I can't. If someone comes up to be and threatens my life, I don't wait to see if he is serious or not, I take his word for it and react accordingly. When are you going to see that Muslims want us dead, either that or to become Muslim. That is precisely the way they see it. It's pretty clear cut for them; make us into Muslims or kill us. You really believe the business about peaceful Muslims. Well maybe there are one or two but the vast silent majority of them, sympathize totally with the fanatical terrorists.

I've heard the crap about trying to understand their grievances and I will try but not until the threat is neutralized. Stop the threat, then maybe we can talk but keep threatening me and I will believe you and I should react accordingly or be called a damn fool.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by mjwx

I am not anti-American.

I just dont want to go to war. Me, I'm 23, male and working in a non priority industry. Am I the only one who can spell conscription.

"War is not nice" Barbera Bush.

by jdclyde

when it becomes a capital offense to Not be muslim?

If this man is put to death, this is going to be a real wake up call to the rest of the world.

Crime? Not being muslim. punishment? death.

That is nuts, as is everyone that thinks it is "just their culture". Rabid dogs have to be put down before they bite and infect others.

by mjwx

In fact religion doesn't hold much sway over here. I don't want to die for a war which I am dead against.

A little while back this little churchie named abbot (we have a Costello in parliament as well) was making noise against Islam saying that "we (Australia) will never have Sharia law" in an attempt to create US style fear amongst the masses. It didnt work, Tony Abbot had to go back to the abortion debate with his tail between his legs.

If we kill all Muslims then what, we will need to destroy the next minority (blacks, Jews, Asians, take your pick). Eliminating your current threat will not make you more tolerant. Eventually they will have to shoot you because your neck just isn?t red enough.

This kind of fear mongering doesn't affect me. A war however will.

To further fuel the fire, whilst I hold no religion as my own if I were to choose it would be Satanism (Anton Zsandor LeVay) which I have found to the most tolerant of religions (with the exception of Buddhism) and most fitting with modern life.

P.S. you may actually care to find out about the religion for your self before making posts against it. I will not tell you about Satanism.

by rob mekel

And there lies the problem as the Sharia is the law in Islam ruled countries.
There are even proposals that the (or parts off) Sharia should be implemented in Canada. ( http://www.ccmw.com/Position%20Papers/Position_Sharia_Law.htm or
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/1885052.stm )

As long as people don't separate state from religion this will happen.
Hence as "the west" still has some laws/rules that refer to Bible/Torah or whatever religious book or religion, the Islam orientated countries will refer to the Sharia.

This will stay this way unless we all get together and declare a bill of rights that underbids this and all of us have to obey to.

[i] Does sound like human rights bills of the UN, doesn't it! So maybe we have already implemented this but do not enforce it as it should have been done. Or the UN has not enough power to enforce (all of) its members to do so! I wonder how that has become this way?[/i]

Rob

edited for format

by tonythetiger

"The majority of Muslims are interested in peace."

Of course they are, and as soon as everyone else is dead, they will have it!

by sleepin'dawg

The book is called:
Night Life of the Gods

The author is/was:
Thorne Smith.

The link to buy it:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0375753060/ref=sib_rdr_dp/102-8824799-3516112?%5Fencoding=UTF8&me=ATVPDKIKX0DER&no=283155&st=books&n=283155

Sorry about the mix up. The author wrote Topper which was made into a movie back in the forties and if I remember correctly starred Cary Grant. When I screw up, I do it by the numbers. Sorry about the confusion but I at least got the Thorn part of the name right.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by absolutely

You mistyped one of your original errors, causing the author's name to appear as "Thorton Wilder", without the first "n" that belongs in the name of the famous playwright of "Our Town", that so that your later statement "but I at least got the Thorn part of the name right" was also inaccurate! "By the numbers" indeed!

:D

by jardinier

A majority of Australians are not religious at all -- a comparison with Americans which I attempted to make in a recent discussion.

However in John Howard's successful endeavours to gain re-election in 2001 by lying about the "people overboard" and making a big issue about the "boat people," he sure demonstrated that intense racism is very close to the surface in an alarming proportin of Australians.

I was actually horrified to find that so many of my "Christian" friends held so much hatred for these Middle Eastern people about whom they knew nothing.

The situation was of course exacerbated by the concurrent pack rapes of young Australian girls by young Lebanese males. I don't recall whether these young males were Christian or Muslim -- I think they were Christian.

But how easy it was/is to lump all Middle Eastern people (except Israeli Jews) together as a threat to western society.

by jardinier

AFP, March 26, 2006

President Hamid Karzai has personally intervened in the case of an Afghan man facing execution for converting to Christianity, a top official said, amid fierce criticism in the West.

Karzai was consulting with various government organisations to resolve the matter as soon as possible, the senior government official said on condition of anonymity.

"The president is personally working to resolve it peacefully. There is a way out of it," he said. "I believe it'll take one or two days."

Another senior official said late yesterday that the convert, 41-year-old Abdul Rahman, was likely to be released from jail soon. He said the matter would be discussed at a top-level meeting.

Rahman was arrested under Islamic Sharia law about two weeks ago after his parents went to the authorities, reportedly following a family dispute.

Sharia law, on which the Afghan constitution is partly based, rules that a Muslim who converts away from Islam should be put to death.

The case has attracted widespread international condemnation, especially from the United States which led the campaign to remove the fundamentalist Taliban regime in 2001 and is destitute Afghanistan's main donor.

The Islamist Taliban implemented a tough version of Sharia that included stoning people to death for adultery and chopping off the hands of thieves.

The matter has presented a dilemma for Afghanistan, which has agreed to international treaties on human rights but is under pressure from conservative Islamic clerics to abide by Sharia law.

Besides the United States, Britain, Australia, Germany, Italy, Sweden, Canada and the United Nations have also voiced their concern about the case, threatening to drive a rift between Afghanistan and the Western countries it relies on to rebuild after 20 years of war.

Afghanistan's Supreme Court said this week it was trying to find a "good solution", including persuading Rahman to revert to Islam.

It has also said Rahman may be psychologically unfit to stand trial, which analysts have said would provide the government with a face-saving solution.

Rahman converted 16 years ago while working for a Christian aid organisation in Pakistan, according to court officials. He later lived in Germany for nine years before returning in 2002.

by absolutely

This is a worthwhile topic, even though jdclyde is the individual who raised it.

Dr Dij: "Islam is facing a serious crisis in that the moderates need to reign the extremists and agree to rule of law rather than rule of religion, if they want to co-exist in a civilize world."

Absolutely: What leads you to assume that "they want to co-exist in a civilize world"? After expelling the atheist Soviets, with the assistance of the United States, numerous nations proved that given the option of democracy [b]with universal human equality[/b], (not to be confused with formalized mob rule such as what is being developed in Afghanistan & Iraq at my expense and that of all other US taxpayers) they were never fighting for freedom at all. They just disliked communism because they had already acquired an addiction to their own local brand of totalitarianism.

by jardinier

Rather than start a whole new thread, I will post this here and maybe some people are still subscribed to this discussion.

By Linda Morris, Religious Affairs Reporter, SMH, May 5, 2006

AUSTRALIA'S most influential Catholic has said the Koran is riddled with "invocations to violence" and the central challenge of Islam lies in the struggle between moderate and extremist forces as the faith spreads into a "childless Europe".

The Archbishop of Sydney, Cardinal George Pell, said reading the Koran, the sacred text of Islam, was vital "because the challenge of Islam will be with us for the remainder of our lives - at least."

But in a speech to US Catholic business leaders, Dr Pell said Western democracy was also suffering a crisis of confidence as evidenced by the decline in fertility rates. "Pagan emptiness" and Western fears of the uncontrollable forces of nature had contributed to "hysteric and extreme claims" about global warming.

"In the past, pagans sacrificed animals and even humans in vain attempts to placate capricious and cruel gods. Today they demand a reduction in carbon dioxide emissions."

Dr Pell said the September 11 terrorist attacks had been his personal wake-up call to understand Islam better.

He had tried to reconcile claims that Islam was a faith of peace with those that suggested the Koran legitimised the killings of non-Muslims.

While there was room for optimism in fruitful dialogue between faiths and the common human desire for peace, a pessimistic response began "with the Koran itself/"

Errors of facts, inconsistencies, anachronisms and other defects were not unknown to scholars but difficult for Muslims to debate openly, he said.

"In my own reading of the Koran, I began to note down invocations to violence. There are so many of them, however, that I abandoned this exercise after 50 or 60 or 70 pages."

Last year, Dr Pell courted controversy when he drew a link between Islam and communism.

His speech on Islam and Western democracies was delivered in Florida on February 4 but only appeared on the archdiocese's website on Wednesday.

Dr Pell said every nation and every religion, including Catholicism, had "crimes in their histories". In the same way, Islam could not airbrush its "shadows."

Claims of Muslim tolerance of Christian and Jewish minorities were largely mythical and he wondered about the possibility of theological development in Islam when the Koran was said to come directly from God.

"Considered strictly on its own terms, Islam is not a tolerant religion and its capacity for far-reaching renovation is severely limited," he said.

However, like Christianity, Islam was a living religion and the existence of moderate Islam in Indonesia was proof of the softening impact of human intervention.

Democracy and moderation did not always go hand in hand and an "anorexic vision of democracy and the human person was no match for Islam," he said.

This discussion is closed to new replies.