Discussion Locked

IT's no wonder that the US Education

0 helpful
88 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

isn't comparing well on a global scale.
My Stepdaughter goes on summer vacation on MAY 4 2006

MAY 4th!!!!

how do you expect your kids to learn anything if they are getting long vacations from schooling?

It's no wonder the USA has such a terrible reputation for the people being ignorant with the rest of the world. [ ignorant as in piss poor education and knowledge base ]

danged typos bugs, gotta spray for them again

88 replies

by apotheon

It's "public education". It just begs to be turned into a propaganda and selective ignorance factory.

by too old for it

They teach them that abstinance is something those silly bible thumpers do, that fashion is jeans slung down to the pubes and halter tops that are barely there, and anyone over 18 who happens to notice the resulting dress+mentality is a perv.

Methinks Japan is on the right track. School 12 months out of the year and uniforms.

by gadgetgirl

(not over here it ain't, pal!)

So, if she finishes May 4, when do they return to school?

(Your system is wierder than ours.....which is about to get wierder, once we "even out" term times, btw)

GG

by jaqui

in Colorado, where my wife and child are. :p

here summer break is at the end of june to the beginning of september.

by jardinier

if you don't also give the end date.

In simple English, what is that actual length of the vacation in weeks?

by jaqui

somewhere around september.

this is an extra long break, with an early start to the prior year to allow for building renovations to the facilty.

it's still way to early to be breaking for the summer.

by dmambo

The relevant figure is the annual number of school days. Here in the NE US, most states set it at 180, which is still shamefully low, especially for secondary school.

by charliespencer

So she gets out May 4th. When did she start?

The start dates, end dates, and even the length of the school year are not set by the U.S. government. In many states, those dates aren't set at the state government level, or even at the county level. In South Carolina the start date is set by the individual school district, although the number of school days is set to 180. (Don't ask why there are multiple school districts in a county.)

In the district where I work (I don't have kids or school-age relatives) school begins in early August and ends in late May or early June. The start date varies by district and is the subject of much debate every year. The closer your district is to the beach, the more likely it is to start later in the year. But all S.C. districts must have 180 days, so the later they start, the later they finish.

What's obscene is 40 of those 180 days are lost to mandatory state or federal tests.

None of this is a defense of the U.S. (lack of a) school system. For some reason unknown to me, parents in the U.S. place a great deal of importance on making educational decisions at the lowest governmental level possible. "I don't want Washington dictating what my kids learn!" That's the real reason we can't compete on a global scale academically. It's not the length of the year, it's the lack of an effective national education strategy. Each state has it's own graduation course and testing requirements, and each state (and often individual school districts) have their own differing methods of funding. We can't compete internationally because we're too busy with interstate and intrastate competition.

Try being a military brat (among other children with parent who must move frequently) and attending school in multiple states with different graduation requirements.

by jaqui

between the US and Canada.

the education is controlled by the Province, not the district.

but the same 180 days and 40 off crap.
Canada does place better in these studies, not a lot better though.

Here, if there is major structural work, they move the students to a different facility if needed, most renovation / alterations take place over the summer, and if more time needed they work with the students in the school still. A very real - life situation where your work space is full of distractions and you have to deal with them. This actually teaches the kids to focus on what they need to accomplish despite externals they have no control over.
{ I actually wired a couple of chools for networks and satelite tv a number of years back, this was scheduled for the summer break, but the break wasn't changed to suit the work, the contractors had to work with established summer break times.

by charliespencer

"... the break wasn't changed to suit the work, the contractors had to work with established summer break times."

That's the way it is in at least one S.C. district. The high school across the street from my neighborhood has been under constant expansion for at least three years. This hasn't affected the lenght or schedule of the school year.

Please don't make generalization about the U.S. education system based on one Colorado district (or any other single district or state). I'm sure you can find plenty of evidence to support more substantial criticisms at a national level. Start with the "No Child Left" program or the U.S. Dept. of Ed.

by onbliss

[i]This actually teaches the kids to focus on what they need to accomplish despite externals they have no control over.[/i]

??

by nicknielsen

They are usually more adaptable because of the number of changes they make between schools.

At least I did...

by ccthompson

Cause later, there is no vacation. Kids need some time off. As adults, americans recieve the least amount of vacation in the world.

Dont believe me? There was a recent article on TR that outlined major countries, I cant remember them all, but I know that Italians get like 40 days, England get 30-35. Germany, around 20-30.

Americans, 5, even if your company builds them up, or transfers over, your max is about 20. And those first few years that you skip to build up, you get 0.

So yea, I believe that American children need a break now, cause America never slows down, and there wont be time for a break later.

by nicknielsen

That hurt!

Although you may be right. I know too many people who think they should get paid simply for showing up at the office.

"I was here every day. Why are you firing me for doing nothing?"

by ccthompson

There are always going to be a few bad examples in any situation. Ill give you that, but if you look at all the things that America has given the world, you cant deny that we are not hard working people. Dont take that the wrong way, i mean inventions, and charities.

There is no doubt that people are getting lazier, and someday, maybe we wont be as an ambishous country. But ill prob be dead by then.

by jdclyde

First week of June, ALWAYS. Both public and private.

Is this a private school?

Did they start the year early?

Did they cut short Christmas break, no snow days, and all the other MANY breaks during the year?

By LAW to get federal funding, they have a certain number of days they have to complete, and they are free to start,stop, break, anytime they want as long as they get that number of days.

by wallowamichael

Here comes one of those whackos who thinks it's better to keep his kids at home rather than send them off to school :)

Even before our kids were born, we knew that they would stay at home to learn. I'm the math/science guy, my darling, wonderful, sexy wife is the history/language girl. We both do music and art, I take care of sports and she does dance/yoga.

We believe learning is a life-long endeavor. There are no 'breaks' from learning. Now, that does not mean that we sit down with lessons every day of the year, but we as parents try and relate everyday experiences into learning opportunities.

I could write for days on this and tell you how wonderful it is. I know what will happen, however. I will get ignored, derided, and (I bet) FLAMED for this! (It's happened before...) All of this from the same people who whine and complain about the state of education for their own kids!

Now I understand that jaqui, jdclyde, and a few other of you separated/divorced/etc. folks may not have such an easy time of it, but there's still private school (I recommend Waldorf schools).

In the long run, it is better for you to teach your own children than have others do it for you. Do you personally know AND APPROVE of the education, morality, and discipline methods of every adult to whom you hand over your children every day? Then why are you doing it?

by tryten

I have never meet or seen an individual that has had a "successful" run with home schooling. Some might have a descent education but the majority of people that I have meet that were home schooled have very very poor social skills.

Home schooling may let the parent be involved with the material that their children recieve but you said yourself that you need to APPROVE of the material. This approval is an opinion formed by the parent. This is a very dangerous situation, being that the parents basically "shut the door" on a learning opportunity for children.

For example, lets say that a parent does not believe in the theory of evolution because of religious beliefs. This parent them would not approve of this material and not provide the child with the option of forming their own opinion of both the theories of evolution and religion; face it folks no major religion can be proven to be 100% true making those religions a "theory". We as worshipers even confirm this by saying that we "believe" in this or "believe" in that.

It puts the entire future of the children in the hands of the parents who may or may not be equipped themselves to make these decisions for the children. This is mainly because we humans are way to opinionated to make these decisions for the children. I will try to teach my son right from wrong but who am I to say that this material should not be taught to him. I do not possess a background of teaching and neither do the vast majority of most parents.

I honestly hope it works for you, for the childerns sake. And if you or your wife were home school and have become successful and mentally balanced and equipped then I am glad to say that I finally have heard of a success story.

by wallowamichael

I appreciate your candor. I also appreciate that you hope my children turn out ok, which is more than most people when they learn about our home education.

Your arguments as to beliefs and appropriate materials are a little flat, however. First of all, why on earth would you want to teach your children something you don't believe in? If you believe in evolution, teach evolution! As an example, (so as not to start a huge thread on evolution vs. creation vs. ID) if we believed in evolution, we would tell our children that is how life came to be. We would discuss the creation stories of the world's religions and mythological heritages (Norse, Ancient Greek, Roman, Chinese, etc.), but our focus would be that evolution is the truth!

Most recent studies on child brain development are coming out saying that giving children choices is BAD. Giving children information is GOOD. The schools in most states can't teach creationism, taking away your argument that parents will "shut the door" on a learning opportunity. The schools are already more opinionated than most parents.

It puts the entire future of the children in the hands of the parents - And where better for kids to be? In the hands of strangers? If you have convictions, morals, beliefs, and ideas that run your life - share them with your children and teach them at home.

Since the 50's, give or take a few years, state run education has declined. We all kind of agree on that here in the posts, I think. Since that time, with women entering the work force, and the 'nucliear family' coming of age, public education has transformed into trying to be everything for everybody. It is failing miserably.

Do you know where the 'best' schools are? I bet you don't. The 'best' schools (and by that I mean high literacy rate, high graduation rate, and high academic scores) in the country are RURAL. More than 90% of the 'best' schools are from towns of less than 50,000 people! Why? Because the entire town demographic usually shares attitudes, morality, beliefs, and everyone knows each other and shares in the education of the children.

We have just taken that one step further and are educating our children at home. We have three other home educating families that we share curriculum, ideas, and teaching tasks with. We have concerts, pot lucks, seasonal parties at least once a month. I wish my parents had been half as involved in my childhood as I am with my kids.

by apotheon

You've created a false dichotomy there -- what we in the logician bidness call a "false dilemma fallacy" in formal argument. You suggest that, in essence, home schoolers are brainwashing their kids and hampering their social development by keeping them out of the more open and social context of public school. These suggestions of yours simply don't hold up to examination.

First of all, you assume that home schoolers can't teach their kids to have an open mind, which is bollocks. As measured against the openness of the minds of people subjected to public education, there's no reason to believe that a homeschooled kid will have a more closed mind, unless the parents set out to close their kids' minds. There's likely to be a wide range of effects in this area for homeschooled kids, rather than the one-sided extreme you suggest.

Second, you assume that public education isn't brainwashing your kids anyway. Have you looked at a public school American History textbook lately? These things tend to have titles like "Rise of a Nation" (real title from a real book). By contrast, tell me when the last time was that you saw a chemistry textbook titled "Rise of an Atom". "Public" schooling is subject to "public" policy, and that policy tends to be very closed-minded in various ways. Teachers, school administrators, school board members, and community members who vote all have agendas to push. If there's a problem with kids' minds being too closed due to homeschooling, public school is [b]not[/b] the solution.

Third, my social development came more from dealing with people at home in the early years of my education than from people at school. I was publicly schooled, and I learned a lot more about human nature and social interaction from my somewhat dysfunctional family life and the vicious squabblings of immature brats in my own neighborhood at least as much as I did from the highly dysfunctional authority structure of school and the vicious squabblings of immature brats on the playground. In fact, with its exercise-oriented "play" times, rigid scheduling, and oppressive rote behavioral indoctrination, public school probably better prepared me for a potential future stint in the state pen than for social interaction in the Real World.

Fourth, public school in the US doesn't teach crap. It punishes failure to successfully memorize trivial factoids, but without some actual desire to learn on the part of the children nobody's going to come away with any useful knowledge at all aside from an understanding of bureaucratic inefficiency. Why do you think some people are able to make it all the way to college without achieving functional literacy? You definitely wouldn't get away with that at home in a one-on-one learning environment. Someone would notice.

For the record, I've met a number of people who were homeschooled and grew up to be far more well adjusted, worthwhile, free thinking individuals than the vast majority of people who are publicly schooled. In fact, I have yet to meet a homeschooling failure. Maybe your problem with homeschooling isn't as objective as you think. It's possible you simply disagree with the views of the people that homeschooling produces. Frankly, I would have welcomed the ability to get as much of a quality education as the homeschooled people I've met have gotten. Instead, I had to fight for every bit of knowledge I got along the way. [b]Public school actually interfered with my ability to learn[/b]. It was my home life that empowered me to become as well educated as I am.

I'm a big believer in autodidactism, and homeschooling has a far better chance of fostering the motivation and capabilities needed for that than public school.

Assuming I have kids at some point, I intend to see that they're homeschooled until they get to about high school age.

by apotheon

Flamed? Perish the thought.

I applaud you for the dedication and perspicacity to homeschool your kids. I encourage it. Take this opportunity to expose your children to all the things they wouldn't otherwise get to experience that can contribute to a healthy, well-adjusted development. Have them read both Upton Sinclair (even if he was a terrible, terrible author) and Ayn Rand, both Immanuel Kant and John S. Mills, and both Lao Tzu and CS Lewis. Teach them Evolution, Intelligent Design, and -- most importantly -- how to think for themselves. Teach them Linux, Mac, and Windows. Teach them how to program in Scheme and Perl, instead of just Visual Basic (and start with a good beginner language like Logo or the Squeak implementation of Smalltalk instead of an awful one like BASIC). Once you've taught them algebra, start teaching them symbolic logic -- trust me, it'll be one of the best things you can teach your kids, and you can learn it at the same time if you don't already know the subject matter. Use the newspaper to teach them how to recognize bias. Use Microsoft-sponsored TCO studies to teach them how to recognize spin. Actually [b]make them read and anlayze the Constutition of the United States of America[/b], whether you live in this country or not, along with some Locke, Voltaire, and Paine.

I got kinda heavily into computer-related things for a couple of reasons, by the way:
1. It will be of great value to them even if they don't become "IT professionals" in the future.
2. I figure that if you're posting here you're inclined that way in any case, so it won't be much of a stretch.

by sleepin'dawg

[i][b]an end user of the product of either public schooling and/or home/private schooling.[/b][/i]

What distresses me most is how many times I encounter many, with degrees even, who have poor reading and comprehension skills or are functionally illiterate. Surprisingly many of these will have a sufficient level of computer skills to know there way around on a computer,if only in a game playing capacity.

Before anyone gets their shorts in a knot, their balls in an uproar and their water all hot, this is not a phenomena exclusive to the United States. I have found similar situations in Canada, the UK and Europe but strangely not so much from Asia. They exhibit a somewhat different problem.

I do not have any answers or solutions; I am just stating certain things I have observed over my past 18 years as an employer. This is not any criticism of the people and their parental units or society as a whole. A lot of these observations I received second hand as I seldom am involved with interviewing for entry level positions.

When I say functionally illiterate I do not mean people who can not spell their own names or words like dog and cat but people unable to form any sort of comprehensible sentence, no matter how poorly spelled it may be. If an individual can't communicate ideas or criticisms, what good are they going to do me when I ask for a report on something and am handed a load of gibberish. What good is an engineer who can't work out one of the most basic of mathematical functions such as determining the area of a room; god forbid asking them for the cubic capacity of that area.

Anytime we canvas for candidates to fill jobs, we find almost twenty plus percent of individuals like these and what dismays me particularly, is many have degrees from some big named universities to their credit. How can this be???

Likewise in terms of business deportment, so many these days lack the self discipline to conduct themselves properly in a business environment. This last doesn't seem to matter much, whether the candidate comes from a home schooled environment or that of a public school. The younger they are the worse it is getting. I noticed this several years ago and it is a steadily deteriorating situation. I've lost track of the number of times I've had to define acceptable behaviour but the amazing thing has been, that once having it pointed out to them, so many have agreed with the criticism and fallen into line. I'm pretty loose about behaviour; I'm primarily intersted in getting the job done within the allowable time frame and a freewheeling atmosphere usually results in achieving this but there are limits and that applies to myself as well. My background is ex-military so I sometimes have to make a concious effort not to be too heavy handed. Somewhere along the way, they weren't taught proper deportment and appropriate, interctive, social skills.

English and European candidates are usually better than their North American counterparts as regards self discipline on the job but do seem to lack the spirit of intuitiiveness and innovation, that North Americans have in such abundance.

Asians are almost too disciplined and are rarely as intuitive or innovative as the others but once they've been here a while, they do loosen up.

As I've said I've found almost twenty percent of North American students deficient in employable educational skills and this only falls off slightly when talking about Europeans and the English. I have yet to meet the Asian candidate who has failed to correctly give me the area of a space and its cubic capacity but unless they've really applied themselves to their English lessons, have a hard time communicting those facts.

Are their any solutions for this condition on which I've stated my observations??? I don't know, but as I have said it isn't a problem exclusive to the US. I've heard similar things from other parts of the world as well. Where the US and Canada stand in relation to the other nations of the world; again I don't profess to know. But I do know there is a problem that seems to be becoming increasingly rampant. I don't know what the answer is or even if there is an answer but It is certainly a problem and becoming more so every day.

Give any fourteen year old a calculator and a tape measure and he or she should be able to answer the above area and cubic capacity questions. Ask them to determine it for their own rooms at home. Make sure you know the correct answer yourself before posing the questions. Given that they can't provide an answer within ten minutes, then your fourteen year old has a definite problem. Ask them to read the first sentence of the Declaration of Independence and then ask them what they think it means. If they can't read it clearly and don't understand the meaning; then your fourteen year old has a very definite, even worse, problem. Assuming you can do this yourself, it should come as a shock to you if your fouteen year old can't. Sad to say, far too many of them can't. I say the reading and comprhension problem is worse because the lack of reading skills probably prevented learning the solution to this basic arithmetic problem.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by onbliss

I come from the camp that believes kids should be enjoying their childhood apart from learning. Unfortunately, the Universal behavior is that they get inundated with school work.
And, it is not that the kids do not learn anything in the summer vacation. There are plenty of opportunities for them to learn.

But you do have a point regarding competitiveness. If across the globe schools are stuffing the kids, then it does affect kids in general.

Edited: A typo.

by jdclyde

is the QUALITY of the education keeps dropping, because the Democrats completely refuse to hold the ever corrupt teachers union responsible for doing the job they are paid for.

I sure wish I could tell my boss that you shouldn't look at the results of my work to determine if I have done my job.

That is exactly what all the BS against the "No Child left behind" was all about.

Blindly continuing to throw more money at this corrupt system had not made education better, but worse.

Overhead is outragous. Accountability is non-existant. Discipline in the schools is a thing of the past.

There are even recent examples of wanting to pass kids through just so they don't feel badly. Yeah, push them through and they will feel real good about themselves and their job as a dishwasher or ditch digger because they can't read or write.

by onbliss

...that advocates Discipline in the schools. Back when I was studying, the teachers could/did pinch, twist the ears, cane the students and employ other tactics(kneeling down, standing on a bench, making one sit amongst the opposite genders). The parents knew about it, and worried about it only if it went abusive.

Times have changed, so I don't advocate such harsh punishments.

The overhead in US schools does seem to be high. And I can only hazard some guesses: Too many schools; method of schooling* are some of them.

As far as the accountability, the parents need to own up some of the accountability too. The parents need to their part - which is getting involved in the kids' education totally.

by faradhi

When I moved from the Florida and Tennessee (Largely Republican) to California (Largely Democrat) I was a year behind in school. Then four years later moving back, I was a year ahead. My nieces recently experienced the same thing.

Further, the PTA meetings are non existent here. The parents are not a involved. Teachers have a hard time getting parents in to discuss the child's education.

Now, I agree that there are some serious problems with education and unions are part of the issue. You cannot pin this all on the democrats.

by apotheon

The poorer you are, the more likely you are to vote Democrat. This is especially true if you're suckling off the government teat for a living. These imbeciles the public education system is creating aren't going to have jobs as dishwashers and ditch diggers: they're going to be on welfare, and they're going to keep voting Democrat to keep the handouts coming.

Each of the major two parties has its form of ignorance to push on the populace at large. This is the Democrats'.

by faradhi

This is a hold out from the US being a former agrarian society. Kids had to be off from school to help the parents in the fields.

I like the idea of having school year around. Multiple breaks throughout the year is fine. When I lived in SanDiego, I went to a school that was all year around.

by jdclyde

In Michigan they are talking about making the core requirements more challenging statewide. I was amazed that over half of what was the core that I needed were NOT part of the state requirement.

You can not leave education in the hands of locals that have no training in such things.

As for parent involvement, there is just as big of a problem with parents trying to be involved but the teachers not wanting to BOTHER with it.

Your example did not show how education was set or hindered by party policies, but instead shows the problems when you don't get a state wide standard.

It is a fact that some regions of the country put a higher emphasis on education than others. Go look at the education in the Miss area.

The lively hoods are less based on tech than industrial.

I can and will blame Democrats for intentionally dumbing down the general population to make a peasent class, so they can get votes from people too stupid and lazy to know better. No, not everyone that is a Democrat is stupid and lazy, but there is no one that can deny that the lower your education level the more likely you are a democrat. The more likely you will have your hand out, the more likely you are a democrat. The more you think that "the government should do something about that", the more likely you are a democrat.

There are also a lot of good, hard working people that are democrats. Are they stupid or evil? No, just a case of good people with bad ideas! ;\

Have a grand weekend Fara! :D

by faradhi

And you are right that many teachers do not like parents to get involved. However, Most are begging for parents to be involved.

Mississippi is a classic example of poor education. The last in the nation the last I checked. I might add that Mississippi is a Republican bastion. The politics in that state is dominated by Republicans.

I would disagree that the less you make the more likely your democrat. I know a lot of poor people uneducated people who vote only for republicans. See Mississippi again. Also, here in Tennessee. I know a lot of wealth educated people who are democrats as well.

I would say that many Republicans are good people with bad ideas.

Oh, by the way, In regard to education levels, are you actually saying "The [state] government should do something about that"? :D (Sorry, I couldn't resist)

I hope you have a good weekend as well JD.

by jdclyde

with how slow TR is loading for me today, I will take this as your failing to comprehend rather than my failure to communicate! ;\

The STATE is suppose to be more in line with the public than the feds. Feds do security and roads. (and tax and tax and tax....).

The state should set minimum standards that everyone must meet. School districts don't meed those standards, they get control taken over by the state.

This had to happen in Detroit because the scum down there are so corrupt. There was even a nice lady on the board of education down there that had a driver that drove her EVERYWHERE (not just for school meetings). This nice lady even would have her driver take her to the mall so she could go shopping and he would have to sit in the car WITH IT RUNNING for two to three hours so it would be warm when she came out.

I have no idea why the schools don't have any money......

Good weekend? Just lined it up! My bud is taking my boys and me out on his boat for the opening of Bass season. yes, a good weekend indeed!

:D

by nicknielsen

Halfway through the post you stopped blaming Democrats and started blaming democrats. I hope that was a typo.

BTW, every one of the 50 states has statewide education standards. What amazes me is that the USA is the only industrialized country in the world that does not have a _national_ educational standard. Strangely enough, every time somebody has proposed a national standard for English, science, math, etc., it has primarily been Republicans who screamed the loudest in the successful attempt to shoot the proposal down.

And no, No Child Left Behind did not set a national standard. It allows each state to set its own standard.

by apotheon

Wasn't it the Bush Administration that was pushing national testing standards, and Democrats who were opposing it (basically just because they couldn't agree with Republicans)?

by jdclyde

our country is set up to leave the control of the states to THE STATES. This is the check and balance to an over powering Fedreal government.

The states are suppose to be self governing, not dictated to from on high.

And note that the only thing the Feds can do is NOT give you money if you piss them off. (remember the horrible idea of making the states drop the highway speed to 55mph? That was a Federal deal, of lower speeds or don't get funding for roads.

Again, the feds should be doing less and taxing less.

The states should be doing more and taxing more. This would remove being under this control of the Feds.

by onbliss

What I am going to narrate is just one example, where I thought my child should not have been given the choice. I do not mean to generalize and say that children should not been given any choice.

My son, when he was five years old, went to a park along with his daycare buddies. They studied plants and bugs. They dug out worms, and washed them. And then boiled them and put them between the cookies and ate.

At the end of the day, my son narrated this to us. We are vegetarians (not vegans) and I asked him did he know that what he ate could be considered as not being vegetarian. He said he did not. We did not pursue this matter much with him.

Next day, I spoke to the Daycare's director. We have standing instructions about giving just vegetarian food to our son. So I asked her if she knew more about the incident where my son and some of the ate worm-cookies. She said, the children were given a choice to eat or not eat. And my son chose to eat. I just dropped the matter and moved on. (what could I have done, though I was upset?)

This incident was enlightening to us as parents, about the choices that we should, can and ought to give our children.

These days, we just tease our son on how he ate worm-cookies :-)

by wallowamichael

Sounds like you had a pretty good experience with your daycare, even though you were upset.
I don't know many who do that type of work with kids, and i've never heard of anybody (preschool class, at any rate) eating worms.

Had the teacher known your child better, there could have been a different focus (feed worms to chickens rather than eat them yourselves) for the same lesson. Even at the tender age of 5, the peer pressure to eat the worms overcame your family teaching of vegetarianism, because he was given the choice without guidance.

'nuf said.

by tony hopkinson

Quite right as well.

My parents aren't vegans but they always told me off if I put a worm in my mouth, so I would n't have eaten them.
:D

by faradhi

--added
that is a fair choice for a 5 year old
--
This is not an statement for or against home schooling.

If the child was given the choice of not eating cookies or eating cookies with worms, Of course the child will eat the cookies regardless what is on them.

However, If the child had been given the opportunity to eat cookies with or without worms. The child might have chosen no worm.

Additionally, the child did not have the information necessary to make the correct choice. The child did not know that insects are counted as meat. Now that the child does, given the situation next time, he will be more likely to make the correct one.

The key here is not to make all the choices for the child. The key here is to give your child limited choices in a controlled environment. Then gradually expanding the the range of choices while reducing your control as the child can handle it.

How would you expect your child to learn how to make good choices if you don't teach the child how to critically examine the choices given to them?
On a side note, your nicer than I would be. Beside the obvious question of Why the hell are they feeding my child worms? I would be asking them why my dietary requirements that I laid out were not followed.

edited to change incests to insects

by onbliss

[I just did not know have a suitable title for my reply :-) ]

You are right, the child did not have enough information to make the decision. And the teachers did not know if the child had all the information.

I do not remember the choices my son had. But since he did not know insects [you should correct your typo, btw :-)] are counted by us as meat, he would have still chosen that option. Because he did not feel it disgusting. Whereas some kids thought so and did not eat them.

The daycare, to my best knowledge (a key aspect), follows our dietary requirements. Things like this are bound to happen once in a while.

My narration is not meant to support or oppose home schooling either. I just brought it up because I thought it touched up the topics of choices and children.

by tonythetiger

but, where else are the kids going to get all that socalist propoganda that they so desperately need. And besides, what parent has the time? They both have to work now that the government takes 60% of their earnings.

My recommmendation (seriously!), Get your kids to drop out of school after 9th grade (before the heavy political BS starts), teach them yourself during the following year, then have them take the GED. After that, have them work (a job) and earn their own money for college. They'll earn it, they'll have a stake in it, and they'll appreciate it more.

by onbliss

...not when the individual pays for it or if the individual's parents pay for it. It will be more appreciated when it - Education - pays the individual back. It could be monetary or non-monetary.

But if one can get away in a society with less education and the parents and society do not insist the importance of education, then education is going to be less appreciated.

by apotheon

That's backwards. The political BS starts in Kindergarten: the best way to handle it is with homeschooling until it's time for ninth grade, then send them to school to learn about bureaucracy and the viciousness of their spite-driven peers once you've armed them against ethical degeneration and political propaganda.

by faradhi

My comment were mainly to dispute the statement that giving children choices are bad.

As you described it, the child had the choice of a cookie or no cookie. Most 5 year olds are not going to care what is on it. That is why I say the choice was unfair for the 5 year old.

I believe strongly in giving choices to a child. Let me give you a successful story about giving a child choices.

When my niece was four, her parent had a awful time getting the child to go to and stay in bed. For whatever reason, the child did not want to go to bed. We gave her a choice, go lay down in the room we prepared for her, or lay down on the couch. We did not give the child the choice of continuing to play. She choose to lay down on the couch. Sure enough within 10 minutes the child was out and in the bed we prepared for her. Her parents eventually used this to their advantage. In our house, the child wanted to stay with us which is why she chose the house. We are fun. At her house with mom and dad, her room was more fun. So she choose to lay down in her room.

The key here was to get the child to sleep. So we framed our goal in a way that would give her a choice.

by faradhi

I understood what you meant. And I agree. The state government is better suited than the Federal government to decide what should be taught in the state.

What you said in the origonal post was "The more you think that "the government should do something about that", the more likely you are a democrat." I know you meant Federal government. But I just couldn't resist. :D

by dr dij

face it, our schools are more exciting to kids. how will they learn about the real world if they don't get threatened by bullies, see other kids having various types of sex in the classroom (I was amazed to hear that hj's and bj's are common!).

They also learn by feeling the earthy environment of a third world country in trailers that are falling apart, lack A/C, have vandalized bathrooms and grafitti. (this is the valuable lesson that large bureaucratic school districts soak up much of the money before it gets to kids)

They also get to feel part of a group when they join gangs for protection, or to become budding entrepreneurs, selling much-in-demand comodities such as crack or weed, guns.

This and selling supplemental protection services (extorting businesses) trains them for a life as a crooked cop if they choose to take that route.

In addition, building your own battery powered tatoo machine gives them valuable electronics skills (I saw some 13 year olds with one of these). And this artistic bent can have them end up in a documentary about tatoo conventions on the discovery channel!

We have very nice communal living areas (prisons) for them when society gets too upset with them. They can still run their gangs and buy / sell drugs but at least we know where they are (at least for the short, revolving door prison sentences they get).

And they appreciate their group when others instigate racial violence such as common black / hispanic strife that has been happening here in LA area.

And they learn the valuable lesson that the gov't laws are BS when they try illegal drugs. Those that don't and instead become alcoholics destroy their livers and their lives even more, esp. when they drive to fast late at nite when drunk (another valuable life lesson).

They learn the valuable lesson of 'keeping up with the jones' materialism (what else is capitalism about?) when they 'have to' have the latest mini-nano-ipod and must obtain for free all the cool music (here learning that 1. they can be sued by the music industry, and 2. that the fuddy duddy's behind the music industry are NOT too cool.

I'm sure all these kids would bored silly in canada without all this excitement. I'm sure you have some of it tho.

(please don't take me too seriously, I'm trying to show how it IS in a light hearted way)

by onbliss

If different States have different minimum standards, does'nt it just hurt the entire country?

by tony hopkinson

Be careful with this one.
In the UK we have a national curriculum.
Unfortunately the gooders and the PC boys constructed it.
There's about 20 subjects to learn, school hours are shorter so guess what, they learn less about more.
This is called rounding !

Even better we have league tables where schools get points for passes and recently something called added value. Needless to say 'good' schools get more investment, bad ones get government investigators all over them.

Of course there's absolutely no drive by schools to achieve good figures whether they are deserved or not, that's a vicious untruth perpetrated by elitists like myself.

Then there's choice, obviously you don't want to send your kid to a lower league school, but of course not all the kids can go to the best schools, there aren't enough places.

Screw up from start to finish, oh all this crap was fetched in a by a right wing government, course the 'socialists' absolutely love it now.

making schools achieve a minimum standard is a good idea, just let somebody with a bit more life experience choose the standards, otherwise you'll end up where we are, in deep poo.

I was more suited to further education or work at thirteen than my kids were at sixteen. Progress eh ?

by oz_media

Jaqui!!! You know better than to utter such truth on TR! While the entire world knows US education is substandard and very limited, okay lets just say it's sad, we have a 'certain peer' here who thinks otherwise. Stats show that Americans are receiving better education than other countries provide....US stats of course. LOL!

I knew a history prof from Cal State who quit after 15 years because he said the history books (at university level) were so out of whack with what really happened that he wouldnt mislead his students anymore, especially at the price they paid for education. His words were something like, "There's so little mention of the rest of the world's accomplishments that you would think they were all undeveloped US colonies."

Oh well, leave them alone Jaqui, it's not nice to tap the glass. Just look and smile. (or just as [i]they[/i] do in Richmond when they practically drive into you, they just wave and smile).

by jdclyde

I have always said that most Canuks are the nicest people you can meet, until you get them behind the wheel of a car! :0 Then get the F out of the way! ;\

by oz_media

Anyone that knows Rickmond would know I am not talking about Canadians here. LOL

They watch you swear at them without a single clue as to what you are saying, they just smile and wave.

by apotheon

It's true that something like 98% of history textbooks are full of crap, but colleges/universities have procedures in place to allow professors to submit lesson plans with all the course requirements -- including texts -- to the department head to be able to teach the courses the way they want to. There are good college-level history textbooks out there. I own one of them, and I've read another of them. You just have to care enough about your work as a history professor to do the research.

It's only in high school that you're stuck with what's handed down to you with no ability to change things for the better, and even then there are ways to circumvent the propaganda.

Of course, that's because high school is even more controlled by government than college. There's a distinct conflict of interest at work: the more government funding a school gets, the more government control there will be, and thus the more propagandized the education will get.

by oz_media

exactly what keeps TR so bizarre.

As I said, he worked there 15 years, obviously completely aware of his control over the curriculum. I think th eissue was that he wasn't allowed to teach what he felt he should. I know he ws quite hot when talking about it.

by jdclyde

Many colleges do not give the teachers a choice of what they will be teaching with.

Kind of a "hit and miss".

by oz_media

Don't flatter yourself.

I DO however think you feel the same way, I can't remember if you supported your educational system or not. I assume you do because it taught you.

by apotheon

The schools' methodologies aren't going to improve. As government gets more and more involved, the schools get worse and worse. Even trying to emulate the successes of education in other countries where the standard of learning is higher only tends to make US public schools just that much worse.

The factor that's not being counted with all these public school reforms, budgetary allowances, and newfangled teaching "philosophies" that come and go with the tide, is parental involvement. It's more the parents in nations that have higher educational standards, and greater educational successes, that make a difference in how the kids learn in school, and that in turn leads to improvements in the schools. Positive change for something like this needs to move from the bottom up, not from the top down.

Instilling, by whatever means they use, valuation of education in the students improves the students. Like leading a horse to water, you can lead a child to a textbook, but you can't make him learn from it. No amount of warm fuzzies passed out to good kids in school or extra money spent on administrators and teachers' salaries will change that. Some communities with high educational standards get their kids to learn by threatening them with dire punishments at home. Others do so by actually opening the kids' eyes to the wonders of learning -- which, in a public education system, involves getting the child to realize that the most valuable learning is going to come from somewhere other than the classroom. That's how it was for me, after all: I knew what was being "taught" in class before the teacher ever spoke it because I was learning things on my own, at home.

Public school is government-sponsored daycare with textbooks and overpaid, officious administrators. It's not education. Once people start to realize that, then things can begin to improve. Those who do realize it are trying to use homeschooling to make up for the lacks in public schooling, but they're running up against a lot of resistance in the form of government-peddled FUD and ever-tighter restrictions because, of course, public schooling sustains huge bureaucracies and employs tremendous quantities of union members with strong lobbies.

The more you can get government out of your kid's "education", the better off the kid will be.

by nicknielsen

and the work was being done a complete wing at a time. Work affecting the entire student body (cafeteria, main office) or educational requirements (science labs) was done over the summer. There was some distraction, but very little, since the building design allowed student traffic to bypass construction areas. High-noise work (jackhammers, etc.) was mostly performed outside school hours.

"No Child Left Behind" was a shot in the dark that completely missed the target. The primary assumptions of this legislation seem to be that first, all students can learn the same amount of material to the same level of comprehension in the same amount of time; second, that school is the only structure in which children learn; and third, if children aren't learning, it's the teacher's fault. My 8-year-old nephew knows better than that: "Whoever wrote this was pretty stupid, Uncle Nick!"

One major problem with the American education system is that it was designed over a century ago to support a primarily agrarian populace and has not changed structure since. A second problem is that schools are now being required to teach moral and ethical lessons. Most of us old guys remember learning these lessons OUTSIDE school: at home, at church, etc.

I don't know what the fix for the first is, but I do have a suggestion to fix the second. Parents are held responsible when minors violate business contracts; we should, therefore, hold the parents responsible when minors violate laws as well. For every adolescent arrested for shoplifting, underage drinking, or whatever, require the parents to attend all meetings, counseling sessions, overnights in juvenile hall, etc.

by nicknielsen

Public school teaches our children that learning can only take place in public school.

What a crock of doodoo.

by jdclyde

faradhi, yes, I figured you were just jerking my chain. :D (need a "flipping the bird" emoicon! ;\ )

Onbliss, and who should set the standards. The Fedreal Government does not have the authority to set standards about education. The MOST they can do is not give fedreal funding (that they should not have taken in the first place) to anyone that displeases them. The feds should tax LESS and the states should tax MORE. Each state should be responsible for themselves, and THEY are the ones that have any Constitutional rights in the matter.

Tony, we already have issues like that popping up. When feel-gooders in the "progressive liberal movement" have started to push teaching social issues in school, we have the schools teaching about homosexuality and diversity instead of math, reading, and government. Everytime you add in another BS program, you are stealing from the time spent on the core classes that are the REAL reason for kids are in school.

by nicknielsen

During the Reagan and Bush I administrations, national standards for English were proposed for adoption. Given these standards were proposed by the "liberal" Modern Language Association, Republicans in Congress and the religious right both reacted predictably. I believe the same thing happened when social studies standards were proposed.

Again, No Child Left Behind mandates testing, but does not set standards; each state can set its own standards, no matter how low. I just find it hard to believe that the USA has achieved as much as it has without mandated national standards.

by tony hopkinson

Don't care how well rounded they are, if you can't multiply two single digit numbers without a calculator or your fingers, or guess the meaning of a word from context then the education system has robbed you and your parents.

There is no place for liberalism of whatever stripe in schools, hard work, discipline and meaningful recognition are what is required.

What they are doing is scary, they are creating a pool of people who will be 'happy' to rely on welfare. A wilfully manufactured underclass. Even worse most of those in power in favour of this stupidity send there kids to private schools where this sort of nonsense doesn't feature.

by apotheon

If the US has surprised you by achieving a lot without national/federal testing standards, you should use this surprising knowledge to adjust your assumptions.

by nicknielsen

My surprise is that we do not have government-mandated national standards. If you think about it, we do have de facto national standards.

Think college entrance exams...

by jdclyde

the ever corrupt Teachers Union did not want to be held to any standards for doing their jobs.

by nicknielsen

Most teachers I know would be more than happy to submit to some measurement of their success other than the results of standardized testing. The problem is that the people choosing the metrics usually have some anti-public education axe to grind. For example, the governor of South Carolina has been pushing a public education improvement program he calls "Put Parents in Charge" which would allow parents a tax break for tuition in private schools. Also, the SC legislature distributes the vast majority of "Education Lottery" funds as college scholarships and to K-8 programs, with only indirect expenditures (e.g. school buses and "education accountability expenditures" [exit exams]) to 9-12 progams (http://www.sceducationlottery.com/images/PDF/benefbrochnew.pdf). They then complain about the failure of the high schools to educate their children; this is the politics of public education in South Carolina.

If you as a parent are not happy with the public education system, you have many options, private schools and home schooling among them. But I will guarantee one thing: Your child will succeed, both in school and in life, if you are involved with your child's education.

Edit: added link

by jdclyde

where some instructor somewhere knows more than everyone else and so feels he/she will enlighten the rest of us.

Had a few like that. Too bad they generally can not back up anything they say and get very defensive if you ask follow up questions.

Bottom line. He/She is paid to do a job. Don't like the way that job is setup to be done? Get a different job and cry to someone that cars.

by oz_media

As was pointed out before, he has some say in what he teaches. Nobody is suggesting the know any better than the school, BUT...as a History teacher, and a very worldly one that has taught in several countries, he saw more and mroe omissions of material and plays on words that make it appear the US had done things they hadn't, without crediting the country that should have been noted.

Of course I wouldnt expect you to agree, being American of course. If you are taught the world is flat, then it is flat and any other theory is not credible.

Why would you possibly believe that your history teachings may have been biased or tainted? We are talking about YOUR country and YOUR educational system, of COURSE its better than others, of COURSE it is correct and others are wrong. Sure.

by onbliss

I come from a country, where each State has different syllabus. Also, there is a Central (federal) syllabus. The Government (public) schools follow the State syllabus. Many of the private schools opt usually for the central.
My father retired from a transferrable job, that meant he used to get posted very often across the country. I was able to study in a school that operated on Central syllabus (actually it was a chain of schools) and get away with it.

by onbliss

That some teachers have to spend some money out of their own pocket for teaching?
I thought I saw some questions regarding this while completing my taxes :-). If it is true, why are the required to spend something in the first place?

by jdclyde

the money is stolen along the way by top administration.

Supers get a 200k while teachers get 24 to 30? (see a problem here?)

The money for class rooms also gets stolen by the system put in place by the government.

For my boys school, they request everyone to send in a ream of printer paper and a box of tissues. I do every year.

It even costs for the kids to do sports activities now.

That is where programs like vouchers comes in. If people have a choice of public or private, for the first time EVER, the public schools HAVE to become competative. Just like in any business class, if there is a monopoly, it is always bad for the consumer. School systems are no different.

As for teachers buying things, it is if they have projects they want to do. They also have been known to out of their own pockets, suppliment kids that are sent to school without the materials they NEED, like penicls and paper.

by onbliss

...so why do the teachers get the blame? I know there are going to be good and bad teachers.

by oz_media

I remember a teacher in grade 6 that wanted to take the class out to a local farm for an edeucational day out. The funding was denied by the school, so she paid for it herself, including chartering a bus.

by onbliss

Why do they go out of way and incur expenses such as these, if they are not authorized (by means of funds) to do so?

by maxwell edison

I've been beating that drum for years. The state of the government-run schools...... I mean the public schools in the United States is in terrible shape. (Disclaimer: Some government schools are fine. Many, however, are not. But overall, the condition and outcome of government run schools is not good. It's just a bad system.)

The declining state of our schools should be a wake-up call to those who advocate doing more of the same. Gee, what do you think you'll get if you keep doing the same thing you've been doing, but only do more of it? Perhaps the same outcome you've been getting, but only more of it? That's right.

Why do people want to do more of the same thing as a solution? I just don't get it. (Well, I really DO get it. These people want to benefit from the problem, not provide a real solution.)

It's time to totally overhaul the public education system in the United States, and to totally rethink how it's delivered.

- Stop throwing good money after bad. Funding, or the lack thereof, is NOT the problem.

- Take the power away from the government, especially the federal government, and give it back to the parents, at least to the states.

- Abolish any form of teachers unions. (Fire the whole lot of them, if necessary, and start over, but whatever it takes to become union free.)

- Get politics out of schools.

- Get rid of tenure for teachers.

- Introduce true competition for excellence.

- Give a parent the freedom to choose the school that she believes is right for the child she chose to have.

- Make schools an activist-free zone.

- Mandate a maximum 20 percent budget for administration.

- Put the juvenile delinquents where they belong (hint: it's not in a "typical" school)

- Holding parents accountable and responsible for their own kids.

That would make for a good start.

And the vacation schedule would just become a moot point.

by onbliss

...can be implemented without Government involvement? Is'nt the power being given back to the government?

by maxwell edison

I was "shooting from the hip" on that one, and I didn't give the details too much thought. However, if you just take the general idea, you might get the general idea.

Bottom Line: Have true competition in the delivery of the education product. Competition results in lower costs and/or a better product. Monopolies (which is what the government school system really is) only results in higher costs and/or poor products.

by too old for it

Administrators of terrible schools around the globe are now mad at you for including them is the same sentence as U.S. public education.

While we are at it: Teachers pay across the board based on merit, with no base. Heck, if you are the music teacher and your band gets superior ratings every time you go to state finals, you deserve more than if you sit on the edge of the desk in English class and say "OK, chilluns, lemme axe you sumtin ..."

No wonder that the kids who tag along with their parents from Japan to here go to school (in uniform) on Saturday when the locals are out mall-hopping.

How abut school year-round, and if you want to take the kids along on your vacation, submit an educational plan for the time they will be out of school?

by apotheon

I think the problem is that you likely didn't correctly convey the person's actual concerns. Chances are good there was more to it than textbooks, since:

A) good textbooks, while rare, do exist
B) it's entirely possible to get a good textbook approved

by oz_media

you would seem to know much better./ After all, I simply worked with him for 5+ years, whilst you have obviously a much better understanding of someone you've never met.

Then again, everyone does that here, quick to judge and call the shots without the foggiest clue what they are talking about.

by apotheon

I'm not judging the individual, you git, I'm relating my experiences with the government-funded education system.

Don't be an ass-weasel.

by apotheon

I didn't say they could just alter class requirements willy-nilly. I pointed out that there's an approval process in colleges for getting things changed.

The only "hit and miss" is who your department head is, and where his or her biases lie -- and what your recourse is for taking it over his or her head.

by jdclyde

"he can't help himself", until I realized i have no idea what exactly an ass-weasel is, nor if he CAN help it or not! :D

by oz_media

I was speaking of someone I knew very well. In return I get people telling me it was a problem with the person I was speaking of, [b]"that was dumb"-apotheon[/b] yet they haven't a CLUE who I am speaking of...typical.

by tig2

The thing that is even, to me, more distressing is the number of companies that find sub-standard work product acceptable. Why on earth would I change my approach if it is getting me what I want?

I can think of a company that honestly believes that the standard for doing your job successfully is to get along well with your co-workers. What level of criteria is that when the goal of the company is to manufacture a product? In that particular scenario, my principal function was to do Notes database design. While I needed to communicate with business effectively, I don't see how in the world being liked by my co-workers had the effect of validating my design.

But then, I am a dinosaur in my profession. New engineering grads are confused by hexidecimal. Many don't know that 10 is either ten or two. A "network specialist" straight out of school has only a passing glance at octal. The last time I checked, these are the foundational tools of the trade. I got a grounding in numeric bases when I was in third grade. My father taught me RPN when I was a kid. Now I get a blank stare from my peers if I mention it- or anyone tries to use my calculator.

And English? We used to be taught the foundations of English so that we could speak in comprehendable sentences. I clearly recall parsing sentences for structure in school. No one does that any more. I got my first commplete Shakespeare when I was about 13 for Chrismas. I asked for my own Shakespeare because I wanted to be able to read Mac Beth as it was written instead of the "Cliff Notes" version more accessable to kids. I grew up with access to books of every type and read them. But then- back in those days, knowledge was a good thing.

It will be interesting to see what happens when those of us who remember when the purpose of education was to become educated (e.g. LEARN something!) are no longer in the workforce. Will the bar just continue to be lowered? Or will someone come to the conclusion that technology is not a viable replacement for actual thought and insist that real education replace the travesty.

by oz_media

While there are some pretty bright and enlightening people here on TR, we laugh our bags off 'watching Americans' when we are there.

Watching/laughig at Americans is a Canadian pastime, we laugh at the giant flags every where, we laugh at the ENORMOUS ribbons people have stuck to thier cars (as if bigger is better), and we laugh at the fat slack jaws everywhere you go.

It really is entertainment and you sure are glad to see Canadian soil again afterwards.

In their defense, most of these people we laugh at are really VERY kind and welcoming people, but just not the most considerate (a word absent from American language it seems)people you've met. They will walk into each other, block driveways on main roads when it's busy and appear absolutely clueless as to what they are doing wrong. they seem on have no concept of the term, queue, or what to do if you see one. They have no concept of moderation or 'enough' it seems as they pack more and more food and watered down beer into themselves...I'll stop before I PO too many people I think. It's just like something from the movie Quest For Fire, one friend asked me last time we were down, "How the hell did THESE people ever become a super power?" It boggles the mind sometimes.

And again in Americans defense, I think MOST Americans I've met are very warm and friendly people.

by ccthompson

All good points, most canadians Ive ever met are also Jolly people. eh....eh...eh....

Thats what i laugh about, no offense, just funny eh...

ALright, but the Candians do have a good land and good people. Although Ive only been over the border, i have no idea what the rest of Canada has to offer.

Likewise, with your view of the american people. Visit a few different areas, we have to be the most diverse land in the world, so dont judge on one section of the coutry, also If having a "support our troops" ribbon on our car is wrong, i dont wanna be right.

Does Canada have a military?

by maxwell edison

......nor did I think it was me. Don't flatter yourself by thinking you can read my mind. I was simply wondering who?

And the public education system of today is vastly different than it was when I went to school, so your assumption is incorrect. (I attended private schools, by the way, just like my son does today.)

This discussion is closed to new replies.