[i][b]an end user of the product of either public schooling and/or home/private schooling.[/b][/i]
What distresses me most is how many times I encounter many, with degrees even, who have poor reading and comprehension skills or are functionally illiterate. Surprisingly many of these will have a sufficient level of computer skills to know there way around on a computer,if only in a game playing capacity.
Before anyone gets their shorts in a knot, their balls in an uproar and their water all hot, this is not a phenomena exclusive to the United States. I have found similar situations in Canada, the UK and Europe but strangely not so much from Asia. They exhibit a somewhat different problem.
I do not have any answers or solutions; I am just stating certain things I have observed over my past 18 years as an employer. This is not any criticism of the people and their parental units or society as a whole. A lot of these observations I received second hand as I seldom am involved with interviewing for entry level positions.
When I say functionally illiterate I do not mean people who can not spell their own names or words like dog and cat but people unable to form any sort of comprehensible sentence, no matter how poorly spelled it may be. If an individual can't communicate ideas or criticisms, what good are they going to do me when I ask for a report on something and am handed a load of gibberish. What good is an engineer who can't work out one of the most basic of mathematical functions such as determining the area of a room; god forbid asking them for the cubic capacity of that area.
Anytime we canvas for candidates to fill jobs, we find almost twenty plus percent of individuals like these and what dismays me particularly, is many have degrees from some big named universities to their credit. How can this be???
Likewise in terms of business deportment, so many these days lack the self discipline to conduct themselves properly in a business environment. This last doesn't seem to matter much, whether the candidate comes from a home schooled environment or that of a public school. The younger they are the worse it is getting. I noticed this several years ago and it is a steadily deteriorating situation. I've lost track of the number of times I've had to define acceptable behaviour but the amazing thing has been, that once having it pointed out to them, so many have agreed with the criticism and fallen into line. I'm pretty loose about behaviour; I'm primarily intersted in getting the job done within the allowable time frame and a freewheeling atmosphere usually results in achieving this but there are limits and that applies to myself as well. My background is ex-military so I sometimes have to make a concious effort not to be too heavy handed. Somewhere along the way, they weren't taught proper deportment and appropriate, interctive, social skills.
English and European candidates are usually better than their North American counterparts as regards self discipline on the job but do seem to lack the spirit of intuitiiveness and innovation, that North Americans have in such abundance.
Asians are almost too disciplined and are rarely as intuitive or innovative as the others but once they've been here a while, they do loosen up.
As I've said I've found almost twenty percent of North American students deficient in employable educational skills and this only falls off slightly when talking about Europeans and the English. I have yet to meet the Asian candidate who has failed to correctly give me the area of a space and its cubic capacity but unless they've really applied themselves to their English lessons, have a hard time communicting those facts.
Are their any solutions for this condition on which I've stated my observations??? I don't know, but as I have said it isn't a problem exclusive to the US. I've heard similar things from other parts of the world as well. Where the US and Canada stand in relation to the other nations of the world; again I don't profess to know. But I do know there is a problem that seems to be becoming increasingly rampant. I don't know what the answer is or even if there is an answer but It is certainly a problem and becoming more so every day.
Give any fourteen year old a calculator and a tape measure and he or she should be able to answer the above area and cubic capacity questions. Ask them to determine it for their own rooms at home. Make sure you know the correct answer yourself before posing the questions. Given that they can't provide an answer within ten minutes, then your fourteen year old has a definite problem. Ask them to read the first sentence of the Declaration of Independence and then ask them what they think it means. If they can't read it clearly and don't understand the meaning; then your fourteen year old has a very definite, even worse, problem. Assuming you can do this yourself, it should come as a shock to you if your fouteen year old can't. Sad to say, far too many of them can't. I say the reading and comprhension problem is worse because the lack of reading skills probably prevented learning the solution to this basic arithmetic problem.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)