Discussion Locked

Its official. America is now a police state!

0 helpful
36 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Summarising the background as quickly as possible for those who don't know: Me Brit. Wife American. Live in UK. Have 4 month old baby.

Wife has two children from her 'previous' life, 14 and 15, both have been resident (adopted, even) by wife's parents since birth. As wife's parents have needed help from the state (NY) with benefits, NY state decided to take wife to court last year for back support.

No issue with this....a parent is obliged to support her children. I do with my children from my former marriage.

But....the judge decreed $50 a month and backdated the support to 1991 and the arrears instantly total $7500 odd.

The court order states payments from now on of $50 a month ongoing, plus $25 a month towards the arrears. Not much, but it's based on my wifes income which is precicely zero. The law states that the minimum support is $50 a month, whether you have $50 a month or not!

Here's the deal. At arrears of $450, they revoke your recreation and drivers permits. No problem there...she had her NY licence revoked years ago and now has a full UK drivers Licence which they can't touch. Above $500, the account is handed over to the IRS so that they can intercept Federal and State tax returns and refunds. No problem there...she doesn't pay taxes in the US or live there anymore! They also report to credit agencies....fine, but US and UK agencies do not have common files or share information. Her credit is good here at 'home'.

Now, should the arrears exceed $5000, which they do (did I mention they slapped her with $7500 instantly?!!), they then automatically notify the US State Department and prevent renewal of or application for a passport. Not only that but if you attempt to enter or leave the USA, your passport will be taken from you there and then. The idea being, to prevent you skipping the country if you owe support.

So....we want to visit family in NY. I'm a Brit and can come or go as I please for 90 days on an IA-94 visa waiver...I have a machine readable UK passport. Our daughter is also British and the same rules apply. The wife however, will have her passport revoked the minute she sets foot off the plane. She has nowhere to live over there (the parents don't have room), no job, no belongings other than what she can carry on a plane, and no money to speak of. I'd then have to return to the UK with my daughter.

Now the US government's idea is that by detaining her in the country and preventing her from leaving, she will somehow 'magically' be able to pay off her support. Meanwhile I have to return to the UK, minus one wife and mother. The fact that I'm paying off the arrears...stipulated by the court at $25 a month remember...at some $75 a month (I'm not made of money...I have to pay my own support and support 'my' family!) is neither here nor there. If she was 'detained' (trapped would be a better term), I'd then have to come back, and funnel what I'm paying towards HER support obligation, AND SOME, into childcare for my daugther while her mother is unable to return to the UK.

Does it not make logical sense that someone residing abroad, and who IS complying with (and bettering) the court order should be allowed to travel freely and return to their home, rather than prevent her returning and actually LESSEN her ability to have her support paid by me??!!!

I have tried EVERY source I can find and even telephoned the CSE agency and State Department in the US, and no one can find any rule or law that covers this scenario.

It seems we have two options....either wait to travel until the arrears are cleared (5-6 years maybe?!!) OR she has to apply for British Citizenship (which she is eligible for as she is married to a Brit and has been resident here for over three years). That takes time and costs about ?214 (US$350)...perhaps 8-10 months for naturalisation then another month for a British Passport.

When she does finally get a British Passport, because it will not be biometric (the UK won't introduce those until at least 2006) she will have to apply to the US Embassy in London for a visa, costing ?64 ($110).

In the mean time, the parents can't get to see their daughter, son-in-law or new baby grand-dauhter, and we can't visit family who we haven't seen for over a year.

I know the US polices it's own citizens to death (that is the purpose of the Social Security Number!), but isn't this going a little 'too far'?!!!

36 replies

by maxwell edison

Early on you said that your wife's parents adopted her children, their grandchildren. Adopted is the key word here, and you said that they were adopted since birth. (There's a difference between "being adopted" and "having custody".)

I'm no lawyer, but I would think that any person who gave up their children for adoption would be free from any support obligation, past, present or future. I suppose I could be wrong, but I don't think so. How can the state of New York, or any other state, for that matter, hold a person financially responsible for a child given up for adoption? It just doesn't make sense.

There seems to be something missing here. I'd consult an attorney who specializes in American adoptions.

by jkaras

I'm not sure Max but, she wasnt orphaned, but her parents were given legal custody like a ward. The attempt to adopt was internal and merly paperwork due to being of the same family rather than some other family. It's far easier to adopt within rather than the typical way most people go through adoption. I think because of this the parent is still connected to the child rather than sealed records and ordered to stay away. This relationship remains connected so I believe there is still proper care responsibility in it's mumbo jumbo. I could be wrong cause I'm only guessing but I have had friends who had adopted family members as well as just adopted who later find out where they come from.

by guruofdos

The parents effectively have court-awarded custody....the kida are not actually LEGALLY adopted. It makes a succinct difference and I apologise for the confusing intro.

The issue is not one of child support avoidance, far from it! Willful failure to pay support is a criminal offence and as such, if she 'willfully' avoided payment, this would be the outcome. We are (I am) paying the monthly due amount from the date of the judgement AND paying off more than the arrears obligation of $25 a month.

The issue is one of falling neatly into a gap in the statutes! I can understand why detaining a citizen within the US borders by revoking their passport could be used as a tool to prevent a person skipping the country and thereby avoiding support payments. Au contraire, my wife has attended hearings (by telephone from the UK), accepted the lawful judgement and with my assistance has complied as best as she can with said judgement.

If a person lives and works in the USA, then by all means keep them in the country if skipping abroad may be an issue. It may also be assumed that if a person is in arrears in excess of $5000 and manages to find the money for a plane ticket or a holiday, then perhaps that money would more properly be used for paying off some of the arrears.

My wife however does NOT live or work in the US, and has no plans to return there to live. She is happily settled here in the UK and this is our home. But, she still has family there and it is only right that she should be able to visit her children, parents and family from time to time.

The court have acknowledged that ours are not normal circumstances, but the law is there to prevent Americans leaving...effectively restricting them to where the government can keep their eye on them.

Although my wife is American, and acknowledges juristiction of the US Family court in awarding a support order (a process known as long-arm) because the children reside in NY State, she was a former resident AND the children were born there, what she fails to understand is that the law takes no account of non US residents, and insists that if they return to the US for a family visit they are 'detained' by the revocation of their passports.

This is effectively TELLING my wife that she WILL leave her home, daughter, husband, friends and life behind should she wish to visit her family and effectively become a 'prisoner' in the US until the support is paid off.

Like I said, as it stands this could take a few years! In the meantime we cannot visit!

We were told that if we did visit, so long as we only dealt with airline staff and didn't bump into any State Department officials, we would probably be alright as an airline worker has no power to confiscate a passport.

Yeah, right!

Every plane leaving any country in the world bound for America has a complete passenger list and details of passport numbers etc., forwarded to the US State Department and has to be approved before the plane can even take off....just look at BA 223 from London to Washington DC last week....it was delayed four times because the State Department wasn't happy about passengers passports.

Like I mentioned in my original post...US citizens are 'imprisoned' at birth by their Social Security Number...it doesn't matter that you marry, change your name or whatever. That SSN is inextricably linked to absolutely EVERYTHING that an American does in life. You can't even get a phone service or electricity supplied to your home without it, so no matter where you go or what you do, the Government have their eye on you!

The support computers notify the State Department automatically of arrears in excess of $5000. That data which includes the SSN is flaged up on a Passport Name Watch List...but names have NOTHING to do with it. It's all done by SSN! When you apply for a passport, you have to supply your SSN. An American cannot apply for ANYTHING without one. As soon as the MR passport is swiped at Heathrow, that data marries up with the data at the State Department, and then the 'men in black' are waiting at the airport. End of story!!!

So, in 10 or 12 months time, my wife will have a British passport. This doesn't have any SSN or anything 'encoded' into the machine readable data...we Europeans don't have such things!

The US Immigration Law states categorically that any citizens with dual nationality, as will be her case, MUST enter the US on their American passport. OK, they revoke it...and then she tries to leave on a British Passport, as is her right as a British Citizen. Only, the US State Department have no record of her entering the country on that passport, and there is no IA-94 visa stamp in the passport. So then all hell breaks loose and she will be arrested, detained and held pending investigation. I know this to be a fact as it happened to a co-worker of mine only a month ago who also holds dual nationality!

Whichever way you look at it, there is a big gap in US law which simply does NOT allow for our circumstances. But where there are no gaps, the law is sewn up tighter than a ducks ass!!

by maxwell edison

.
Even though your wife "owes" child support, whether it be for past or present obligations, the person to whom she "owes" the money could file a motion in the courts releasing her from any and all financial obligations. Even though it appears as though the courts are going after your wife, they never would have started the process in the first place unless another person, her parents, I presume, filed the initial papers seeking financial support. It seems to me that the villain here, if there is one, is her parents, not the courts. (Not to suggest that American courts can't be a "villain".)

As far as the rest of your comments, I agree with some, disagree with others, some to a greater or lesser degree, and I may or may not comment on them. Social security numbers, for example, are indeed abused and misused used as a quasi national identification number, a pet peeve of mine to be sure. (It would take some time to develop my thoughts, and I'm rather busy lately.)

Good luck to both you and your wife.

by jkaras

I am really sorry to hear about your dilemma. The law was meant to protect the disadvantaged from the estranged family member that might be hiding money or jewlery in a safety deposit box or anything else that only could be retrieved personally. Also due to be abroad it's the only way to maintain compliance with the order to resolve issue. It cant discriminate whether or not the person responsible has money or not, it has to be treated evenly.
My brother got involved with a lady who had two kids and an absent father that worked overseas because he made an s_load of money for his work.
Being a rather bright guy he saw the writting on the wall that the marriage was about over began to slowly weed out the accounts and open offshore accounts that couldnt be proven. He did this to get a better deal in the divorce forcing her to accept what he gave rather than what she needed to take care of the children leaving her high and dry with little money. The lawyers couldnt do much as it dragged out due to abroad status. Before the final court date my brother ended the relationship so I dont know what the final outcome was, but she definitely got the short stick, all because of the complications of different countries avoiding the responsibility.

It sucks when laws made to protect and help you have that loophole that gets exploited, especailly when there is elections around the corner that prompts people in charge to throw the book rather than use it responsible. To tell you the truth the only issue I can think of to help is contacting the New York Post or the Times with your story. If they are going to play the election game, why not you? Awareness that there is a New Yorker who for the good of her children gave them up to her parents and now trying to help assist with what she can is getting denied the right to see her family. Any politician will most likely want to grandstand for a little press that they care about the little guy since many people have broken marriages and have issues with child privledges. Hopefully this helps and wish the best. Keep us informed on the status.

by hal 9000

When they are running for election they tend to promise you the earth and when elected do bugger all.

Well at least thats been my experience of Politions from both sides of the fence over a 20 year period when election time rolls around they are all helpfull and nice but the moment they get elected they just do not have the time for you to even see them let alone do anything about what you originally approched them about.

A group I was involved with some 10 years ago made some very well thought out suggestions on "Child Protection" to both State and Federal Governments all of whom thought them great ideas and all of whom promised to impeliment these ideas as soon as elected. Well guess what nothing happened until now as there is a Federal Election coming up latter this year I heard the current Government offer the very same suggestions that we gave both them and the other side of Politics all those years ago.

The actuall paper that they released was even the same as the one we presented but naturally enough the organisations name had been removed from the bottom of the page. If only I had of thought to put a watermark through the page at least then they would have to have retyped it instead of just cutting off the bottom two lines and releasing it as their "New Policy."

I still have the copy here archived on HDD and I draged it out just to compare the two and they are exactly the same if only I knew then that one of my printers would have ended up being used to promote a political party I should have asked for a fee for my efforts.

I suspose it isn't all that hard to see just why I hold politions in such low esteme after all they did promise to impelment these suggestions ASAP and a little over 10 years latter release the very same proposals as their own ideas after a lengthy and costly tax payer funded investigation.

Personally I would not trust a polly as far as I could kick one and that's not far at all.

Col

by thechas

I don't think the US is a "police state". (Although the "Patriot Act" brings us closer than ever!)

What we do have is legislators that respond to highly publicized situations and create poorly written laws to address that situation but fail to account for the situation of the average citizen.

As to the Social Security Number;
It is ONLY supposed to be used to track wages and tax compliance. Far too many companies use it as a mandatory identifier which has the consequence of making identity theft much easier.

Chas

by guruofdos

Utilities, DMV, US Passport Issuing Agency and virtually every government department you can think of. On every court paper we have for support, my wifes divorce, and virtually everything, you are REQUIRED to provide the SSN. It's NOT optional!

by oldefar

It is optional to provide the SSN. Included is a comment about impacts from not providing it, such as delayed processing. Most people choose (key word) to provide to avoid the hassle. This is covered in the Privacy Act going back to 1974 or 1975.

Now regarding your situation, I noticed in your original post that your wife has failed to provide support going back to 1991. This makes the problem self inflicted in my estimation. While I applaud you and your wife for your efforts to correct this now, and I empathize with the impact on your family, I cannot see why the government of New York (which is providing financial assistance for your wife's children through the taxes of New York residents) or the federal government (which also provides funds used by New York to support children through the taxes of US residents) are somehow the bad guys. Had your wife paid to support her children the back support would have been less and the problem might not exist.

by maxwell edison

.
Why not just pay the $7,500 and be done with it? Even though it's a healthy sum, it's really not that much money, and with a little creative thinking, just about anyone with a reasonable degree of initiative and prioritizing could dig up such an amount.

You mentioned in a different thread that you were planning a trip to Canada to visit Oz. There's 25% of it right there.

But like I said, how you set your priorities is none of my business. (Hope I didn't offend.)

by hal 9000

What if he isn't the one paying for the trip and it is business related?

We have all been in the position of when we work for someone we are sent all over the place to do jobs and on some ocassions when we are sent to one place we take the oportinuty to kill two brids with one stone so to speak and visit someone we know there when we aren't working.

Personally I've been sent to many parts of the world on business related trips and although there are no records of it I even once spent two weeks in the USA but as I cam in on a Milatery transport from the Gap I wasn't required to have a pasport on me and in that particuar ocassion it would have proved counter productive to actually admit that I had been there.

But I've been to Germany, Switerland and several other places on work related trips and there is no way that I could have got the company who I then worked for to pay someone else the money that it would have cost to send me there without me doing the work.

While I do not know if that is the case here I wouldn't jump to any conclusions either and if I ever needed to go to the US for any reason I would not hesitate to look you up while I was there either.

Col

{PS if you live in CA I'm prevented from visiting there or talking to anyone who ives there as my wife knows everything that I do even before I do it and CA is OFF LIMITS to me as I tend to spend far too much money there.}

by guruofdos

The dollar is pretty low at the moment which works in our favour...but $7500 is still over ?4000, and that is four months take-home wages.

By take home, I mean after taxes and insurance AND the British Child Support Agency have taken their slice for my other two children. That sum alone translates to some US$700 a month!

I could happily sit here paying $100 a month with no trouble, slowly whittling away at the deficit...but the issue isn't the money...it's the time.

The court imposed an arrears amount of $25 a month...now let me see...that's 300 months at $25 a month, which is the rest of my working life. Thats on top of the $50 a month ongoing. Naturally it is in our interest to pay MORE and clear the arrears quicker...$200 a month is not an unreasonable sum I feel, out of what little we can spare. We have even put this in writing to the court and explained that to them but no, the retrospective arrears trigger a passport revocation and that's automatic and tough shit!

So we're in a dilemma where a court has imposed one figure as reasonable, we can quadruple (at least) that figure, but that still doesn't get us out of the passport revocation trap. Fine if we lived in the US...she'd just be stuck there. We don't, we live in the UK.

Surely the law should allow for such payment arrangements, in excess of what the court has decreed. But no, it's bye-bye passport, no ands, ifs or buts. If she had refused to pay support and built up the arrears, I could understand, but these are not accrued arrears for failure to pay. They are court imposed arrears and the account was set up with a 7.5k deficit. Within seconds of the support account being set up, the transmission was on it's way to the State Department. The law simply has no leeway for this!

As for travelling to Oz...Col hit the nail on the head. It would be a stopover on a business visit.

by cactus pete

that your wife can take a part time, stay at home job?

Maybe she can translate English into American English?

by hal 9000

From my reading of the original post it was originaly a "Family Issue" and if the woman wasn't able to offer any child support it appears to me that it was a family decission.

But then some years latter a Law was passed which threw all this into turmoil and threw the baby out with the dish water. The fees that where imposed by the court where mandatory and the minimum allowed. So it appears to me that the Presiding Court Official {Judge or what ever) depending on how this was heard seem to have acknolledged the existing problems but has his/her hands tied in what they could do about the current situation. The person in question oppeted to impose the minimum allowed payment possible but this by the Law had to be backdated to the early 90's. When any form of retrospective legislation is introduced it is only because the current government thinks that it will save them money aqnd has nothing to do with right or wrong only what is politically expident at the time.

Anyway would you care to explain how you get blood out of a stone to me?

If the person has no income they can not pay the imposed bill and if she was living in the USA would be free to visit her children whenever she chose to without paying a single cent to do so. However it is discrimation in preventing a person from returning to a country and here I do mean any country and then refusing to allow them to leave again.

If this was to happen no doubt she would end up recieving Social Security and be a further drain on the US economy and she would recieve a payment as well as an allowence for any children she was legially required to support. Sorry but the whole thing seems self defeting to me and makes absolutely no econimic sence but then again what do you expect from Politicions?

Common Sence certianly isn't one of those requirments to enter into political office.

Something similar happened in the UK several years ago and a British woman who screwed a 16 year old boy as a "Birthday Present" here in Australia and got pregnant returned to the UK and had the child was quite happy until the child turned 14 years old an a new law was passed where the parent was required to support the child and that 16 year old who by then was in his late 20's early 30's who knew absoultly nothing about this child was then ordered to pay all the back child support. Of course being an international rulling he wasn't obliged to pay the money but if he ever visited the UK he could be prevented from leaving there until the money owing was paid although I think if this was ever appealed it would raise some interesting questions and have some interesting legal implications.

Col

by oldefar

Simple is generally better.

The law simply holds a parent financially responsible for their children, and does not allow a parent to use absense as an escape from the responsibility.

No, you cannot collect when there is no money. Instead, the debt grows with an obligation to pay when able. Sound to me like this is what happened.

If she were in the US, she would not be on Social Security unless unable to work. Unemployment compensation is based on previous employment. Welfare now stipulates a requirement to be available and accept work when offered, or to accept training for new work. It no longer is a check to let someone sit around watching TV all day. Assistance would have the child support deducted. These options are still available to her if she chooses to return to the US.

It ceased to be a family issue only when the family chose to request state assistance. The initial government action was triggered by their decision, it was not a state initiated action. In a police state, the government tends to initiate such actions.

As for the problem now with travel, that is unfortunate. However, it can be argued that blind justice (without regard to extenuating situations) is overall fairer than justice arbitrated on every individual case by the judge handling the case. In fact, the move towards less judicial latitude came about because of the widespread variance among judges as to how to apply laws.

The bulk of the decisions are up to her. The choices may be hard, but they are her choices. Hardly a police state situation. And that is my point.

by hal 9000

Of the US being a Police State I was just attempting to point out that some people just fall between the cracks and while it is the same here on Welfare or as it is called here the Dole a person must not only be prepared to undertake any work that is offered as well as any training but they may also be required to "Work for the Dole" as well. While this is a disputed topic in some circles and there needs to be more thought put into the scheme overall it is a good idea.

However she could very easily get around the travel problem just by remouncing her US citizenship and becoming a British Subject and when she entered the US on a British Pasport the Authorities could do nothing about it because they lack the authority to detain a foregin national unless they is an imediate threat to the welfare of people/person in the USA.

by oldefar

Sec. 7(a) (1) It shall be unlawful for any Federal, State or local government agency to deny to any individual any right, benefit, or privilege provided by law because of such individual's refusal to disclose his social security account number.

(2) the provisions of paragraph (1) of this subsection shall not apply with respect to--

(A) any disclosure which is required by Federal statute, or

(B) any disclosure of a social security number to any Federal, State, or local agency maintaining a system of records in existence and operating before January 1, 1975, if such disclosure was required under statute or regulation adopted prior to such date to verify the identity of an individual.

(b) Any Federal, State or local government agency which requests an individual to disclose his social security account number shall inform that individual whether that disclosure is mandatory or voluntary, by what statutory or other authority such number is solicited, and what uses will be made of it.

by maxwell edison

.
I'm glad you posted this information. I was thinking exactly the same thing. I remember back in 1974, when the act was passed, I was in the Air Force and they made a big deal out of it, making sure we understood it.

Of course, I also remember always having to sign a "paperwork reduction act" form that was included with just about everything. (A real oxymoron - a piece of paperwork about paperwork reduction.)

by oldefar

I was also in at that time, and I submitted a suggestion that rather than having us sign that Privacy Act Disclosure form hundreds of times each they should have it done once at the time of enlistment.

The suggestion was kicked back. Yup, I had forgotten to sign and attach a copy of the Privacy Act Disclosure form.

by guruofdos

US Government forms always seem to make mention of a 'processing burden'...i.e., how long it takes a clerk to process and file the form!!

DA Forms (Department of the Army) are the worst! A repair on site for the US Army in Europe may take one of our engineers ten minutes. Then an hour to fill in the DA2407 and then half an hour running around getting the right signatures on them. Then back in the office, we have to do perhaps another hour or two on more forms and then send them to the US to be processed...the administrative burden on the form states 2.4 hours...and that's just for an Army clerk, let alone us! The then pay us, say $100 for the labour, which just about covers the form filling time....and God only knows how much an Army pen-pusher gets for his or her 2.4 hours!

by hal 9000

You're wife renounced her US citizenship and became a British subject?

I know it isn't the prefered option but it is probably the only one left open to you.

Yesterday the USA threw out Ian "Molly" Meldrum an Australian citizen who has only visited there a few thousand times as they where not satisfied with the Visa that he had. Seems that he was handcuffed and held as a prisioner on the International side of the airport and then put on the first plane out of the place luckely it was Australia bound but he could have ended up anywhere. And here I was thinking that before you went through Customs you where on international land and since this guy is such a threat to everyone as he Interviews Music Industry people he was treated correctly in being handcuffed and held as a priosner.

At first he thought it was a joke but in reality it was a major overreaction on the part of those involved as if they had just refused him entry he would have been quite willing to leave again without all the fuss and unnecessary BS that he was exposed to.

I can just see the travel adds now come visit the good old USA and be welcome but don't expect to get into the country as once we have all you're bookings paid for we are only too willing to treat you as a criminal and throw you out of the country before you even get past custome. But who cares we already have you're money so we don't get hurt.

Col

by maecuff

Of course, ours isn't quite the same, however, my husband can't get a passport right now because he is over $7000 in arrears for child support. The reason is because my step-daughter elected to stay with us permanently after a summer visit (She was 16 at the time) Her mother didn't balk but insisted we still pay her child support. (I still don't understand her logic). The problem is, their original agreement was made in one state, they had moved to another and we live in yet another state. Two years later, we still haven't gotten it sorted out, and while the powers that be agreed that we could cease paying child support, the arrearage accumulated in the first year she lived with us is still hanging over head. Mind you, her mother didn't pay a dime of support between ages 16 and 18 and we've been told we have little hope of collecting. At this point, we don't care, we just want to have the arrearage cleared up. Over the course of these two years, we've paid almost as much in attorney fees as the back support amount. And it's not that we are devastated at not being able to travel outside the country, what is aggravating is that it is taking so long to clear this up.

by hal 9000

The wheels of justice turn very slowely and need constant lubrication with cash to prevent them grindiong to a complete halt.

This is not a US thing but a general observation from most Western Countries. Recently my wife served on a jury where the accused was found inconent but by that time he had already spent 3 years in jail on remand had not seen his child that was born after his arrest except from the other side of a reinforced glass window and listened to her over a telephone. But of far more impo4rtance had lost the property that he was buying as because he was in jail and couldn't work and make the payments the bank forclosed on him and sold the property for less than its real value which covered what the bank was owed but left nothing for his wife to live on. Actually in evidence the court was told that the crop that he was growing on the farm was worth more than what the farm was sold for.

Then because he was a "Property Owner" he was not eligable for Legal Aid talk about the Law being an ARSE.

Col.

by oz_media

I'll start by sayig I was ALMOST in a similar siuation as I raised my son until he was 18 and had tremendous problems travelling AT FIRST.

I ended up reapplying for my UK passport (old one was dead) waited the 8 months, did the British Consulate in BC, more waiting and finally was 'released.'

Upon returning to Canada, I was hit hard by Social services because my son was applying for welfare while on his own, as he lost a roomie and was broke and without a home. He wouldn't attempt to contact me (was on tour with the band and could have easily sent money back)as he figured he could sort it out.

A year later, I was off to Japan (tour again)and had similar problems except this time, they wanted me to repay all of my sons welfare debt back before allowing me to leave again. I finally was able to arrange payment through a Canadian account setup with an automatic deposit from a Canadian company that I worked for (friends company, I just sent him money to stick in my account) and withdrawl for social services.

It turns out that there ARE credit agencies that operate internationally. AIC-Allied Insurance Corporation is now global, your debts will follow you practically ALL over the world if they get a hold of them.

I know this doesn't resolve your issue but hopefully you will realize that this is not unique. In your case it is not at all logical but I would retain a lwayer and poke around with some ideas. I don't see how a court order would not be able to resolve the issue with payments directly made to an independant collection agency on their behalf. you may end up payng MORE, LOTS more in the long run but I'm sure the costs is trivial when compared to having your family together.

As i have attorneys in the family, I will poke around and see what comes up, unfortunately this is Canadian law and not US, where things may not have the same loopholes.

My heart goes out to you all, I know this must be the hardest and most nonsensical thing you've had to deal with.

by guruofdos

Just an aside...making the payments isn't a problem...we simply send cheques via airmail made out in Sterling from our British bank account to the Support Collection Unit and let them worry about cashing them...it takes them six weeks and they have to pay bank charges of $25 a time, which the court actually stated is THEIR problem, not ours, so they can't deduct these fees from the payments LOL.

I have given them over a dozen alternatives for payment...wire transfer from a UK bank in dollar funds, credit card payments (most American government agencies will NOT accept payments on credit cards issued outside the US), Western Union, etc, but they just said send cheques so there you go....their problem if each cheque for say $100 equivalent costs THEM $25 to cash and they HAVE to credit the full $100 to the support account!

by oz_media

Yes it is very typical here too that they have NO clue how to really resolve issues at all. There is too much INTERNAL red tape and political BS they have to clear for them to possibly operate in a logical or 'normal' fashion.

I once had UIC (unemployment insurance)overpay me. FIVE years later when applying for automotive school assistance, they offered to pay me X amount each month for living expenses while in school.

They then realized I owed them money, I had never been told before, and scheduled a repayment plan of $120.00 month.

Now, I had JUST received acceptance for support while in school and would need to pinch in order to make it work for me (thyis is in addition to student loan and several trades bursaries).

UIC (responsible for my support in school, wanted me to repay UIC $120.00 month. They then raised my allowance by $225.00 each month so I would have enough to pay THEM with?!? In an effort to repay THEMSELVES, they ended up giving e an extra $105.00 month in living expenses, that's AFTER taking back their share!

Needless to say, I didn't compain and they indeed did repay themselves and sent me a letter in the mail for me to claim the tax break.

Good government spending! Too bad their own internal politics and red tape cause them these problems, I made money off of it, I just don't see how nobody has seen this within the UIC offices. Mind you, it is rare that the right hand knows what the left is doing when it comes to governments.

The best part, out PM is the first in god knows how many years to alance the budget year after year. Make you realize how much money shifting and hiding really goes on. If they overpay ONE person over $1200.00 year in order to repay themselves, how many other people and thousands get lost this way? How do the books then balance?

I'm sure this isn't the ONLY screw up they make.

by road-dog

Actually, you are the victim of our elected leaders' ill executed attempts to hammer "deadbeat dads".

This is simple bureaucratic incompetence, not fascism.

Here in Florida, they have gone so far as to begin driver's license suspension proceedings 15 days from the first missed payment.

I was laid off from a high paying job in 2001, and my child support payments were $938 / month. My unemployment benefits equaled $1100 / month. (you do the math). Try executing an effective job search without a driver's license because your license suspension begins in 15 days, but a court date for a child support reduction takes 15 MONTHS.

There are no common sense caveats in the system because all parents are treated like the absolute worst among us. Oddly enough, if you are willing to work pud jobs and quit whenever they begin pay garnishment, you can get break after break after break. The system only hampers those who try to play by the rules. The true deadbeats slide by as they always have....

by hal 9000

It is the bureeaucrats who manage to totally screw things up.

I remember not so long ago that there was a saying to really screw things up you required a computer.

Now days the proper way to put that should be If you want something never to work give it to a bureaucrat with a computer and you'll never see any sence ever again.

If it wasn't so serrious it would be a joke I'm revoking you're licence for non-payment of child support because you are unemployed in 15 days and you can appeal this in the court but it will take you 15 months to get a hearing to make amends for you're change in circumstances.

About 40 years ago over here the negelant husband who didn't pay any child support was placed in prision for 2 weeks to let them know the error of their ways when they where realised from prision they promptly walked into the arms of a Balif who served more papers on them for non payment of the last 2 weeks child support and where taken straight to court where they where again sentenced to 2 weeks jail. This would go on in some cases for years and there where many occurances of Magistrates tearing strips of the man for the nonpayment of child support for sometimes periods exceeding 2 years and they where told what a bad parent they where and so on and so on but again the Magistrate would impose a 2 week stay in jail and then 2 weeks latter would see the exact same person on the exact same charge with only the dates being different.

Luckly that is something that has long passed but it does show just how stupid the Law actually is as they could jail a person for nonpayment of child support and after serving their time they where imediatly charged with the same offence but thisd time with different dates.

How any sane person thought that one up is beyond me as obviously if you are in jail you can not pay the bills as you can not work. There was one very well publisied case where the woman shaked up with a very rich guy who was in the top 2% of the income level and then applied to have the husband jailed for non payment of the child support as the only evidence rerquired was the woman saying that she never recieved the money.

Now this guy was jailed for 2.5 years and eventually the Magistrate asked him what was going on as he was sick and tired of constantly placing him in jail for this offence. The person in question told the Magistrate what he had been told but as he had been in the jail he could offer no evidence so the Magistrate sentenced him to the rising of the Court instead of the normal 2 weeks and because the woman did not attend the court case and had not after the first three ocassions she was unpreapered for her ex to burst in with a Police Officer and get the required evidence.

She was even very insistant that the man had excaped from jail and it was the Policeman's duty to take him into custody and return him to the jail. While that ended that guys suffering there where pleanty of others who suffered the same things and it was only with the introduction of the Family Court over here that this was ceased.

Then the Legal Whores got their grubby little hands on the new court and wrecked it as well.

Col

by guruofdos

I nearly wet myself! American English is her second language....she's a New Yorker!

Here's the rub...there ain't much in the way of 'home work' for someone with her skills, or lack of.

Under new UK legislation, all childminders have to be registered with the local authorities. Not only does this mean that they need to be trained and approved, but they need to earn UK minimum wage. As my wife has no qualifications to speak of, she's pretty much restricted to not much above minimum herself. As she says, why work 8 hours to pay a childminder for 8 hours and have perhaps ?5 ($8) left. She had a perfectly good job in a local supermarket, and they are very supportive of new mothers. She COULD in theory work evenings or weekends,but that would mean looking after a baby all day, then having to go to work in the evening. When she first came over, I was working 7 days a week, 8am to 8pm and 9am to 6pm at weekends, PLUS running my own repair shop, and that was no life at all.

We did consider this angle, but the fly in the ointment is my job. I may have to work away at a moments notice and perhaps be away for a few days. Unfortunately, most employers will not accept this situation. They are hardly going to want to keep changing shifts around at perhaps less than a day's notice, especially when they can get part-timers like a dog gets fleas! Besides, it will cost her whatever she makes to tax, insure and fuel a second car.

As soon as GuruJr enters full time education at 5, she will return to work, and her current employers WILL give her a job then. Until then, it looks like it's down to me to cover the bases.

For now, it seems to be pay as much as we can as soon as we can to drop the arrears down to zero. However, within 6 months, she could get British citizenship. To get round the issue of dual nationals having to enter the US on an American passport, then leaving on a British one (and then the immigration service going ballistic because they can't find an entry stamp or IA-94 slip), she will simply go to the US Embassy in London and give up her US citizenship. Not my preferred scenario, but if that's what it takes that's what she'll do!

by oldefar

Direct flight in and out of Toronto or Montreal, and let Bestefar and Bestemor drive over to Canada for a visit.

by guruofdos

Seeing as the 'outlaws' often holiday up near the St Lawrence, which is only a spit from the Canadian Border. I'm sure something could be wangled so that they hop across to visit us.

The downside, is that we'd end up having to shell out for a hire car or taxis and a motel, as opposed to staying at the family homestead for zip, nit, nada and gratis, with a pick up an drop-off from JFK thrown in.

Still, it is a very sensible suggestion and one that is certainly worth considering. To my way of thinking though, I'd rather put the extra money for that option onto the support arrears and knock a month off the delay.

Having found that the waiting time for naturalisation for a married partner of a British Citizen is now down to about 5 months, we are going to go with that angle.

Of course, once she is a British Citizen, the issue of her US passport revocation is irrelevant and so long as she can get a UK passport issued before October 30th this year, there is no need to get a visa...all MR passports issued before 30 October this year from the UK do not need to be biometric. If she can't get one before then, she'll just have to pay the fee at the US Embassy and get a visitors visa.

So now it's a race...pay as much as I can afford each month then go through hoops to get a formal letter from the State Department stating that the arrears are below 5k and the revocation order has been withdrawn (and I won't accept a verbal statement!!!), or see if the British passport arrives first! Either way...six months is do-able!

Every problem has at least one solution, but these usually involve time, money or both. That said, it still doesn't fix the fundamental problem that the regulations on support enforcement within the US have no provision for ex-patriates who are doing their best to comply with 'long-armed' enforcement orders and exceed the court stipulations, but still get caught up in this situation if they want to visit relatives.

Thresa actually has 4 children in the USA...not only the two who have lived with her parents since birth, but two others. One is with the father and we are ordered to pay support for him, and another who is a ward of the State because of mental health problems and we have to pay nominal support for him too.

Yeah I know.....why did I marry a damn foreigner with so much 'previous' and baggage, when I could have found a local girl with no ties?

Love....is why!

by oz_media

Why don't YOU move to America?

apparently everyone wants to live there anyhow, you could take a lower paying job with more competition and be a proud new American.

But then I'd only ended in flame wars with you too. Somehow I don't think you'd take offense as easily though.

OK guys, I'm out, no more Yankee bashng!
(I do feel better though)

by guruofdos

We had a choice...I live there or she lives here.

For me to go there....visa, green card, work permit, 5-6 years of farting around with paperwork and several thousand dollars worth of 'filing fees' before it's all done and dusted. Her needing to earn 125% of the state poverty level for two people to qualify for importing me as a spouse. Her being a single mother at the time (youngest child at the time was with her...now in father's custody since she came to UK). Me only having finalised divorce proceedings and settlements for previous marriage in late 2000. Her being homeless and having no income at the time. Her parents having to 'sponsor me' for ten years if wife cannot. And as they retired last year and need state help (hence us paying support) with the older two children....I think not!

Me having a place to live in the UK, steady job and the fact that a spouses visa costs NOTHING and there is only one simple form to fill in and NO interviews. The fact that as soon as she had the visa, she could work with no restrictions....free NHS medical care, the fact that she could get a UK driving licence after 10 lessons and one test (NY licence revoked years back and not allowed to re-apply for 8 years). The fact that the UK tax and National Insurance system is simple and administered by the employers without having to file tax returns every year. The fact that almost every aspect of day to day life (banking, shopping, utilities, etc.) is so much easier and straightforward here. The fact that the beer here is so much better and that Europe is only 45 minutes away for cheap weekend breaks and cheap ciggys and wine.

Add to that the fact that she hate's the 'American Way' and the 'system' and having visited Britain, fell in love with the place, and I feel that America is OK to visit but I wouldn't want to live there because the 'system' is infinitely more burocratic than ours (which is bad at best!), I think that explains why!

If I lived in NY (or anywhere else in the USA for that matter), it would be a hell of a way to go just for a pint or two of decent cask ale! That's really what swung it!

by 1stladytech

Could you possibly find a way to pay the arrearages down to under $5,000? If the total amount of the arrearages falls below the threshold of the passport confiscation, you should be able to visit and then leave again. I would check this angle out, as it would give you a nearer target date for a visit. If you could get conformation of the reduction in debt, that should clear you at the airport in case the "men in black" haven't gotten thier records updated yet.

Just a thought for a possible work around.

Vickie

by guruofdos

I'm hearing you....legislation states that the arrears ecxeeding $5000 triggers the revocation. Many sites also advise that if this is reduced to below $5000, then the name/SSN is removed from the Passport watch list. Even dropping one cent below the $5000, i.e. leaving an arrears balance of $4999.99 SHOULD be enough. In practice though, this doesn't happen! I checked very carefully and the computer system is automated so that triggering the 5k threshold is instantaneous, but removing the name from the watch list takes two to three months and involves countless letters and phone calls and to-ing and fro-ing between the Support Enforcement Agency, the local court where the order was issued, the State Department and such like. The other problem is very few government departments are able to call long distance, let alone overseas, so we will have to make all the running from this end and spend hours on hold waiting to talk to the right people. Even then, most are reluctant to send mail overseas to addresses outside the US.

Good info, though, and in theory, there's our answer, but in practice, burocracy, red tape and the inability of the US system to integrate with the rest of the world is a major stumbling block!!!

by merchantbanker

I'm a Brit that lives very happily here in the USA (Cedar Rapids, Iowa, since you ask ...) with my American wife. And yes I like it and Americans very much. Well Midwest folks anyway. Mostly. AN d some others. Except hunters. I digress.

Now that said, NEVER in my whole life have I seen and had to deal with SO MANY stupid and pointless pieces of paper. We wanted to borrow a paltry $3000 from OUR bank to buy a vehicle and it took TWO hours and at least 15 signatures plus an insulting lecture from some spotty whelp about 'fiscal responsibility' before we could get out of there. The UK equivalent ? A two minute phone call to the Bank and the money is in your account because it's such a tiny amount they ain't bothered. The reason ? The stupid little tiny regional and local banks that have so little money to play with they treat it like, well I can't think of the right word but you know what I mean. Not that the nationals such as US Bank are much better.

Paperwork. The US obsession if you ask me.

Usually consisting of forms so cramped and cryptic you'd be forgiven for thinking you are supposed to balls them up. Such as ANY US tax form I've ever seen.

It's all a racket I reckon.

PS ... It took a whole year of interviews and paperwork and general poncing about to get my Green card for the US. We lived in the UK for 8 years before coming here. To get my wifes fiancee visa ? 2 hours. The get her UK residency ? One afternoon and my word for it that she'd not be a burdon on the state.

So IT CAN be done, but there is no will from the system here to change anything, just as long as the 'people' don't realise how awful the system is. Any by the way it may be initially cheap to live here, but there is a needless fee for every last bloody thing, so they get the money one way or another.

The great rip-off of the citizens continues apace, as it ever has. But no-one seems to say anything about it ?

Why not folks ?

MB.

This discussion is closed to new replies.