I just found this buried in my Ipaq. As-is, errors and all. Typed up by my wife, Robin.
To whom it may concern,
Tony Dunlap and I have had ?Temporary Legal Custody? of Mackenzie D. Branham, since May 31, 2003.
Kevin Parker is the case worker on Mackenzie?s and her mother, Faith Vaught?s case. Tony and I have tried to help Faith out in many situations, both because of knowing some of her background, and our love of her and her children. For many different reasons, we have thus far had only limited success.
Tony and I have talked many times to Kevin Parker about our concerns. Faith, at times, was uncooperative with us and/or Kevin and Children Services. Tony and I do not debate the disappointments that all of us have seen.
We are here today, not to cast blame, but to sit and discuss the facts . . . of what has been told to Kevin by either myself, Tony, Faith or Anthony . . . to discuss why the process seems to be failing Faith and her children, and how we can work together to make sure it does work in the future.
Tony and I have tried, on a few different occasions, to explain our concerns about Faith?s other children. We were told that there was not an open case. We tried to get a case open. All the accusations and concerns were real . . . we didn?t want to cause anyone any grief . . . we were told some things and seen some things that appeared to be very suspicious, and we wanted them, and still want them checked out for the sake of Faith and especially her children. There is a certain hostility between Judy Carrol and Faith (and everybody who is wanting to help Faith), which needs to be discussed, because it is severely interfering with Faith?s recovery for herself, as well as alienating her other three children from her (and the rest of their family).
Attached is a log documenting the events and efforts that were made by us to address some of our concerns.
5/31/03 (Dates approximate)
We obtained temporary custody of Mackenzie. At the hearing the judge ordered Faith to obtain counseling. We were under the assumption that Kevin Parker, her caseworker, would see to it that she complied with the judge's order.
9/2003
Tony and I talked to Kevin, I asked him, "what was he doing for Faith?", He said, "Nothing" I asked him why? His reply was..."I have Priority cases".. I said, she, (Faith) is pregnant, and living in a garage, Isn't that some kind of Priority? He replied with "well, it depends what the garage looks like, My father has a garage that is an apartment." Later he said "We're not miracle workers." I asked him about the counseling. He said that he had failed Faith and Anthony. I was disturbed by his cavalier attitude, waited until he was done, and tried to get him to help Faith... He explained what his job was, while I felt, as if I was being his supervisor, I told him, some of the things I heard. (from Faith's sister, Sue).. That Faith's daughter Becky age 4 at the time, told her at Sue?s, that her cookie hurt... and told a little of the history I knew about Faith's up bringing, by her maternal grandmother Judith Carrol, and her husband Frank Carrol... although there weren't any charges filed on Frank Carrol by Faith Vaught, her children, by her husband, John David Vaught, were left at the Carrols? home, and Faith had spoke of her concerns, and suspicions to us, and didn't know what to do. Kevin told us, that he would talk to his supervisor, prosecutor, and the sexual abuse investigator, at Children Services, and try to see what they could do. During this conversation Kevin told me that once Faith and Anthony set up housekeeping together, Anthony would also have to follow the plan, counseling, domestic violence classes, etc. Tony and I had left, satisfied that Kevin was really going to do something to ease our fears saying "Let's see if we can pull out a couple of miracles."
10/2003
I dropped off Mackenzie at Children Services for Faith's Supervised Visitation, Sue Branham (Faith?s sister) was with me, Faith came in and said she was cancelling her visit, she was too upset, I followed her out the door, to see what was wrong, Her and Anthony were arguing, He wanted just her to go visit, the baby, because, of his concerns, that Mackenzie didn't know her, and that he would just wait, til she was done, Faith was also upset that Kevin wasn't doing his job, so I said, lets go talk to him, and we did... In that conversation, Faith revealed that there was a locked box of audio cassettes of the sexual abuse, taped by her grandmother. I thought it was a confession of the acts. a few days later, I was talking to Faith, and brought up the tapes, and called them, the confessions... she had corrected me, that, the tapes were of the actual sexual abuse, that she had gone through growing up, and that there were pictures. I called Kevin Shortly after that, and told him, of what I thought, when she revealed this to us, in his office, a couple days earlier. and set the record straight, by telling him, these were tapes of the actual acts. In between the end of September, and Oct 17, 2003, Faith had lost her baby, the baby was born stillborn, there was a funeral. I, again brought up the suspicion of Becky getting sexual abused, and did they have a case open?.. Kevin said, this was the first time he had heard anything about it?... and I tried to refresh his memory, and still he said, he must of missed this... I tried to remind him, of the first time Tony and I visited him, with this allegation, and he said, there would have been something done, if we would of told him... he apologized, saying, that he must of missed this...but that he would get the investigators on this, and talk to his supervisor, the prosecutor and and they would get a case open, I and Faith also discussed with Kevin, that Maybe she could come to our home and babysit Mackenzie, while I worked in the daytime, She then would earn money, and be able to bond with Mackenzie. Kevin said he would get that OK?d, He would send something over to the judge about our proposal and get back to us.
11/01/03
I called Kevin Parker and told him what happend on Halloween night, and said that things had gotten real bad with Faith and Anthony. Earlier that day and leading into the night, I and Tony had tried to get Faith and Anthony to go to the Crisis Center. we tried until 10:00 pm. Faith called and said that she would come over to our house so that I could take her out to the center. I didn't want Faith to come to the house to babysit, and I explained our reasons. Halloween, (earlier that day) Sue, Stephanie, and I) tried to talk to Faith for hours. She was upset at Anthony. We got her calmed down until Anthony came to our house. They argued. I tried talking to them. They were blaming each other for different things, and in that conversation Anthony had revealed the time that Faith had locked the baby in her car-seat outside in the cold (before Tony and I received custody). In turn, Faith revealed that the reason that Anthony and her were arguing is that he had talked about he and a friend "bumping off" a liquor store. Because of this, I asked Kevin to stop the paper he was sending to the judge about the babysitting at our house and lifting the unsupervised visitation. He told me to inform him if Faith went to the Crisis Center.
Kevin told me that Teresa Reeves was the sexual abuse investigator. I later told Miss Reeves about the things that Faith told Kevin and I about the locked box and the history of the abuse that Faith went through growing up. Miss Reeves told me to tell Faith that she could go to the Crisis Center and they would have a Deputy Sheriff come out and have her swear out a statement about the locked box and they would get a search warrant. Later Faith came to our house. I told her about the conversation I had with Kevin. She got angry... saying that was the one thing she was looking forward to. I told her that I had to tell Kevin about what had happened the night before because she and Anthony had told me stories that gave me concern for Mackenzie's safety and "where they were at" because of Anthony's statement about planning to rob a liquor store that I couldn't rightfully say everything was OK after hearing what they told me the night before. Faith felt very betrayed by me and got angry like the way she was the night before. I told her to leave... or come into the house and talk to me like she had some sense. She came in... still spinning out of control with her anger... and words were exchanged. I then called Tony at work and told him to come home. There was more arguing... and Tony told her to leave.
I called Kevin to see if Tony and I could have an emergency meeting with him to discuss what had happened earlier in the day. He said he had a meeting to go to, and also that he would try to intercept the request to the judge. I told Kevin that there was no more we could do for Faith. He said it was a shame that it turned out this way, because he had just done a home inspection a couple of days before and it checked out... that they were like " the Cleavers". Supervised visits at Children's Services remained.
12/15/03
Faith had her first counseling appointment.
12/25/03
Christmas wasn?t bad.
2/07/04
Sue related to me a message from her mother, Debra, that Judy wasn't bringing the kids in for the baby's birthday party because of "that bitch" (referring to me).
2/08/04
Faith and Anthony were coming over at 2:00 to help decorate for Mackenzie's party. Faith was upset because she didn't have any money to get the baby a card. We gave her a little money so she could get a card, and she calmed down. Tony's ex-wife Sharon (Faith's aunt) called Judy and asked if she could come and get the kids (we had invited Sharon and her boyfriend, Roy, to the party) and Judy said no. Sharon told her if she changed her mind she would be at home for awhile (Sharon called and told Stephanie, Tony's daughter, all this). Everybody asked Tony to call Judy and ask. She again said no, that she didn't want to leave the kids here alone, and he told her she was invited too... that we had plenty of food as well as cake and ice cream, but she said no again, and said it was because Anthony was going to be there. The party was supposed to begin at 4:00. Around 3:45 I was taking a shower. At 4:00 I got out of the shower, Stephanie waited until I got dressed, then told me what her grandmother said to her... that she can't bring the kids down, and it's not because of Robin, but because of Anthony.
At about 4:20 Judy called and said she was coming with the kids. Most of the people were in the kitchen when Judy came into the foyer. Faith told Anthony to get up to go hide and I told him to sit back down... that he didn't have to hide... that it was going to be OK. Judy acted as if she had just stepped into a spider web. I greeted her and asked her if she wanted some coffee. Tension was a little high considering that these kids had been kept away for so long and for so many reasons. The kids were happy to be there and happy to be seeing everybody. I was finally able to have Judy come into the kitchen to get herself something to eat. Faith and the others went into the living room. Tony and I sat and talked to Judy for awhile... I gave Mackenzie to Judy to hold while I cleaned out her high-chair and we chatted with Judy for awhile... when Judy told Tony about the possibility of Frank, her husband, having cancer... and also told Tony "You remember how mean he used to be... well... he's going back to that." The kids were getting restless, so we all went into the living room to open presents.
After opening the presents we went back to the kitchen to serve the cake and ice cream. Judy knew that Anthony was there... everyone was happy and having a good time, when I heard Faith yell from the hallway "You don't care?" and I went to the hallway and saw Faith and Judy standing and arguing and I told Judy "You're not going to do this." (meaning starting trouble) and she said "You don't tell me what I'm going to do" and I went into the living room and told Sharon "She's your mother... do something with her" and Sharon subdued her mother, telling her "Don't do this here!" I was angry so I went into the living room to calm down... Roy, Sharon's boyfriend, and John, Debra's boyfriend, took all the kids into the baby's bedroom (in the back of the house) because of all the arguing among the adults.
I tried to calm Faith (and everyone else) down and Faith told me that Judy had grabbed Becky out of Anthony's arms and in the process knocked Mackenzie down and when Faith told Judy she knocked the baby down and Judy said "I don't care." Judy went into the living room and started arguing with Debra and Sharon (her daughters) and Faith. I told Judy "Please STOP!, we just wanted to have a birthday party. We got the kids calmed down, and were getting them cake and ice cream, when Samantha said to me "I don't want to go home with grandma, I'll get ?whupped?. I want to stay here." She also repeated this to her grandmother Debra, her aunt Sue, and other people who were at the party.
Faith wanted to call the police because Judy had knocked down the baby, and Judy just went off yelling and screaming and shoving people around and the kids were getting very upset and Tony called the police because someone needed to get Judy under control. The police came (officer Netter, officer Onny, and officer Buchanan) and Tony told the officers to get this woman (Judy) out of his house. We (Tony, Faith and I) were telling officers Buchanan and Netter what happened and Judy was talking with officer Onny. Judy then wanted to leave with the kids and I said I didn't think it was a good idea because of Judy's state of mind and the kids' fearfulness... that the kids could stay here for now and we would contact children's services in the morning. Judy said she had custody of those children and Tony and Faith both said at the same time "No she doesn't" and I then asked the officer to please verify that. Officer Buchanan went outside and called Children's Services to see if Judy had custody that she claimed to have had, and the police found out that she had no custody papers, and that there was no open case on those children. The officers said that as far as they knew, their mother had custody, so they asked Judy to leave with out the children.
Then Judy asked one of the officers if she could say goodbye to the children and Faith said yes, but only if an officer was a witness to it. Faith and I stood in the foyer with Officers Buchanan and Onny standing just outside the door with the door open. Faith called the girls downstairs to say goodbye to their grandmother. They didn?t want to talk to her and they ran back upstairs. Judy was outside hugging Jonathan and saying ?Remember... This is all your mother?s doing...? and one of the officers chastised her saying ?Alright Judy, that?s enough?. Judy left.
After she left, I saw how upset Jonathan was, and I asked Tony and Sue to go into my bedroom with me and Jonathan so I could talk to him. Sue sat on the bed with Jonathan, and I told him everything was going to be OK... that he wasn?t in trouble... that his grandmother and grandfather weren?t in any trouble... that everything was going to be worked out. Jonathan then went and played with the other kids. Sue and I talked to all of the kids a little later when Faith and Anthony went to get them some clothes. Jonathan asked if he was going to see his grandma again. I said yes... your grandmother and grandfather... and that things would get worked out but that they would stay here tonight with their mommy. They watched TV for awhile and went to sleep.
2/09/03
I called Kevin around 8:00 am to discuss what had happened the night before. Kevin said he had John Vaught (the father of the older kids) in his office and he continued to blast me (I couldn?t understand half of what he was saying and he wouldn?t let me explain). He said ?I?m sending Mr. Vaught to get his kids. Do I need to send the police with him or do I need to come with him?? and I said ?No, there will be no problems?. I asked him ?Can I explain?? and he said ?I don?t want to hear what happened.? I hung up, John David came over and got the kids, and Faith was trying to talk to him... to tell him about the abuse from Frank Carrol, and John David said ?He?s old... he can?t do that no more.?