[i]We are hard wired to [u]BELIEVE[/u] whatever is stamped into our minds.
A few months back I argued the case for value investment and asset protection.
I referenced scientific studies that didn't support technical analysis
or market timing. Some people strongly objected to my conclusions, but
nobody addressed the question of my evidence.
Similarly, over the years I've written and spoken extensively about
individual liberty, and found myself puzzled when I couldn't
convert followers of socialism, communism, or any other forms
of big government to the principles of individual freedom and personal responsibility.
Once again, all this, in spite of historical evidence.
I've puzzled over this phenomenon throughout my life.
Arguments for a free-market fail to sway those who believe in
government intervention. Evidence for Darwinian evolution
fails to convince believers in religion. And studies showing
the random nature of price movements fail to sway believers in
technical analysis.
It seems that evolution has endowed us all with wiring that
demands we support whatever beliefs that have been "stamped"
into our brains. This has been demonstrated by a recent
research study at Emory University in Atlanta, a study that
has potentially wide implications, from politics to religion
to investments.
The investigators used functional magnetic-resonance imaging
(fMRI) to study a group of committed Democrats and Republicans
during the three months prior to the last U.S. Presidential
election. The Democrats and Republicans were asked to evaluate
threatening information about their own candidate while
undergoing fMRI to see which parts of their brains were
activated.
As reported by Emory, "...the partisans were given 18 sets of
stimuli, six each regarding President George W. Bush, his
challenger, Senator John Kerry, and politically neutral male
control figures such as actor Tom Hanks. For each set of
stimuli, partisans first read a statement from the target
(Bush or Kerry), followed by a second statement that
documented a clear contradiction between the target's words
and deeds, generally suggesting that the candidate was
dishonest or pandering. Next, partisans were asked to consider
the discrepancy, and then to rate the extent to which the
person's words and deeds were contradictory."
Drew Westen, director of clinical psychology at Emory who led
the study, said: "We did not see any increased activation of
the parts of the brain normally engaged during reasoning, What
we saw instead was a network of emotion circuits lighting up,
including circuits hypothesized to be involved in regulating
emotion, and circuits known to be involved in resolving
conflicts."
In other words, in most cases, no amount of logic interferes
with our strongly-held beliefs. The brain automatically
rationalizes discrepancies in facts to support our beliefs.
Evidence that contradicts our beliefs fails to reach the
dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain most
associated with reasoning (as well as conscious efforts to
suppress emotion). The finding suggests that the
emotion-driven processes that lead to biased judgments occur
outside of conscious awareness.
Do you and I succumb to emotionally-biased judgments when we
have a vested interest in supporting our beliefs? Only when we
find ourselves resisting the evidence. Success in life tends
to be proportional to our willingness to examine the evidence.
H. L. Mencken observed: "The most common of all follies is to
believe passionately in the palpably not true." Beliefs, at
least false beliefs, are an impediment to us all.
Or, as Mark Twain put it, "It ain't what you don't know that
gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so."
As well, Sportin' Life in Porgy and Bess put it, "It ain't necessarily so........"
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
[i]Edited for spelling and punctuation errors[/i]