Justification for receiving a laptop instead of a desktop
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
I directed a project for a very large (100,000+ staff)
multinational where there were no desktops anywhere except for
specialist departments that required intensive processing power
that had to be justified. Everyone had a laptop and a dock. The
time saved in internal meetings where everyone could share
documents electonically was an offset against the additional
cost. There was also the advantage of communications between
different time-zones where one side was at work and the other
was at home. With laptops in universal use, connection
protocols and processes had to be simplified - thus magnifying
the advantages even more.
by geraldkiii
by dkerta
I have the same situation, finally decide to develop a draft policy but it still open some lack of personal justification. At least, my boss see the general condition to accomodate Laptop request, and in case the presure is to hard my boss will be able to say - "hey, this is policy from the IT manager. If you don't happy with my justification, talk to my IT manager"
Entitlement policy:
1. Working environment required the employee to move from one location to another location or travell often.
2. Employee need to create/update/change company information propery: to support system infomration remotely to ensure the business process run as expected.
3. Employee need to representing the company on customer site with a standard technology presentation.
Also, I am preparing Laptop check-in/check-out mechanism in case there's a request temporary to borrow a laptop.
The other challenge I have is defining Laptop specification base on users working behaviour. I have splited into 3 category:
1. Standard, multi media 14" screen
2. Moderate, Multi media 15" screen, extra USB
3. Advance, multi media, extra USB and finger print
by aliabdoh
Well, it seems there are many factors affecting the decisoin:
Mostly, here are the main:
1- Cost
2- Support
3- Security
In all cases, company needs to assign standards to implement each
Now there are some questions might appear?
-cost-
1- Does the company reduce the support & increase the security when it buys computers? or that could be accomplished by implementing the standards anyway?
-support-
2- Suppose computers are owned by employess, and in case their machines have problems like office or what ever, how network administrators or technical supports should deal with them? as an outside customer, and might charge them, or as an employees in the company with free charges?
-Security-
If company alternated computers' budget with remoting servers & remoting software[citrix], with best network performance and security supports, does this consider better or worse than applying that on computers in case it has bought them?
Regards..
Ali
1. Road Warrior
2. Executive or other important person who travels / works a lot at all hours of the night.
Otherwise, we keep a few older laptops for the "check-out" crowd who needs one while they're travelling for work or have to head down the road to do a presentation.
Otherwise, for the average employee, a laptop is a luxury that'll sooner or later get lost, stolen, abused, broken, infected. Too many risks, very little return. I've seen my share of company laptops clogged up with spyware, games for their kids, etc... where it was clear that their dire "need" for a laptop was nothing more than a status symbol or personal playtoy.
I had a laptop at my last job and while it was nice, it was a pain in the ass in that I had to lug the damn thing around everywhere I went (we couldn't leave laptops at work). I'm a network administrator (soon to be manager) and I have a desktop.
If I need to work at home, I just VPN in and remote desktop to my work PC. If I need to hit the road, I bring along my $250 eBay used laptop and VPN/remote desktop to work or home so if that gets FUBAR'ed, I'm only out $250 and not $2,500.
Besides, I've had my share of 10:00 PM calls from someone at a hotel 10 states away trying to check their e-mail and they can't get the network connection at their hotel room working and they expect me to fix it.
I appreciate that laptops can increase productivity for certain employees... but you must also consider applicable labor laws in your area (is someone working from home on the clock and entitled to overtime?), security risks, and the level of support required to get someone up and running when they're away from the mothership and can't get an IP address for any one of many reasons.
If you have someone burning the midnight oil at home, set them up with VPN that's easy for the average Joe to install and have them access their work PC via remote desktop / terminal services / Citrix... or even allow them to connect to their work PC via something like GoToMyPC, LogMeIn, etc. These services can be centrally managed and leave your network less exposed to the exploits of a clueless employee who happened to leave his logon credentials on the back of the business card in the laptop case that was stolen from the airport while he went to get a cup of coffee from the Starbucks kiosk.
by rdpeters
then think again.
I have MANAGED projects of hundreds of people, each with laptops, each with secure data on their machines. They were responsible individuals, they logged millions of airline miles, and they did business with reputable individuals like themselves.
Like me, their productivity and job satisfaction far outweighed the costs necessary to do business in this fashion, and we were able to use Mobile I/T technology as a competitive and strategic advantage to our firm. The cost of such security and administration was factored into our decision-making capability at the highest levels of the corporation.
I/T had a job to do -- protect us from our sins -- but they were NOT expected to editorialize and gripe about doing it! Their job was SUPPORT -- not to be the tail that wagged the dog!
And yes -- I've experienced both the conditions you've noted -- from the I/T perspective, the User perspective (I did it myself), and from the Corporate Management Perspective. I deeply respect the work of our specialists who support the "warfighters" of our corporate "armies" -- but let's keep the roles straight, shall we?
by aliabdoh
.... Continue on Computer Removing
Well, it seems there are many factors affecting the decisoin:
Mostly, here are the main:
1- Cost
2- Support
3- Security
In all cases, company needs to assign standards to implement each to accomplish the best
Now there are some questions might appear?
-Cost-
1- Does the company reduce the support & increase the security when it buys computers? or that could be accomplished by implementing the standards anyway?
-Support-
2- Suppose computers are owned by employess, and in case their machines have problems like office or what ever, how network administrators or technical supports should deal with them? as an outside customer, and might charge them, or as an employees in the company with free charges?
-Security-
3- If company alternated computers' budget with remoting servers & remoting software[citrix], with best network performance and security supports, does this consider better or worse than applying that on computers in case it has bought them?
Regards..
by tkerber
by mharris672
Excellent comments...In today's business environment, fewer people are constantly required to do more work. Commuting and working from home are almost a necessity. As a Training Manager, I can work round-the-clock, and still remain behind on numerous projects. Utilizing a flash drive (1GB) just isn't enough. I need access to everything...whenever I'm out of my office. Laptops with docking stations should be increasingly implemented. Security practices can be maintained...and people can be held accountable.
M.H.
Try exploring the use of VMWare Workstation. You can create an image of a laptop in a VM, preset for the user's needs and things like VPN, put the VM and the VMWare program on a DVD with an installer for them. That way they can take the DVD home, run the installer, and have a virtual laptop running on their own computer which is locked down, never needs transit, can be restored with a simple reinstall, and patch management and virus updates can go out on RW CDs. The bust out retail for VMWare is 300, much cheaper than a laptop, and you'll have overall lower maintenance costs plus no capital expenditure as with hardware.
It doesn't fit all users of course. And any remote solution should also include a user system fire wall that has server based rules like McAfee's. That way you can control if they're running programs on the basis of being connected to the network...having access to a centrally managed file share.
That will allow you to lock down the remote desktop you're using, which is kind of a big hole in your firewall.
Present management with the idea, I know they don't want to spend anything, but the expense of making a bad decision is really ugly....you can't control what they have on their personal equipement and if just one of them gets something like sql slammer and it jumps the remote connection...well you can imagine the impact financially.
Demian
This situation always comes up at company, as well and I always looked at the travel requirements for each user and determined that if they travel less than 30% of the time then it's not worth the investment. I even have cases where certain directors have laptops just because the president does, but they sit on their desk when they're out of the office. These are the cases they drive network administrators/managers crazy because the technology is not being utilized properly, especially for someone that travel 75% of the time. Go figure!!!
Doug Smith
IT Coordinator
PRS Pharmacy Services
by 1ieengle
by zfwilliamson
We've done this at our company and I think it'll work for you:
We remote access via VPN and Remote Desktop Connection to a local server. Every employee has a personal drive space mapped to any computer they log into. This is done for security reasons as well as business reasons. A benefit of remoting in and letting a server do the 'work' is that you don't have to use a brand-spanking-new machine. We have several laptops that are too old to issue (Win2k boxes) that work perfectly for this work. Have had no complaints from Management or Personell and our job is much easier.
I agree with those who say that Laptop users should not be a Local Administrator. However, it's something you will have to decide based on the level of your network security and remote abilities. All you need is to have a user out of town for a week and discover on Day 1 they (or you) forgot something and there's not a darn thing you can do about it!
by abarnes70
Here is a copy of the 'Laptop Determination Policy' I drafted a couple of months ago. It was later signed off by my management, which was a good thing, and they seem to be going to bat with it so far.
Aim
The aim of this policy is to provide a framework for the determination of hardware procurement for users; specifically, to assist management in deciding whether a user should receive a laptop or desktop computer.
The decision to purchase a laptop computer over a desktop computer should remain with the business, in particular the manager of the intended user. However, this policy aims to provide the information necessary to make that decision.
Desktop vs Laptop Computers
Desktop computers, generally speaking, are faster, easier to maintain and support, and have a greater realistic longevity than a laptop of equivalent price. They have greater upgrade prospects and are a much lower risk of loss or theft.
Laptop computers, on the other hand, are certainly more convenient owing to their mobility, but that mobility comes at a price; components such as hard disks that are made to be smaller and lighter are necessarily slower as a result. They are also more expensive than equivalent desktop computers due to the following tangibles and intangibles:
larger initial capital investment
additional investment for peripherals and accessories (docking stations, bags, extra power adapters etc)
extended warranty (if purchased) is more expensive than for an equivalent desktop
each laptop has to be added to the business insurance policy
shorter realistic life span requires more frequent purchasing
higher level of support
longer downtime for an equivalent repair
greater risk of theft
greater risk of sensitive data being exposed
Convenience
In many cases where it would be more convenient for a user to be able to take work home, the optimal solution would be the purchase of a desktop computer to be installed in the home of the user, perhaps at a pro-rated sharing of cost between the user and the business.
The prime requisite for the purchase of a laptop should be the amount of travel or working off-site (i.e. out of the office and not at home) a given user will undertake throughout the life of that laptop. For example, a user who visits other businesses or patients regularly would be a good candidate, as would a user who spends weeks away at a time while travelling.
Recommendation
It is the recommendation of this policy that a user could qualify as a laptop user by spending more than days working away from the office per year, or who visits other business or patients off-site more than five (5) times per month.
by demroyer
Thanks for sending along these guidelines! The document I crafted for my company is very similar to this (and was based on a lot of suggestions from this discussion thread), so it's nice to be able to compare it to another existing policy.
Here is a copy of the "Laptop Eligibility Requirements" document I submitted (the formatting is probably off-kilter, but you get the idea):
This document outlines the various scenarios that would justify the need for a laptop PC rather than a desktop PC. Ideally, employees should meet at least one or more of these criteria in order to be eligible for a laptop. These eligibility requirements have been compiled from various IT best practice documents, as well as advice from other IT professionals.
1. Travel ? If an employee is required to travel on a regular basis for business or routinely performs work off-site. Please note, the term ?off-site? refers to public locations or other businesses, not working from home.
2. Telecommuting ? If an employee is set up as a telecommuter (i.e. working out of their home on a permanent basis).
3. After Hours Support ? If an employee is required to provide regular after hours support that may need to be performed either at home or on the road.
4. Disaster Recovery Responsibilities ? If an employee is required to maintain data or applications on their primary computer so that they could function as an offsite ?disaster recovery? system.
5. Technology Requirement ? If an employee has a special technology need that can only be fulfilled by a laptop (i.e. a technician that has to directly connect to devices on a factory floor, a salesman who has to give public presentations, a user who requires Tablet technology, etc.)
In order to apply for a laptop, an employee must first receive approval from their direct manager, who is responsible for ensuring that the employee has a genuine business need for a laptop. In addition, the IT manager must sign off on the purchase to ensure that the purchase falls within the hardware budget and meets the eligibility requirements. Once approved, the IT department will purchase a laptop appropriate for the user?s specific needs, and will configure the laptop for use.
Please note, the Company has purchased a number of ?loaner? laptops which can be checked out by employees for temporary use. In addition, several dedicated laptops are used by the rotating on-call technical staff when providing after hours support.
For more information about deciding on whether a laptop is an appropriate choice, please read the following excerpt from a trade magazine article which defines some of the pros and cons of laptops:
The Pros And Cons Of Laptops
There are an increasing number of people who now work out of the office, are on the move or travel a lot. The market for laptops has been steadily growing and is likely to continue. However, while notebook PCs look good and can be convenient, you might get better value from investing in a desktop PC. Consider the following Pros and Cons before deciding what type of computer to buy.
Cons
Notebook PCs are generally more expensive
Whilst they have come down in price, they are still significantly more expensive, if you want reasonable power and memory.
Notebooks generally have a shorter life cycle
Desktop PCs have comparably fewer malfunctions and performance issues over their lifecycle.
Notebook PCs are more prone to theft or breakage
There are serious security issues associated with carrying a laptop around. Leave it alone for a few seconds and it's gone. Also, it's easy to drop or throw it carelessly in the car. Warranties have improved but they will probably not cover simple slips, let alone habitual carelessness.
Notebook PCs generally require more complex support
Due to the fact that notebooks often need to connect to multiple network environments (like the office, home, hotel, etc.), have varying hardware profiles (docked, undocked, wired, wireless, removable drives, etc.), and are frequently away from the corporate network during normal after-hours maintenance windows, notebooks tend to cause higher support and training overhead than a desktop PC.
If you work with graphics and digital media, a notebook PC may not be the best option
Desktop PCs will generally have higher speed and power for the same dollar value.
By this stage, you're probably thinking it's not worth buying a laptop. But there are number of reasons that you might consider buying a laptop over a desktop PC.
Pros
Portability is a huge advantage
The ability to leave the office early, finish a project at home, complete a presentation on the airplane or in the hotel room and check emails and schedules remotely can save you time and money.
Notebook PCs have come down in price and you are getting more for your money
Average prices have been significantly lowered in the last few years and many commercial models now have better features, such as higher processor speed, more RAM and hard disk space. They have also improved in terms of weight and screen size.
Wireless advancements have improved network access for people on the move
Through wireless PC Cards, laptops can more easily connect to internal networks, anywhere, anytime. For example, a major announcement can be sent from a hotel room to every user in your company.
Notebooks can easily be used both in and out of the office
Many people are now choosing to use their laptop both in and out of the office and laptops can easily be connected to a larger monitor or keyboard, depending on your needs.
Compared with Desktop PCs, the configurations for Notebooks are almost the same, as well as the processor speeds and graphic capabilities. If you need all your information and work at your fingertips whilst you are on the move, a Laptop is the way to go. You could pay a little extra, but then again, you might be leaving the office early!
by jsamuelson
Personally I would find it a bit strange if management asked me to create the criteria for mobile computing approval. If it were me, I would do the following:
-Provide documentation on which laptop would be best suited for which department, with pricing based on the maximum number of units.
-Provide documentation on infrastructure to accomodate secure roaming and remote network access (VPN, WAP, added security measures, etc.)
-Provide overall cost analysis, including pros and cons.
Is management asking you for advice on whether or not they should approve laptop requests, and for whom? It would seem more appropriate to me to help them by providing the tools necessary to make that decision. Personally I feel the only reason to deploy laptops is the need for mobility, but in today's world more companies are deploying work-from-home strategies, so perhaps this is an opportunity for you to help your company to join in this future of mobile computing?
-john
1. MUST be a travelling user;
2. MUST either be a VIP Manager or a Senior Manager; mid-class and first-level managers not to have a laptop;
3. In case of engineers going to vessels, this can be provided only if the vessel is not the same Company you worked with.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending