Discussion Locked

Light is Shed on Middle east

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

On the news last night Many Mideast countries are calling fowl about the Iraq/US war. They say that this isn't lawfull because the UN didn't approve. Talk about hypocritical, they didn't mention the same phrase when they were trying to overrun Israel during 1971 War.

Also not mentioned is that the Palestinians were traitors in Jordan and either fled or were kicked out of the country. But because Arafat (another ruthless Dictator who bleeds the wealth of his people)is trying to Steal Israel's land, though mass murder of civilians is not complained about.

The Arab countries have a fall guy to try to get the wealth of Israel's real wealth, Its food. It grows more food than any othe nation in the world. It only produces 5% of the worldsoil. It is the bread basket of the world, and that's why Russia is working behind the scenes to topple them. France and Germany are no better because they now cannot have arms sales to Iraq. This is only an opinion on my part but have you noticed that the God of the Arabs is mad at us and Israel. But the God of Israel and the U.S. are blessing our countries while there God seems to have abandon them? Makes a person wonder whose religion is true and whose is false. Since actions speak louder than words. Remember the Olympics terrorism, the plane Hijackings, the So called suicide bombings, the Twin Towers massacre, the torture chambers of Iraq, the hostages of Mohamar Kadafi of Libia. Was this done in love and Peace? We will continue to fight to prevent this insane greed under the guise of true? religion? GOD Bless America and God bless the peacemakers.

53 replies

by john_wills

"been there" is guilty of anti-Semitic bigotry. It has usually been the Zionists who have started hostilities, most notably in 1903, 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1982. In particular, the Israeli state is keeping large numbers of people away from their private property on the grounds of nationality and religion, i.e. because the Palestinians, besides being the first Jewish nation, were the first Christian nation. The Israeli state's economic success is based on U.S. subisdies of ca. $3m/day. But during the 19th and early 20th Century the sub-province of Palestine, with its successful agriculture, was the economic underpinning of the Ottoman province of Syria. What the Palestinians would have achieved if the Zionists had left them in peace is a matter for "parallel world" fiction, but it would have been something great. On the side, Arafat was democratically elected, and some of his family property has been stolen by the Israelis for expansion of the Wailing Wall area. Let us have no more bigotry, let us get our facts right, and let us not misunderstand the religious issues.

by road-dog

Now please shed a little light on what you mean.

1903, 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1982

Israel wasn't a country in 1903
I assume that with 1982, you cite the Israeli strike on Iraq's nuclear reactor (osirak)

Please describe:
-Zionist, by your definition
-What Zionist Aggressions occurred in the years you cite
-How disagreeing with you constitutes bigotry

by john_wills

Zionism is the movement commonly so called, the activities and aims of a series of leaders from David Alroy to David Ben-Gurion and beyond with the foundation and pereptuation of the Israeli state and the concommitant perpetration of the Nakba.
In 1903 the World Zionist Congress definitively decided to dispossess the Palestinians. Herzl was in favor of accepting a British government offer of the then uninhabited Uasin Gishu in East Africa, but Weissmann tore the map of East Africa from the wall and won the vote in the Congress.
In 1948 the UN partitioned mandated Palestine between an Arab state and a Jewish state, withe the provision that no-one would lose civil or political rights from being on the side of the partition assigned to the other group. The Zionists started mass expulsion of Christians and Moslems even before the partiton date and on the partition date, following their "Plan Daleth", invaded the territory assigned to the "Arab State", expelling people and twice breakingtruces to dispossess more people.
In 1956 the Zionists tried to complete the Nakba by attacking the teeny independent part of Palestine, i.e. the Gaza Strip, the West Bank and Egypt.
In 1967 there was a succesful reprise of the 1956 attempt.
In 1982 the Zionists invaded Lebanon to massacre and disperse the Palestinians living there.
I have not said that anyone disagreeing with me is a bigot. What I have written in this screed is not opinion but verifiable history. I am willing to learn of some evil done by the Palestinians justifying the 1903 decision.

by jim phelps

I thought this was "TECH" republic, not "POLITICS" republic! Please, let's keep the politics out of this web site. I don't want that kind of thing to overrun a very valuable web site.

by jackofalltech

and you don't know history.

The area that most people today call Palestine was nothing but a wasteland inhabited by nomad tribes until it was given BACK to the Jews in 1948. At that time the Israelis BEGGED the locals to stay and help them rebuild the land.

Another thing to consider is that the 'Palestinians' DO have a land of their own - Jordan. Unfortunately, it was taken over by another mad Sheik and HE refused to allow refugees from Israel in.

'Palestinians' are neither Jewish nor Christian, if they were they would live in peace with their neighbors when at all possible as the Bible teaches.

Ralph

by john_wills

Palestine was one of the most prosperous parts of the Ottoman Empire.
It was NOT given BACK to the Jews: it was partly given in sovereignty to to people who had no historical rights there except that the Palestinians had once been of the religion the newcomers claimed to be. The israelis have no national historical right in Palestine.
Any blow-by-blow account will tell you that the Israelis were expellling Christians and Moslems even before Partition. There were massacres of some villages, and these massacres were publicized in the hope of frightening the others out.
A large proportion of Palestinians are Christian. Palestinians were the first Christian nation and, before that, the first Jewish nation. They are willing to live in peace, but the Israelis keep them in exile, insist on holding the already stolen land, and keep on stealing yet more land.

by john_wills

On second thoughts I can do more than correct facts: I think that rdschaefer's understanding rests on two doctrines. Firstly, he believes that the promises God made to Israel in the Bible were made to a nation; secondly he believes that the Israelisare the national descendants of the Biblical Israelites. Now, Israel did grow to a great nation(Hebrew: goy) in Egypt, but on passing Sinai it ceased to be a nation (Nm 23:9), remaining a church. My book Albatross 0-595-19418-4 goes into this a little further. For the second matter, the Israelis are of various national origins, but their ancestral conversions to a branch of the religion of Israel mostly occurred long after Bible times. The national descendants of the Biblical Israelites are thePalestinians, the first majority-Jewish nation and the first (ca. CE 200) majority-Christian nation. With these two misconceptions corrected I think rdschaefer will be able to restate his position.

by jkaras

I hate all the God pointing that this God or that God is better, true, or right. Religion is based on faith for the region that people populate. It's there to guide people to act civilized to one another as a set of moral rules to abide by, its a schame that no one plays the game correctly. I believe that there is a God and whatever his name is, color or gender doesnt matter. God doesnt have an ego, man does and masqurades as God told me this or that for justification, it's about impowerment and continuing the security of the survival of said religion from fading from existence like all the others that were replaced. The problem with the middle east is that's where it has been documented where life started as well as where God walked the Earth. They will never give up the fight to the right of that land believing that they are the chosen one from God and await his return that God will favor them more than any other race ect.. is the absurdity that cant be corrected. This blind hatred will destroy the world where life started, ironic huh?

by admin

you are talking about God"

My theology professor told us that first day in Theo101.

I have found it to be quite true. :)

by road-dog

Israel is not the breadbasket of the world, the U.S. is. The US produces more tonnage of food total and in many crops, more food per acre than any other nation on earth. Export data shows this.

You assert that Russia wishes to topple Israel because of their food production. Why and how are they attempting to do so? Arming the Arabs is not the answer, as they sell arms to anybody with the US dollars to buy them.

I agree that Islam seems to have two faces, one purporting to be a religion ofpeace, the other ordering followers to kill, rape, enslave, and steal in the name of Allah. I am disappointed in mainstream Islam's failure to denounce extreme Islam in any clear and firm way.

The creation of Israel and the expansion of Israel in the last 50 years might justify the Intifada but not the suicide bombings. I believe that if Israel were to withdraw from "palestine", the terrorism would not stop, as the palestinian homeland is simply a justification for hostilities for most Arabs.

Personally, I'd like to see a Palestinian homeland created on the borders set at the creation of Israel. When the acts of war continue then this palestine would be revealed as the terrorist run joke that it is and the palestinian authority branded as a terrorist group, instead of the object of sympathy that it is.

by admin

that would take place after solidifying said borders, I do think this is the only good solution. Do it this way and police these borders militarily with U.S. or COW forces and I think we would see a much more clear picture.
Of course, Jerusalem would need to remain open and divided amoung the 3 major world faiths acknowledging Yaweh as well IMO.

I think this would make it more clear to us and the world what needs to be done in the region and that although initially it may not bring peace (in fact it mnay bring initial turmoil), that the entire region would settle down in time more with this action than any other.

by road-dog

This is my master plan, I have no illusions that it has greater than zero chance of actually being implemented:

The city of Jerusalem is declared a nation in it's own right, using land from adjoining territories for a 20 mile radius from the center of town. The country is administered by a council of representatives of each faith, Christian, Muslim, and Hebrew, appointed in the method of choice for each faith to accomodate sub faiths.

Jerusalem is considered a soverign nation, and no new construction or residence is allowed, other than for maintenance and operation of the city as a large religious site. An International University is created and administered where faculty are representative of all faiths, and all students are treatedas equals under the eyes of God, by whatever name.

Any attack on Jerusalem is considered an act of war on all countries.

Visitors, tourists, and pilgrims are treated as guests in the eyes of the governing council and all citizens of any nation in the world are welcome, limited by visa.

The council will also administer and share ownership of any archaeological finds and sites. Funding this effort is paid for by visitor taxes and no funds are distributed back to any other nations, beingused only to maintain the city as a historic and theologically important site.

City security is carried out under the control of the council, an equal number of police from each faith. Any transgressor who is convicted of misusing historic sites is banned for life from entering the city, under death penalty for return.

Well, it's my dream.

by john_wills

The Zionists have never accepted the partition as more than a temporary measure. Neither have the Palestinians for that matter. But if there were two independent states living in peace in the Holy Land the Christians and Moslems dispossessed in the Nakba could return to their property in the 1948 territories of the Israeli site, frustrating the Zionist purpose in expelling them. Fairly soon there would be a majority in both states voting for a single state in the Holy Land, and the Zionist dream would be over. So the Israelis will not, without credible threat of U.S. aid, make peace with the Palestinians.

by madroxxx

That suicide bombings may be the only way to fight back that the palestinians have. Isreal rolls in with U.S. tanks and Helicoptors and Guns and decimates them every chance they get. America provides 10 Billion dollars in weapons aid to isreal everyyear. That 10 Billion for a country with something like 6 million people. That is nuts.

by admin

Yaweh or the the Mispronounciation that became accepted -Jehovah or the "letters which cannot be named" all refer to the exact same God all coming from Adam, Abraham and Moses to the Jewish, Christian, and Muslim faiths.

Theologians, leaders and historians of religion in all these faiths can attest to this, although it has not commonly been disseminated broadly to the believers.

by john_wills

Brought up a Christian, I was told from early days that the Moslems were my fellow-worshippers of the One True God. I was also told that I was among the true spiritual descendants of the Biblical Israelites because I practised their religion, messianically transformed by Jesus of Nazareth, whereas modern Rabbinical Jews were my premessianic brothers. I got the idea that the Pakistanis must be right about Kashmir because their opponents were polytheists, that the Somalis were particularly noble among Black Africans, etc. I certainly was aware of a great commonality of religion.

My more mature learning has not changed this view of the religions in question, although I can now give more details.

by jereg

Aside from this being a technical site, you play pretty loose with the facts. The US produces more food than any other country. Start with that fact, get rid of your bigotry, and try to learn some more FACTS.

Or don't, stew in your hatred. It's so much easier.

by jkaras

This just in,... apparently my friend called to report that we found weapons grade plutonium in Iraq!!!! Ihope this isnt sensationalism, but trust we got the regime by the short hairs.

by admin

I'd vote for your plan if it ever came up. Heck, I'd even go and help if I could be of any use :)

by john_wills

A better solution, I submit, is the erection of 3 Vatican-style microstates in Jerusalem: Zion City State up agains the Wailing Wall for the presently non-existent Chief Rabbinate of All Israel; Holy Sepulchre City State; a trilocal statelet for thepresently non-existent Supreme Mufti of Sunni Islam with one locus on the Temple Mount. This distinguishes the confessional claims from the Zionist and Palestinians claims, making both easier to handle.

by road-dog

Was to force these 3 faiths together and make them work together to administer the city. If they fail to do so, then Jerusalem would become the perfect example of the failure of all faiths due to the hubris of men.

I have no real definable faithexcept in the ability of men to create religions to get in the way of the work of God.

I cannot help but believe that a supreme being really cares if we eat meat on Fridays, be home before sunset on Saturdays, or eat pork on any day.

These constant killings and other atrocities in the name of God must make him wish that Noah's family didn't make it on the Ark in time.

by oldefar

A search on the referenced information seems to lead only to either Palestinian sponsored or Israeli sponsored sites. Each has its own biased interpretation of the events that took place leading to the creation of Israel.

On a side note, discarding the Mandate of 1903 and the other work done by the League of Nations not only elminates the legitimacy of Israel, but eliminates Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Lebannon, Iraq, etc. I believe these areas would revert to Turkish territory. Of course, we could step back a bit further and turn the whole area over to Greek control, or further back still and put Italy in charge.

On the other hand, we could acknowledge a long history of conquest and theft has led to the current world state, withno clean hands left anywhere, and move forward from where we are. A beginning is the recognition that individuals have a right to exist, and that among us still are those who would choose to enslave others for personal gain. If I treat those I deal from a basic position of fairness, and expect others to do the same towards me, those of us who respect others far outnumber those who do not and we can oppose them together.

by mrafrohead

I find it absolutely humorous that there is all of this talk regarding religion and this god and that god.
The reason that I find this humorous is for this reason. This thread is discussing violence and religion.
Those two words should NEVER be together in the same sentence.
Personally, I'm not a very religous person at all. I question it quite a bit. I do believe that there's a God. But I don't know if it's the same one that every one else believes in. I can say that it's not the god that's in the Bible. I tried to read the bible once. It's a joke. It's beyond Satanic. I was never able to make it past the first book. It goes against EVERYTHING that I was raised to believe.
And I find that funny as Bible Thumpers will justifyit. "Well you have to take it with a grain of salt and read past this and read past that." I disagree, it says what it says. And it means what it means. There's no prettying up the words to make them say what you WANT to hear.
As for Muslims, Jews, and other religions out there that are more than I can honestly name right now - I think that we're all trying to praise the same person. So why in the hell are we all fighting with each other??? It makes no sense.
All this Jihad rubbish. Come on. You can't get pissed off at someone and then kill them in the name of God. It doesn't work that way. WHat ever happened to love they neighbor? What about Though shalt not kill???
All of this convenience BS is just rediculous. If you actively practise a religion, you can't just temporarily stop and do what you want just because it's convenient at the time.
I think we all need to get off our asses, buck up and start to figure out a way to get along. We're ALL the same here. We ALL bleed the same blood. Supposedly we all came from the same source. So if we're all that close, why can't we all just get along???
Mrafrohead
But again, just my opinion... ;p

by jkaras

I've seen most of your postings in the past and we tend to share the same view points. I too am not religious despite having been raised in private schools most of my education and having a Jesuit priest in the family but I still believe that has tobe a God, it's too coincidental that we exist whereas no other world can. The Bible, Koran, Torah..etc... all guides for moral behavior to follow. These were incorporated into the various societies due to people changing religions like changing clothes appeasing to hedonistic desires by people needing absolution of actions. As time went on people noticed the difference that these religions posed as false or silly. As time went on with government pressure many faded from existence, this is wherereligious people got their fear of dying religion if the word wasnt spread, or poputated. This brought about all the wars that grew hatred to ensure the prolification of said religion, if the word doesnt spread it cant continue. Unfortunately peopleabused the voice of reason pushing belief either through harrassment or war. People's fear of the unknown causes irrational behavior that religious leaders stroke to keep their flock growing and under control. The middle eastern people fear the change that our government plans to do to their way of life. Women are going to gain power, abuse will be outlawed, ect... that will contradict their social structure, that we will tempt them with a higher lifestyle vs. keepin faith so to speak. Freedom has a price, they might not be ready to pay it. Lastly the average person isnt well educated to make own decisions and trust elders following their hatred. Think if you listened to an old racist relative never questioning due to fear, would you ever question it?

by jkaras

to quote Burt Reynolds..lol. I just have been monitoring the threads reading the rediculous postings from our new crackpot, welcome, feel free to post crazy ideas to entertain us. I have studied religion due to private school but dont have the technical knowledge of the true history of the region to offer concrete rebuttles. I dont know if he's just stirring the pot or off his rocker. As for his Albatross book (appropriately named) posting we didnt know about his book till he pointd it out, so it still wont sell any copies after his threads, thankfully. Did anybody find it humorous that our troops were equipped with the regime playing cards? Is it wrong to want a copy of these? I can image the ebay bidding wars that the former troops will make from it or will the government sell these to raise money for our struggling economy? If every American bought 1 deck at $5.00 imagine what money we could generate to combat AIDS or whatever? . I'll admit it was rather brilliant to familliarize (correct spelling?) the troops with this tactic due to the most probable entertainment game for the troops during downtime. I cant wait for the complete collector set including Russia, Germany, and France, lmao. Can you imagine raising your hand with this idea a a war council hoping not to get laughed at?
Lastly how bout that Syria?

by john_wills

The Palestinians were the first majority-Jewish nation. At the beginning of the Common Era Judaism split into on the one hand Christianity, which recruited from both Jewry and the Samaritans, and on the other hand Rabbinical Judaism. The Palestinians were majority-Christian by 200 CE, and stayed that way for centuries. Could it be that that is the reason some Rabbinical Jews have picked them for dispossession?

by road-dog

of this. I saw the Palestinians dancing in the streets when 9-1-1 happened. I watch the news and see Palestinians crowing about the setbacks in the Iraq war. I hear the Palestinians whining that the US isn't doing anything for them, but when we shutdown a despot who has killed more arabs and Muslims than the Israelis have, we are still the bad guy.

If our flag is burned in the streets regularly over there, why should we give a crap when the homes of suicide bombers get bulldozed? Why shouldwe care that a Palestinian stupid enough to throw a rock at an Israeli with a rifle gets shot?

OK, so there is a lot of history there, almost none of which had ANYTHING to do with the US. If the Palestinians are still pissed about events 2000 years ago, why should we bother to involve ourselves in any way.

Don't give me any crap about military aid to Israel, we give more aid to Arab nations than we do Israel. Our humanitarian aid to Palestine is more than what the Saudi Arabians give each year. Saddam only donates to the families of "martyrs" not to feed them and give them hope for a better life.

Thanks for the historical references, I discounted most of it as totally subjective and anti-Israel. Please connect all of this to the interest of the US.

by admin

But I still can't get over the fact really that we all need to realize that the whole path of trying to return the earth to it's rightful owners is absolutely impossible. Which owners at which time and why should they even get it? We have to work with what we have, unless we want to go back and find the Anasazi then ask them who was here before and give up the US of A, give Britain back to the original folk (who again no longer exist) as well as those in Australia, Easter Island,
Mexico and even before, yes, the Palestinians there were different humans.

We can't go back. Time is Linear, get on with it.

by maecuff

I'm spending a little unproductive time reading through all these posts and really didn't feel the need to join, reading was enough..until reading the Jesus Christ message. I come from a family and married into a family who beleive fervently in Jesus Christ, and you know, they STILL have the same issues and problems us skeptics, or god forbid, non-believers have.

by road-dog

Political discussion threads are symptomatic of great interest in current events. We can always pursue the Certification Vs. College debate after the war.

we technical folks do have things that we feel are important and need articulation that arenot technical in nature.

Roll with the flow, this too shall pass.

by mallardtooxx

Besides, those of us who are embroiled in these debates are still answering the questions of those of you who are not so if we can do both then you can do more than look at the hot discussions page. Have a shot of windex and chill, things will always be addressed, just not in the order you might like. That is our choice, not yours.

-duck

by john_wills

The U.S. funds the Israeli state with $3m/day. The Palestinians and other Arabs know this, and they do not understand what they have done to merit U.S. hatred of this kind. The U.S. gives far more military aid to the Israeli state than to all the Arab states combined - indeed, for a long time more than half the U.S. foreign-aid budget went to the Israelis. The U.S., as for a long time the greatest and now the sole superpower, would be hated even if it did nothing but good; to the Palestinians it has in fact done tremendous wrong - or can you name some Palestinian wrong which justifies Zionism?. During the cold war the USSR gave Cuba $1m/day. Which of the U.S. and the USSR was getting the better deal? The U.S. funding of the form of anti-Semitism known as Zionism seems quite gratuitous.

by road-dog

then so be it. Israel is the closest thing we have to an ally in the middle east. They are the only real and functioning Democracy in the middle east.

Go ahead an spew your vitriol all you like, world opinion has not turned in the favor of the Palestinians for a very good reason. We know that Hamas and other groups will not stop terrorism until Israel is destroyed. Syria has done nothing to stop them, and their work is evident in the current conditions in Beirut.

Israel has a right to security, if it takes occupation of the West Bank and Gaza in perpetuity, then so be it. Palestine is a wasteland. Until Palestinians sprout balls and deal with the terrorists and quit celebrating every bombing, it will continue to be one. If other Arab nations gave a damn, they would be providing real aid and assistance, instead of checks for martyrs. If the Saudis gave a damn about palestine, they could invest in a future for Palestinians.

They don't to any real degree because they make a great outlet for externalizing Arabs' blame for their squalid existance under the horrific backwardness of their governments.

Instead they let their hatred for Israel blind them to the obvious solution of coexistence.

Keep looking for zionists behind every rock and tree, you will find them....whether they exist or not....

Palestinians will get their homeland only when they decide that they love their children more than they hate Jews.

by john_wills

The Palestinians are not occupying any private property of Israelis. A very large part of the 1948 territories is the private property of Palestinians kept in exile. The Israelis have no right to security of that property, and it is only because they hang on to the stolen property and continue to steal more that they are in danger. Of course, justice might mean the end of the Israeli dream, whatever that is, but justice comes before dreams. The Palestinians have a right to security, and the Israelis have been violating that right since 1948.

by madroxxx

"Don't give me any crap about military aid to Israel, we give more aid to Arab nations than we do Israel."

Wrong - we give isreal about 10 billion a year in weapons.

by admin

In 2001 the US government approved phasing out civilian assistance to Israel by 2008 and increase proportionately military assistance.

We are going forward according to this schedule which should hit 2.4 billion by 2008. One of the conditions is that a high
% must be spent on US defense products, so we get a lot back. I don't think this has changed, and is really a shift from the old mixed civilian\military position, not new aid.

Another issue that comes up is related to the Cranston Amendment (which may have never been and is not currently an issue) and has to do with the many forgiven loan guarantees. If you count in how much in loans we have forgiven it raises the aid amount.

Additionally there are other dollars under dispute. Like the DOD joint defense projects for the Lavi Attack Fighter and the Arrow Missile projects. It has never been clear whether the US is really interested in projects such as these or using them as a primary way to divert income.

There are morethings I'm sure, but it really depends on how strict your interpretation of aid is IMO.

I think it is safe to say that we do support Israel a great deal in the region, and that we send additional dollars there in some form beyond this one package. They, in turn, send some of it back plus additional funds to us and in a sense, support us back to some extent.

Anyway, the US\Israel relationship monetarily is complex, but then there isn't much about that area that isn't complex.

by jackofalltech

What Semi-Parallel Dimension Are You From? The people lately referred to as palestinians have never been Jewish nor Christian. If you insist on attempting to foist this delusion on the rest of us, I can provide reams of historical references refuting all of your points.

Ralph

by john_wills

I know as a historical fact, aand you can confirm for yourself, that the Palestinians are the national descendants of the Biblical Israelites. At the beginning of the Common Era they were majority-Jewish, with a lot of Samaritans too. During the first two centuries of the Common Era they became majority-Christian. There are continuing institutions, notably churches, from the beginning of Christianity until today. I do not know when they became majority-Muslim, presumably in the Middle Ages. About 20% of the Palestinians are still Christian, and over half of the Galileans. There are both Orthodox and Catholic bishops of several rites in Jerusalem, and their sees go back centuries. You cannot refute this, because it is true. If you rebut it you will make a fool of yourself, because anyone reading consecutive history of the Holy Land - e.g. the relevant part of a good encyclopaedia -can confirm what I have written.

by mallardtooxx

His damned book. Man get a publicist and leave us alone, you are not enriching anything here, you are offering no real content, you simply cannot stand to see that your veiws, while somewhat askew, can be refuted by anyone. On several occasions I have seen you spouting the same line, In my Book Albatross blah blah blah, hell I am more inclined to believe Colin luck has a PHD than I am any of the drivel you are spouting off here, and that is almost insulting colin. Get over it, you have been refuted and rebuffed time and time again and I tire of having to wade through your posts to get to the rest of the real posts. I think ralph is right here, go back to Ork, mork misses his right hand man, maybe Alf can give you a ride when his 10-10-220 gig is up.

-duck

by john_wills

My previous posting consists of verifiable facts. Not only are they not refuted, they are not even rebutted. And my previous posting contained no reference to my book Albatross, which you so kindly mention, because the book sode not go into the matters discussed in that posting.

by hal 9000

Even when I have nothing to do with this one. The only coment that I have here is that there are certinally Christian Churches in the area that go back a very long time and some claim to have been started long before 400 AD which is about the time Rome became Christian.

However having mentioned that I still don't see the point in this whole dissuccion. It seems to me to be an ever tighting sprial turning in upon itself.

by john_wills

There exists an Israeli state. Every state has the purpose of securing such God-given rights as those to life, to liberty and to property. The Israeli state is therefore obliged to allow the exiles home and to restore their property, arranging that the beneficiaries of the dispossession pay back rent with interest for the time the owners have been kept away from their property. The Palestinian nation does not need a national state, let alone an independent state - the division of humanity into states at various levels is a matter of convenience, not principle - but its members do need a state to secure their rights; the state which actually has power over them, however, is violating their rights.

by john_wills

My previous posting did not carry on properly from what you had written. I agree that trying to restore national or ecclesiastical sovereignty is normally pointless. Private human rights are a different matter, though, and if the Israeli state were to stop violating the rights of Palestinians, notably their property rights, Palestinian anger would probably die down pretty quickly. There was calm for a while after the Oslo accords, but the Israelis, instead of restoring sstolen land, proceded tosteal yet more, leading to the Second Intifada. Of course, respect for human rights would transform Israeli society - more than a third of the inhabitants of the 1948 territories would be Christian or Muslim - but doing the right things usually leads to transformation for the better, even if we cannot at first see how.

by road-dog

stolen property and territory annexed by war. You love to extoll the virtues of the helpless Palestinians and completely fail to acknowledge the aggression of Egypt, Jordan, Palestine, and Syria in 1948 and other times since. The need for a securityzone between these aggressor nations and Israel is justifiable to any not blinded by antisemitism as you are.

As I pointed out earlier, The emblem of the Palestinian Authority shows a map with the entire land of Israel. They have no intention of stopping with the creation of a homeland and ending the occupation. Their end goal is the destruction of Israel. Why should Israel acknowledge the rights of those who do not acknowledge Israel's right to exist.

Yasser Arafat was elected by Palestinians and they know what the Palestinian Authority stands for. He is not a statesman, he is a terrorist.

by lordinfidel

i'm not prude or anything....

but TR is really not the right place to be airing out religious views.

It's one thing to spew out the political crap with the war going on. it's to be expected right now. Albeit it pushes the "PC" envelope for this site.

I know many of you are religious and stuff. But this is not the place for it.

Sorry (which I don't say very often) if I offend some of my colleagues who are religious. But I am sure you will agree that there is a time and a place for everthing, and this is not the place.

by jardinier

please feel free to visit my website www.thinking-seriously.com

All comments are most welcome. But please email your views directly to me from the website, as I am also tired of Techrepublic being used as a forum for political and religious discussions.

Julian Hancock.

by jackofalltech

I agree that this is not the proper venue for arguing over anything. As I've said before in other posts, intelligent debate, exchanging FACTS and offering opinions stated as such is healthy. But it is the duty of everyone to refute lies and revisionism wherever they occur on whatever topic.

Ralph

by road-dog

are getting a lot of play lately because it interests a lot of us.

If these threads do not interest you, ignore them and jump in on others.

This discussion is closed to new replies.