Discussion Locked

Louisiana Leaders - The epitome of incompetence and corruption

0 helpful
91 replies

91 replies

by av .

Lousiana officials should have bused people out. They should have had food and water and facilities at the Astrodome to accommodate that number of people they put there if there was a castastrophe. They didn't. FEMA didn't respond quickly enough. What about the weather predictions? Shoulda, coulda, woulda.

This catastrophe really was the ultimate test of how ready we are for the world we face today. We failed miserably.

If there is anything that really jumps out at me it is this - how prepared am I personally to deal with a storm or catastrophe like that. Where should I go in the event of a disaster? What should I do? Its obvious to me that our government won't be there when disaster strikes for even the basics. Its up to me.

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "If there is anything that really jumps out at me it is this - how prepared am I personally to deal with a storm or catastrophe like that."

That's the key. Everyone should assume that they're on their own if a major disaster strikes. Just like the police department really does more to respond to crime rather than prevent crime, at least for the most part, the same should be assumed with anything. Some disasters just can't be prevented, and/or accurately predicted, and/or adequately responded to. And to expect as much is being unrealistic.

I could load my gas guzzling pick-up with the bare necessities, including vital documents, and we could literally be "outta' here" in probably 15 minutes (including 20+ gallons of extra gasoline). We also have several possible destinations in several different directions that we've actually discussed and planned -- or no destination at all. We could probably live in the mountains or out in the middle of nowhere for a month or more if we had to.

I just can't comprehend how a person can be comfortable living his or her life believing that he or she is dependent on anyone else for anything at all. Now that's not to say I would expect a "free for all", ignoring anyone else who might need assistance. But just like in an airline emergency, put the oxygen mask on yourself first, or else you won't be around to help anyone else. The key to being inter-dependent with each other is being able to be independent yourself first.

by jmgarvin

1) Where was the National Guard? They were standing by, but never deployed.

2) Why weren't people forced to evacuate?

3) Why were their buses standing buy at the Superdome, but never used?

4) Why did it take two national agencies (FEMA and "Homeland Security", three state agencies (NG, Police, FD), and a gaggle of reporters to figure out what was going on?

5) How hard is it to get bottled water from point A to point B? Jeez...

by stress junkie

... young children and babies not having water for five days when they were in an evacuation shelter. That really bothers me.

The fact that the city officials didn't evacuate the people without personal transportation is also troubling. I heard the mayor of New Orleans say that he didn't have any responsibility in the way that the situation was handled before the hurricane struck because of the magnitude of the storm. He wants to say that the Federal government was completely responsible for evacuating people who don't own cars. That doesn't make any sense. The city and state government failed as miserably before the storm hit as the Federal government failed after the storm.

All of this reflects the way that many business managers fail to address disaster recovery in their own jobs. People tend to say that such a disaster is so unlikely that they will risk being unprepared. That really bugs me. This disaster reflects the irresponsible attitudes of management in both business and in government that is prevalent in American culture. When a disaster actually occurs the consequences are much worse than they would have been if managers had done their job in advance, planned ahead, and put resources in place to mitigate the damage.

by jdclyde

Ok, lets assume for a minute that it is the governments job to bus these people out on the chance the storm hits their town.

Question, where do they go? Is the government now responsible to put these evacuated people up somewhere while they wait for the storm to blow over? Where do they put them all? Where would the money come from to house 20 to 40 thousand people? Then to feed them? Sorry, the govenment can't just make a CITY to throw these people in until the storm is over. This wasn't a few hundred people.

by itgirli

The biggest thing that I don't get is why the mayor called for a forced evacuation yesterday (Sept. 7th it was to go into effect), yet didn't decide to do this before the hurricane or even after the hurricane but before the flooding. He ordered a mandatory evacuation and then made sure he was on every news channel. Now he's blaming everyone else and ordering a forced evacuation. too little too late.
At a nursing home they have found 30 dead. Before the hurricane, that nursing home had been offered two buses, but the owner turned them down. When the hurricane was on top of them, the owner asked for help. too late.
These people need to look around them if they want to blame people. They need to blame themselves for not getting out of there by any means necessary. They have dead bodies floating by them and they still won't leave. The answer, my friends, is blowing in the wind.... and it reeks of stupidity.

by jdclyde

Ok, you have two busses to get people out. Out to where?

Why didn't family members come get them out of there when there was an evacuation called for? Their own family let them down as much as anybody did.

by jdclyde

How in our free society do you force people out of their homes on the CHANCE something might happen?

If this forced evacuation had occured and the levies didn't break, where do you think the ACLU would be? Up one side and own the other about the "police state" that Bush has turned the country into, that is where.

The recommendation was out to get out of town.

There were warnings from the mayor of New Orleans to the people that stayed to stock up on food and water, but to NOT store it on the first floor in case of major flooding. He even took it a step further to tell people to have an axe or saw in case they had to cut a hole in their roof to excape the rising waters.

People were warned, but just like the 9/11 tragedy, no one believed it could happen to them. It did.

THAT is why so many people died, not because of government inaction.

Maybe the next time someone says "get out", people will get out.

NOTE: now that they ARE doing forced evacuations, there are STILL fools that are refusing to leave. You can't save everybody, and you can't MAKE someone save themselves. After all this and they still won't leave. What are the chances the people would have left on the CHANCE that the storm would hit them?

Remember also, they DIDN'T know exactly where the storm would hit land at.

As for the after the fact stuff, I don't have an answer except that like Max said you can't expect the government to act quickly to take care of you. You have to take care of yourself, first by removing yourself from harms way.

by m_a_r_k

As the hurricane approached, the mayors should have been talking to their respective state about mobilizing help ASAP if needed after the storm blasted through. In turn, the governors should have been in contact with the feds to get everyone prepared. Double-checking on assistance plans may have helped a lot of agencies get mobilized ahead of time. Did all these officials wait until after the levee broke to start screaming for help? Did they expect the feds to jump in even before the locals said they needed help? First we all want less government, now we suddenly want more government. If you don't want to help yourself, what gives you the right to crawl to the national government asking for a handout? On another note, I lost all respect for Mayor Nagin after he got on the radio and screamed and sweared at the feds for being slow to respond. That was pretty immature and not very professional.

by jdclyde

of trying to save his own job by deflecting the blame on the fedreal government.

It is very fashionable these days and everyone is doing it. Great fun, you should try it.

by m_a_r_k

Old Ben said "God helps those who help themselves." I have no idea what God does do or doesn't do, but I think Benny boy had some good advice. I'm too stubborn and independent to blame someone else or to take a free handout. I got laid off a few yrs ago. I felt guilty about applying for my unemployment compensation. Seemed like a waste of money. Why give me $1000 a month instead of making me find a menial job that pays the same? It is an incentive not to work. Just like the authorities in the hurricane areas, maybe we've come to expect too much from the federal govt and everyone gets lazy. Assume the feds will be there to back you up, so why prepare on your own?

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "In turn, the governors should have been in contact with the feds to get everyone prepared."

Yes, indeed. But the Louisiana governor did just the opposite.

The following is an excerpt from a cut-and-pasted news story:
Though her state has been devastated by Hurricane Katrina and thousands are believed dead in New Orleans, Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Blanco has refused to allow the federal government to take control of evacuation efforts.

Shortly before midnight Friday, the Bush administration sent her a proposed legal memorandum asking her to request a federal takeover of the evacuation of New Orleans, the Washington Post reported in Sunday editions.

Gov. Blanco's office rejected the request, the paper said - concerned that such a move would be comparable to a federal declaration of martial law.
The Louisiana Democrat had also failed to use more than a hundred school buses parked near the Superdome to transport stranded citizens who didn't have the means to obey earlier evacuation orders.

After the 17th Street Levee broke on Tuesday, the buses were rendered useless by rising flood waters.

State and federal officials also told the Post that Gov. Blanco did not reach out to a multi-state mutual aid compact for assistance until Wednesday - more than 24 hours after New Orleans descended into chaos.

by jdclyde

ruining a good Anti-Bush smear with facts again.

What could be going through your head?

How will the rest of the world blame Bush and the Republicans if they find out that it was a Democrat that caused the delays instead?

Well, I guess the Bush Bashing was fun for them while it lasted? Or is it over? Never let FACTS get in the way of a good Bash!

Will just have to see if this raises up in the general media or not.

by itgirli

Anywhere outside of New Orleans would have been a start. Maybe the old people didn't have family. Anywhere is better than a nursing home with 30 dead people left to decompose.

by jdclyde

to no where?

Is that the best solution you can come up with to a problem that hadn't happened yet?

These people would have to be moved SOMEWHERE, or someone else would be complaining now about these poor people on this bus with no were to go.

Real solutions are not as simple as "the government should have come in with a bunch of busses."

Tell me EXACTLY what they would do with these people that were evacuated. And remember, there was no disaster yet, just the CHANCE that the storm MIGHT hit land where they are and then MIGHT do a lot of damage.

Where do you put 20 thousand people?

by itgirli

I could tell you, but it wouldn't be pretty! (hahaha)
I would put old people, women and children in schools that were not in the path of the hurricane.
I've evacutated many times. I head inland to stay with family. I'm one of the lucky ones who has been through quite a few hurricanes and never been so much as scratched. Isabel came through here and I evacuated. Took my son to a festival in PA in the mean time. Came back the next week and my house was the only one on the block that didn't have a tree fall on it or have any of my trees fall. We didn't have power for a month, but we got through it a lot better than most people in the area did. We still have people that haven't recovered from Isabel (trees still down on property and houses still being rebuilt) and that was a category 1 that hit 2 years ago this very week.

by jdclyde

I am a victom, come take care of me. We have been hearing that for so long, it is just sad that finally some people ARE victoms.

I feel no guilt in collecting the unenjoyment checks, as I used that time to go back to school AND this is something that is paid into WHILE I was working. This isn't some unearned handout. But your point is why there are time limits for how long you can recieve the benifits because many DO prefer to get money for nothing (get your chicks for free).

The same thing is true about workmans comp. Many companies will have you come in on restricted duty doing almost nothing to keep you from getting used to sleeping in and still getting your check.

by m_a_r_k

I forgot that part of my salary compensation actually goes into the unemployment insurance pool. So I guess I was getting my own money paid back to me. Now I don't feel so guilty anymore. Thanks for the reminder. By the same token, I now feel much better about having 13% of my salary being dumped into the Social Security fund.

by jdclyde

my work here is done! :)

While yes, there are often abuses of the systems, there is NOTHING wrong with getting YOUR unenjoyment money to get you through.

I will actually wait a month before looking for the next job so I can catch up on things around the house that you are always too busy to do. After than, back to the grinding stone. It has been about nine years though since the last time I was laid off, and it is never a good feeling.

by m_a_r_k

Are you advocating letting all the menfolk die in the hurricane? I'm not sure putting anyone in schools would have been such a good idea in New Orleans. The flood waters weren't very discriminatory. They washed over schools as wells as dog houses. Besides that, you wouldn't have enough room in schools to pack all those people inside. In NO alone, it would have been over 300,00 even if you did force all the men to fend for themselves. My solution for NO would be to build a dome over the whole damn city. Call it the SuperSuperDome. That will protect them from wind, rain and floods.

by jmgarvin

It doesn't matter where. You can split them up into groups of 5 or 10 thousand.

The state government foots the bill for food and lodging for a couple days and if the worst happens than that is when the feds step in.

What happened here is the mayor and govenor KNEW that there were major issues and that the city was in big trouble, yet they blame the feds for not doing anything. No food or water was planned for, no training was done in the NG for a flood or hurricane, and there was very little if any support by the govenor in assisting.

Where was the distaster plan?

This was total and complete failure of disaster planning. It isn't hard to ship water out. I've done it and I can tell you a few thousand lister bags and a few million gallons aren't that hard to come up with.

by itgirli

You can bus the men out too..... if you want to...
And I wrote "schools not in the path of the hurricane" meaning schools in a more inland part of the state.
Besides, in disasters it is always women and children first, followed by the elderly, then the men folk because they are so robust!

by m_a_r_k

It might be kinda fun to look into the eye of a huuricane and see who blinks first. The other menfolk can catch the bus out of town if they wanna live the rest of their lives being known as a chicken. For your "stuff them in school theory", you won't know which schools are in the path of the storm. You'd have to ship 'em about a hundred miles inland to get some measure of safety that you're not gonna kill 2000 people when their schoolhouse gets washed into the ocean. If the damn space shuttles were usable flying machines, we could send everyone to the moon to wait out the storm. I'd even forsake my life's desire of staring down a hurricane for that.

by stress junkie

"Where do they go?"
That is what the mayor and state governor were supposed to figure out before the storm hit. They had to deal with this question during and after the storm anyway. Why not put in some time before the emergency to plan for this question?

"Is the government responsible ... to put these people up somewhere ...?"
Yes. Again, they have had to deal with this issue during and after the storm. Why not plan ahead?

"Where do they put them all? Where would the money come from?"
Same thing. They are dealing with those questions now. Why not deal with the questions in advance?

In summary all of your objections revolve around the government not being responsible. However the government has accepted the responsibility to handle all of these problems. The only unresolved question is why they didn't adequately plan ahead.

Self reliance is a fine thing and I support it. There are times that we should expect to take care of ourselves but there are also times that we should expect the government to assist us.

by jdclyde

is like staring down a tornado.

It isn't the wind that kills you, it is everything IN the wind that tears you to shreads.

Haven't you ever seen a peice of straw driven about two inches into a tree? Or a poker card driven into the side of a house?

THAT is why they say to take cover in a ditch or low lying area, so the crap getting thrown around by the wind doesn't get you.

by itgirli

I don't leave for tropical storms and usually sit outside and watch them (sometimes you got to hold on), but any hurricanes that they expect to do some damage, I'm getting the heck out of dodge.

by maxwell edison

.
FEMA is GIVING a debit card with a $2,000 limit to everyone who has been displaced or effected by the hurricane and/or the incompetent New Orleans and Louisiana political machine.

- Everyone, meaning no means test, from the very poor to the very wealthy, will get this debit card.

- Some of these people will undoubtedly tuck the debit card into their wallets, right next to their Platinum American Express Card, perhaps using it later to refuel their 100 foot yachts.

- Some of these people have never even seen a debit card before.

- Talk about potential for fraud, abuse and misuse, this is dripping with it.

- These people are scattered around a dozen, or more, states. There is no "plan", at least not that I've seen associated with it, to verify anything about those who might "claim" to have been displaced.

- I might venture to guess that the displaced population of New Orleans might grow from 500,000 to 1,000,000 in a very short time.

- If this applies to people from Mississippi and Alabama as well, let's multiply the fallout from this debacle by a factor of three.

$2,000 x 500,000 = 1 billion dollars x 3 = 3 billion dollars in VERY UNWISE spending, money that could have been spent more efficiently. But government efficiency has always been an oxymoron; and the bigger the government, the bigger the inefficiencies, and the bigger the morons.

This is just another example of "throwing money at a problem" that will ultimately be nothing but an exercise in gross inefficiency, unfairness, fraud and wide-spread abuse.

by jdclyde

It will do a few things. The people giving OUR money away will be able to feel good because THEY helped these people out.

It will BUY a lot of forgiveness.

And is this per person, or per household? I never did hear that part.

Where is all the money that the red cross has recieved? Wonder when we will start hearing about the same type of horror stories about the red cross money like we did after 9/11 and the money was not getting dispersed.

by stress junkie

As you say you only need to remember the way that the American Red Cross decided to sideline money donated for the 9/11 relief effort to find reason not to trust them. At the time they said that the money would be used for other emergencies. I believe that the money was eventually turned into salaries for the top level management at the American Red Cross. I believe that they are a bunch of stinking thieves.

by m_a_r_k

The only fools who willingly and gleefully stare down hurricanes are the idiotic TV news reporters. Last week one of them even proclaimed to the world on live TV how dangerous and precarious his situation was as he was being buffetted by winds and pelted by flying pieces of sheet metal. But of course it was his duty as a professional news idiot to portray the news as realistically as possible. I only pay attention to them for the comic relief and in the hopes of the off-chance that once of them will get blasted on live TV by a brick that is being hurtled at them at 100 mph.

by maxwell edison

.
But on the "Anti-Bush smear", have you noticed that it's subsided over the last couple of days, with much less smearing than was going on last weekend? Or is it just me?

And do you see who's getting RAVE reviews? TEXAS! The despised state of TEXAS! Home of George W. Bush AND Karl Rove. They must want to throw-up saying good things about TEXAS.

But there's still a lot of time for them to misrepresent things so they can continue their lame attempts to simply advance their political agenda. It's becoming more and more transparent every day, don't you think?

I think the truth is really starting to get out, and the Bush smearing will be relegated only to the most radical of the radical partisans -- the MoveOn.org crowd, the Nancy Pelosi and Charles Wrangle type partisans, Howard "the screamin' duck" Dean, and, of course, Jessie Jackson and his merry band of rainbow lunatics, who look for any excuse to play the race-game, the only way for them to justify their miserable existence.

by jck

Bush is president...he is ultimately responsible.

Chertoff - Homeland Security Secretary - appointed by Bush.

Brown - Director of FEMA - reports to Chertoff - former college roommate of last FEMA director that "left" the Bush administration.

All Republicans, or people who were put in place by Republicans, who are ultimately responsible for the safety of our country and response to natural or man-made disasters.

Dunno...maybe they'll find a registered democrat pump maintenance worker in New Orleans who misspelled Bush and fire him?

Can't see your logic, jdclyde. When it comes down to it, FEMA didn't respond fast enough. And, they can't say they didn't know a hurricane was coming because it hit Florida before it went in the gulf....and it's their job to watch out for natural disasters.

I can't imagine FEMA doesn't get weather alerts of possible catastrophic weather from the National Weather Service, National Hurricane Center, or the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

Anyways...someone will be held responsible and fired. Won't be Dubya tho.

by maxwell edison

.
You, just as any other partisan, will blame Bush for everything. Do you have any pimples on your butt for which you can blame Bush as well?

But keep it up, your own words, when compared to the facts, will show the lack of credibility they hold.

"Responsibility", in times if crisis, as you said, is first held by local governments, then state governments, and lastly the federal government. To suggest the opposite order is showing your ignorance.

Who took responsibility for the 9-11 crisis in New York, as it pertained to rescue efforts and such? I seem to remember a local mayor named Rudy. And yes, he asked for, and received, federal help. But when Bush asked the governor of Louisiana take the necessary steps to secure such help, she refused. She refused!

And you blame Bush?

By the way, are you a founding member of MoveOn.org?

by jck

Let's take a practical, apolitical look at this:

When President Bush declares a Federal State of Emergency, he takes right to override local and state authority and take control of dealing with the situation for which the declaration is made.

According to foxnews.com:

===================
Bush Declares State of Emergency
Sunday, August 28, 2005

CRAWFORD, Texas ? President Bush declared a state of emergency in Louisiana on Saturday because of the approach of Hurricane Katrina and his spokesman urged residents along the coast to heed authorities' advice to evacuate.

===========================

So on the 27th of August, Bush declared a Federal State of Emergency for Louisiana. At this point, he was empowered to command FEMA to begin disaster-related efforts.

However in an interview with Katie Couric on NBC's today show, FEMA Director Michael "Brownie" Brown, told Couric they weren't informed about the disaster and all the people affected for 2 days *after* the hurricane hit, which was August 31st.

Evidently, George Bush failed either to directly communicate to his FEMA director that he was empowered to go in and deal with the emergency, or Chertoff (Homeland Security head) failed to communicate that declaration to his subordinate.

Or, Chertoff and/or Brown in no way exercised their powers to evacuate people prior to, or stage recovery efforts following, his Presidential declaration.

In either case, Brown as FEMA director should have known:

a) he was empowered under the declaration
b) that there was a category 5 hurricane going to hit near New Orleans, Biloxi, Mobile and Gulfport.
c) a storm that size will cause catastrophic damage within 70 miles of the eye wall.

So, blame who you want.

Wwhen Bush made that declaration of a Federal State of Emergency, he was effectively taking over from the Governor of Louisiana, and all subordinate executives, the responsibility of handling emergency preparedness and recovery. And, he was responsible as chief executive to "delegate authority" to his subordinates to handle those issues.

by maxwell edison

.
Take your pick, New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin or Louisiana Governor Kathleen Blanco.

The following is cut-and-pasted:

"While the governors of both Mississippi and Alabama put in a formal request for federal assistance before Katrina even made landfall, the governor of Louisiana refused to relinquish any of her power for the good of the people. Now she and her party point the finger of blame at the White House......The truth is, the Democratic governor wouldn?t allow Bush to do anything.

It has come to light that all during the night on Friday, September 2, the president of the United States was forced to ?negotiate? with Governor Blanco for the lives of the suffering and dying people of New Orleans. She feared that allowing the federal government to take control would make her administration appear as though it had failed. How she would be judged was more important to her than the lives of those people who were dying in the squalor. How many died as Blanco maneuvered to protect her reputation?

The Posse Comitatus Act prevents, by federal law, the president of the United States from sending federal troops into any state without the direct request of the elected governor of that state. A frustrated President Bush could only stand by and watch as the horror unfolded until he received the request for help. Despite the finger-pointing at President Bush, there was little that he could do until he was formally asked for assistance. No matter how loudly the liberals scream, they know full well that the president was helpless to do much of anything.

As the death toll rose and the animalistic behavior of some of those who chose to remain within the city became public knowledge, it was obvious that authorities needed to regain control. As the scenes from New Orleans, now a national disgrace, were being beamed around the world, a shameless Governor Blanco only cared about her own political image.

There is reason to believe that President Bush, running out of patience with Blanco by Saturday morning, used the only option that remained to him. It is being reported that Bush went around Blanco and utilized the Insurrection Act to federalize the National Guard and send in active military troops to take over the rescue and put down the lawlessness that had taken over New Orleans. The forces that Bush had poised to move into the city, swung into action. It was no accident that the major, organized rescues began when the sun came up on Saturday morning. At 6:30 AM, when the sky over New Orleans was suddenly filled with military helicopters and military convoys poured into the streets, they were there because of President Bush, not Governor Blanco.

The largest military evacuation the world has ever seen moved with the precision and efficiency that is only seen within the military. With men like Lt. General Russel Honore, 1st Army Commander and Army Brigadier General Mark Graham in charge, law and order was quickly restored, and an endless line of helicopters and boats began removing the stranded people and taking them out of the hell-hole called New Orleans. Those forces were ready to act because the President of the United States had positioned them to be ready.

Everyone demands answers and everyone wants to put the blame for this catastrophe on someone. The most convenient person to blame is President Bush. In truth, he is the least responsible on the local level. While the liberals feel this is the perfect time to make political hay because so many African-Americans are involved, the first line of defense for those people, the mayor of New Orleans, and governor of Louisiana, both Democrats, are the leaders that failed them. The people of New Orleans were abandoned by an arrogant governor and a hapless mayor as both struggled to save their own political careers. But, because they are both Democrats, the leftists want these ineffective leaders seen as helpless victims of a thoughtless and racist Bush who ignored their repeated pleas for help.

Mayor Nagin has been reduced to babbling about how the CIA is out to kill him because he 'spoke his mind,' and Governor Blanco has become the invisible woman hoping that no one will notice that her gross incompetence and arrogance cost lives. But the left marches on, blaming President Bush because it knows it can. Most Americans are not aware of the laws preventing the federal government from 'taking over' a city or a state.

The Democrats have closed ranks around their incompetent members and blame the president who was forced to 'deal' with an inept governor. Governor Blanco?s thanks is to point the finger of blame back at the president when she knows the fault is her own.

The Democratic Party could not possibly sink much lower than it has this past week......."

http://www.chronwatch.com/content/contentDisplay.asp?aid=16626&catcode=13

----------

jck, do you really believe the crap you spew?

by jck

You said:

"The Posse Comitatus Act prevents, by federal law, the president of the United States from sending federal troops into any state without the direct request of the elected governor of that state. A frustrated President Bush could only stand by and watch as the horror unfolded until he received the request for help. Despite the finger-pointing at President Bush, there was little that he could do until he was formally asked for assistance. No matter how loudly the liberals scream, they know full well that the president was helpless to do much of anything."

I beg to differ:

=================================
"Application of the Act

To understand the extent to which the act has relevance today, it is important to understand to whom the act applies and under what circumstances. The statutory language of the act does not apply to all U.S. military forces.[2] While the act applies to the Army, Air Force, Navy, and Marines, including their Reserve components, it does not apply to the Coast Guard or to the huge military manpower resources of the National Guard.[3] The National Guard, when it is operating in its state status pursuant to Title 32 of the U.S. Code, is not subject to the prohibitions on civilian law enforcement. (Federal military forces operate pursuant to Title 10 of the U.S. Code.) In fact, one of the express missions of the Guard is to preserve the laws of the state during times of emergency when regular law enforcement assets prove inadequate. It is only when federalized pursuant to an exercise of presidential authority that the Guard becomes subject to the limitations of the Posse Comitatus Act."

====================================

http://www.homelandsecurity.org/journal/articles/Trebilcock.htm

And this is the excerpt about the Army guy who wrote that article from the top of that same web page:

=========================================
"Major Craig Trebilcock is a member of the Judge Advocate General?s Corps in the U.S. Army Reserve. He is assigned as an operational law attorney with the 153d Legal Support Organization in Norristown, PA. His area of specialization includes the laws applicable to U.S. forces engaged in operations in both the United States and abroad. Major Trebilcock is a graduate of the University of Michigan (A.B. with high honors, 1982) and the University of Michigan Law School (J.D., 1985). His military education includes the Judge Advocate General Basic Course (1988) and Advanced Course (1992), U.S. Army Command and General Staff College (1997), and the U.S. Navy War College International Relations Seminar (2000). Major Trebilcock is a civilian immigration attorney with the firm of Barley, Snyder, Senft, & Cohen in York, PA."
====================================

Hence under law, Bush could have legally sent the national guard and/or the coast guard into the area for evacuation and/or recovery efforts. Only if he had "federalized" them (enacted them as military police), would they have fallen under Posse Comitatus.

And, they are units of the United States Armed Forces and therefore fall under the designation as "federal troops" as you prescribed.

Also, Posse Comitatus in Latin is "County Power" or "Power of the County". The act applies to exercising law and works to exclude federal military as acting as police, not disaster recovery assistance.

I invite you to read more on this webpage. It is quite informative about the history and use of the Posse Comitatus.

by jck

You said:

"The largest military evacuation the world has ever seen moved with the precision and efficiency that is only seen within the military. With men like Lt. General Russel Honore, 1st Army Commander and Army Brigadier General Mark Graham in charge, law and order was quickly restored, and an endless line of helicopters and boats began removing the stranded people and taking them out of the hell-hole called New Orleans. Those forces were ready to act because the President of the United States had positioned them to be ready. "

Jesus...talk about propaganda...I think the Army Press Corps wrote that one.

OK...let's hit the facts again...so your politically-aligned source there doesn't mislead the good people of TR:

According to Guinness Records, who keeps track of these things...

===============================
"Largest Evacuation - Military
The greatest evacuation in military history was carried out by 1,200 Allied naval and civil craft from the beachhead at Dunkirk, France, between May 26 and June 4, 1940. A total of 338,226 British and French troops were evacuated"
==============================
and...
==============================
"Largest Civilian Evacuation
An estimated 2 million Germans were evacuated from East Prussia in 1945, when the region was ceded to the Soviet Union under the terms of the Potsdam Agreement."
==============================

According to the Washington Post:

"About 42,000 people had been evacuated from the city by Saturday afternoon, with roughly the same number remaining, city officials said. Search-and-rescue efforts continued in flooded areas of the city, where an unknown number of people wait in their homes, on rooftops or in makeshift shelters. Hundreds of thousands of people have been displaced by the flooding -- 250,000 have been absorbed by Texas alone, and local radio reported that Baton Rouge will have doubled in population by Monday. Federal officials said they have begun to collect corpses but could not guess the total toll."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/03/AR2005090301680.html

Most of that 250,000 in Texas includes the number who voluntarily left when Mayor Nagin called for an evacuation of the city.

Baton Rouge has also evidently doubled in size inside of 10 days.

So, the number taken out of New Orleans is nowhere near the largest military evacuation the world has ever seen...in total people evacuated, or people evacuated within a 10 day period.

by jdclyde

it is the STATES job to take care of the state. If they need help, they are to ask or accept the help that is available or offered.

It is looking like that isn't what happened. Will just have to wait to see for sure.

The governor is the one that makes the call for how the state is run, not the predident. Don't you remember your high school government classes?

Be as sarcastic as you wish, it doesn't change who was in charge here and who is ultimately responsible. The Governor is responsible for the state, the Mayors are responsible for the Cities. If the city needs help, they call the governor. If the state needs help, they call the president. Looks like it just took a while to ACCEPT the help that was offered. That is Bush's fault how? Oh wait, "Dubya". Any time a Dem wants to say something venimous, they always add that, don't they?

by maxwell edison

.
....that the mayor of New Orleans called the president and asked him to ask the governor to take certain steps. The president had to "negotiate" with the governor during a meeting with her on Air Force One. The governors of both Mississippi and Alabama put in a formal request for federal assistance before Katrina even made landfall, but the governor of Louisiana refused to do so. The mayor called the president and asked him to get her to do this.

There is a lot that went wrong, but the governor of Louisiana is the most culpable.

Have you ever noticed how these people (people like jck) just NEVER blame Democrats for anything? It's absolutely amazing.

---------- Edited Part:

By the way, I'm certainly not exonerating the mayor of New Orleans. To the contrary, he's proven himself to be an incompetent boob.

- The city's very own evacuation plan called for 72 hours to implement and complete, but he didn't order an evacuation until 24 hours before Katrina hit.

- The city's evacuation plan called for the Superdome to provide shelter and food and water to people, but it did not include the logistical means to get food and water to those people, nor did it provide for a means to ensure security for those people.

- 250 city school busses became trapped underwater. (The city didn't flood, you'll recall, until the day AFTER Katrina passed). Why didn't the mayor order the use of those busses to evacuate the people without transportation?

I could go on.....

Incompetence run amok in New Orleans and in Louisiana -- one of the biggest examples of the failed welfare system and the "depend on government" mentality.

by gsosbee1

fbi/cia world inhumane domination; the world's people are sitting ducks.
geral sosbee | 08.11.2006 16:41 | Globalisation | London
The media presently prevents the publication (by a former intelligence officer of the uSA) of evidence of fbi/cia high crimes and misdemeanors globally. The indymedia groups, such as indymedia ireland, are also beginning to show signs of mainstream media tyranny. The article that follows is in the form of a parable and hurts no one, except perhaps the assassins and torturers of the world's most hideous group of thugs: the fbi and the cia.

The indymedia ireland banned and made unavailable the following article for the reason quoted below :

"Document Not Available
Sorry, this story has been removed due to a possible breach of the editorial guidelines and is under review by the editorial group. If you think that this story should be allowed to remain on the newswire, please check our editorial guidelines and if you think that your article does not breach any of these guidelines, you can contact the editorial collective to make your case. "
[Sosbee responded as follows: permission to publish from cowardly fools.......NOT.]

From Democracy to Tribalism Nov 07 06 by marius65
new film about oil company crimes in Burma Nov 05 06 by sophia
Oaxaca Urgent Action Worldwide Photos Nov 05 06 by Solidaria
FBI / CIA world inhumane domination
international | rights and freedoms | other press Tuesday November 07, 2006 17:48 by geral sosbee - self gsosbee at yahoo dot com fascist uSA 9564593024
The fox is in the hen House
The world's people are sitting ducks at the mercy of the tyrants, murderers and terrorists of the uSA.
Geral Sosbee

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

the parable of the fox in the hen House
7 Nov 2006 @ 17:16
From Brownsville, Texas
November 7, 2007
Little Noticed and Ominous Headlines:

"FBI steps up probes of politicians, might run sting

Chicago Tribune - Nov 06 5:12 AM
The new chief of the FBI's criminal division, which is swamped with public corruption cases, says the bureau is ramping up its ability to catch crooked politicians and might run an undercover sting on Congress. "

"Bill would put all warrants in FBI system

Boston Globe - Nov 07 1:08 AM
Governor Mitt Romney filed legislation yesterday that would require local police departments to put all felony and serious misdemeanor arrest warrants into a national FBI database. This would enable any police department in the state to check quickly whether a suspect has a recent history of troublemaking or violence, the governor's office said. "

Sosbee writes:

All "troublemaking" is a new category of federal offenses and subjects the accused to a new and non erasable label . The corrupt police in all jurisdictions can now destroy or otherwise 'set up' any person who discloses governmental atrocities or misconduct. Troublemakers beware.

In concert with the ever increasing and far reaching authority of the federal authorities over all local law enforcement, the fbi and the cia now expand their menacing presence inside the halls of the legislature (a formerly separate and now unequal branch of government which had originally been established to safeguard the constitutional rights of the citizens against possible abuses by the other branches of government). The parable of the fox in the hen house (the foxes being the fbi and the cia thugs, referred to below as foxies) takes on a new meaning as the foxies enter the House to force (by blackmail or threat of arrest) compliance upon the high flying hens:

The foxies now enjoy a kind of free for all frolic at the funny farm where the hen house (occupied by congress and the courts) has become a very dirty and corrupt culture removed from the rest of the world by the luxuries afforded the occupants therein. On the outside, the sitting ducks go about their lives, largely unaware that soon they too may be targeted (around the globe) for imagined offenses (such as trouble making, or activism) in all jurisdictions and in all countries; the foxies after all now enjoy by their global reach a certain unimpeachable authority wherever their guile may take them.See worldinaboxhttp://www.sosbeevfbi.com/part4-worldinabo.html.
Indeed, many sitting ducks are now being clothed in fox attire and receive pay and other benefits from their ruthless benefactors (the fbi and the cia shrewd foxies). As expected therefore, as one glances at the broader landscape, many sitting ducks are now living in prisons, in war zones , or in poverty, all at the direction of the foxies and their little rat companions (i.e. foxies clothed as ducks but imbued with the minds of rats).

Those sitting ducks who have not yet attracted the attention of the foxies are oblivious to the suffering all around them; for they have their lucrative employment, their comfortable dwellings, their fancy vehicles, and their health benefits (and other perks) to keep them mesmerized. These hypnotized sitting ducks sometimes violently attack their brethren who may from time to time try to highlight the great suffering brought about by the liars and traitors who constitute the band of frolicking foxies and their little rat companions.

In essence today, only the disenfranchised and the imprisoned ostensibly stand to gain anything by attacking the standards established by the foxies. The vast numbers of sitting ducks refuse to see the encroaching enslavement of their kind for all times , as forecast by the troublemakers. Never mind that the foxies are themselves murderers, torturers and terrorists; never mind that the future of the world and indeed the destiny of the human species is presently being shaped and defined by the lowest form of human intellect as reflected in the characers of these foxies. The sitting ducks thus leave to their offspring the ever worsening task of dealing with the miscreant foxies and their little rat associates.

For now, the foxies are in complete control; and for as long as the sitting ducks at large remain lethargic in the face of widespread suffering and chaos, the concepts of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness are long forgotten and unfulfilled promises once concocted in the hen house for the purpose of appeasing the troublemakers.

Related Link: http://www.sosbeevfbi.com

?

geral sosbee
e-mail: gsosbee@yahoo.com
Homepage: http://www.sosbeevfbi.com

by maxwell edison

.
"But perhaps the greatest disappointment stands at the breached 17th Street levee. Touring this critical site yesterday with the President, I saw what I believed to be a real and significant effort to get a handle on a major cause of this catastrophe. Flying over this critical spot again this morning, less than 24 hours later, it became apparent that yesterday we witnessed a hastily prepared stage set for a Presidential photo opportunity; and the desperately needed resources we saw were this morning reduced to a single, lonely piece of equipment. The good and decent people of southeast Louisiana and the Gulf Coast -- black and white, rich and poor, young and old -- deserve far better from their national government."

- Louisiana Senator Mary Landrieu

And how does that partisan statement jive with the following?

Top five states that received the most Army Corps funding in the President?s FY2002 budget:

(Army Corps money is used for the levees.)

1. Louisiana - $342,006,000

2. Florida - $228,686,666

3. Illinois - $201,301,925

4. Texas - $200,350,000

5. California - $182,370,000

Who controls the money provided for the Army Corps of Engineers in each state? The state, itself, that's who? And Louisiana received MORE money than ANY OTHER STATE in the nation.

Of course, before Katrina hit shores, Senator Landrieu said this:

""I would like to commend both Governor Blanco and all of the local leaders who have done a tremendous job helping the people of Louisiana prepare for Hurricane Katrina."

Prepare? Prepare how? By declaring "party time" in New Orleans again?

"If one person criticizes [our sheriffs], or says one more thing, including the president of the United States, he will hear from me - one more word about it after this show airs and I - I might likely have to punch him - literally," Landrieu railed on "ABC's "This Week."

What a total imbecile she is.

And speaking of imbeciles (and surprise, from the New York Times, of all papers):

Gov. Kathleen Babineaux Blanco told the White House it would have to wait for her decision on its proposal. Then she told them her answer was no.

After huddling with her advisers late into the night last Friday and again Saturday morning, she rejected a White House proposal to consolidate the National Guard and active duty troops in the Hurricane Katrina disaster zone under a single commander appointed by the Bush administration.

"If I had seen a greater purpose, if I had felt it would make an immediate difference, it would have been a no-brainer, but by Friday, we had everything in control," she said in an interview in a trailer behind the state's emergency operations center.

And, so, Ms. Blanco, 62, a football coach's wife and former schoolteacher and homemaker - as unlikely a governor as any - defied a request from the president of the United States.

Whether her decision was best for her state remains to be seen, but the episode is revealing about Ms. Blanco's personality and leadership style, her advisers said.

The public has glimpsed different versions of the governor over the past week and a half. After the devastation became clear, she appeared haggard and shell-shocked before television cameras while blinking back tears and calling for prayers.

Later in the week, she warned looters that National Guard soldiers were on their way with "M-16's, and they are locked and loaded."

----------

Maybe it's something in the jambalaya.

by maxwell edison

.
And I can't edit the stupid message.

Did you know that if you submit a message without a title, it can't be edited?

Something just doesn't JIBE.

by stress junkie

I can read the title-less message. I can just make out the dot in the subject area.

We've seen a few posts with absolutely no title. You would think that the clever TR web developers would put in some error checking code to ensure that there is a title.

by maxwell edison

.
Here's the opinion of one Republican Congressman.

Dear Mr. Speaker,

Given the abysmal failure of state and local officials in Louisiana to plan adequately for or respond to the effects of Hurricane Katrina on the city of New Orleans, and given the long history of public corruption in Louisiana, I hope the House will refrain from directly appropriating any funds from the public treasury to either the state of Louisiana or the city of New Orleans. Instead, reconstruction and relief funds dedicated to the people of New Orleans should be administered by a private organization or a select committee similar to the historic Truman Commission.

Public corruption is a well known problem in Louisiana. The head of the FBI in New Orleans just this past year described the state?s public corruption as "epidemic, endemic, and entrenched. No branch of government is exempt.? Over the last thirty years, a long list of Louisiana politicians have been convicted of crimes; the list includes a governor, an attorney general, an elections commissioner, an agriculture commissioner, three successive insurance commissioners, a congressman, a federal judge, a State Senate president, six other state legislators, and a host of appointed officials, local sheriffs, city councilmen, and parish police jurors. Given the documented public corruption in the state, I am not confident that Louisiana officials can be trusted to administer federal relief aid.

Clearly the federal response from FEMA in the aftermath of the hurricane was hampered by bureaucratic ineptitude. Making matters worse, the Mayor of New Orleans and the Governor of Louisiana have demonstrated mind-boggling incompetence in their lack of planning for and response to this disaster. According to one recent media report, ?A year ago, as Hurricane Ivan approached, New Orleans ordered an evacuation but did not use city or school buses to help people evacuate. As a result many of the poorest citizens were unable to evacuate. Fortunately, the hurricane changed course and did not hit New Orleans, but both Gov. Blanco and Mayor Nagin acknowledged the need for a better evacuation plan...[but] did not take corrective actions. In 1998, during a threat by Hurricane George, 14,000 people were sent to the Superdome and theft and vandalism were rampant due to inadequate security. Again, these problems were not corrected.?

The city of New York, by comparison, had no advance warning of 9/11. Yet Mayor Giuliani and Governor Pataki displayed tremendous leadership in managing a chaotic situation in the city. Their leadership inspired confidence in their ability to manage the emergency and coordinate federal aid. In contrast, despite knowing days in advance about the coming hurricane, Governor Blanco and Mayor Nagin seem to have done little beyond encouraging residents to leave the city or gather at the Superdome. City school and transit buses could have carried 12,000 persons per run out of the city, yet they sat idle in parking lots under water ? while both the Mayor and Governor criticized the federal response.

In the coming days, tens of billions of dollars will likely flood Louisiana to address the costs of rescue, clean up, and rebuilding. The question is not whether Congress should provide for those in need, but whether state and local officials who have been derelict in their duty should be trusted with that money. Their record during Hurricane Katrina and the long history of public corruption in Louisiana convinces me that that they should not.

Sincerely,

Tom Tancredo, M.C.

----------

Congressman Tancredo took a lot of heat years ago when he warned about the porous borders, the very lax border control, and the turning of a blind-eye to rampant immigration laws violations. In fact, it was his primary issue. Years after he took the heat, history has shown him to be correct. Congressman Tancredo, for those who may not know, is a very frank speaker. He doesn't pull any punches, calls em' as he sees em', and just let's the political chips fall where they may. As a result, he does take a lot of heat. But to me, such frankness is refreshing.

by av .

Its just a bad idea to have Louisiana manage any money. They have enough to deal with and have already proven they are not up to the task.

We definitely need private organizations to manage the money. FEMA is just dysfunctional. Unfortunately, they are in charge of the distribution of the money. How scary is that?

Congressman Tancredo is right in what he says and he's not afraid to say it. He was one of the first to try to address our border security problems. We need more people like him in our government because we face some really dire problems today and we have to get it right.

We need to start acting like the superpower we're supposed to be. We have the resources, our military people are awesome. Its embarassing though and scary at the same time, that our government as a whole is just so dysfunctional.

by stress junkie

Nancy Giles has no more respect for the truth than does Karl Rove or Bill O'Reilly.

Liars are everywhere.

by maxwell edison

.
Nancy Giles is just delusional. And so are the radical Democrats like Howard Dean, Nancy Pelosi, et al.

But keep it up. Please, keep it up. People like that are digging the Democrat Party's own grave by being so delusional, radical, and irrational.

It doesn't work anymore. People can see through it. But please, Nancy, Howard, and Charles, keep it up. It will only mean more defeat for the Democrats. It's almost comical, if it wasn't so pitiful.

The following certainly applies to all such Democrats:

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt."

-Mark Twain

I love it.

by av .

We don't have any planning on the local level at all. It is the government's job to tell us where to go and give us a way to get there. Not one place - many places. We all need to know that now - before the next disaster so we all know what to do and where to go.

When I was a kid, we always had practiced fire drills and disaster evacuations. I think we need to do something like that as a nation. We should be issued a survival kit by the government. No it isn't cheap, but its cheaper to do that than respond after the disaster. Instead of training just government, we should be trained too.

I think Louisiana local and state governments were complacent. They knew in advance that many people had no cars or couldn't leave and made no attempt to accommodate them. Thats ridiculous in a place like New Orleans, hurricane capital of the US.

All local governments need to get their disaster plans together - now - so this doesn't happen again. We all need to have our own plans too.

by jck

But, Florida already has stuff like that. Buildings that are built to hurricane-tolerant specs are deemed shelters in the different cities and counties, designated evacuation routes, toll roads become free during disasters, etc.

The building I worked in at my last job was rated to withstand 250mph winds. They had 18 inch thick steel-reinforced concrete walls, metal coverings that were bolted and would seal over the windows, solid metal storm rated doors with bar locks, etc. Of course, then you were cooped up in that place for days if you had to stay there.

My biggest beef with all this is that if the government is going to pay for the total rebuild of the city of New Orleans, they should also look into requiring, as part of the rebuild, elevating the entirety of the city of New Orleans up to a level that would keep it from being under 8-12 feet of water if a levee breaks.

Meterologists have predicted that we are in an up-trend in tropical activity for about the next 10-20 years. And, the next big storm is just going to do this again and I don't want to be stuck paying for people living in the middle of a dry lake bed.

If it's going to take years to rebuild, I think it best to look at doing it right so that people don't lose homes and businesses again and again...and the American taxpayer doesn't get stuck with the bill.

by maxwell edison

.
....then why doesn't Louisiana?

Could it be the STATE GOVERNMENT?

(okay, this is where you launch into the Bush brother crap.)

But maybe Jeb Bush is a much better governor than the miserable failure they voted themselves in Louisiana.

by av .

If not, American taxpayers will just keep paying the price. Maybe the smart thing to do is not rebuild in parts of New Orleans that are too vulnerable.

No one wants something like that, but can you really depend on a levee to withstand category 4 and 5 hurricanes? Hmm.

Florida sounds like it's really as well prepared as you can be for disasters. I honestly don't know how Floridians deal with the constant storms. I couldn't do it.

by maxwell edison

.
Well, when you said, "Nancy Giles has no more respect for the truth than does Karl Rove or Bill O'Reilly", I assumed you would thereby associate Karl Rove with GWB.

If you believe that Karl Rove has no respect for the truth, one might assume that you believe GWB doesn't either. You're known by the company you keep, after all. At least it's so said.

Did I draw a false conclusion? If I did, I stand corrected. If I didn't, what's the point of your message?

by maxwell edison

.
Tell me, what do you think of the job done by Louisiana's governor, considering all that you've read about her and her decisions in this discussion. (I assume you've read all these messages.)

by aldanatech

True, there is room for improvement on her part, but the White House can't just wash off their hands out of this. I see two important points in this issue. The first one is that the president was well informed that winds were picking up to 115 miles per hour in the gulf. About 48 hours before disaster struck, they've gone up to 160. Well instead of rushing to Washington and start making all necessary preparations, he decided to go to Arizona and California and enjoy the good life. As for the governor, she is 40,000 troops to help in the relief efforts. We need those troops here now more than anywhere else.

by maxwell edison

.
I say good for them. That's all we need, a terrorist bomb being sneaked into the port of Houston under the guise of humanitarian aid.

In my opinion, we can get along just fine without their aid, even though, I will admit, it's a very nice and appreciated gesture. And I would guess that it will eventually get to its intended destination, albeit a little delayed, and will help people just as it was intended to do.

But yours was a typical Aldanatech message. Simple posting the story or the link to a story that attempts, somehow, to discredit the Bush administration. Geesh, dude, can't you come up with some thoughts of your own? Just once in a while? What a mind-numbed robot you must be. You can't think and speak for yourself, but rather rely on the words of others. Sad....Sad indeed.

(On the other hand, perhaps you're just heeding Mark Twain's observation about fools.)

by maxwell edison

.
Why is it that Mississippi and Alabama apparently received all the help that was possible BEFORE the hurricane hit? Because the governors of those states did what was necessary to request it.

Why didn't the same happen in Louisiana? Because the governor DID NOT do what was necessary to request it -- in fact, she TURNED IT DOWN!

And by federal law, the governor of a state MUST request the help. The feds can't just go marching into a state without that state's governors approval, and Louisiana's governor did not give such approval. In fact, she opposed it.

The following is cut-and-pasted from another opinion column:

"The Posse Comitatus Act prevents, by federal law, the president of the United States from sending federal troops into any state without the direct request of the elected governor of that state. A frustrated President Bush could only stand by and watch as the horror unfolded until he received the request for help. Despite the finger-pointing at President Bush, there was little that he could do until he was formally asked for assistance. No matter how loudly the liberals scream, they know full well that the president was helpless to do much of anything."

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=180840&messageID=1843766

by maxwell edison

.
.....both to the Democrats in power and the Democrats who continue to be in denial about it. This one is clear as day. And when more becomes public, assuming the media will cover it, we'll all know it, and not even you will be able to deny it.

And you know what? If the Republican governor of Mississippi did the same thing as the Democrat governor of Louisiana, I'd be calling for his head. That's NOT the kind of person I'd want in my party.

by jevans4949

We have been watching the repercussions of Katrina on TV in the UK, and have been horrified by the scale of the problem.

I have read all the posts, which are most interesting.

Although I am no fan of George Bush, I do not see that he should have cancelled his plans to take charge personally. The primary responsibility was clearly with local and state government; presumably he also had confidence in the FEMA leadership, or he would not have appointed them. In fact he does appear to have intervened when needed, i.e., when the established chain of command was falling apart.

With regard to the behaviour of the people in the evacuation centres: if "the authorities" take it upon themselves to order the population to take some action, then they are effectively relieveing the population of their duty of "self-reliance". Whoever gave the order must be held responsible for the chaos that ensued.

One of the references in the discussion starter was along the lines "whatever happened to self-reliance?" One report I heard over here stated that Amtrak and the bus companies ceased operations in the affected area some time before the storm arrived. How were those without their own transportation supposed to leave the city? And does the welfare money that many of these people were living on include provision for sudden bus or train fares?

by jmgarvin

For those that can't get there there is usually state run up transportation.

States do have plans for such a thing. However, the mayor, govenor, and National Guard all dropped the ball.

Families don't even know there are victims from New Orleans in Albuquerque. FEMA has screwed up and what is this deal with "processing" the victims?

by jdclyde

This sounds like it is the governments fault these people are collecting money from the government? It is also the governments fault that they don't have any money sitting aside for emergancies? Maybe the government wasn't GIVING them enough welfare money?

I have known many people on welfare, and every single one had a car.

by stress junkie

Yes you drew a false conclusion. I believe that the White House team is doing a good job of keeping dirt off of GWB's image. It seems that a lot of GWB criticism comes from people who criticise all things Republican. I used to get very tired of hearing them make excuses for President Clinton when it was clear that they simply refused to admit that sometimes Republicans do good things and sometimes Democrats do bad things. In the same way it seems that you refuse to admit that sometimes Democrats do good things and sometimes Republicans do bad things. I think it's a mistake to take the position that one party is always right and the other party/parties are always wrong.

by itgirli

I know people that gave money to the Red Cross for the Tsunami relief and their checks didn't get cashed until 6 and 7 months later. Not only thieves, but liars as well.

by charliespencer

Well, a retired one, at least. I was called out for four hurricanes, including twice for Hugo in 1989. Here in South Carolina we;ve learned a multitude of lessons from the mistakes we made during Hugo.

The first one is that all lanes of all highways are made outbound. I saw several television shots showing the normal outbound lanes jammed with traffic while the inbound interstate lanes were clear and empty. Maybe they were made outbound after the shots I saw.

Second, we now activate Guardsmen and position supplies at armories as much as 24-36 hours in advance. We position them at armories close to but not directly within the estimated strike zone. Close enough to get where they're needed quickly, but not so close they're in danger and rendered unable to assist afterward. I'm not sure why it took the LA Guard over three days to get into NO. I wasn't there and I don't know the circumstances so I won't criticize them without full info.

UPDATE - I learned this afternoon that appx. 3000 of LA's roughly 7000 Guardsmen are deployed out of state, along with much of their heavy trucks and electrical generators.

Third, we mobilize Guardsmen from -way- outside the estimated impact area. It's a lot easier to help others when you aren't worried about your own family and home. The units are informed annually about what areas will be their responsibility in a hurricane. That way the commanders and soldiers of each unit can track the storm and see if the landfall predition is in their area of responsibility. Yes, this does result in having Guardsmen in areas that are unfamiliar to them. That's why we work in cooperation with local authorities.

Fourth, we don't expect any federal assistance for the first three or four days. The feds are too large to move quickly, even with the amount of warning now available for hurricanes. We acually plan on them not being available.

If LA is like SC, the Guard can't make it's own decision to mobilize. That's the governer's call. In addition, here we don't set our priorities. Each mobilized unit works with the local Civil Defense authorities, usually on a county basis. CD sets the priorites and tells us what they want us to do. (I've been out for almost three years; is CD still an independent agency or has it been co-opted into Homeland Defense?)

Any other weekend warriors with disaster recovery experience? Hurricanes are easier than most other natural disasters. Earthquakes and tornadoes don't give you a week's advance notice.

by willcomp

I'm not sure when or where you observed traffic but major north-south arteries were contra-flow (one way north) about 48 hours prior to landfall. Those were Interstates 55 and 59 and US 49. I-10 which passes through New Orleans and the Mississippi Coast cannot be restricted to one way traffic.

Yes, only the governor of a state can mobilize the National Guard.

by montgomery gator

What flag is that for your avatar? Is it from the War of Northern Agression, since it has what looks like the "Bonnie Blue Flag" in the upper corner?

by charliespencer

I also read in the paper this weekend that the contra-flow worked successfully, so apparently all the photos and film I saw were from early in the evacuation.

by maxwell edison

.
I assume, by past discussion with you, that you believe the federal government's role is to protect everybody at all times, under all circumstances, regardless of the issue, and regardless of the circumstance. I also assume that you're a partisan Democrat, or in the very least a raving anti-Republican.

Regardless of what goes wrong, regardless of the circumstances, regardless of anything, Bush is to blame, at least in your eyes.

Get real, dude. Take responsibility for yourself, and expect the same of others.

In my estimation, my life is mine, regardless of who's in the White House or regardless of which party is in power. If I don't take full and total responsibility for whatever happens to me, regardless of the circumstances, then, by definition, I pass my own responsibility on to others. If that's your outlook, God help you.

by jdclyde

the governor in Louisiana is a Domocrat! They CARE about the poor people that they just let drown and get flooded out.

This just MAY hurt the Dem standing in that state, as I will BET that about 25% of the ecacuees never go back.

The people that DO go back will remember just how little the state did for them when they needed it.

by jdclyde

that it doesn't matter what the facts are. These are just people waiting for an excuse to run on about how much they HATE Bush, and will look to stick him with anything and everything, facts be damned.

These are also people that don't think the STATES should HAVE the authority that it does. Need papa bear federal government to take money from the "Evil Rich" to pay for anything that is wrong in our lives. Why is it the responsibility of the rich to pay this? Because they can, and there are enough [b]leaches[/b] in the country that have found they can vote money away from one person, and give it to themselves.

by absolutely

The news reporter standing in front of flying sheet metal that looked like it could easily be 8 foot square pieces was ridiculous. The only news there and then was "there's a dangerous storm and people aren't safe in it". The reporter was there for our entertainment, and I know I was curious about the likelihood of his death. In retrospect, I have to admit that if I had a Nielsen box, I'd be encouraging more reporters to meet their death to dramatize things that should be obvious. Whether viewers tune in for helpful information or morbid curiosity, the advertisers' exposure is only counted by the number of viewers. All that matters is that we watch. I vaguely recall the reporter saying that he was on the leeward side of a building, which must have been behind the cameraman, but it's still completely unnecessary to have a live reporter there. A couple cameras mounted REAL solidly to the sidewalk or whatever is handy would have conveyed as much useful information, but would not have convinced anybody to stay and find out if the poor reporter dies in the line of duty.

by jck

See my other post about declarations of Federal State of Emergency and the authority the President takes when declaring such.

I take responsibility for my own actions...shouldn't everyone else? Including a President?

Thanks.

BTW...you should know by now...God can't even help me...I'm a registered Republican who doesn't agree with you...so, you should have no hope for me! :D hahaha

by jck

Did my post break up someone's argument?

Facts hurt, eh?

ok...can't discuss now. Time to go to the dentist.

by jck

I need more than one...cause...I'm the multiple lover...hahahaha ]:)

by willcomp

Flag of State of Mississippi from 1861 until 1894 when current flag was adopted that has Southern Cross (Confederate battle flag for the uninitiated) in canton corner.

Flew over the sovereign state of Mississippi from shortly after secession until joining the Confederacy.

That is Bonnie Blue flag in canton corner of Magnolia flag. Green Magnolia tree on white field.

One of these days I'll find a picture of one hanging that won't distort so much when used as avatar.

Wish we would go back to it.

To answer the unasked, I'm a member of the Sons of Confederate Veterans and very aware of Southern history. Grant marched within one block of where I'm sitting on the way to Vicksburg.

by montgomery gator

Adopting the Magnolia Flag in MS does seem like a good idea. It would quiet those who complain about the current MS flag with the Battle Flag in the upper corner, while at the same time, honor the Confederate history of Mississippi. I have 2 g-g grandfathers from SC that fought for the CSA. Why did MS change its flag in 1894?

by willcomp

Mississippi's current state constitution was enacted in 1894 and the flag was changed at that time, supposedly to honor Confererate veterans.

The constitution was drawn up immediatelely after reconstruction. It provides for a weak governor, strong legislature, and far too many elected offices. We need a new one but the legislature does not want to call a constitutional convention and lessen their clout.

Flag could have been changed to thumb their collective noses at reconstruction rather than honoring veterans or perhaps to do both.

As I said earlier, wish we would go back to Magnolia flag. It's unique and has historical value. Had a new flag proposed 2 or 3 years ago and a referendum that failed. Design was chosen by committee and as a result was plug ugly. Magnolia flag would have had a chance.

by willcomp

What you saw could have been I-10 which has to be 2 way and passes through New Orleans and the Mississippi Coast.

Contra flow worked well, apparently main bottleneck was exiting New Orleans area. The Mississippi coast has a number of north-south state highways available but New Orleans is pretty much limited to major routes due to being almost surrounded by water.

This discussion is closed to new replies.