As a disclaimer, I admit to believing that our border security and immigration policies are in abysmal shape, and they have been for decades. No ONE administration or congress is to blame; they ALL are. I've heard that as few as 5 percent of all containers entering our seaports are checked. I can only hope that the 5 percent that is being checked is more strategically targeted, and less random. And thousands of illegal people enter across our southern borders daily. The majority probably intend no harm, but it only takes a small minority to inflict a great deal of it.
But let me play devil's advocate with some of your comments. If we isolate the UAE from operating a dock at one of our seaports, what other business should we prevent them from operating in the U.S? What about airline ticketing counters and airport gates? I'm sure the UAE have dozens in various airports around the country. And if we selectively profile based on nationality with this, should we also profile passengers at boarding gates? And why stop at transportation functions? Should we prohibit them from even owning real estate or any other businesses? Should we outlaw truck drivers and taxi drivers who are from the UAE? And why stop with just UAE? Why not Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Jordan, and other Arab countries?
Also, from my research on the issue today, I discovered that this is simply a business transaction. There's no reason to believe that the current lot of employees won't remain on the job, or the management of the ports won't remain intact. And I'm sure the longshoremen's union will have some influence to keep those jobs in place. And the Coast Guard and Port Authorities will not be giving up one iota of control over security. Everything will continue to operate exactly as it has in the past, only under new ownership.
I think this might be analogous to a skyscraper getting new owners; it's just another big business deal. Such a building can undergo a change in ownership that's completely transparent to the tenants, employees, or functions of that building. How many such buildings change hands without anybody even knowing it? Quite a few, I would imagine.
And then there's this consideration. We certainly don't want to give the impression that we're against all Arabs because of the tactics and actions of a very small minority of radicals. That's all we need, the entire Arab world upset at us because we show that we don't trust them enough to conduct a normal business deal. Maybe they'd kick U.S. businesses out of the UAE as retaliation.
You said that you don't understand the secrecy surrounding the whole process, and I initially had the same thought. But considering this is really just another one of thousands of business deals that are consummated daily, I'm beginning to wonder why we heard about it at all? Who was the first one, for example, to "report" this story? How did that person get the story, and why? What's the motivation behind the story's release? I'm not so sure that the deal was done in secret, but rather this was selectively chosen for public consumption. I wonder why? And I wonder who?
Personally, I think not letting it happen would do more harm than good. I guess I just convinced myself on which side I should fall. Even though I hate to agree with Jimmy Carter, I guess I'll hold my nose and agree with him on this one.
But why didn't Trump buy the business?
P.S. An edit to my comments:
I just heard Tom Tancredo, a Colorado Republican Congressman (whom I like a lot, by the way), ask a pretty good question. (I'm paraphrasing.)
Why should the United States government let ANY business from ANY foreign country, state owned or otherwise, own ANY strategic business and/or real estate in the United States? That's a pretty good question. But I suppose the answer might lie somewhere in how we might prevent it. What if, for example, no American interest wants to buy it? What then? And define "strategic"? The repercussions could lead to a slippery slope indeed.
Are there any reasonable and rational arguments that might get me to switch positions? I did, after all, go from undecided to decided in one day; perhaps I'll be back at undecided tomorrow.