Discussion Locked

Managing a loud and obnoxious subordinate

0 helpful
283 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

283 replies

by Member 25916250

Ewww, you have it bad there, mate.
They are in chapter 11, which generally means that they are restructuring. As part of their re-org, NOW is the time to get those crucial clarifying documents in place! You will be supporting their efforts to bring about an organized change.

Just be careful not to miss any important areas when it comes to job duties. Make sure that someone (preferably more than one) has the task of Project Management for the team. That way any structured, non-assigned items can be assigned later as projects. Also include the usual "other duties as assigned" where appropriate.

I would also heed the call to prepare your resume, as if you meet hard resistance, it is not likely to be a swift or successful turn-around.

Good luck,
Mark

by vvega

I will try not to sound too "touchy-feely". Here are my suggestions:

1) Deal with the insecurity- find ways to sincerely bring the person in for their suggestions highlighting their experience, praise them publicly when warranted. Communicate how much you appreciate their positive contributions and spell them out. Diffuse some of the unmet needs that lead to this behavior.

2) Look at yourself- sometimes our pride gets in the way (probably not often in the case of this person) and it becomes important for us to look inside to see if we are "encouraging" bad behavior and/or bringing certain poor responses on yourself. Bottom line-don't give the employee reasons to act badly.

3) Have a heart-to-heart face-to-face talk with them. Tell them what you appreciate first and then delineate the bad behavior and discuss how the behavior undermines the department. Ask if their are personal issues that may be driving this behavior (be prepared to offer guidance and direction to support services: employee assistance program, social services, etc.).

4) Unfortunately, this employee may simply want your job, resent you and is determined to undermine you. In this case speak with them about transitioning them to a new department or to a new company. Help them in the process as you work toward replacing them. Make this positive; you are looking at what is in their best interests career-wise as you seek to make their transition less disruptive for the company.

No matter what you must deal with this quickly and effectively or you will find that formerly good employees will begin morphing into disruptive employees right before your eyes.

by isha_mehak_83

Just discuss with them about their attitude in the office and tell them u r the boss. But if they don't understand then try to be louder than them just for once.

by gyzmo_13

Take this person to lunch one day, tell her you value her experience and would like to get her input. However, you need to tell her that there is a time and place for everything, and a way to say things. Tell her you are open to her suggestions, but if she would please make it on a personal level.
Don't be afraid to tell her it bothers you when she does the group announcements bit, as long as she believes you value her opinion I think she should pipe down. It's better than saying nothing.

by slsb

At some point you need to confront her, whether at lunch or another location. She may not know that she is being a problem. After you have met with her, monitor her progress. If you notice that she is improving, let her know. If she still misbehaves, you will probably want to follow your company procedures and write her up. She may be causing problems for other employees, too. And if you don't get control of the situation, you may find the good ones on your team looking to move on.

Good luck on dealing with her.

by larry_yarmchuk

You're the manager. The company has hired you to perform a job. Quit hiding, do your job or get out of the way so someone else can.

I'm an older worker and I certainly have no problems with being led by a much younger leader. The point is though, lead, follow or get out of the way.

Enough said.

by jerry~beans&bytes

i strongly disagree that you can't change anyone's behavior. what the heck is a manager for, if not to help their people act in ways that beter serve the company? SOMETIMES, you find someone who can or will not learn how to act properly: if they won't change, they have to go. most people understand that, and would rather change their behavior than look for a new job.

by bongy69

i wound face her head on ,tell her myway or highway so shout up,tell her that u are her manager and if she dont like it to move on ,as its making bad feeling with the team.

by dcollins1

Sometimes a leader has to show how to lead by example
I'm not about to give advice becauce I do not know you or her. But the best work place is a freindly work place. Maybe the person is scared! and is tring to show she is still useful and productive. But she doesn't have the personal or professional ability to
ask for help

by rasn2001

I don't know the specifics of the types of things this person is getting under your skin with so this suggestion may not be fully applicable to the situation.

I have found that the best way to deal with someone who is trying to "Show You Up" is to act interested in what they are making noise about and casually ask them to prepare a document containing their thoughts on what they feel are the most important facts/causes specific to the item(s) they are voicing their concern(s) about. Also, ask them to include, in that same document, the appropriate steps/actions that should be taken to address the concern(s) as well as how those steps/actions would be best implemented.

If you show lots of gratuitous enthusiasm while you are asking this person to "Help You Find a Solution" to the "Important" Concern they have brought to your attention, you might be surprised to receive some valuable information within the document the person prepares as a result of your request. More likely however, is that you will never get the document you requested, but you'll probably notice a major decline in the number of concerns being voiced by the person. If the voicing of inappropriate concerns by the person does not decline, you will at least be able to respond to her in a reserved manner: "You know, I asked you for your help to solve a concern you brought up in the past and you didn't provide with the document containing the steps/actions that should be taken to address the concern(s) you had voiced at that time."

by commonsensa

Amcol, said it the best that it could be said, your are the manager,"PLEASE EXCUSE THE FRENCH@&* HERE" and sometimes it sucks but there is an old small story about the boss being an asshole. and it pretty much is the truth. But he can also earn respect, noone enjoys costing someone that job atleast noone I would consider worth a crap. But you are in charge and in that position you MUST be in control if the person is a problem then correct it, and use the means provided to you to do so, use HR and managing steps to document every step but you must either get control or give it up to this person. they will either change or you must send them on thier way, if your other team members see that you gave her a chance then they will see a fair deal, you get thier respect and either a good emply from her or a team that sees you will do what is needed to get the job done. as it was said either way you win. Just remember respect is earned, newver demanded. But as a leader you MUST do what has to be done for the greater good, in this case the team and the companies goals.

by kevaburg

I get the feeling that this person has earned the respect of his peers because he has been working the post for the amount of time that he has. I think this woman whovever she is is simply believing she is better than he is and that means if he changes his attitude too much and too forcefully, could lose that.

Sorry but I think the answer you have given would more than likely lead to a confrontation which wold make the prospect of a more comfortable working environment even more difficult to attain.

by vltiii

Actually it was never said her peers had her respect. What was said is that they act like they try to get on with her and that there is quite a bit of bitching going on. That sounds to me as if her peers tolerate her more than anything. Whatever is happening, something does need to be done in that department.

by lfuhrmann

I recommend having a Conflict Resolution Specialist mediate between the supervisor and the individual. A collaborative solution is always a better and longer lasting solution.

by bizzo

I apologise if my post sounded harsh, it's just that that was very similar to my situation a couple of years ago and I still feel a little bitter about it.

If your group was created after the troubles with the company, does everyone have a specific role?

It might be an idea to hold a team meeting to discuss and define the roles and responsibilities within the group. That way, if it's agreed that you're responsible for stock, no-one can pull you up on it. Has she lost any authority recently? It could be that she's resenting having some of her "favourite" work taken from her, and maybe giving her some responsibility back may bring some self-esteem back for her.

Make it feel to her that she's not working *for* you, she's working *with* you.

by jardinier

No, I am not in the least bit confused. I fully understand the discussion topic and stand by the tactic I have suggested.

Perhaps you could actually make a comment on my posting instead of just brushing it aside to voice your own response to the discussion topic.

by government tech

She sounds as if she has no respect for you or your authority. My suggestion is to meet with her and tell her what she is doing wrong and what she needs to do to correct it. Have another lady present from Human Resources to witness the meeting. Get with the HR lady before the meeting to set up what you can and can not say. Document everything. Give her a time period to correct her behavior and have another meeting. The second meeting is to tell her she is improving or go to plan B if she is not. Plan B is whatever HR's policy is in such matters and was discussed with your employee on the first meeting. Bottom line, either she straightens up or due to following HR's policies, she will be fired. Hope this helps.

by cynth113

In reading through all the replies above, I see 3 basic problems emerging.
First, it appears that you dislike conflict, enough so that you go to some lengths to avoid it. Not wanting to jump right into confrontation mode can be a valuable trait, but you can't take it too far. Some people are only happy if they are making waves or loudly and publicly demonstrating their "superiority" over someone else. As a manager, you can't allow that to continue, particularly when she is challenging someone who is her manager. That undermines management as a whole if allowed to continue.
Secondly, it sounds like the problem employee is making great use of "the squeaky wheel gets the oil." You took on ordering supplies yourself at least in part because "she didn't want to do it." She gets to choose? Is it cost effective for you to be doing something that does not require your management level skills? Again, sensitivity to the desires of your staff can be taken too far. If the problem employee is perceived as a prima donna who gets what she wants by being loud and disrespectful, you will indeed have a lot of other unhappy employees, and some of the unhappiest may well be those who follow the rules and feel it does not benefit them.
Finally, you said "if there is anything to be bitched about, it gets bitched about" in the open office area. That cannot continue. It sets a tone of negativity for the entire business. Every time you hear it, you should immediately say to all within hearing that that is inappropriate, unacceptable, and won't be tolerated. If they have a complaint, they need to bring it to the appropriate person as a concern, minus any invective, not air it in a public bitching session. If you do not personally have the authority to enforce this, then take it to whoever does. If they want to bitch among their peers, they can do it after hours at the pub, but you do not have to tolerate it at work.
Best of luck with a difficult situation!

by cheufte

I am quite surprised that nobody suggested that much earlier in the thread. Now this is 2:1 situation, if things go hairy, it might be interpreted as intimidation and fall back on you. She needs to be accompanied as well.

Cheers
CFT

by netgeezer

Really! Take her to lunch and try to work it out. Tactfully tell her how you feel, and let her know specifically what she is doing that you don't like. This worked for me once, but I can't guarantee that it will work for you. At least you can say that you did everything you could to resolve the issue.

by mikev9

Using the term "snippets" when referring to her experience seems to indicate you may be showing some insecurity or hostility of your own.

That said, YOU are the boss and merit respect, AT LEAST INITIALLY.

However, with that you also get the lion's share of the responsibility for managing relationships, that is why you are called a manager (no suprise there).

I would be honest in a face to face meeting where I would be very well prepared to weather a verbal tirade WITHOUT an emotional reaction on your part. That may be all it takes. Let her speak freely and judge carefully what is said. If you can compromise to make the relationship better, "consider" doing it if it is not an outrageous imposition.

This is the best start, because I have seen this from both sides before and usually there is blame enough to go around.

If that doesn't work you have these options:

Be more politically agressive and let her hang herself with her own mouth by documenting her mistakes and mispeaks in detail. You can point them out to her at opportune moments to shut her up.

-or-

be a good, fundamentally sound, manager by setting general standards of conduct and performance that delineate your expectations and create an environment that matches your style.

Then, if she doesn't comply, fire her butt!

Have fun, and welcome to management!!

by stuffit

The position carries with it authority and responsibility. The position should be respected by those below given the positions place in the organizational heirarchy. The person filling that position has the duty to earn or justify by their actions receiving that respect. This flows both directions and can be called "professional behavior".

There is no excuse for "unprofessional" behavior. Inform the loud person that their behaviour towards you is unprofessional and not acceptable using the HR guidelines of your company (i.e. in writing, with witnesses, etc.). Give the loud person an opportunity or a FEW opportunities to correct their behavior. If no correction is forth comming, then document (again!) and take actions to remove them from that environment/office. You cannot change a persons behavior, you can only give them the opportunity or environment to change.

All of the books cited in previous posts are well and good, but YOU must decide to what level you wish to escalate or what actions YOU feel are necessary to change or correct the environment.

by stuffit

I work with someone that also fills the "loud/obnoxious" label. However, instead of just her manager, she is that way to ANYONE who is in a management tier above her or that disagrees with her viewpoint. Almost all verbal communications are what my grandmother would call a "back-handed complement" or "undermining" but never directly at or to the person she is attacking.

One of the things that helped me was a book called Nasty People by Jay Carter, Psy.D. It helped me take the aggressiveness out of my interactions with this employee. After that, I directed my efforts to diffuse the negative impact she was having on the office by assisting those being affected (including her manager) in seeing that being the target did not make them "at fault" or "in the wrong".

I firmly believe that there are those that do not play well with others. In a highly team oriented environment, it is required to give them a limited number of reasonable positive opportunities to correct their obnoxious behaviour or work habits. After those opportunities have been missed or wasted, it is time to dismiss or remove the offensive employee. EVERY single step or communication of this entire process must be well and thoroughly documented (to the point of absurdity!) to prevent further HR or legal issues.

Since I do not work in your environment, I am trying not to give advice, just options.

by avid

i think if you ignore it, then you are pretty much condoning it. you can't let others see her getting away with this attitude. it sets a terrible example for the rest of the staff. this company just came out of ch11. i doubt if morale is very high right now anyway. watching someone insult your boss in public and getting away with it is not very confidence inspiring. besides, if her disposition worsens, she could decide to do something damaging to the company as a whole like accidently lose the accounts receivable file or who knows what. put her in her place.

by thomas.demonja

I have gone through this many times. You need to counsel your employee, in writing, to ensure that both her rights , your rights and your company's rights are fully protected. Look for a company policy or procedural manual that may offer you the minimum things you need to say and do. Also, talk with your State Unemployment office. Proper documentation is always a must! Talk with the offensive person is a polit, but firm way. Perhaps this is a sign that your employee needs help. Contact your HR and legal departments to see what Employee Assistance Programs your company offers. Don;t let this get you down. Her behanvior may be masking other emotions.

by ginese11

There is no magic formula with people, she may be deadset in her ways. Follow the established poliecs and ensure everything is documented.

If she know everything, them she must also know, if I do not work well in a team enviorment, I'm gone.

There are many ways to approach situations, but the situation will dictate the action.

Once you resolve that one, all the whinners will wake up.

by johnesther

I have been in the IT industry since 1965 as student and later Lead/Supervisor/Manager. I would take the person aside and go through standard management proceedure for dealing with that type of employee. Just as you would not want a upper level manager to dress you down in front of the group, you don't need a subordinate to do the samr thing. So take him/her aside in a private office and lay it out. As a manager you are not there to be liked, but you are there to be respected and as you treat your group with courtesy, you expect the same. As i tell my group, we are all professionals, I expect professionalism from each and every one.

by nrichards1371

I've dealt with the same situation. I started a program called "Welcome to my world" where I'd have people like what you described, sit with me for a few days and see exactly what it is that I do and when problems come up, ask their solution, then address the issue with your solution and let them see first hand that you know what you're talking about. If you want to hit the other end of the spectrum, address them in the same way with your way of dealing with an issue. There are most likely others who are going to posess some of the knowledge you posess and chime back in agree, which will (sorry to say but) make the person feel like and idiot and see that you're smarter than they take you to be.

by dcbeckster

I've had this type of situation before and the way I finally resolved it was I documented each infraction or outburst with date, time, and bulk of what was said. I then later sat privately with the employee and presented my documentation and explained that this behavior was unacceptable. I then later had to present my documentation to HR and the employee finally realized that if they didn't change their behavior, they were going to be released. So it worked out very well.

by too old for it

Let's see: Loud, obnoxious, tries to trip up her superiors, been there 5 years, and stayed on despite Chapter 11 and her department being moved elsewhere.

She obviously "has the goods" on someone with enough pull to keep her employed there. Company Christmas party photos? Barged in on someone in a compromising position? The CEO's ex-fling? Major investor's wife?

Either way, tread lightly or you will find yourself home reading the want ads while she is making the next managers life hell on earth.

(Yeah, I know some readers think such things never happen ...)

by kenneth.glass

You hit the nail on the head. She should write a plan for her dept. and let the loud mouth know her part. Let her know she can be a part of it, just not the leader. Ask for suggestions and give credit where credit is due. listen listen listen

by inxale

Phew!!

I had one, pulled him to one side, explained his attitude is affecting team performance. He never realised. He was smart, intelligent and diligent. Trouble was, he was quite negative.
After the chat, though he was still negative he was more constructive about what he said.

But, by the way you have expressed yourself she has been stood on, do not know by whom or why.. But clearly upset and because she is upset she has become unprofessional. Unless she was always like that.

Being reserved can also be construed as weak.

Is this team bitching one you inherited?

If so, kill it. Simple.. Arrange appraisals. Have the one to ones. Identify to yourself who you want. Provide training, make them marketable, they will look and they will leave. Its cheaper to provide training and let them leave of their own accord rather than firing them, and less messy.

Are the team bored? is the devil playing with the idle mind?

Do you have a budget for training?
Identify a tech's ambitions?
Is your mentoring, condescending?

And oh, a big oh.. Just clocked the Ch11 bit. Has there been redundancies? If so, has the redunancies created a dog-eat-dog atmosphere within the company?

If there was redundancies, I doubt there is a training budget..

You need to try to get her to express her fears and concerns. If this is a personal issue which you are getting the brunt of then by listening as a Manager you may help her to chill..

You have to deal with it, or you will suffer. HR is a fantastic resource to use. Use it!

Ultimitely, she has to change, or you will be forced to make a change.

by dimondstar1

As an older employee, I can tell you - as a younger manager you're being 'dissed.

You, as the manager, should be setting the standard and developing procedures - it is NOT her job to criticize you. If you choose to unwrap the memory, for example, how you do it is YOUR procedure. NOT hers.

Personally, if I was such a spoiled brat of an employee - I'd be expecting to get fired. You've been unusually lenient - I hope you've been documenting her destructive, disruptive behavior.

by kevaburg

One of the problems associated with having to manage an older team memeber is the perceived illusion of authority that the older person seems to believe they have over the younger one. We all know this to be nothing more than the illusion that it is but the way this needs to be managed is completely differently to the way the same problem with a younger person would be.

You need to be extremely careful in the way you approach the problem and the "chain-of-command" through HR channels is the best option. If things still do not work out then see if a transfer of her or you between departments is feasible.

Unfortunately this is a situation that could escalate into an unacceptable confrontation very quickly if not handled properly.

Good luck!

by aaron a baker

Knock it off with the MR Nice. She's obviously an abnoxious "Wont'say the word" and so you have to take the bull by the horns.
When something is blatant and she misses it, then you make it a point of telling her in a very loud voice what she's missed. Use the same voice that she does. If she doesn't like it, then tell her to get her mind to the job. We have all learned from snippets of one form or another, but no one has the right to be as she is being to you. If she were on my staf, I'd chew her up in little pieces and leave the cud for everyone else to see. I'm a darned good guy, but I won't be pushed, ever.
Even if you really are a nice guy, and I do believe you are, there comes a point when you must acknowledge that yuo're being taken for a fool and that is unacceptable.Especially in your position. Be nice and the minute she steps out of line trounce on her. When she finally has had enough and asks why, then tell her that all your doing is reciprocating in kind. In this world you get back what you give, "Well most of the time"
Good luck and remember, Reply in kind, only louder." Who's the real Boss you of her?
Make it a point to let her know and don't let up.She'll either smarten up or move on.
Good Luck, this can't be easy.
Aaron

by kevaburg

It seems this person wants to assert authority in the most negative way. There was no use of the help and assistance that HR can provide and basically the manager should go in guns blazing.

This would worsen the situation because noone likes being brought down like that in public and any respect gained over the past years in the position is likely to be badly damaged.

I do agree that this person is a manager and should manage this person according to the level of skill he has but once it gets to much they need to realise it early before the situation escalates beyond recovery.

This woman obviously has issues with herself, and that is apparent if she feels the need to make someone else look bad just to make herself look good. If that is the case, then perhaps an assessment of her skills based on facts would be enough to get her moved on somewhere else, maybe in another department or out of the company.

The one thing that must be remembered is that this company is not the Army and these people need to be spoken to and not spoken at.

by kevaburg

I'm surprised to hear you say that!!!

I think the one issue that bypasses alot of managers is the "human factor". Noone like to be intimidated or made to feel inadequate. Therefore the fact this woman has acted in the way she has and the manager has kept himself calm is a credit to him.

It must be said that the point is rapidly aproaching when strong-arm tactics are going to become necessary but the manager is also managed and surely this is the time for him to use that assistance. Going "one-up" and asking for assistance is what helps gain respect by your peers and not the strong-arm tactics suggested.

I would suggest though, in addition to some previous comments made that this managers managing techniques are OK. The fact one person is rebelling is no negative judgement on him overall. Its just a new experience he has to learn about.

One more reason to consult his manager before going overboard.

by kevaburg

Amcols response, I believe is only the right one if all other avenues have been exhausted. Creating a confrontational environment such as would happen is both negative and non-productive.

Maybe I'm being naive!!!

by arsnake

It boils down to an issue of organizational inertia. Ideally in a situation like this, an employee with that long with the company would be building new skills relevent to the new department or position. However, I've worked with people like this before, who don't understand that someone moved their cheese. Suggestions?

1. Avoid direct confrontation unless you are ready to write her up. The employee does not respect your leadership and likely needs a stern warning (documented well in your records).

2. Make her go to some fluff classes on coping with change to get the hint. If she doesn't, confront her and write her up for insubordination when she bristles.

3. You indicate there is lots of bitching, which to me says wasted time and productivity. Implement a metric-based performance system where possible and quantify performance where you can.

by vltiii

Avoiding the issue is never an option, period! If the "Manager" runs and hides he/she may as well give up their right to lead/manage. The only thing that comes out of hiding is when she absolutely has to stick her head out again, the proglem is still there.

Sending the employee to "fluff" classes in hopes that she will get the hint is not a good idea. I don't know how large this organization is, but many organizations have intervention programs. If the manager feels this is needed, she can recommend the employee attend or check HR policies to see if she can be forced to attend. However she gets there it should be explained and documented before attending the classes why this action has come about. Hoping she gets the hint you might as well put your head in the sand.

The actions that you have suggested here will have the same impact as the managers reserved personality, and that is the unacceptable behavior will continue.

by cremaster

Take her to lunch and attempt to discuss the problem with her. Try to bring it up as "You know Miss loud and obnoxious subordinate (who may or may not realize that she has different agendas than you and your company) the office is very open and I would like to discuss an issue with you." If she does not get the hint then be prepared to offer up "the issue" as a task that she can not accomplish. Give her something she can not do. You win either way. She quits bitching to the whole office or she gets to fire herself.

by jdmercha

Good communication takes two willing participants. You, as the manager, must lead the way and give the benifit of the doubt to the employee. But the employee needs to make an effort also. Some people just don't want to change.

If she will not chsnge then you have to find a way to work with her. Assuming she does her job, her behavior can be overlooked. Provided it does not interfere with the production of others.

As others have pointed out, she does not show you the proper respect due a manager. If you are doing tasks that you should deligte to others then that makes it more difficult for you to gain her respect. If your job descriptin allows it, stick to managing and let the workers do the work. If the work is not getting done, document it and assist those who are failing in their duties.

I agree with others that taking her aside may nnot be the best thing to do. But her annual review may be the time to point out her disruptive bahavior.

by rakeshdosi

Since your office has an open environmnt, use it your advantage. List down the activities that this person does. further break tha down int what u think she enjoys and what she doesnt. After having done this exercise start routing work that se likes to someother person.whille doing ths make sure that you make this lady hear that this is going to the other person aslast time it wsnt handled apppropriatly..have a story..
do this couple of times and this person will come to u for a one on one talk..thn u dictate ur terms

by srini_soma

I would say - first step should be to sit down with her and discuss what's her problems. If you find the problem is only with the attitude, you may have to plan for second disucssion with HR with/ without you. It's possible she can bring up some concerns to your HR. That would help you to correct if anything missing from yourside.

Definitely there is no use in following her voice level and to fight with her. There won't be any difference if you do so.

by srini_soma

I feel this approach creates more threat, worry, fear for your rest of team members. Your silent approach of handling the situation in terms of discussions, or reporting HR will smoothen process than a complicated deadlines and in a way that can become good reason for her to take up the issue with your boss. That will create more troubles than benefits.

by Big. Papi

It is time to take the bull by the horns... and have a one-on-one conversation with this associate. I can relate to your situation, having had the same thing happen (starting out as a new manager). Just remember, it only takes one bad apple...

by cab2

Reading a paragraph describing the problem, and really understanding the personalities and issues are two different things.
However,
from a lot of years of experience, including being a younger manager of more senior folks, I have seen/used two solutions to what I *think* your problem is:
(1) Fire her. If you have the clout and documentation, just get it done. It sounds like you have already tried the mentoring and counselling.
(2) If you don't have the clout, find your own mentor or top exec to jump on the person/problem; read her rights to her, tell her the options (straighten out or get out.) I had a 20 year employee tell me he had several managers tell him he had a problem, and he was still there while the managers were gone. I got a 30 year executive who told him he had a choice to make; get with it, or leave. He got with it, and became to good supporter.

by jaustin_larkin

You are the manager and you need to put a stop this this person's behavior in the office. Nothing more and nothing less.

by bpasp

1. take the person to a private room
1.1 explain that generally accepted professional standards that apply to every company and every positions (cook, soldier, janitor, rocket scientist, IT staff and even clown in a circus) include Never Addressing a Conflicutal Issue or Make Remakrs To Anyone In Public.
1.2 explain that anyone who would want to be recruited by your firm and who would display your person's behavior during interview or trial perdio would not stay in the company
1.3 using the word 'I' tell your person that you really want to understand what is/are the issues leading them to display their behavior in the workplace.
1.4 ask the person to come forward with the problems they may experience either at work or in their life; tell them that agressiveness in the workplace is a sign of a deeper problem, often not related to the workplace, and that bringing in a problem from life to the workplace is leading to unfair burden on co-workers.
1.5 whatever the conversation turns out to, never start 'the game' of entering into the agressive rationale of the subordinate; you have placed the burden of explaining themselves on the person now, stick to asking what is wrong with them; be nice, become their sounding board.
1.6 you may be surprised.
1.7 if you have already tried the above, fire if you have the power; if you dot have the power, report to your direct supervisor your efforts and explain how you have tried. if your supervisor does not support you, or says 'we are aware and there is nothing we can do', quit yourself: you do not have a supervisor/manager, you have a glorified process team member in front of you!
1.8 make this your motto:
"I would rather be a dreamer amongst the humble who have a vision to realize, than a Lord amongst those without dreams or desires" (Khalil Gibran, Lebanese poet and writer).
Good luck!

by cdowner

There are a couple of things you should understand when you work on a desk like that you have no friends at work and you are a manager and you should treat everyone with respect but but at the same time stay away from confrontation and people who learn on the job and feel you you should thank them for been there.

There is a reason why they employed you as a manager and not some one from within the company so when you are at work deal with the issues like how a manager should, dont be too pushy but kind in the ways you go about details on the job and let others be, as a manager you have to understand a couple things you wont be liked and you will be feared.

Now for that getho trash on the job what you need to do is make her a couple of notes as to what you need to have on the team and if she continue then a second letter to her and forward to management mediator and if that dont work have her remove to another desk or location, you are a manager act like it, it is call dealing with issues and you have to understand as IT personel we are all analyzers and we have to offer a solution to all issues or it is our job on the line.

Good luck, remember empty barrel makes the most noise.

by donweb

If this person is the "senior" person as far as time at the company, you may be able to derail some of it by asking their opinion on issues. Who knows? You might actually learn something or get a new idea.

I'm not saying on EVERY little thing that comes up. But when she comes to you and fusses about something ask her for how she would handle the whatever. Force her into being constructive or looking like a fool.

by vltiii

It's most likely because you are younger and newer to the organization that this subordinate is testing her boundaries. You must disregard the difference in age. You are in a senior-subordinate relationship and you both must understand where you fit into that relationship. Everytime you back down from her she as well as your other subordinates that may witness this loses a little more respect for you and the position you hold. Understanding that you have a reserved personality, but if you allow this to continue, you will have lost complete control over all of those you are there to manage which will ultimately affect productivity and efficiency. When this problem subordinate gets into one of those moods you need to take her to the side or your office (if it's private) and re-enforce your role, her role, and what your expectations are as they apply to those roles. Discipline should always be done in private and praise in public. Your subordinate probably understands this already, but she will test the boundaries as long as you let her. Whenever you have to tighten up on the leash, document... document... document, just in case it continues and becomes counter productive to progress. She may ultimately have to be let go and you want to have your ducks in a row. If you need to keep your seniors informed about what's taking place. They may be able to offer additional guidance. You certainly don't want them to get the impression that you can't/won't lead or manage. This can ultimately cost you your job and your problem subordinate will still be there until someone stronger comes along.

by vltiii

This employee has been there for 5+ years, 4+ more than the manager. At this point one would think that she knew her worth. Even if you're right and she doesn't her approach is still a problem. At 40+ years of age and obvious experience in the work force I would think that she would know how to conduct herself in the workplace. Holding her hand is not going to make this problem go away. Leaders lead and managers manage. Personally, had it been me, after this happened one time, I would have explained in no uncertain terms where she fits into the heirarchy and what's expected of her in that role. If it happened again after that, it would have been clear that she had no respect for the position I hold. It doesn't matter if she respects me or not. Ultimately, we're not paid to win popularity contest even though as you stated a friendly work environment is preferred. In any case after the second occurance, the issue would have been dealt with accordingly. I have a reserved personality also, however, if I'm in a position to lead, manager, and supervise, my employer is going to get what they are paying me for.

by vltiii

I'm not sure where the absolutes came in here. His post was very eloquent and point out many reasons that this situation "MAY" or "MAY NOT" be taking place. Trust and respect are earned, however respect for the position should be there no matter what. In the absence of trust and respect unless the manager does something immoral, unethical, or illegal, they are still the manager and the one in a position of authority. If they can never agree on anything it is the subordinates responsibility to adjust to the seniors style. In this case the manager will never "earn" respect or trust as long as this behavior goes unchecked.

by vltiii

As stated in the original post this has been going on for almost a year now. How much hand holding does it take before a change comes about? You want to deal with this situation with kid gloves and these are supposed to be adults. They can act the part or deal with the consequences. That's reality. Sure each individual has unique needs and the manager has to realize that in his approach to managing, but, I don't see how taking the touchy feely approach applies in this situation. By her very actions this problem employee understands aggresiveness very well! Why not respond with what she understands?

by kevaburg

I was actually talking about the author having the respect. In all respects of the scenario it would seem she is the cause of the bickering that is mentioned.

It must be said though: The more I read of the threads posted here, the more I am inclined to believe she should be sacked and let that be the end of it.

by vltiii

I think your last paragraph pretty much sums up the problem in support of everything else here. She does what she can because she can, but what she is obviously has not considered is that those that are successful have better work ethics than she is demonstrating. The problem here is that the manager lacks the leadership skills to reel her in and make her a productive/contributing member of the team. The manager should be concerned because in the end, if she cannot get her team functioning cohesively, she may be out of a job. I can understand her being reserved and there is nothing wrong with that, but doing so to the point that she is non-effective should be cause for concern. Situations require action at different levels, and just letting it go is not the answer.

by vltiii

...with most of what you said until the part about not putting energy into a marginal employee. A true test of a leaders leadership skills can be reflected in their ability to turn a marginal employee into an exceptional employee. There is no reason the already exceptional employees can't be recognized for what they already do while at the same time coaching the marginal employees to become better.

by vltiii

In the end I don't think it matters what is going through her head. In the end what matters is that the employee is disruptive to the work force. The manager can try to ascertain what the root of the problem is in order to come up with a solution to correct it, but we can only guess as to whether it will be effective or not. At 40+ years of age, one would think this person would have some understanding of how to comduct themselves in the work place regardless of what ails her. In every organization there is a chain of command in which authority flows. There also is an expectation that those in subordinate positions understand and recognize the authority of those appointed above them. In the absence of that there is anarchy.

by bill.affeldt

Talk to the person and say you feel her actions are not professional and that if she has an issue it should be addressed IN PRIVATE. Then document that discussion with her.

If it happens again bring out that document and simply say... we have discussed this before and it needs to stop. Document that discussion.

Now go to HR and say I am haviong problems and I want you to be aware of them.

If she persists bring out both documents and remind her and do a formal write up. Include those documents.

If it happens again ---- You need to have a 3 way meeting with HR you and her.

Depending on the outcome of that meeting the next infraction shuold be termination.

She is obviously undermining your authority, affecting your ability to manage and being a general PITA.

It is not easy nor is it fun to manage someone like this, but it has to be done and is one of the drawbacks of managment. But you have to do it no matter how much you don't like it. It is kind of like working with an aggressive dog.,.. if you show fear or hesitation you have lost the battle.
It is too bad some people insist on making it a battle.

by lucyfur

I think if my manager were to write to this site, he ( and no-one else I work with ) would say much the same thing about me, but in turn I would feel very uncomfortable about writing such a vague criticism about the people who report to me.

Apologies in advance if anyone gets offended, or some of these points are already dealt with.

So in her/my defense,
1) I am loud. I don't try to trip my manager up, its just that he constantly makes public declarations about things he knows nothing about( never asks first ), and he has to be told he's wrong before he makes decisions based on the incorrect information. Which he does. Often.
Without being there, we can't judge if she is just correcting your mistakes, albeit in a rather public way, the same way that you cant tell if I'm right in my discussions with mine.

2) "People try to look like they get on with her," I can see my manager saying that too. Personally I think people get on with me, but he likes to pretend they don't( mainly cos I dont get on with him ). He thinks they like the endless boring stories about widgets and gadgets and I think they bore others senseless.
Again, personal opinion which may differ depending on perspective.

However, if I had started this post, I would not have mentioned that as it is a personal opinion of yours that "People" dont like her, and pretend that they do.

3) If she's stayed in a company through bad times, couldnt that mean she is really good at her job? as opposed to her blackmailing someone - a suggestion from another response.

4) 5 years experience is not "snippets", plus whatever she learned wherever else she was in the 10 + years before that, I would get very offended by that and say that it is very condescending to say that. My boss says things like that too all of us ( you'll never be as good as me is always kind of implied, cos he has a phd, and we only have "ordinary" degrees ), and it really winds me up. If you really think like that, it comes across in your posture, and the way you speak, which may explain some of the attitude.

5) "When I'm being nice"???? Again, I'm, afraid that doesnt come across too well, what you are saying is you only try to mentor her when you feel like being nice to her??? hmm.

6) Don't mentor her in things she (thinks she)knows. Ask her what she needs to know, and teach her that stuff, then she can't shrug it off.

Try to stand in her shoes for a while. Try to see why she might feel the need to be like this. Maybe you come across as condescending, I do , and I apologise for it as soon as I see its winding people up, but its just the way I speak, and people are OK once I explain that.

I know I am picking you up on some of the smaller details, but it seemed like a lot of your attitude toward her come out in the post, so i have responded to that, whether correctly or incorrectly.

Then again, maybe she really is a complete dragon, and you are just as good a manager as me ;-)
But even if I am wrong, it's still possible that she feels as offended her (mis)perception of your attitiude as I did.

by vltiii

I don't think it's appropriate for the first disciplinary action to be to send someone home without pay. The first step should be sure the employee understands appropriate behavior in the workplace and the expectations of management. This can only be done through communication. After these things are made clear then the more drastic measures can be implemented. I think to discipline someone without full knowledge that they understand why they're being discipline only fosters more hostility and bitterness in the employee.

by vltiii

You are neglecting the overall impact on the division. If this were a one on one situation, what you recommend may be appropriate,however, this is done in public and only serves to undermine the positional authority the manager has. Co-workers see this type of behavior go unchecked and start to question why they should conform to any rules of a decent workplace, which ultimately will cause a complete breakdown in the organizational structure. The manager needs to handle this situation and her team needs to know that she is taking it for action which will solidify her position as the boss.

by vltiii

If you've tried this and it's not working you need to consider that she just doesn't care or is very immature, or both. In any case you as her manager need to take action. There have been an abundance of good recommendations posted that you can try. Most of them are not consistent with someone who has a reserved personality, but you must overcome that and exercise the authority your company has trusted you with. The performance of your department is a direct reflection on you as the head of the department. If this one employee is having a negative impact on others (and I don't see how she couldn't be at this point) you have or will have a problem.

by vltiii

Most people would consider the workpace a public place. This employee knows her co-workers and doesn't care what they think about her outburst. Why do you think that taking her out to lunch around a bunch of people that she doesn't know will cause her to not make a scene?

by vltiii

Professionals have business lunches with members of the opposite sex all the time. That shouldn't be a concern unless there are some insecurities in the marriage itself. I do agree that any meeting should be in a controlled environment. I also agree that taking one member of the team out to lunch and not the whole team could send the wrong message to the other team members, as innocent as it may be.

by vltiii

That detail caught my attention also. At this point it' starting to sound like the manager is doing things in order to be liked more so than be in charge. This manager needs to understand that her employer is not paying her to win a popularity contest. They're only concerned about the bottom line. She needs to do her part to contribute to the bottom line and as you have stated, that is "Manage"!

by vltiii

If anyhelpwouldbegreat is only expecting feedback that feels good, that is an indication of being unfit to lead! In the real world we have to be prepared to hear the truth and the truth is not always pretty. She can view it as contructive feedback from Amcol or negative feedback from her boss when he/she is let go for non-performance.

by vltiii

I was half way with you through much of your post then you mentioned unwrapping the memory.
1. I'm pretty confident it's not the managers responsibility to unwrap memory. Sometimes leaders do the labor to attempt to show that they are part of the team. Almost alsways the outcome is the team sees them as another member of the team and not the head of the team.
2. Since she did decide to unwrap the memory, why does she need to conform to the subordinates methods for accomplishing this. I can't in the wildest stretch see how this is disrespectful.

Just because we ask someone's opinion doesn't mean that we have to follow their advice. By definition the person offering their opinion should understand that there is a possibility that we won't. How do you handle differing opinions? Using your philosophy, someone is bound to be offended in a situation where there are multiple differing opinions.

by vltiii

When the victim is the manager. Victim and manager are contradictory in this situation. Manager-Authority. Subordinate-No authority (or less authority best case).

by vltiii

People are responsible for their actions. The manager is responsible for squelching them in this case. Your reaching a lot of conclusions i.e. "just wants to push buttons", without having all of the facts.

by jmgarvin

Sure, I could be jumping to conclusions, but from what the poster said, I'm dead on the money.

People in the work place need to not only handle themselve professionally and deal with superiors in the same manner, but they need to learn how to act in a social situation.

The manager is a young manager who doesn't quite know how to handle this and clearly the subordinate is taking advantage of this. She is working the manager because she wanted the job and is upset that he/she took the position. I'm sure this subordinate can handle themselves professionally, but they chose not to.

I've posted what the manager should do and why he/she should do it. Further, clearly the subordinate is angry about the chapter 11 re-org, doesn't know her job very well, and is trying to remove a young manager because of envy.

by baal

Is it any wonder IT 'Managers' are not seen as actual 'Managers' by their peers. Why must the solution always be along the lines of reprimand, sack or hand the problem to HR? This person however obnoxious she appears obviously either has friends higher up the ladder or has proved she can make a valuable contribution to the company (thats why shes still there. She 'had' a comfort zone (5 years) but that has been disrupted by change of role and change of Manager. You should sit down with her (and not hidden away in a private room) and acknowledge to her that you both seem to have got off on the wrong foot. Acknowledge that she has great value to you (she has 5 years company exp)and explain that you have found it difficult to draw on her expertise in company related instances because 'you' believe that your approach is misinterpreted. 'Ask' her what you can do to repair the situation and reach a compromise. Have a similar meeting (individually tailored) with each of your department members, then have a full team meeting and explain that you have now listened to and accepted everyones input to how the department can work better together. Explain that above all else you are all professionals and the dept must be seen as prof by all other employees of the company. You believe that by presenting a solid team approach and supporting one another the dept can move forward and show the rest of the company that above all else the IT dept is a professional team. Then tell them that you are going to appoint a team captain position which each person will have a chance to wear the cap. Each week the Team capt is appointed in turn (either alphabeticaly or similar that gives your 'obnoxious' employee third shot at the role - never first or last) the capt has the responsibility of maintaining morale and sorting out tasks etc for their week. Each other member gets a turn to vote on how they did at the end of the week. When every member has been in the role a team meeting can be called where each one tells of their experience and the others can give their verdict on how they did. Eventually all staff members will be aware of each others 'people' skills or failings. After nearly 30 years of doing this I can honestly say I have always (yes always) ended up with the best team I could have asked for - Remember 'Everyone' has a value you just have to let them show it.

by vltiii

By bringing in a Conflict Resolution Specialist, the manager is essentially stating that she has failed and cannot handle the situation. Bringing in a specialist is an option, but it should be the last option when all else has failed. Even in a last effort situation, I'm not particulary keen on bringing in someone else to resolve personnel problem especially when it sounds as if it's a one on one issue. If the managers whole department were revolting then I'd be more amenable. I believe that professionals understand the heirarchy and the lines of authority. A professional accepts their place within that heirarchy. Based on that, if the situation came to the point of needing to bring in a specialist, I would probably be more incline to dismiss the employee before I payed someone to do what I haven't been able to do. Of course if the manager is the problem, that is an issue her bosses need to look at and apply the same philosophy. As has been mentioned we don't know all of the details and one poster astutely noted that we're only hearing one side of the story. The manager needs to use all the tools at her disposal to resolve this, including seeking advice from other more seasoned managers, her supervisors, HR, etc. We don't know that there is a conflict. We only know that the manager has a problem with this individual.

by vltiii

You've reached a lot of conslusions about why this employee is acting the way she is that have never been stated by the original poster. There have been a wide range of recommendations posted including talking with the employee to get to the root of the problem. In fact most of the more well thought out post included counseling (talking if you want to play symantics). Most of the more well thought out post only recommend firing, reprimanding, etc after trying other less severe alternatives first. Firing is a tool at the disposal of a manager. Whether we like it or not, there are times when this tool must be used for the overall good of the organization. And, just for the record, I'm not terribly concerned about how my peers view my status. My employer pays me to do a job and I'm going to do that job to the best of my ability. What my peers think is inconsequential. What my boss' think, not that is something to be concerned about.

by andyharrop_11

I have such a person within my section. The good thing is that i am louder. One thing is for sure even though you think you are being beaten. Other people have respect for you as you are a 'johnny on the spot' the man that does.
What i have found is you need to insert a hard drive into the oral pipe that is known as the mouth, of this person! Sometimes actions speak louder than words.
Good luck and don't back down!!!!!!

by love challenges

I was in the similar situation. My staff will tell me he'll never break the rules or go against the security policy, but I caught him a few times doing just that - with solid proof! I spoke to him and each time he'll give me plenty of excuses - From "don't know" to "I think we shd make people happy!".. "Why make our life so miserable??" and it never works... At last, I seek the help of our HR Mgr - unfortunately, our HR Mgr, being very bias & personal, simply gave me 'Lip service'. On 1 hand, she advised me to give my staff verbal warning - which she'll do but on the other hand, she just keep mum. Can you imagine the shock I got from her (1 year after I spoke to her twice to issue warning letter to my staff?) - she'd never spoke to my staff! She felt that my staff was great - always attending to her requests & was very prompt! And she 'thought' I was just sharing my unhappiness with her only ... This just showed that even HR Mgr - though attended security training before, still do not understand what's security and is very naive ... ???
Therefore, bottomline, if the people around you are not supportive and are naive, forget abt it, just carry on with your Mgr role...!

by ntguru

Sometimes it's not easy for older people to be under the supervision of someone younger, as there may be some reserved resentment. My sugesstion is to speak firmly to her and move forward!!!

by jerrym mcse+i / a+

you stated the issue right at the start. She's mid 40's and you are younger. She's probably feeling alot of insecurity and likely put in for your job before you got it. She probably feels like she's "been there, done that" and why the heck did some young punk come in and take "my" job???

Feeling like she has to prove she's better than you is definately insecurities.... most people don't realize that managers don't have to be technical or have all the answers. They are free to be total dimwits when it comes to technology. Now what managers must be able to do is manage resources, projects, and timelines to meet goals and budgets.

If she's good at what she does I'd see about having a Female HR representative sit in with you two and maybe talk about the situation and perhaps offer her an opportunity to see a professional to help her deal with her feelings.
jermo

by malcolm_pattison

Hi:

Don?t worry your not alone; this type of activity among workforces is common.
What you?re dealing with is a person who has been passed over and thinks she has been around long enough to be given a management post on merit alone. As you will be probably aware not in this day and age.

As a manager take it with a pinch of salt and don?t let her autocratic way of using an audience to get a point over bother you, 95% of people with her attitude will never be a manager as long as they live due to their attitude alone. If was you here is a few things I would have a look at.

a. Pull her in and have a chat with her tell her that you value her experience and input on certain aspects of work. Explain to her that if she has anything to input on anything specific to speak to you one on one and explain the bigger picture to her.

b. Give her a project make it hard and see what kind of reaction she gives you, this is a good way of calling her bluff, and do it in front of the work force that?s also a good way of reviling a bluffer to the rest of your department.

c. This is the hard one always be nice treat her firm fair but friendly.

A good manager always has a line drawn you don?t have to be the best friend of everyone in the department to be a good manager, people follow respect and respect is earned. Use your education over bluff, and remember experienced workers have a very short limit, try and surpass that limit, so that you stand well above.

Experience in a workforce is vital and you need to mould this experience to how you want to use it not how they want to use you.

Be strong stand your ground you don?t have to shout scream and bollick people to do this, be tactful, resourceful ho yes and did I say be NICE always be nice.

Regards

MP
MCMI

by guardianoz

I agree with you about asserting your position to any subordinate, however this is more about timing.

With regards to management I am a very strong believer in tried and tested methods.
The first approach should be mutual respect, regardless of age, however we all know that this is not often the reality or you would not be in this position now.

Secondly adapting to Dale Carnegie's methodologies in ?how to win friends and influence people? can be a way to get an employee on side, which is a great way of maintaining their knowledge but also winning their support. Winning the support from an employee with years of experience is great, but also the relationship and the significance of that relationship to you (for other to see) is priceless.

Last but not least, is going down the very hard and fast path of enforcing your position onto them.
Firstly, write up their letter of warning, giving several reasons for the letter ?support, disruptive, non productive, undermining behavior etc? but also state that someone of their experience and capabilities is not only of great value to the business but also very valuable to you as their superior. This way you are not just giving them a kick in the rear, but you are letting them know if they can get on board and work with you that you see them as important.

If they can not understand the letter or mature to their role, things pretty much will not change, so I would suggest that you start drafting their second and then final letter, cutting them loose as soon as possible.

REMEMBER: it is all about timing, if you do not address the issues fast enough you become more limited in the options that are always available to you from the commencement of your initial appointment.

This discussion is closed to new replies.