Discussion Locked

Member signature phase 1 is live

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Today, we launched the first phase of a new Member Signature, our first (of many) new Community features. The Signature provides more information about each of our members as well as more opportunities for other members to interact with them.

One of the new pieces of information that we will be displaying is the Site Activity Rating. The Rating, which is represented by a status meter, shows how active that member has been on the site in the past 30 days. It is still in beta; however, the algorithm that we have built to drive it is scalable so that it can be tweaked and enhanced over time.

The second phase of the Member Signature will launch over the next couple of weeks. This phase will include:

1. Ability to add a photo or avatar (that members host) to the Signature

2. Addition of Signature to Technical Q&A pages

3. Addition of a Top 100 status message to the Signatures of our Top 100 members (#47 of Top 100 members)

4. Addition of a Top 100 listing page that displays all of the Top 100 members

Let us know of changes/tweaks/additions you'd like to make to the signature. Thanks.

25 replies

by apotheon

While I certainly understand the need to have members host their own photos/avatars, that strikes me as a potentially dangerous solution to bandwidth issues. It's possible that this could lead to abuse of the feature, including introduction of JPEG exploits and inappropriate images. Are there any ideas for how to defend against that sort of thing?

by oz_media

When inaaprorpiate material is posted here, it is VERY quickly reported to the editors and gets removed. Now as for viral jpeg's etc. well let's just hope TR has a way to scan uploaded photo's before posting them.
But as for inappropriate, you should see some of the stuff that's been removed, some is a 50/50 toss up of SOME people find it offensive and others didn't, in which case those offended are given the benefit of the doubt and the post is pulled. They don't moderate as much as they respond to user complaints.

by smorty71

Oz,
Ultimately, we want the community to be self-policing.

It is our hope that users will keep the photos or avatars on the "appropriate" side of the spectrum since the images will represent them everywhere they post on the site. Plus, we will provide a suggestion on the photo attachment page that reminds people that they should keep the images clean.

However, we know that there will always be someone who posts something just to see if they can get it through.

Inappropriate photos will just be something we'll have to deal with on a case-by-case basis until we can let moderators share in those responsibilities.

sm

by smorty71

I may have spoken out of turn when I suggested that users host the images. I will definitely let our engineers determine the best (and most secure) approach to those images.

My thought was that it would shorten the time to market for the feature. However, I hadn't yet considered the potential security implications.

You all aren't scared of a little malicious code are you? :)

Thanks for pointing that out.
sm

by oz_media

It is amazing what a single pixel is capable of isn't it?

It is almost a microscience in that respect.
Can you not have a simple engine scanning of uploaded images? You wouldn't need to scan each and every post, just the image upload section of the profile page when signing. or even have it posted to a secondary source (such as yourself or some other employee) that is physically checked, time depending and added afterwards.

by hal 9000

But I wonder is the Location of the Peer is currently restricted to the USA/Canada as mine doesn't appear and I've just had a look see to make sure that I have everything correct.

As far as making the engineers work better and faster a long stock whip tends to let them know you mean business but you can not play favorites who ever screws up or isn't pulling their weight needs some form of incentive to pick up their game. When I was told that I could no longer threaten either the Staff or the Dealers I just replied I wasn't threating them but using "Aversion Therapy" which was far less painful than the then medically accepted methods.

Col :D

by smorty71

Colin
I think it should display any location, not just US and Canada. Let me get with our engineers and see what we can figure out.

sm

by thechas

In general, the Signature looks good.

I find the selected discussion threads interesting.

I think the added ease of contacting peers should go a long way to fixing some of the TQ&A problems.

Chas

by house

The addition of the meter looks wicked. I don't know if anyone else has been experiencing the same issues as 'apotheon', but it looks great on my end.

I can't wait for the photos to start rolling in when you release that feature. I'm sure it'll be good for a few laughs. I don't know about the rest of you folks, but I'm slapping on my actual face. It might be flagged as offensive though.

I'm sure we'll see everyone's favorite avatar too. These are the ones that we'll probably have to flag as offensive. I've seen some pretty nasty ones on some Chat contacts of mine.

How are we going to draw the line between offensive and not so offensive? I guess we'll have to wait and see. I'm not really offended by anything...but some people like to complain. "Politically Correct" is a term that I associate with the works of George Orwell. I would hope though that there is no nudity, racism, bad language, etc. It would make us all look very unprofessional to a new subscriber.

by hal 9000

A photo of myself taken after I dropped a car on myself. That resulted in a two week hospital stay as I was purple from about the nipple line up.

When I got pulled out I was bleeding from the ears, eyes, nose and a small cut on my head that only required 20 odd stitches but the Ambulance guys where really funny I don't know who or why they where called but I was sitting on the ground having a smoke when they arrived they went ballistic then proceeded to insert 6 IV lines refused to allow me to walk to the ambulance as I may have suffered serious injuries so they dumped me on a back board with a neck brace and then proceeded to move me that way. The only problem is that the guy at my head was so fat that he forced my neck to bend quite dramatical luckily I wasn't really hurt or there may have been a problem with that one.

Even people who have known me for years fail to recognize me in those pictures or maybe I could cut out just my eyes from one of them as the whites are blood red. I'll have to put some thought into this.

Col :D

by house

A few years ago, a friend of mine got into a fight, and ended up with black eye. Not uncommon though...Literally...his eyeball itself was black - sickest thing I've seen on a face.

I'll look forward to that one - Are you serious about posting it? Sounds like Aussies are just as crazy as us. Nothing like a good smoke after a traumatic blow to the head.

Chris

by oz_media

The most descriptive picture of me I could put online would be pulled for being too explicit.

I even had a little hat and some fake eyes I was gonna put on it. :)

by Member 29327465

I don't mean to be dense, but what specifically can be hidden in a pixel? I know about html-based cross scripting exploits, but what is there to look for in jpgs.

Ned Rhinelander (TR Engineering)

by oz_media

I am not malicious myself,well not technically malicious that is.

Is it not true that an entire script can be embedded into a single pixel of a jpeg? When the jpeg is loaded so is the script?

Here's another issue, obviously in this case it does require an executable but is triggered from an infected jpeg.
http://www.geek.com/news/geeknews/2002june/gee20020614012193.htm

Granted other similar scripts also need to be 'fried' by an executable, but what if the virus is resident in psople's
PC's and then 'fired' by viewing an infected image on TR?

There are some pretty good security experts here (not I), perhaps they can elaborate for me.

by Member 29327465

I did a little more research,

JPEG's are not executable, I think that the link you sent earlier was reporting a virus that changed the jpeg interpreter to allow execution of code..this is obviously very different, as damage would be limited to infected machines.

However, here is one of the legitimate concerns:

http://www.microsoft.com/technet/security/bulletin/ms04-028.mspx

This involves a buffer overrun...which is I suppose a way of making a jpeg executable.

However, this is such a severe flaw, that I wonder if it's really introducing much of a risk for TR members...the internet is full of graphics hosted elsewhere. (akamai, 3rd party ad servers, etc.). It seems to me that if an exploit were released, the only possible way of combatting it would be through the client. So, I personally don't see much of a security risk to allow 3rd party graphics, at least in the non-commerce portions of the site.

btw, I also read that there is a server-side exploit in a module called 'imagemagik', which would affect any servers that were engaged in reformatting images...

If anyone has any better information or conflicting viewpoints I'd love to hear them.

by oz_media

I think Colin sent me that picture once, quite flattering I must say! LOL :D Colin at his best?

I have some good pitcures of my car wrecks, 'car wreck'...just about sums up MOST of my life. :p

by oz_media

I figured it was something like an small executable on an infected machine that was activated by the code in the jpeg as it was downloaded. Therefore anyone infected, which could be a massive audience if the coed is unobtrusive enough to go unnoticed, would automatically get nailed when the jpeg loaded.

by apotheon

I forgot this thread existed, and had forgotten to subscribe to it so that I'd get notifications of new messages after I posted here. Anyhow, after finding it again, another thought occurs to me about the idea of allowing images to be hosted elsewhere: If you host the images here, you can test images as they're uploaded to be sure they're the right size (both height and width limits and maximum filesize limits).

As I think about it, though, I'm becoming more interested in the idea of user avatars. It should be interesting, at least, to see how the various TRIs choose to represent themselves visually.

by apotheon

That image is a quite flattering representation of you. I think you should go with it.

Well, maybe not. It might be considered "inappropriate".

by house

As if I would use that pic. I wouldn't even post that url anywhere in the open forums. Thanks to TRI, we can have a little bit of fun without offending the masses.

I can't wait to see the inappropriate avatars that are going to show up.

by bfilmfan

Apotheon is the old lady that wouldn't let me over in traffic this morning! Who woulda thought it!

by oz_media

Actually they did a similar thing wit hthe featured posts a while back. I have a real issue with people taking my picture candidly so I don't have any without me sticking up A finger to ruin it. (brings back a funny story!)

I sent them a picture of when I was about 19 or 20, whatever right?

I think it would be MORE amusing to see people's baby or toddler pictures than their latest photo's. People can still retain their privacy as you wouldn't recognize them in the street anyway.

Oh, the story...I went through a phase where we used to rat race our cars around Stanley Park's winding roads. I mean RAT race, e-brake slides around hairpins and literally bumping doors trying to get position for corners and running each other off the road, hey we were bored okay? It's the GOVERNMENT's fault for not entertaining us.

Stanley Park is the #1 spot for wedding pics in Vancouver, so we'd be flying aroud and have to come to a halt for some big limo to let out 10 peple in gowns for photos, when we drive by them as they were taking pictures, we'd hang out the window and moon or give them the finger. Something most wouldn't notice in the background until a special family member has a good look at the picture.

Hey I have NEVER said I was a good teenager!

by hal 9000

As the Pollies already do it {over this side of the pond at least} and we still can recognize then although they all bear very little resemblance to their electoral photos particuarly the women who seem to think that they have to look like someone in their mid 20's to get elected.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.