Discussion Locked

Misuse of this site

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It seems to me that every time I look at the new discussions...people are opening a discussion when they should actually be using the Q and A Section. Are these people trying to get answers without sacrificing any TechPoints or are they just not aware of how the site works??

In my slack time (not very often I get any!) I enjoy the forums and will actively join in an interesting discussion but the last two or three that caught my attention have all been plain and simple tech questions. What do other members feel about this? I'm personally happy to help anyone, TechPoints or not...I just feel that if people want to put a question like 'where do I find drivers for....' it shouldn't end up in the Discussion area!!

Mike :-)

7 replies

by bushroller

I do agree. When people ask for drivers or contact information, this should be done in Q&A.

Mind you, how many of the people that use this site are actually IT professionals, and how many are just novices looking for help because someone told then to 'try TechRepublic'?

Not only that, but as a site gets more popular, the percentage of errant users remains roughtly the same but the sheer numbers increase. Perhaps the site should function like a 'professional body' such as the IEERE or IEETE/IEEE. If a 'professional' subscription was levied, that would instantly weed out the unwanted! Mind you, that would then defeat the object of this site as a free forum for discussion and mutual help.

It seems misplaced questions are just anotherone of life's niggles...like with Microsoft; generally not too bad overall but has it's irritations!

GWB

by guruofdos

Perhaps TR should introduce a 'Banish Button'. If a user posts a question to a discussion forum, other users who feel that it should be posted in Q&A could hit the 'Banish Button' next to the user name, generating an event somewhere on the server. Agiven level of 'Banish Button Events' (no more than one per member - so as not to leave the system open to abuse) could trigger a 'polite' email informing the user that the question will be removed from Discussions and re-posted to Q&A....after theyhave allocated the appropriate TechPoints, of course!

It's just a thought....

Mike :-)

by guruofdos

What is the difference between a Technical Q&A posting and a Discussion Center posting?

If you have a technical question that needs a definitive or technical answer, you'll be best served to post the question in the Technical Q&A area of our site. You will need to have TechPoints to post a technical question, because you award points to the TechRepublic member or members who give you useful answers.

The Discussion Center is where you can discuss relevant IT topics, such as technology, career, and management, with other IT professionals. No TechPoints are needed to participate in these discussions, and there are no right or wrong answers. Think of this as an online team meeting with other IT professionals participating.

by natcat

I'm not going to attempt to explain anyone elses behaviour.

But there is a very thin line between a discussion and a question in real life. Actually most questions lead to discussions in real life.

Sometime you don't want a simple answer to a question. You want people to repsond with thier OPINIONS and then have people make responses directly to those opinions.

Other times, you just need a direct answer yes or no or an explaination. Not to see other points of view.

by tomsal

They should of seen this "misuse" coming a mile away.

TechPoints, and I know this was debated 100 times, are basically worthless.

Big deal you earn techpoints for answering questions and the incentive is to attract more responses to your questions by offering more techpoints.

There's no REAL value to tech points, as was promised initially by TR I might add, so not to be rude or arrogant or whatever but what did you expect would happen?

If TechPoints had a value, like even 10000 points gives you 25% off a TechPro subscription or 50000 points awards you any one single book or guide published by Tech Republic, then the Q & A would be more attractive to post too.

The dicussion boards are easier to read, are better organized and I think are easier to find than Q & A...mix that with the aforementioned lack of value to tech points and I don't find difficulty in understanding why the misuse is happening.

by radiic

I remeber hearing about TR at the 99 Atlanta Networld/Interop convension. They said that I would get all sorts of points and that the points would be good for products and stuff. So much for that...

Otherwise the only good thing about the points is to see the little 5k or 10k next to your name. Wow I feel so much better now...lol

I also have to agree that some questions need discussion, but you can still discuss it when its a tech Q/A, although that area is not as good as it could be.
My 3 cents.

Rad

by admin

The whole system over there sux, IMO.
If anyone wants tech points for answering any of my questions, just ask me and I'm happy to oblige.

Maybe there should be a feature where if you say something I want to reward, I can just click on your nameand gratefully award you points, or, of course, also if you request them and I agree to pay I can just award them... otherwise it's "hey, meet me in Q&A and answer some stupid made up just for you to get points question so I can give them to you..."

Another thing about points, while I'm at it, is that the people who have the most answers that are useable often have the most points and the people who need good answers have the least. This is ludicrous. The people who need answers should be able to post lots of points for them and on the demand for answers side, the people answering should actually need or want points. It's the suckiest system ever and I don't even go over there anymore. Lot's of bad answers, hurt feelings and bad questions to sort through. I'm not likely to take time out of my day for this. On the other hand, The Discussion area is actually something I look forward to and enjoy, and I get to reach a fulfilling level of conversation I don't get with my co-workers about (admittedly sometimes barely :>) IT related stuff.

This discussion is closed to new replies.