General discussion

Locked

Modem Throughput

By raatkins ·
Has anyone ever seen or done a comparison between ISA and PCI bus modems? Specifically USR sportsters. Assume all updated drivers and firmware, v.90, typical connection 52k.
thanks for your input.

This conversation is currently closed to new comments.

9 total posts (Page 1 of 1)  
| Thread display: Collapse - | Expand +

All Comments

Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by veeray In reply to Modem Throughput

I get many variations on this question, almost daily. The answer is related to many factors, PCI bus speed, CPU speed, Hardware and Phone Lines. The Throughput shouldn't be affected by all of these, but experience has shown me that it is. A new system with a 133 bus and high speed CPU will use a PCI modem to gain the fastest throughput, always assuming there is a path for the data, (connection speed) An Isa modem will sometimes outperform a PCI if the system is slower and older, not to mention if the PCI bus speed is slower.
The final analysis relates to the actual modem, no two modems perform exactly the same way in the same conditions. A current example would be the infamous Athena modem, by Conexant (Rockwell chipset) Three of these in the same system on the same phone line with the same drivers ect., will perform with wildly different attributes, one may not connect at all, another may constantly lose configuration, and the third will consistantly connect at 50k and remain sofor days. As a resul

Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by raatkins In reply to Modem Throughput
Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by raatkins In reply to Modem Throughput

thanks for everybodys input, it was informative.
Robert

Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by kyle In reply to Modem Throughput

Well....Like the first response stated, there are alot of variables in the throughput benchmark. Are you reffering to internal throughput from the modem to the bus or from the net to the modem? Ill assume you mean net to modem. In that case your MAIN drawback is your phone lines. Any ISP tech knows how big of a role lines play in the internet game. While bus and processor speed and so on affect the throughput from card to bus and so on....
they do not affect net to card. So there are two levels of throughput to measure. ISA and PCI are very different in the internal level of throughput. But as far as Kbps....they are irrelevant.

Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by raatkins In reply to Modem Throughput
Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by raatkins In reply to Modem Throughput

thanks for everybodys input, it was informative.
Robert

Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by tchieng In reply to Modem Throughput

If you're talking about speed, there is no difference between an ISA and PCI model. The answers above are correct. Your connection speed is dependant on line quality as well as the quality of the modems on both ends. So you think you're connected at52kb? Point your browser to the URL below to get an reasonably accurate through put test. You'll probably find that its effective through put is only in the 35kb range.

http://www.computingcentral.msn.com/topics/bandwidth/speedtest50.asp

Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by raatkins In reply to Modem Throughput
Collapse -

Modem Throughput

by raatkins In reply to Modem Throughput

thanks for everybodys input, it was informative.
Robert

Back to Community Forum
9 total posts (Page 1 of 1)  

Related Discussions

Related Forums