Discussion Locked

Negativity..Is it just me, or anyone else noticed..

0 helpful
150 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

150 replies

by the scummy one

what did you think of that chocolate surprise cupcake thingy?
The caramel, when prepared in a specific way turns crumbly like a cookie (oh, btw -- I used too much chocolate with it)

After it happened, I was able to re-create the steps on purpose (and made the cupcake thingy's). Just more notes for my collection.

by michael jay

I did not have any of the chocolate surprise cupcake thingy, but the girls said that it tasted like a reeses peanut butter cup, only better.

by the scummy one

it had peanuts chopped up.
With how few I used, I was surprised at the overpowering peanut butter flavor.
(or even peanut butter flavor at all).

Oh and I was also surprised how well the caramel flavor was covered -- it comes out as an aftertaste

by justin james

A few of the folks in this thread have mentioned that this seems to be cyclical, and especially bad during the holiday season. For the last few years, I've noticed the opposite, around this time of year, nearly all comments to the Programming & Development blogs (not just what I post in it, the whole category) cease entirely. On the flip side, I can count on one hand the number of outright "you stink!" style posts on a yearly basis anyways, probably.

Not sure why this is, or what we're doing right (or wrong!), but it *is* something I've noticed. Last year, some of my best content ever (in my opinion) came out in the tail end of the year, and it went without much comment. Heck, it was even mildly controversial, too!

Some times, I suspect that high quality content in the purely (or mostly) factual realm draws few comments, other than the occassional "Thanks!" or "Good job!" style comment. As soon as you get into the opinion type stuff, regardless of how well done it is, or how well argued it is, you have the chance of seeing hecklers.

But I really can't speak outside of the P & D blog space... in all honesty, while I read a number of the other blogs on TR, I typically don't have the time to read the comments as well, particularly in a long thread.

Another theory of mine, is that the "typical" reader of the P & D blogs saves their vacation time until the end of the year. Many developers I've met do that, and many projects unconciously expect it. We break our backs all year, and from Thanksgiving to the new year, we use all of the time off, and while we *are* in the office we tend to take it easy. After all, hard to work when everyone you need information from is out anyways...

I also like to think that the P & D readers are also a bunch of super nice people who think the world of me, Tony, and the other folks who post to P & D. :)

J.Ja

by tig2

People reading and responding in your blog have more than two brain cells to rub together- and it shows. Impassioned discussions in P&D (Hungarian notation, anyone) tend to involve more concrete and defined elements. Easier to have rational discussion!

My best discussion was on the COBOL question- is it still valid. A great many people weighed in on that and it stayed rooted to the topic- for the most part. But even there, I saw some level of digression.

You seem to be blessed among bloggers. I envy that.

by justin james

... read the item reviews/comments on the WWE's online store someday for some laughs. Oddly enough, I spotted a John Cena yarmulke (I can imagine showing up for Passover in one of those...) there too. Didn't get any customer reviews though.

Yes, I was perusing the WWE online store, extensively. No, I was not shopping for myself, although I must admit, in the last few months I started watching it... it's like a soap opera, for men. If they made new episodes of Twin Peaks, or if Criminal Intent had started new episodes in November like they were supposed to do, I probably never would have gotten sucked into WWE so easily... as it is, my TV watching has devolved into Hannah Montana, SpongeBob, and WWE...

J.Ja

by Member 19291532

Shelbot...

First...

The "Toni doesn't want a hug" blog...

Toni is one of the site contributors I find myself disagreeing with on a consistent basis. Toni focuses on soft HR issues, and personally, I've had to restrain myself from ad hominem attacks on her, simply because she *looks* so much like a typical HR staff "Group Counselor". I suppose just saying that is a personal attack that has nothing to do with her writing, according to the Politically Correct - but I think that if you can *predict* (with a high probability of being correct) that the guy getting out of the Suburu Forester is going to be balding, wearing a tweed jacket with patches on the arms and with round, metal frame glasses, or will be an older woman with a disheveled, snow white hair, a hemp sweater, and birkenstocks with wool socks - you're on to something more than a random stereotype.

Please don't confuse my cynicism with negativity. We're not all drinking the happy Kool-Aide and living a utopian dream of world peace.

Anybody ever seen the classic movie "Heathers"? You know the teacher with the bean bags in her class instead of desks that wants to explore everyone's "feelings" after the suicide?

Yeah... *exactly*...

I have strong opinions on people who are drawn to HR, counselling, social work, and the like.

But listen, ShellBot... if my worldview doesn't taints the tint of your rose colored glasses, I never said you had to be my friend, agree or even like me.

And I'm hardly hiding behind a wall of anonyminity.

Second: Tech Republic consistently publishes articles under inflamatory headlines *designed* to encourage lively discussion. Lively discussion, by nature, requires two *passionate* and opposite perspectives. Guess what, the side you *don't* agree with is ALWAYS going to sound negative to *you*. To the other side, it sounds like the voice of logic, reason and obvious truth.

I didn't realize that we were supposed to sit here in the forums and hum khum-buy-yah in a circle and agree blindly that the iPhone rocks, Linux rules, and Vista is the next Windows ME, otherwise we would be labeled "neagative"...

by shellbot

but your giving yourself WAY too much credit here.

I started this thread because of the many "personal attacks" on blog discussions on here over the past 6 months or so. I've accused you on nothing in this thread..as I was thinking in general terms, not about anyone specific.

I'm sorry, but I only know of your posts from the thread where we clashed. So I cannot pass judgement on any other of your posts.

I personally don't give a rats what goes on in the general forums..I am guilty of saying rude things myself..and have instigated more than my share of sh!t throwing.

And guess what, the side I *don't* agree with is not always negative to *me*. maybe you have me mistaken somebody you know? Please don't assume to tell me what I am and how I think without being familiar with me.

My problem is that people are saying personal mean things about the bloggers, and thier work. Feel free to disagree all you want..thats what discussion is all about..but there is a line.

For instance if you wrote a blog and I disagreed with your ideas, I'd be pretty quick to say "Get F*cked" and argue my point, however, I would not say "Your useless and ugly and your work is sh!t"
Lively discussion is good, if you've been around more than a few months you'd know I cross the line in certain threads a good bit..I'm better behaved now..but I wasn't always so..

Do you understand the distinction between personal attacks and differing points of view? You seem to think everything is one in the same. An iphone is a waste of space, a person isn't.. (well..ok..some are but ye know what I mean)

I think you misunderstand some of my politeness (and attempt at humour) for being a p*ssy. I have no desire to explore anyones feelings..I have no rose colored glasses..

Feel free to knock the cr@p out of Vista and Linux..Linux is sh!t.
Vista..well..I'm on the fence..as a user i like it..but as a developer its a peice of sh!t.

So basically, what I'm saying is, there have been a lot of fly by night posters being @ssholes the past few months.. AKA seagulls

As I said before, chill out..you take yourself way to seriously mate..life only happens once, have fun with it.

A merry christmas to you and yours..and hey..I'll be on over the hols..stirring sh!t..pop in and join the fun !! :)

by jdclyde

Some discussions do get more "lively", but once someone starts to bash, the discussion is over and it is now a pissing contest.

Guess it all depends on what you are looking for, huh?

Merry whatever you believe in.

:D

by jiminpa

you probably think this song is about you...

come on guys sing it with me you know the words... right? :0

by tig2

Toni Bowers is the Senior blogs editor. She manages several blogs including Leadership and Career. She also writes.

The situation that you are referring to was out of line. Period. No excuse. The OP responding to the "Hug" blog had attacked her in the responses to a different blog and then went digging THREE YEARS BACK to find a blog that had never been responded to in order to attack again. The only reason that thread wasn't sent to Silicon Hell is because Toni chose to stand for the right of each individual to express an opinion. In that same light, the very strong community that exists here chose to express an opinion with regard to that OP.

Shellbot is also a long-standing member of the community who sees that this level of negativity is not a positive thing. She has an opinion and chose to voice it. At no time did she suggest that the community should join hands and sing Kum-Bi-Yah. She voiced an opinion.

As a regular contributor to TR, I title my blogs in a manner that is consistent with the content. I also try to find a title that is attention grabbing enough that it entices the reader. Oddly enough, this practice is not uncommon. Check out the front page of any newspaper. Or go read recent contributions on any other technical website whose content is provided by specific individuals. Journalistically, TR does nothing out of the ordinary.

We value all of the people that make up the TR community and recognize that opposing viewpoints are the foundation of healthy debate. Please do not suggest that mere nastiness should be tolerated as a foundation for discussion.

by jck

no need to add.

jdclyde is just jealous that I will be having pints with you and he won't :^0

so...what would you like for Christmas, Shell? :)

by shellbot

hmm..

well.. the material side of me wants:
a small Radly handbag

the immaterial side of me wants to spend xmas with my kid..but not happening..so..ya..maybe I'll get that handbag after all..

one or two other things are on the list..but can't tell you what they are..
]:)

What about you..what did you wish for ?

by jck

the material side of me: the winning FL Lotto Ticket for Christmas Eve, so I could tell my parents Christmas day..."We need to go on vacation. How's Jamaica sound?"

the romantic side of me: a letter from Ms. Corr saying that so many of my friends have written her about me, that she would like to have a cuppa with me, then go to the cinema, and to take a walk in St. Stephen's Green and talk with one another. (pipe dream? lol)

the kid inside of me: wished for another LCD TV to put in my bedroom to replace the TV i'm taking to put in my parents spare room.

the lazy side of me: a maid, so i don't have to clean house anymore. :^0

the nurturing side of me: a wife and kids, cause i'm sick of being alone and not having anyone to love and hug

DOH! ok...getting reminiscent...and sappy...and blah. back to revamping VBA code!!! lol :^0

by jck

I have 8 of them, after all :^0

Maybe I'll bring the one signed by James Taylor and the daughter Sally he and Carly had together.

Gosh...can we sing Kumbayah next? or, maybe I'll break into "So Young" lol :^0

by tig2

Maybe I can find a couple of trolls to rub together to make a fire.

I have graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallows. I sense S'mores in the future!

by jessie

Nobody asks me what *I* want for Christmas? Ya'll just don't love me anymore. See what happens when I go away for a while... you completely forget about me and move on with your lives.

Anyway, what I want for Christmas is Peace, Love, and Happiness, all of which I'll be getting because I'll be spending the day with the hubby and kiddos.

A bonus would be a house that's clean without me cleaning or yelling at anyone, but I'll [i]settle[/i] for Peace, Love and Happiness.

Merry Christmas to all!!!

by Member 19291532

I'm not giving myself too much credit, you just haven't come across enough of my posts. You're not giving me ENOUGH credit. Evidence? Look at your general tone in the few posts we've had, versus your tone in this one singular post. I think I've done my job, here. Nothing like getting the guy in the tye-dyed VW Van with the "Envision World Peace" bumper sticker to start screaming that he'll rip your effin' head off, but still.

I'm not talking about general forums, I'm talking about blog posts (well, I'm talking about any post, anywhere. Being staff doesn't make you special, to me). Toni is one of my favorite targets. I could care less about how she looks or what kind of person she is. Many of her posts leave me going, "Are you FSCKing KIDDING me?!?" And I'm not shy about calling her on it. The way she looks and the kind of person she seems to be really *begs* me to make personal attacks, but I'm cautious of that trap. I can certainly see how other posters would be tempted to go there, though. Even Frank Zappa, sufficiently provoked, isn't above telling a Senator to kiss his @ss.

Attacking her work, or the perceived quality of her opinion, is fair game if she wants to post in a public forum. Being a site contributor doesn't make her immune to that. Listen, even if they want to cut off the ability to comment about her in THIS forum, there is nothing preventing anyone from commenting on the quality of her work 1000 other places on the Net.

You keep going back to that "If you've been around here for any length of time". It is a big site, I don't think you really know how long I've been around Tech Republic. It is a little arrogant to assume that you do. Just an observation.

I mean, in theory, I agree with you. I think the problem is that the line is in different places for different people - just like a sense of humor. You have been entertained by pieces that I thought were a waste of bandwidth, I've written pieces that were very entertaining that left you flat. A lot of it seems to depend on your point of perspective.

We're not having an academic debate here, so I don't see that we need to strictly apply avoiding ad hominem attacks. Extrapolating opinions on an author based on the opinion they express seems fair game here. I mean, you and the group who follows your posts seem to feel quite comfortable doing this - for example, when you disagree with the sexist philosophy of a poster. I didn't see a rational discuss of the lack of value of sexist philosophy, I saw you calling the guy a caveman, a moron, and a relic. Um - that is an ad hominem attack. "Ahh, but ours was justified, because we were correct".

No... it is POSSIBLE that his sexist philosophy is valid - we don't know, because you guys started attacking HIM, not his philosophy - all the while crucifying him for ad hominem attacks. Quick, can anyone name THE other two logical fallacies mentioned in the last two paragraphs including this one?

And before you get too caught up in this above, you're the one who questioned if I understood the difference between an "attack on the man" and attacking the subject at hand, so I didn't go here. It we want to get into the rules of academic debate, I did quite well on the team, thank you.

You keep telling me to chill out. I didn't start this thread, and I'm not the one who seems worked up about it. I'm having fun taking the position I've taken and presenting my case. Again, if you feel there is tension here, maybe you should look inward and take your own advice? I'm cool. You're actually kind of fun to have these discussions with, you're much better at this than many of those who seem to post supporting replies in your threads. They bore me. Anyone can stir the sh!t, but doing it skillfully is a rare talent.

Merry Christmas to you, too. :)

by shellbot

Thanks for the compliment DC.. ]:)

I stand in awe of a bigger @ss than myself :)

Its been fun mate..catch ya around over the holidays..I'm sure I can whine and b1tch about something you've posted!!

And just to try and get in the last word..
""I didn't see a rational discuss of the lack of value of sexist philosophy, I saw you calling the guy a caveman, a moron, and a relic.""
I don't recall being in such a debate..or calling someone a caveman.. If I did, it was probably one of the guys that I am on first name basis with..most likely JD :)

1 more sleep..are you excited??

by Member 19291532

She is going bonkers. Last night it was "Can I open just ONE present?!?" This morning it was the same...

Tonight she gets to... which ought to get us through until she wakes at 5am the following morning. :)

Well, I may have been paraphrasing on exactly how the conversation went, and it may not have been YOU specifically that called him those things...

And... those things MAY be true...

But... anyhow... I dunno. I've successfully turned this into a debate about me and not this other guy, at this point anyhow, so I've got my hands full in another branch of the thread. So... I suppose you DID get the last word in, more or less.

But at least I proved that it isn't just the fly by night "seagulls" that can p!ss everyone off in the forums! (Or at least, p!ss of everyone who evidently matters).

:)

by Member 19291532

First time I heard the song that I remember I was probably 6 or 7. It was a Looooong time ago and I was arguably too young to really understand the meaning of the song.

When I first heard that it was about Warren Beatty a few years later, I was certain there must have been some mistake.

I've adored myself as long as I can remember, I don't plan on giving that up anytime soon.

It takes a common person to hear that song and think of someone they know who it could apply to.

It takes a remarkable person to hear that song and think it might be about them. As far as I'm concerned, if you're going to sing my song, you should probably pay me some sort of royalty.

Keep being common. Us remarkable people need people to fold our towels and flip our burgers and otherwise keep our world humming along.

:)

by jiminpa

A remarkable a$$

I guess it is good you think so highly of yourself since no one else obviously does.

Me, I prefer the respect and admiration of my peers.

My hope for you is one day you grow up and realize that.

B-)

by jck

fold their towels and take care of other responsibilities...before they come online ;)

I'd say you're common too, being that you're procrastinating right now...so...back to work!!! :^0

by Member 19291532

There is a point where even I go, "This isn't going to go anywhere, so why even bother", and just walk away.

Like I said, I basically agree with her, but I think the line moves and depends on the person.

by jck

*big smooch on the cheek*

Merry Christmas, mo cara! Have a fresh, REAL Guinness for me if ya would, and enjoy your hols with hubby.

Nollaig Shona Duit. :)

P.S.- if you see Ms. Corr, let her know I should be arriving Feb 2010 in Dublin for my b-day ;)

by Member 19291532

Speak of invoking a "Frank Zappa-esque response" reflex...

I don't care WHO Toni Bowers is. I've never responded well to that, "you don't know who you are messing with" mentality. I'm seeing a lot of that following ShelBot around from thread to thread too. It reminds me of nothing as much as salivating dogs following around a hot poodle and humping the air in frustration. Really, the responses regarding the OP you mention are more of the same. A room full of nerds and a couple of women and suddenly all logic, reason and rational thought flies out the window.

I read the original post - and frankly, the fact it has spawned such a massive thread speaks more to intense in-group cliquish over-reaction than to the severity or lack thereof of the offense of the original poster. I've yet to make a judgement on the original post, BTW... this is more about the backlash it has generated - like a evangelical church with all the congregation stamping their feet and raising their hands in a-men brothers and hallelujas.

Very Strong Communities (tm) are a bane to effective communication and rational thought online. The Well fell victim to being a Very Strong Community far before TR was even conceived. What Very Strong Communities need is outspoken and blunt a$$****s shaking up the status quo, and breaking the group-thought - as often as not.

Shellbot voiced an opinion, and I voiced an equally valid counter opinion. I'm not really concerned if you disagree or agree with my opinion, but your inability to see this fact is the part of this entire thread (and several other similar threads) that annoys me so much. Censor and clamp down and use social pressure to stifle opposing perspectives as a group if you want, but that isn't going to make TR a better forum.

If the content posters of TR did not use Yellow Journalism headline techniques, I wouldn't find it so easy to satirize the style and content...

e.g.

"5 Reasons why Tech Republic Content Publishers are Tools!"

"Come on, that wasn't designed to INCITE Tech Republic Content Publishers, it was an honest observation of 5 points where Tech Republic Content Publishers have failed to deliver top quality content for the Tech field... You've misrepresented my intentions in posting this piece..."

When a user does it, you call him a "troll", when a content publisher does it, you call it a "witty headline". Got it. Thanks for the clarification.

You know the first sign that something is wrong?

The locals are circling the wagons and coming to the defense of their neighbors, and saying things like,

"If you had been around here for awhile..."

"Maybe if you had read all of the posts"...

"I know and so do the other dozen people who jumped to her defense, and NO ONE has seen the post by , therefore, you should just shut up if you know what is good for you".

"I am a long term contributor and I know a thing or two about..."

"We value"...

WE do? Could you define WE, TiggerTwo? Because you seem to imply that you speak for EVERYONE, but I get the feeling you're drawing a distinction, for example, between "we" and between *me*, in this case.

We DO value all of the people, right? But are WE telling ME that I should "please not suggest that..."

How can that be WE? If I were WE, wouldn't I already know our little unwritten rules of what is and isn't acceptable?

Come on...

You don't own this place, neither does Toni, neither does ShellBot. It isn't YOUR place... it is owned by a big souless corporation called C-Net. That is the WE that dictates things around here. Not US.

Trust me... your behavior is far more disturbing than any misbehavior of the OP.

by jamesrl

At the risk of getting Palmie's head rung like a church bell at Christmas....

Yellow Journalism? Surely you jest. Sure the writers here use provocative headlines, but so does the New York Times.

No one is threatening you or trying to censor you. What we are trying to do is to get you to understand our opinions (note the plural), same as you. The fact that a number of us think the same way in no way implies group think, we differ enough on other matters, something you'd notice if you read enough posts here.

But mostly posters here refrain from calling each other tools or poodles or using such silly or lurid analogies. That is much closer to the J school yellow journalism definition that I'm familiar with.

Feel free to shake up the community with reason and logic and passion. In my book your personal attacks only make your reason and logic suspect.

I don't trust you. I value the opinions of those I've come to respect here, who contribute thoughtful and meaningful content, analysis and yes even criticism. Sure even the posters I value do on occasion step over the line, but they have such a strong signal to noise ratio, I can overlook the occasional stray remark.

You, on the other hand, seem hell bent on provoking fights by getting mean and personal, and its gets in the way of your "logic".

But hey suit yourself, the only loser here is Palmie.

Don't be suprised though if everyone tires of your tirades and people stop replying.

James

by Member 19291532

Who is Palmie? And what does Palmie have to do with this?

You also missed the point of the "...are tools" portion of my last response. It was in quotes and an exaggerated example. You did get my lurid humping dogs example correct though. Glad that one came across loud in clear. Just a gut-reaction to the behavior here - beauty is in the eye of the beholder and perhaps some of the people posting *really* see Toni as a woman of rare beauty and delicate grace, and they're not just defending her on those terms because of sick desperation. Who am I to judge...

I'm not the one attacking. Some guy posted some crude comments about Toni, a bunch of you got all over HIS case, I simply pointed out how ironic that HE was attacked with ad hominem attacks for MAKING ad hominem attacks - and suddenly this has spiraled into an ongoing debate of my character and the value of my opinions...

Um... the article titles are sensationalized here in order to draw in readers and spurn comments. Most of the authors basically admit as much. It seems that the tone has died down a little recently, but for awhile every other post was either gushing hyperbole about the iPhone are wishing the ultimate demise of Microsoft based on Vista. With Toni, it isn't so much the titles, as the content itself that often makes me want to claw my eyes out. Sorry I feel that way about a writer that you consider a friend or... whatever. But I do.

by bfilmfan

Justin get thee to Hulu man!

I have recently discovered this thing called Anime.

And let me tell you that my nephew was correct that Afro Samauri (voiced by Samuel L Jackson) is Off Da Hook!

by justin james

Hulu is great, I agree... unfortunately, my time in front of the PC is nearly 100% mutally exclusive with my leisure time (I get to play a video game for an hour or three a week, that's about it). I keep thinking about putting a networked device in my living room though, and I'm getting a DVR in a few weeks, which should expand my options a bit (as well as let me not have to compete with the wife when wrestling is on). :)

J.Ja

by Member 19291532

I don't understand why my bad behavior would affect "Palmie".

I'm genuinely concerned - because, well... I'm fine with my suffering the consequences for my own behavior...

But not with anyone else suffering consequences on my behalf.

Of course, the tools are acting typically toolish, and answering with cryptic answers.

So, listen, Jimmie Jam... I *am* self absorbed, and I have no idea what you're babbling on about. Care to clarify, or are you going to continue to act like a frustrated, zit-faced, AD&D playing 7th grade mathalette? This kind of behavior is why Jr. High and High school were probably an 8 year string of humilations for you.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I just ate the cupcake surprise thingy. Very yummy, not at all peanut butter cup like, IMO.

Very yummy. B-) Bet it's killer diller in semi-sweet, too.

by shellbot

See..you were TRYING to make this post all about you...caught ya!! ]:)

Ah man..i remember being a kid and begging to open just 1 present :) Now that I'm older I have a bit mroe restraint.

Hope it was all good

by unhappyuser

There's an old saying of "you can attract more flies with honey than you can with vinegar."

Unfortunately people like to play the vinegar role and put others down. I think it makes them feel better about themselves. I don't think it really works in the long run as it makes us all worse off.

I try my best to bee on the side of honey (pun intended). Am I perfect or have I never been overly negative? No, but I try to put a positive spin on it and make other feel better about themselves. It usually comes back to me as positive spin (or food).

Hopefully, others will follow suit and make this an even better site by being more positive (is that possible considering how great it is now?). Good post Shellbot.

Remember: BEE the Honey!

EMD

by hal 9000

But I do agree Honey is a Cutie and I like being on her side. :^0

Doesn't do me any good though she just ignores me. :(

Col ]:)

by jck

more like Baretta?

Gets tough and says what he means, but he knows what the heck he's doing and does it right! :D

This discussion is closed to new replies.