Discussion Locked

New profile and contacts about to go live

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just wanted to give all of you a heads up that the new profile page with the contacts functionality is about to go live any minute.

So please take a minute this evening to fill out your interests, your bio and add some members to your contacts list.

BTW, to add members to your contacts, just go to their profile page and click the "Add to my contacts" link under their photo.

In our next phase, we will allow you to search for members by alias (instead of hunting for them). For now though, you will need to go profile to profile.

Let me know what you all think. Also let us know if you find any bugs.

Thanks,
sm

53 replies

by thechas

Well,

I took a look at my profile.

The recent discussions and questions caught my eye.

The list is just as random as the My Discussions and My questions list have been.

Looking at Recent Questions, one of the questions listed I posted my answer some time ago.
The question was just closed today.

Same with the Discussions.
At least 1 of the discussions on my list I last posted to several days ago.

I'm not ashamed of what I have posted, or answers I have given.
However, if the list is suppossed to be "recent" activity should it not give priority to the most recent postings?

Chas

by oz_media

I think it is tracked similar to the My Discussions link that keeps the most recently changed topic (even if by another peer) at the top of the list.

This way you can see any discussions that you have participated in (at any time) that have been most recently added to.

Correct me if this wasn't what you meant though

by thechas

I was having all kinds of problems attempting to fathom the order of my subscribed and participated discussions.

Thanks for the info.

One good thing!

They did not loose our list of subscribed discussions this time.

Chas

by smorty71

I've noticed that the "#1 of Top 100 members" links have disappeared from the member signatures and profile pages. We're looking into that.

sm

by oz_media

I looked for a new thread real quickly but got side tracked and ended up posting to my very own, 2nd thread instead. Sorry!

Anyhow, all that I said here:
http://tinyurl.com/66fh9

oh...and here:
http://tinyurl.com/4hp43

But just to emphasize....I WANT MY DISCUSSIONS BACK!!

Noticed you stripped points out of Tech Q&A stats to, yet all the questions still show point values. Will you keep the points system in Q&A anyway?

by smorty71

For now, the points system is unchanged. We left them off of the profile page with the intention of replacing them at some point. However, we don't have a replacement plan, so points will probably be hanging around "as-is" for a while.

by smorty71

I'll see where we can squeeze that link back in.

BTW, in the meantime, you could just add some contacts and other info to your new profile page :)

What that self-promotion too obvious?

sm

by apotheon

I'm beginning to really miss that My Discussions link. Really. Please?

By the way, a nice thing to include in the profile view might be a profile search function, so that we can search for other profiles by name from a profile. For instance, if I was looking at Col's profile and wanted to jump to house's profile, and they didn't have each other contact-listed, I could enter "house" in the search and find it quickly without having to hunt down a link to house's profile.

Or, y'know, the site code could be rewritten so that the username is in the URL for the user's profile. Heh.

by thechas

How far back did you go for the number of posts and discussions started?

I know I have started more than 2 discussions.

I also am positive that Max has started more than 1 discussion.

Chas

by oz_media

Cool huh?

I suppose they haven't really kept track of all our discussions in the past.

Oh well, I was surprised to see the number of posts though. I used to laugh when I went to sites and saw some guy had posted 45000 times on a game site.

Now I see how they all add up.

by smorty71

It is supposed to be your true total. If it is not showing the correct number, it may be a bug. I'll look into it in the morning.

sm

by hal 9000

The discussions started is defiantly incorrect but I'm not complaining for myself but there are a lot of others who have contributed quite a lot here on TR and do not seem to be getting listed for what they have done.

Also what about revoking Chas's Q & A privileges so some of the rest of us can have a go occasionally? Sorry just joking Chas :D but I've just come from a Question where every single answer was rejected of course you Chas where the first respondent and to me at least appeared to have the correct answer but it was rejected and the question closed with no solution.

Col :(

by willcomp

Smorty,

Looks very good. Like the design and layout. Hats off to you guys, you're really trying and things are looking up.

Now that window dressing has been accomplished, how about requiring new (and old, if feasible) users to supply a valid e-mail address.

Some more food for thought. How about adding at least one other category under job function. Need something like "PC User" to make it easy for non IT folks. I see some real disconnects between Job Category specified and actual expertise in TQ&A.

Dalton

by smorty71

New users (for the past couple of years) have been required to provide a valid e-mail address (we send them a confirmation message that they have to click to verify). So all new users will have one.

As for the job function, I am hoping to add a field to the edit profile page that allows a user to enter a freeform job function that is separation from the one specified at registration. Once that freeform field is in place, we will only show the existing list job functions when the user hasn't specified something new in the freeform field.

Thanks for the feedback,
sm

by house

I still have the habit of trying to click the "my discussions" link... I'll get used to it. It looks pretty good.

I haven't had much time to play around, so I'll let you know if I come across any annoyances.

by oz_media

They will figures out where the My Discussions link got fropped and will add it back in.
Start Thread and New may screw up new users. New generally means post new thread. Perhaps nixing either New or Hot, who reads HOT threads?

Something to make room for teh My discussions link.

Perhaps even a text link under the Top 5 Listing, below View Top 100, you could have My Discussions or something.

by smorty71

We will definitely find a spot for it.

So, since you brought it up, do you all use "Hot" and "New" at the top? If not, maybe we can remove those to make room.

You're right about the "new" link being confusing. I moved "start a thread" to the beginning so that I would quit clicking "new" everytime I wanted to post.

I've worked here for almost 6 years and I still click "new" when I want to post! Pretty sad.

by house

Perhaps the "discussions" tab shoulb the first one. I don't care to see my pic and bio every time I want to browse my discussions.

My suggested order...

1) discussions
2) Q&A
3) profile
4) contacts

This way, there is no "extra click" involved.

PS - The "View Profile" link should be named "activity" or something to indicate that there is some functionality in regards to your discussions and questions.

Chris

by oz_media

HElP ME!!!!

After 4 years trying to get the Tech Q&A and Discussions links reversed or renamed, you come back with reverting to the old style that was a HUGE issue for site navigation ! Say it isn't so.

Bite your tongue laddie!

When people look for navigation, especially NEW people, they will INSTANTLY click the Discussion link (completely missing the obscurely named Technical Q&A) and ask their question in a discussion forum, as that's how other sites have their tech Q&A accessed. I have been trying to get the nav improved here for years, that system was proven as disasterous.

This would be the biggest step backwards I could possibly think of, sorry mate but we'be been there and done that for years, the most horrible navigation issue of TR is finally gone, DON'T ask for it back you blasphemous ........., you know what!

IF anything,

>Technical Q&A, (should be renamed to get help or Computer Questions)
>User Profile
>Contacts (that's redundant)
>Discussions
>My Discussions

Or have a separate tire for

[u]DISCUSSIONS[/u]

>HOME
>NEW
>HOT TOPICS
>MY DISCUSSIONS

by house

Rename the 'view profile' to 'discussions' and switch the tabs. I'm not really too concerned about the Q&A right now, all I know is that I love the tabs, but some won't like that extra click.

My suggested order is the exact same as the current order with the exception of the profile tab.

Also, more people use the discussions that the TQ&A. In fact, it's been a while since I answered any questions. Time to get cookin'.

by thechas

sMoRTy,

I notice a big change from last night and this morning to right now.

On my Profile page, the list of Discussions and Questions is gone.

Same with the links to the full list.

Also, the tabs don't work.

I know you guys are working on changes. Just letting you know what I come across.

Chas

by Jay Garmon

Without divulging too many sensitive details, let's just say another CNET property wrote a self-referencing SQL query that pegged our shared app server.

We were not pleased with the timing.

It's fixed now. Sorry for the hiccup.

--Jay

by house

...let me also say that recently, a major industry leader broadcasted our public range because they thought that it belonged to them, bringing our whole network down. Morons.

by oz_media

I never use them myself, but I am but one peer and I have my own ways of getting around the site to what I want to see.

I wouldn't use it, but others may.

Gotta say though, the site really is starting to shape up, very well done!

by thechas

I posted this in Jay's thread.

But want to back up my concern by posting it here too.

On the Discussions and T Q&A tabs, our actual names are used.

On the Profile and Contacts tabs our alias is used.

I recommend that you use our alias on all 4 tabs.

While I have nothing to hide, I prefer using my alias on the site.

Chas

by smorty71

That is most definitely not supposed to happen! That's part of the reason we have truncated all of the aliases that are e-mail addresses. We wanted to make sure that no one's personal info was exposed (unless they chose to expose it).

We will correct this problem ASAP. Thanks for pointing that out.

sm

by smorty71

Chas,
This fix is going to be deployed around noon EST.

Thanks for reporting that one.

sm

by thechas

Thanks for correcting the error.

Aside from the error, as I get used to it, I do like the changes to the site.

Good Job to all.

Chas

by apotheon

I don't suppose I could prevail upon youse guys to provide some way for linebreaks to appear in the "Professional Biography" section of the profile . . . could I?

While I'm at it . . . has any thought been given to allowing easily-implemented HTML character entities in posts?

by smorty71

We have that one on our list of things to add. It drives me crazy trying to read bios right now.

Thanks for the suggestion,
sm

by apotheon

I added a brief note about my new second job in my bio, and had to start pruning words from my bio. 2000 characters seems stingy for a maximum length of the bio, but maybe that's just because I'm full of hot air.

by house

1) I use the 'new' function almost daily, but the 'hot' function... well I've used it once or twice so I don't care much for it.

2) I like the new layout... just rename 'view profile' and shuffle the tabs. I don't need to see my fat head every time.

by hal 9000

Besides the already mentioned ones is that you no longer have the ability to delete discussions that have become dead.

I suspose there is a limit of current discussions that are allowed it's just that I would hate to see one from 2 years ago crop up and loose a current topic.

Col

by house

The discussions list is not updated as often as some would like. I'm not sure if that is directly related to your CNET friends, or if the list is only updated at regular intervals.

I noticed that it was in real time before, is that still the case?

Chris

by Jay Garmon

...because all this data can't be made with live calls. We'd smoke the database. So there will always be a slight delay in some data points, but we're tuning to keep in manageable.

--jay

by house

I never thought that it should have been real time due to load issues, but I had noticed before that it was almost an instant process.

I would never had expected it to be it to be instant, but I just thought I'd let you know of the lag.

by oz_media

The blue links across the top. That way I don't have to go to my profile to see the discussions and the link is back on all the discussion pages.

Just like it was before, we gained new profiles which was cool, but lost my most commonly used link.

I wonder what the clicks on that link really are each month. Man, if you had a 2 penny porno pop-up banner with that kinda click-trough traffic, you'd make some dough. (oops, mustn't give them ideas). Mind you I'd rather see porn ads to MS ads.

by house

Or some of that romnation action. ;)

...if the profile link showed us the discussions first, we wouldn't have that problem.

by oz_media

I didn't really get you the first time. You know what's kinda mental though, now that I think about it, The 'View and Edit Profile" goes to your own profile from EVERY page. I can click one of my posts if I need to get to my profile, quick access isn't a concern.

This might work as a fix;
Get rid of the 'Edit Profile' link from THIS page and just have it available from your profile page (where it belongs really).

Ditch 'Hot' Discussions.

Add the My Discussions link back in.

There are still two ways to get to your own profile easily if still needed.

1) Top 100

2) Click any post

Bonus#3
Make the 'My Account' link (way up there in the nose bleeds), an actual link to your profile, instead of some page that never accepts a password no mater how many times you confrim it correct, get a new one, change it back to one of your choice.

by oz_media

If you posted dto a discussion, as soon as you went to My DIscussions, it would be at the top of the list.

Now it doesn't update the same.

In a way though, it is easier. When you go down your list of discussions 1 by one and respond to new posts, it stays where it was so the next 'most recent' is right below it. Before you had to track the titles becasue as soon as you replied, it went to the top of your recent list and you'd lose your place.

Man, I spend WAY too much time here!

by house

I see this problem all the time with our clients. My diagnosis... [i]fat fingers[/i].

I noticed though, that I needed to enter my username and password every time I wanted to edit my profile... with this new feature, I can make my changes without being prompted.

by oz_media

Not fat fingers that's for sure.

IN fact iot is one of a comon pool of passwords, you can type it in one letter at a time and it wstill tells you it's wrong.

SO you get a new one sent, and IF you're lucky, which I haven't been in some time, it will be accepted, THen you need to change your password.

I could make mine 1111111 and it would STILL say Incorrect password.

Just a headache if you ask me.

by house

It still reminds me of some of our clients though.

I've never had an issue like that here. Then again again, I've only had a legitimate active profile for a few months.

by house

...on the profile page, similar to the extended url issue that we see here.

If someone uses an extended term without a space...

well I guess you know what happens :)

by Jay Garmon

We're doing an incremenetal upgrade, which should roll out in the next few days, that will include both a member search and the return of My Discussions. Plus other funs stuff, but we have to have a few surprises, don't we?

--Jay

by hal 9000

Wasn't that mentioned somewhere previously?

Maybe I'm getting old or something but I'm sure that we where told that we would be able to search the Peer Listings to add contacts.

But the My Discussing Button will be greatly appreciated!

Col

by house

"Start new thread" or "Ask a question" within the respective profile tabs. Please don't tell me that we're scrapping the tabs. The my discussions link, will it bring us to the old layout or the appropriate tab within our profile? I guess I'll wait and see.

Chris

by smorty71

The profile tabs are staying put. We are going to add a very thin Community-only nav bar (really just a line of small links) just under the big ad at the top of the page that has links to Discussions, Technical Q&A and the new page for searching for members.

There will also be links to My Profile, My Discussions, My Questions and My Contacts. These will be a little redundant in the profile area; however, we want to make sure that the relationship between Discussions, TQ&A and the profile stuff is clearer.

Plus, we want members to be able to move between these areas very quickly. The current navigation between these features is kind of clunky.

by apotheon

I am psychic. That was supposed to be a secret, though. Ssshhh.

Aren't you glad I'm in TRI?

Thanks for the updates!

by oz_media

I want My Discusisons back, trudging through tthe site has been....well, lets just say "kind of clunky" is a gross understatement.

:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.