Discussion Locked

NEW US GOVERNMENT REPORT CONFIRMS....

0 helpful
82 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

That there is HUMAN caused GLobal Warming.
BBC news:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/2023835.stm

The US Government has acknowledged for the first time that man-made pollution is largely to blame for global warming....

The EPA:
http://yosemite.epa.gov/oar/globalwarming.nsf/content/NewsandEventsScienceandPolicyNews.html

Global Warming for Kids:
http://www.newscientist.com/channel/earth/climate-change

maybe now that GWB has ADMITTED that pollution is causing global warming Maxwell will have to retract his comments saying it's all BS. after all his hero the president admitted that us lunatics that have been mentioning it are correct.

82 replies

by maxwell edison

First of all, jaqui, when people make such a silly comment such as suggesting that President bush is my hero, it only shows your lack of understanding. It's a shallow and meaningless charge, and only serves to discredit the person making it. For the record, and this is something I'm getting very tired of repeating, I probably disagree with President Bush on more issues than those on which I agree with him. I could enumerate them, but I don't feel like doing it AGAIN right now.

Having said that, my position on the human-caused global warming myth remains unchanged. I don't care who disagrees with me (or vice versa).

Okay, on second thought, I will list some of them.

President Bush is dead-wrong, and/or in disagreement with me on the following issues:

- Human-caused global warming.

- The death penalty.

- Legalizing recreational drugs.

- He capitulated on the Social Security problem and dropped the ball. (And what he was proposing was pretty insignificant.)

- He's expanding the role of Medicare, not reducing it.

- He's expanding the role of government, not reducing it.

- He should have vetoed and number of spending bills.

- He has fallen short in articulating our true mission in our war against Islamo-Fascism.

- He is failing dismally in the illegal immigration issue.

- He is failing dismally in securing the U.S. borders with Mexico.

- He is being to "nice" with Mexico President Fox.

- And he should challenge the stupid attacks on him, his policies, and his character. It just irks me that he doesn't fight back against his political enemies. He might think that he's above it all, and that the office should be above it all, but it's only detrimental to remain silent.

I could list more, but that should do.

All of my positions and opinions are based on principle and reason, not blindly following any one person. In the very least, I should be given credit for that, as I am VERY consistent with my positions.

Come on, jaqui. Can't you rise above that stupid and silly crap? People who spew it only show their own ignorance.

As for your global warming comments, I've said it before as well. The "global warming" issue is a political issue, not a scientific one. And just like I consider today's Republican Party no more than baby Democrats when it comes to social spending issues, they are being forced to accept this political position in order to compete in the political arena and keep their elected jobs.

Get politics TOTALLY out of the global warming question, and you'll have a much better chance of changing my position. And until every scientist and climatologist in the world is in total agreement, I'll remain skeptical.

In the mean-time, I subscribe to the following:

http://www.opinionjournal.com/extra/?id=110008220

And I agree with the following scientist:

http://www.cnsnews.com/Culture/archive/200412/CUL20041202a.html

And if this puts me in disagreement with President Bush, then so be it.

by oz_media

Max, I noticed when you were listing differences that one was legalizing recreational drugs.

I have two questions (not baiting you or anything);
1) What is GWB's stand on recreational drugs, I asumed it was against legalization.

2) If the above is true, and you feel that recreational drugs should be legalized, what exactly would you deem a recreational drug? Do you accept marijuana but reject heroin etc.?

I ask with sincere interest, I know the thread here was a bit old and whack so this may be an interesting segue.
Thx.

P.S. While you are sick and tired of explaining what you don't agree with Bush on, rest assured it works the same for me too. Do you know HOW many times i have explained WHY I object to the initialization of the Iraqi conflict? Every day there was someone new asking what I would do if my family was threatened or terrorized. Then they accused me of supporting terrorism. You should know by now that while I feel the war on terror is imperative, the rapid move to Iraq was my objection.

I was thinking about you this morning when watching young lefty wingnuts handing out papers from the college antiwar group. You told me some time ago that people's views change from right to center to letf and then back to right as they age, you were dead right on that.

by maxwell edison

What is GWB's stand on drugs, you ask? Well, I won't speak for him, but he's in favor of tough drug laws and expanding our stupid and failed "war on drugs". That about says it all.

This is a good site to get a general idea of issues and/or people's positions on issues:

http://www.issues2000.org/default.htm

Drug-Bush specific:

http://www.issues2000.org/George_W__Bush.htm

- Aggressive drug education, treatment & enforcement. (Jan 2004)

- $23 million more for drug-testing in schools. (Jan 2004)

-Use of performance-enhancing steroids sends wrong message. (Jan 2004)

-$600M plan help 300,000 addicts via vouchers. (Aug 2003)

-Use faith-based programs for addicted Americans. (Aug 2003)

-Turned from alcoholism by power of prayer. (Jun 2003)

-$2.8B more for Drug War, for state treatment & abroad. (Oct 2000)

-Clinton-Gore drug policy is inconsistent and has failed. (Oct 2000)

-Feds must help border counties fight drug traffickers. (Jun 2000)

-Supports military package to Colombia to fight drug supply. (Mar 2000)

-Stronger penalties for first time cocaine possession. (Mar 2000)

-Full background checks on drug use for all appointees. (Aug 1999)

-Parents make up for past by warning kids against drugs. (Aug 1999)

-Supports tough drug laws as well as drug education programs. (Dec 1998)

In a nutshell, I'm against just about any law or program that infringes on an individual's liberty, privacy, or right to live his/her life as he/she sees fit as long as nobody else is hurt or otherwise infringed upon. That puts me at odds with both the Democrats and Republicans, including "my hero" GWB, on a variety of issues. I realize that a couple of my positions seem to contradict this premise, and those issues are abortion and gay marriage. But come up with both a legal and medical definition of when life begins, and I'll readdress the former (abortion) position; and I could probably be swayed on the latter (gay marriage).

What would I consider "recreational drugs"? Well, marijuana to be sure. Other than that, I'll admit to being unsure. But open it as a possibility first, and let's talk about the details later.

(More on your other comments later.)

by jardinier

As I have no interest in, or reason to be interested in American domestic politics, could you tell me if these are all recent issues or have they developed over a period of months/years?

If John Howard had not sent Australian troops to Iraq, I would never have been particularly interested in Bush at all.

Recently the following news article arrived in my email, and I published portion of it with a link on my website.

Perhaps you would care to comment on the article -- and the statistics attached -- because it is directly related to some of the issues you have listed, especially as regards overspending.

http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/2006-04-02-federal-spending-inside_x.htm

by deepsand

You stated "[i]And until [b]every[/b] scientist and climatologist in the world is in [b]total agreement[/b], I'll remain skeptical.[i]/"

Do you use the same standard for [b]all[/b] issues?

I suspect not.

by oz_media

If life was based on 100% surety, then we would have no need for politicians, judges, debates or anything else that determines validity.

If all we needed to do was wit for proof, life would be easy, it wouldn't progress much at al, but it would be pretty black and white. there would be no war in Iraq, that's for sure.

by deepsand

Main Entry: pol?i?cy

Pronunciation: 'p?-l&-sE

Function: noun

Inflected Form(s): plural -cies

Usage: often attributive

Etymology: Middle English policie government, policy, from Middle French, government, regulation, from Late Latin politia

1 a : [b]prudence or wisdom in the management of affairs[/b] b : management or procedure based primarily on material interest
2 a : [b]a definite course or method of action selected from among alternatives and in light of given conditions to guide and determine present and future decisions[/b] b : a high-level overall plan embracing the general goals and acceptable procedures especially of a governmental body

Are you saying that we should have [b]no policy[/b] with regards to the possible consequences of our actions in this regard?

by mjwx

Maxwell, We have had this discussion before.

now I will not repeat myself but I will suggest you talk to some meterologists and some geologists before you blame global warming on the sun. In fact I insist you be scientific about it and talk to at least three meterorologists.

About Bush, to paraphrase comic book guy "worst president ever" but thats an [b]opinion[/b]. I'm trying to avoid heated political debate at the moment but I will say, If your looking for a replacement president I'm available. :) Hey I dont think I could do any worse than bush.

by bob g beechey

Indeed it is - certainly as far as Tech Reps discussions go.
Side One - the ultra-consevative, libertarian, privatise social security, de-regulate business side of politics (ultra-republican if you will) that will always rationalise a tendency to rubbish pro-environmentalist research because of the costs to business and the distortions to market forces.
Side 2 - the left-of-centre(rudely referred to as "socialists" or "communists" but not yet "Islamists") who are more interested in the equitable re-distribution of wealth (ultra-ultra-democrats) who are interested in "social capital"
Side One is exemplified by posters like Maxwell Edison and by right wing think tanks such as the Cato Institute and by web-sites such as "junkscience.com". Side Two is exemplified by posters like neilb and sites like "sourcewatch.org". I apologise if I have (in general terms) wrongly categorised either poster.
This colours the science we "see" and affects our interpretation and selection of the data out there. To pretend that for ANY of us that our science is politics free is extremely naive.

by oz_media

It was in 24 yesterday too, the focus was on how are republican supporters going to squirm from this when their party has flip flopped. LOL :)

So nicely put isn't it? Gotta love reporting.
This morning whil egetting coffee, some beatnick, tree hugger with his knapsack of life on his back, was handing out newspapers from an anti-war group at UBC. It was all just real lefty spew about how horrible it is that Canadians are in Afghanistan. That's about the only part of this whole damn war that was justified! The only thing I disagree with is the end to major conflict and the removal of so many troops to hit Iraq. UK, US, Germany, Canadia and many others still occupy various regions but the fightign is getting fierce again, Taliban are moving back to control the area again, women are still represssed, schools, water and other vital infrastructures are still in dire need of rebuilding etc.

We need to be there stilll, just too bad the focus is elsewhere.

News is a heap'O'shite, now that Canada's bleedng hearts are targeting, we are seeing all the left/right BS here too.

The GWB issue is old news, he has already said he would support it and wanted further investigation to continue, the only thing is that he wants it to be voluntary and not mandatory that companies seek better/less destructive emissions standards. If they want to look good they tell everyone they invested a couple of million here and there for better emissions (chump change at the oil refinery level) and they get sdom egood press and everyone feels better. Again, smoke and mirrors and just more BS.

Recently Canadian companies haven't been much better either.

Rant over, thank you for your time.

It's all lip service and just more BS from Bush, what else can you really expect?

by maxwell edison

I can't recall a single time when you indicated that you believed anything coming out of this government, especially this administration. Why do you believe that nothing else is genuine, but you do believe that this is?

by oz_media

Searching the White House website for his name, not a single mention of him exists, nor is there mention of that branch of NASA, besides comments about various space programs.

by oz_media

I didn't really know your stand on this issue, I am not really surprised though.

While I mainly agree, how do we stop some drugs from being legalized while we legalize others. It's like the decision to legalize alcohol and tobacco, more than a few headaches there. I think the fear is that as soon as they legalize marijuana, they will be under constant pressure to legalize other drugs. The scary part is that herion actually does have a valid casem I couldn't see it happening for coaine but heroin, that's a nasty one to have to deal with.

The only problem I see with gay marriage is that we chose to use an English word that has a specific religious definition. If we can remove such direct relationship between the word and one specific choice of faith (gay people believe in God but have a different definition of marriage, as do many other cultures and religions globally, but we all commonly see a coupling as being marriage)then it is much easier to accept variety ni the definition.

Really it's not about money and taxes as many thing, gay people just want to have the same recognition as a contributing part of society as anyother couple.

If two other people can commit to life together and have that recognized by the government and more importantly the community, why can't they?

What possible harm or negative impact can this have on mankind?

by deepsand

Main Entry: mar?ry

Pronunciation: 'mar-E also 'mer-

Function: verb

Inflected Form(s): mar?ried; mar?ry?ing

Etymology: Middle English marien, from Old French marier, from Latin maritare, from maritus married

As originally used, it meant to be joined "according to law or custom."

Religious "blessing" was not a prereguisite.

by oz_media

The definition as used in North American culture is derived from Christian faith though. If we referred to marriage as just a word, as other countries do, then the gay marriage issue woul dnto BE an issue. But because people have equated a descriptive word as being the religious acceptance of marriage into government, now we are stuck with religious zealots saying it is unChristian.

If they had used any other word (coupling, legal bonding or whatever), it would not be an issue.

by deepsand

declaration that "no sound scientific studies"
support the medical use of marijuana, thus contradicting a review by government scientists.

--------------------------------------------------

April 21, 2006

F.D.A. Dismisses Medical Benefit From Marijuana

By GARDINER HARRIS

WASHINGTON, April 20 ? The Food and Drug Administration said Thursday that "no sound scientific studies" supported the medical use of marijuana, contradicting a 1999 review by a panel of highly regarded scientists.

The announcement inserts the health agency into yet another fierce political fight.

Susan Bro, an agency spokeswoman, said Thursday's statement resulted from a past combined review by federal drug enforcement, regulatory and research agencies that concluded "smoked marijuana has no currently accepted or proven medical use in the United States and is not an approved medical treatment."

Ms. Bro said the agency issued the statement in response to numerous inquiries from Capitol Hill but would probably do nothing to enforce it.

"Any enforcement based on this finding would need to be by D.E.A. since this falls outside of F.D.A.'s regulatory authority," she said.

Eleven states have legalized medicinal use of marijuana, but the Drug Enforcement Administration and the director of national drug control policy, John P. Walters, have opposed those laws.

A Supreme Court decision last year allowed the federal government to arrest anyone using marijuana, even for medical purposes and even in states that have legalized its use.

Congressional opponents and supporters of medical marijuana use have each tried to enlist the F.D.A. to support their views. Representative Mark Souder, Republican of Indiana and a fierce opponent of medical marijuana initiatives, proposed legislation two years ago that would have required the food and drug agency to issue an opinion on the medicinal properties of marijuana.

Mr. Souder believes that efforts to legalize medicinal uses of marijuana are a front for efforts to legalize all uses of it, said Martin Green, a spokesman for Mr. Souder.

Tom Riley, a spokesman for Mr. Walters, hailed the food and drug agency's statement, saying it would put to rest what he called "the bizarre public discussion" that has led to some legalization of medical marijuana.

The Food and Drug Administration statement directly contradicts a 1999 review by the Institute of Medicine, a part of the National Academy of Sciences, the nation's most prestigious scientific advisory agency. That review found marijuana to be "moderately well suited for particular conditions, such as chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting and AIDS wasting."

Dr. John Benson, co-chairman of the Institute of Medicine committee that examined the research into marijuana's effects, said in an interview that the statement on Thursday and the combined review by other agencies were wrong.

The federal government "loves to ignore our report," said Dr. Benson, a professor of internal medicine at the University of Nebraska Medical Center. "They would rather it never happened."

Some scientists and legislators said the agency's statement about marijuana demonstrated that politics had trumped science.

"Unfortunately, this is yet another example of the F.D.A. making pronouncements that seem to be driven more by ideology than by science," said Dr. Jerry Avorn, a medical professor at Harvard Medical School.

Representative Maurice D. Hinchey, a New York Democrat who has sponsored legislation to allow medicinal uses of marijuana, said the statement reflected the influence of the Drug Enforcement Administration, which he said had long pressured the F.D.A. to help in its fight against marijuana.

A spokeswoman for the Drug Enforcement Administration referred questions to Mr. Walters's office.

The Food and Drug Administration's statement said state initiatives that legalize marijuana use were "inconsistent with efforts to ensure that medications undergo the rigorous scientific scrutiny of the F.D.A. approval process."

But scientists who study the medical use of marijuana said in interviews that the federal government had actively discouraged research. Lyle E. Craker, a professor in the division of plant and soil sciences at the University of Massachusetts, said he submitted an application to the D.E.A. in 2001 to grow a small patch of marijuana to be used for research because government-approved marijuana, grown in Mississippi, was of poor quality.

In 2004, the drug enforcement agency turned Dr. Craker down. He appealed and is awaiting a judge's ruling. "The reason there's no good evidence is that they don't want an honest trial," Dr. Craker said.

Dr. Donald Abrams, a professor of clinical medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, said he had studied marijuana's medicinal effects for years but had been frustrated because the National Institutes of Health, the leading government medical research agency, had refused to finance such work.

With financing from the State of California, Dr. Abrams undertook what he said was a rigorous, placebo-controlled trial of marijuana smoking in H.I.V. patients who suffered from nerve pain. Smoking marijuana proved effective in ameliorating pain, Dr. Abrams said, but he said he was having trouble getting the study published.

"One wonders how anyone" could fulfill the Food and Drug Administration request for well-controlled trials to prove marijuana's benefits, he said.

Marinol, a synthetic version of a marijuana component, is approved to treat anorexia associated with AIDS and the nausea and vomiting associated with cancer drug therapy.

GW Pharmaceutical, a British company, has received F.D.A. approval to test a sprayed extract of marijuana in humans. Called Sativex, the drug is made from marijuana and is approved for sale in Canada. Opponents of efforts to legalize marijuana for medicinal uses suggest that marijuana is a so-called gateway drug that often leads users to try more dangerous drugs and to addiction.

But the Institute of Medicine report concluded there was no evidence that marijuana acted as a gateway to harder drugs. And it said there was no evidence that medical use of marijuana would increase its use among the general population.

Dr. Daniele Piomelli, a professor of pharmacology at the University of California, Irvine, said he had "never met a scientist who would say that marijuana is either dangerous or useless."

Studies clearly show that marijuana has some benefits for some patients, Dr. Piomelli said.

"We all agree on that," he said.

Copyright 2006 The New York Times Company

by plusaf

that the issue has been politicized and created divisiveness, rather than any kind of rational discussion at all.

did the FDA studies interview ANY mj users with diseases like cancer, parkinson's, or whatever? [rhetorical question.]

are they afraid of Bush [junior... aka, The Shrub] cutting them off at the budget, so they know damned well what to say so that their jobs aren't at stake?

i've had a similar "discussion" going about gays... a very old and close friend of mine's wife made a comment about "their choice of that lifestyle..." [in a "maybe they can be cured if they come to jesus, etc., context], and i almost choked in not replying:

where did you learn that "it's a LIFESTYLE CHOICE"??? from the leader of your sunday bible study group? who else? did you EVER have a sit-down-look-each-other-in-the-eye chat with a gay person and ASK THEM if they ever thought it was a "lifestyle choice." many dollars to many donuts that the answer would be one big you-know-whatting "no, of course not."

i've met many gays and i've never EVER gotten the impression that their sexual inclination was a "lifestyle choice" any more than "breathing" was their "lifestyle choice."

please let me know if you've ever used this kind of challenge and found ANYONE who's HAD that face-to-face and come away with the "choice" answer.

especially reverend fred phelps and his ilk, may their souls rot in the hell i don't even believe in... :)))))))))

by deepsand

even their religious beliefs!

Witness my mother. Born into an old-fashioned German farming family, she was indoctinated into the Lutheran faith as a child, but insists that she "chose" such beliefs.

When asked what other faiths she investigated, she becomes extremely indignant, refusing to even recognize the legitimacy of such question.

This attitude she extends to all things in life.

by absolutely

The government should not cut taxes for people based on a custom derived mostly from religious customs, nor for any hogwash "community value" of two people's declaration of love for each other. It is financially worthless to the rest of the community, and absolutely not worthy of special treatment vis-a-vis taxes.

by oz_media

There is no way we are going to emliminate the tax breaks given to married couples, so that's not an issue of debate.

Do all gay couples want to marry to get tax breaks ? Nope, I know many who dont.

BUT, IF a tax break is available to couples that have devoted sharing life and supporting the community as a couple, then why shouldn't those breaks be available to other 'couples' regardless of sex?

My point to you is, IF the system is flawed, as you see it, why is that not made available to gay couples too?

But regardless of that, again, these couples are not really in it for the money but the recognition as a minority.

Either way, it is an archaic thought process, derived incorrectly from religion that has created this mess. Religion, in this case, has NO place defining government action.

by absolutely

[i]My point to you is, IF the system is flawed, as you see it, why is that not made available to gay couples too?[/i]

They deserve better than the grudging recognition of an inane, prehistoric superstition. Being charged extra by the taxman for somebody else's religious beliefs means that freedom of religion is a LIE.

by plusaf

you said...

"Either way, it is an archaic thought process, derived incorrectly from religion that has created this mess. Religion, in this case, has NO place defining government action."

may i offer a suggestion for a small change to that?:

"Religion, has NO place defining ANY government action."

+af

by deepsand

When it comes to taxes, one person's "break" is another's "loophole" or "penalty."

The only way out of that conflict is to abolish personal income taxes.

Works for me.

by apotheon

I usually phrase it differently:

Our form of government mandates a separation of church and state. As opposed to a mere contractual agreement such as a civil union, a marriage is a spiritual union. In other words, it should not be under the control of government because a spiritual union is covered by the "church" part of the separation of church and state. Therefore, marriage shouldn't be a matter of law at all. Period.

Since it is, and that's not likely to go away any time soon, we should just treat it as a civil union. As such, government should not be in the business of discriminating against any demographic in granting the legal right of entering into such contractual agreements.

by jamesrl

They call it marriage. And since all of those religious groups call it marriage, and their ceremonies are recognized by the government (as non-religious ceremonies are as well), then it isn't any one religion's domain to define marriage.

Indeed there are "Christian" churches both Gay centred and non gay centred(United Church of Canada) that recognize a broader definition of marriage which includes two adults of any sex.

So do where does that leave us?

James

by oz_media

As much as, "Where does it leave them?"

I think MOST Canadians I have discussed this with feel it should be okay for same sex couples to marry, most feel that if hetero couples can 'committ' themselves to a life sentence, why shouldn't gay couples suffer the same 'misery by choice'.

The opposition ALWAYS seems to be the religious zealots who CLAIM that the word marriage defines opposite sex as per their bible. Even GWB made such comments when he addressd it. He said that he supports a couple's right to marry despite sex, BUT then he really goofed, he said that he feels that people of opposite sex should be entitled to the benefits and breaks for being married, but not same sex couples. So while trying to appear accepting, he also condemned them as well.

I think the government should accept people's choices and allowe them to reap the exact same benefits as any other married couple.

by deepsand

It's the nature of religios zealots to claim to be omniscient.

Witness the persistent claim that the US was founded as a "Christian" nation. Talk about revisionist bullshit.

For them, [b]any[/b] word employed at law for the personal union of two persons, that failed to otherwise specify, would mean "man & woman."

by deepsand

Max is being logically [i]inconsistent[/i], yet seems to refuse to acknowledge such.

by oz_media

What a bunch of fluff. In a nutshell, we agree that something needs to be done. We must lead the pack and not follow them, therefore if India and China can do as they like, then we will too.

Bush is just pissed because HE didn't get to enforce Kyoto, or some similar pact, on the rest of the world.

This is simply priceless though, [i]" This is an issue that I know is very important to the nations of Europe, which I will be visiting for the first time as President. The earth's well-being is also an issue important to America."[/i]

Now if that was said by a kindergarten student, we'd all say how cute it was, unfortunately this was from the Commander in Chief of a world superpower.

I am quite pleased to find that Bush knows that Europe and America are on the same planet though.

the problem I see is that while he plays lip service and meets with other nations to discuss issues, he has absolutely NO intent on following their guidance. It happened when allies were questioning his proof to invade Iraq, and it is happening again with global warming. He's like one of those bosses that discounts any input unless it's HIS idea then all must heed his words.

Or when the boss steals YOUR idea and claims it's his just because he can't accept following someone else's lead.
Just a big, dumb ego maniac who has to be in charge or he doesn't want to play.

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2001/06/20010611-2.html

by x-marcap

OZ we should agree to disagree. You and I have two widely different views about things.

1. The USAs sovereignity. I would fight and kill for it, as I have already done that.

2. Not everybody who disagrees with you is stupid. At times I am sure that You and I disagree more than most all others except Julian and I.

3. Why do you think that Canada has closed the books on global warming also?

4. He was more acedemically successful in an MBA program than 140 others at Harvard. He was sixth in 146 MBA class. Not too stupid.

5. You may not like his Texas based attitude.
Suicide in Texas is standing up in a Dallas bar and yelling Go Pittsburgh. (Football Joke)

6. He speaks simply to get it through to liberals that they may not misconstrue his meaning. it is also more difficult to mistranslate simple ideas.

by deepsand

Then they cause brush fires, which cause smoke, which contains particulates that block sun light, which causes [b]cooling[/b], rather than warming.

Which means that the solution to global warming is to produce large quantities of cows and light their farts!

by too old for it

I was so stoked by the recent attempt to legalize recreational quantities of certain (ok, well most) drugs in Mexico.

I was actually eyeing up a handful of MCI series 9 tour busses and the paperwork to become a charter bus company.

by the admiral

A bureaucrat sanctioned report is not a confirmation of nothing, since they are the ones that intentionally take any numbers and can twist them to mean the opposite.

And I did not see GWB perform the study. These are the people that Clinton put into the EPA 10 years ago.

by tonythetiger

confirmation that we have too many bureaucrats with nothing better to do :0

[edited to change smiley (We need more of a selection :) )]

by plusaf

your note took me to a link that helped me realize why i'd never vote for Burr as senator from NC, any chance i get.

i'd invite you to consider some of my "Soapbox" rants at www.plusaf.com about gay marriage and "when life begins" , etc.

let me offer here that the entire gay rights thing could go away in minutes if states [and preferably the nation] bifurcated marriage into "civil" and "religious."

any two people [we'll limit it to the human species for starters, ok? :) ] can be married and they get all of the same legal rights, whether they're straight or gay.

they then have the option [free choice] to participate or not in any religious ceremony of their choice in order to recognize or affirm their "marriage" in the "eyes of their church" [or their whatever] and abide by THOSE rules, if they wish.

all legal, insurance, inheritance, whatever... rights accrue to the two people [we'll consider n>2 later, ok, for the same reasons...], equally in all states of the Union.

anything their church or lack of same bestows upon the loving couple is also their business, choice, or whatever.

can you live with that?

i sure can.

by x-marcap

If a marriage is not between a man and a woman, changing the definition allows for further change.

People into beastiality have already filed papers in Massachusettes requesting further marriages.

by plusaf

i'm a VERY bad student of history and such, but a very bright friend of mine says that the real injuntion in the bible was intended to stop the military troops from stealing young men and using them to fulfill their sexual desires, and not really anything other than that.

as described elsewhere in this thread, the "powers that be" stole THAT concept, too, and expanded it to include any two folks of the same gender under ANY social or private [no ten inpunded] conditions!

WWJSay? he'd agree that stealing young boys by the military for sex is a bad thing. but that's apparently all that they really meant, back then. a lot has been lost in translation.

by rrmaddo

And you believe this because you read it on BBC??

Excuse me, but isn't that (BBC) one of the few sources that is less believeable than a BLOG?

It is important to remember that scientists have postulated a theory that relates human activity to climate change. This theory rests on observed climate over an incredibly small time period out of the supposed billions of years of earth's existence. Climate is very complex and, apparently, not all that well understood if judged in light of daily weather predictions. But if you want to put more stock in predictions of melting glaciers in the distant future than most of us do in whether it will rain tomorrow, be my guest. Just don't be upset if I don't accept that as fact!

Ralph

by rrmaddo

And you believe this because you read it on BBC??

Excuse me, but isn't that (BBC) one of the few sources that is less believeable than a BLOG?

It is important to remember that scientists have postulated a theory that relates human activity to climate change. This theory rests on observed climate over an incredibly small time period out of the supposed billions of years of earth's existence. Climate is very complex and, apparently, not all that well understood if judged in light of daily weather predictions. But if you want to put more stock in predictions of melting glaciers in the distant future than most of us do in whether it will rain tomorrow, be my guest. Just don't be upset if I don't accept that as fact!

Ralph

by deepsand

1) Scientists have demonstrated a high degree of correlation between increases in atmospheric CO2 levels & increases in global temperatures. This is fact, not hypothesis.

2) It is demonstrated that mankind's recent activities have resulted in increases in said CO2 levels. This too is fact, not hypothesis.

3) It is demonstrated that there now exist statistically significant increases in both atmosperhic & oceanic temperatures. Again, more facts.

4) Given the historical correlations, and the resultant global changes, it is logical to conclude that mankind's activities in these regards [b]cannot be beneficial[/b] to the planet, and may in fact be quite delitorius.

5) Prudence dictates that we cease doing that which may prove harmful.

by tonythetiger

But does the temperature rise beget the CO2 increase, or does the CO2 increase beget the temperature. CO2 levels are at the highest level ever recorded, tis true, but average global temperatures are not. Why not?

For a theory to become fact, it has to explain away all of the reasonable alternative explanations. This one hasn't.

by dr dij

but we may not. Life will continue on earth, pretty much no matter what we do. Tho we most likely will cause huge extinctions of many species.

life other than us will eventually adjust to higher temps, sea levels. We, who dumbly build at sea level will be displaced. And we run chance of run-away greenhouse effect raising temps 10o by 2100. A time your kids will see.

so for those who don't believe it is happening, open your eyes, the victims will be you and your children.

by rrmaddo

Perhaps you fail to appreciate the difference between correlation and causal relation?

by maxwell edison

You've been one of the US government's harshest critics.

You've been one of President Bush's harshest critics.

When did you start believing the US Government or President Bush?

This only proves that you form your predetermined conclusions before you decide what to believe.

You said, [i]"maybe now that GWB has ADMITTED that pollution is causing global warming Maxwell will have to retract his comments saying it's all BS. after all his hero the president admitted that us lunatics that have been mentioning it are correct.[/i]

Well, you are right about one thing (lunatics).

As for me, this is yet another thing I disagree with President Bush about.

By the way, what's your damn problem? You're a real nut-case.

by oz_media

Well done, don't get a picket in the bumb though, you'll have to pick a side sooner or later.

by maxwell edison

.....of my principles (or at least the ones I strive and try to live by), and just let the chips fall where they may.

by jdclyde

[i]"What do Jews, Muslims, Hindus etc call it"[/i]

Other religions also using the word marriage does not support a claim of it being a non-religious cerimony.

My question for you is:
How do the Jews handle gay marriage?
How do the Muslims handle gay marriage?
How do the Hindus handle gay marriage?
How do the Budists handle gay marriage?

Is it truely only Christianity that is against this redefining of the term?

by jdclyde

Look at the latest cover stories. Ann Coulter is being railed against because of comments in her book that are "over the edge", but we did not hear the same outrage when Franklin or Moore had their books and movies out that were just as far "over the edge", and were just as inflamitory.

Consistancey? Crediblity?

Na, just politics as usual.

by jamesrl

Are you suggesting that what Coulter said is ok, because Franklin or Moore weren't picked on?

Really?

I watched some of the Coulter stuff, particularly the Olberman (sp?) interview on You Tube and she has surely gone insane. Pat Robertson has been eclipsed. Just watch it for yourself. What shocks me is how little coverage there has been on the issue. For me at least, all of a sudden she becomes a very ugly person.

She called the 9/11 widows "witches who acted as if the terrorist acts happened only to them".

James

by x-marcap

These women who were obscure have achieved noteriety, but their views may not be opposed without the opposition being lambasted as mean, critical,etc. Her point exactly...

Why would I listen to women whose acedemic credentails I believe may came from crackerjack, who received millions of tax money, that are now showing up on TV, and on radio as anything more than opportunists? Obviously, they didn't refund the money given them. They now ride around in limos but when asked a real question break ito crying, or say that they would have rather still have their husbands? So What? The only reason they have become celebrities is that they are the vocal anti-Bushies...

by jamesrl

Just as there are those in the Christian faith who do not consider gay marriage a problem (United Church etc) there are those who feel the same way in other religions. There is no consensus in the Jewish faith, Buddhist faith. There are muslims who are open to it (Muslim Canadian Congress) but as with the other religions there may be a larger number who oppose it.

All religions have a broad range of views from what I read. There is no consensus.

James

by jdclyde

to still make a choice.

Your mother had a choice to be Lutheran or not. Just because she didn't look into OTHER faiths, does not change that she still had a choice of faith or no faith.

I don't have to try every ice cream flavor in the store to decide if I want my favorite "Blue Moon", or nothing.

I don't have to try every recreational drug to decide to use drugs or not use drugs.

You always have choice. Just because you don't agree with the choice, doesn't change that.

People choose to do drugs or not.
People choose to smoke or not.
People choose to be successful or not.
People choose to live a homosexual lifestyle or not.

You have chosen not to give people that don't agree with you credit for their choices that you don't agree with. Your mother had her choice and made it.

by jdclyde

I am not really meaning EVERY person from every off-shoot of every religion.

The MAIN branches of each religion, what is their stance?

Can a gay couple marry in the Middle East TODAY?
Can a gay couple marry in China today?
Can a gay couple marry in India today?
Can a gay couple marry in Mexico today?
Can a gay couple marry in Africa today?

The arguements FOR gay marriage try to make it sound like the only place in the world that is "discriminating" against the poor gays is the US? Also note, they distort the arguement as "taking away" the right, instead of the accurate "not giving something that never was".

And of course, there never was a valid reason for not giving a NEW name to this NEW type of "union", instead of redefining the existing one.

by jamesrl

I've never made that claim.

As for main stream - who represents the mainstream Christian church - the Roman Cathloics think they do, and thousands of cathloics and protestants died hundreds of years ago around that particular argument. There are more than one stream of Buddhist. There is no one faction of Islam (witness Sunni versus Shia in Iraq and elsewhere).

I am not suggesting that around the world the majority of people are for "Gay marriage". But that doesn't mean we should follow their example. I hated one of our former Prime Ministers, Pierre Eliot Trudeau, for many things including his supreme arrogance. But one principle he held to works for me "The state has no place in the bedrooms of the nation". For me its a human rights issue, and last time I checked, gay people were human too. I don't want them to have any rights that others don't have.

James

by jamesrl

I'd agree with everything except your last one.

I don't believe people choose to be gay. They do choose to follow through with their "desires" or supress them, but I don't think its a lifestyle, its something "bred in the bone".

Did you chose to be straight?

James

by jdclyde

I think she DID take a very valid point, and then poisoned it by going beyond the point and making it a personal attack on the women. This has allowed people to side-step the VALID part of her arguement and focus on just the name calling.

I am just pointing out that when the press LIKES the hateful things said, there is a free pass.

When they DON'T like it (like in this case), it becomes this horrible thing that should shock us all?

Consistancy is what I want. Hold them ALL accountable, not just the ones you don't like.

Yes, she should not have gone as far as she did, but if this really is like the media is claiming, that she is just tring to sell her book, they are doing exactly what she wants by making all the hubbub over this.

Is wasn't for the left SCREAMING about it, I would never have known she had said it. [b]Thanks to the selective reporting,[/b] I and the rest of the nation all get to hear what she has to say and many more will now buy her book.

Oh, and your quote was by far NOT the worst thing she said about them, and I disagree with her saying it.

But then again, where are all the freedom of speech advocates now? Oh yeah, only speech they agree with.

Consistancy, or lack of, bothers me more than anything any one person could say.

Lack of coverage? I have been hearing more about this on left radio than anywhere else.

by maxwell edison

...pales in comparison to what Michael Moore and Al Franken have said about many others who are equally (or more?) deserving of respectful consideration.

The selective outrage is ...... well, it's outrageous.

by tonythetiger

Someone posted a joke that made fun of the way Jocelyn Elders talked. One of the black ladies here at work printed it out and showed it to all of her black friends, who were outraged and offended.

My question was:

Who is actually offending, the person who posted the joke, or the one who deliberately showed it to others whom she [b]knew[/b] it would offend?

by jdclyde

I was careful how I worded the statement.

I did not say they choose to be gay.
I did not say others choose to be straight.

I did say you CHOOSE how to live your life. You can CHOOSE to live a straight lifestyle, or a gay lifestyle.

You can choose to have neither, and not chose a mate of either gender.

But that part is still a choice. People choose to act on their urges, be it with same sex, opposite sex, animals, excessive self gradification, or even people that become rapists or child molesters. They might not be able to help the way they think or feel, but they sure can help the way they CHOOSE to act on the way they think or feel.

Now please don't take this as putting gays into the same category as child molesters, because that was NOT my intention or my point.

The point is you CHOOSE how you live, not how you feel.

by maxwell edison

How many family members (parents, spouses, kids, etc.) were affected? Thirty thousand (or more), perhaps?

Are each and every one of those thirty thousand people above reproach just because they lost a loved one?

Did any of those thirty thousand people try to extort money from government or insurance companies? Yes, actually, there were such people. Are these financial opportunists above reproach? I think not.

Is it possible that these few "9-11 widows" actually ARE political opportunists? I think yes. I also think that once a person enters the political arena, at least in today's political climate, in any way whatsoever, but especially in the way that these "9-11 widows" have, all bets are off and nothing is above reproach. If you put a political target on your back, somebody's gonna' take a shot at it.

Too many opinions on this issue are based on a very narrow view of a very big picture. And James, yours is just one such example.

Edited to add another's opinion:

http://www.opinionjournal.com/medialog/?id=110004950

by jamesrl

Did you actually listen to the interview?

Do I think some of these widows may be doing a "Cindy Sheehy"? Yes, its entirely possible.

Does going political justify Coulter saying "that they enjoyed their husband's deaths"? Never. No way, no how. If any politician had said that no matter what party they are from, they would be toast come the next election, and rightfully so.

Common decency suggets there limits to how far political discourse can and should venture. Ann Coulter went over the line.

James

by maxwell edison

The word "enjoyed" has a couple of different connotations.

1. Enjoyed, as in taking pleasure or satisfaction in something. [i]Nancy enjoys bathing in the sunlight.[/i]

2. Enjoyed, as in to have the use or benefit of. [i/]Nancy's home in Colorado is able to enjoy more than three hundred days of sunlight, thus helping her solar heating system.[/i]

I assure you, the context of Ann Coulter's "enjoyed" comment is obvious when read, in its entirety, and in full and total context, as written in her book. I'll give you a hint, the intended definition was not number one.

I'd bet a dollar to dirt that you did not read the book, and that you will also say that you only saw an interview or a report of an interview. However, the leading nature of the interview questions, and the badgering and determination of the interviewer to focus on a narrow view, gave a false impression to anyone watching -- especially anyone predisposed to a certain (political) way of thinking. Actually, I think Ann Coulter put Matt Lauer to shame when he interviewed her. (However, I will admit that Ann Coulter is a little too abrasive at times. But she just calls 'em as she sees 'em.)

by tonythetiger

"If any politician had said that no matter what party they are from, they would be toast come the next election, and rightfully so."

That's how "politically correct speech" was invented. It's a way of lying so that everyone knows your lying and also knows the truth that was not spoken. Since you never actually spoke the unspoken truth, you can't be held accountable for insulting someone.

The bad thing is if you choose not to use politically correct speech, and to tell the unvarnished truth, you are most often raked over the coals for it, because for many (including most of the left), the truth hurts!

by oz_media

It doesn't matter, he clever right wing will agree with his questionable BS and not agree with him if they feel it is undeiable BS. Flip Flopping, a term seemingly coined by the right wing certainly descrtibes many of thier positions.

I find much of the right wing has really started to slowly backpeddle and is becoming far more centered now, they now it's dangerous to be seen supporting a circus freak I suppose.

GWB admitted this a while back (at G8), he STILL said that while he feels more testing is needed, it can't be conducted within the USA but only on the other European countries, who have been following such a program for decades now. I am sure the results will be far less alarming that way.

by jamesrl

I did see the interview with Olbermann on You tube, without reading any other commentary.

I will take a direct quote from the Lauer interview:

Lauer: "Alright on the 9/11 widows and in particular a group that had been outspoken and critical of the administration. 'These self-obsessed women seem genuinely unaware that 9/11 was an attack on our nation and acted as if the terrorist attack only happened to them. They believe the entire country was required to marinate in their exquisite personal agony. Apparently denouncing Bush was an important part of their closure process.' And this part is, is the part I really need to talk to you about. 'These broads are millionaires lionized on TV and in articles about them reveling in their status as celebrities and stalked by grief-arazzis. I've never seen people enjoying their husbands' death so much.'"

Coulter: "Yes."

Lauer: "Because they dare to speak out?"

Coulter: "To speak out using the fact that they're widows. This is the left's doctrine of infallibility. If they have a point to make about the 9/11 commission, about how to fight the war on terrorism. How about sending somebody we're allowed to respond to? No, no we always have to respond to someone who just had a family member die..."

Lauer: "But aren't they the people in the middle of the story?"

Coulter: "...because then if we respond, 'Oh you're questioning their authenticity.' No the story is..."

Lauer: "So grieve but grieve quietly."

Coulter: "No the story is an attack on the nation..."

Lauer: "And by the way..."

Coulter: "That requires a foreign policy response. That does not entail the expertise..."

Lauer: "And by the way they also criticized the Clinton administration for their failures leading up to 9/11."

Coulter: "Oh not, not the ones I'm talking about."

Lauer: "No they have."

Coulter: "No, no, no. Oh no, no, no, no."

Lauer: "But is your message to them just grieve..."

Coulter: "No, no they were cutting commercials for Kerry. They were using their grief in order to make a political point while preventing anyone from responding."

Lauer: "So if you lose a husband you no longer have the right to have a political point of view?"

Coulter: "No but don't use the fact that you lost a husband as the basis for your being able to talk about it while preventing people from responding. Let Matt Lauer make the point, let Bill Clinton make the point. Don't put up someone I'm not allowed to respond to without questioning the authenticity of their grief."

Lauer: "Well but apparently you are allowed to respond to them."

Coulter: "Well yeah I did."

Lauer: "Right so in other words..."

Coulter: "But that is the point of liberal infallibility. Of putting up Cindy Sheehan, of putting out these widows of putting out Joe Wilson. No, no, no you can't respond it's their doctrine of infallibility."

Lauer: "But what I'm saying is they've..."

Coulter: "...somebody else make the argument..."

Lauer: "I'm saying I don't think they've ever told you, you can't respond. So why can't they make their point?"

Coulter: "Look you're getting testy with me."

Lauer: "No I'm not. I just..."

Coulter: "Ohhh."

Lauer: "I think it's, I think it's, I think it's your dramatic statement. 'These broads,' 'you know are, are 'millionaires stalked by grief-arazzi.'"

Coulter: "You think I shouldn't be able to respond to them."

Lauer: "'I've never seen people enjoying their husbands deaths so much.'"

Coulter: "They're, they're, yes. They're all over the news."

Lauer: "The book is called Godless: The Church Of Liberalism. Ann Coulter always fun to have you here."

Coulter: "Hey where's Katie? Did she leave or something?"

Lauer: "She did. 7:17am. And now here's Ann."

Do you think she meant definition one or two?

If Michael Moore or Al Franken says something outrageous, call them on it. Have your read their books - I bet a dollar to dirt you haven't? And I'd be happy to pay off if I am wrong. I've read none of Michael Moore, and a few chapters of Franken. I don't lionize them.

I'm not being selective, I am reacting to what I have seen. And I call em as I sees 'em.

James

by x-marcap

2nd amendment to the Constitution.
Too many judges are idiots who can't read.

Congress shall make no law... They should have stopped there.

The second amendment refers to the Church of the USA. Like the Anglican church... Not to prevent religious expression. The only religion allowed free expression is aetheism, or state-ism.

by maxwell edison

Other than asking me the same question that I asked you (even though I already answered it), you pretty much ignored my whole message. I wonder why?

[b]Enjoy[/b]: 1. To receive pleasure from. 2. To have the use or benefit of.

Again, I suggest that definition number two was her intended connotation. Which one do YOU believe she intended to imply? And if she did use the second connotation, why is the news media making hay out of it? Why is the news media misrepresenting her meaning and intent? And why are you dodging the question?

I saw the silly interview; I hope you didn't post the transcript for my benefit. I'm glad you did, however, as it shows Ann Coulter turning the tables on Matt (wishes he was Katie) Lauer. And do you notice that whenever one of Lauer's charges (put in the form of a question) was answered and a subsequent challenge was made to the premise of the question, he just jumped to the next "setup" question without continuing on the same issue or answering the challenge, and/or interrupting the answer to ask a new question? It's a typical ploy used by a lot of interviewers -- just get the leading charge ..... I mean question ..... out there, and don't let a good answer get in the way of the real agenda to mislead the audience. (And kinda' like you did by not answering ANY of my questions.)

As far as full context, you will probably agree (at least I hope you do) that a person's true context and intent can sometimes be understood only by looking beyond ".....one part of one sentence.....", or sometimes beyond the full sentence, or sometimes beyond even several sentences strung together. What precedes (and/or follows) any comment is, oftentimes, just as vital (or perhaps even more so) than the sentence itself so as to understand the full thought process that led up to a comment. To read the full essay, for example, will garner more understanding than reading just a few sentences from the essay. Do you disagree? And in this case, do you (or does anybody) really believe that Coulter thinks these women actually took pleasure in their husbands death? To even make such an assertion should speak volumes to one's credibility and/or intentions.

In this case, Ann Coulter is being called outrageous for speaking her mind. And the ironic thing about it is that she was speaking her mind on some extremely outrageous comments made by others. Why is Ann vilified for it, while the others are not? As I showed, just because these few women are 9-11 widows, it doesn't mean they're above reproach. They (and others) might say they're entitled to speak their mind, without comment form anyone, just because they're 9-11 widows. Hog wash! They're political opportunists, pure and simple. And any outrageous things they might say is free-game for anyone who wants to reply -- whether that reply is equally outrageous or not (or anywhere in between).

If it were me, however, I wouldn't have used the word [i]enjoy[/i] like Ann did. I would have used the word [i]exploit[/i]. At what point in time does a "grieving widow" (or grieving mother) become an opportunist? Even more worthy of consideration, however, is this. At what point does it become exploitation by the news media?

And I also wonder why these "Jersy Girls" aren't challenged with equal time given to people like Sandy Dahl? Maybe it's because Sandy Dahl won't exploit her husband's death for political (or monetary) expediency. (But her views could be learned if you care to find out.)

You owe me a dollar, by the way. I did read Franken's book, [i]Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them[/i], but I will admit I didn't buy it. (He's not getting any of my money.) I sat in a bookstore for several hours and finished the whole thing. It's one of the worst and misleading examples of political humor and satire I've ever read; and when he tries to be serious, he only sounded stupid. I also force myself to listen to Franken on Air America (puke!) ..... and Randi Rhodes (man, talk about a mean-spirited bi**h) ..... and Ed (always making false assertions) Schultz, who used to spew his nonsense on AA before they canned him. (Yea, why isn't Randi Rhodes vilified in the main-stream press? Some of the things she says are down-right nasty and disgusting!)

Give the dollar to the next "homeless" guy you see holding a sign about working for food. Tell him it's from an American who told him to get off the juice and into a friggin' job!

by deadly ernest

to do with legitimising the rip off approach taken with the Kyoto Garbage Papers. I don't think that anyone with half a brain has ever said that human activities did NOT contribute to some extent, however you would have to be a total idiot to think that they are the sole or major cause of global temperature variations.

Long term records show that the current average temperature is less than it was 250 years ago. Longer term records, from the ice cores, show that global temperature has been on a roller coaster ride since the atmosphere first formed. Each year we have volcanic activity that makes humanity's poor efforts look like nothing. If anything we may have reduced carbon emission as much of the land that humans have urbanised and farmed used to be forest and plains that under went yearly or two-yearly bush fires. These are things that are totally ignored by those who are using the global warming scare to enrich themselves from it.

by Member 25348569

at least have the decency to quote some logical science.

Volcanic activity is part of a natural cyle that prevents the permanent incorporation of carbon dioxide in chalk and limestone rocks by recycling subducted sea-bottom. You can't have it as part of your argument and neither can I as "what goes around, comes around". Anyway, volcanic release of CO2, far from "making our poor efforts look like nothing" is only around one percent of humanity's efforts. Poor old volcanoes, is what I say! We produce more CO2 than volcanoes in an average year by heating carbonate rocks to make cement.

A forest locks up carbon dioxide in wood. A mature forest is a null entity with regards to atmospheric CO2 as it has reached equilibrium. This even applies to natural forest fires because it all regrows eventually.

However, if humanity replaces forest with grassland - or concrete or desert - then the majority of that carbon is released into the atmosphere and is not taken up by regrowth. The equilibrium point is shifted to a higher atmospheric CO2 level.

So, taking the obvious that burning 300m year old fossil fuel and creating cement by heating calcium carbonate rocks releases "ancient" carbon and raises CO2 levels above any "natural" equilibrium and that urrent human-inspired deforestation, urbanisation and desertification moves the equilibrium to a higher CO2 level, the only thing left for you to do is to say that raised atmospheric CO2 produces no measurable effect.

Or you could dispute my arguments.

Either way - good luck.

by deadly ernest

create matter or energy but can convert things between the the two. The amount of carbon in the world today is the same as it was millions of years ago, it just changes its format over time.

The Global Warmin Alarmists (GWAs) would have you think that the earth is a stable platform and that average global temperature would not have varied a damn without human intervention. Well they are wrong, the scientific community has proven that the world temperatures have varied greatly through the ages - it has been hotter than this and colder than this. The world has a number of natural rhythms that cause the average global temperature to vary, up and down. This has been happening since before man existed or learnt about fire.

It is only in the last few hundred years that mankind has had any impact on the earth through large scale crop management and large cities. These have had the effect of decreasing bushfires. At the same time they have increase the number of small fires, coal power stations etc.

The volcanoes undersea and above produce huge amounts of CO2 and other greenhouse gases - mostly sulpha dioxide. This is a natural action. they put out many gases and blast lots of carbon and crap into the atmosphere every time one blows its top. Such activity is measured in the multi mega tonnes. The major climate change problem from volcanoes is sulphur dioxide, and that is usually much higher than the CO2 produced by volcanoes. BTW in Morse and Mackenzie, 1990, Geochemistry of Sedimentary Carbonates they make claims that ongoing CO2 emissions from volcanoes is about 3% of total world wide CO2 emissions.

The experts are not sure how extensively any single eruption does or will affect the overall climate as there are too many factors to take into account - a lot depends upon how much CO2, sulphur dioxide and how high the emission go. In fact there is evidence to show that some volcanic eruptions can cause a world wide lowering of the average global temperature.

The GWAs first claimed that humans had caused a dramatic increase in the average global temperature over the last 200 years through the use of perto-carbons and fluro-carbons etc. Yet we have weatehr records that show the average global temperature 250 years ago was 2% higher than it is now. For the GWAs claims to be true then there MUST BE NO natural actions that caused significant temperature changes, up or down. Yet we know that there are many such natural causes. This means that they are not taking into account significant factors and cannot accurate place the cause at anyone's doorstep.

Blaming all the global warming on human activity, the way the GWAs do, is like blaming an unusual high tide in California on two Hawaiian fishermen pissing over the side of the boat that faces that way.

Sure we should take REASONABLE steps to reduce emissions for the same reasons we take out fire insurance - it's a good idea. But that does not mean the GWAs are correct in blaming humans for it, and it does not mean that the biased, economically based garbage in the Kyoto Protocrap should be supported. NB Please see other thread on this re why KP is economic and biased.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Only the very most fattening foods will be prohibited, of course.

Just take my word for it, [some petty bureaucrat in] the government will choose the right foods for you.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]The Global Warmin Alarmists (GWAs) would have you think that the earth is a stable platform and that average global temperature would not have varied a damn without human intervention. Well they are wrong, the scientific community has proven that the world temperatures have varied greatly through the ages - it has been hotter than this and colder than this. The world has a number of natural rhythms that cause the average global temperature to vary, up and down. This has been happening since before man existed or learnt about fire.[/i]

We, in science, all know that the Vostok Core shows marked evidence of rhythmic variations in temperature & greenhouse gas concentrations. They are roughly ten times more gradual than what is measured in the past ~150 years.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=263796&messageID=2511304

This is not normal.

This discussion is closed to new replies.